House prosecutor Rep. Chel Diokno during the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte on Thursday, Nov. 19, flagged the defense's line of questioning towards witness Atty. Rainer Dela Fuente, as he questioned the relevance of the witness' credentials in anti-money laundering, even though the respondent is not being charged with any cases concerning the matter.

He said that the Senate impeachment court's proceedings is centered around Article II of the Articles of Impeachment, which was Duterte's alleged unexplained wealth, and so far he has not heard anything that would qualify Dela Fuente on those matters.

Defense counsel Mark Vinluan responded saying that there are existing allegations pertaining to money laundering from other Articles of Impeachment, and that the prosecution panel also presented their own witness on anti-money laundering, therefore stating that the defense also has the prerogative to present its own.

Diokno disagreed to Vinluan, saying upon reading the Articles numerous times, he has not seen anything that refers to Duterte committing any crime under money laundering.

Vinluan said that the defense panel will present the documents pertaining to the matter later on. (Video courtesy of Senate of the Philippines)

#VPSaraOnTrial #VPOnTrial

Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5664f6TkaeHgwBly50DWZQ/join

Subscribe to the Manila Bulletin Online channel! - https://www.youtube.com/TheManilaBulletin

Visit our website at http://mb.com.ph
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/manilabulletin
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/manila_bulletin
Instagram: https://instagram.com/manilabulletin
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@manilabulletin

#ManilaBulletinOnline
#ManilaBulletin
#LatestNews

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00You also have experience as a former consultant for CESA.
00:04Para lang po alam ng lahat, ano po ba tong CESA and what were your duties and responsibilities dito?
00:09Yung CESA ho, Cagayan Economic Zone Authority.
00:12If I may correct your honor, consultant pa rin po ako nila.
00:17Up to now, up to now.
00:19Sorry for that.
00:20Opo.
00:20Yes.
00:21So, ang CESA ho kasi one of our supervising agencies insofar as AML matters.
00:27So, again, as their advisor pagdating mo sa AML matters in crafting their supervisory framework,
00:39they are considered a supervisor po sa AML matters for their covered persons.
00:46Meron po kasing CESA covered persons that are under the AML regime.
00:51So, doon ho sa aspeto na yun, sa segment ho na yun, doon ho tayo tumutulong.
00:58Crafty, the framework.
01:01I'm very sorry to interrupt the defense and the witness.
01:04But may I know the relevance of this line of questioning?
01:09The witness apparently is delivering his credentials on anti-money laundering.
01:15But the respondent in this case is not being charged with any money laundering crimes.
01:22The issue before this court are all centered on unexplained wealth, non-declaration of sal-in, and participation in business.
01:31And I haven't heard anything from this witness that would qualify him on those matters.
01:38Yes.
01:40Attorney Mark, what do you say?
01:41Yeah, to correct the good counsel, under the Articles of Impeachment,
01:46there are actually allegations pertaining to money laundering and other related matters.
01:52So, we will tackle that issue later on, Your Honor.
01:56But in the meantime, Your Honor, can we just proceed with qualifying this?
02:01At any rate, Your Honor, they presented an AMLO if I may be allowed to finish.
02:06Honorable Jokno, kindly allow Attorney Mark to finish.
02:09In fact, Your Honor, they presented an AMLOC witness and they made interpretations on the data as well.
02:17They also presented their own witness, Your Honor.
02:20So, it is our position that Your Honor, that we also have the prerogative to present our own expert on
02:28the witness.
02:30May I speak, Your Honor?
02:31Yes, Honorable Jokno.
02:33Well, I would have to most respectfully disagree with the attempt by the Defense Council to correct this representation.
02:42I have seen and read the Articles of Impeachment a number of times.
02:47I have not seen any single word that refers to the respondent committing any crime under money laundering.
02:56We will show that later on.
02:57I'm not yet finished, Your Honor, please.
02:58So, may I know where in the articles that is contained, if any?
03:03We will show that later on.
03:04Because an allegation like that is too serious to let pass.
03:08I hope that I will count you to it, counsel, that you will show it at the point you decide
03:14to.
03:15Very well, Your Honor.
03:17Can we just move on?
03:19To abbreviate the proceedings, Honorable Chell, that Attorney Rainer is qualified as an expert by the counsel for responding, Attorney
03:30Mark, only means that he can give his opinion.
03:34Not that it's gospel truth, not that it's the truth, not that it's accurate, not that it's correct, but only
03:40to allow the witness to give his opinion if he's qualified as an expert witness.
03:47He will be testifying to giving his opinion on documents identified, AMLC documents identified, presented, offered, and allowed by this
04:00court.
04:02So, in the interest of abbreviating the proceedings, again, subject to cross, of course, as regards the depth of his
04:10expertise.
04:11It will only, qualifying Attorney Rainer as an expert will merely enable him to give his opinion.
04:16Not that it's correct, again, and not that it's, not that we agree with it, not that it's legal, not
04:20that it's accurate, but only to give his opinion, as opposed to an ordinary witness that's not allowed to give
04:26his opinion.
04:28So, we can skip with this if you will stipulate that he's an expert that can give his opinion with
04:38respect to AMLC documents identified by the prosecution and by the defense.
04:42Correct, Attorney Mark?
04:43By the defense also?
04:44That's correct, Your Honor.
04:46Or, if you don't want to concede it, you're also free to do so, Honorable Jokno, and we can proceed
04:52with, I think we're about to go to the seminars he has attended.
04:57We're going to that.
04:58If Your Honor, please.
05:00Yes, Honorable Jokno.
05:01I was questioning the relevance of the line of questioning of the good counsel.
05:06He responded by saying that it is relevant, but said that the reason being that money laundering is included in
05:15the articles of impeachment, particularly Article 2.
05:18Since that is his contention, Your Honor, please, may we hold him to that now, and may we ask him
05:25to show the relevance of this line of questioning by pointing to the allegations of the Article 2 that, according
05:33to him, pertain to money laundering.
05:35Yes, Your Honor, we will cite the exact page later on, but it will preempt our line of questions, Your
05:40Honor.
05:40So, we ask for some leeway, Your Honor.
05:43And besides, Honorable Jokno, again, you have common exhibits coming from AMLC by the respondent in the prosecution, which is
05:53the proper subject matter of this witness to testify on, again, if he is going to be qualified as an
06:00expert.
06:02May the court ask again, are you willing to stipulate as to his expertise on the subject matter, again, Honorable
06:11Jokno, without conceding that what he will say will be the truth and is accurate and is legal and correct,
06:16subject to cross.
06:18Inasmuch as I would like to facilitate the proceedings, Your Honor, I am not in a position to make any
06:24such stipulation at this point.
06:25Then we will listen to the seminars he attended.
06:28Very well, Your Honor.

Recommended