00:00You also have experience as a former consultant for CESA.
00:04Para lang po alam ng lahat, ano po ba tong CESA and what were your duties and responsibilities dito?
00:09Yung CESA ho, Cagayan Economic Zone Authority.
00:12If I may correct your honor, consultant pa rin po ako nila.
00:17Up to now, up to now.
00:19Sorry for that.
00:20Opo.
00:20Yes.
00:21So, ang CESA ho kasi one of our supervising agencies insofar as AML matters.
00:27So, again, as their advisor pagdating mo sa AML matters in crafting their supervisory framework,
00:39they are considered a supervisor po sa AML matters for their covered persons.
00:46Meron po kasing CESA covered persons that are under the AML regime.
00:51So, doon ho sa aspeto na yun, sa segment ho na yun, doon ho tayo tumutulong.
00:58Crafty, the framework.
01:01I'm very sorry to interrupt the defense and the witness.
01:04But may I know the relevance of this line of questioning?
01:09The witness apparently is delivering his credentials on anti-money laundering.
01:15But the respondent in this case is not being charged with any money laundering crimes.
01:22The issue before this court are all centered on unexplained wealth, non-declaration of sal-in, and participation in business.
01:31And I haven't heard anything from this witness that would qualify him on those matters.
01:38Yes.
01:40Attorney Mark, what do you say?
01:41Yeah, to correct the good counsel, under the Articles of Impeachment,
01:46there are actually allegations pertaining to money laundering and other related matters.
01:52So, we will tackle that issue later on, Your Honor.
01:56But in the meantime, Your Honor, can we just proceed with qualifying this?
02:01At any rate, Your Honor, they presented an AMLO if I may be allowed to finish.
02:06Honorable Jokno, kindly allow Attorney Mark to finish.
02:09In fact, Your Honor, they presented an AMLOC witness and they made interpretations on the data as well.
02:17They also presented their own witness, Your Honor.
02:20So, it is our position that Your Honor, that we also have the prerogative to present our own expert on
02:28the witness.
02:30May I speak, Your Honor?
02:31Yes, Honorable Jokno.
02:33Well, I would have to most respectfully disagree with the attempt by the Defense Council to correct this representation.
02:42I have seen and read the Articles of Impeachment a number of times.
02:47I have not seen any single word that refers to the respondent committing any crime under money laundering.
02:56We will show that later on.
02:57I'm not yet finished, Your Honor, please.
02:58So, may I know where in the articles that is contained, if any?
03:03We will show that later on.
03:04Because an allegation like that is too serious to let pass.
03:08I hope that I will count you to it, counsel, that you will show it at the point you decide
03:14to.
03:15Very well, Your Honor.
03:17Can we just move on?
03:19To abbreviate the proceedings, Honorable Chell, that Attorney Rainer is qualified as an expert by the counsel for responding, Attorney
03:30Mark, only means that he can give his opinion.
03:34Not that it's gospel truth, not that it's the truth, not that it's accurate, not that it's correct, but only
03:40to allow the witness to give his opinion if he's qualified as an expert witness.
03:47He will be testifying to giving his opinion on documents identified, AMLC documents identified, presented, offered, and allowed by this
04:00court.
04:02So, in the interest of abbreviating the proceedings, again, subject to cross, of course, as regards the depth of his
04:10expertise.
04:11It will only, qualifying Attorney Rainer as an expert will merely enable him to give his opinion.
04:16Not that it's correct, again, and not that it's, not that we agree with it, not that it's legal, not
04:20that it's accurate, but only to give his opinion, as opposed to an ordinary witness that's not allowed to give
04:26his opinion.
04:28So, we can skip with this if you will stipulate that he's an expert that can give his opinion with
04:38respect to AMLC documents identified by the prosecution and by the defense.
04:42Correct, Attorney Mark?
04:43By the defense also?
04:44That's correct, Your Honor.
04:46Or, if you don't want to concede it, you're also free to do so, Honorable Jokno, and we can proceed
04:52with, I think we're about to go to the seminars he has attended.
04:57We're going to that.
04:58If Your Honor, please.
05:00Yes, Honorable Jokno.
05:01I was questioning the relevance of the line of questioning of the good counsel.
05:06He responded by saying that it is relevant, but said that the reason being that money laundering is included in
05:15the articles of impeachment, particularly Article 2.
05:18Since that is his contention, Your Honor, please, may we hold him to that now, and may we ask him
05:25to show the relevance of this line of questioning by pointing to the allegations of the Article 2 that, according
05:33to him, pertain to money laundering.
05:35Yes, Your Honor, we will cite the exact page later on, but it will preempt our line of questions, Your
05:40Honor.
05:40So, we ask for some leeway, Your Honor.
05:43And besides, Honorable Jokno, again, you have common exhibits coming from AMLC by the respondent in the prosecution, which is
05:53the proper subject matter of this witness to testify on, again, if he is going to be qualified as an
06:00expert.
06:02May the court ask again, are you willing to stipulate as to his expertise on the subject matter, again, Honorable
06:11Jokno, without conceding that what he will say will be the truth and is accurate and is legal and correct,
06:16subject to cross.
06:18Inasmuch as I would like to facilitate the proceedings, Your Honor, I am not in a position to make any
06:24such stipulation at this point.
06:25Then we will listen to the seminars he attended.
06:28Very well, Your Honor.