Skip to playerSkip to main content
‘THAT WAS LIKE A CLOSING STATEMENT’

Senator-judge Pia Cayetano moved to strike prosecutor Atty. Amando Ligutan’s response from the record, saying it sounded more like a 'closing statement' than a direct answer to Senator Risa Hontiveros’ question during Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Tuesday, July 07. Presiding officer Chiz Escudero deferred ruling on the motion, while Hontiveros clarified that her question is related to how evidence is material to the allegations in the Articles of Impeachment, since there was no proof Duterte hired an assassin. She added that she did not intend to prompt a closing statement from the prosecution. (Video courtesy of Senate of the Philippines)

RELATED: https://mb.com.ph/2026/07/07/prosecutors-premature-closing-statement-called-out-by-escudero-pia-cayetano

Subscribe to the Manila Bulletin Online channel! - https://www.youtube.com/TheManilaBulletin

Visit our website at http://mb.com.ph
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/manilabulletin
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/manila_bulletin
Instagram: https://instagram.com/manilabulletin
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@manilabulletin

#ManilaBulletinOnline
#ManilaBulletin
#LatestNews

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00We may all make those mistakes. Even I may make that mistake.
00:03And I'm telling you, please call me out if I make a mistake and ask the kind of question
00:06that should not properly be asked by a judge.
00:09Manifest my support for the statement and observation of the presiding officer.
00:14That was like a closing statement, Mr. President.
00:17So I don't think this is fair because, you know, some parts are exciting, some parts are dragging.
00:24We're trying our best to be paying attention and what evidence, you know, we have to affect the evidence.
00:30Before us, what is admissible, what is not. The official objections will come later.
00:34But when we allow this to happen, then we shortcut the process.
00:41So, if I may, with all due respect, Mr. President, admonish us.
00:47Call us out if the question natin is also not proper at the proper time.
00:54We may all make those mistakes. Even I may make that mistake.
00:57And I'm telling you, please call me out if I make a mistake and ask the kind of question
01:01that should not properly be asked by a judge at that particular time.
01:06Because it is not right.
01:08We must follow the rules.
01:09And I know you are being courteous to all of us.
01:12But that was a closing statement.
01:16And I also ask the parties involved.
01:19You have an oath as lawyers.
01:23Don't take advantage of the generosity of this impeachment court.
01:28I don't want to see this happen again.
01:31Thank you, Mr. President.
01:32Julie noted and well taken.
01:34The chair, as I said, or as the presiding officer said earlier, reminded our colleagues with respect to similar questions
01:44to be asked in the future.
01:46Your Honor, may I...
01:49We are going to make a ruling that the counsel for the respondent will be given, I think that was
01:55approximately 8 minutes or 10 minutes.
01:58We will get the exact time to answer after the cross-examination of this witness so that we would be
02:05fair in listening and hearing the views of both parties in regard to the query raised earlier.
02:13Senator Judge Pia Cayetano?
02:15Yeah, sorry, Mr. President.
02:16I don't mean to interrupt.
02:19I want to give the defense to your time.
02:21I respectfully move that the statements of the prosecution be stricken off the record.
02:27It is not proper for those statements that have been made.
02:31Ms. Rizan De Veros is recognized.
02:35What is your pleasure, ma'am?
02:36Salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
02:39Just a point of clarity.
02:41Briefly, if I may, Mr. Presiding Officer.
02:44Salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
02:45And of course, I will submit to any ruling or statement of the presiding officer to this Senator Judge.
02:54But for clarity, Mr. Presiding Officer, my question po had to do with how the evidence is material to the
03:02allegations in the Articles of Impeachment.
03:05Kasi nga po, hindi naman napapatunayan na the Vice President actually sought an assassin.
03:11I wanted to appreciate the evidence before me in light of the Articles of Impeachment.
03:17If you wish to strike out the response of the prosecutor, then so be it, Mr. Presiding Officer.
03:23But for clarity again, my intention was not to provoke a closing statement.
03:29Salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
03:30We will review the transcript again.
03:42You

Recommended