- 9 minutes ago
Shan, RJ, and Bobby debated whether the Cowboys should strip Christian Parker of play-calling midseason. They discussed Mike Pettine taking over, running yet another scheme, hypothetical DC candidates, and more.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00As we await the word on Christian Parker's status after Brian Schottenheimer left it
00:06open-ended in his Monday presser, then yesterday at 8.30, you see it on all the national TV
00:12shows, Jerry Jones saying, yes, we are considering and thinking about things, and it could go
00:17into effect for the Tennessee Titans on Sunday.
00:22Other reaction before we get to Bobby's study of worst freshman defensive coordinator seasons
00:27ever here in DFW in the history of the Cowboys.
00:31A couple of other reactions.
00:32I was listening to Nate Newton.
00:34Are you doing a show with Nate tonight?
00:35Yep.
00:35We got LB, Larry Brown with us.
00:39All right.
00:39Nice.
00:40Nate Newton and Jesse Holley.
00:41Nate was like, I'm not listening to Christian Parker if he's demoted, if I'm another player.
00:49And Nate spits fire.
00:51He's not over there worried about anyone upstairs coming downstairs or listening in the hallways.
00:56They spit fire on that Hanging with the Boys show.
00:59Again, Jesse, waiting for you to mention us by name, me, once, not just a fan.
01:04You can say we asked the great questions to Jerry that you guys talk about.
01:08Yeah, Jesse got a mention somewhere else yesterday, too.
01:12Jesse did?
01:12Mm-hmm.
01:13Peyton mentioned him.
01:14Oh, yeah.
01:16Talk about that.
01:17More on that.
01:18We will tomorrow.
01:21We'll talk about it tomorrow and Friday and maybe Monday and all next week and maybe Tuesday.
01:27We will talk about that.
01:29But Nate's like, I'm not listening to Christian Parker.
01:32You're a dead man walking.
01:33Are you kidding me?
01:34You're demoted.
01:35You're on your way out of here.
01:37Heck no.
01:38And Nate said this should have been done like the Denver situation with their offense.
01:44This should have been done three or four weeks ago.
01:46And I was wondering to myself, really?
01:49Would it have been better three to four weeks ago when you have people questioning right
01:55now whether this is too early?
01:57And I think Nate is like, there's no point right now.
02:00You're not salvaging anything.
02:02You're not going to have some magical switch go off to go to the postseason.
02:08And this is where Cowboys macro and micro always comes back to bite them.
02:15Head versus heart.
02:17Your head tells you should.
02:19Your head says they're done this year.
02:23They're done.
02:24They're not going to be a factor in the playoffs.
02:28And they have zero shot to win it all.
02:31And they may not even get there.
02:33So the smart, heady decision, let Christian Parker finish out.
02:39See what you can do over the second half so you can decide on not having to have more turnover
02:45for next year, which is one of their number one objectives on their whiteboards.
02:51We don't want another coordinator.
02:52We don't want another system.
02:54That's the heady thing to do.
02:57The emotional, hard thing to do is we've got to do everything we can to try to salvage this season.
03:04We've got to do everything we can to hope that the Giants stutter and stumble one more time or multiple
03:10down the stretch.
03:12And it can't get any worse.
03:14Like, there's third time's a charm.
03:15It'll get a little bit better with Mike Pettin, who is a more experienced game caller.
03:19And it will get better.
03:22And unfortunately, and I know this drives you crazy about them, Choppy, the Cowboys react way more with heart than
03:29they do head.
03:31Because the smart overall plan was to see what Christian does down the stretch to finish this out.
03:38So that you can have reason to be optimistic for next year.
03:42Which we had reason to be optimistic for this year, you know, in the offseason.
03:46And it wasn't.
03:46But yeah, I mean.
03:47Well, the reason was really Matt Eberfloos.
03:51Right.
03:51It wasn't really anything about Christian Parker.
03:53It was the unknown.
03:54It was.
03:55And the law and the averages.
03:57It can't be.
03:58It can't be as bad.
03:59Can't be.
04:00It can't statistically be as bad or worse.
04:01It just, it can't.
04:03Can't.
04:03It is.
04:04And Bobby's about to tell us.
04:05And Bobby's about to tell us that it is.
04:06Yeah.
04:07But yeah, I mean, look.
04:08I mean, truthfully, like, I've always been a fan of continuity.
04:11You know, moving on from coach to coach to coach.
04:14I mean, teams who do that are like the Jets.
04:17And the Raiders.
04:18They move.
04:19They're recycling coaches.
04:21They're revolving doors.
04:23But no, listen.
04:24There comes a point where if it's not working, it's not working.
04:26Right?
04:26Sometimes you just hire the wrong guy.
04:28And you just move on.
04:29You got to cut bait.
04:29And you got to avoid the sunk cost fallacy.
04:32But, you know, Bobby brought the point up.
04:33Like, if you give.
04:35If this season's a wash.
04:37And you just say, hey, we're not going to win the Super Bowl.
04:39Let him play it out.
04:41See if he gets better.
04:42Play it for next year.
04:43You know, there's a song years ago.
04:47Rock set.
04:48Called Listen to Your Heart.
04:50You remember that song?
04:51Chop.
04:52Listen to your heart.
04:54Na-ni-na-ni-na-na.
04:55And that is the wrong advice in this instance.
04:58Give me head.
04:59Okay?
04:59I want head in this instance.
05:03Because that's the correct play.
05:04They're out of this.
05:05Because they're out of this.
05:08You can't keep changing people.
05:10Like, if you get into year two and it's like this by week 10, fire him midseason.
05:14Like, I would be completely in favor of just an outright firing at that point.
05:17But it is to me like, you got to let somebody run it back at some point.
05:20And see if it, like, settles in.
05:22What if someone runs it back with a similar system?
05:25Someone different?
05:29I mean, there's still going to be nuances.
05:32There's still going to be differences.
05:33Sure.
05:34I mean, if they remove play calling from him and it goes to Petten, that is a fourth different scheme
05:40from the ones that they've run in the last few years.
05:42And then he may not be able to just run his scheme.
05:44He may just have to call what he calls.
05:46And, like, you've got to play within the structure of what we've already got here.
05:49But it's just so much to – what I can't reason in my head is why you're walking away here
06:00or why you might walk away here.
06:01And you didn't with Eberflus.
06:03I told you yesterday.
06:04I told you yesterday.
06:05There is more reason to believe that Matt Eberflus would fix it because of his experience than Christian Parker.
06:11They had determined by –
06:13I've seen Matt Eberflus swim a lap in the pool before.
06:17At some point in his career, he swam the lap to that end and come back.
06:21Christian Parker has got to the middle of the pool and he's six feet under.
06:26Right.
06:26But they – like, for instance, they had determined – and this speaks to the, hey, if you don't have
06:32a replacement, we just got to keep you in place.
06:34Like, they had made up in their mind last year Eberflus was done.
06:38Like, during the season they made up their mind.
06:40But they looked at it and thought, there's not really anybody that can step in and do it.
06:45Like, the coaches – the coaching staff's bad on the defensive side.
06:47There's not really anything we can do.
06:49So there's another reason you did not have a Mike Petten.
06:51And so – but, again, you're talking about infusing something that's completely different.
06:55And if it's like –
06:56If it's completely different, why did Mike Petten get brought in as an advisor?
06:59You would think you'd bring in an advisor who had similar scheme idea.
07:03Same one.
07:04No, you would – generally, you don't want to bring in an advisor who's going to check them.
07:07Like, they're going to check – yeah, they –
07:09No.
07:09I'm telling you, though, that's Schottenheimer's idea.
07:12Schottenheimer wants checks.
07:13Why would Kyle Shanahan – why would Bill Walsh not bring in an assistant versed in the West Coast offense?
07:19I'm sure he would.
07:20I'm saying Schottenheimer's whole philosophy is he likes counter – like, that was a whole thing for him this offseason
07:26during the process.
07:26He wanted people in place with him during the coaching search that had counter ideas because he wanted a check.
07:32And he wanted somebody to be able to say, all right, give me the opposite view so that it's not
07:36just the way I see it.
07:37And so I would assume he wants the same thing with Petten.
07:39So if Christian Parker was an assistant on Mike Petten's staff, why don't they view and run defense the same?
07:46How are they different defensively?
07:47Because he was basically a – when Parker was on Petten's staff, and there are aspects that he's cobbled from
07:54Elko and Petten and Fangio and things like that.
07:57But when he was an assistant, he was a quality control guy, basically.
07:59So he was like – he was kind of like a larger intern.
08:05Yeah, get the replays.
08:06It was like, yeah, go do this for us.
08:08Go research this.
08:09Go do this.
08:09Yada, yada, yada.
08:10The one where he cut his teeth with and, like, really started developing his views on things was under Fangio.
08:17And Fangio is the one who, like, his defense most – it's not an exact replica of Fangio,
08:22but it's the one that most it similarly looks like in terms of its structure.
08:26And it's very secondary top-down, the way that it's done.
08:30And Petten's going to be a lot more, like, aggressive, attack-with-the-blitz type of thinking than what Parker
08:37and Fangio would be.
08:38Now I'll get to Jesse Holley's point where he said Mike Petten should tell them no.
08:48If he does, because Mike Petten is in that –
08:53Mike Petten should say, that's my guy, Christian Parker.
08:55You brought me in to mentor him.
08:58I didn't sign up for this.
09:00And Jesse kept saying, if you're a real true OG, it would not be a real true OG move to
09:05take this promotion
09:07and push Christian Parker down or out.
09:11I love the idea.
09:12I love the sentiment.
09:14You know, it doesn't have to always be, you know, I don't say backstabby, right?
09:18But it doesn't always have to be like that.
09:20Yeah, Petten can talk to Parker and be like, sure, let's talk.
09:23That's what they want me to do.
09:24Yeah.
09:24I feel uncomfortable with it.
09:26And Christian can say, dude, just do it.
09:28Just do it.
09:28Now, if I were Petten, I also wouldn't do it for another reason.
09:32I also know this is probably my last chance of being a DC.
09:35Why the hell am I putting my faith in this unit?
09:37He didn't want to be a DC anyway.
09:39He was in Italy.
09:40Well, yeah.
09:41He was out.
09:43And they tried to hire him before the season and they couldn't.
09:45So he doesn't really want to – I don't think he –
09:48This would be that just as I thought I was out, they'd bring me back in.
09:51He doesn't want to do this, like, long term, I don't think.
09:54He retired.
09:54He was gone.
09:56So –
09:58My concern at this point is starting to be if you give 10 weeks here
10:06and then you just immediately swap it to Petten, who's one of your buddies,
10:11and you had gotten Rex Ryan in here and here for an interview,
10:15who was one of your buddies, and you didn't fire Nick Sorensen
10:18as your special teams coordinator.
10:19One of whose buddies?
10:20Schottenheimer.
10:21You didn't fire Nick Sorensen this offseason after the special teams
10:25was not great and then had problems at the beginning of this year.
10:28Sorensen, who's one of your buddies,
10:30who you've worked with at two different stops before this,
10:34it does make me wonder, like, all right, where's the check and balance
10:37for your potential buddy system?
10:40I mean, everyone hires buddies.
10:41Yeah, but, like, if you're – this feels –
10:45there's a difference between hiring your buddies
10:48and Lincoln Riley refuses to fire Alex Grinch.
10:50Lincoln Riley.
10:51Like, that's where it's like –
10:52Is that the play-by-play guy?
10:53No, that's the defensive coordinator who is just as bad.
10:57Yeah.
10:57But, no, when you look at – or former defensive coordinator.
10:59But when you look at the way that Sorensen wasn't held
11:03to the same accountability, it seemed like that Iberflus was.
11:07But special teams has gotten better, hasn't it?
11:09No, I don't – I mean, it's improved a little bit from –
11:11Jerry was sitting here raving about special teams the other day.
11:13It's improved a little bit from earlier in the year.
11:15But, I mean, overall, like, the unit the last two years
11:17has not been up to what it's been in the past.
11:19Yeah.
11:20And they would have probably argued, well, we don't have C.J. Goodwin anymore
11:22and Aubrey's, like, just going through a little bit of a slump.
11:25But they've got way more issues with the return game, blocking, kicks,
11:30different things like that.
11:32Sorensen not held to that.
11:34If Patton's just brought in here and it's, like, becoming good old boys network
11:37just to, like, grease the tracks for your buddies, I don't like that.
11:39Well, I don't really – I expect that.
11:41The checks and balances, to me, is supposed to be your general manager.
11:44Your general manager – I expect Will McClay to be a check and balance.
11:48I expect my football people and the ones above the coaching staff to say,
11:53well, Christian's not doing anything.
11:55Like, this is elementary, basic stuff that he is not getting.
12:01But, man, what a catastrophe.
12:04It really is.
12:05What a catastrophe.
12:05Of all the possible things that could have happened,
12:08we're sitting here talking about this.
12:10And if Patton says no, then what?
12:14Then does Schottenheimer go up there today at 12-10 on the fan
12:19and say, we thought about it.
12:22This would be the smart thing to do, I think.
12:24We thought about it.
12:26We exchanged ideas.
12:28Christian's going to remain the rest of the season.
12:31Now, emotionally for me as a fan in the moment, I want – I'm part of the problem.
12:37I have a Jerry-ism to me.
12:39This was zero money in my pocket.
12:42You won your bets.
12:44Yeah, that's right.
12:45Yeah, I won those bets.
12:48I would like to see a change emotionally because I've seen this already
12:54and it's been historically bad.
12:56The problem is, what if Mike – here's another problem.
13:00What if they are pretty decent under Patton?
13:05Let's just say, give me the sake of argument.
13:07They finished the year 16th in defense.
13:12No, not – from here on out, they're the 16th best defense.
13:15Yep.
13:15They're not going to finish the year 16th.
13:17And Mike Patton doesn't want to do this next year.
13:20They want to go back and retire.
13:21Yeah, he wants to go back and retire.
13:23He wants to go back to Lake Como.
13:24That has to be the part of the conversation where it's like,
13:27all right, what if Patton takes over?
13:28Or he's good, then we go back to Parker?
13:31And then – because we can't have Patton do it full time after this?
13:35Right.
13:36That's another issue.
13:37It's a major issue.
13:38You know, because then you have to figure out –
13:41What if he's good and then he leaves?
13:43I mean –
13:43No, I don't think he's going to be good.
13:44I'm just saying, what if?
13:46Look, then you've got to – you have to either overpay him
13:49and money whip him to stay, or you've got to go back to this,
13:53or go back and find the other coordinator again.
13:57I just wish right now they said to themselves,
14:00we're keeping Christian, and in the offseason,
14:03we're calling Brian Flores, we're calling Rex Ryan.
14:08I'm on the Rex train with you.
14:09Let's go, baby.
14:10I'm here.
14:10Bobby, I'm sorry.
14:11I'm pushing you off.
14:12Sexy Rex, baby.
14:13I'm desperate.
14:14Give me all the feet.
14:15I'm desperation, baby.
14:17Watch your toes in DFW.
14:19Watch your toes in Frisco, baby.
14:21Let's wax that toe hair, baby.
14:22Let's go.
14:23I'm calling Flores.
14:24I'm calling Rex.
14:25I'm calling Belichick.
14:27I'm calling – I'm calling all of them.
14:28They have to be established.
14:29Bring a Belichick here.
14:30I'm calling all of them.
14:32I'm calling – I need some A-holes.
14:34Does it count as established if you've been out of the NFL for a decade?
14:38Established?
14:38Yeah, I mean, definitely there's some expiration on it.
14:42It might be some rotten, nasty, spoiled milk.
14:44Not that you're saying, like, Rex would be your top candidate.
14:46I have often wondered, is there a weird dynamic in he was your boss and now you're his boss?
14:53Like, I have a wonderful –
14:54Christian Petten?
14:55No, just Christian Petten or Schottenheimer Rex.
14:58Like, I've always wondered, like, would that create too much of a weird dynamic to be able to exist the
15:03way you want, even if he was good at it?
15:05Yeah, but Brian wouldn't be here.
15:07I'm not calling those guys.
15:09I'm calling Flores for head coach.
15:11I'm calling Rex for – whoever Brian wants.
15:15Whoever – I'm calling – I'm back on the Tomlin.
15:17I'm here on Tomlin.
15:19I was 9-8 making my jokes before.
15:21Isn't this who Brian wanted, though?
15:23Somebody brought in.
15:24Parker.
15:25Brian who?
15:27Schottenheimer.
15:28Yeah, and what's the relevance?
15:30Why are you bringing that up?
15:31Because he said whoever Brian wants.
15:32No, whoever was Brian.
15:33Flores wants.
15:33Oh, no.
15:35No, Brian Schottenheimer.
15:36That does not matter.
15:37Brian Schottenheimer's gone, too.
15:39I'm calling Flores.
15:41Whoever you want, you name your D.C.
15:44I would really want you to run the defense, and then – Rex, give me some Flores tree.
15:50Give me that Flores tree.
15:51That's the next tree that we – I don't need the Kyle tree.
15:55I don't need the McVay tree.
15:56I need the Flores tree.
15:58There is no Flores tree.
16:00You got to have – see, Rex, if you're going to bring Brian Flores in here, I'm not bringing
16:04him here to be the head coach.
16:05I'm bringing him here to be the head coach and run the defense.
16:07Yeah.
16:07Oh, he has to run the defense.
16:09So Rex is out, right?
16:11Fine.
16:12Somebody brought up, bring in Tomlin, and then get Rex as the D.C., and bring back
16:16Jason Garrett as the offensive coordinator.
16:18Jason Garrett.
16:19Somebody said the fifth.
16:20We've got to remember to save some of the stuff so that if it ever happens, we go back
16:25and go, you did ask for it.
16:27You did ask for it.
16:28That's right.
16:28The Tomlin experiment that everybody was like, God, Pittsburgh's just miserable, just sitting
16:35there at nine wins every year, and then you asked for it now because absence makes
16:40the heart grow fonder.
16:41All right.
16:42This is a brand new Whale Wednesday, and it's brought to you by Gray Whale Gin and Vodka.
16:49My guy Jamie Bellen over there said, what's this whale thing y'all do?
16:52We have a whale bottle-inspired vodka and gin.
16:56So if you're a gin guy like Choppy, vodka guy like Bobby, Gray Whale has you covered.
17:01Gray Whale Gin and Gray Whale Vodka, California-inspired, additive-free, and crafted for a smooth, refreshing
17:07pour.
17:08Your team might be complicated.
17:11Your spirits don't have to be.
17:12Gray Whale, pick your pour.
17:15So thanks to them for signing up for the new show of whales every hump day, including Chuck
17:21Cooperstein at 820, Nick Eatman at 920.
17:25Mark Slareth was on with the G-Bag Nation, and they asked Stank, are you in favor of replacing
17:31CP?
17:32Yeah, well, I think one of the funniest things I saw was somebody had said on Twitter as Christian
17:36Parker held up his play sheet over his face like this, you know, as he's calling plays,
17:41and they said, I'm pretty sure you're not, nobody's trying to steal your plays.
17:46So, yeah, I mean, they are that bad.
17:49They have been horrid, and at some point you've got to do something about it.
17:53And I'm not going to say you're going to get any more talented, but come on, when you've
17:58got consistent, you know, making mistakes and blowing coverages and not being on the
18:04right spot, you're either coaching it or you're allowing it to happen.
18:08And those are things that just can't happen.
18:11Mental mistakes cannot happen.
18:13You're going to get whipped every now and again physically.
18:15That's going to happen.
18:16But mental mistakes can't happen.
18:18And then the other thing you have to understand is put a guy in a position to fail.
18:22Don't be surprised if he fails.
18:24You're the dumbass that put him there.
18:25And, you know, I see that last touchdown to Christian McCaffrey where they're bringing
18:29blitz and they're having Vaughn Miller peel off and try to cover Christian McCaffrey.
18:35That's never going to happen.
18:36I'm sorry.
18:37It's just not going to happen.
18:38So you put a guy in a position to fail, and he failed.
18:42And that's on you as a coach in my estimation.
18:46So there you go.
18:47Now let's get the predictions in.
18:49We'll do Bobby's study at 840 and below the belt on your home of the Cowboys, Mavs, and
18:54Rangers.
18:55What is said today around noon?
18:59Shadi sits down and he says, all right, before we get started, we were making a change at
19:05play caller.
19:05Christian Parker is going to continue to be our defensive coordinator, but we're going
19:08to have Mike Petten call plays.
19:09Pet's been in the building for a few weeks now, and he's got a handle on things.
19:13We had him in the spring, so he's not completely new to this.
19:16But we're really excited about it, and just get some of that stuff off Christian's plate
19:21to help him settle in a little bit.
19:22And I know he's going to be better for this.