- 2 days ago
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:26At first,
00:27it seemed like a place of utter desolation.
00:31But then I saw them, the stylized angels' wings hovering over the ceiling.
00:40Out of the dust burst the colors, the blues of heaven,
00:44the reds of the kings of Judah, the rainbows coming through the glass.
00:52And then, amidst all this absence, I began to sense the presence,
00:57the cantor's chant, the murmuring banter.
01:01And there in the galleries were the women of Jewish Koshice,
01:05and down below the men in silks and hats.
01:11In the spring of 1944, 15,700 Jews from Koshice,
01:16the entire community, were sent to their deaths in Auschwitz.
01:21But this wasn't a place that sat passively, waiting for its death sentence.
01:29Before the Holocaust, Koshice, like thousands of Jewish towns and villages
01:34strung across Central and Eastern Europe, was alive, thriving, confident, noisy.
01:41The opera and the klezmer, the schnorrer beggars and the prosperous merchants,
01:46the pushcart peddlers and the street corner revolutionaries.
01:54That this world somehow flourished despite all the pounding storms that would come its way,
01:59is an escape act so epic that it counts as one of history's all-time redeeming miracles.
02:06Even when systematic annihilation overwhelmed the people,
02:11the world that had nourished them survived.
02:14This is the story about how this unique culture of faith and ferment,
02:20of poetry and music, of a search for deliverance from brutality and oppression,
02:25did not get pulverized by the hammer of history.
02:28It just changed its address.
02:33From Minsk to Manhattan, from the shtetl to Hollywood,
02:37and ultimately, from destruction to salvation.
02:41I'm not so proud.
03:05I'm not so proud.
03:12The American Name of Egypt
03:13The American Name of Egypt
03:13Yeah, it is famous.
03:41As a grounds result in the world,
03:41some of his ум being diminished.
03:41home to more than five million Jews, the largest population of Jews in the world.
03:49They were the Ashkenazi, Yiddish speakers who first came east from the valleys of Germany
03:55and France in search of refuge from persecutions and expulsions sometime around the 13th century.
04:04They would find it in what was then the largest and most tolerant state in Europe, the Polish
04:10Lithuanian kingdom. Pragmatists, not sentimentalists, the Polish kings asked the Jews to harvest
04:17their taxes, allowing the Jews not just to settle, but to prosper. But when at the end
04:24of the 18th century the kingdom was carved up between Austria, Prussia and Russia, most
04:30Jews fell under Russian rule.
04:34For Russian merchants, this new Jewish population was unwanted competition. Russia's response
04:42was to expel the Jews from the major cities and confine them to the Pale of Settlement,
04:48stretching from the Baltic to the Black Sea. Somewhere at the northern end of it, in the
04:54neck of these Lithuanian woods were my mother's family, the Steinbergs. Like many Jews in the
05:01small towns of the Pale, called Shtetls, they eked out a living as best they could, trading
05:07an illegal liquor, hustling in the markets, and felling trees in the woods.
05:12You don't really think about the Jews as woodland people very much. In fact, in Jewish tradition,
05:18the woods are where demons lurked. Yet somehow the Steinbergs and countless thousands of them
05:25had to make a living in what was called the lumber business. The rich Jews got to ship it
05:31off to Hamburg and places west. My lot would cut and stack and log and pile. In our family,
05:39there were stories of the wolf attacks. My mother used to talk about her great uncle showing off
05:45his wolf scars on his birthday. The Lithuanian Jews, the Litvaks, took a kind of pride in the harshness
05:55of their world. They were kind of fierce and flinty. I tell you how you can tell the difference,
06:00the way Lithuanian Jews felt about themselves, and Polish Jews to the south.
06:05Lithuanian Jews never put sugar in their gefilte fish, the way the Poles did.
06:11They only liked it salt, tough, briny kind of fish. And they were fierce in their religion, too.
06:19But it wasn't at least, however harsh, a solitary life. Everything the villagers of the Shtetls did,
06:26they did together. They worked together. They sang together. They ate together. They lived together.
06:32They died together. The word individualism, I think, doesn't have a translation in Yiddish.
06:39They were never individuals. They were a kahal. They were a community.
06:50There's little left of the Jewish Lithuania the Steinbergs knew. But its ghosts have materialised
06:57in the most unlikely places. In 2001, someone reached into a sofa of this gloomy St Petersburg
07:07apartment and pulled out a miraculous treasure trove of over 350 hand-printed photographs of
07:15shtetl life, taken between 1912 and 1914 by a group of Jewish ethnographers, led by the writer
07:24and socialist revolutionary Semyon Anski. They had set off on what they called an expedition
07:31into the dark continent of the pale to document everything they could find. The streets, the schools,
07:42the extraordinary wooden synagogues, and the countless ways the Jews made their living.
07:55So many of the clichés, you know, take a beating in these incredible pictures. And there's nothing in
08:02these shtetls that Jews aren't doing. It's not true that they're just tailers and peddlers. They're blacksmiths
08:09and they're bakers and they're weavers. And this cobbler is quite fantastic. He's not going to pose for the camera.
08:16This is actually someone living. He's not a folk caricature in any way. But there is, I don't know,
08:23the uncle, the local grocer, who's sitting there patiently on the bench, waiting for his souls to be repaired.
08:31And here's three incredibly dirt-encrusted, nebbishy types. You know these. These are the bad uncles, really,
08:42who've had a bit too much vodka. And there they all are, just sitting there, a bit curious.
08:51This is a world that lives and breathes and dances and sings, really. And it's not sentimental. It's real.
09:00Shut out from the cities, from professions and universities, forbidden to own land,
09:06shtetl Jews looked inwards to their own culture for enrichment. To the outside world,
09:12they looked impoverished. But they had the treasure of their holy books,
09:17bequeathed by countless generations of sages. From the Cheder schools,
09:23where the Hebrew teacher taught fidgeting children every word of the Torah and Talmud.
09:32To the deep culture of self-help and charity, where everyone from the rabbi to the old folk in the
09:39retirement home had an allotted place,
09:42the shtetl was a wrap-around world, a micro-estate shaped to survive amidst the repressive policies of the Russian
09:49Tsars.
09:54And perhaps one of the most enduring and painful memories of shtetl life was the forced conscription of Jewish boys
10:02as young as 12 into the Russian army for up to 25 years.
10:11It's hardly surprising then that there were times when the shackles would be cast off in a collective frenzy of
10:19joy.
10:20Times are hard in the shtetl. The rabbi's on his last legs. Nobody can make a living anymore.
10:26The Cossacks around the corner. What do we all need? We need a simcha.
10:29And the best simcha of all is a chossena, a wedding. Weddings are the time when the whole shtetl comes
10:36together.
10:37In these streets around here in the shtetl at the beginning will be the nigun, the procession, slow, dignified,
10:45the bride being led into the square by the two mothers, two mothers, one on each side, under the chuppah
10:52they go.
10:54Their friends say the seven blessings, the sheva barachot. The groom stamps on the glass finally.
11:01With the left or right foot, I can never remember which.
11:04Because in all weddings, in all simchas, in all moments of joy there must be a moment of sorrow.
11:11We must remember the destruction of the temple, sorrow and happiness. Such a Jewish idea.
11:19The crowd go crazy. Muzzled off they shout. The klezmorim, the cream of music from all around.
11:26The skirling caranet. The tsimbal, the tsimbalon. The whirling fiddle, the drums.
11:34Dancing starts. And maybe even if the rabbi is not so well, he starts the dancing.
11:40The men on one side, the women on the other.
11:45Chassan karo mazel tov. And the rabbi himself dances and dances with his eyes burning.
11:52Because an old Jewish saying says,
11:55Every man is an instrument and his life is the melody.
12:00For many shtetl Jews, feeling the joy letting it course through the body
12:05wasn't something that should be reserved for a wedding.
12:08And that deep craving for an ecstatic Judaism sparked the astounding mass phenomenon of chassidism.
12:24Unlike traditional Jewish orthodoxy that centered almost exclusively on the study of the Torah and the Talmud,
12:32chassidism also urged Jews to commune with God directly through joyous bouts of singing and dancing and ecstatic trance-like
12:41prayer.
12:44That's what God wants. Turn somersaults before the ark, if the holy moon takes you.
12:51The idea was to melt the soul into the Shekhinah, the divine radiance that flows through all earthly things.
13:05Chassidism has left an extraordinary imprint on the Jewish world.
13:09But to understand why it emerged, one has to travel further into the pale and back 300 years.
13:20The shtetl of Satanoff in Ukraine was once deep chassidic country.
13:29The number and sheer exuberance of the gravestones reveal the prosperity and vitality of the Jewish presence here.
13:37They burst with animal energy and chassidic high spirits.
13:42Hairs spin on the cosmic wheel. Bears clamber for grapes on the tree of life.
13:49Lions are rampant as Jewish lions must be.
13:54This community clearly didn't tremble in terror.
13:58But terror was never far away, descending on Satanoff, not just in the form of famine and plague, but rampaging
14:05Cossacks,
14:06who singled out Jews for slaughter as the protected people of their hated enemy, the Polish king.
14:14That's why Satanoff's Jews built their synagogue as a fortress.
14:20And if the horrors receded, the memories didn't, and many Jews felt that the traditional leaders of the religious community,
14:28the severe masters of the Talmud, fell short of answering their spiritual and emotional needs.
14:37Into the breach stepped a group of itinerant mystics called the Ba'ale Shem, the masters of the name.
14:45Whose name? Well, gods, of course.
14:48And these were masters who, through secret knowledge, could manipulate the letters of God's name to protect you from harm.
14:59Those secrets were derived from the ancient mystical tradition of the Kabbalah, a doctrine of esoteric knowledge revealing profound truths
15:08about the nature of God and the universe.
15:12Kabbalistic tradition has it that the very substance of the world was made of letters alif, air, shin, fire, mem,
15:21water.
15:22And the most powerful and dangerous letters of all were the many holy names of God, which could be rearranged
15:29and chanted to perform miracles on earth, bringing the infinite of the divine into the finite world of man.
15:48It was an extraordinary moment in Jewish history, a moment when wonder-working rabbis ascending into the heavenly courts of
15:57God to defend their people from harm struck a profound chord with the people of the pale.
16:03And the most legendary of them all was the man who came to be known as the founder of Hasidism,
16:08the Ba'al Shem Tav, the master of the good name.
16:13And over the next hundred years, his followers, known as tzaddiks, righteous men, became kings among Jews, creating courts with
16:22tribes of young followers, founding dynasties, some of which survive in Hasidism even today.
16:33Hasidism was so popular and so successful, I think, because essentially it was a response against helplessness, against the autocratic
16:43states that took Jews for cannon fodder and every other kind of fodder for that matter.
16:48Against those states, Hasidism created states of faith, complete with a righteous man, a prince-messiah scholar at its center,
17:01the tzaddik, and around him an entire spiritual army,
17:05and with him a great body of fabulous lore, tales of wonder and healing and resurrection, the tzaddik prince could
17:16make barren fields fertile.
17:19He could make the impotent virile. He could communicate with the stars. He was the possessor of secret mysteries which
17:27would keep away demons.
17:29Demons. Now how could enlightened despots, and for that matter, enlightened Jews in their city suits compete with that?
17:45Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, Hasidism has returned to the land of its birth.
17:53In the Ukrainian town of Uman, 30,000 pilgrims visit the grave of one of the most charismatic tzaddiks, Rabbi
18:01Nachman of Bratislav, on Rosh Hashanah every year, two centuries after his death.
18:06They come to ensure their tzaddik's protection for the year ahead.
18:14Hasidism is still a cult of ecstatic communion, and it holds true to the principles of its birth.
18:24I think today it's very difficult to live as a religious Jew without a Hasidic way,
18:33because Hasidism teaches that you can find God in anything.
18:39Even very bad things.
18:41This is our purpose, to reveal holiness in anything that we deal with.
18:48Money, business, food, intimacy. This is his mission, this world.
18:58And joy is that you know that you do the right things, that you live a meaningful life.
19:08But not every Jew fell into the redemptive raptures of Hasidic prayer.
19:13If you craved more than ecstatic visions, if you had a restless Jewish mind and even more restless feet,
19:21then the world of the shtetl could bring on attacks of claustrophobia.
19:25And there at the very bottom of the pale, facing the Black Sea, was one place, a port city with
19:31eyes open to the world,
19:33that drew those Jews like moths to a flame.
19:38Its name was Odessa.
19:41A city of grand boulevards and brothels of theatres.
19:46And progressive schools that taught Jewish boys, Russian, politics and mathematics.
19:52The flames of hell burn seven miles around Odessa, the rabbis warned.
20:07And it was soon full of modern Jews, who loved that hellish heat.
20:13Grain merchants and gangsters, tarts and klezmer fiddlers,
20:17poets and Jewish thinkers who hung out at cafes,
20:20where they smoked and sang and read radical Russian literature.
20:25Here, they'd ask themselves the big question,
20:28how to be Jewish in the modern world without resorting to Hasidic miracles in the sky.
20:38Two of them would make a profound impact on the world of the Jews.
20:43Moshe Lillianbloom was a religious runaway from Lithuania,
20:47who turned his back on what he regarded as the stifling relic of Jewish orthodoxy.
20:53His friend, Dr Leo Pinsker, was the son of an enlightened Hebrew teacher,
20:58who'd been taught that Jews must live in the real world,
21:01not in their mystical version of it.
21:07And like a lot of their fast-talking crowd,
21:10they believed that if only Jews embraced revolutionary politics
21:14and joined forces with the downtrodden people, their Russian comrades,
21:19they could change the motherland,
21:21and that surely would be enough to make a better life for the Jews.
21:30But the bitter truth was that even here, in Odessa,
21:34the Jews couldn't escape the shadow of violence.
21:38On the 13th of March, 1881,
21:42Tsar Alexander II was assassinated in St Petersburg
21:45by the Russian left-wing terrorist organization Rodnaya Volia,
21:50the People's Will.
21:52One Jewish girl was amongst the plotters,
21:55and within the month, a tidal wave of pogroms,
21:58from the Russian word to destroy,
22:01was unleashed across the pale.
22:04They hit Odessa, Kirovograd, Kiev,
22:09then Yekaterinoslav and Kishinov,
22:13followed by attacks on hundreds of shtetls across the pale.
22:22And in 1903, the most violent wave yet,
22:27Minsk, Simferopol and Odessa,
22:29once again for the sixth time.
22:35In the morning of November the 6th, 1905,
22:38people all over Britain
22:40were reading this in their Guardian newspaper
22:44as they ate their bacon and eggs.
22:48The events in the suburbs of Moldovanka,
22:52Slobodka and Bugayoka last night
22:53were of a most terrible nature.
22:56Immense bands of ruffians,
22:58accompanied by policemen,
22:59invaded all the Jewish houses
23:01and mercilessly slaughtered the occupants.
23:06Men and women were barbarously felled
23:09and decapitated with axes.
23:12Children were torn limb from limb.
23:14The streets were littered with corpses,
23:17hurled out of windows.
23:19The houses of murdered Jews were then
23:21systematically destroyed.
23:23In this way, the Jewish population of the district
23:27was wiped out.
23:45The morning that the reporter visited the hospitals of Odessa,
23:49there were at least 3,000 people in the emergency wards.
23:54It was, by any standards of outrage,
23:57the most appalling atrocity
23:59in the entire blood-stained history of the Russian pogroms.
24:06For many Jewish intellectuals,
24:08this was the moment that shot them out of the complacency
24:12that they might ever attain equal rights in Tsarist Russia.
24:17One of the illusions was that non-Jewish leftists would come to their defence,
24:22but they hadn't.
24:24And this bitter lesson threw them in different directions.
24:27Some would rush even further into the arms of socialist revolution.
24:33Others, like Lilian Blum and Pinsker,
24:36would acknowledge the death of those dreams.
24:40Having devoted their futures to Russia,
24:43they now founded the first Jewish nationalist organisation.
24:47They called it the Lovers of Zion.
24:52After the terrifying pogrom here in Odessa,
24:56Pinsker published a small booklet,
24:59which I read as a child had an electrifying influence on me,
25:02called Auto-Emancipation.
25:05In that booklet, Pinsker diagnosed,
25:08and he was a doctor, remember,
25:11Judeophobia as a kind of fear of ghosts.
25:14The problem, he said, was that Jewish national existence
25:17had died a long time ago,
25:20but Jews were still alive everywhere,
25:22and people treated them as phantoms,
25:25and you get neurotic about phantoms.
25:29The only way to cure it for Pinsker
25:31was not for Jews to be beholden to others,
25:34to receive civil rights,
25:36like charity given to a beggar.
25:39The issue was to seize a sense of your own national identity,
25:44to make it happen somewhere,
25:46and make it happen with power and moral strength.
25:51Thereupon was a momentous departure,
25:55momentous absolutely for Jews,
25:57and as I need hardly tell you,
26:00incredibly momentous for the world.
26:08For the countless Jewish multitudes,
26:10there was, of course, another way out.
26:13Why wait for Zion,
26:15when there was another promised land
26:16lying across the ocean?
26:18America!
26:21It was known in Yiddish as the Golden Medina,
26:24the Golden Sanctuary,
26:25and it had long been on the lips of the pale.
26:31Letters from relatives who'd already made the trip
26:34told fables of a land of miracles,
26:36and if that sounds like something straight out of Hasidism,
26:40well then, it's no coincidence.
26:48Maybe this is where the Messiah might be,
26:52even if this Messiah would be called American Democracy.
27:01And the tales weren't all tall.
27:04Earlier Jewish immigrants had gone west and struck gold.
27:09In America, Mottel the Tailor could become Levi Strauss of Levi's Jeans.
27:16Peddlers could build banks.
27:20A Jew, Adolf Sutro, could even become the 24th mayor of San Francisco.
27:28All of them had the same story.
27:33Emigrating from provincial Germany in the 1850s,
27:36they'd peddled their way across America,
27:37selling soap, polish and cloth,
27:40opening stores and investing wisely.
27:43In the industries that built America,
27:45the steelworks, the mines, the railroads and the skyscrapers.
27:55In Uptown New York, the Temple Emmanuel on Fifth Avenue
27:59shows just how established and successful
28:02this wave of Jewish immigrants would become.
28:06This was and still is the headquarters of American Reform Judaism.
28:12Progressive, English-speaking,
28:14not sticklers for the minutiae of Talmudic laws,
28:17but proud, unapologetic Jews nonetheless.
28:23This is where many of those Jewish American names you might have heard of,
28:27the Wall Street bankers and industrialists,
28:30like the Schiffs, the Warburgs and the Guggenheims,
28:33could sit together with their wives
28:35in their fancy hats from Bergdorf's, Macy's and Bloomingdale's,
28:39their fellow congregant stores.
28:43Here was the promise of Jews out in the world becoming something,
28:47astonishingly realised in glass and stone.
28:51Anyone coming into this place could be forgiven for thinking
28:55that they'd arrived perhaps in a third temple in Jerusalem.
29:00And if this wasn't actually Jerusalem,
29:03it must have seemed pretty much like it.
29:05This stupendous, glorious decoration,
29:09marble, mosaic, soaring Romanesque columns,
29:12all will have delivered an astonishing proclamation
29:16of Jewish magnificence.
29:19Remember where the Jews of New York had come from.
29:23And now, uptown, they could lay claim
29:26to one of the most extraordinary buildings,
29:28not just in New York, but in the whole of the United States.
29:41A couple of miles downtown,
29:43most of the new wave of Jewish immigrants pouring into New York harbour
29:47ended up just streets away from the boat
29:50in the mega shtetl of New York's Lower East Side.
29:54It's the iconic landing place in the Jewish American story for a good reason.
30:00Of the two and a half million Jews arriving in America between the 1880s and the 1920s,
30:06more than 60% of them began their new lives here,
30:10stuffed into a patch of land just one and a half miles square.
30:14This lot were deeply different from the uptown Jews of Temple Emmanuel.
30:20Proletarian, drenched in old world superstitions or radical politics,
30:25and worst of all, Yiddish.
30:28And in many ways, the New World was just a high-rise version of the old one they'd left behind.
30:34Here too were the pushcart peddlers and the street corner revolutionaries.
30:40Here too were Orthodox synagogues built in the Moorish styles of Eastern Europe,
30:46where star canters were shipped in from Odessa,
30:49albeit now on $2,000 contracts.
30:52Welcome to America.
31:10But in the shav and jostle of city life,
31:13the authority of the rabbi was soon overtaken by the institutions of democratic America.
31:20In particular, the socialist newspaper The Daily Forward and a Yarmulovsky bank,
31:25described as the two handles of the Torah scroll, holding the community up.
31:31By the standards of 1912, these two buildings were skyscrapers,
31:36the tallest boys in the block and are very close to each other,
31:40two big animals ideologically locking horns.
31:44They were built on the same street in the same year by two immigrants from the Pale.
31:51On one side was Abraham Kahan, a revolutionary socialist from Lithuania,
31:55who turned The Forward into the most widely read Jewish newspaper in America.
32:00Like a secular tzaddik, he fought the battles of the poor in print
32:05and initiated them into the novelties of American life, like baseball and voting.
32:11On the other was Sendor Yarmulovsky, a New World banker, but always a good Torah Jew.
32:18Not only did he encourage Jews to save in order to get themselves out of the Lower East Side,
32:24he also provided reliable shipping tickets to those they'd left behind in the nightmare of the pogroms.
32:31And just to make sure his building was taller than Kahan's, Yarmulovsky added a 12-metre cupola to his roof.
32:39Such an American story.
32:42Look, it's possible to think of these big boys, the socialist and the banker,
32:47as locked in a battle for control of the Jewish future in the Lower East Side,
32:53but I don't really think of it like that at all.
32:56I think both of them essentially embodied the old Jewish principle,
33:03right out of Hasidic Europe, tzedakah, benevolence or charity,
33:08the loving-kindness of your fellow neighbor,
33:11planted in that other meaning of tzedakah, justice.
33:15Both these tall, big boys were the embodiments of Jewish justice.
33:21And I found my inspiration on the east side of New York City.
33:36Justice, charity, the community.
33:39Words that had come straight from the shtetel,
33:41hardly surprising in the world of the socialist newspaper,
33:45perhaps more so in the world of New York banking.
33:48All form a part of my tenement symphony.
33:58But what's even more surprising is how shtetel idealism would cling
34:03to the next generation of American Jews,
34:05who'd take it right into the brassy heart of American popular culture.
34:11Growing up in the pressure cooker of the Lower East Side was a group of Jewish boys
34:15who'd go on to create the music that all America would sing.
34:21There was Israel Baleen, who became Irving Berlin,
34:25super-patriot, the composer of God Bless America.
34:29There were the Gershowitz brothers, shortly to become the Gershwins,
34:34who took the cool of the jazz age and injected romantic warmth in it.
34:40And then there was someone some of you might not have heard of,
34:44Isidore Hotberg, who became Yip Harberg.
34:47Now, Yip had something entirely different in mind for his great song lyrics.
34:53He wasn't interested so much in escaping from this world,
34:56the world of the Lower East Side as taking its passions and its concerns
35:01right slap-bang into the heart of American show business.
35:07Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. E.Y. Yip Harberg.
35:25Yip Harberg was born on the sixth floor of a walk-up on Allen Street
35:29to two Yiddish-speaking immigrants,
35:32Lewis and Mary Hotberg from Minsk in the Pale.
35:35She was deeply orthodox.
35:39He was a little bit less so,
35:42taking work in the sweatshops whenever it was on offer.
35:46Their grandson, Yip's son, Ernie Harberg,
35:49still lives on the Lower East Side.
35:52They were all desperately poor.
35:55They worked six days a week,
35:57and then the mother used to work on Sundays.
36:01I think she made some kind of hatch for people, all right?
36:06And it was all work.
36:08You had to work all the time.
36:10And the parents spoke Yiddish.
36:13They never spoke English.
36:15So, Yip was the intermediary between them and the outside world,
36:20no matter what it was, the landlord, the postman, anything.
36:24They had to get Yip to play the man in the house, see? Right?
36:28So, you know, he grew up pretty fast.
36:32And the one thing that startled me a little bit was to know,
36:37because it was an Orthodox or at least a moderate Orthodox family,
36:43that the father actually told the mother that he was taking Yip to Shul,
36:50to the synagogue, and they wouldn't go there.
36:53They went to the Rialto musicals along on 2nd Avenue there.
37:01It was a household immersed in the sweatshop socialism
37:04of the Lower East Side, which sent Jewish America
37:07into a fever of unrest in 1909 and 1910,
37:12when over 80,000 mostly Jewish garment workers went on strike.
37:25His father read the socialist daily paper to him,
37:32the Daily Forward, I think it was, every night and read him poetry.
37:36And I think the left-wing leanings of the fathers
37:41was handed down to the sons and the daughters.
37:51Desperate to get his parents out of the tenements,
37:54Yip gave up his dreams of becoming a songwriter
37:57and set up a company selling home appliances to New York housewives,
38:01which, by 1929, was worth a quarter of a million dollars.
38:08But then, on the 29th of October 1929, came the Wall Street Crash,
38:13which brought his business and America to its knees.
38:19Four million unemployed almost overnight.
38:23The industries that have built America,
38:26railways, mines, steel plants,
38:28all put into what seemed like an eternal deep freeze.
38:34When do we work?
38:38There's nothing wrong with me.
38:40I can still work.
38:41I'm okay.
38:46By 1932, the Great Depression had become the battleground for a new election.
38:51President Herbert Hoover versus Franklin Roosevelt, the Governor of New York,
38:56who put the blue-collar working man at the heart of his campaign.
39:00These unhappy times call for the building up of plans
39:05that build from the bottom up and not from the top down,
39:09that put their faith once more in the forgotten man at the bottom of the economic tyranny.
39:18But if it was America's nightmare, it was Yip Harburg's salvation.
39:24Yip had written enough songs to land a job on a new satirical show on Broadway called Americana,
39:31which was to center on Roosevelt's Forgotten Man.
39:36And it was with an unknown Tin Pan Alley composer, another Jew, Jay Gorney,
39:42that he wrote the song that will become the anthem of the Great Depression.
39:49I didn't want a song to depress people.
39:52I wanted to write a song to make people think.
39:56In other words, it isn't a hand-me-out song, a hand-me-up song,
40:01of give me a dime, I'm starving, I'm bitter.
40:03It wasn't that kind of sentimentality.
40:06Once I built a railroad, made it run, made it race against time.
40:13Once I built a railroad, now it's done.
40:17Brother, can you spare a dime?
40:20Once I built a tower, to the sun, brick and rivet and lime.
40:29Once I built a tower, now it's done.
40:33Brother, can you spare a dime?
40:41The melody was based on a Yiddish lullaby that had been sung to Jay Gorney by his grandmother, Back in
40:48the Pale.
40:49And on to a song of suffering and hope, Yip played the poetry and passion of Lower East Side politics.
40:56The first line of their song runs, they used to tell me I was building a dream.
41:04We all know who they are, the fat cats who were surviving the slump.
41:09And what is this song doing, saying that American dream no longer survives?
41:14You bet it was. And it only got tougher still in Yip Harburg's lyrics.
41:22The song was a potted history of the American dream fallen into the ash can.
41:28A song about American heroes, the railway and construction worker, the veterans of World War I reduced to begging.
41:36And it took two new Americans, two Jews, immersed in the ideas of justice, to prick America's conscience.
41:44And above all, tragically, it's a dagger pointed at the heart of what had become of buddydom, that deep American
41:52ideal of friendship.
41:54Don't you remember? I was your pal. Buddy.
41:58For the first time, that word brother becomes buddy. Can you spare a dime?
42:04Say, don't you remember? Say, don't you remember? I'm your pal. Buddy, can you spare a dime?
42:32Isn't that a bitter song? He's a man who was proud of what he did.
42:37Now, you would think the audience, out for a night out in Broadway, would be horrified by walking out.
42:42They did nothing of the sort. They stood every single night for an ovation, cheered till they were hoarse.
42:48Harburg and Gawney had not only written a song that was in American history, they'd made American history.
42:55The election was just a few weeks away. Suddenly, every crooner, Bing Crosby, Rudy Vallee, wanting to record this confrontational
43:05anthem of the Great Depression.
43:07The Republicans were terrified that it would elect Roosevelt and attempted to ban it, and maybe it did.
43:14He was swept to power. Looking back on it, Jay Gawney said that was the song of the American soul.
43:34Jewish soul, with its minor key melodies and plaintive but defiant vocals, finds its musical kin in that other great
43:42family of American song, black soul music.
44:00This is Joshua Nelson, a Jewish African-American singer, who's married up chazanut, traditional Jewish cantorial music with African-American
44:11spirituals,
44:12in what he calls kosher gospel, a fusion of kindred souls.
44:34So, Joshua, is there something about the structure of the music, the sound of the music, the insides of the
44:41music,
44:41which is common between black and Jewish experience?
44:44Kosher gospel music is experiencing that shteto experience, in a way.
44:50You know, in the old cantors, nowadays, a lot of cantors, the chazanut is not as intense as it used
44:57to be.
44:58No, when I heard you sing it, it was absolutely electrifying. It was like the 19th century.
45:03And that's what soul is.
45:05Soul is the neshama, it's the spirit inside of the body crying out from suffering.
45:11Um, you take, um, for instance,
45:16Onihimami
45:21Onihimami
45:24Onihimami
45:25Onihimami
45:25Onihimami
45:29Onihimami
45:40Onihimami
45:50Un adjectives
45:53Onihim
45:55Onihim
46:10Onihim
46:11It's not necessarily a black or a Jewish thing.
46:15I think it's a matter of humanity.
46:24What America had taught the Jews is that the dream that they could be both Jewish and part of the
46:30wider culture in which they live,
46:32a dream that was impossible in the old world of Russia, did actually have a chance of working out.
46:40And not just working out, the success of their songs would take Yip, the Gershwins and Irving Berlin across America
46:47into the dream factory of Hollywood.
46:53Of all the American industries that the Jews had been involved in, this was the one that made the most
46:58powerful imprint on American life.
47:04In the 1930s, all the big studios had been created and were run by Jews, Paramount, and 20th Century Fox.
47:14Warner Brothers, run by Harry and Jack Warner.
47:21And the big daddy of them all, MGM, under the iron fist of Louis B. Mayer.
47:27Those Jews had pretty much the same story to tell.
47:32Their fathers, who'd been the immigrants from the Shtetls and Eastern Europe, from the bad part of Germany,
47:38had pretty much all been failures in the scrap metal business, selling stuff off barrows on Hester and Delancey Street.
47:47But their boys, their boys were hungry for something bigger and more spectacular.
47:53And very often, they took time off, especially time off from Jewish observance, to come to places like this, to
48:00vaudeville shows.
48:06Between the dog and pony acts and the busty sopranos and the flat-footed comedians telling slightly off-color jokes,
48:14there they saw the future.
48:16They saw little Picture Palace shorts, news of the day, mini documentaries, but sometimes little tiny biopics.
48:24And they saw how America would change through the movies.
48:31And it wasn't just about swashbuckling romances or making huge sums of money, but they'd certainly do that.
48:38They wanted the movies to be a school for working-class America.
48:43Such a Jewish idea.
48:45They'd exalt it with history, with the noble epics of world literature, creating on screen an ideal America.
48:54No wonder, out of all the possible birthdates that were claimed for Louis Mayer, the one he chose was, of
49:01course, the 4th of July.
49:06In 1938, Louis Mayer would give Yip Harburg, Hollywood's dream ticket, the job of lyricist, on The Wizard of Oz.
49:16A fantasy about munchkins and witches and a magical utopian land in the sky, not too far removed from the
49:23Hasidic tales.
49:25This time, his composer was Harold Arlen, the son of a synagogue canter from Buffalo,
49:31who'd started his career in the vaudeville theatres of the Lower East Side.
49:37Together, they'd write the song that would come to define the golden age of Hollywood,
49:42and which would win them the Oscar at the Academy Awards of 1940.
49:47To Harold Arlen and E.Y. Harburg for the year's best song,
49:50Over the Rainbow, from The Wizard of Oz.
50:02Somewhere over the rainbow, way up high,
50:13It was a long way from the shtetl, or was it?
50:17For who could write this universal song of hope better than a Jewish boy from the Lower East Side?
50:23And what is Oz other than America,
50:26or any place where dreams of a better life really do come true?
50:31And the dreams that you dare to dream
50:36really do come true
50:40It's amazing to think that the song,
50:43which pretty much everybody believes is the greatest movie song of all time,
50:48almost never happened.
50:50It wasn't in the book for The Wizard of Oz.
50:53Because the producers of the movie complained that it wasn't right to come out of the voice of a little
50:59girl in Kansas.
51:01But Yip Harburg and Howard Arlen believed in it passionately.
51:06Why?
51:07Well, because it summed up all of the history of Jewish yearning for deliverance from oppression.
51:15All that back history of their own families.
51:19But what they did was actually to channel that specifically Jewish American sensibility
51:24and marry it up with something authentically American.
51:29The intense American faith in optimism.
51:33And by doing that, they made somewhere over the rainbow a universal treasure.
51:54I wish the story could end there,
51:56with the collective success of America's Jews and the dream world of Oz, but it didn't.
52:03Remember the date of that triumphant night at the Oscars, 1940.
52:23What American Jews saw when they looked across the oceans at their old homelands
52:28were nationalisms inflamed by war that had grown ever more violently racist and not just in Germany.
52:36And this was not good for the three million Jews who'd stayed behind.
52:43I was born in Belongian in 1923.
52:56I was born in Belongian in 1923, a Jewish family.
53:07In the 1930s, the small town of Plunga in northern Lithuania, the land of my mother's family,
53:14was like any other shtetl community in what was once the pale, half Jewish, half Lithuanian.
53:21And where life for the water carriers, merchants, and Jewish grandmas still revolved around the old world institutions of market
53:29and synagogue.
53:36But in 1941, the shtetl was engulfed in tragedy.
53:43Aged just 17, Jacobus was conscripted into the Red Army to fight the Nazis, which saved his life.
53:52But on his return to Plunga after the war, he found a shtetl emptied of Jews.
53:58His father, brother, and grandfather all disappeared.
54:02How many people were killed here, Jacobus?
54:28Jacobus was the last Jew in Plunga.
54:30The carpenter, he's devoted his life to rebuilding its Jewish memory, carving his own land.
54:36a memorial in the woods, and surrounding himself with the shtetl characters of his youth.
54:41This is a typical Jew of Batshuish.
54:46This is...
54:50This is...
54:51This is...
54:53This is...
54:53This is a shtetl.
54:54This is...
54:57This is...
54:59This is...
55:00This is...
55:01This is...
55:03this,
55:03this Mense religious system.
55:11This...
55:15This is...
55:16This is the Holocaust...
55:17This is...
55:42In the end, it wasn't the gas chambers of Auschwitz that killed the Jews of Plunga.
55:47However, the Holocaust had barely got into its stride by the summer of 1941.
55:55Instead, Plunga's Jews were rounded up and their wooden synagogues destroyed with the
56:00active participation of some of those who'd been the Jews' neighbours for generations.
56:11As the grandchild of a Lithuanian Jewish family, I need to tell you what happened.
56:18What happened was this.
56:20The Jews, those Jews who'd been rounded up, were hermetically sealed inside a synagogue,
56:26locked up with no air, no water, no light for two weeks.
56:33People died in their own filth.
56:36They were not even allowed to throw the dead bodies of the old people, the children, outside.
56:45When they were finally allowed out, they were forced to defile and burn the heart and soul
56:51of their faith, the Sefer Torah, the scrolls of the law, before being led into the forests
56:57where they had worked for centuries, but where they were now forced to dig their own mass graves
57:03before they were shot.
57:07So I suppose I should tell you that the Jewish idea, that the ethical spirit, that moral force
57:16could vanquish physical force, that the Shekhinah, the divine presence, fills the entire world,
57:24came to an end in those stinking pits of broken bodies and horror.
57:29But it didn't end.
57:33It never does end.
57:35It moves elsewhere.
57:40The Jews pick up their old battered suitcases and find somewhere else
57:46where there's a possibility of the decency and the nobility of an ordinary life.
57:55I remember something said by the Hasidic rabbi, Shaloma of Carlin, who said that the worst
58:02thing the evil urge can do is to make us forget that men are all the sons of a king.
58:14Even in a place like this, thinking of a time like that, I wouldn't be Jewish if I didn't at
58:22least try and remember that.
58:30Somewhere over the rainbow, bluebirds fly.
58:40Birds fly over that rainbow.
58:45Why then, oh why can't I?
58:51If any little bird can slide beyond the rainbow, why, oh why can't I?
59:01When I am in again, I will find each other and 문�им from an 같은데,
59:02depending when I am in-and-w miserably.