1
- 2 days ago
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:04It was the last day of December 1720 and there was one place that everyone in
00:11Rome wanted to be. It was the hottest ticket in town.
00:23Cardinals, ambassadors and dignitaries assembled in a gilded private chapel.
00:30To pay their tributes to the new-born heir of an ancient dynasty, son of James, pretender
00:40to the British throne and Clementina, the daughter of a Polish prince. A child baptised on the
00:48day of his birth as Charles Edward Stuart, a boy that would come to be known by many
00:56different names. The young pretender. The prince over the water. And of course,
01:07Bonnie Prince Charlie. The man who, at the age of 24, raised a legendary Highland army.
01:16And God defends Scotland! An army that captured Carlisle, Preston and Manchester and terrified
01:27London. And the legacy of Charles, the young Chevalier, is still with us.
01:34270 years afterwards, people are still laying wreaths in loving memory. But of his 67 years,
01:45Charles spent only 11 months in Scotland.
01:52So, this is not a Scottish story, not a British story, but a European story.
01:59Of kings, popes and princes. Of great military and diplomatic alliances.
02:08How the exiled Stuarts used, and were used, by the most powerful European dynasties.
02:27In the 1720s, the Stuarts were among the most illustrious and notorious families in Rome.
02:36They were, if nothing else, something of an upmarket tourist attraction.
02:41James and his wife Clementina would be driven through this, the Piazza Navona, in an open carriage.
02:52Visitors from Britain were fascinated at the chance to see their exiled royal family.
02:58One account describes their child, the infant Charles, being carried aloft
03:03and shooting at onlookers with his toy crossbow.
03:09The fascination with weaponry, well, it wasn't hard to fathom.
03:15Stuart history had been bloody.
03:18The boy's grandfather, King James VII of Scotland and Second of England and Ireland,
03:23had been driven from power and into exile, seen as too aggressively Catholic and too close to the French.
03:31His son, also James, had attempted to reclaim his crowns in the failed Jacobite uprisings of 1708, 1715 and finally
03:41in 1719.
03:43That same year, James escaped to the continent and married Clementina.
03:50They settled here in Rome.
03:58The Pope, Clement XI, recognised the Catholic James as the rightful King of England, Scotland and Ireland.
04:05He gave the young couple two palaces, an allowance and a papal guard.
04:11Five years later, James and Clementina brought their four-year-old son, Charles, to the papal palace.
04:19As was the custom, both parents kissed the Pope's feet.
04:23Charles didn't fancy the idea and refused point blank.
04:28You can make too much of one childish moment, but this seems to have been a young boy confident in
04:33his own skin, no shrinking violet.
04:42The life of the exiled Stuarts is hidden deep within the workings of this city.
04:50These are the Rome headquarters of a multinational construction company.
04:55On the surface, there's absolutely nothing remarkable about these offices, nothing special.
05:02Until you look up, the ceilings are very special indeed.
05:12These interiors have never been filmed before.
05:17The oldest examples were commissioned by Pope Clement XI to decorate the home he had chosen for King James.
05:26Clement renamed the building the Palazzo del Rey, the King's Palace.
05:33The furnishings were extremely lavish and expensive.
05:36We have the accounts, an awful lot of money was spent producing a sequence of state apartments,
05:42building up to the King's apartments and then into this gallery which is just beyond the King's bedchamber.
05:49Do we have any sense of how these buildings and these new decorations were received at the time?
05:53Oh, they were well received.
05:56I mean, this became an important social centre in Rome.
05:59You have to remember that because the Pope did, Roman society recognised James as King.
06:06And therefore the princes, the cardinals of Rome, came always to this building to pay their court to James.
06:15Living amid such opulence didn't come cheap.
06:19The Stuart Palace employed upwards of a hundred servants, paid for from the pension James received annually from the Pope,
06:27today worth around three quarters of a million pounds.
06:32James's rooms were here on the first floor.
06:35His wife Clementina occupied the floor above.
06:39Her household took charge of baby Charles and four years later his younger brother Henry.
06:51And outside the palace would have been a very visible sign that this was an exiled court.
06:56Yes, indeed. Up there above the doorway there would have been the English royal coat of arms,
07:01placed there at the request of the Pope to recognise that this was the palace of the legitimate King of
07:08England.
07:10He's the only king in Rome and consequently his status is second only to that of the Pope.
07:16Queen Clementina is of course the first lady of Rome.
07:20And so this gives them immense social status among the cardinals and princes and people of Rome.
07:26This can be particularly interestingly seen when they go to the opera,
07:29because they have certain privileges when they go to the opera.
07:33And the most interesting of all is that James is given three boxes,
07:37because he is the king of three kingdoms.
07:41And you have one box for your kingdom.
07:44I mean, the Holy Roman Emperor had two because he claimed to be the king of Spain,
07:48but James had three.
07:54Directly across the square from the Palazzo del Rey
07:58is the magnificent church of Santi Apostoli.
08:02From their arrival in 1719, the Stuarts would come here to worship.
08:08The exiled king, James, commissioned the singing of a special mass for his son
08:15every year on the 31st of January.
08:24While most of his British subjects were Protestant, James was Catholic.
08:29But he didn't want his Catholicism to stand in the way of his restoration to the throne.
08:36James had said many times that he would respect the different religious beliefs of his people.
08:42James's vision was also a Britain of three kingdoms, England, Scotland and Ireland.
08:50That vision was seen as a grave threat to the new British state
08:55that was determined to exclude his family from power.
09:00James and his Jacobite supporters were continually monitored.
09:04My trick, I think?
09:06Yes, my son.
09:07No one is to approach with any earshot.
09:09Your Majesty, not a black beetle shall show its nose,
09:12though faith they might be English spies the way they encroach on us.
09:17Into the story comes a gentleman called Philip von Stosch,
09:23who arrived in Rome in January 1722.
09:29Outwardly, he was known as a dealer in antiques.
09:33But Stosch had another job.
09:37He was a spy operating under the pen name of Mr. Walton.
09:42And every week, he'd write back to England with intelligence,
09:46gleaned from a mole within the Stuart Court.
09:49Those letters, written in coded French,
09:52revealed that the exiled Stuart King and Queen were having major marital difficulties.
10:00Walton described how, in November 1725,
10:04James gave voice to what Walton described as
10:07very angry words against his wife.
10:11Controversially, James had decided to remove infant Charles from the Queen's household
10:16and place him in the hands of six male appointees.
10:23Walton described how Clementina wrote to the abbess of a Rome convent,
10:28asking for the main door to be left open at a predetermined time.
10:34And on the 15th of November 1725,
10:39Clementina slipped through the door and into sanctuary.
10:44Walton recorded her saying,
10:46I had rather suffer death than live in the King's palace
10:50with persons who have no religion, honour nor conscience.
11:00The separation of the Stuart King and Queen shocked Europe.
11:04What hope for their dynasty returning to Britain,
11:07if they genuinely despised each other?
11:10James and Clementina would remain separated for two years.
11:17It would take almost a decade for the Stuarts to get their reputation back on track.
11:24And it would not be James or Clementina who would achieve this.
11:28It would be their eldest son, Charles.
11:33What we now call Italy was, in the 18th century,
11:38a collection of independent kingdoms and city-states.
11:43In 1734, the 14-year-old Charles was given permission, by the Pope,
11:49to leave the city of Rome.
11:52To accompany his cousin, the Duke of Beric,
11:56serving with the Spanish army,
11:57then at war with the Austrian-occupied Kingdom of Naples.
12:02A hundred miles south of Rome,
12:05the Spanish army began to lay siege here,
12:08in the fortified harbour town of Gaeta.
12:13Close to the city walls, the fighting was ferocious.
12:17The Spanish were anxious to keep the young prince
12:21at a safe distance from the front line.
12:24But Charles wanted to witness the battle firsthand.
12:28He impressed his older soldier cousin,
12:31who reported neither the noise of cannon nor the hiss of bullet
12:35could produce any sign of fear in him.
12:38Despite his years, Charles was every inch the noble warrior prince.
12:46After a four-month siege, the town of Gaeta surrendered,
12:50and the young prince basked in reflected glory.
12:56Charles departed Gaeta, bedecked in jewellery,
12:59with two fine horses, all gifts from the Spanish.
13:03Back in Rome, the Pope himself provided Charles
13:06with an honour guard of 50 men.
13:11The physical actions of the young prince
13:14eclipsed the domestic melodramas of his parents.
13:18The Stuarts were back,
13:20in the handsome, glamorous form
13:22of this most plausible young prince.
13:25The spy Walton warned that the Stuarts
13:29had re-emerged as a dangerous enemy.
13:31But dangerous to whom?
13:44Standing in the way of a Stuart restoration to the British throne
13:48was a family with its roots here,
13:52in the tiny German state of Hanover.
13:56The dynasty that would become known as the Hanoverians
14:00came to prominence in 1714.
14:04Back then, the Elector, or Prince of Hanover,
14:08was 52nd in line to the British throne.
14:11His name was George,
14:13and he was the king at the very bottom of the pack.
14:17But there was a problem with the 51 above him.
14:20They were Catholic,
14:21and the English Act of Settlement
14:23had ruled against a Catholic monarch.
14:28So, aged 54 and unable to speak a word of English,
14:33the Protestant George came up trumps
14:35and became King George I of Great Britain.
14:42George took the crown the Stuarts claimed as their own.
14:47But just a year after his coronation,
14:49he faced a 10,000-strong Jacobite rising.
14:55George needed to advertise the power and potential
14:59of his new dynasty.
15:01And with the help of two English engineers,
15:04he shaped the Royal Gardens here at Herrenhausen
15:07into a potent symbol of Hanoverian ambitions.
15:11I want to show the world what we can do,
15:15and so he started to lay out the waterworks.
15:17And it took another six years until the great fountain started
15:21at up to 35 meters, and it was in those days
15:23the highest fountain in Europe.
15:26And there were some British-English engineers,
15:30Benson and Holland, and they got a very complicated technique,
15:33but it works with five water wheels and 40 pumps,
15:37and they just managed to do it up to 35 meters.
15:45And this was amazing.
15:47He could show his power.
15:59And what do you think that was aiming to say?
16:03What do you think George's vision was?
16:05I think it would say, we don't have the biggest garden,
16:08we don't have the biggest country or the biggest state,
16:10but we can do the biggest, have the highest fountain,
16:14and so I'm worth the big king of England.
16:18Yet behind the hydraulic wizardry,
16:21behind the horticultural splendour,
16:23the Hanoverians, like the Stuarts,
16:26were not a happy family.
16:27In London, King George faced sexual and financial scandals,
16:33and was frequently accused of diverting money and armies
16:37from Britain to Hanover.
16:43George died in 1727,
16:46and his son, also called George, took the British throne.
16:51He and his supporters would portray their Stuart rivals
16:55as dangerous Catholics and backward-looking relics,
16:59the very opposite of his progressive Protestant monarchy.
17:06The Hanoverians were a dynasty on the make.
17:09They were now major players on the European stage,
17:13ambitious, keen to make their mark.
17:2518th century politics were bitterly partisan.
17:29On the one hand, there were the Tories.
17:32They had opposed the Hanoverians.
17:35They were said to be riddled with covert Jacobites.
17:39So, unsurprisingly, King George banished them from government,
17:44leaving power in the hands of the Whig Party,
17:47who had secured the Hanoverian succession.
17:52In charge of the Whigs, and Britain's first Prime Minister,
17:56was Robert Walpole.
18:00Walpole had spent much time and effort cultivating the Hanoverians,
18:04so he protected them, sometimes from themselves,
18:07but mostly from the Jacobites.
18:10And Walpole saw Jacobites everywhere.
18:17To counter that threat,
18:19Walpole established Britain's first state-sponsored intelligence agency.
18:25He saw the Jacobites as the Reds under the bed.
18:30The 18th century equivalent of Philby, Burgess and Maclean,
18:35the notorious Cambridge spy ring.
18:39I think it's very accurate to think of the whole situation
18:42between the Jacobites and the British government
18:44as a kind of long-running Cold War.
18:47It involved agents and a vast amount of interception of communications,
18:53which the British government did shamelessly on a vast scale,
18:59regularly opening the correspondence, not just of suspected Jacobites,
19:04but of everyone who was sending mail overseas.
19:08They would stop the mails in London or at the channel ports
19:12and then send hastily made copies of letters
19:17to deciphering teams back in London or nearby.
19:21How worthwhile was this huge investment in surveillance,
19:26code-breaking, reporting, vigilance?
19:29I mean, it's rather like the CIA operation to spy on the Soviet Union
19:34during the Cold War.
19:38They invested billions in it over decades,
19:42and yet at the end of it,
19:44despite having acquired a huge amount of information,
19:49a huge amount of data,
19:50they couldn't predict the fall of the Soviet Union.
19:55It's a huge amount of data.
19:56Walpole spent fortunes hunting Jacobites all across Europe.
20:01But there was a very real threat much closer to home,
20:06the Tories.
20:08Exclusion from power had fuelled their resentment
20:11and their hatred of George and his devoted servant Robert Walpole.
20:17Often, when we think of Jacobites,
20:20the word itself conjures up Hollywood images
20:23of swashbuckling, fearless Scottish Highlanders.
20:28But the man who lived on this fine country estate,
20:32just west of Cambridge,
20:34was a Jacobite of a very different stamp.
20:38A man called Sir John Hind Cotton,
20:42an old-school English Tory
20:45who'd lost his lucrative government job.
20:47By the early 1740s, he was broke,
20:51and his estate here at Maddingley was heavily mortgaged.
20:55And the flamboyant Hind Cotton
20:58was no great friend of the Hanoverians.
21:02He's an extremely charismatic, even rather bombastic figure.
21:06He's a famously brilliant parliamentary speaker,
21:10patron of poets and playwrights.
21:12He's extremely proud of his boasted ability to get through six bottles of claret in an evening,
21:19while remaining, as he claimed, perfectly sober.
21:22He makes an unsuccessful attempt to introduce the kilt as an English fashion accessory.
21:29So, though colourful figure.
21:30And what makes English Jacobitism different from Scottish Jacobitism or Irish Jacobitism?
21:36They want to bring back the glory of England under Queen Elizabeth I, under Charles II.
21:43And so it's partly about recovering in England that's been lost,
21:46but it's partly also about making England a great power in the world.
21:50So how did someone like John Hein Cotton set about making his support for the exiled Stuarts known?
21:56A lot of that is really centred here at Maddingley Hall.
22:00He brings paid agents of the exiled Jacobite court into his residence.
22:07He wines and dines them.
22:09He promises his support.
22:10He sends messages via these agents back to the exiled court in Rome.
22:16For much of the 1720s and 30s, the English Jacobites had posed little real threat.
22:23But that all changed in 1740, when Britain went to war with France,
22:29in the War of the Austrian Succession.
22:32And from his rooms here in Maddingley,
22:35Hind Cotton passed British state secrets to the French government,
22:39offering support for a French invasion scheduled for 1744.
22:46An invasion that was intended to lead not only to a Stuart restoration,
22:52but to a Tory one as well.
23:03On the 8th of February 1744, a young man on horseback arrived on this Paris street.
23:11He was beyond exhaustion.
23:13Travelling in disguise, his journey from Rome had taken an entire month.
23:19That man was Charles Stuart.
23:22Now 23, he had grown into a true warrior prince.
23:27He was handsome, strong and a brilliant marksman.
23:33News that the French were secretly planning to invade southern England had brought him here.
23:39A force of 15,000 was to capture London to reinstall the Stuarts on the throne.
23:45But all had not gone according to plan.
23:48From England, Hind Cotton had written to the French king, Louis XV, demanding a delay to the invasion.
23:56His letter had been intercepted and Cotton was placed under surveillance.
24:01And worse followed.
24:04A month after Charles arrived in Paris, the French invasion fleet was blown apart by a channel storm.
24:16Charles crossly dammed the storm as a Protestant wind, but he wasn't about to give up.
24:23Charles remained in Paris and appealed to the French king to put together plans for a new invasion.
24:30But the notoriously indecisive King Louis made no promises and fell short of backing the Stuart cause.
24:4255 years before, Louis' great-grandfather had given the exiled Stuart sanctuary in the magnificent palace of Saint-Germain-les.
24:54Now, in the summer of 1744, Charles found more humble Parisian lodgings here in what's now the artist's quarter of
25:04Montmartre.
25:06Charles had been ordered by Louis to remain incognito, to keep his head down and stay out of the public
25:12eye.
25:13But he refused point blank.
25:16In fact, the glamorous young prince traded on his celebrity, seeking popular support for a French-backed Stuart restoration.
25:27And portraits of James and Charles were widely circulated as part of a propaganda campaign to remind the French public
25:35that the Stuarts were the legitimate kings of England, Scotland and Ireland.
25:39And that they would be a staunch ally to the French.
25:43Do you think he is good?
25:47Yes.
25:47He is great.
25:48The nobility, the expression and everything.
25:52Here.
25:52Bravo.
25:55Here.
25:57Thank you very much.
25:59And good day.
25:59Thank you very much.
26:00Good luck.
26:01Good luck.
26:01Good luck.
26:04By the spring of 1745, and still in Paris, Charles offered King Louis a new plan.
26:12Instead of invading England, Charles proposed that the French give military support to a rising of the Scottish clans.
26:22Scottish clans that had supported his father in the 1715 rebellion.
26:26The Scottish chiefs had a high reputation in Europe, and they are considered as remarkable warriors.
26:37Such an enterprise did not need much money, did not need much soldiers.
26:46Such an enterprise needed a charismatic man.
26:50And Charles was the right man in such a struggle, in fact.
26:55For he was a young man, he was an impulsive man, he had great courage, and he had already the
27:07behaviour of an hero.
27:11But in the end, King Louis wasn't persuaded.
27:14He refused Charles' request for a 3,000-strong French army.
27:21And Charles left Paris.
27:26In late June 1745, he headed south-west, towards the city of Nantes, and then on to the mouth of
27:35the river Loire.
27:36He'd assembled a secret arsenal of 20 cannons, 11,000 guns, and 2,000 broadswords.
27:45He'd also put together a war chest of 4,000 gold coins.
27:52Charles was heavily in debt.
27:54He needed funds, not just to finance his invasion, but also to pay off his loans.
28:02Back in Rome, his father pawned the family silver, a security on a loan of 120,000 crowns.
28:12With no foreign power offering support, the Stuarts were acting alone and at great speed, but with very good reason.
28:22The English Jacobites had advised Charles that this was a good time to invade.
28:27King George II was out of the country.
28:31So, too, was the Duke of Cumberland's army.
28:34The door to London wasn't exactly wide open, but it had been left a little ajar.
28:42Charles assembled a tiny invasion force of 700 Irish mercenaries here on Belle Isle,
28:49a small island 15 miles off the Brittany coast.
28:54He chartered two ships, both privateers, operated by French-backed pirates.
29:02They set sail on the 16th of July, 1745, bound for Scotland.
29:11Things did not begin well.
29:15Four days out, his larger ship, the Elizabeth, was gravely damaged by a British warship and limped back to port.
29:24Charles lost his small mercenary army.
29:27He lost his cannons.
29:30He and his seven officers pressed on in the smaller ship, the Dutelle.
29:42Two weeks after leaving Belle Isle, on the 3rd of August, 1745, she anchored off the Hebridean island of Eriski.
29:50Look! Look over there! Scotland!
29:55His great Scottish adventure had begun.
30:02The reaction of the clan chiefs was mixed.
30:05What have you brought us here for if you cannot be honouring your promises?
30:09Where is your 10,000 French troops?
30:10But on the afternoon of Monday 19th of August, the 24-year-old Charles raised the Stuart colours at Glenfinnan.
30:21A thousand clansmen, McDonalds and Camerons, looked on.
30:26And two days later, the Jacobite rebels set out for Edinburgh.
30:34They avoided General Cope's government army and attracted hundreds of new recruits.
30:43Six weeks after landing on Eriski, Charles arrived, unchallenged, in Scotland's capital.
30:53His appearance divided opinion.
30:56The city's political leaders hedged their bets, but Edinburgh's women were said to be captivated by the young prince.
31:05But Charles's focus was unwavering.
31:09And 400 miles to the south, the Hanoverian government was becoming increasingly anxious.
31:16The army, commanded by George II's youngest son, the Duke of Cumberland, was recalled from Flanders.
31:24General Wade's army was ordered to Newcastle.
31:29And finally, General Cope's 2,500-man army sailed from Aberdeen to the east of Edinburgh and camped at Preston
31:38Pans.
31:39And early on the morning of the 21st of September, Cope's men were surprised by an almost equal number of
31:46Jacobite soldiers.
31:50300 government troops were killed in less than 10 minutes of ferocious fighting.
31:57Here was proof that Charles Stewart and his Jacobite followers were a serious and deadly threat to the British government.
32:15Six weeks after their victory at Preston Pans, the Jacobite troops headed south, into England.
32:23They arrived on the outskirts of Derby on the 4th of December, 1745.
32:30They had made spectacular progress.
32:33They'd left Edinburgh just over a month before.
32:37They'd captured Carlisle, which Charles had entered, on a white horse flanked by bagpipers.
32:45Next, they travelled on to Preston and Manchester.
32:49A government spy, a man named Eliza Birch, was waiting for them as they approached Derby.
32:59Birch had the rather clever idea of using peas to count the size of the Jacobite force.
33:05For every hundred men, he placed a single pea in his pouch.
33:10He watched as the Jacobite cavalry approached first.
33:13Then the foot soldiers, six or eight abreast, with bagpipes and men carrying the Cross of St George to attract
33:21English followers.
33:25Birch would have needed 55 peas to count a force of 500 cavalry and 5,000 infantry.
33:33An army almost entirely composed of well-drilled and ferocious Highlanders.
33:41Charles' men had encountered little resistance, but had attracted almost no English recruits.
33:48And as they arrived in Derby on the evening of the 4th of December, they were closing in on England's
33:55capital.
33:58This was their southern outpost, Swarkston Bridge on the River Trent.
34:04Just four or five days' march from Westminster.
34:08Distance to London, 110 miles.
34:13In Cambridge, Hind Cotton buried three portraits of the Stuarts in case they fell into the wrong hands.
34:20In London, there was rioting, a run on the Bank of England.
34:24The Hanoverian regime was in genuine danger.
34:31The next morning, Charles attended church at what's now Derby Cathedral.
34:37Immediately after, he and his generals held a council of war.
34:43Time and again, Charles was asked for evidence that English or French armies were on their way.
34:49There was none.
34:51Charles' military commander, Lord George Murray, was pessimistic.
34:57Protecting the capital, a force of 4,000 men, including the Grenadier Guards, was stationed at Finchley.
35:0580 miles north of Charles' army, General Wade had 6,000 men in Weatherby.
35:14Closer still, the Duke of Cumberland had 9,000 men in Litchfield, just 25 miles to the southwest.
35:22In total, Charles' army was outnumbered by almost four to one.
35:34That afternoon, Charles rode out of Derby.
35:38His aim was to persuade local landowners to pledge support, soldiers or weapons.
35:46The man, who wanted to be Britain's king, was reduced to cold calling the local nobility.
35:55He visited the Burdettes of Fourmark Hall.
35:59Nothing.
36:01Next, the Poles of Radbourne Hall.
36:05Again, nothing.
36:09And finally, the Harpers of Cork Abbey.
36:13Nothing.
36:15Everywhere, Charles was treated politely, but nowhere did he attract any sign of support.
36:23And it begs the question, what help could the landowners have given?
36:28A hundred years before, the families might have dispatched the local yeomanry.
36:33But now, what use gardeners, footmen, stable boys, against a standing professional army?
36:43That night, Charles returned to Derby.
36:46He met again with his military advisers.
36:49And Lord George Murray spoke plainly.
36:53Sir, it is your council's recommendation, endorsed by me, that the army should retreat.
37:01Retreat?
37:03Clanchine Rannog?
37:08Clanchine Rannog?
37:10Not one of you marched with me on London.
37:15Things could have been very different.
37:18Charles and the clan chiefs didn't know that the French King Louis was planning his own 15,000-strong invasion
37:26of England in support of the Jacobites.
37:31But when Charles and his army turned back to the north, Louis abandoned his plans.
37:39The Jacobites returned the way they had come, through Manchester and Preston and back into
37:45Scotland, pursued all the way by the Duke of Cumberland's army.
37:51With Edinburgh now in government hands, Charles made for Glasgow.
37:58His army arrived on Boxing Day 1745.
38:04The city gates were left open and he reviewed his troops here on Glasgow Green.
38:12When we tell the story of the Jacobites, there are certain places that seem woven into the
38:16fabric of that narrative.
38:19There's Glenfinnan where Charles raised his standard, marching into Edinburgh, capturing
38:24Carlisle.
38:25Glasgow doesn't normally get much of a look-in, but it's important because Glasgow frankly
38:31didn't care much for the Jacobites.
38:36The Presbyterians of 18th century Glasgow had no religious affinity with the largely Episcopalian
38:43or Catholic Scottish Jacobites.
38:46And Glasgow wasn't looking back to a Stuart past when the city's tobacco lords and shipowners
38:53were busy making their fortunes in the Hanoverian present.
38:57One of the biggest misconceptions about the Jacobites in 1745 is the extreme popularity with which
39:04they were met.
39:05They were not.
39:05In fact, there was great resistance throughout all towns and especially those with something
39:14to lose.
39:15Economy was booming in Glasgow and the Jacobite threat was something that would unseat everything
39:23that they had built.
39:25Most people didn't want to be bothered.
39:27They were settling into the Union.
39:29They were happier than they had been in many, many years.
39:34Charles left Glasgow on the 3rd of January 1746.
39:39Two weeks later his troops defeated a Hanoverian army at Falkirk and then withdrew further north.
39:47The Duke of Cumberland continued the pursuit.
39:51His British government army contained three Scottish infantry regiments.
39:56And on the 16th of April, at Culloden, Cumberland's troops put the exhausted Jacobite army to the
40:05sword.
40:061,500 of Charles's 5,000 men were killed or wounded.
40:13The bells of Glasgow Cathedral rang out in celebration.
40:18The Jacobites had been defeated.
40:20Contemporary accounts talked of the general drinking of healths and bonfires in every street.
40:30Reaction to the battle divided Scotland.
40:33The Highlanders paid a heavy price for Charles's rebellion.
40:38Their language, their culture, even their kilts were outlawed.
40:43As for Charles, he disappeared into the heather.
40:47He spent five months in the wilds of north-west Scotland, hunted by government forces, then
40:54rescued by a French warship.
41:00Charles arrived back in France as quite possibly the most famous man in Europe.
41:05He'd tried to regain the Stuart's crown, and he'd failed.
41:09But he was only 25.
41:11He could always try again.
41:15In Paris, Charles was reunited with his younger, deeply religious brother, Henry.
41:25The pair were lavishly entertained by King Louis, who proposed that they should live here,
41:31at the Chateau de Vincennes.
41:34And straight away, Charles wrote to Louis, asking for military support.
41:3918,000 to 20,000 men.
41:42Charles described his recent Scottish adventures as a setback.
41:47It couldn't be clearer.
41:48He wanted to try again.
41:54And to succeed, he needed French popular support.
41:59On 28 October 1746, he came to the Paris Opera.
42:09The audience expected arias and sopranos.
42:14Instead, they got the young pretender.
42:22The audience erupted into rapturous wild cheering.
42:27Charles found himself making more bows than any of the performers.
42:31For the young prince, this was a magical moment of appreciation.
42:38He distributed medals and maps of his British exploits.
42:43Again, he won over the French public.
42:46But his relationship with the French king steadily withered.
42:52Louis reneged on his offer of a palace.
42:56And when the French king offered Charles a royal pension, he refused it.
43:02Charles was losing the favour of his most important ally.
43:07And he was about to lose someone closer still.
43:12In April 1747, Charles was invited to dinner by his brother.
43:17He arrived to find Henry's servants ready to serve the meal.
43:20But of Henry, there was no sign.
43:24Charles waited and waited.
43:30For three whole days, he heard nothing.
43:35Until a letter from Henry arrived.
43:39The dinner invitation had been a ruse.
43:43His younger brother had secretly departed from Paris.
43:47He was travelling back to Rome.
43:51Henry Stuart, supported by his father James,
43:55was giving up the Stuart cause to become a cardinal.
44:00Charles's brother had never seemed likely to have children to preserve the Stuart line.
44:06But here was the final word.
44:09Charles was furious and severed all contact with his father and brother.
44:14The future of the Stuart dynasty now rested entirely on him.
44:19A single assassin's bullet could end everything.
44:26Worse was to follow.
44:28The war of the Austrian succession ended in 1748
44:32with the peace treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle.
44:36The terms of that treaty obliged the French state
44:39to evict Charles Stuart from their territory.
44:43Increasingly drunken, promiscuous,
44:46Charles ignored King Louis' repeated demands to leave France.
44:53He knew he was in genuine danger.
44:58On the 10th of December, he headed once again to the Opera,
45:02the scene of his great popular acclaim just over a year earlier.
45:09His carriage approached the gates of the Opera House
45:13as an army of 1,200 men prepared to receive him.
45:18A sergeant came up to Charles and kneed him in the back.
45:24He was disarmed, he was arrested, his hands and feet were bound,
45:30just like a common criminal.
45:32He was transported back to familiar ground, the Chateau de Vincennes.
45:39This was part of the palace that Louis had offered him as a residence
45:43just two years earlier.
45:45Then Charles had been the darling of France and fated across Europe.
45:49Now he was heading for the palace dungeon as a prisoner of the French state.
46:00So this is the cell to which Charles was brought.
46:03Just a simple bed and chair and very small.
46:07Ce n'est pas magnifique, he said.
46:10It was far from magnificent.
46:13He wasn't the first occupant.
46:16He'd clearly been a priest incarcerated here before.
46:25It was all a far cry from what he was used to.
46:31Brought up in the gracious splendour of Roman Palazzi,
46:35this small cell was the nadir of his fortunes.
46:42The next morning, Charles agreed to leave France.
46:48What followed was the start of Charles' slow descent
46:52into drink, debauchery and political obscurity.
46:57He flitted around different European cities, but no-one wanted him.
47:02Then in the summer of 1750, he showed once again
47:06that he had not lost the power to surprise.
47:09He travelled, in disguise, to London.
47:23The 29-year-old Charles paid his first visit
47:26to England's capital in September 1750.
47:31The trip was shrouded in secrecy,
47:33but included a spying mission to the Tower of London.
47:40Five years after his march on London,
47:43Charles was now clutching at straws.
47:46He became central to a series of plots involving,
47:49as each unfolded, French, Swedish, Prussian
47:53and Scottish Highland troops.
47:55It was all rather far-flung, desperate, sad even.
48:03Charles met a group of English Jacobites.
48:07Hind Cotton had died the year before.
48:10Charles attempted to win the support of those who remained.
48:15But he didn't.
48:16The English Jacobites said that they had no money,
48:19that they were spied upon, that they couldn't raise men.
48:22Just what they'd told him five years before.
48:26Nothing had changed.
48:28But Charles himself was about to make a seismic change.
48:33The man who'd been brought up in the heart of Catholic Rome,
48:37who'd been given an honour guard by the Pope,
48:40had decided to become a Protestant.
48:45Can we tell anything about Charles's religiosity, or Charles the man,
48:51in connection with this decision to convert?
48:54I think not very much.
48:57All the evidence suggests that Charles was essentially a freethinker,
49:01someone who had very little in the way of religious belief.
49:03His debauchery was the topic of a lot of conversation in Catholic circles.
49:10It was concern in Catholic circles.
49:13The general view is that Charles was engaged in a very cynical publicity exercise
49:18that therefore actually brought him no benefit at all.
49:23Charles left London after just one week.
49:26Any lingering hopes of a Stuart restoration faded as the months and years went by.
49:32But he and his family would have won last chance.
49:37In 1756, Britain declared war on France.
49:50Three years in, to what would come to be called the Seven Years' War,
49:54the French were losing.
49:57They needed a new plan.
49:59The French Foreign Minister, Etienne de Choiseul, proposed an invasion of England.
50:08A hundred thousand French troops would be carried across the Channel
50:12in a fleet of flat-bottomed boats.
50:16De Choiseul invited Charles Stuart to talk about this project here at his home in central Paris.
50:23This meeting gave Charles and the Jacobite cause a chance to piggyback the French invasion.
50:29Charles was broke, an alcoholic, flitting between cheap houses with his mistress Clementina.
50:38They had one child, Charlotte.
50:44But now, here was the prospect of the French army he had longed for in the winter of 1745.
50:52Charles arrived for the meeting on the 5th of February 1759.
50:56He was late, he was drunk.
51:00He was asked to lead the supporting invasion of Scotland, or Ireland if he preferred.
51:06Charles refused.
51:07It was England or nothing.
51:20The French fleet of flat-bottomed boats intended to carry the invasion force was brought together here at Quiberon Bay.
51:30Charles had no guarantees.
51:33He had a profound, and not unreasonable, distrust of the French.
51:38Yet it was a great chance.
51:40Probably his best ever chance.
51:42And probably also his last chance.
51:45Yet he didn't show up.
51:49In the end, it hardly mattered.
51:52The French warships that were to escort the invasion fleet set sail from Brest on the 14th of November, bound
52:01for Quiberon Bay.
52:02Six days later, they were attacked and defeated by a Royal Navy fleet under the command of Admiral Edward Hawke.
52:12The Jacobite cause hadn't died at Culloden in 1746.
52:17It died 13 years later, somewhere over there, at the Battle of Quiberon Bay in 1759.
52:27Charles' life continued along the same sad trajectory.
52:34His mistress, Clementina, sought sanctuary in a Paris convent, just as his mother had done.
52:41And in December 1765, news arrived from Rome that his father, James, was gravely ill.
52:58James Stuart, the old pretender, died on the 1st of January 1766.
53:05Charles arrived in Rome three weeks later, after a 22-year absence.
53:13When he reached the Piazza di Santi Apostoli, his brother had choreographed a crowd to chant,
53:20Viva il re! Long live the king!
53:23But he wasn't the king.
53:25After long consideration, Pope Clement XIII had refused to recognise Charles as his father's successor.
53:34Across the square, the Stuart family home had once been bedecked with the English royal coat of arms.
53:41It was gone.
53:45Charles was not a king. This was no longer a king's palace.
53:53Charles sought consolation with a daily diet of six bottles of Cyprus wine.
54:00He married the young Princess Louise, who, like his mother and mistress before, would escape to a convent.
54:14The final years were truly dreadful.
54:17The man who had once been Bonnie Prince Charlie now had elephantitis in his leg,
54:22which was hideously swollen, with sores and open wounds.
54:26He also had terrible piles, an ulcer, and was in permanent pain.
54:36He died on the 31st of January 1788, in the very palace where he'd been born 67 years before.
54:52Charles had no legitimate children.
54:55His one illegitimate daughter, Charlotte, outlived her father by only a year.
55:02The direct Stuart line continued on to 1807, in the form of Cardinal Henry Stuart.
55:08But this was his church.
55:14Like his elder brother, Henry's life ended in turmoil.
55:19At the age of 72, he lost his fortune and income when Napoleon's French army sacked Rome.
55:28In his final years, he was awarded a pension by the Hanoverian king, George III.
55:39Of the many memorials to the Stuarts, the most important is here,
55:44in the very heart of the Catholic world, St. Peter's Basilica in the Vatican.
56:02In death and in exile, James, Charles and Henry were granted the regal status they were denied in life.
56:12Their fate had always been in the hands of Europe's great powers.
56:17But their legacy would be strongest in the country they had fought for, but hardly knew.
56:34Lot number three.
56:36A finely presented lock of Bonnie Prince Charlie's hair.
56:40£4,200.
56:43Relics of the young pretender, up for sale to the highest bidder.
56:4831, 32 is back in, next bid is 34,000.
56:53And 32,000.
56:57For two and a half centuries, Scotland has been fascinated by the rise and fall of the Stuarts,
57:04and their dashing and much-lamented Prince.
57:20From Walter Scott to Kenneth McKellar, and on to the present day,
57:25the powerful and romantic image of the Stuarts presents a Scotland that never quite happened.
57:33Charles didn't come back again, and there's little doubt about who actually won the great dynastic battle of the 18th
57:42century.
57:44The success of the Hanoverian dynasty is written large in Edinburgh's new town.
57:51In the end, the Hanoverians gave Scotland and Britain what most people wanted.
57:57Industry, empire, stability and money.
58:02But a lot of what-ifs remain.
58:05Not just what if the Jacobite army had marched south from Derby.
58:10Exactly how different would a Jacobite Britain have been?
58:16What of Britain's empire?
58:19Of its religion?
58:21Of its government?
58:23Three centuries later, these questions of how we are ruled, and from where, still haven't quite gone away.
58:37A view through the world's largest solar telescope to pick out the colours in the sun here on BBC4 tomorrow.
58:43Don't miss the first part of Helen Chersky's brand new series, The Spectrum of Science at Nine.
58:49But first, unravelling the history of the world, one incredible map at a time.
58:53Power, plunder and possession, next.
58:56The Spectrum of Science at Nine