• 1 week ago

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:21Today, there are over 50 countries around the world
00:24which continue to use the death penalty.
00:28Individuals who break the law can face a firing squad in China,
00:34lethal injection in the USA,
00:37and the hangman's noose in Singapore.
00:45It is only a decade since capital punishment was finally removed from British law.
00:52For centuries, Britain carried out state executions,
00:55and capital punishment was defended as a deterrent against crime,
01:01retribution against those who broke society's rules.
01:06The noose would be put over their neck, a hood put over their head,
01:12and the cart would drive away, leaving them to dangle,
01:15and to gradually, slowly, up to 30 minutes, to strangle to death.
01:22For over 200 years, a moral battle raged about whether the state has the right to execute.
01:30A powerful liberal elite emerged, determined to abolish the death penalty.
01:37The death penalty is inhuman and degrading when you see how it is carried out and the procedures that are
01:45necessary.
01:49But the vast majority of public opinion has continued to demand the ultimate punishment.
01:57There are certain sorts of murder that are so premeditated, so violent, and so shocking,
02:06that in the interest of maintaining confidence in the rule of law, the only appropriate punishment is the death penalty.
02:16This debate has shaped our ideas about how a civilized society should punish its citizens in the 21st century.
02:25The word punishment comes from the same root as pain.
02:31It is, in its essential conception, painful.
02:35If it is not painful, it is not punishment.
02:47The history of capital punishment in Britain is a long and bloody one.
02:52Since the Middle Ages, those condemned to death have variously faced being boiled alive, burnt at the stake, or hung,
03:01drawn and quartered.
03:04But it was in the late 18th century that the death penalty was applied most widely.
03:12London, 1783.
03:14Thousands crammed the streets of the capital to watch a public execution carried out in the king's name.
03:24This is the height of the bloody code.
03:28A system of justice and punishment that listed over 200 offences for which a man or woman could be sent
03:34to the gallows.
03:37In a society in which, as they would have expressed it in those days, they were lovers of liberty and
03:44very keen on property,
03:47they had to have a means of protecting both their liberty and property.
03:51So you don't want a standing police force, and you don't want a standing army, and therefore, there was a
03:56very successful argument in Parliament that you had capital punishment for just about everything.
04:04Under the bloody code, even petty theft, like pickpocketing or stealing a sheep, could result in the death penalty.
04:13And it also threatened to execute anyone who kept the company of gypsies for more than a month.
04:20Or who blackened their face with the intention of stealing.
04:25Because we've lost sight of its meaning to contemporaries, and we can reach only for one explanation, that those people,
04:34two, three hundred years ago, were barbarians compared to us.
04:39But go back to the 18th century, and you have very few prisons, very inefficient policing, but you do have
04:47the noose.
04:48And the noose is understood, not as a cruel device, but as a way of testifying to the anger of
04:57the king.
05:03The execution day started at Newgate Prison, just to the west of St Paul's, in the centre of town.
05:09And the procession went from the gates of Newgate, through High Holborn, what is now modern Oxford Street, on to
05:17the site of Tyburn.
05:21From the Middle Ages, Tyburn had been the traditional site of the majority of public executions in Britain.
05:29The condemned would probably try and wear their best clothes, some would put up a big, brave show, and they
05:37would be taken along this route,
05:40where people would either stand on the street, or the better off, would actually hire out rooms on either side
05:47of the streets.
05:50With no police force or prison system, capital punishment served as a deterrent against crime.
05:59It was therefore important that everyone in society should attend, to witness justice being carried out.
06:08There was one occasion where a school teacher was reprimanded by the moral authorities, probably by the local newspapers,
06:15because he decided to take his children on a picnic, so they wouldn't see the execution.
06:19If this was considered a very bad thing to do.
06:24The trouble was, learning a moral lesson from the death of somebody else, was what the moralists wanted.
06:32It wasn't often what they got, because people would frequently go along there in more of a party atmosphere.
06:41The execution day had its own ritual involving the participation of the crowd itself,
06:48which appeared to revel in a macabre party atmosphere.
06:54But some historians have interpreted this scene very differently.
07:00It misses the silence that descends when the executioner comes onto the platform.
07:08When Top Hats came into fashion, it misses the point of the big cry,
07:14Hats off!
07:16It misses the kinds of communication that were possible between members of the crowd
07:22and the felons about to die.
07:28The jokes, the teasings, the cries from the crowd.
07:32Hello Curly, keep up your spirits.
07:36Of course, a poor sod was actually shitting and pissing himself in sheer bloody terror.
07:47Capital punishment as a deterrent was believed to work due to the painful nature of the executions.
07:54Hangings often ended in a slow strangulation.
07:58If they were lucky, their friends would pull on their legs to help end their misery.
08:06This is the origin of the phrase, pulling your leg.
08:13The watching crowd knew that a person's social class would have determined whether they were executed.
08:21One of the great defences of the death penalty was the idea that somehow every aristocrat
08:27and every member of the gentry was subject to the same laws.
08:31In fact, it's not true. It's self-evidently not true.
08:3499.9% of everybody who was executed by the state was dirt poor
08:40and from the lowest class of Britain.
08:44The vanishingly small number of aristocrats and members of the gentry
08:48who ended their lives in execution did so by dint of being psychopaths and lunatics.
08:58The accused faced trial by a jury drawn from the local community, many of whom were sympathetic to the defendant's
09:05case.
09:08Frequently, these juries sought to commute the punishment to avoid the death penalty.
09:15Many juries, for example, refused to value property at their full value,
09:21precisely in order to prevent a capital charge being applied in that particular case.
09:26Juries also regularly pleaded for mercy, even after they found somebody guilty and seen them sentenced to be hanged.
09:39Between 1770 and 1830, over 35,000 people were sentenced to death.
09:47But only one in ten were actually executed.
09:53But the elite in society were indifferent to any notions of unequal justice.
09:59They believed capital punishment worked as a deterrent.
10:05And even enlightened thinkers of the time, such as the churchman and philosopher William Paley,
10:10were able to justify this even if innocent people were executed.
10:15When he was told that many people were hanged who didn't deserve it or who might even be innocent,
10:23oh, he said, in a very fine language of course,
10:28so what?
10:30These people may be deemed to have hanged for England.
10:33In other words, their deaths were part of the price we had to pay for social order and deference to
10:42the established hierarchy.
10:47This view was supported by the work of German philosopher Immanuel Kant,
10:53who argued that even in a civilized society, the state had the right to punish the individual.
11:01For Kant, the only purely evil thing is an evil will.
11:04So you measure the seriousness of the crime by the attitude of the criminal.
11:10For Kant, the death penalty was a moral imperative.
11:14It was a duty.
11:16But it was to be done without any emotion.
11:18We did it as a matter of duty.
11:22And in fact, we celebrate human dignity by executing them,
11:26by saying, you are a responsible agent.
11:28You chose to do what you do, what you did, and you deserve to die for it.
11:32We will not look at you as a means to deter others from committing crimes.
11:38He firmly believed that you never use a person as a means to your ends.
11:43Human beings are ends in themselves.
11:50Kant's ideas continued to influence the debate about punishment into the 19th century and a new Victorian era.
12:01But by the 1830s, the election of the Whigs into government brought a new reforming agenda.
12:11The reform act, famously, gives the vote to the middle classes, but also a lot of the statutes on the
12:18bloody code are repealed.
12:21So that by the end of the 1830s, you can hang really only for murder.
12:30Despite this new age of reform, the Victorians were still committed to retaining the death penalty for those convicted of
12:37murder.
12:40But for other lesser crimes, they wanted a more proportional punishment that fitted the crime.
12:46So a sheep stealer would no longer be treated the same as a murderer.
12:52Punishment ought to be not only proportional, but by being proportional to the offence rational.
13:02Measurement proportionality is one big idea that begins to unseat the old system that had, of course, gone back for
13:10centuries.
13:13Dismantling the bloody code had an immediate effect on the Victorian justice system.
13:18Now, juries were more likely to convict, in the knowledge that the death penalty no longer applied.
13:27They eliminated capital punishment from rape in 1842.
13:32And what happened afterwards is that the conviction rate went straight through the roof.
13:37It went from a modern equivalent of about 5% convictions to between 13 and 18% conviction rates,
13:45simply because they changed the nature of the punishment associated with that particular crime.
13:52But as conviction rates soared, so too did the Victorians' fear of crime.
13:58This fear came from the presence of a new mass urban population,
14:03which during the Industrial Revolution had migrated to Britain's cities in their thousands.
14:11As you start to have very large numbers of fairly poor people crowded into districts together,
14:16society is becoming much more concerned about criminality, about the possibility of a criminal underclass,
14:22about the consequences of having so many poor people congregated in very small areas.
14:29One of the other things that's happening in the early 19th century is for the first time the government is
14:33starting to collect figures
14:34as to how many people are brought before the courts.
14:36And again, the figures always seem to be going up.
14:38Of course, we know now that the population is rising anyway.
14:41The figures seem to be going up.
14:42So, of course, that helps to kind of contribute to this fear of crime,
14:45which is really starting to emerge in the early 19th century.
14:50In 1862, there is a moral panic about mugging that is precipitated in the newspapers by one solitary event,
14:59when an MP called Pilkington was mugged by a garotter.
15:09With conviction rates rising, but fewer crimes subject to the death penalty,
15:14the Victorians searched for new ideas about punishment.
15:20Up until now, local jails have just held prisoners before they were punished.
15:26But into the 1840s, as part of a wider expansion of the state,
15:31and the ending of transportation as a sentencing option,
15:35the Victorians began to build large prisons across Britain,
15:39as places of both punishment and reform.
15:44A new idea of prison where you have the ordered prisons with the sexes separated,
15:49different kinds of criminals are classified,
15:51being made to perform useful work as part of their punishment,
15:55all in a specially designed building set apart from the rest of the community.
16:02But those convicted of murder still faced a public execution,
16:08which by the mid-Victorian era was coming under attack from an educated elite.
16:16You got prominent publicists as well,
16:21Dickens and Thackeray being probably the most prominent,
16:23who both attended public executions and both wrote about them.
16:27Both of them were appalled by the behaviour of the people.
16:30It was so loathsome, pitiful and vile a sight,
16:34I did not see one token in all the immense crowd,
16:38at the windows, in the streets, on the housetops,
16:42anywhere of any one emotion suitable to the occasion.
16:46No sorrow, no terror, no abhorrence, no seriousness,
16:52nothing but ribblery, debauchery, levity, drunkenness and flaunting vice.
16:57The public execution is almost a way of saying
17:00that aggression and violence is acceptable and tolerable
17:03and it's kind of promoted by the state.
17:05And this is the very last thing that the Victorians want.
17:08They've got a kind of a civilising idea.
17:10It was this disgust at the scene of a public execution
17:14that led to the first real movement to abolish the death penalty.
17:20By the 1840s there's a really very serious movement
17:26for total abolition of capital punishment in England
17:29that pulls in people like Thackeray.
17:33The argument being that we have other ways of controlling order
17:40so that we do not need to resort to the sledgehammer control
17:45delivered by the noose.
17:47But the vast majority of the population
17:50were convinced that the death penalty should be retained.
17:54And this view was openly supported by the Church of England.
17:59Now capital punishment is a peculiar punishment
18:03because it was justified specifically on biblical terms.
18:07All the arguments were to do with the Bible.
18:10After all fines or community service or even being put in the stocks
18:15don't actually appear in the Bible.
18:18You know they have killed the image of God, another human being,
18:23and so they will be killed themselves.
18:26And that was accepted by practically everyone.
18:32Convinced that the death penalty was sanctioned by God,
18:36the Victorians turned to their newly built prisons
18:38to solve the debate over public executions.
18:43It was one of the suggestions of Bishop Wilberforce
18:46that we've got these wonderful prisons.
18:49Why don't we put capital punishment into a prison?
18:57In 1868, the last public execution was carried out on British soil.
19:03Michael Barrett, an Irish Republican, was hanged outside Newgate prison
19:08while the crowd sang a popular music hall tune, Champagne Charlie.
19:19By moving the gallows into the prison,
19:21the authorities also wanted to introduce a more official
19:25and systematic way of killing,
19:27which would be carried out by professional hangmen.
19:34But you had the rise of regular hangmen.
19:38One of the things they could do,
19:39and this was developed in a very systematic way,
19:42was they could take the weights and measurements
19:45of the person they were going to kill.
19:47They would view them in a prison cell through a loophole
19:51so they could gauge this person's stocky, this person's thin,
19:55this person's 5'3", or whatever.
19:58And then there were scales and measurements
20:00by which you could then judge how much rope you would use
20:04and the quality of the rope.
20:07That would ensure that you neither made it too long,
20:11in which case you might decapitate the person,
20:13or too short, in which case you might strangle the person.
20:17Just the right length, which should lead to instantaneous death.
20:28Hangmen were now expected to carry out their duties,
20:30in an orderly and responsible fashion.
20:35One of the concerns that the Home Office had
20:37was the amount of drinking that the executioners used to engage in.
20:44And so that was restricted.
20:47From then on they had to spend the night in the prison
20:49before the hanging and they were only allowed
20:53a quarter pint of spirits and a couple of pints of ale
20:58the night before.
21:00So it was all much more dignified.
21:05This move towards a dignified system of capital punishment
21:09silenced those voices who had called for the abolition
21:13of the public execution.
21:19And once it's proposed to hide the executions in the prison,
21:25the argument is one for sustaining capital punishment
21:30all the way through to the sixties.
21:32So it's a key moment.
21:34Had there not been a solution to the problem of the crowd
21:38found in the hiding of executions,
21:40the whole thing might have collapsed much earlier than it did.
21:52The Victorian era saw a major shift in how a modern civilized society
21:57maintains order and administers punishment.
22:03The great transformation of punishment in the modern era
22:07moved its locus from the body to the personality.
22:12That is, originally punishment was the infliction of pain and suffering on the body.
22:19And then the enlightenment came along.
22:21And the enlightenment embraced the idea of human beings as rational.
22:27And instead of inflicting pain and suffering on the body,
22:30we took the great good not to be so much life as liberty.
22:35So that we now correlate the heinousness of the crime
22:39with a degree of loss of liberty.
22:42And instead of inflicting pain and suffering directly on the body,
22:47what we do is we deprive people of rights.
22:57For the next 60 years, it appeared that those who supported capital punishment
23:02had won the debate.
23:05Hang me, hang me, hold it a little while
23:11I think I see my friends coming, riding many a mile
23:17Into the first half of the 20th century,
23:20executions continued inside the walls of Britain's prisons
23:24without any significant opposition.
23:27What did you bring me, my dear friends?
23:29Keep me from the gallows floor
23:33While public opinion remained solidly in favour,
23:36only a handful of eccentrics, like the heiress Violet van der Elst,
23:41campaigned against the death penalty.
23:44Mrs van der Elst is one of those curious figures in capital punishment
23:49because she was a classic, eccentric English woman.
23:52She inherited a lot of money
23:54and she decided not to take up the cause of cats and dogs
23:59but to take up the cause of capital punishment.
24:02And because of her money and her sense of stage management,
24:10she could ensure big displays wherever she went.
24:14So, for instance, when executions were taking place in prisons,
24:18she would drive up to the prison in a Rolls Royce.
24:22So she was much more difficult for the authorities to handle
24:24because you couldn't just sort of knock her out the way.
24:27A, she's a woman. B, she's rich.
24:30C, she's sort of rich and well-connected.
24:33And she's in a Rolls Royce.
24:35In some ways, of course,
24:37she was a person that proponents of capital punishment
24:41could point to and say,
24:43well, it's lunatics who are really concerned about this sort of thing.
24:50Kept from view by the authorities,
24:53capital punishment was now largely beneath the public's radar.
24:58But this would change in the aftermath of the Second World War.
25:03By executing Nazi war criminals,
25:06Britain and its wartime allies were exacting a visual show of justice.
25:17And over 200 of these executions were carried out by a British hangman,
25:23Albert Pierpoint, whose deployment to Germany propelled him into the spotlight.
25:30Of course, in the early part of the 20th century,
25:32the hangman, the executioner, had been an obscure figure.
25:35He was an agent of the state, his identity was covered up.
25:38What made Albert Pierpoint a celebrity was not executing people in the 1930s,
25:43but it was when he goes off to Nuremberg at the end of the Second World War
25:46and he executes all these Nazi war criminals.
25:48And the press sort of dig and find out his identity,
25:52and he becomes a celebrity because he's oddly a kind of patriotic icon.
25:57You know, it's one of our boys who has had the last word in the war
26:00by stringing up all these awful Nazis.
26:02I mean, that's the sort of way it's presented.
26:05And Pierpoint then becomes the first and only modern executioner celebrity.
26:12Pierpoint became a familiar face to British audiences
26:15through numerous television interviews.
26:18You always get a new rope and an old rope.
26:22Well, we always choose the old rope if we can,
26:25because a new rope, it seems to lash back.
26:28See what I mean? Springing on it, you see?
26:30And if you get an old one that's been used before,
26:33you've got to examine it well before you use it.
26:35Yeah.
26:35And you see, you leave a sandbag on that,
26:38the same weight hanging overnight.
26:40You see?
26:42It's all prepared for the morning then.
26:46There's a kind of macabre fascination to him, I think.
26:49And the reason that you have that is, I think,
26:51because the concept of executing people
26:53has become so detached from people's ordinary lives.
26:56In a very ordered, settled, consensual society,
26:59to be the person who actually carries out the sentence
27:02has this kind of weird exoticism to it,
27:05and I think that's why he became such a public name.
27:08Did it matter how you've attached the rope?
27:11Oh, yes, there's a certain way in doing it.
27:14To be instantaneous, yes, definitely.
27:18It has on the rope, at the end of the rope,
27:22a brass ring light.
27:26The rope goes through that, you see?
27:28And you put that under the left jaw.
27:30You see? And when he falls and stops dead,
27:33it finishes under the chin.
27:35Should finish under the chin.
27:36It throws the head back and breaks the final chord.
27:48The British public may have supported the Nuremberg executions,
27:52but by the 1950s,
27:55there was increasing disquiet at the continued use of the death penalty.
28:00In 1953, this unease was evident in the case of Derek Bentley.
28:11Bentley, along with his accomplice Christopher Craig,
28:15were stealing from a warehouse when they were confronted by the police.
28:19Craig fled, but Bentley was arrested,
28:22and was alleged to have shouted,
28:24let him have it,
28:26moments before Craig shot dead PC Sidney Miles.
28:30As Craig was only 16, Bentley would hang for the murder.
28:37It also transpired that Derek Bentley had a mental age of something like 11.
28:45that he came from a rather disturbed background.
28:48These facts were withheld from the jury at the trial.
28:52He had certainly not been the leader in this enterprise of breaking into this warehouse.
29:02He'd been easily captured by the police,
29:04and the police simply said that he had shouted out to Craig as he came up onto the roof,
29:10let him have it.
29:13That was much disputed.
29:16The case rested on the prosecution's assumption that let him have it
29:21was an encouragement to shoot the policeman, not to hand the gun over.
29:27But many of the public disagreed with this interpretation.
29:31And there was even doubt that he had said this at all.
29:38I think everybody thought that he would be reprieved.
29:42And when he wasn't reprieved, there was a great deal of public concern,
29:45both in the press but also by people going along to the prison in the morning
29:49and creating a large demonstration.
29:54The apparent injustice led to some public sympathy for Bentley
29:59and to a questioning of the state's right to execute a mandatory death sentence
30:05on a vulnerable individual.
30:11I think what that demonstrated was that to have a system in which the death penalty was mandatory for murder,
30:20and in which everything, every way of trying to classify murders
30:26as those that were death worthy and not death worthy,
30:29came down to a political decision of the secretary of state.
30:32That particular secretary of state decided that he would not act in the favour of Derrick Bentley.
30:39So there seemed to be a gross unfairness in the case.
30:45Bentley's case caught the public's attention through its coverage in the press.
30:51Through the 1950s, capital punishment began to be openly debated
30:55on the pages of the nation's newspapers.
30:59Britain had one of the highest rates of newspaper readership in the entire world.
31:04And there's enormous competition between, you know, the sort of, the people, the news of the world,
31:09the mirror, the mail, the express and so on.
31:11And they use kind of those classic kind of Victorian staples of sex and sensation and murder and whatnot
31:18to sell copies.
31:22In 1955, the press seized on the story of Ruth Ellis, a young woman sentenced to hang for the murder
31:31of her lover.
31:34We have to say that there's an element of interest in the fact that it was an attractive woman,
31:41that it was a crime of passion, so-called.
31:44She wasn't necessarily a sympathetic person in those times when promiscuity was decried even more than today.
31:53She'd had a couple of lovers, she had two children.
31:56There was quite a bit of concern that she didn't just shoot him once, but several times.
32:06But there was a degree of public empathy for Ruth Ellis.
32:10Like the Bentley case two years earlier,
32:13people questioned whether this crime of passion should carry a mandatory death sentence.
32:22The idea that a distraught woman acting in a passionate moment would go to the gallows,
32:30I think caught the public imagination and made people question whether that was the right thing to be doing to
32:38a young woman.
32:47And that raised the further question then, if it was not right to do it for young women,
32:52was it right to do it to young men?
32:55And so I think the debate, if you look at the papers, I think she is, and the way her
33:02case was treated,
33:03was the catalyst for what would later become a campaign.
33:09Both Bentley and Ellis were hanged by Britain's chief executioner, Albert Pierpoint.
33:17Such was the controversial nature of the Ellis and Bentley cases,
33:21that in 1957 the Conservative government passed the Homicide Act,
33:27which introduced the new defences of provocation and diminished responsibility for murder.
33:36So they'd brought in that some murders would be capital murders,
33:41what the Americans call first-degree murders, capital murders,
33:44and other murders, the pub fight, the domestic dispute, the...
33:48..or whatever, would not be.
33:53This law resulted in fewer executions,
33:57with only five or six people a year being sent to the gallows.
34:02But the Homicide Act caused confusion.
34:07We don't know why some are hanged and some are reprieved.
34:10One Sunday newspaper posed this question and gave these examples.
34:14Francis Forsyth, 18, murdered Alan Gee as he was walking home.
34:18He robbed him and kicked him unconscious with his pointed shoes.
34:22Forsyth was executed.
34:24But David de Ducca, 21, did much the same thing.
34:27He battered an old man to death and stole his wallet.
34:31But David de Ducca was reprieved.
34:34Those sort of anomalies convinced quite a lot of people,
34:38including members of the judiciary,
34:41which was the other change that really took place in the 50s and early 60s.
34:46You actually got members of the judiciary thinking that this just wasn't going to work any more.
34:57The debate over capital punishment peaked in December 1964,
35:02when a Labour MP, Sydney Silverman, submitted a private member's bill to Parliament.
35:09Silverman's bill proposed an experiment, the suspension of all executions for five years.
35:15On the 21st of December 1964, as Parliament debated this bill, the BBC screened a live debate between proponents of
35:27capital punishment and abolitionists.
35:32In two and a half hours from now, we shall know whether or not hanging for murder is likely to
35:38be abolished in Great Britain.
35:40At this moment, the House of Commons is locked in debate on capital punishment.
35:43There'll be a free vote at 11 o'clock.
35:46But I believe that this particular penalty for particular people, namely professional criminals, is the one real deterrent.
35:56This argument about deterrence, of course, is the standard argument that's been put for 150 years in respect of every
36:02form of capital punishment
36:03and has always been proved wrong.
36:05It's astonishing that Henry Brook should bring testimony today to say that he's now convinced that that particular argument cannot
36:11be borne out.
36:14Later that evening, Sydney Silverman's bill was passed by 200 votes to 98.
36:23But it didn't reflect public opinion on the issue.
36:27Despite much sympathy for cases like Bentley and Ellis, there was still widespread support for capital punishment.
36:36In polls in the 1960s, people said the one thing about the whole of the 1960s that they disliked most
36:42was the abolition of the death penalty.
36:43So what you have effectively is an elite-driven kind of liberal establishment project to reform the death penalty.
36:54Now, that comes from, I guess, education and from a different moral outlook and whatnot.
36:58But it also rests on something that we just simply don't have today, which is a sense that the people
37:03in Parliament know better.
37:06They know best.
37:07And they are not dependent on the kind of popular will, if you like, on popular opinion for their mandate.
37:14So, in a funny way, the abolition of the death penalty would be impossible in today's Parliament.
37:19It's something that was only possible in the 50s and 60s because they didn't have that kind of populist vertical
37:25culture that we have today.
37:29Despite Parliament's ruling, the debate over capital punishment continued to rage throughout the 1960s.
37:37And they were expecting that if you could abolish it at Parliament, that you could also bring it back through
37:44Parliament.
37:45So, naturally enough, any high-profile case, especially one which might, as it were, lead to at least bringing it
37:55back partially,
37:55say for the murder of policemen or for a particularly violent set of murders, these were leapt on by newspapers
38:03in order to try and reverse the decision.
38:08In October 1965, less than a year after abolition, the resolve of Parliament would be tested by one of the
38:17most notorious murder cases of the 20th century.
38:22We think of the mid-60s as this great utopian, happy-go-lucky, kind of orgiastic age where everyone's having
38:29a great time.
38:30In fact, the mid-60s was a much more anxious, darker time than we remember.
38:36In what would become known as the Moors' murders, Ian Brady and Myra Hindley kidnapped, tortured and killed five children,
38:46burying them in shallow graves on Saddleworth Moor.
38:51On these bleak and desolate moorlands 1,600 feet up in the Pennines, senior police officers believe they'll find two
38:58more bodies, possibly a third.
39:02It's impossible to overstate how shocking those crimes were, particularly when the tapes were played in court and then reported
39:10in the newspapers.
39:12At their trial, there was public outrage when a tape recording was played to the court of Brady and Hindley
39:19torturing ten-year-old Leslie Ann Daly.
39:24And that means that within a year of the suspension of the death penalty, you have newspaper columnists,
39:31and particularly kind of, you know, people in the pub, people on street corners and whatnot, calling for the death
39:36penalty to be brought back
39:37because there are kind of two people who, to people in the 1960s, seem ideal candidates for the hangman's noose.
39:45It's Brady and Hindley.
39:47The overwhelming majority wanted to see Brady and Hindley hang for their crimes.
39:58But public pressure could not convince the government.
40:02Brady and Hindley were both sentenced to life imprisonment.
40:08A life sentence for murder was now mandatory, following the suspension of the death penalty in 1965.
40:18The mandatory life sentence was brought in as a condition of abolishing the death penalty.
40:24Those who opposed abolition were told by those who advocated it and who, in the end, prevailed,
40:30that they would always be safeguarded because there would be this mandatory life sentence.
40:36The mandatory life sentence was aimed at extending the amount of time a convicted murderer could be imprisoned for.
40:45In the days of capital punishment, those reprieved, and that was the majority of murderers who were reprieved,
40:55served sentences considerably lower than they would serve today,
41:00despite the media thinking we are soft on crime.
41:04Craig, who couldn't be sentenced to the hangman because of his age when Bentley was executed,
41:11served 11 or 12 years for the shooting of a police officer.
41:17Now, even as a 16-year-old, he would probably serve a minimum of 25, so the sentence doubled.
41:26In fact, under today's tariff system, some prisoners serving life sentences are eligible for early parole.
41:34But this raises its own moral questions about how the state punishes individuals,
41:40like Harry Roberts, who's been locked up for 44 years,
41:44convicted after the murder of three policemen in 1966.
41:49I think it's extremely cruel to lock someone up forever, but in a slightly different way from executing them,
41:55because it's the gift that keeps on giving.
41:59If you see what I mean, you know, you're in prison maybe for 40 or 50 years.
42:02I mean, Harry Roberts, who was the man who murdered the three policemen in Shepherd's Bush,
42:05is still in jail after 44 years.
42:08I happen to believe he should still be there, because he committed three very, very nasty, gratuitous murders.
42:14And if you let someone like Harry Roberts out, and there has been talk about doing so,
42:18you're effectively saying to other people who might want to kill the police,
42:21oh yes, he was away for 44 years, but in the end, it's forgive and forget.
42:26Wouldn't it be the mark of a more humane society to execute him?
42:33And if that means dealing through the state in a final way with someone who has committed the most grave
42:42crime,
42:43then I don't see that that's a problem.
42:46Well, I counter that by simply pointing out that as a matter of logic,
42:52it's much worse for an individual to spend the rest of their life on a prison than to be executed
42:59immediately.
43:00I don't take the view that there is somewhere down there a hell that all bad people are going to
43:06be tortured by.
43:08I think, you know, if they're turned off, that's an end on it.
43:11And why give them the benefit of being turned off like that when they could be made punished for the
43:24rest of their lives?
43:25I think it's a far worse punishment, life in prison, because they suffer. They suffer.
43:33In 1969, Parliament voted overwhelmingly in favour of permanently abolishing the death penalty for murder.
43:42Two years later, capital punishment was also removed for arson in a Royal Naval dockyard.
43:51Now, hanging only remained for treason and piracy.
44:01Britain's new position was soon followed by other Western countries, like France and Spain,
44:07which through the 1970s would also stop using the death penalty.
44:16Even the USA, which hadn't executed anyone since 1967, suspended capital punishment in 1972.
44:26In America, the instrument for the temporary abolition of the death penalty was not Congress.
44:32It was the Supreme Court, the one part of the government of America which is not susceptible to re-election.
44:40It was that body that actually declared that at least the process of executions in America was unconstitutional.
44:51The Supreme Court's decision infuriated the majority of Americans.
44:57Private papers of the Chief Justice, who was in the dissent, indicate that he thought that was the end of
45:03the death penalty in America.
45:06As did most of the abolitionists, they thought they had won their permanent victory.
45:09They couldn't have been more wrong.
45:10And the states immediately, responding to overwhelming public support for the death penalty,
45:15in outrage at the United States Supreme Court decision, re-enacted death penalty statutes.
45:22In 1976, the Supreme Court was forced to review its decision in response to widespread public pressure.
45:31Less than two years ago, death cells in prisons throughout America were emptied,
45:36when the Supreme Court ruled against capital punishment.
45:39The court decided that it was unconstitutional, because it was a cruel and unusual form of punishment,
45:45in the sense that it was so arbitrary, some people would be sentenced to death,
45:49and others merely to a term of imprisonment for the same offence.
45:52Now, though, the court is having to think again.
45:55And while it's doing so, death rows throughout the country are filling up again.
46:02The Supreme Court voted to reinstate capital punishment.
46:08And in 1977, Gary Gilmore became the first person to be executed in the U.S. for ten years.
46:17Gilmore eventually insisted that the state of Utah put him to death.
46:22So he was the first of many volunteers from death row,
46:26basically people who could save their own lives by continuing to appeal,
46:32and to have their cases reviewed and have their cases delayed.
46:36He took the opposite path.
46:38He volunteered. The state of Utah put him to death.
46:41And from that day onwards, the execution pattern began once again in the U.S.A.
46:46very slowly at first. In 1977, there was only two.
46:49And then in the early 1980s, there were a handful each year.
46:52But by the end of the 1990s, there was almost 100 people being put to death each year.
47:01Gilmore was executed by a firing squad in Utah.
47:06Since then, other U.S. states have chosen to use the gas chamber,
47:10or lethal injection, to carry out death sentences.
47:17Gilmore's execution hit the headlines in the British press,
47:20and inspired some British lawyers to offer to cross the Atlantic,
47:24and help defend those facing the death penalty.
47:30Through the 1980s, British lawyers like Clive Stafford Smith
47:35took up cases that challenged America's right to execute.
47:39In a fair world, you're going to win, but the world isn't always unfair.
47:43I'd become obsessed with the death penalty,
47:46and this was from quite a young age.
47:49You know, I was very young when I was writing something about it.
47:51I was, like, 16 in school.
47:53And I thought it was a history paper.
47:56I thought the death penalty was history.
47:57And when I discovered that the Americans were still killing each other,
48:02I was really shocked.
48:03A death row inmate at Parchman is scheduled to die in the gas chamber in two weeks.
48:08In 1987, a BBC documentary followed Clive Stafford Smith,
48:15who had volunteered to act as the lawyer for a man on death row in Mississippi.
48:2114 days in May captured his attempts to stop Edward Earl Johnson being executed.
48:28The funny thing is, I think about a future.
48:33Now, that might seem kind of crazy.
48:35Now, what future could I possibly have in knowing that I might supposedly be executed in the next two weeks?
48:42Despite evidence suggesting Johnson was innocent,
48:46he was executed in a gas chamber on the 20th of May, 1987.
48:51Ladies and gentlemen, at 12.06 a.m., Wednesday, May 20th,
48:57Edward Earl Johnson was executed in the lethal gas chamber
49:01here at the Mississippi State Penitentiary
49:04in conformance with the sentence of the circuit court of Leap County.
49:10Sitting there watching him be gassed to death in the gas chamber was just horrific.
49:17In a way, the fact that there were cameras there made it slightly easier
49:22because you thought this was all a movie or something
49:25and someone was going to call cut and it would all be over.
49:28But I think that's what Edward thought and that made it a little easier for him, perhaps.
49:34When the family asked me why, all I could say was,
49:38it's a sick world. It's a sick world. Thank you.
49:4614 days in May was one of a number of British documentaries
49:50which attacked capital punishment in America.
49:53These films helped shape the ongoing debate in the UK.
50:00When you see documentaries of people on death row in America,
50:04which are fantastically common,
50:06you get the feeling that this is contributing to the debate here,
50:11reflecting liberal opinion here,
50:13but probably not actually reflecting what the majority of the population believe.
50:18I don't think it's changed their minds in any way.
50:20In many ways it's the, and so often these things,
50:23it's the liberal elite speaking to the liberal elite.
50:29While British programme makers used the American experience
50:32to highlight the flaws in capital punishment,
50:36in the UK itself there was rising public demand
50:39that Britain too should begin executing again.
50:44For the first time since abolition, Britain had a Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher,
50:49who supported the death penalty.
50:52And MPs were given a free vote on the subject throughout the 1980s.
50:58When I first came into Parliament, there was still, certainly in the public domain,
51:02quite an active debate going on about the death penalty
51:04because it was the height of the IRA, outrages,
51:09innocent people were dying in random terror acts,
51:13and people were saying, well, at least bring it back for terrorism.
51:15You know, even if you don't bring it back for anything else,
51:17at least bring it back for terrorism.
51:18So there was a, there was still quite a lively debate
51:21about whether it should be brought back.
51:26When there was a free vote on the death penalty,
51:28I always voted for restoration
51:29because I do believe there's a very strong moral case
51:33for saying that such a deterrent should be available.
51:36This government will never surrender to the IRA, never.
51:42Really, all of that was really smashed at the end of the 80s and 90s,
51:48when, of course, the government had to confront the fact
51:53that in the cases of Irish terrorists,
51:56particularly the Birmingham Six and the Guildford Four,
52:00that all of these people have been exonerated on the basis
52:04that they had not had a fair trial
52:06and that the evidence was not sufficient to convey.
52:14In 1991, the Birmingham Six and Guildford Four were declared innocent
52:19and released after spending almost two decades in prison.
52:25I've been in prison for 15 years for something I didn't do,
52:29for something I didn't know anything about.
52:33Had Britain retained the death penalty then,
52:36they would have almost certainly faced execution.
52:40Whether it's Guildford Four, Birmingham Six,
52:43Judith Ward, Tottenham Three, and so on,
52:47in many of these cases, what transpired was
52:52that there was a flawed system.
52:56You can't have a final verdict, like an execution,
53:02where you haven't got an infallible system,
53:07which means that there's a serious risk
53:10you're going to, as it were, kill innocent people.
53:16It was cases of miscarriages of justice like these
53:20that persuaded many in government
53:22that Britain could never reinstate capital punishment.
53:27In 1994, the last free vote took place in Parliament
53:32on reintroducing the death penalty.
53:34It was heavily defeated,
53:36with Home Secretary Michael Howard
53:38now voting in favour of retaining abolition.
53:44For a long time, I supported capital punishment,
53:48because I thought it was a deterrent.
53:51And actually, I still think it is a deterrent.
53:56But I changed my mind because of the risk of a mistake.
54:02It was the cases of the Birmingham Six and the Guilford Four
54:07that changed my mind on that.
54:10I accepted that you could never completely eliminate the risk of mistake.
54:15And since then, I've become averse as well
54:19to the whole idea of the state deliberately taking someone's life.
54:27But it wasn't until 1998, when the Labour government passed the Crime and Disorder Act,
54:33that the death penalty was completely removed from British law.
54:38Up until then, executions could still be carried out for treason and piracy.
54:45Later that year, the Court of Appeal quashed the 1953 conviction of Derek Bentley,
54:51and he was posthumously pardoned.
54:56By 2010, 139 countries had abolished the death penalty.
55:09We are seeing a greater polarisation in the world.
55:14We are seeing a wide gap between the mental make-up of those people
55:23in the countries that oppose the death penalty
55:26and the people in the countries that see no problem with it.
55:35Surprisingly, the country that has the highest cases of capital punishment per capita is Singapore.
55:42But it is believed the country that executes the most people per year is China.
55:49The trouble with China is still a state secret,
55:52and the party will not reveal the number of people sentenced to death and executed.
55:56So you have no idea really how many people are put to death there.
56:01But at the UN Human Rights Council, at the end of 2007,
56:07the Chinese delegate, I think he's called Mr. Lai Yifan,
56:12made a statement that China was reducing its use of the death penalty
56:17and was setting in plans to do so with the ultimate aim of abolishing it.
56:24Now, this is a statement really from the state and state authority that abolition is a goal.
56:31We haven't heard that from the United States, I'm sorry to say, from the State Department.
56:38But even in America today, the use of capital punishment is a lot less widespread.
56:44It's also true that amongst the 35 states that have the death penalty, about a third of them never use
56:49it.
56:49Another third impose death sentences but rarely carry them out.
56:52And the death sentences that are carried out are typically in one region of the nation, that is to say
56:58the South.
56:59These days, nearly more than half of the death sentences that are executed occur in Texas.
57:05So, is America a death penalty nation? Well, in parts.
57:11In 2010, those American states, which continue to use the death penalty,
57:17have been challenged over whether executing an individual in a painful manner infringes their human rights.
57:26This debate could see the end of the death penalty in America.
57:30But its supporters have gone back to 18th century ideas of punishment,
57:34to defend the right to execute.
57:38To say that it has to be painless is to lose sight of what it is, which is punishment.
57:45In its etymology, in its very meaning, the word punishment comes from the same root as pain.
57:54It is, in its essential conception, painful.
57:58If it is not painful, it is not punishment.
58:03When killers, intentionally, or with a depraved indifference, inflict intense pain and suffering on their victims,
58:12in my view, they should die a quick but painful death.
58:17Not torture, not drawn out, but quick and painful.
58:23The debate about capital punishment has raged for over 200 years.
58:31Both sides believe they are in the right.
58:35And if the history of capital punishment has taught us one thing,
58:41it's that both sides will continue to fight their corner passionately.
58:50To challenge your views and learn more about the justice system,
58:53go to bbc.co.uk forward slash justice
58:57and follow the links to The Open University.

Recommended