- 2 days ago
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:03This is the story of an immense leap of faith made on a promise of equality and toleration.
00:12It would carry the Jews of Europe from the certainties of tradition
00:17and from the ghettos enforced by ancient prejudice
00:21and expose them to the opportunities and to the threats of freedom
00:26in a world transformed by revolution, technology, mass culture and nationalism.
00:41It would begin in a world of aristocratic libraries, temples of learning.
00:47It would culminate in a world of metropolitan magnificence,
00:51department stores, palaces of plenty, concert halls, capitals of culture.
01:03From the ghetto to the salon, from the hallowed past to the promised future,
01:09this was one of the greatest human journeys in the shortest space of time ever made.
01:20And the consequences would be world-changing as hopes born on the pages of books
01:27died in the flames of hatred and destruction.
01:35It was in the 18th century that the world of Gentile learning
01:40and the world of the Jews finally came face to face,
01:44finally came to engage with each other.
01:47The philosophers of the Enlightenment held that everyone, Jews included,
01:52guided by the light of reason,
01:54could sweep away the inherited prejudices of centuries.
01:59So they made the Jews a special bargain.
02:02Come out of your mental ghetto.
02:05Expose yourself to modern languages, to learning, to science.
02:11And then you will become useful members of society.
02:15And when that happens, we will embrace you fully and legally in civil rights.
02:21And you'll become something new.
02:23You'll become a citizen who happens to practice the Jewish faith.
02:30Well, it was a noble idea.
02:32For that matter, it still is.
02:34The question is, would it work?
02:37The question is, would it work?
03:26Embracing the new was never going to be easy
03:29for the Jews.
03:30They'd survive long centuries of exile and persecution by cleaving to their traditions.
03:37Any challenge to those traditions seemed to threaten survival itself.
03:48Baruch Spinoza, a 23-year-old merchant and precocious thinker from a religious family,
03:54posed just such a challenge.
03:56Which is why, in 1656, in the synagogue on the Hout Hrath Canal, he was cast out of Amsterdam's
04:05community of Jews.
04:09We ban, expel, curse and damn Baruch de Espinosa with the consent of God.
04:18Cursed be he by day, and cursed be he by night.
04:23Cursed be he when he lies down, and cursed be he when he rises up.
04:30The Lord shall blot out his name from under heaven, and the Lord shall separate him unto
04:37evil.
04:39None shall contact him by mouth, or by writing, nor stay under the same roof as him, nor read
04:48anything he wrote.
04:51In the eyes of the Amsterdam community, Spinoza was a heretic, undermining through soulless logic
04:58and wild speculation, Jewish faith and Jewish identity.
05:05Miracles were myths.
05:06The soul was not immortal.
05:09The Bible was the work of men, not God.
05:15The revelation of God can only be established by the wisdom of the doctrine, not by miracles,
05:23or, in other words, ignorance.
05:29It wasn't just the Jews whom Spinoza risked outraging.
05:33The Protestant Dutch, who had given the Jews a refuge following their expulsion from Spain
05:39and Portugal, identified with the Biblical children of Israel, founded their faith on the
05:44Old as well as the New Testament.
05:47Spinoza's attack on Jewish tradition was an attack on Christianity, too, and a threat
05:54to the New Jerusalem the Jews had been allowed to build in Amsterdam.
06:02Was what Spinoza said so shocking?
06:05Well, it was shocking enough for him to be accused of atheism by both Jews and Christians.
06:11But Spinoza was no atheist.
06:15He believed in God, all right, but it wasn't the God of the Hebrew Bible.
06:23No, Spinoza's God was nothing less, but nothing more, than the whole of created nature itself.
06:33The logical end of Spinoza's reasoning was toleration, still a challenge in some parts
06:40of the world now, explosive then.
06:42Because under a God identical with all of nature, no one religion could claim a monopoly of wisdom.
06:50All very well.
06:52But it robbed the Jews, not just here in Amsterdam, of course, but everywhere, of their own special identity,
06:59their sense of divine election, their sense of being the chosen people.
07:04It was that character that had sustained the Jews through generations of difficulty, hardship, and calamity.
07:12And what was this God who was also nature of Spinoza's offering instead?
07:17Well, in Spinoza's mind, it was offering to bring the Jews together with the rest of humanity.
07:24Jews, Christians, and anyone else, for that matter, who could share the same common space.
07:30And Spinoza thought, what was not to like about that?
07:42Spinoza challenged Jew and Gentile alike with his philosophy of toleration.
07:47Two generations after his death, that challenge was taken up here, in the Prussian capital of Berlin.
07:56Berlin, then, was enclosed by a city wall.
08:00Inside, some 2,000 privileged and protected Jews were permitted to live.
08:05Elsewhere in Prussia, they were confined to provincial towns, inward-looking, closed off from the Gentile world around them.
08:15But then, a young Jewish scholar, his first name, Waiti, with historical significance, walked to Berlin, following his religious teacher.
08:24Moses Mendelssohn, unprotected, unprivileged.
08:28He somehow made it into a city world rich with new possibilities.
08:36In 1743, the lad, Moses Mendelssohn, barely out of his bar mitzvah, stood before one of these heavily guarded city
08:45gates in old Berlin,
08:46on the brink of a great cultural adventure that would transform not just his life,
08:52but all of the relationships and encounters between Jews and Gentiles.
08:58Of this mighty destiny, he could have had very little inkling.
09:02He'd lived all of his young life amidst religious Jews like himself.
09:07He spoke just two languages, Judeo-German, otherwise known as Yiddish in his daily round,
09:14and Hebrew in the synagogue in prayers and studies.
09:18He would end his life as the embodiment of the Jewish Enlightenment,
09:23able to speak and write and read every language you could think of, French, English, Latin and Greek.
09:29He didn't know what was in store for him, but it was an extraordinary opening,
09:36not just in these city gates, but the entire history of the Jews and those who met them.
09:46Mendelssohn may have come to Berlin to pursue his religious studies,
09:49but soon he was reaching well beyond the Talmud,
09:53exploring new worlds of secular knowledge, dipping into dangerous Spinoza.
09:59He wasn't trying to escape his Judaism, though.
10:02He would live, marry and raise six children all within the faith.
10:10At the Jewish Museum in Berlin, there's something that captures his ideal of vigorous new growth,
10:17deeply rooted in long tradition.
10:20It's a masterpiece of synagogue art, made from Mendelssohn's wife's own wedding dress.
10:29This is a Torah art curtain, which was given to the Berlin Jewish community by Moses Mendelssohn and his wife
10:35from it.
10:37And both their names are on it, and it was dedicated by them.
10:41And what I think is particularly special about them, when the names are in parallel, there's something that's like equality.
10:46Yeah, that's a very Enlightenment theme.
10:50Spinoza would have loved this.
10:53If you had to make something that says, God is nature, this is surely it.
11:00What's a bit unusual here is that you actually have the flowers on the grass and it's all alive and
11:05it's a real landscape.
11:06Yes.
11:06That's very, very unusual.
11:08Yeah, it is, isn't it?
11:09And that the flowers, you can actually tell which kind of flowers they are, that you can find.
11:14What have we got?
11:15We've got roses and we've got lilies.
11:17We have carnations.
11:18We have carnations.
11:20We have carnations.
11:20And we have, goodness, those beautiful blue flowers.
11:23This whole sense of botanizing, being part of the 18th century mind, that you catalogue the wonders of nature.
11:31And you can have two views about that.
11:33You can have the kind of non-religious view that nature is its own thing, or you can have the
11:38view that nature is absolutely proof,
11:41not just of God's existence, but of his genius.
11:44So a sense actually of the deep past, made beautiful by the possibility of a flowering present, is all in
11:52the object.
11:59Nourished by the ideas of the Enlightenment, there were other flowers that bloomed for Mendelssohn.
12:04Close and enduring friendships made with non-Jewish writers seem so obvious, so easy now, sharing culture, without being asked
12:14to sacrifice your identity.
12:15But then it was almost incredible.
12:23His closest friend was the poet and playwright Gotthold Lessing.
12:28They played chess together, walked in their gardens.
12:31Mendelssohn even came round for dinner, bringing his own kosher food.
12:38Lessing honoured their friendship in his play, Nathan the Wise.
12:43Nathan, a Jew, expresses in a few resonant words the high hopes of the Enlightenment promise.
12:53It is enough to be ein Mensch, a man.
12:59And the man who had been the inspiration for Nathan wanted other Jews to share in that promise.
13:09He began to think about the problem, the issue of language.
13:14You could not be an aspiring 18th century philosopher and not think about the relationship between language and identity.
13:23That was at the heart of a great deal of the discussion of which he was part.
13:28And the relationship between the language of the Torah, Hebrew, and the language of his adopted country, the language he
13:35knew his children would grow up speaking German.
13:40Hebrew, he thought, in some way, while magnificent and noble, had actually been lost in esoteric debates in the Talmud.
13:49And if these young Jews, who were simultaneously Prussians and Jews, were going to feel the Bible and the Torah
13:59as a living thing,
14:00they were going to need to read it in the new language too.
14:04But, and this is the crucial point, the only translations into German available at that time were essentially the achievements
14:13of Christian Bible scholars.
14:19So it needed a Jew somehow to actually translate that supple Hebrew into a German which faithfully reflected its richness
14:31and strength.
14:32And there was only one person who could do that himself.
14:35So he gets to work.
14:37And here it is, right from the beginning, the Book of Genesis, the beginning of the beginning.
14:44And it's extraordinary to read, on one side of the page, the Hebrew, very familiar to all of us who
14:51went to Hebrew school,
14:52and the other side, incredibly unfamiliar to me, in Hebrew letters.
14:57This is the halfway house, exactly the same verse.
15:00How does the Bible begin?
15:01All of you out there will know this, won't you?
15:04Possibly not in Hebrew.
15:06Here's how the Hebrew sounds.
15:16And I'm moving my eye over to the difficult bit in German, where it says,
15:22Im Anfang, Shuf Got.
15:27At the beginning, again, God created.
15:30The Himmel, the heavens, the Erde, and the earth.
15:36And I'm stumbling over it because it is so difficult for me.
15:39I could see him really thinking about exactly how the Hebrew letters would perfectly fit the German.
15:47And there was something deeply moving in its linguistic and cultural optimism about this,
15:54seeing German alongside Hebrew as though they were naturally kindred spirits to each other.
16:07Mendelssohn's Bible was the bridge over which generations of Jews would cross,
16:11from the Jewish world to the German world, from the religious to the secular.
16:16They could read Isaiah in the morning and Goethe in the afternoon.
16:24But Mendelssohn expected them to cross that bridge as Jews and to stay that way.
16:29Adapt yourselves to the morals and constitution of the land to which you've been removed, he advised,
16:36but hold fast to the religion of your fathers.
16:42To his friend, Gotold Lessing, Moses Mendelssohn was simply Ein Mensch, a man.
16:49But growing fame as scholar and philosopher made him a prize
16:53for those who believed intellectual enlightenment was simply the first step
16:57towards the ultimate enlightenment of Christianity.
17:02Swiss theologian Johann Caspar Lavater publicly challenged Mendelssohn
17:09to do what wisdom, the love of truth and honesty must bid him.
17:14In other words, to convert to Christianity.
17:20But Mendelssohn replied, I declare myself a Jew, I shall always be a Jew.
17:28The prophet of the Jewish enlightenment died in 1786.
17:41For Mendelssohn's children and grandchildren, things would be very different.
17:49In 1789, revolution came to France and soon after, revolutionary armies began marching through Europe,
17:56tearing down ghetto walls in the name of Liberté, Egalité and Fraternité.
18:05It was assumed that the Jews would happily shrug off their separate identity
18:09in exchange for something they'd never enjoyed before, equal citizenship.
18:18Some did, some didn't, but when the Emperor Napoleon was finally defeated,
18:23it was assumed, just as mistakenly, that every Jew must have been a dangerous Bonapartist.
18:29So those New One liberties were constantly threatened, pushed back, reversed.
18:39For Moses Mendelssohn's children, the road to Jewish emancipation now seemed clogged with barriers.
18:46Now they had to prove that a Jew could also be a good German.
19:06One of Moses' children, Abraham, was a banker.
19:11He and his wife, Leah, threw themselves headlong into German culture.
19:17Judaism took a back seat.
19:26And their road into German acceptance would be through music.
19:32Their children, Felix and Fanny, both became prodigies.
19:50Music critic Norman LeBrette is in no doubt about their formidable talent.
19:55They both have a prodigious gift.
19:58At the age of ten, Mendelssohn was writing music that was far in advance
20:02of anything that had been seen, of anything that Mozart was doing at that age.
20:05This boy was an absolute whiz.
20:08He's the grandson of the great philosopher Moses Mendelssohn,
20:11the first who actually creates a dialogue between Jews and Christians in Western Europe,
20:16who marks the beginning of the thought.
20:18And now, suddenly, his grandson is the new Mozart.
20:21So there are huge hopes for him.
20:22And suddenly, people are talking and recognising that Jews make music.
20:28He becomes the favourite composer of the establishment.
20:33In England, he becomes close, very close personally, to Queen Victoria and Prince Albert.
20:39And Prince Albert.
20:40Yes.
20:41The Queen's diary entry on first meeting him was,
20:45He is short, dark and Jewish looking.
20:49But appearances were deceptive.
20:51In fact, Felix was a Christian.
20:55When he was just seven years old, his father Abraham had had him baptised,
21:00hoping to ensure his future prospects.
21:03But perhaps Felix Mendelssohn's conversion was never complete.
21:13This is a composer who is living in the age of romantic nationalism,
21:17where everybody is looking for a label, and everybody is keen on identity.
21:20Mendelssohn never refers to his Jewish background.
21:24Mendelssohn is in denial.
21:26But when it comes to his most famous work, there is a Jewish imprint on it.
21:32Take a look at the violin concerto in E minor.
21:35Yeah.
21:36And tell me why that is not a Jewish work.
21:46It's exploding.
21:47It's coming, it is coming out of, out of the composer and out of the violin.
21:53It can't, it's an unstoppable force.
21:59It's so over the top.
22:01It, it speaks of suppressed emotions and suppressed ideas and, and a suppressed society,
22:08and a suppressed identity in Mendelssohn's case.
22:14When it actually comes to the performance, Mendelssohn can't conduct it.
22:18He, he, he, he goes into a hissy fitty.
22:20He, he, he, he's, he's not feeling well.
22:22He leaves it to someone else.
22:24That's so Jewish.
22:24He's not obsessed.
22:25Exactly.
22:26I've got a headache.
22:27Exactly.
22:27My, my arm won't move.
22:29Can't, can't do it.
22:31It's too personal.
22:31It's too personal.
22:36So, did success require a baptismal sprinkle?
22:41The story of another Berlin family suggests not.
22:45The Beers were just as self-confident and ambitious as the Mendelssohn's.
22:50But they wouldn't abandon Judaism to make it in German culture.
22:54Instead, they would bring it into the modern world.
23:00Judah Beer had made his fortune in the sugar business.
23:04But it was the voluptuous, raven-haired Amalia who ruled the clan.
23:08Her childhood name, after all, had been Malka, the queen.
23:12And her pedigree was as close to royalty as you could get among the Jews,
23:16learned rabbis and bankers.
23:19Queen Amalia stayed true to both by being socially dazzling and resolutely religious.
23:26She opened the doors of her elegant salon at Villa Beer to the cream of Berlin society,
23:32scientists and poets who vied with each other for the privilege of sipping chocolate
23:37and polishing their witticisms in her regal presence.
23:42And at the same time, she and her husband led a campaign among German Jews
23:47for a modern, enlightened brand of Judaism.
23:55Leading by example, they built a synagogue inside their own home,
23:59with services held in German as well as Hebrew,
24:02and, shock, an organ.
24:06A choir.
24:12We all think of Jews and music in the same sentence,
24:16but even though music did become the royal road for Jews
24:21into the heart of German culture, it was a little surprising.
24:25Singing, much less instrumental music,
24:28was really not part of the world of the community or the synagogue.
24:33But upwardly, mobile Jews took to music like ducks to water.
24:39So music was always going to be very important to an ambitious family like the beers.
24:45If the first generation was all about the raw power of money,
24:49for the second, what was crucial was the display of cultural refinement
24:54in an elegant salon like this.
24:58And the third generation was always going to be about cultural performance.
25:03And there was no performer more dazzling than the nine-year-old son
25:08of Judah and Amalia beer, little Jacob,
25:11who at that tender age managed to pull off such a sensational performance
25:17of Mozart's D minor piano concerto that it wowed Jews and Gentiles alike.
25:23Now, that little boy was going to grow up to be Giacomo Mayabea,
25:29and this is Giacomo's travelling piano.
25:33He was not only the man who was going to reinvent the entire form of opera,
25:38he would also become an international superstar, a celebrity.
25:43And for such a superstar, it was always going to be a case of
25:48have piano, will travel.
25:55And so, Jacob travelled.
25:58In 1816, he left Berlin for Italy to study opera,
26:02and it was there he changed his first name to Giacomo.
26:09But while he Italianised at one end, he Judaised at the other,
26:13adding his grandfather's first name, Meyer, to his surname,
26:18emerging as Giacomo Mayabea.
26:27He could have returned to Berlin and made a musical career there.
26:31But if he wanted to make it big time, there was only one place for that.
26:38Paris.
26:441831, they are packing them through the turnstiles here in the Paris Opera House.
26:49And what are they coming to see?
26:51They're coming to see an opera called Robert the Devil,
26:55by somebody called Mayabea, but his first name is Giacomo.
26:59Well, does he think he's Rossini or something?
27:01He's a Jew.
27:02We know he's no Donitzetti, no Rossini, no Bellini.
27:06So, what's he doing with this Robert the Devil thing?
27:09Answer!
27:10Medieval!
27:11Renaissance!
27:12Extravaganza!
27:17Orgiastic nuns rising from the tomb to do urr things with their shrouds.
27:23A tormented hero on the rim of hell, and rather liking it.
27:47It's Les Mis in chainmail.
27:50It's spectacle, it's colossal production numbers, it's tonic for the turnstiles.
27:57And it seems to presage an entirely new phase in the history of opera.
28:05This is, in every sense, grand opera, big opera.
28:08No, it is not Mozart, it is not Beethoven.
28:14But if you think of it in terms of fantastic entertainment,
28:19taking all those things which got the voltage whirring and stirring
28:23in the minds of people in the 1830s,
28:26ruins, the Christian soul, heaven and hell,
28:30then this was absolutely perfect.
28:33The public, Paris, all of Europe,
28:36could not get enough of Giacomo Meyerbeer.
28:40From now on, in opera, he was the man.
29:00But despite his international fame,
29:03and despite his appointment as musical director to the Prussian court,
29:07Meyerbeer discovered there were still some places where the king of opera
29:12still smelled a bit too much of chicken soup to be asked to the tables of society.
29:23As he noted in his diaries in 1847, it's the same old story.
29:27The ambassador held a dinner tonight and invited all the Prussians, but not me.
29:37Successful Jews had to deal with snubs of this kind all the time.
29:41However high they climbed,
29:43there were always those who thought they could see the gabardine inside the frock coat.
29:48But for Meyerbeer, there was something much more menacing
29:51than a dinner invitation that never came.
30:01In 1850, when Meyerbeer was very much still king of the opera in Paris,
30:08an essay of extraordinary violence appeared,
30:11which, although it didn't personally name him,
30:15made it very clear that he indeed was the target.
30:18And the reason was there in its title,
30:21because it was called Das Judentum in Music,
30:24Jewishness in Music.
30:26And what that Jewishness was,
30:28according to its particularly hostile author,
30:31was the corruption of high art by sordid commercial popularity.
30:38That author was Richard Wagner.
30:41What made his onslaught on Meyerbeer and the other Jews in Music
30:46so ferocious and almost psychotic was that Meyerbeer had been Wagner's patron.
30:55He was biting the hand that fed him.
30:58Ten years before Das Judentum in Music appeared,
31:01it was Meyerbeer who'd read Wagner's early opera Rienzi,
31:07Meyerbeer who'd written a letter of recommendation,
31:10Meyerbeer who'd enabled the opera to be performed both in Paris and back in Germany.
31:16And at that time, Wagner could not possibly have been more obsequious.
31:22I must work so I will be worthy of you, Wagner wrote cringingly to Meyerbeer.
31:28I am your property, he even said.
31:32Ten years on, when he had a little fame and just a little money,
31:36Wagner was already thinking, as is clear, in a very different way.
31:43The Jew speaks the language of a nation in whose midst he dwells,
31:48but he speaks always as an alien.
31:53The Jew has stood outside the pale of any such community,
31:57stood solitary with his Jehovah in a splintered, soilless stock.
32:04In his art, the Jew truly cannot make a poem of his words,
32:11an artwork of his doings.
32:15At this point, the hymn Art was all about the spiritual depth of nationhood.
32:23It was about tribe, about race, about myth, about blood,
32:29about territory, about soil.
32:31And how could the Jews know anything about that?
32:36They who were wanderers, they who had no country.
32:51Wagner's poisonous track sounded an ominous note
32:55for the fate of the great Enlightenment hope of toleration and sweet reason.
33:02That had always been an urban hope,
33:05the place where ancient suspicions would melt into city life.
33:10Metropolitan Jews, now dressed like everyone else,
33:12shopped like everyone else, applauded in the concert halls.
33:16With everyone else, the promise had been realised.
33:20But then, with Wagner providing the seductive mood music,
33:26German culture took an unexpected turn away from that urban future,
33:31back towards the dark shadows of a mythical Christian Teutonic past
33:36where Jews had no place.
33:39There are always going to be those who fear the future.
33:43The more the Jews became identified with that future,
33:46the more danger they would run if its progress stalled.
33:53You can see what fed the paranoia.
33:56German Jews had made the greatest leap
33:58that any minority has experienced in modern history.
34:07By 1870, Berlin, home to a mere 3,000 Jews in Moses Mendelssohn's time,
34:13now had 36,000 Jewish citizens.
34:24An educational revolution was underway.
34:27Mendelssohn's dream realised more completely
34:30than he could ever have imagined.
34:36Jewish children were four times more likely
34:39to go to high school than Gentiles.
34:43And those children would go on to become captains of the new industries,
34:49shipping, chemicals, electricity, mass circulation, newspapers and publishing,
34:54and masters of the professions, law, medicine and science.
35:01They had good reason to believe that the prejudice against them
35:05was a dying vestige of the past.
35:07They were patriots, their destinies closely entwined
35:11with the destiny of the new Germany.
35:14And they expressed their confidence the way Jews always did,
35:19by building a synagogue.
35:24A really big synagogue.
35:273,000 could get inside this one on the Oranienburgstrasse,
35:32the new synagogue.
35:33But it was a big synagogue for a big year in German and Jewish history,
35:381866, just three months before this gorgeous monster opened.
35:44The Prussians had defeated the Austrians
35:47to ensure that the drive for German unification
35:50was now going to be led by Prussia.
35:53And from Berlin, from what had already become a city
35:57in which the Jews had an immense part to play.
36:00So, it was natural then, that Otto von Bismarck himself,
36:04the Chancellor, who had managed to win the war
36:07through the help of money loaned from his personal banker,
36:11the Jew Gerson Bleichroeder,
36:12was actually here in attendance
36:15with all the Jewish good and the great.
36:18So those two big moments, those two histories,
36:22converged at the inauguration of the new synagogue
36:26in September 1866.
36:29The new Germany had taken a bet on the loyalty of the Jews,
36:34and the Jews had certainly thrown their lots with German power.
36:39It was a marriage that seemed to be made in heaven
36:42between modernising Jewish history
36:45and the power of the new Germany.
36:48Not a cloud on the horizon, not yet, anyway.
36:55And in France, the story was the same.
36:58Only a dyed-in-the-wool Jewish pessimist
37:01could have worried about cloudy skies here.
37:07Like their German cousins, French Jews had made a place for themselves
37:11at the heart of urban prosperity.
37:18And most successful were the Rothschilds, the Paris branch of a dynasty
37:23that had begun in the Frankfurt ghetto.
37:27I wonder how many of the commuters who come and go every day here in the Gardu-Nord
37:32know that it was a project of the French Rothschild family.
37:36We usually think of the Rothschilds as masters of international finance,
37:42supporting government debts and sometimes wars.
37:45But, especially here in France, there was a strongly practical side to their enterprises too.
37:51Baron James, the great patriarch of the French Rothschilds,
37:56thought of himself above all as a patriotic Frenchman,
37:59invested in both the emotional and the financial sense
38:03in the modernisation of classical France into an industrial superpower
38:09that could compete on equal terms with Britain and Germany.
38:13So, railways were very important to him.
38:16This station connected the other industrial pulses of Northern Europe,
38:21particularly Belgium and Germany.
38:24Now, the Rothschilds were not in this for charity.
38:27They made a packet of money out of the railways
38:30and that opened them to a certain amount of resentment and envy.
38:34But, one has to say about France,
38:37the tide of anti-Semitism hadn't yet crashed on the Rothschilds
38:42and the other great Jewish families.
38:44Really, in the middle of the 19th century,
38:47they were embedded in the project to modernise France.
38:51They were as strong as one of Baron James's iron rails.
38:57The Rothschilds could afford to ignore anti-Semitic growling.
39:02They moved into an urban palace on the Rue Monceau
39:05and filled it with great art.
39:07And where the Rothschilds went, other wealthy Jews followed.
39:13Among these Monceau families was a great Sephardi dynasty, the Commondos.
39:19They had come all the way from Istanbul,
39:22where the patriarch Abraham had created a banking fortune.
39:28They spoke Judeo-Spanish at home,
39:31but Abraham's grandsons, Nisim and Abraham Junior,
39:34had been educated in French
39:36and were drawn irresistibly to French culture.
39:40So they moved their bank and its fortune to Paris
39:43and their splendour to the Rue Monceau.
39:48There, they went completely native.
39:51Their Monceau mansion owed nothing to the rich culture
39:55of Ottoman Turkey, not a Turkish rug in sight.
40:00The Commondos had committed themselves, heart and soul,
40:03to being French.
40:05They took the Declaration of the Rights of Man at face value
40:08and assumed it included their rights too.
40:16It looks here, doesn't it, as though they have been here for generations,
40:21urban aristocrats in Paris.
40:24But in fact, the Commondos, where Johnny come lately,
40:28is they only came here in 1869.
40:30But in some sense, the family always felt they belonged to France.
40:35It's been said of them that they thought of France as their promised land
40:41and Paris as their Jerusalem.
40:43And there was a good reason for this.
40:45They saw in France a place, after all,
40:47where Jews had been emancipated for the first time in Europe,
40:52a place where Jews could prosper and thrive at the heart of high society.
40:57And once they did come here in the 1870s,
41:01they built themselves, along with all the other great Jewish families
41:05on this street in the Rue Monceau,
41:07a place of sumptuous refinement.
41:11They began to collect the furniture.
41:13They began to become great connoisseurs of fine art.
41:17And the hope was that they'd somehow settle into this world
41:21as a natural piece of the period of the Belle Epoque.
41:26And to a large extent, they did.
41:27But in some ways also, their timing was really awful.
41:32Because it was exactly at the time when this house was going up,
41:36when they were filling it with their extraordinary artistic collection,
41:40that French nationalism was changing
41:43from a broader, more cosmopolitan character
41:46to something narrower, more strident and more visceral.
41:50And to those who embodied this narrower, more tribal view
41:55of what it meant to be French,
41:57the commandos were not an admirable, magnificent instance
42:02of everything that French culture could do.
42:05They were simply Jews with a lot of money.
42:14Defeated nations are dangerous nations, prone to paranoia,
42:18and that's exactly what happened when France was defeated by Prussia
42:23in the War of 1870.
42:29The war was followed by a global stock market crash,
42:33and the financial panic triggered an outbreak of anti-Semitism.
42:40All the medieval clichés about blood-sucking Jewish moneylenders resurfaced.
42:48The witch's brew of modern anti-Semitism coagulated around the demonic figure
42:56of the Jewish banker, locked in his vaults undertaking machinations
43:02that might control the European economy now, of course.
43:07There were, in fact, Quaker bankers, Presbyterian bankers,
43:12to say nothing of the Catholic bankers to His Holiness the Pope.
43:16But somehow, as global capitalism became wired to speculative businesses
43:22like mining, and railways, and the booms and busts of the world of finance
43:28became sharper.
43:29Those who were the victims of the crashes thought that their predicament
43:33had to have come about because there were certain people
43:38in the financial world whose loyalty was to each other
43:42rather than the nations in which they happened to reside.
43:46And who, I wonder, could those certain people be except the Jews?
43:55The term anti-Semitism itself was an attempt
43:59to make Jew hatred appear rational and even scientific.
44:03Anti-Semites held that Jews were bound to each other
44:06not by their adopted countries,
44:08but what lay beneath their skin, their Jewish blood.
44:13The runaway bestseller in late 19th century France
44:17was also the most vitriolic,
44:21Edouard Drummond's La France aux Juives, Jewish France.
44:26So when it was revealed in 1894
44:29that someone had been passing military secrets to the Germans,
44:33that someone, of course, had to be a Jew.
44:4034-year-old army captain Alfred Dreyfus was a model of Jewish-French achievement.
44:46His family had been peddlers in rural Alsace.
44:52Dreyfus had risen through the ranks of the French army,
44:55which uniquely at that time allowed Jews to serve as officers.
45:01But his dreams of service and advancement were shattered
45:05when he was accused of sending military secrets to the Germans.
45:10Dreyfus was a victim of convenience.
45:13The handwriting evidence on which he was convicted was bogus,
45:17the identity of the real traitor covered up.
45:23Dreyfus's public degradation, which took place here at the military academy in Paris,
45:29brought to the surface anti-Jewish hatred in speeches and in print
45:33of the most primitive kind.
45:38His face is grey, flattened and base, showing no sign of remorse.
45:44A wreck from the ghetto.
45:52Parisians have always loved a good public spectacle.
45:57Ugly punishments as well as joyous moments.
46:00So the humiliation of the Jewish officer was bound to be a crowd pleaser.
46:06Almost 20,000 people packed themselves into this great courtyard,
46:13ready to shout,
46:15death to the Jew, traitor Judas,
46:18as the sorry figure of Dreyfus was marched in promptly at 9 o'clock in the morning.
46:27He must have felt terrible sense of turmoil.
46:31The Ecole Militaire, after all, was the place which stood most for the honour and glory of France's military past.
46:39The place which must have meant most to him in his life.
46:43And here he was, right in the dead centre, ready for this formal ceremonious degradation.
46:53At the critical point, he stood absolutely stock still.
46:59The commanding officer read out loud to him,
47:02you are no longer worthy of bearing the arms of France.
47:07And then the really torturous stuff began.
47:11His epaulets and buttons were ripped from his uniform.
47:16A sword, which had been shaved through so that there would be no comical mishaps,
47:22was broken over the knee of the officer.
47:26There was the sorry figure at the centre of it all.
47:29And then he did something, maybe for the first time in his life, that broke the rules.
47:35He was supposed to remain silent while the mob howled.
47:39But Dreyfus did not.
47:41He said, an innocent man is being degraded.
47:45An innocent man is being dishonoured.
47:47And then the most tragic things that could have come out of his mouth.
47:52Vive la France! Long live France!
47:55Vive l'armée! Long live the army!
47:58And then he stepped over the debris of what was not just his own personal career,
48:05but the debris of a noble dream.
48:07The possibility of being a patriotic citizen, Frenchman and a Jew.
48:20More was at stake than just Dreyfus' personal tragedy.
48:25Whether the Jew was a traitor or was the victim of atrocious prejudice became the touchstone for the entire fate
48:32of democratic justice.
48:34And there were other equally troubling questions.
48:40Not everybody in the crowd at the Occult Militaire that January day was begging for Dreyfus' blood.
48:47There were some among them who were acutely moved by his plight, his torment, and that was because they were
48:55themselves Jews.
48:56And one of those Jews was a young journalist from Vienna, Theodor Herzl, acutely conscious that perhaps the assimilation route
49:06of being a Jew in modern Europe was never going to work out.
49:10Something snapped in Herzl as that sword was broken over the officer's knee.
49:17Something which told Herzl there had to be another future, another way for Jews to survive in the modern world.
49:30Weeks after the degradation, Herzl left France and returned to Vienna, sunk into a deep pessimism.
49:46As a boy, young Theodor Herzl had been taught to believe the axiom of the Jewish Enlightenment, that a whole
49:53-hearted commitment to secular society would sweep away all the old prejudices.
50:01All his life, Herzl had abided by the conventions. Don't make too big a deal of your Jewishness.
50:08And Vienna will open its arms to you, embrace you, give you a career, a reputation, in Herzl's case, that
50:16of a lawyer who was also an aspiring author, a journalist, a playwright.
50:21But now, in the middle of the 1890s, Vienna was becoming a very different place.
50:27Anti-Semitism was a toxin at the centre of municipal politics.
50:32The mayor, very popular Karl Luger, was an intensely demagogic anti-Semite.
50:38Vienna regularly sent anti-Semitic deputies to the parliament.
50:43So Herzl was having a profound change of heart.
50:47He was coming to the conclusion that anti-Semitism could not be cured or defeated.
50:52You just had to get out of the way of it.
50:55And the problem for the Jews was that they were a nation without a home.
51:00So in 1895, he wrote his little book, a booklet really, called Die Judenstaat, The Jewish State.
51:08And this is what he said in it.
51:10We have sincerely tried everywhere to merge with the nations in which we live, seeking just to preserve the faith,
51:20the religion of our fathers.
51:22But this has not been allowed to us.
51:26It's been in vain that we've tried to enhance the fame of our countries in arts and sciences.
51:32It's in vain that we've tried to increase its wealth by commerce and trade.
51:37We are still in the place where we've lived for centuries, decried as aliens.
51:42And often by people who were not even here when the size of our fathers had been heard for centuries.
51:51Now, thus was born Zionism.
51:55Now, Zionism has become a heavily loaded term.
51:58For some people even a tragically loaded term, but not for me.
52:01I'm a Zionist.
52:03I'm quite unapologetic about it.
52:05Because it comes down to this.
52:07Was Herzl, who had a sense of a catastrophic event just around the corner, telling the truth?
52:15Or wasn't he about whether it was possible still to live the Enlightenment dream here in the German world?
52:22Of course he was.
52:24With that knowledge, with that sense of the Jews having never had the power of their own national home,
52:32how could you not be a Zionist?
52:44But not everyone was ready to give up on the Enlightenment dream.
52:48Many still believed that anti-Semitism belonged to a rotten, decadent past, not to the future.
52:55And in the new, fearless modern world that was being created in music, art and architecture,
53:01Jews would march side by side with their brothers and sisters in the Cultural Revolution.
53:10One of the most fearless modernists was the Jewish-born Austrian composer and painter Arnold Schoenberg,
53:18who in the early 20th century changed the very nature of music.
53:24Working in Vienna and later Berlin, he abandoned tonality,
53:28the system of notes that had sustained Western music for 500 years.
53:37Schoenberg counted many non-Jewish thinkers and artists among his friends.
53:42Among them, Vasily Kandinsky, who was also ripping up the rulebook with his abstract art.
53:48Like Felix Mendelssohn, Schoenberg had converted Christianity,
53:53hoping it would immunize him from the growing virus of anti-Semitism in Germany.
54:00It didn't.
54:03Even the love between modernist comrades could be tainted.
54:07In 1923, Schoenberg discovered that Kandinsky had been sounding off about the so-called Jewish problem.
54:21Kandinsky hastened to assure Schoenberg he didn't mean him, goodness no.
54:26Schoenberg would be an exception, of course, to the Jewish question.
54:30And Schoenberg said, I do not want to be an exception,
54:34and wrote a long, impassioned letter to Kandinsky in which he said this.
54:40The events of the past year have forced on me a lesson,
54:45and it's one I will never forget.
54:47What was that lesson?
54:49Well, it was that I am no German.
54:53I am no European.
54:55Yes, perhaps I am a man.
54:58Perhaps I am not even a man.
55:01Since Europeans seem to prefer the worst of their race to me.
55:06I am a Jew.
55:14When the Nazis came to power ten years later, they agreed with him,
55:19forcing him out of his job at the Berlin Music Academy.
55:24Germany was now over for Arnold Schoenberg.
55:28He left for America via Paris.
55:32And there he stepped towards another light.
55:39This story of a great leap of faith began in a synagogue
55:44when a Jew was cast out by his own people.
55:48It ends in another synagogue rather differently.
55:55On the 24th of July, 1933, Arnold Schoenberg stood here in the synagogue on the Rue Copernic in Paris,
56:04seeking formal readmission to the community of Jews and Judaism.
56:10The date could hardly be more significant for more than a decade.
56:15He had been predicting that if Hitler and the Nazis ever came to power,
56:20it would not just be the great experiment in cultural modernism,
56:24which had begun perhaps since Spinoza and Moses Mendelssohn,
56:28which would be a casualty,
56:30but the entirety of Jews that would be engulfed in something utterly catastrophic.
56:35He knew that what had begun with words would end with terrifying violence.
56:42He'd long been devoted to themes Jewish.
56:46He was in the middle of what was an unfinished opera,
56:48Moses and Aaron.
56:50And now he stood there absolutely committed to this identity.
56:55He'd become an ardent Zionist.
56:58And above all, he wanted, right from this minute,
57:01to alert the world to the extermination which he thought was about to happen.
57:08Indeed, of course, he was so prescient.
57:10That great dream of being Jewish and a cultural adventurer
57:15was about to disappear into the smoke of the crematoria.
57:29Was it all a delusion then, right from the start?
57:34I don't know.
57:35I like to think I would have been optimistic with Moses Mendelssohn
57:40and realistic with Theodore Herzl.
57:44I like to think that the humanity of the Enlightenment idea
57:49was not entirely cancelled out by the inhumanity of its incineration.
57:55To declare anything else is to declare victory for the murderers.
58:03I do know I grieve endlessly for those here in Berlin and all over Europe
58:11who innocently imagined they could be Jews and citizens of their own countries
58:16and who, to the end, could not imagine the evil
58:20that would turn their books and their bodies into ash.
58:29ORCHESTRAL MUSIC PLAYS
58:29ORCHESTRAL MUSIC PLAYS
58:29ORCHESTRAL MUSIC bailICS
58:31ORCHESTRAL MUSIC晃
58:31ORCHESTRAL MUSIC PLAYS
58:33ORCHESTRAL MUSIC PLAYS
58:43ORCHESTRAL MUSIC PLAYS
58:58ORCHESTRAL MUSIC zoomed out by Yout Barnes & Process changing system of core