- 7 weeks ago
On today’s episode, Editor in Chief Sarah Wheeler talks with Bill Killmer, Senior Vice President for Legislative and Political Affairs at the Mortgage Bankers Association, about how the midterm elections could affect the mortgage industry and housing.
Related to this episode:
Mortgage Banking Summit: FHFA’s unified LLPA grid for FICO, VantageScore raises investor concerns
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/fhfa-unified-llpa-grid-fico-vantagescore/
HousingWire | YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire
Want more from Sarah? Don’t forget to subscribe!
The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look behind the scenes of the top mortgage and real estate.
Related to this episode:
Mortgage Banking Summit: FHFA’s unified LLPA grid for FICO, VantageScore raises investor concerns
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/fhfa-unified-llpa-grid-fico-vantagescore/
HousingWire | YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire
Want more from Sarah? Don’t forget to subscribe!
The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look behind the scenes of the top mortgage and real estate.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:10welcome everyone my guest today is bill kilmer he's the chief lobbyist at the mortgage bankers
00:15association to talk about what might we see in the midterm elections and how that could affect
00:20housing bill thank you so much for being here thank you sir i appreciate the invitation we just
00:26got off stage a little while ago at the mortgage banking summit here in dallas and great discussion
00:32there that i wanted to continue here because this is a big one so let's start at the top and
00:38talk
00:38about what do the polls show um do we think there's going to be a big change in the midterms
00:43there
00:43usually is some change um that two-year political cycle right what what are you guys seeing uh well
00:50you know sarah you and i were talking earlier that historically any president republican or democrat
00:55typically in the midterm election cycle has some pressure based on you know that uh administration
01:02being held accountable particularly if their party also is in control of the congress and that's the
01:08situation for republicans but even since you and i were first talking a couple weeks ago about this
01:14event uh things have really been moving in the democrats direction and the polling reflects that i
01:20think there's so much more polling that a lot of it's erratic but the trusted polling sources are
01:28are really showing that democrats have got a tailwind particularly in the senate um the house the
01:35conventional wisdom has been that you know because of the historical precedent and uh just the way that
01:41redistricting and and and and and some of the other factors uh have played out that democrats have a
01:48very serious shot to retake the majority from republicans the question is how large will the margin of
01:54majority be if they in fact do get that kind of mini wave to help them do that and um
02:01you know
02:03a month ago i would have said there are 24 25 really competitive house seats now it's probably more
02:09like 35 to 40 and um i i do think it's a question of what margin of majority is if
02:17it's 10 or less
02:18that's that's not a real large working majority we've seen how that's impacted republicans and
02:22speaker johnson and his leadership team and how tough it is for them to corral votes i think the same
02:27thing would be true for democrats but uh i if you asked me today i'd say republicans are looking at
02:37holding the majority but maybe just with a 50 50 uh ratio and that would mean democrats had netted
02:44three seats uh it's entirely possible that they could have a clear majority and actually be in
02:49control but if it's 50 50 the vice president is the president of the senate would break ties and we've
02:54been through that as a country several times here recently um but that that would have major implications
03:01for um the administration in terms of oversight and that will bleed not only from the white house
03:08through you know uh national security and the pentagon and those agencies that are affected
03:13but certainly into the housing space as well so um if we take a concert not conservative but maybe a
03:19middle of the road view that you know one house we're gonna is gonna change as per normal what does
03:25that look like versus if there's a you know a blue wave if you if you will both houses yeah
03:31and i i'm kind
03:32of laughingly referring to a way a blue wave would mean a majority of more than 10 seats and
03:39definitely having the senate flip to go uh democratic it would be more like purple rain if only one um
03:46you know uh chamber of congress flipped but real more consequential there there will be more oversight if
03:54that's true just in the house but doubly so and more intensely if the if the senate is also democratic
04:00there
04:00would be coordination between the two chambers and the leaders of the various
04:03committees and that would be true for housing regulators just like it would for you know officials
04:08across the entire trump administration so lots of hearing invitations document requests
04:16subpoenas probably to compel people to testify um but you know that would be true for
04:23hud officials for fhfa i think usda va um cfpb all the prudential banking regulators
04:30and then obviously there'll be a different kind of scrutiny on on the president and his family
04:35um and then that'll be the real trick is you know what kind of policy agenda are democrats going to
04:40want to pursue and how much time are they going to allot to that oversight i personally think that
04:47if congress flips one or both chambers that the administration two more years and they're going
04:54to kind of double down to try to finish regulatory modernization and some of the agenda that
04:59they've set forward because they'll be the only republican game in town in terms of pursuing that
05:04policy direction that's really interesting um you know we've talked on this podcast and and you and
05:11i talked earlier like a two-year political cycle is so tough to get stuff done yeah and then i
05:16think
05:16about you know if you're in this industry if you're in mortgage or real estate or but particularly let's
05:21say mortgage because um that's where so much the regulation is and you were like you know i i started
05:26covering mortgage when it was under obama so if you think about okay obama and then and then you
05:32went to trump and then you went to biden and now you're back at trump and it's like it can
05:35feel like
05:36whiplash as far as like when it comes to regulatory stuff but maybe especially this time because there
05:41was such a um a real uh determined dismantling of some of those regulations it's what uh president
05:48trump ran on won on um so i can you be a little bit more specific about what you think
05:53that looks
05:53like sure i mean let's start with the cfpb i think there was a concerted effort particularly with respect
05:59to enforcement activity um to reduce personnel no secret that was all very public and it kind of
06:06flowed out of the doge efforts to reduce the size of government staffing i think what um policy teams
06:15in the white house and throughout omb and and and and the trump administration realized is if you want
06:20to directionally change a regulatory attitude of an agency you need rule writers to actually help you
06:28do that and accomplish that so i'm a big believer that personnel is policy and that'll be a really
06:34important function of the senate it'll be very different in terms of the scheduling of trump nominees
06:41that would need to fill vacancies if democrats are in control of the senate if republicans maintain
06:46control then their chief function may well be personnel management to like we see every time there's
06:54you get to the two-year point with any administration people leaving and then vacancies that need to
06:59be filled and we see that at the cfpb brian johnson who was a deputy director is now back as
07:04the nominee
07:05from the administration to be the director of the cfpb i think he'll get uh confirmed before uh the end
07:13of the year after uh whatever the outcome of the midterms with republicans still in control to january
07:18when the senate returns in in november the same thing's true at hud uh fha commissioner that job
07:26the nominee to fill the current vacancy at hud is matt jones and um he literally today while we're
07:34sitting here had uh a nominations hearing in the senate banking committee that went fairly smoothly
07:40i think aided by the fact that senators were ready to get out of town after after their final floor
07:44votes last night uh but he's very able um grew up in the industry his dad had a mortgage company
07:50as an
07:51imb he's been a licensed loan officer so he knows this stuff cold he's a former colleague of ours at
07:57nba
07:58and i think um a subject matter expert but somebody's got the right attitude about you know what he'll do
08:04at fha in the last two years so there'll be opportunities to you know try to help consumers
08:08maybe with the mortgage insurance premium reduction that's not where republicans at hud start they always
08:15want to manage the safety and soundness of the mmif the single family fund but that capital ratio has
08:21been high so there are ways to reasonably and responsibly think about reducing premiums and he'll
08:27work on a lot of servicing and loss mitigation rules as well with with his team there so those are
08:33some examples of of things that i think will be uh focused on i think the the push to try
08:39to reduce
08:39regulatory frictions and and help the private sector writ large will will you know creep into housing too
08:46and again like i said a minute ago i think that the administration will want to try to accomplish as
08:52much as they can in a durable way um you know so that it could survive legal challenges if it's
08:58close to the edge you know in terms of being an aggressive posture for some of the change um
09:05because they won't have a congress to work with uh and you know you talked about starting to cover
09:10mortgage during the obama administration that that's a real example of the way our system has
09:15kind of worked he had democratic control for a couple of years and you know dodd frank was enacted
09:21with him as president in 2010 and then it was implemented by his administration and then you
09:27saw partisan shifts back and forth several times so it's only when you get a political party aligned
09:33with the congress and the executive branch that you see these really big swings that are taken like
09:38the tax bills or health care reform or dodd frank things of that so so if you have divided government
09:44then it makes it much tougher to you know get those kinds of things even out on the playing field
09:50much
09:50less you know enacted and signed into law i think one of the things that um hopefully listeners of
09:56this podcast know um who's who controls what controls uh mortgage rates but one of the big questions has
10:02got to be for people in our industry and housing at large is like does one of these outcomes one
10:07of
10:07these scenarios lead to lower mortgage rates more than the other and if so which one you know i think
10:13really in control of congress whether it's a democrat or republican majority in charge
10:21um there could be policy shifts there could be directionally democrats wanting
10:26um to take housing policy in in a direction particularly in terms of regulatory enforcement
10:33um they'd have a tough time getting that past the president's desk i think he'll be exercising a veto pen
10:40a lot more aggressively so then you have to have durable bipartisan consensus you know over 60
10:47senators on a bipartisan basis in particular but a pretty substantial bipartisan majority you know
10:53housing's kind of having a moment and just like with the road to housing bill when those bills got
10:58altered several times when they made it to the floor out of committee they would get close to 400
11:04votes in the house and almost 90 votes in the senate on a couple of different occasions and that was
11:08true
11:09in the final instance and you know the the version of the proposal that became law in july so i
11:16i think
11:16there will be bipartisan opportunities but building that bipartisan consensus will be tougher so i i still
11:25think you know the traditional levers at the fed and the treasury would be kind of the traditional way to
11:33think about what could impact rates but we're in a really in you as people that are listening to this
11:38podcast you know should recognize like you were saying we're in an unusual market situation where
11:44the data is not seeming to make the same difference in terms of the direction of rates now if the
11:49conflict
11:49in the middle east you know um came to an end then maybe that impacts you know oil and gas
11:56prices and diesel
11:57and and uh you know you see some deep deflationary effects and that could have a positive impact on the
12:03on the 10-year
12:04treasury and on mortgage rates but um probably the most consequential thing that congress could do would
12:10be focus on fiscal policy and the debt and the deficit because marsh you know the capital markets
12:15are are not buying the traditional levers as a means of trying to direct uh interest rates and you know
12:24this president talks more about mortgage rates and interest rates than just about any of his predecessors
12:29given his real estate background that was true in the first term as well and you know jawboning hasn't
12:35worked so uh i think some serious acknowledgement by the markets that congress was trying to reform
12:42entitlement programs to save money or to to really kind of directionally shift the debt and the deficit
12:48might be the most consequential thing that congress could do you know to impact rates i think those are
12:53great comments because it is that larger picture and we've seen in this administration the the limits
12:59of what a president can do to try to lower rates um and and some of the things and we're
13:04seeing now
13:05even the limits to what a fed chairman can do to try to impact rates as kevin warch is dealing
13:10with a
13:10new set of realities it's true it has been fascinating for fed watchers um a little less fascinating when
13:16you're out the you know boots on the ground trying to make all this work and you're and you're trying
13:20to
13:20get people to the closing table at seven and a quarter right okay so a couple of things that um
13:27i
13:27know were priorities for you guys this year first of all you know it i want to say congratulations on
13:33the road to housing act it's been a couple months but that was such a monumental thing to accomplish
13:38and it took multiple years and so many stakeholders um so i think that's first of all that's great and
13:46and don't want to go too too far past that when it comes to things like um llpas for instance
13:52uh
13:52credit score models things like this where are where is the nba right now what do you think you
13:58know what is a priority what do you think you can accomplish there are essentially three things that
14:02we've been pressing the administration to try to do that could uh you know reduce the amount of
14:08money that a consumer would have to be laying forward at the at the closing table um one of those
14:15is to try to reduce the cost of credit score reporting that is passed along to the consumer
14:21from lenders by ending the tri-merge requirement and looking again at either a buy merge or maybe
14:26a single score with the appropriate guardrails in place because you know we want safety and soundness
14:32and underwriting um you know relative to the conventional market and the gse's that that could
14:37save hundreds hundreds of dollars uh for closing transaction uh i mentioned a minute ago a possible
14:44reduction to the mortgage insurance premium for fha loans that's something the administration could do
14:49still responsibly do that and keep the capital ratio of the single family insurance fund in a safe place
14:57and save borrowers you know hundreds to thousand dollars you know at the closing table and and then
15:04loan level price adjustments like you're mentioning that grid for the gse's there could be substantial
15:09savings there director pulte has taken some action just over the last couple of days you know relative
15:14to vantage score and integrating the grid with fico uh for the use of both those scores uh it's you
15:21know
15:21the jury's out on exactly how how much of a savings that's going um to mean but a lot of
15:28our lenders
15:28and and you know prominent members are estimating a substantial reduction in cost potentially for
15:33consumers um i think there will be an uptick in the use of vantage you know particularly at this
15:39at the jump here with the with the change um but we'll have to see what the reaction is over
15:44time and
15:44and investor reaction the mbs investor and their comfort level with vantage versus classic fico it
15:52probably accelerates fico to get their tinty the score out more quickly but um our lenders immediate
15:59reaction was hey we need some time to assimilate what this means and and so it may take some time
16:04for some of those savings for consumers to be realized as the guardrails are set in place for
16:09you know how to approach those transactions uh just this week we got uad 3.6 we got a waiver
16:16for that
16:16um if uh for the lenders that weren't ready i i was kind of surprised that maybe i shouldn't have
16:21been i don't know the inner workings but i was like oh okay um well it's big and again that's
16:25something that had been in the works for a while and it just goes to show that operationalizing
16:30these things in the complex mortgage ecosystem you think you've had enough time for people to get
16:35ready and and you know uh the market just wasn't so it's great that there's now this ability to get
16:41an exception for that and have a little bit more time to work through that but we're we're you know
16:45very pleased and have been lobbying pretty heavily to see that kind of change be put in place so
16:49we're encouraged by that um and i again i just keep going back to the notion that housings
16:57you know in a moment and even if the house flips and maxine waters is the chair of the house
17:02financial
17:02services committee she and french hill worked really well on this road to housing project and it really
17:09became more of an arm wrestling between the house and the senate as two institutions and the legislation
17:14was better as a product because of that back and forth instead of just knuckling under to what the
17:19senate could get you know a real a big majority vote uh for and and and i've done this now
17:25for a
17:26while so i'm kind of old school but i think that that's an appropriate way to to do a serious
17:31legislative effort where you can get bipartisan consensus because it's more durable but to take
17:36your time to make sure that you get it closer to right um so i think we accept your congratulations
17:42i think it was a consequential package but almost directionally showed hey congress can work together
17:47on something where they're trying to be responsive to a need because there there is a crisis in so
17:53many of the housing markets around the country and this was an attempt to try to influence um
17:58affordability and in uh remove some of the impediments to increased housing supply i think
18:05if there is a road 2.0 attempt whatever the outcomes in the midterms it will focus more on the
18:11nuts and bolts of housing finance than perhaps this original road uh proposal did so we look forward to
18:18that opportunity um and you know i think responding to the way that the political continuum shifts if
18:29democrats are in control they're going to put more emphasis on the mission side of the you know
18:34improving and the utilization of housing programs so probably some deeper subsidy down payment
18:38um you know proposals they're going to uh emerge i think they'll look at trying to use the tax code
18:45how much of that they can get across the veto pen you know we'll have we'll have to see whether
18:49they
18:49can build that kind of consensus but the fortunate thing for us is it you know i heard one of
18:55the other
18:55panelists say this today at the at the summit event it really matters less who is in charge but that
19:01we're ready to work with both sides because we can usually find something to agree upon with the majority
19:05on housing when it comes to you know if we do see a big change and you think about regulation
19:11how soon could something like that happen or or
19:20so assuming there is a you know a pretty big change let's say at least one house you know when
19:24it comes to regulation specifically mortgage uh industry regulation how quickly could something
19:30like that change from where we are now well i mean there there is the you know the pause that
19:37comes
19:37when a new director a new regulatory agency head is put in place i'll just go back to like the
19:42cfpb and
19:43fha examples that i was using earlier i mean for matt jones at fha fha when he's confirmed he'll be
19:51working with a lot of the team that he's already working with now and so um he'll probably be trying
19:56to
19:56continue the direction of a lot of the work that was already ongoing at hud i think because of what
20:01we talked about with cfpb the fact that there was a real reduction in workforce the ramping up will
20:07take a little bit longer uh brian johnson would be quicker to be able to step in given his history
20:13of
20:14working at the cfpb but he'll have to prioritize what he wants whatever size team he ends up with
20:20you know to to focus on and prioritize and so you know there's a there is a limit as you
20:26were saying
20:27a minute ago to what you can accomplish in two years even on the administrative side where the
20:33executive branch you know has to work through the the uh the rulemaking process with the guardrails in
20:38place there and get things passed l and b um which has really solidified its role as a gatekeeper in
20:45this administration even for a lot of the independent agencies you know their their their work has to go
20:50through the omb clearance process um but i again i believe that they will make a concerted effort to
20:56kind of double down and get as much done as they possibly can in the last two years and so
21:01we'll be
21:01reacting uh you know no matter what i appreciate you coming on and and taking on this topic because
21:07we are just a few weeks away from knowing no one really knows what's going to happen we've got some
21:12polling you even said you know the polling seems to be going one way but it's really going to matter
21:17what that majority if there's a majority what that is what what can even be accomplished and so um i
21:24appreciate you coming on walking us through it we will talk again soon when we know more about what
21:28we're talking about look forward to it thanks sarah thank you bill
21:32you
21:32you
21:32you
21:32you
21:40you