Skip to playerSkip to main content
'DON'T LOOK AT THE DEFENSE'

House prosecutor Atty. Mae Divinagracia and Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero reminded Davao City accountant Vengeline Bahan not to look toward the defense team while answering questions during cross-examination on Tuesday, Nov. 10.

Divinagracia raised the concern after noticing Bahan looking at the defense twice while being questioned about her involvement in an accounting firm while also working as a job-order employee of the Davao City government. Escudero backed the prosecution, saying he had noticed the same behavior. (Video courtesy of the Senate of the Philippines)

Subscribe to the Manila Bulletin Online channel! -
https://www.youtube.com/TheManilaBulletin

Visit our website at http://mb.com.ph
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/manilabulletin
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/manila_bulletin
Instagram: https://instagram.com/manilabulletin
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@manilabulletin

#VPSaraOnTrial
#ManilaBulletinOnline
#ManilaBulletin
#LatestNews

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Bahagi po ba kayo ng isang accounting firm na nirehistro noong 2003?
00:08Ang pagkaalala ko po, your owner, yung first job ko po dito sa siyudadano accounting firm po.
00:17First job mo?
00:18After graduation po.
00:20So empleyado ka, pero dito nakalagay may capital ka.
00:25Parte ka ng accounting firm?
00:29Empreyado ka o parte ka ng accounting firm?
00:31Is this a corporation, attorney me?
00:33It's a partnership, a general professional partnership.
00:39Iba po ang may-ari sa empleyado, ha?
00:41Alam niyo naman, as an accountant, you should know that.
00:44So were you part of this accounting firm?
00:50May seven.
00:57Your Honor, may we request the witness not to look at the defense council, Your Honor?
01:03Um, yes, kindly respond, attorney Ms. Evan.
01:14Your Honor, we're reiterating a request for a copy of the-
01:19We profusely apologize, Your Honor.
01:21Upon checking, Your Honor, we were only able to reproduce one copy.
01:25Do we-
01:26Because we learned of this information.
01:29We would have to insist on a request, Your Honor,
01:32so that we may be able to examine the document
01:36and to meet it intelligently if need be, Your Honor.
01:39We are already having it photocopied, Your Honor.
01:43Going back to you, Ms. Evan, please answer.
01:48Yes, Your Honor.
01:50Okay.
01:50You're part of that firm, that accounting firm,
01:54registered in 2003.
01:56You're a witness, attorney me.
01:58So madaling sabi, Ms. Bahan,
02:02habang ikaw ay humahawak ng job order position sa city of Davao,
02:08ikaw rin ay nag-participate na,
02:11nagpa-participate din sa isang general professional partnership bilang partner.
02:16Tama po ba?
02:17Ang job order po is to employer-employee relationship.
02:20Hindi po yan ang tanong ko, Ms. Bahan.
02:22Ang tanong ko lang po,
02:23habang job order po kayo sa city of Davao,
02:26kayo rin po ay registered bilang partner
02:29ng Ampil,
02:32Elises, Ciudadano, and Co. CPAs.
02:34Tama po ba?
02:35Your Honor, the witness already answered, Your Honor.
02:37That is the answer of the witness, Your Honor.
02:40It was not responsive.
02:41She was trying to justify that there's nothing illegal.
02:44So the answer is yes.
02:45Only that there's nothing illegal.
02:47Right, Ms. Bahan?
02:49Yes po, Your Honor.
02:51At papatotohanan nyo rin po
02:52na itong accounting firm na to,
02:55noong 2015 lamang ay nag-amend
02:58ng Articles of Partnership.
03:00Tama po ba?
03:01Just to refresh your memory also,
03:03we will be confronting you
03:04with a copy
03:06of the said amendment
03:08of Articles of Partnership.
03:10May we ask for a copy, Your Honor?
03:15So ordered.
03:17So ordered.
03:35Your Honor, may we request, Your Honor,
03:38again,
03:39that the witness be reminded
03:41not to be looking
03:42at the defense counsels, Your Honor.
03:45Witness is so instructed.
03:46No one has to look at the documents.
03:48The witness is so instructed.
03:50The chair also noticed that.
03:53Kindly avoid that, Ms. Bahan.
03:55Just look at the documents
03:58being shown to you.

Recommended