Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 months ago
America was not invited to the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation summit in Bishkek. So why is a top Trump envoy in the same city, meeting Central Asian leaders as Narendra Modi, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping gather for the SCO? On this episode of Statecraft with Geeta Mohan, we examine Sergio Gor’s striking presence around the SCO summit and the growing American push into Central Asia.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:08can america influence a block it does not belong to while bringing russia back into a room it was
00:14never fully pushed out of today two stories about washington finding new ways to shape a changing
00:20global order in bishkek america stayed outside the seo but used the world nomad games to meet
00:27central asian leaders and push its c5 plus one agenda but can washington compete with the
00:33influence of beijing and moscow without forcing these states to choose sides then from central
00:39asia to the g20 trump is reopening a high-level channel with russia angering europe and raising
00:46a bigger question if washington is willing to talk to moscow again can europe afford to stay out of
00:51the room one story is about america building influence from the sidelines the other is
00:57about russia walking back into the room they were always a part of hello and welcome you're
01:02watching statecraft with me gita mohan a handshake with xi jinping a warning aimed squarely at pakistan
01:08and a telling moment between shabazz sharif and vladimir potin the seo summit in bishkek has
01:15delivered a series of striking diplomatic visuals and optics but prime minister narendra modi's message
01:20on terrorism was unmistakable with both xi jinping and shabazz sharif in the room modi declared that there
01:26can be no double standards in the fight against terrorism he called for the entire ecosystem of
01:31terrorism to be dismantled including its financing and then came the sharper message prime minister
01:38modi said countries that have made terrorism a state policy and provided its refuge and support
01:43must be told one thing terrorism cannot be anyone's strategic asset a clear signal to pakistan and an
01:51uncomfortable message for china given beijing's long-standing strategic backing of islamabad
01:56yet the summit also showed another side of india china ties modi and she exchanged a handshake as
02:02they entered the meeting hall the interaction was brief but significant after the 2020 galwan clash
02:09india and china have gradually worked to stabilize ties but new delhi's engagement with beijing has not
02:15meant ignoring china's strategic partnership with pakistan during operation sindoor china was accused
02:20of providing pakistan intelligence and technical support and that makes modi's message at the seo
02:26even more significant security connectivity and economic cooperation may unite the bloc but for india
02:33terrorism remains the red line and then came the moment that caught everyone's eye pakistan being
02:40pakistan resorted to petty social media antics during seo summit prime minister narendra modi was
02:46cropped out of the seo family photograph along with iranian president possession shared by prime minister
02:54of pakistan shabazz sharif the crop photo tactfully placed shabazz sharif in the middle moments later after
03:01juvenile move faced backlash the pakistani prime minister's account shared another photo at this time
03:08it was the family photo which included prime minister modi and president prasash kyan shabazz
03:14sharif was also seen rushing to meet and talk to vladimir putin after the seo family photograph
03:19the internet as usual has started a meme fest the brief exchange has sparked attention online with
03:25the clip from prompting a playful question wait for me
03:38america is not a part of the seo nor was it invited but from the looks of it america showed
03:44up at the
03:44venue anyway bishkek has two big shows one seo summit and one carefully timed american appearance
03:52sergio gore washington's special envoy for south and central asia and ambassador to india arrived to
03:59support american athletes at the world nomad games the games opened as seo leaders narendra modi
04:06vladimir putin and xi jinping gathered in the same city god did not walk into an seo meeting demand a
04:12chair and ask who ordered the snacks instead he met kyrgyz president sadir zaparov tajik president
04:19imamali rahman and uzbek president shavkat mirzi yoyev while pushing washington's c5 plus one agenda
04:28so was this just sports diplomacy or did america find a clever way to enter the seo spotlight without
04:34actually entering the seo why make this move now because timing matters the seo council of heads of
04:42state and seo plus meetings took place in bishkek on 31st of august and 1st of september while the nomad
04:48games opened on the 31st of august that gave washington something useful a high profile event
04:54in the same city on the same days with the same regional leaders around the us is not an seo
05:01member or formal observer so gore could not join the club but he could meet the club's members and
05:07that is exactly what happened was this a diplomatic disruption yes but in a controlled way gore did not
05:15crash the seo room he used the nomad games as a parallel diplomatic platform the message was
05:21simple washington may not have a seat inside the seo but it can still reach the capitals around the
05:26table that matters because the summit gave beijing and moscow a huge stage gore created a separate
05:33american stage right beside it but what did washington actually put on the table the talks focused on
05:40political dialogue trade investment and the c5 plus one format with kirghuz president zapirov gore
05:48discussed stronger political ties and expanded trade economic and investment cooperation along
05:53with prospects for a second c5 plus one leaders summit in 2027 with tajik president rahman discussions
06:02included bilateral cooperation regional security and c5 plus one engagement while tajikistan showed interest
06:09in u.s capital for energy industry and mining with uzbek president mirzi yoev the agenda covered energy
06:16transport critical minerals digital technologies ai and agriculture so can washington outbid beijing
06:24in moscow the information here points to competition not replacement the u.s offer is built around trade
06:31investment technology critical minerals energy transport and digital cooperation china and russia remain
06:39major regional reference points but washington is putting its own package on the table the question
06:45is whether that package can become more than diplomatic courtship for now washington is testing the option
06:51it wants central asian states to see another door open even if that door does not replace the ones leading
06:58to moscow or beijing and who benefits most from this engagement or arrangement central asian states do
07:05why because they can talk to washington while also sitting inside the seo framework kirghistan tajikistan
07:12and uzbekistan do not need to pick one side in this particular encounter gore's meetings give them
07:18another channel another set of offers and another source of diplomatic attention this is the logic behind the
07:24multi-vector balancing act keep several relationships alive and improve your bargaining position but is
07:31there a limit of course too much visible competition between washington moscow and beijing could create
07:37diplomatic blowback the trick is to collect options without looking like you have chosen a camp that
07:44makes kirghistan's role especially important bishkek hosted both events turning its capital into a crowded
07:50diplomatic crossroads the nomad games gave the american delegation a natural reason to be there
07:56the sporting and cultural event also created a politically neutral setting for meetings that might
08:01otherwise have looked like a direct challenge to the seo the horses wrestling and traditional games
08:08provided the perfect diplomatic camouflage gore could support american athletes and talk geopolitics in the
08:15same trip then there is gore's second hat he's not only the u.s special envoy for south and central
08:22asia
08:22he's also us's ambassador to india why does that matter because india was in bishkek for the seo summit
08:31alongside china and russia gore's presence therefore sits across two connected regional tracks on one side he
08:38can push the c5 plus one relationship with central asia on the other his role connects that diplomacy to
08:46new delhi going back to your question on my special envoy role when the president appointed me to be
08:51ambassador here in special envoy one of the things he said is for too long this part of the world
08:55has not
08:55gotten that tension it deserves from the united states and so i am able to travel to those countries
09:01countries and i'm able to add i don't subtract we have embassies at those places but i mean i'm able
09:06to add on and raise whatever it is that um that might be happening directly to the president and to
09:13the white house and we've done some incredible deals done kazakhstan uzbekistan each one of them
09:17has have signed deals over 25 billion each with the united states in the last few months those are real
09:24results that benefit both sides um the president wants to hear about those things directly and i'm able to
09:29elevate that directly to him does that mean washington and india can build a coordinated counter narrative
09:36what it does show is an awkward but useful overlap india shares the seo stage with beijing and moscow
09:43while washington's envoy works the diplomatic sidelines with central asian leaders what about the
09:49practical stakes critical minerals energy transport digital technologies and ai all appeared in the
09:56discussions especially with uzbekistan tajikistan raised u.s capital for energy industry and mining
10:03that gives the american outreach a clear economic edge at the same time c5 plus one provides washington
10:10with a separate regional format minerals are one hook investment trade technology and transport
10:17are others could this also become a sanctions play the information provided does not establish that
10:23sanctions enforcement drove gore's bishkek visit so that claim would go too far what the evidence does
10:30show is a push for stronger u.s central asia ties across economic and strategic sectors that is enough
10:37to explain the visit without adding a secret mission that the available facts do not support now zoom out
10:45does gore's appearance signal a new american habit of hovering around non-western summits in this case the answer
10:52is clear washington did not boycott the seo atmosphere and it did not try to join the seo either
10:58it created a parallel track the nomad games gave the cover the c5 plus one gave the structure and
11:06bilateral meetings gave the access so did sergio gore gatecrash the seo literally no strategically he
11:14came close to the idea he entered the same diplomatic space without entering the institution met three
11:19central asian presidents promoted the c5 plus one agenda and put american trade investment minerals
11:27energy transport ai and technology interests into the conversation beijing and moscow still had the seo
11:35summit but washington made sure it did not disappear from the picture in bishkek america did not get an seo
11:42seat it got something else a front row view a parallel microphone and a reminder that central
11:49asia has more than one diplomatic door the iran war is heating up again president donald trump is
11:55threatening a fresh response after a month-long lull iran had fired missiles at a u.s base in jordan
12:01the attack came after u.s forces struck iranian military assets that washington says were preparing
12:07to lay mines in the strait of hormones tehran says the american strikes killed two people and wounded
12:13several others now trump is vowing retaliation but this is no longer just a u.s iran confrontation
12:19iran had also launched missiles towards the uae overnight the uae says it intercepted an iranian drone
12:26over its waters no damage was reported meanwhile the strait of hormuz remains closed iran is holding one
12:33the world's most critical energy choke points hostage because of what america is doing beyond
12:40the gulf of oman and the u.s is maintaining a naval counter blockade while threatening crippling
12:45sanctions six months into the war neither side appears ready to back down but trump faces another
12:52battle at home his approval rating has crashed to just 33 percent the lowest of his political career
12:59a reuters ipsos poll shows americans increasingly unhappy with his handling of the iran war and the
13:05economy it is trump's third consecutive poll at 33 and the timing couldn't be worse the november
13:12third midterm elections are approaching republicans are defending razor-thin majorities in congress
13:17so trump now faces a dangerous double pressure escalate abroad or pay the political price at home
13:24and with iran striking back the question is no longer whether trump will respond it is how far
13:30he's willing to go so donald trump is bringing russia back into the room not the g7 not the g8
13:38the g20
13:39that russia is a part of a member of russian finance minister anton siluanov has appeared in person
13:46at u.s hosted g20 finance talks in north carolina meeting treasury secretary scott besant and europe
13:54is furious because this is not just about one russian minister it is about whether washington
13:59is beginning to treat moscow as a country that must be engaged again and if america is changing its russia
14:07policy europe faces a very uncomfortable question can it afford to keep treating russia as a diplomatic
14:13outcast silvanov's appearance is significant it is his first in-person g20 finance meeting since 2022
14:23he met besant on the sidelines washington says the talks included trump's ukraine peace plan
14:28moscow says they discussed financial cooperation and interaction within the g20 and then came the
14:35diplomatic shock european officials refused to join siluanov for the traditional g20 family photo
14:43germany called the decision a troubling signal poland said it did not trust moscow europe's message was clear
14:49talking to russia may be necessary normalizing russia is another matter but here is where history becomes
14:56important russia once sat inside another powerful western group the g7 expanded into the g8 when russia
15:04joined the format in the late 1990s then came 2014 russia annexed crimea its participation in the g8 was
15:12suspended the group returned to becoming the g7 that episode created a powerful precedent russia could be
15:21isolated from an elite western forum but the g20 is fundamentally different russia is not a guest at the
15:28g20 russia is a member it is one of the 19 countries alongside the european union and african union and
15:36that
15:37changes the game washington cannot simply recreate the 2014 g8 formula and declare russia out of the g20
15:45the g20 is a broad economic forum bringing together major economies russia has remained part of that
15:51framework despite the war moscow has not been expelled from the g20 it cannot be and that is why
15:58siluanov's return matters america did not have to invent a new diplomatic channel it already had one the g20
16:07trump has chosen to use it trump administration argues that talking to russia is necessary if washington
16:13wants to end the war trump defended the invitation by saying he likes getting along with everybody
16:19but there is an important caveat talking to moscow does not mean washington has lifted sanctions
16:25it does not mean russia has been rewarded besant reportedly made one thing very clear to silvanov
16:31no economic relief or no new agreements while the war continues so this is not full normalization it is
16:39something more subtle engagement first pressure alongside it but europe sees danger in that approach
16:46for european governments russia is not simply another difficult negotiating partner russia is the aggressor
16:53in a war that has transformed european security europe has spent years imposing sanctions reducing
16:59energy dependence on moscow and supporting ukraine now washington is reopening high level channels with
17:06russia while europe is preparing more pressure that creates a strategic dilemma if the united states
17:12and russia begin talking seriously european governments cannot pretend those conversations do not matter
17:18any eventual peace settlement will affect european security ukraine's future and sanctions policy so the real
17:26question is not whether europe likes russia being back in the room clearly it does not the question
17:31is whether europe can afford to stay outside that room if the us is inside it because diplomacy has a
17:38brutal rule if you're not talking somebody else is washington appears determined to be the one talking to
17:44moscow trump's approach is transactional he wants results and an end to the bloodshed and for europe this
17:52could become much bigger than one awkward g20 photograph it could expose a growing gap between
17:58american and european strategies europe wants pressure trump appears more willing to combine
18:03pressure with engagement and russia knows what this opening means moscow has been under tremendous
18:10western sanctions and was pushed out of the g8 format but it never disappeared from the global economic
18:17system it remains in the g20 a major energy producer and nuclear power with relationships across the
18:23world the uncomfortable reality is simple russia can be isolated but it cannot simply be erased and trump's
18:31america appears increasingly willing to deal with that reality that does not mean europe is wrong to resist
18:37normalization but it must decide how isolation works when washington itself is reopening channels does europe
18:45join influence those talks or risk watching decisions about european security being made without it and this
18:53is why anton silvanov's presence in ashville matters far beyond the finance ministry he's not just a
19:00russian official sitting at a table he is a symbol of a diplomatic shift the g8 became g7 after russia's
19:07participation was suspended the g20 never followed that path russia stayed inside and now washington is
19:14choosing to use that door again the family photo excluded silvanov but the meeting happened the
19:21conversation happened and that is the signal europe cannot ignore because if america is talking to
19:27moscow again the real question for europe is no longer whether russia deserves a seat at the table
19:33the question is whether europe can afford to leave its own seat empty a pakistani court has now drawn a
19:41line
19:41inside adalia jail former prime minister imran khan and his wife bush rabbi cannot be kept in solitary
19:47confinement any longer the islamabad high court has also ordered jail authorities to facilitate their
19:53meeting under prison rules the ruling comes as khan now 73 remains behind bars serving lengthy sentences
20:00in corruption and related cases his wife bush rabbi is also detained at adiyala jail in raal pindi but
20:07this battle reached the courtroom through their families khan's sister alima khan challenged his
20:12alleged solitary confinement bush rabbi's daughter mubashra havar maneka filed a separate petition over
20:20her detention conditions justice khadim hussein sumro has now ordered authorities to follow jail laws and
20:27allow khan's family members to meet him the court also directed arrangements for telephone conversations
20:33between khan and his sons for imran khan this is more than a prison ruling it is a court imposed
20:39check on how pakistan's most high profile political prisoner is being treated behind bars solitary
20:45confinement is barred family meetings must be facilitated and his sons must be able to speak to him
20:52the question now is whether adiyala jail follows the court's order nepal's devastating floods have left
20:59behind a trail of death destruction and thousands still missing but amid the search for survivors there
21:05are heartbreaking stories of those waiting for their loved ones to return home on the ground our
21:11correspondent ashitosh mishra brings us the story of lily a dog still searching for those who once cared
21:18for her watch the story scale of devastation in nepal the toll mounting nearly thousand thousands are
21:26missing there are people rescue agencies who are looking for every possible survivor and even those
21:31are missing and in this one of the devastating such calamity we also see one of the worst humanitarian
21:36crisis lily for past five days is looking for someone these two children who have grown up with lily
21:43when she was a puppy and now she has been absolutely calm she has been looking for someone there was
21:48a
21:48hotel where she used to live in the evening there were people who were feeding her and now other than
21:53these two children for last you know four to five days she's just roaming around in certain limited
21:58pocket perhaps looking for someone the loved ones who who has seen see you know she has seen around uh
22:05grown up with them and you know the pets when we say that the most loyal pets on the earth
22:10and someone she
22:11grew with you know people who care of uh feeding and now they have gone missing many of those people
22:18in the dunge bazaar after this devastation have left this pocket and now lily is looking for the people
22:24who have always loved it's a calamity and at the same time it's a crisis humanitarian crisis
22:31that's all in this edition of statecraft before we go leaders including russian president vladimir
22:36putin indian prime minister narendra modi and iranian president masood bazashian arrived in the
22:42kyrgyz capital of bishkerk for the world nomad games the games opening ceremony took place on the
22:4831st of august on the eve of a summit of the shanghai cooperation organization take a look at the visuals
22:54goodbye and take care
23:31so
23:39so
23:40so

Recommended