Skip to playerSkip to main content
Chinese online marketplaces are rapidly changing the way Malaysians shop, offering factory-direct goods at prices many local businesses say they simply cannot match. Now, the government says it is moving towards tighter regulation of e-commerce platforms. So, can the government protect consumers and local businesses, without shutting out the benefits of greater competition? On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid, Chief Economist of Bank Muamalat Malaysia.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:09Hi, welcome back to Consider This. I'm Melissa Idris.
00:13The government says that it wants to ensure that e-commerce platforms,
00:17including those that are operating across borders,
00:20they want to make sure that these platforms are properly regulated and made accountable.
00:25And this comes at a time when we're seeing foreign online marketplaces
00:29undercutting local businesses at extraordinary scale and speed.
00:35And have we come to the point where the government needs to intervene
00:38to ensure that the market remains fair and sustainable?
00:42And how do we make sure of that happening without it being at the detriment of consumers?
00:47So joining me on the show now is Dr. Muhammad Afzanizam Abdur Rashid,
00:51who is the Chief Economist of Bank Mwamalat Malaysia.
00:53Dr. Afzanizam, thank you so much for being on the show with me today.
00:57Let's start with the look at the platforms as a landscape.
01:01From an economic perspective, do you see the rapid rise of these foreign online marketplaces?
01:09Is that a problem or is that a threat for local SMEs?
01:14Well, thanks, Melissa. Thank you for having me.
01:17Well, I guess on one hand, we would argue that if there is so much competitors,
01:24especially from abroad, that could compromise our local SMEs
01:29who are competing in the same space, i.e. the local consumers in Malaysia.
01:35But at the same time, economists also argue that competitive forces would also shape the dynamism
01:44of the businesses, which would eventually benefit the consumers.
01:50If I can quote some numbers here, Melissa, if you look at the producer price index,
01:57it went up. If you look at the breakdown, the crude material, which is the raw forms of inputs for
02:05businesses,
02:06in terms of prices, it has gone up by 25% in June alone.
02:10But if you look at the other components, such as the intermediate material, which is used also in the productions
02:17of a business,
02:18only grew by 7.4%, which is only single digit.
02:22And if you look at the finished goods, it only grew by 2%.
02:26So you can see from crude, intermediate, finished goods, only increased at a marginal rate.
02:34And more so, if you look at the consumer price index in the Q2, it only grew by 1.9%.
02:41Yes, it's higher compared to Q1, 1.6%.
02:44But again, because of the competition, because of the competitive forces,
02:49some businesses decided to actually absorb the higher cost in the name of competitions.
02:56Meaning to say they are willing to sacrifice some of their margins.
03:01Perhaps also they want to maintain the relationship with their clients and be able to retain the market share and
03:07whatnot.
03:07But these are all the competitive dynamics in the markets.
03:14And if you allow to do that, then perhaps it can help to address this rising cost of living in
03:21a truer sense, I would say.
03:23Okay, so where does this leave the government?
03:26At what point does this stop being a story about healthy competition and it becomes a policy concern?
03:35Right.
03:36I think obviously there must be a mechanism to screen our existing SMEs.
03:43I'm sure there are also a lot of our SMEs businesses who are very dynamic, who are very, you know,
03:50embrace all this digitalization endeavor.
03:54And I suppose those who are perhaps, you know, may not, you know, practicing the current form of doing business.
04:05So that leaves them quite vulnerable when it comes to, you know, competitive forces.
04:10So I think the screening process really, really matters because if you look at the government's, you know, assistance, there's
04:17a lot.
04:18And there's a lot of government agencies who are responsible to help and to give assistance, be it in the
04:24form of access to finance and also training.
04:28So there's a lot of assistance, but then again, it also warrant for perhaps right attitude also among the businesses
04:39so that whatever assistance being given to them will be materialized in a manner that will produce a desirable outcome
04:49such as high productivity and ultimately better profit margins now.
04:54Yeah, okay.
04:55Well, I mean, competition is supposed to benefit consumers, right?
04:59On the flip side of this coin, consumers are definitely benefiting from more competition, lower prices, greater choice.
05:08How do we think about how should the government balance the consumer interests against, I guess, the survival of local
05:17businesses?
05:17When does it make economic sense for the government to intervene and how do they intervene without becoming protectionist?
05:26Yeah, true.
05:27I think that the shortcut is always, you know, to do this protectionist policy stuff, which I think is very
05:35counterproductive.
05:36But I think maybe this is the main role of the government in a grand scheme of things, especially in
05:45the context of geopolitics.
05:49Then therefore, we need to see what are the sources of competitions that, you know, that deem to be detrimental
05:57to our businesses.
05:58Perhaps, let's say, if you say that businesses coming from China is actually become a detriment to our local SMEs,
06:08obviously, opting for protectionist is not the way to go.
06:13Perhaps it is to have more engagements, more dialogue, so that we have a common ground to address these issues.
06:21And perhaps also how we can, you know, be able to allow sort of, I don't know, perhaps some form
06:29of a JV joint venture with them and to allow technology, transverse of technology.
06:36Those are the things that I think the government can do to actually help to navigate these challenges rather than
06:42to, you know, to opt for unilateral kind of policies such as protectionist.
06:49Which, I think, it doesn't serve a good purpose, especially in the current context.
06:55Right. Can you elaborate a bit more? What are the tools at the government's disposal currently?
07:02So, you talked about, you know, JVs and having more tech transfer.
07:07But are there other tools that the government can use at its disposal that it can address some of the
07:14concerns from both businesses while still protecting consumers and regulating e-commerce platforms?
07:20Right. I think at the moment, the way I observe it, most of the assistance is actually in the form
07:27of access to finance.
07:30For instance, in our case, at Islamic banking institutions, we have these programs called ITCart, which uses, you know, the
07:41grants from Bandagara and also the expertise coming from a bank.
07:45And also how these tools can help to uplift the B40 businesses so that with the right kind of assistance
07:59and training programs that will help them to, you know, to have a better chance in terms of, you know,
08:05doing their business.
08:08So, other agencies such as perhaps Amanah Ikhtia, you know, even SME, the bank, perhaps, these are centered around access
08:18to finance.
08:20Trainings, yeah, I do believe there's a lot of training too, like Institute Keusawan Negara, INSCAN, and the likes.
08:27So, but to address this in a holistic way and to address the competition is something that the government needs
08:35to really look at in a broader picture, Melissa, because I don't think we have that proper, you know, framework
08:43for that.
08:44Okay. Then, can I ask you in terms of timing? Is there, so how do you see the timing now
08:50that the government has said they want to regulate e-commerce platforms, including the foreign marketplaces?
08:56Are we, are we behind the game? Are we too late in terms of the need to regulate this? Or
09:02are we, is there a policy risk of intervening too early and distorting the market?
09:09I think at this, at the current gesture, I understand we have this digital tax, which allow the governments to
09:18tax these digital players.
09:21So at least they would have some level playing field in the, in the, in the, in the form of
09:26tax, but beyond that, I think, um, um, uh, Malaysians are a sport with a lot of choices.
09:34Even if you look at BNPL, you can see, uh, platforms such as TikTok, the Shopee, uh, are widely available
09:43to our, uh, uh, consumers.
09:45So, um, um, I think in a nutshell, uh, it's hard for the government to actually regulate the, the business,
09:52uh, so the, the, the ideal solutions or intervention is through capacity building.
09:58To ensure that our, our, uh, SMEs, uh, better equipped to face, uh, the discompetitive forces.
10:06Yeah.
10:06Definitely. Dr. Afzal Nizam Abdul Rashid there from Bank Muamala Malaysia wrapping up this episode of Consider This.
10:13I'm Melissa Idris signing off the evening.
10:16Thank you so much for watching and good luck.

Recommended