Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 weeks ago
Ian Lee, Associate Professor at Carleton University’s Sprott School of Business in Ottawa, spoke to CGTN Europe about the breakdown in U.S.-Canada trade negotiations and Canada’s economic dependence on its southern neighbour. He said the two countries’ deep economic, cultural and geographic ties make any major decoupling unrealistic. Lee argued that the current tensions reflect both policy differences and President Trump’s political style, which has fuelled strong emotions in Canada and made compromise more difficult. While some Canadians hope relations could improve after Trump leaves office, he said negotiations are likely to remain challenging for now.

Category

🎵
Music
Transcript
00:00Well, Ian Lee is associate professor in the Sprott School of Business at Carlton University in Ottawa.
00:06There were many people, and I was one of them, that thought that we were going to have a deal
00:11last night,
00:11and it did fall apart at the 11th hour, at the final hour or minutes of the negotiation.
00:18My own interpretation is that the interjection in Canada yesterday of three different premiers of provinces,
00:30so these are not the prime minister of Canada, these are governments that are state governments, provincial governments,
00:39and the premier of Manitoba said he just didn't support it,
00:43and the premier of Quebec, the French-speaking province in Canada, also indicated deep unhappiness with the deal.
00:52And so at the 11th hour, Canada asked for some additional compromises, it has been reported, from the Americans,
01:02and they said no, and the prime minister of Canada then told his negotiators to leave and quit the negotiations.
01:10How realistic is it for Canada to push to reduce its dependence on the United States?
01:18I've just completed a manuscript with a colleague on this very issue, where does Canada go from here?
01:25There are some Canadians who say we should just walk away from the United States,
01:29and we will pivot to Europe and pivot to Asia-Pacific.
01:32And while many Canadians, I certainly support the idea of trade diversification,
01:37increasing exports to Europe and Asia-Pacific, the idea that we can walk away from the United States,
01:44where we have shared two and a half centuries, and a border that is 8,800 kilometers long,
01:53and according to Statistics Canada, 90% of Canadians live within 150 kilometers of the U.S. border,
02:01were strung out across Canada, hugging the U.S.-Canadian border.
02:06And our businesses, we have integrated supply chains,
02:10and there's been cross-marriage going on for two and a half centuries.
02:14The ties are so deep, economic, cultural, geographic,
02:19that it is simply not credible to suggest that Canada can just leave and stop dealing with the United States.
02:26How much of this is about policy? How much of this is about personality?
02:30And how many people in Canada are waiting for Mr. Trump to shuffle off?
02:36I mean, realistically, how much is he a part of any of this?
02:40I won't sugarcoat it.
02:44Canadians are... I've never in my lifetime seen Canadians so angry, so many so angry.
02:51I mean, just... it's incredibly emotional.
02:5570% of Canadians, I think the fair word to use is hate and despise Mr. Trump.
03:00And so his personality and his comments throughout the last two years have enraged Canadians.
03:09And I think that that's making it more difficult, much, much more difficult,
03:13for the leadership, for the prime minister and the premiers to come to a deal,
03:17because there are so many Canadians so angry.
03:21There's almost half of Canadians don't want any compromises whatsoever.
03:25Well, of course, you cannot have trade negotiations between any two countries
03:30without some compromises on both sides.
03:32So Mr. Trump is making it far, far more difficult to come to an agreement.
03:38And there are some who say, well, let's just wait it out until he's got two years...
03:43roughly just a little over two years left to the end of his term.
03:45And that's one possibility.
03:47So...
03:48So.
03:48So.
03:48You

Recommended