#bordertalks #iftikharfirdous #pakistan #saudiarabia #turkiye #makkahdefencepact #MeccaJointDefenseAgreement #arynews
👇🏼
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLS19FEYA85DjMXsnoR2YfAXLvuriQIEKb
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
👇🏼
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLS19FEYA85DjMXsnoR2YfAXLvuriQIEKb
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:01. . . .
00:56Thank you very much, Mr. Rasool, for joining us.
01:00There's an important discussion that's going on across, on a global level as well as social media is literally flooded
01:06with different analysts putting their suggestions in the forefront as to what might have prompted this defense agreement between Saudi
01:16Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan.
01:18And obviously each country has its own perspective and there's been official statements as well. But Mr. Rasool, from a
01:24Turkish perspective, exactly what does this entail to?
02:00I've been forced somehow to look to each other, not just outside powers for their security.
02:09So Israel's ongoing war on Gaza and then its attacks on several countries in the region is threatening language against
02:18almost any individual countries in the region.
02:21And so somehow what you're seeing is that the regional countries are in search of creating the blocs, the regional
02:29alliances to deal with these threats, the emerging threats, and the unpredictability, geopolitical unpredictability across the region.
02:38So it is mostly about the collective deterrence because now the countries are convinced that individually none of them are
02:48going to be able to somehow prevent or to avoid these threats.
02:52That's why these countries, particularly the big three in the region, Pakistan, Turkey and Saudi Arabia, coming together, joining their
03:01forces and joining their capabilities to achieve a regional deterrence.
03:07So it was mostly about the new geopolitical environment that has forced these countries into this position.
03:16So the way that you're explaining it, that obviously there is a lot of changes in the geopolitical environment, as
03:22well as the security threats that are illuminating from different parts of the globe, but particularly with the Israeli expansion,
03:30as well as the war in Iran.
03:33But how do these, like three different elements, three different countries coming together with each different part, and what's been
03:41assessed so far, we don't have any official statements on that as well, is that, you know, the Turkish part
03:47is mostly related to the military-industrial complex, and obviously Turkey is one of the countries that is far ahead
03:55in terms of technology.
03:56In terms of Turkey's contribution to this block, what is your perspective on that, how do you see that contribution
04:02coming in?
04:04Well, look, the reason that this is being called as three big, and the Mecca alliance among these three big,
04:13is that each of the countries that are now in these alliances, they have their own capabilities.
04:19So for the Turkish part, one of the things is that Turkey already has NATO's second largest army, and very
04:28advanced and sophisticated drone technology.
04:31Indeed, if you just regard the fact that more than 65 percent of the drone sales globally is from Turkey,
04:39so you will see that it's almost a monopoly in the global market when it comes to the drones and
04:45the drone technology.
04:47Besides that, so Turkey also has one of the world's fastest growing defense industry, and what we are talking about
04:55is not only about the drones.
04:57I think there is one misleading, of course, Turkey's Bayraktar drones are extremely famous, but so Turkey is now producing
05:04the helicopters, producing tanks, and there are the facilities, tons of the facilities, particularly when it comes to the ammunition.
05:10And indeed, in many parts of the world, where there is a lack of ammunition, so Turkey has been one
05:16of the main suppliers.
05:18So here, Turkey is going to come up particularly with its sophisticated drone technology, and also its very much robust
05:27defense industry into this game.
05:30But it's not only about that.
05:32Another fact is that, so in any way, the defense industry, without the economic or financial resources, cannot move forward.
05:41And when it comes to Turkey, despite the economic challenges that the country is facing, despite the chronic high inflation
05:49and so on, but Turkey is also one of the strongest manufacturing house or manufacturing hub in the region.
05:56Just remember, last year, in 2025, the total export figure of Turkey has exceeded $257 billion, and that is not
06:06coming from the gas or the oil.
06:08It's pure production.
06:09So you will see the Turkish products almost across the whole globe.
06:14And in that sense, so the economic productivity and also the advanced defense industry is what Turkey is going to
06:22put at the table.
06:23And also here, another third factor is the geography of the country, the location of the country.
06:31So in that sense, Saudi Arabia is an economic powerhouse.
06:34Pakistan is the only Muslim nation, Muslim-majority nation with a nuclear capability.
06:42And Turkey having the second largest army in the NATO, a robust defense industry, and of course, the very advanced
06:51drone technologies and with its manufacturing capacity.
06:55So we'll go and take a short little break.
06:58Lیکن میں ناظرین کو جو ہے وہ سمجھاتے ہیں کہ رسول سردار صاحب نے جو سوال ان سے پوچھے گئے
07:04تھے.
07:04ایک particular خصوصی طور پر یہ سوال تھا کہ اس اگریمنٹ کی ابھی ضرورت جو ہے وہ کیا تھی.
07:10اور انہوں نے دو طرف جو ہے وہ اشارہ جو ہے وہ کیا ہے.
07:12ایک یہ کہ جو اسرائیلی ایکسپینشن ہے اور جو ہم دیکھ رہے ہیں میڈل ایسٹ میں.
07:18اسرائیل جو کرنے کی کوشش کر رہا ہے اس کیلئے بہت ضروری تھا کہ تینوں ممالک جو ہے وہ ساتھ
07:23میں ہاتھ جوڑیں.
07:24اور جس طرح کیا اگریمنٹ جو ہے وہ سامنے آیا ہے دیپینس کے حوالے سے.
07:27لیکن اس میں دوسرا ایمپورٹنٹ فیکٹر انہوں نے کہا کہ جو ایران کی جنگ تھی اور اس میں جو نیگوسییشن
07:33اور بعد میں کسی نتیجے پر جو ہے ایکسیس فائر اور پھر دوبارہ جنگ کا آغاز.
07:38اس نے خطے کو مجموعی طور پر جو ہے انسٹیبل جو ہے وہ کر دیا ہے اور اس کے جو
07:44محرکات ہیں اس کو اس طرح تبدیل کر دیا ہے کہ جس میں اب ضرورت جو ہے وہ پیش آئی.
07:50کہ جو تین بڑے ممالک ہیں جن کے اپنے اپنے خاص ایسپیکس ہیں خصوصی طور پر ترکیہ کا انہوں نے
07:57ذکر کیا کیونکہ وہ ٹھرکی سے بات کر رہے ہیں کہ ایک تو نیٹو کے اندر جو دوسری سب سے
08:03بڑی فوج ہے وہ ترکیہ کی ہے اور امپورٹنٹلی جو ترکیہ کی ڈرون ٹیکنالوجی ہے وہ سب سے فاسٹسٹ گروئنگ
08:10ہے اور سعودی عرب کی حوالے سے انہوں نے کہا کہ آبیسلی وہ ایک میجر ایکنومک پاور ہے اور پاکستان
08:16جو ہے وہ مسلم ممالک کا واحد نیو
08:19کلیر پاور ہے اس لیے آہ ان حالات کے اندر ان تینوں کا آنا اکھٹے ہونا ڈیفنس کوپریشن کے لیے
08:25یہ ناغذیر ہو چکا ہے پروگرام کے دوسرے حصے میں ان سے جو ہے وہ سوال پوچھیں گے کہ جو
08:30انہوں نے اسرائیل کا ذکر کیا اور خصوصی طور پر آہ مشرق وستہ کے حالات کے بارے میں کہ وہاں
08:35پر اب کیا سیچویشن جو ہے وہ ڈیبلپ ہوتے ہوئے نظر آتی ہے ہمارے ساتھ رہیے گا
08:49Welcome back Nazareen. So Mr. Rasool we were talking about the situation the way that it is developing even in
08:56the aftermath of this defence cooperation agreement that we see.
08:59Yesterday we have seen renewed sort of an escalation on the Syrian border as well and I want to ask
09:07for your comment related to because in the Makkah agreement akin to the NATO agreements clause 5 it says that
09:13an attack against one signatory will be considered to be an attack against all.
09:19There's been various clarifications that have been coming in that this is not something that is a presupposed sort of
09:26an agreement in which there is a task for a preemptive war strategy.
09:30Rather, it is a defensive war strategy that has actually been put forward.
09:34But when we see the kind of escalation that is taking place, particularly with respect to the Middle East, what
09:40do you think that in terms of its foundational clause, how soon do we see this act into play?
09:46And secondly, whether the expectations from it would be the way that the discussion is ongoing right now?
09:54Well, here, I think the main vulnerability of the Mecca alliance is that it has never been tested yet because
10:00it's been just a couple of days that the agreement was signed between the three countries.
10:05And indeed, the commitment is binding. It's quite a bold and assertive commitment.
10:10So in Article 5 of the NATO, which, by the way, Turkey is a NATO member, and we first are
10:17used to that concept of the Article 5 because again and again in Turkey that will be discussed as Turkey,
10:23as the country has been a NATO member since 1952.
10:30So the Article 5 says an attack on one member of the alliance is an attack on all, and that
10:37comes with the responsibility of the collective response.
10:40So here we're seeing the main close of the agreement.
10:44That is the crux of the agreement.
10:45That is the backbone of the agreement that was signed between Islamabad, Riyadh, and Ankara, that if one of them
10:52is attacked, so it's going to be considered as an attack on all.
10:55So here, what is going to define the success of this agreement is not what the agreement says on the
11:03paper.
11:04It is what happens when one of them is attacked, either by a state or non-state actors in the
11:13region.
11:14And if there are attacks directly on the soil of one of the members, will the other two or with
11:19the others come to its defense or not?
11:22So the answer to this question is going to determine whether this agreement becomes the foundation of a genuine regional
11:36security architecture or it remains, at least for now, just as a powerful political declaration.
11:44So another flow, of course, for now, at least, the mechanism is still not very much detailed.
11:51What is going to be the secretary and how they're going to response, whether there are going to be ministerial
11:55level meetings on a regular basis.
11:59And also the details of that, the technical details are still not there.
12:03However, one thing that I could say, even when the NATO was founded, right after the Second World War, it
12:11took quite years, and in some cases, decades, to be well-defined.
12:15So as long as the seriousness and the sincerity of Islamabad, Ankara and Riyadh is in place, by the time
12:23there will be several other mechanisms established to simply support the same, the core mechanism.
12:31So for such alliances, particularly the regional blocs, they do not get their final shape and form overnight.
12:38Just one last question before I actually leave you.
12:41There's a lot of discussion as to Egypt being pulled to be a part of this, and they did not
12:49become part of it as yet.
12:51What is the speculation in relation to that?
12:54How do you see this pan out?
12:56Well, indeed, so the general expectation, just remember, after 27th of February, when the United States and Israel once again,
13:06started to attack, to initiate attacks on Iran, immediately what we have seen was Turkish, Pakistani, Saudi, and Egyptian foreign
13:18ministers coming together and having a meeting in Riyadh.
13:23And that was the first official meeting of these four big countries in the region, trying to somehow come up
13:32with the regional ownership or a regional response for the regional crisis.
13:36And then these kind of meetings have been repeated in Islamabad, in Ankara, and then in Cairo.
13:43So in each of these meetings, even the last one, just one day before the signing of this agreement in
13:51Mecca, so in Oman, in the capital of Jordan,
13:56once again, we have seen the Pakistani, Turkish, and Egyptian, and Saudi foreign ministers meeting.
14:00So, and there was an expectation that Egypt is going to be a part of them.
14:06I think here there are two reasons that perhaps that did not happen.
14:12I suppose Riyadh has some concerns about Egypt's participation in the initial phase because of the divergence of the policies
14:21across the region.
14:23That was one of the regions.
14:25And second, perhaps there was a little bit of the reluctancy from Egypt as well regarding its relations with Abu
14:34Dhabi.
14:34However, still, both Cairo and also Ankara are again and again expressing one fact that the alliance is not,
14:46so this alliance between the three countries is not going to be staying limited.
14:52So it's open to the friendly countries in the region.
14:57And one thing that I know that Ankara is extremely keen to see Cairo also in this alliance.
15:02If that happens, this is going to be quite an organic regional bloc, not just an alliance, but also a
15:08regional bloc.
15:09So Pakistan, a nuclear-powered Pakistan with almost 250 million people,
15:16and then a Saudi Arabia with its tremendous financial resources,
15:21and then Egypt with its extremely important geopolitical location and quite more than 120 million people,
15:29and then a Turkey with being the second largest member of the NATO and its advanced defense industry,
15:37then this is perhaps going to be, if that happens, it's going to be a pivotal moment for the region.
15:43Indeed, for many, it will be the agreement of the central.
15:49Thank you very much for your time, Rasul.
15:52Thank you very much.
16:36Thank you very much.
16:54Thank you very much.
17:22Thank you very much.