- 2 days ago
🎧 Now on Spotify! Listen here: https://open.spotify.com/show/033BGa9LZFyU7BTt2XLQpH?si=8a02daf1b8404c64
By mid-September 1942, the Japanese Army estimated 7,500 Americans on Guadalcanal. The real number was over 19,000.
Three months of scouts sent toward the Marine perimeter. None came back. Three separate offensives launched without a single officer who had seen the ground he was attacking. And an intelligence gap so wide that an entire division, plus every gun and truck feeding it, sat invisible on a strip of coast narrow enough to hear voices across.
Then on the night of October 24th, something changed. A Japanese colonel and about a hundred men broke through the wire and came out the other side — alive, standing inside the American rear, looking at what was actually kept in there.
What they found shattered every assumption their army had fought on since August.
Whether that information ever reached anyone who could act on it — and what it cost a light cruiser, a division, and a staff officer they called the God of Operations — is the part of Guadalcanal almost nobody tells you.
Subscribe for forgotten WW2 stories ▶️ https://www.youtube.com/@ww2dispatchh
Like if you think
By mid-September 1942, the Japanese Army estimated 7,500 Americans on Guadalcanal. The real number was over 19,000.
Three months of scouts sent toward the Marine perimeter. None came back. Three separate offensives launched without a single officer who had seen the ground he was attacking. And an intelligence gap so wide that an entire division, plus every gun and truck feeding it, sat invisible on a strip of coast narrow enough to hear voices across.
Then on the night of October 24th, something changed. A Japanese colonel and about a hundred men broke through the wire and came out the other side — alive, standing inside the American rear, looking at what was actually kept in there.
What they found shattered every assumption their army had fought on since August.
Whether that information ever reached anyone who could act on it — and what it cost a light cruiser, a division, and a staff officer they called the God of Operations — is the part of Guadalcanal almost nobody tells you.
Subscribe for forgotten WW2 stories ▶️ https://www.youtube.com/@ww2dispatchh
Like if you think
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00October 24th, 1942. Half past nine at night. 3,000 yards in front of the American line on
00:08Guadalcanal, south of the dirt airstrip the Marines had named Henderson Field.
00:13Sergeant Ralph Briggs, Jr. lay in the wet grass with 46 other Marines,
00:18and he had stopped moving because the jungle around him had started to walk.
00:23They came past in single file, not creeping, walking. Some were smoking, some were singing,
00:30low and flat, the way exhausted men sing when they have been on their feet for eight days.
00:36They passed close enough that Briggs could hear canteens knocking against belts.
00:41One Japanese soldier caught his boot on a Marine's helmet, stumbled, and kept going.
00:47Forty-seven Americans, and a column going by them in the dark that took a very long time to pass.
00:55Nobody in that outpost fired. Sit with that for a moment, because it is easy to read straight past
01:01it. Forty-seven men, 3,000 yards beyond any help on earth, lying still in the grass while 3,000
01:10enemy
01:10soldiers walked over the top of them. Not one of them broke.
01:15When the last of the column had gone, Briggs got to a field telephone and called the command post
01:21of the 1st Battalion, 7th Marines. Lieutenant Colonel Lewis Puller picked up. Briggs told him
01:27there were about 3,000 Japanese between the two of them. Puller asked if he was certain.
01:33Positive, Briggs said. They had been all around him, singing, smoking, heading his way.
01:41Now hold that picture, because here is what makes this night different from every other
01:45night on that island. Those men were not marching to the American line. They were marching through
01:52it. And a small number of them were going to manage it. They would be the only soldiers in
01:59the entire six-month campaign to stand inside the American rear area, look at what was kept
02:05in there, and stay alive long enough for anything at all to be said about it. What they found behind
02:11that line, and what got reported about it afterward, is the part of Guadalcanal almost nobody tells
02:17you. It is also the part that decided the island. If you want more stories about the men who held
02:23that line, the ones who stayed still in the dark when everything in them said run, a like
02:30and a subscribe help these stories reach the people who want them. To understand what was
02:35walking toward Briggs that night, go back 66 days to the first time the Japanese army tried
02:41to find out what the Americans actually had on Guadalcanal.
02:44August 19, 1942. Colonel Kiyonao Ichiki had come ashore east of the perimeter with roughly 900 men
02:54and orders to retake the airfield. Before he moved, he did the correct thing, the thing every manual
03:02tells a commander to do. He sent out a scouting party to walk west and find the enemy. They found
03:09them. Except that Captain Charles Brush found the scouts first. Brush had taken 60 marines from
03:16A Company down the coastal track that morning. Around midday, the two patrols walked into each
03:22other in the trees. Inside an hour, all but five of the Japanese were dead. Then Brush did the thing
03:29that mattered far more than the shooting. He walked among the bodies and looked at them properly.
03:36New uniforms. Boots still shiny. Not one of these men had been on that island longer than a few days.
03:44And in their pockets, and their leather dispatch cases, were diaries, notebooks, and maps. And the
03:51maps had American positions marked on them. Understand what just happened there. Because it sets the pattern
03:58for everything that follows. In the first serious ground contact of the campaign, the Americans came
04:05away reading the Japanese. The Japanese came away guessing about the Americans. Five men ran back
04:13through the jungle to Ichiki and told him the marines were dug in, alert, and nowhere near where he expected
04:19them to be. Two nights later, Ichiki attacked anyway. Now here is a number I need you to carry with
04:27you
04:27through the rest of this story, because everything that comes later hangs off it. By the middle of
04:33September, Japanese 17th Army Headquarters had revised its estimate of American strength on Guadalcanal
04:39upward. Their new figure was 7,500 men. The true figure was above 19,000. By the 13th of October,
04:51it was above 23,000. Stay with that gap for a second, because the size of it is the whole
04:58story.
05:00That is not a poor estimate. That is an entire extra division, plus a regiment, plus every truck and
05:08gun and crate of rations that keeps them alive, sitting invisible to an army that had been fighting
05:13for two months on the same narrow strip of coast, some nights close enough to hear the Americans talking.
05:19Not one Japanese commander who ordered an attack on that perimeter ever knew what he was sending his
05:24men into. So the real question is not why the Japanese estimates were wrong. Every army gets
05:30estimates wrong. The question is why they stayed wrong, month after month, with the answer sitting
05:37a few miles away, behind a line of sandbags that men were walking through in the dark. Because men did
05:43get
05:44through. And before the sun came up on October 25th, a report traveled out of that jungle, reached 17th
05:51army, and went on to Rabool. It moved fast. Within hours, warships were at sea acting on it. Among them,
06:00a light cruiser called Yura. Yura would not see the end of the day. And the officer who sent that
06:07report
06:07had never once set foot inside the American rear. August 20th, 1942. A tidal creek near the village
06:15of Volonavua on the coast east of the American perimeter, roughly a day before Colonel Ichiki
06:20would move on the airfield. Jacob Vuzza was crossing the water when the current took his footing.
06:26The splashing brought a Japanese patrol down the bank. Vuzza was a retired sergeant major of the Solomon
06:33Islands Constabulary, a career policeman who had come out of retirement to scout for the Marines.
06:38He was carrying a small American flag one of them had given him as a gift. He had tried to
06:44hide it.
06:45They found it. They took him to an officer who spoke English. They tied him to a tree with vines.
06:52And then they asked him the question. Where are the Americans? How many of them are there?
06:58What do they have? Understand what is happening in that clearing. That is the question this entire
07:06story is built on. And on the 20th of August, the Japanese army had the answer standing in front of
07:12it, tied to a tree, unable to walk away. They questioned him for hours. He said nothing. They
07:20beat him with rifle butts between the questions. He said nothing. Then they used bayonets. And the
07:28wounds were to his arms, his shoulder, his face, his stomach, and his throat. And when they were
07:35finished, they left him there to die. He did not die. Once the guards had gone, he bit through the
07:42cords holding him to the tree and worked himself loose. And then he started west toward the American line.
07:49When he could no longer stand up, he went on his hands and knees. He covered close to three miles
07:55that way. And not through empty jungle. The fighting had already begun. He crawled through the middle of
08:02it. He reached a marine outpost. A private from G Company saw him coming and understood that the
08:09bleeding man in front of him was not an enemy. They got him back behind a jeep, and Martin Clemens,
08:14the coast watcher who ran the island's scouts, came down to him. And before anybody put a dressing
08:21on him, before he would let a single wound be touched, Vuzza made his report. How many Japanese
08:28were coming? What they were carrying? Where they were? It went to Lieutenant Colonel Edwin Pollack,
08:35whose battalion held the ground the attack was about to land on, with roughly ten minutes to spare.
08:41Ten minutes. Consider what ten minutes is worth to a machine gun crew that suddenly knows exactly
08:48which way to point. Vuzza took about a hundred stitches and spent twelve days in a field hospital.
08:55Then, he went back out on patrol. Now here's what I need you to see in that story. And it
09:02is not the
09:02courage, although the courage is what you will still be thinking about tonight. It is the direction the
09:08information was traveling. The Japanese caught a man who knew everything they needed and got nothing
09:15out of him. The Americans caught a patrol of dead men and read their maps. Every hour of that campaign,
09:23intelligence was flowing one way across that line and stopping dead at the other. And that was not luck.
09:30Keep the name Martin Clemens somewhere in the back of your mind, because we are going to come back to
09:35what he had built. The short version is that the Japanese were fighting on an island where the island
09:40itself was working against them, and they never fully understood that this was happening. Which brings
09:46us to September, and to the second Japanese attempt on the airfield, and to a decision that tells you
09:52everything about what bad information does to an army. Major General Kiyotake Kawaguchi arrived with
09:59his brigade in early September to do what Ichiki had failed to do. Hyakutake offered him an extra
10:05infantry battalion. Kawaguchi turned it down. He turned it down because his intelligence told him
10:12that only about two thousand marines were left on Guadalcanal. And against two thousand marines,
10:17he did not need it. Sit with the arithmetic on that for a second. The wrong number did not simply
10:25mislead the Japanese. It physically removed Japanese soldiers from the battlefield. A commander looked
10:32at a figure that was wronged by a factor of nine and used it to subtract his own reinforcements.
10:38Then he took his brigade inland, south into the jungle, to come at the perimeter from the one direction
10:44the Americans were thinnest. It was a good idea. It was, in fact, the correct idea. And the Americans
10:51knew he was doing it, because on the 8th of September, the raiders landed behind him at Tassimboko,
10:58wrecked his supply base, and came away with papers. Papers that told the American command which units were
11:04coming and roughly how strong they were. On the evening of the 12th of September, with his men finally in
11:11the jungle south of the ridge and the attack hours away, Kawaguchi discovered two things. Only one of his
11:18battalions had reached its jump-off point. And not one unit in his brigade had managed to reconnoiter
11:24the ground they were about to assault. He attacked anyway. In the dark. Against a ridge that no Japanese
11:32officer had looked at. Waiting on it were Merritt Edson's raiders and parachutists, dug in on ground they had
11:39walked every yard of in daylight. Afterward, he described himself as disappointed and helpless,
11:46scattered by the jungle. Two attempts now. Two commanders who sent men to find out what was
11:53behind the American line. And two commanders who ended up attacking blind and losing most of what they
11:59had. By the end of September, the 17th Army still could not tell you what was inside that perimeter.
12:06So in October, they stopped trying to find out. They made a different decision instead,
12:12and it was the most ambitious thing the Japanese Army attempted on Guadalcanal.
12:17It required an entire division to walk 15 miles through the worst ground on the island,
12:22with every single man carrying an artillery shell on his back, in addition to his own weapon and pack.
12:29And it very nearly worked. Because for the first time in the campaign,
12:33the Americans could not see them coming either. Early morning, October 20, 1942.
12:39The bank of the Lunga River, deep in the interior of Guadalcanal.
12:44Lieutenant General Masao Maruyama stopped his column at the water, opened his map,
12:49and made the decision that would kill most of the men standing behind him.
12:54He judged that his division was about four miles south of the airfield.
12:58He gave orders accordingly. Both wings would move north, parallel to the river,
13:03and the attack would go in at six o'clock on the evening of the 22nd. He was eight miles
13:09south of
13:09the airfield. He was wrong by a factor of two about his own position, on his own line of march,
13:16with a map in his hands. Take a moment with that, because it changes the shape of everything you have
13:22heard so far. We have been talking about a Japanese army that could not see the Americans.
13:28On the morning of the 20th of October, the commander of the finest division in that army
13:34could not reliably see himself. To understand how a general ends up four miles from where he thinks he
13:41is, you have to know what the previous eight days had done to his men. On the 12th of October,
13:46a company of Japanese engineers had started cutting a trail from the Matanakao toward the southern face of the
13:52American perimeter. They had no road building equipment. They cut 15 miles of it by hand,
13:58with axes, saws, and machetes, through ravines, across rivers, over ridges, in the worst country
14:04on the island. The horses had been left behind at Rabaul. 800 tons of supplies had to be carried
14:11forward on men's backs from as far away as Cape Esperance. Then the division walked up it. 7,000 men
14:19in single file. And every one of them was ordered to carry an artillery shell. Picture that for a
14:25moment. Your rifle, your pack, your ammunition, your 10 days of rice, and on top of all of it,
14:31a shell for a gun somebody else is dragging. 15 miles.
14:38Chest-deep river crossings with your weapon held over your head. Rain that turned the ridges to grease.
14:45Here is what happened to those guns. They did not make it. The heavy pieces were abandoned along the
14:51trail, one after another, because there was no way to get them through. When the attack finally went in,
14:58exactly one Japanese gun had reached a firing position to support 7,000 men. A 75mm mountain gun.
15:05It fired 20 rounds. 7,000 men had carried shells for 15 miles. Through that, for 20 rounds.
15:15By the 21st of October, Maruyama had to put his division on half rations, because they were burning
15:21through their food faster than they were covering ground. They had arrived to fight the decisive battle
15:27of the Pacific War, and they arrived hungry. Now hold that image, and set it beside what was happening
15:33eight miles north of them at the same moment. On the 13th of October, 2,837 soldiers of the 164th
15:43Infantry Regiment came ashore at Lunga Point. National Guardsmen from North Dakota. Farm boys, mostly,
15:50who had been part-time soldiers a year and a half earlier, who had never been in a battle. American
15:56strength on Guadalcanal that day reached 23,088 men. They had roughly 36 hours to settle in. At 33 minutes
16:05past 1 in the morning on the 14th of October, the Japanese battleships Kongo and Haruna opened fire
16:12on Henderson Field. In 83 minutes, they put 973 14-inch shells into the Lunga perimeter. 973.
16:24That is, a battleship shell arriving roughly every 5 seconds, for an hour and a half, onto a patch of
16:32ground you could walk across in 10 minutes. It destroyed 48 of the 90 aircraft on the island.
16:39It burned nearly all the aviation fuel. It killed 41 men. And I want you to remember what I am
16:46about to
16:46tell you next, because when we get to the end of this story, it is going to be the whole
16:51answer.
16:52Within a few hours, one of those runways was operational again. The same morning.
16:59Aircraft were flying off Henderson Field before the smoke had cleared.
17:03Now the critical part. No Japanese officer on Guadalcanal ever learned that.
17:10They fired the shells. They watched the fires from the sea. Their reports said the airfield was
17:16finished. And the reports were believed. Because nobody went and looked. Nobody could go and look.
17:23That is what two months of dead scouts and unread intelligence buys you.
17:28So when Matayama's exhausted, half-starved, gunless division finally turned north through the jungle,
17:35they were walking toward a place they believed had been wrecked 11 days earlier, defended by 10,000
17:42Americans, who were actually 23,000. On ground their commander could not accurately locate. And it was
17:50still, somehow, the most dangerous moment the Americans faced on that island.
17:56Because nobody saw them coming. On the 23rd of October, it got worse inside the Japanese command.
18:03Kabaguchi, moving on the right, decided on his own authority that the American defenses were weaker
18:09further east, and began shifting his whole wing. Maruyama ordered him back onto the plan. Kabaguchi refused.
18:17So Maruyama relieved him of his command, in the jungle, hours before the attack,
18:23and handed his wing to Colonel Toshinari Shoji, who had never commanded it before.
18:29Hyakutake also sent a staff officer forward to monitor the division's progress and report back on
18:35whether the assault could actually begin. That officer was Colonel Masanobu Tsuji. Hold on to his name.
18:42He comes back at the end of this, and what he says is the most honest sentence any Japanese officer
18:48produced about Guadalcanal. Which brings us back to Sergeant Briggs, lying in the wet grass with 46 men
18:55while the column walked past him. Behind Briggs, holding the entire southern face of the perimeter,
19:01was Lieutenant Colonel Lewis Puller, with 700 marines strung across 2,500 yards of jungle.
19:09700 men. Coming at them, 7,000. And the only reinforcement anywhere within reach was a battalion
19:18of those North Dakota farm boys who had been on the island for 11 days. Between 4 in the afternoon
19:23and 9 at night on the 24th of October, it rained on Guadalcanal the way it rains there,
19:30and the Japanese 2nd Division came apart in the dark. Units lost each other. Whole battalions drifted off
19:36their bearings. Shoji's right wing, the wing Mariyama had handed to a new commander that same day,
19:43turned by accident until it was moving parallel to the American line instead of toward it, and all
19:48but one of its battalions never made contact with anybody at all. The exception was the 1st Battalion
19:54of the 230th Infantry. At about 10 o'clock it walked into Puller's marines, more or less by accident,
20:01and was driven straight back off. Then, at half past midnight, the 11th Company under Captain Jito
20:08Katsumata found a company of Puller's Battalion and attacked it. They hit the wire first. Heavy
20:16barbed wire, in the dark, in the rain, with men behind it who had been waiting all night. Machine
20:23guns, mortars, and artillery went to work on the men tangled in it, and by 1 o'clock most of
20:28Katsumata's
20:29company was dead. At a quarter past one, further west, the 9th Company charged straight into Puller's
20:36C Company. Waiting for them was a machine gun section led by Sergeant John Bassalone. Within
20:43five minutes, almost every man in that Japanese company was dead. Let me put a number on that so
20:50it lands properly. A Japanese rifle company was somewhere around 180 men. They crossed open ground
20:58into prepared machine guns, and it took five minutes. By 25 past one, American divisional
21:06artillery was falling not on the attack, but behind it, onto the routes Nasu's men were using to come
21:12forward, and onto the ground where they were forming up. The Japanese were being killed on their way to the
21:19fight. Now I want to take you eight miles back into the jungle, to a Japanese headquarters that could
21:26hear all of this and see none of it. At 50 minutes past midnight, Lieutenant General Hyakutake sent a
21:34signal to Rabao. It reported that, shortly before 11 o'clock that night, the right wing had captured the
21:41airfield. Henderson Field had not been captured. Henderson Field had not been reached. Not one
21:50Japanese soldier had set foot on it. What appears to have happened is this. Somewhere out in the
21:57blackness, a Japanese unit crossed a large open field, and in the rain and the dark, with no map
22:03that meant anything, and no officer who had ever seen the place, the men decided the open ground under
22:10their boots was the runway. That belief went up the chain. Maruyama's staff passed it to Hyakutake as
22:17fact. Hyakutake passed it to Rabao as victory. Mark what happens next, because this is the moment the
22:25cost of two months of blindness gets paid in full. The Japanese Eighth Fleet had task units waiting at
22:32sea for exactly this signal. On receipt of it, they went into action. Three destroyers came into
22:39Lunga Point in daylight on the 25th, chased off two old American destroyers that were delivering
22:45aviation fuel, sank a tugboat called Seminole and a patrol boat, and began shelling the shore.
22:52At 53 minutes past 10 in the morning, a marine shore gun hit the destroyer Akatsuki and damaged her.
23:00And all three withdrew, with American fighters strafing them on the way out.
23:05The second group came through the indispensable strait with the light cruiser Yura and five
23:09destroyers. Five American dive bombers found her. They hit her hard. She turned to escape. And
23:17aircraft from the field she had come to support kept finding her all day long. That evening,
23:23her crew abandoned her and she was scuttled. A light cruiser died because a group of tired men
23:29in the dark walked across a field and thought it was somewhere else. And nobody in that chain had
23:36sent a single man forward to confirm it. That is the habit two months of dead scouts builds.
23:44At half past four in the morning, Hyakutake withdrew the message about the airfield. At seven,
23:50he issued another one, saying the results of the attack were unknown. Read that sequence again.
23:55At one in the morning, the Japanese high command believed it had won the campaign. By seven,
24:01it could not tell you what had happened on its own front line, four hours after the fighting.
24:07Meanwhile, back on that front line, the Americans were doing something I still find remarkable.
24:13Puller had recognized early that this was the main attack and asked for reinforcement.
24:17What he got was the 3rd Battalion of the 164th Infantry,
24:21under Lt. Col. Robert Hall, the North Dakota guardsman. 11 days on the island, no combat experience
24:29of any kind. At a quarter to four in the morning, in the dark, in heavy rain, in the middle
24:35of an
24:35ongoing battle, those soldiers were fed into an existing Marine line, piecemeal, squad by squad,
24:42and slotted in between Marines they had never met. Think about what that actually requires.
24:47You are moving hundreds of untested men forward at night into a firing line, mixing them with another
24:56service's troops under fire with everyone's blood up and everyone's finger on a trigger.
25:02There are professional armies that could not do that today. They were all in position before daybreak.
25:10Puller would later recommend Hall for the Navy Cross, and Hall would get it. But 15 minutes before
25:16Hall's first men reached the line, at about half past three that morning, something happened in the
25:22center of Puller's sector that nobody on the American side understood until it was over.
25:28Colonel Masajiro Furumiya, commander of the 29th Infantry Regiment, came through the artillery with
25:35two companies and his headquarters staff, and behind him came the regimental colors and the men whose job
25:41was to guard them. Most of them were killed getting there. About 100 were not. They went through the
25:48wire, past the pillboxes, and out the other side into the trees. For the first time since the 7th of
25:55August, Japanese soldiers were standing inside the American perimeter, alive, with nobody shooting at
26:01them, in the dark, looking at what was back there. Sunrise on the 25th of October, 1942, inside the Lunga
26:10perimeter, in the trees behind Puller's line. About 100 Japanese soldiers were standing in the one place
26:17their entire army had been trying to reach since August. They had done it. They were through. Every
26:24commander who had thrown men at that line since August had been trying to buy this exact position.
26:31Fudumiya's men had it. And here is what it got them. Understand first what the Japanese army
26:38thought was back there. Their picture of Henderson Field was a runway, some tents, some fuel drums,
26:45and roughly 10,000 Americans holding a thin crust around it. Break the crust, and you are in the soft
26:52part. That was the theory behind every attack for two months. What was actually behind Puller's line,
26:59that morning, within a mile or two of where those hundred men were standing, was this. The Marine
27:06Divisional Artillery, which had been firing all night and had ranged in on the approaches so precisely
27:12that Japanese troops were dying before they reached the fight. An entire fresh army infantry regiment,
27:19a Marine battalion held in reserve behind the sector, engineers, motor transport moving on cut roads,
27:27and an airfield that the Japanese high command believed had been destroyed 11 days earlier by
27:33battleship gunfire. That airfield was working. The 25th of October is the day American veterans of
27:40Guadalcanal remember as Dugout Sunday, because Japanese aircraft, artillery, and warships hammered the
27:47perimeter from dawn until dark, and most men spent it in a hole. 82 Japanese aircraft came over in six
27:55waves,
27:56and through all of it, American fighters kept getting off that runway. By the end of the day,
28:02the Japanese had lost 11 fighters, two bombers, and a reconnaissance aircraft, along with most of
28:07the crews inside them. The Americans lost two fighters. Both pilots walked away. So put yourself
28:15in that tree line at first light. You have broken into the enemy's rear area, which is the thing your
28:21army has spent two months and several thousand lives trying to do. And what you find is not a rear
28:27area.
28:27It is more army. There is no soft part. There is no back. The line you came through was the
28:35outside edge
28:35of something that goes down and down in depth, and every layer of it is functioning. And the airfield
28:41you were told was wrecked is putting aircraft into the sky over your head. This is the answer to the
28:47question we started with. Right here. At six in the morning on the 25th of October, inside those trees,
28:54Japanese soldiers were finally in a position to see what the Americans actually had.
29:00And now the part that I think is the most important detail in this entire story.
29:04They could not tell anybody. They had no radio that would reach anybody who mattered.
29:11They were a hundred men in a pocket, 150 yards wide, and the line they had come through had closed
29:16behind them and was now stronger than it had been the night before, because the North Dakota guardsmen
29:21were in it. Any runner going back would have to cross that line outward, in daylight, through
29:27Marines who were actively hunting. Do not lose this. The one report that reached Rabul from that
29:35battlefield came from men who never got inside and saw nothing, and it made the trip in under two hours
29:40and put a fleet to sea. The men who got inside and saw everything could not get a single sentence
29:47out.
29:47That is not bad luck. That is what an army looks like when it has spent two months making itself
29:53unable to receive information. The Americans spent the 25th of October dealing with them.
30:00Puller's Marines and the soldiers of the 164th attacked the salient and closed it, then went
30:06through the ground behind their own line in small groups, hunting. They killed 104 Japanese inside the
30:13perimeter that day. 150 yards by 100 yards. That is an area you could walk across in under a minute,
30:21and it took the better part of a day, tree by tree, with men who had been awake for 30
30:27hours.
30:29Futumiya himself was not among the dead that day. He and a small group stayed alive inside the American
30:35lines for roughly two days, with the regimental colors still with them. Somewhere in the Japanese chain of
30:42command, the knowledge that a regimental color was still flying inside the American position
30:46was one of the reasons the belief in a victory took so long to die. He was killed. So were
30:53the
30:53men with him. Every group that broke through that night was hunted down over the following days.
31:00When the Americans went through the ground afterward, they found a notebook on a Japanese officer who had
31:05died in there. He had written that he did not know what excuse to give, and that he was sorry
31:10for what he had done.
31:12He wrote about his men and about the loss of the regimental flag. And then he wrote that he was
31:19going
31:19to return his borrowed life that day, with short interest. There is no propaganda in that. There is
31:27no emperor in it, and no talk of glory. It is a man who had finally seen the true size
31:33of the thing his
31:34army was attacking, sitting in the middle of it, doing arithmetic on his own life.
31:40That notebook reached American intelligence. It never reached Tokyo. By half past seven that morning,
31:47General Nasu had pulled the survivors of his wing back into the jungle to reorganize,
31:53because he intended to attack again that night. He did. And the second night was worse than the first.
32:01By the time the sun came up on the 26th of October, the Japanese 2nd Division had lost a major
32:07general,
32:07two regimental commanders, and four battalion commanders, all in a single night. Afterward,
32:14Chesty Puller insisted that division headquarters send out a formal detail to count the Japanese dead
32:19in front of his position. The number they came back with is the reason the Japanese army stopped
32:25talking about Guadalcanal. Before I give you the number, you should know how it was arrived at.
32:30Puller did not want an estimate. He wanted a count. So a detail went out in front of the American
32:37line,
32:37into ground that had been fought over for two nights in the tropics,
32:41and they counted the Japanese dead as they buried them. 1,462. In the sector held by the North Dakota
32:50Guardsmen, the burial parties put 975 bodies into the ground in front of two rifle companies,
32:56K Company and L Company. Two companies. American dead for the entire battle, across three days and
33:04every sector, were somewhere between 61 and 86 men. That is not a hard-fought victory. That is a machine
33:13running correctly against men who could not see what they were walking into.
33:19Now let me take you back to the night that produced those numbers, because how it happened matters more
33:24than the arithmetic. At 8 in the evening on the 25th of October, Mariyama committed his last reserve,
33:31the 16th Infantry Regiment, and sent it in beside what was left of Nasu's wing. Through the night,
33:37they came at Puller and Hall in a series of frontal attacks. Waiting for them this time was a line
33:43that had
33:44had a full day to prepare. Rifles, machine guns, mortars, divisional artillery, and 37-millimeter
33:51anti-tank guns firing canister at close range. Essentially, a cannon firing a shotgun shell into
33:57massed infantry. Colonel Toshiro Hiroyasu, commanding the 16th, was killed. Most of his staff were killed with him.
34:05Four Japanese battalion commanders were killed. General Nasu, who commanded the entire left wing,
34:13was hit by rifle fire and died a few hours later. Stop and count that with me, because I do
34:19not think
34:19most people have ever had it put in front of them. In one night, on one hillside, the Japanese 2nd
34:27division lost a major general, two regimental commanders, and four battalion commanders.
34:34Futumiya was already gone inside the wire. Why were so many senior officers that far forward?
34:41Because that was the only reconnaissance system they had left.
34:45Think about what we have followed for three months now. Patrols sent out and killed. A brigade attacking
34:52ground no officer had looked at. A division commander four miles wrong about his own position.
34:58When an army cannot see, the only way an officer learns what is in front of him is to go
35:04and stand
35:05in it personally. So they went. Colonels went. A major general went. The Japanese army was, by the end,
35:15paying for reconnaissance with general officers. And it was still not getting the information.
35:22Here is the proof of that. And it is almost unbearable. While Nasu's men were dying in front of
35:28Puller, Colonel Shoji's entire right wing, thousands of men, did not attack at all.
35:35They stayed where they were, covering Nasu's flank against an American counter-attack that was never
35:41coming, and that nobody had any evidence of. And Colonel Oka, out west near the Matanikau,
35:48whose attack was supposed to pull American attention away from the main effort, arrived 48 hours late.
35:55His men went in when the battle they were meant to support had already been lost.
36:00Oka's attack came at 3 in the morning on the 26th, against the 2nd Battalion, 7th Marines,
36:05under Herman Haneken, dug in along a saddle ridge. It fell hardest on F Company, holding the far left
36:12of the position. A machine gun section under Mitchell Page stood in the way of it, and Page's guns killed
36:19a great many Japanese soldiers that night. But the fire coming back killed or wounded nearly every gunner
36:25he had. At 5 in the morning, a Japanese battalion got up the steep face of the ridge and pushed
36:31what
36:31was left of F Company off the crest. That was it. That was the single piece of ground the Japanese
36:38army took away from the Americans in the entire battle. A ridge crest, at 5 in the morning, on the
36:45last day. They held it for about an hour. Major Odell Connolly was Haneken's executive officer,
36:52which means he was the battalion's administrator. When the crest went, he did not wait for a rifle
36:58company to be found and moved up. He grabbed whoever was standing near the command post.
37:03He got 17 men. Communication specialists. Messmen. A cook. A bandsman. That is the counterattack.
37:1317 men, most of whom had not carried a rifle forward in months, going up a hill at first light
37:20to take
37:20back a crest from a Japanese battalion, before the Japanese could dig in on it. Elements of two other
37:27companies and the unwounded survivors of F Company came in behind them. By 6 in the morning, the ridge
37:33was American again. The marines counted 98 Japanese dead on the crest, and roughly 200 more in the ravine
37:41below it. Haneken's battalion lost 14 killed and 32 wounded. Hold on to that cook, because he is the
37:49entire argument of the story standing in one place. Two nights earlier, a hundred Japanese soldiers had
37:57broken into the American rear and discovered there was no soft part to break into. This is what that
38:03actually meant on the ground. When the American line finally cracked, at the very last hour of the battle,
38:10the thing that came up the hill to seal it was the battalion clerks and the man who cooked the
38:16breakfast.
38:17An army has no depth when its cooks are cooks. It has depth when its cooks are a reserve.
38:25At 8 in the morning on the 26th of October, Hyakutake called off all further attacks and ordered his
38:31forces to withdraw. The greatest effort the Japanese army ever made on Guadalcanal was over, and it had
38:38gained nothing at all. Some 3,000 men were dead. The division that had marched up that trail with shells
38:46on their backs was no longer capable of offensive operations, and never would be again. And now the
38:52survivors had to walk home. Whatever the Japanese army finally understood about the Americans on
38:58Guadalcanal, it did not learn it from a scout, a prisoner, or a captured map. It learned it on the
39:04walk back down that trail. October 27, 1942. The Maruyama Trail, somewhere in the interior.
39:13The survivors of the left wing started back down the path their own engineers had cut.
39:18They had run out of food several days before the attack. Now they had to cover 15 miles of ravines
39:24and river crossings and greased ridges in the other direction, carrying their wounded.
39:29A lieutenant named Keijiro Minegishi wrote in his diary on that march that he had never imagined going
39:35back over the same mountain trail they had crossed with such enthusiasm. He had not eaten in three days.
39:41Walking had become difficult. Going uphill, his body swayed, and he could not keep his feet,
39:46and he had to stop and rest every two meters. Every two meters. Men who could not go on were
39:53buried along that trail as they died. The leading elements did not reach the 17th army headquarters
39:59at Kokumbona until the 4th of November. It had taken them longer to walk home beaten than it had
40:05taken to walk in. Shoji's wing, the thousands of men who had spent the decisive night guarding a flank
40:12nobody was attacking, was sent east to Kohli Point. American forces went after them there,
40:19and a Marine battalion harried them for most of the way back. Shoji had started that campaign with about
40:253,000 men. About 700 of them reached Kokumbona. Some were killed in the fighting around Kohli Point.
40:32Many more simply did not survive the march.
40:36So, after all of it, after the dead patrols, the tortured scout who said nothing, the brigade that
40:44attacked ground it had never seen, the division that carried shells 15 miles for one gun,
40:50the hundred men who got inside and could not send a word out. What did the Japanese finally report?
40:59Start with the simplest version, because Maruyama said it himself while the battle was still going on.
41:04He signaled Hyakutake that he could not penetrate the American perimeter. Not that he needed more men,
41:10or more time, or better artillery. That it could not be done. Then the honest version. And I told you
41:18earlier it was coming. Colonel Masanobu Tsuji, the staff officer Hyakutake had sent forward to watch the
41:25division on that trail, went back to Tokyo in person. He first argued for reinforcements. Then,
41:32he accepted that nothing could get through, and recommended that Japan evacuate the island.
41:37He told Imperial General Headquarters that he took full responsibility, that he had underestimated the
41:43enemy, and had insisted on a flawed plan. His words were that he deserved 10,000 deaths.
41:51That is the man they called the god of operations, the planner of the conquest of Malaya, saying plainly
41:58that he had been wrong about the Americans. But neither of those is the real report. The real one came
42:04later,
42:05and it is a single number, and it explains everything you have heard for the last hour.
42:11After the war, General Miyazaki, the 17th Army's Chief of Staff, was asked about supply. He testified that,
42:19of everything dispatched from Rabao to Guadalcanal, only 20 percent ever arrived. Twenty percent?
42:28For every five tons Japan loaded at Rabao, one ton reached the hands of a Japanese soldier. The other four
42:36went to the bottom, burned on a beach, or sat in a warehouse no ship would risk.
42:42That is why Minigishi was resting every two meters.
42:46That is why the guns were left on the trail.
42:49That is why an entire division attacked the most important position in the Pacific on half rations.
42:56Now set that beside the thing I asked you to remember at the beginning. 973 battleship shells
43:03into Henderson Field in 83 minutes on the 14th of October. 48 aircraft destroyed. Nearly all the
43:12fuel burned. One runway operational again the same morning. If you take one thing from this story,
43:20take this. The Japanese army spent six months trying to answer the question,
43:25how many Americans are there? It was the wrong question, and getting the right answer would not
43:32have saved a single one of their soldiers. Because the Americans on Guadalcanal were not a quantity.
43:38They were a rate. You could destroy 48 aircraft, and there would be aircraft flying by lunchtime.
43:45You could kill the men in a machine gun position, and a cook would be behind the gun by dawn.
43:50You could break a hundred men through the wire, and find that the wire was the outermost skin
43:55of something that regenerated faster than you could damage it. Every accurate report that ever came
44:01out of that perimeter, in whatever words, was saying the same thing. Not, there are more of them
44:07than we thought. Something worse. There is no number at which this stops. That is what the men in the
44:15tree line saw at sunrise. That is what the notebook in the dead officer's pocket was circling around.
44:21And it never reached anyone who could act on it. And here is the detail that finishes it.
44:27Before the campaign even began, back in Tokyo, Miyazaki had asked himself the correct question.
44:34Was the American landing the whole of the enemy effort? Or was it the leading edge of something
44:40much larger? He wrote that if it was the first, Japan would certainly succeed. And if it was the second,
44:47the outcome hung in the balance.
44:50He asked the right question in the summer of 1942. The Japanese army then spent six months,
44:57three offensives, and roughly 20,000 lives, behaving as though it had already been answered,
45:02because the men who could have answered it kept getting killed. And the men who came back
45:07with answers nobody wanted were told they were mistaken. Japan gave up Guadalcanal
45:13and evacuated the last of its troops in the first week of February, 1943.
45:19The Second Division, the Sendai, the pride of the Imperial Japanese Army, went home a defensive
45:25formation. It never mounted a major offensive again. There is one more thing to tell you,
45:32and it is about the people rather than the argument. Because some of the men in this story
45:37lived long enough to see exactly what that night had been worth. And one of them went on wearing an
45:43American uniform for the next 42 years, late October 1942. 3,000 yards in front of the American line,
45:52south of Henderson Field. Sergeant Ralph Briggs and the men of that listening post came back in.
45:58They had lain in the wet grass and let 7,000 men walk past them. They had made one telephone
46:05call.
46:06Then they had stayed out there in the dark while the whole thing happened, on the wrong side of a
46:11battle,
46:11with nothing to do but wait for it to end, and hope somebody on their own line recognized them when
46:18they came through. They came through. Nobody made a film about that outpost. There is no memorial to 47
46:26men who lay still. But every account of that battle turns on the fact that Puller knew what was coming
46:33half an hour before it arrived. And he knew it because Briggs did not move.
46:40Puller's battalion finished that battle with 24 men dead, 28 wounded, and two missing.
46:46He noted in his report that his outfit's total casualties on Guadalcanal now stood at 24% of its strength.
46:55That is what those three nights cost the men who held the line. 24 dead against 1,462 buried in
47:04front of them.
47:05John Bassalone was given the Medal of Honor for those five minutes with his machine guns.
47:10He was sent home to sell war bonds, hated it, and asked to go back to the fleet. He was
47:16killed on Iwo Jima in 1945.
47:20Mitchell Page received the Medal of Honor for the Ridge.
47:23Robert Hall, the National Guard officer who fed farm boys from North Dakota into a Marine firing line
47:30in the dark and the rain, and got every one of them in place before daylight, received the Navy Cross.
47:37Puller put him up for it himself, which if you know anything about Marines and the Army in 1942,
47:43tells you a great deal.
47:45The Marines had been fighting alone on that island for two months and had strong opinions about soldiers.
47:52After the 25th of October, a lot of those opinions quietly went away.
47:58Men from the 164th and men from the 7th Marines had held the same stretch of wire in the same
48:05dark, and that settled it. Nobody recorded the name of the cook. And Jacob Vooza, who was tied to a
48:13tree
48:13and asked the question this whole story turns on, and who did not answer it, lived a long life.
48:20The British gave him the George Medal. The Americans gave him the Silver Star and the Legion of Merit.
48:26The 1st Marine Division made him an honorary member, and put him in a Marine uniform with
48:31Sergeant Major's stripes. And he wore that uniform for the rest of his life. He was knighted in 1979.
48:39He died in 1984. In 1962, he sent a message to the 1st Marine Division Association.
48:48He said he was an old man now, and no longer looked good. Then he added four words,
48:54But me never forget. On the other side, Colonel Furumiya, who got closer to the answer than any
49:01Japanese officer of the campaign, is buried on Guadalcanal. So is General Nasu. So is Colonel
49:09Hiroyasu. The Sendai Division was evacuated in February 1943 and never mounted a major attack again.
49:17Masanobu Tsuji, who said he deserved 10,000 deaths, was quietly moved to a headquarters in Nanking.
49:24Then to Burma. He avoided prosecution after the war by hiding in Thailand, came home in 1949,
49:32was elected to the Japanese parliament, and in 1961 walked into Laos and was never seen again.
49:40And Harupichi Hyaktake, who commanded the 17th Army through all of it, got one more chance.
49:47In March 1944, on Bougainville, he attacked an American perimeter at Empress Augusta Bay.
49:54His intelligence told him he faced about 30,000 Americans, 10,000 of whom he was assured were
50:00airfield ground crews with no fighting value. He was facing 62,000 men. He attacked with 15,000.
50:09He lost more than 5,000 killed and 3,000 wounded. American ground forces lost 263 dead.
50:16Same commander, same mistake. 18 months later, on a different island, in front of a different American
50:24perimeter that also turned out to have no soft part in it. So here is the answer, as plainly as
50:30it can be put. The Japanese scouts who reached the American rear and lived did not come back with a
50:37count of men or guns or aircraft. They came back with something about time. They had seen a place
50:44that repaired itself faster than Japan could break it, that put fighters in the air the same morning it
50:49took 973 battleship shells, that filled a hole in its line with a bandsman and a cook. You cannot defeat
50:58that by getting through the wire. There is nothing on the other side of the wire to reach. That is
51:05not a compliment to American courage, although the courage was there in every foxhole on that line.
51:11It is something colder and more permanent. It is a description of what a country can do when it
51:17decides to. And the tragedy for them, and the reason so many of them are still on that island,
51:24is that the men who understood it were lying in the trees with no radio, or bleeding out in a
51:29foxhole
51:30writing an apology in a notebook, while a message, that was not true, went to rabaul in under two
51:36hours and put a cruiser to sea. An army is not what it knows, it is what it can hear.
51:44Thank you for spending this time with me, and with them. If this story meant something to you,
51:50a like really does help it reach the people who would want to hear it. And most of those people
51:55are
51:55not looking for it. They just come across it. Subscribing and turning on the bell means you
52:02will not miss the next one, and I would like to know where you are watching from tonight.
52:07If your father, your grandfather, or your uncle served in the Second World War,
52:12tell me about him in the comments. Their names deserve to be typed out somewhere. I read them.
Comments