00:28Transcription by ESO
00:31Yes, Emil, dito nga sa impeachment court ay inaharap ngayon ng prosecution panel ang isang state auditor ng Commission on
00:39Audit.
00:39Ito po ay nagtestify kaugnay sa audit na ginawa niya sa mahigit 600 million pesos na confidential fund ni Vice
00:47President Sara Duterte para sa taong 2022 at 2023
00:51na ayon po sa prosecution panel ay hindi umano na gamit sa tamang paraan.
01:01Labing limang kahon na may markang confidential fund ang bit-bit ng prosecution panel sa impeachment trial ngayong araw.
01:09Ang inupong testigo kaugnay nito, si Roderick Wamil, state auditor ng Commission on Audit o COA,
01:15na siyang nag-audit sa paggamit ng pondo ng tanggapan ni Vice President Sara Duterte at ng Department of Education
01:22habang ito ay pinamumunuan ng bisi.
01:25Ayon kay Wamil, nakitaan niya ng paglabag sa mga alituntuni ng COA ang dalawang tanggapan sa liquidation ng confidential fund.
01:34Gaya ng hindi pagbibigay na specific confidential activity, hindi nagtutugmang pecha ng dokumento, kulang-kulang na liquidation documents at iba
01:43pa.
01:43Pinakita sa iyo ang isang physical financial plan, and this is now being shown on the screen.
01:49Ano, ano-ano ang observations mo dito sa physical and financial plan approved on December 13, 2022?
02:01Hindi po siya compliant to the Joint Circular dahil yung first column, which is the programs, activities and projects,
02:09hindi po in-indicate ng OBP yung kanilang specific confidential activities na kanilang paggagamitan ng confidential fund as required under
02:19item 4.2 of the Joint Circular.
02:23Isa rin sa binanggit niya, ang 125 million pesos ng Office of the Vice President para sa huling quarter ng
02:302022 na ginastosaniya sa loob ng labing isang araw.
02:35Bakit mo napansin itong period na ito?
02:38Napansin ko lang naman po yun kasi yung kanilang cash advance based on the physical and financial plan po supposedly
02:44is for the whole fourth quarter of 2022.
02:48Pero based on this document po, na-disperse lang siya from December 21 to 31, 2022 or around 11 days.
02:56May mga dokumentong pirmado ng BSE, gaya ng physical and financial plan at accomplishment reports.
03:02Kaninong signature itong nakikita natin dito?
03:07Ito po ay signature ni Vice Presidente Sara Duterte.
03:12At anong ibig sabihin under your circular ng attested?
03:19Ang ibig sabihin po ng attested ay kanyang kinoconfirm at bine-verify na yung contents ng certification na ito ay
03:26totoo.
03:26Ang confidential fund ay pondong inilaan para sa confidential expenses, gaya ng surveillance activities, pagbili na impormasyon, pagbibigay na reward
03:35sa impormante, pagbabayat sa safe houses at iba pa.
03:39Matapos makita ang mga paglabag, sinabi ni Wabil na nagsubmit ang OVP ng Revised Accomplishment Report.
03:46Pero may nakita pa rin ilang gastos na hindi pinahihintulutan.
03:51I'm based on this document po, some of the line items as presented po na confidential expenses ay hindi among
03:59the allowable expenses under item 4.8 of the joint circular.
04:04Yung provision of medical and food aid for 40 million pesos at yung payment of incentives or traveling relative to
04:11confidential operations na 10 million pesos.
04:14Nakita rin ang COA na ginamit ang confidential fund pambili ng lamesa, upuan, computer, pero wala raw resibo, kundi acknowledgement
04:23receipt lang.
04:24May napansin din siya sa pecha ng ilan sa mga ito.
04:27Napansin ko na some of the payments were dated December 2023, which is beyond the scope po nung covered ng
04:34kanilang cash advances.
04:37And yun nga po, katulad nung nasabi ko kanina, may mga payment of rewards po sila, either in cash, in
04:44medicines, and in various goods.
04:45Pero wala na po silang sinamit na any document na support or evidence, document evidencing the success of the information
04:53gathering activity on account of the information given by the informer.
04:58Pinanggit sa korte ang ilan sa mga tumanggap ng pera, bukod pa sa isang Mary Grace Piatos.
05:03So, ina-acknowledge ng isang Mary Grace Piatos na tumanggap siya na magkano?
05:11Based from this acknowledgement receipt po, tumanggap po si Mary Grace Piatos ng 70,000 pesos for the payment of
05:18rewards, close in open parenthesis, medicines.
05:21Pag merong pangalang Mary Grace Piatos, e kayo ba ay nag-i-investigate?
05:26Or kasama ba ng post-audit nyo ang mag-assertin?
05:30Sino ba itong Mary Grace Piatos?
05:35Since what we do po is compliance audit,
05:38So, ang nagiging basihan lang po namin ng audit ay kung ano yung nakalagay or piniprescribe ng Joint Circular 2015
05:46-01.
05:47Pero dun sa Joint Circular naman po kasi, hindi naman nakalagay doon na kailangan tingnan namin yung recipient ng payment.
05:54In the name of Odie or Andy C. Lim, for 50,000 pesos.
06:03Andy, ah!
06:07Andy Lim!
06:09Kanya ko pala hindi mabasa, Andy Lim.
06:13Para kay Andy Lim.
06:1650,000 pesos.
06:18Ang date, 12-21-2023.
06:22Yung date of payment po, December 27, 2023, is outside the coverage po nung kanilang period of disbursement.
06:29Kung merong Andy Lim, siguro dahil piquit.
06:33Objection, Your Honor.
06:34I'm sorry, but I've been giving leeway to opposing counsel, but I think she's been coloring, you know, the contents
06:41of the documents more than what is shown in the documents itself.
06:43Your Honor, I'm just reading. It says here.
06:45No, Your Honor.
06:46It says Andy Lim. And the next one, maybe you will object again, it's Alejandro A. Piquit.
06:52I was gonna say, kanya siguro madali, may pikit ang mata.
06:55Counsel, counsel for the panel of prosecutors, I think you know what the counsel for the respondent is talking about.
07:00Yes.
07:01Can they proceed accordingly?
07:02Nang sumahin daw ito ni Wamil, lumabas na ang halagang nakasaad sa acknowledgement receipts, sobra sa nakalagay sa acknowledgement report
07:11ng OVP.
07:11Magkano ba ang binigay na confidential funds?
07:15Based on the documents submitted to Iqpaw, 125 million pesos po.
07:21May discrepancy? Hindi tugma, 150,000 na butal.
07:27Based on the documents po, yes, may discrepancy po yung acknowledgement receipts and the accomplishment report.
07:36Amil, bukas ay inaasahan na sasalang sa cross-examination ng abogado ni Vice President Sara Duterte.
07:43Itong si Wamil, pagkatapos po meron pa isang witness, isa ring state auditor ng Commission on Audit, ang isasalang bukas.
07:51Amil?
07:52Maraming salamat, Sandra Aguinaldo.