• 4 months ago
June 9, 1913

Luther Z. Rosser, chief of counsel for Leo M. Frank, issued the first public statement Tuesday that he has made since the arrest of the factory superintendent six weeks ago on the suspicion of being the murderer of Mary Phagan.

He took occasion to point out many of the absurdities in the stories of the negro Jim Conley, and paid his respects in a forcible manner both to Chief of Detectives Lanford and Colonel Thomas B. Felder, who have been accusing each other of trying to protect Frank.

Mr. Rosser explained the violation of his invariable custom of maintaining absolute silence in regard to a case in which he was interested by calling attention to the prejudice that had been aroused in the public mind against Frank by the controversy between Lanford and Colonel Felder.

His statement, in full, follows:

Mr. Rosser's Statement.

Editor, Atlanta Georgian:

Felder and Lanford, in an effort to make progress in their feud, charge each the other with giving aid to Leo Frank, Lanford charges that Felder was employed by Frank and is seeking for that reason to shield him. Felder charges that Lanford and his associates are also seeking, for some reason, to shield and protect Frank.

Both charges are untrue, and, at a time when no harm could come to an innocent man, might well be treated as antidotes to monotony.

Unfortunately, however, the present situation is such that fair-minded citizens may be misled by these counter charges.

Felder does not, nor has he at any time, directly or indirectly, represented Frank. For Lanford to charge the contrary does Frank a serious injustice.

Felder Against Frank.

If Chief Lanford had been in a sane, normal mood, he would have known that every act of Felder has been against Frank. The engagement of the Burns agency ought to have satisfied Lanford. No detective agency of half prudence would have double-crossed the Atlanta department in the Phagan case. Nor did Felder have excuse for suspicion against Lanford. There was reason to suspect his fairness, his accuracy and the soundness of his methods, but not his reckless zeal against Frank.

Had Felder been in a calm mood I am sure he would never have charged the chief and his associates with intention to help Frank.

Lanford at once, as soon as Felder charged him with favoring Frank, settled in his mind the guilt of Frank, and from that monent has bent every energy of his department, not in finding the murderer, but in trying to prove to the public that Felder was wrong in charging him with trying to shield Frank.

Frank Found Clean.

His department has exhausted itself in an effort to fix upon Frank an immoral life, on the theory that a violator of the seventh commandment was likewise a murderer. This effort has failed. No man in Atlanta has had his moral character subjected to such a test and there is not in the whole city of Atlanta a half dozen men who could have more successfully stood the test.
Transcript
00:00Rosser Asks Grand Jury Grill for Conley. The Atlanta Georgian, June 9, 1913.
00:06Luther Z. Rosser, Chief of Counsel for Leo M. Frank, issued the first public statement Tuesday
00:11that he has made since the arrest of the factory superintendent six weeks ago on the suspicion of
00:16being the murderer of Mary Fagan. He took occasion to point out many of the absurdities in the stories
00:22of the Negro Jim Conley, and paid his respects in a forcible manner both to Chief of Detectives
00:27Lanford and Colonel Thomas B. Felder, who have been accusing each other of trying to protect Frank.
00:32Mr. Rosser explained the violation of his invariable custom of maintaining absolute silence in regard
00:39to a case in which he was interested by calling attention to the prejudice that had been aroused
00:43in the public mind against Frank by the controversy between Lanford and Colonel Felder. His statement
00:49in full follows Mr. Rosser's statement. Editor, Atlanta Georgian, Felder and Lanford, in an effort
00:56to make progress in their feud, charge each the other with giving aid to Leo Frank, Lanford charges
01:01that Felder was employed by Frank, and is seeking for that reason to shield him. Felder charges that
01:07Lanford and his associates are also seeking for some reason to shield and protect Frank.
01:11Both charges are untrue, and at a time when no harm could come to an innocent man, might well be
01:17treated as antidotes to monotony. Unfortunately, however, the present situation is such that fair-minded
01:22citizens may be misled by these counter-charges. Felder does not, nor has he at any time directly
01:28or indirectly represented Frank. For Lanford to charge the contrary does Frank a serious injustice,
01:34Felder against Frank. If Chief Lanford had been in a sane, normal mood, he would have known that
01:39every act of Felder has been against Frank. The engagement of the Burns agency ought to have
01:44satisfied Lanford. No detective agency of half-prudence would have double-crossed the Atlanta
01:49department in the Fagin case. Nor did Felder have excuse for suspicion against Lanford.
01:55There was reason to suspect his fairness, his accuracy, and the soundness of his methods,
01:59but not his reckless zeal against Frank. Had Felder been in a calm mood, I am sure he would
02:05never have charged the Chief and his associates with intention to help Frank. Lanford at once,
02:10as soon as Felder charged him with favoring Frank, settled in his mind the guilt of Frank,
02:15and from that moment has bent every energy of his department, not in finding the murderer,
02:20but in trying to prove to the public that Felder was wrong in charging him with trying to shield
02:25Frank. Frank found clean. His department has exhausted itself in an effort to fix upon Frank
02:31an immoral life, on the theory that a violator of the Seventh Commandment was likewise a murderer.
02:36This effort has failed. No man in Atlanta has had his moral character subjected to such a test,
02:42and there is not in the whole city of Atlanta a half-dozen men who could have more successfully
02:47stood the test. His employees, without a single exception, have made affidavits to his uprightness.
02:53Lanford's department subpoenaed every one of them before the coroner's jury,
02:57and after keeping them more than two days, did not dare to swear a single one of them.
03:02Before and after the coroner's verdict, this whole city has been continued on page 2,
03:06column 1. Eyewitness to Fagin killing now sought story. That companion of Conley saw
03:12him strike down girl opens new clues. Continued from page 1, combed with a fine-tooth comb and
03:18a light combing has been applied to Brooklyn, the city of his birth, to find something against
03:22his moral character. With what result? The silence of the detective department gives the answer.
03:28Drivel and nonsense! Lanford's conduct in connection while you tie the woman Formby and
03:33the negro Conley shows that he was stung by Felder's charge that he was favoring Frank,
03:37or that for some other reason he was temporarily out of his head. He swallowed whole the statements
03:42of this Formby woman, bearing upon their face the clear proof that they were by no means to be
03:47believed. This woman was not unknown to Lanford. She did not entrap him by appearing under the guise
03:53of a truthful, sober, virtuous woman. But so absorbed was he, either in trying to disprove
03:58Felder's charge, or in the foolish pride of opinion that he accepted without doubt or fair investigation
04:04the drived and nonsense of this woman. So far beside himself did he become that he had the folly
04:09to furnish to the papers, based upon this woman's statement, the theory that Frank, during the night
04:14of the murder, wishing to rid himself of the body, was seeking to do so in a room rented from
04:20this woman.
04:20The folly and difficulties of the theory did not disturb Lanford. They would have disturbed
04:25anybody but Lanford. His insane desire to justify himself cleared the matter of all difficulties and
04:31follies. Conley's actions. If the case of the Formby woman did not clear Lanford of Felder's
04:36charge, that of the Conley negro ought to have done so. Conley is a very ordinary, ignorant,
04:42brutal negro, not unacquainted with the stockade. His actions immediately after the crime were suspicious,
04:48so much so that they attracted the attention of the employees of the factory,
04:51and occasioned general comment. In spite of these facts, Conley was not taken into custody until
04:58several days after the crime, and not then until the employees of the factory caught him suspiciously
05:03washing a shirt, and as a result reported him to the police. He was not brought before the coroner's
05:09jury, and practically no notice was taken of him in that investigation. So swiftly was Lanford and his
05:15associates pursuing Frank that they ran over this negro, standing in their path with the marks of
05:20guilt clearly upon him. Finally, the pressure of public suspicion brought this negro to Lanford's
05:26attention. Conley began to talk, and negro liked to talk so as to protect himself, and as a means
05:32thereto to cast suspicion upon someone else. Ordinarily, the detectives could be trusted not
05:38to aid the negro in an effort to clear himself by placing the crime on a white man, but in
05:43this case
05:43it is to be feared that the negro was not discouraged. Lanford had finally banked all his sense,
05:49all his reputation as a man and a politician upon Frank's guilt, and it would be remarkable if the
05:54discouraged this negro from involving Frank. If Lanford and his followers had acted wisely,
06:00and kept open minds seeking only the murderer, and not seeking to vindicate their announced
06:05opinions the negro would have by this hold the whole truth. Varying affidavits. Conley made one
06:12statement. It did not meet the announced opinions of Lanford. He made another. This second was not up to
06:18the mark. It did not sufficiently show Frank's guilt. Another was made, which was supposed to
06:23be nearer the mark, whereupon there was great rejoicing. Forgetting all others, this last statement
06:29reached through such great tribulations, was proclaimed the truth, the last truth, and that
06:35there would be no other statement. The detectives had at last got the statement which they thought
06:39sustained their views, saved their reputations, and ensured their places. But what a statement!
06:45So full of contradiction, so evidently made for self-protection, and wherein was so easily
06:50apparent the guiding hand of detectives. If Lanford meant to be fair, if was only seeking
06:55the truth, why did he rush into print with the assertion that this statement was the truth,
07:00and therefore of necessity the last? Might he not in decency have left this negro to his own will,
07:06unbiased by the opinion that the statement was true and the last to be given? Who knows but that
07:11this negro might have given numerous other statements if he had not been so heavily handicapped
07:16by Lanford's opinion? The truth is this negro is not to give any other or further statement if the
07:22detective department can prevent, unless made under their supervision and direction. He must at all
07:28times be under the influence and control of Lanford. He must have Lanford's sucking bottle at all times
07:33to his lips, sucking Lanford's views and theories of this case. The ragged places in his statement must be
07:39darned, the torn places patched, and no one but the detective department could be trusted to do that.
07:45Demands fairness. No one has been rude enough to bring this negro before the grand jury, nor indeed
07:50to make any charge against him. After the statement of this negro, and in view of all the evidence which
07:55so strongly points to him as the slayer of little Mary Fagan, is the grand jury to leave him without
08:00charge or investigation to be wet-nursed by Lanford until Frank's trial? Or is it the purpose to keep the
08:06negro's case from the grand jury in the nature of an offered reward to spur him on to swear his
08:11worst
08:11against the white man? Would it not be just and decent to bring this negro's case before the grand
08:16jury, and let that body hear his confession so that it can then decide whether the negro should
08:21then be indicted? In the shadow of this great crime, let there be no thimble ringing. Let no single fact
08:28be
08:28concealed. Let no man's place or reputation stand in the way of the fullest, fairest investigation.
08:34Respectfully, signed, Luther Z. Rosser

Recommended