Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 5 minutes ago
Has fear of crime turned Birmingham city centre into somewhere people think twice about visiting? With footfall falling, major shops closing, dirty streets, roadworks, parking costs and the Clean Air Zone all part of the debate, we ask whether the city is facing a confidence crisis.
Transcript
00:00Far fewer people are choosing to visit Birmingham City Centre.
00:05Analysis from Avis & Young reported by Visitor Insights
00:09found footfall was 19% lower currently than in 2022,
00:15although that year was boosted by the Commonwealth Games.
00:18I'd have to say, as sort of having grown older,
00:21it's a place I go to less often, and when I do go there,
00:25I tend to feel, and perhaps it's an age thing,
00:29the demographic, or the age population, has shifted notably.
00:35It's not the place where all people tend to go into shop,
00:39and of course you see that by the shops that have closed down.
00:42And also, what's of course a bit disconcerting,
00:44you see lots of security guards on shops,
00:46which of course is to deal with shoplifting and so on and so forth.
00:49I suspect that Birmingham is no worse than many other cities,
00:52so you've got to put these things in context.
00:54But undoubtedly, there are particular issues,
00:58and of course can only be solved, I guess, by sort of greater policing.
01:01But of course the policing is a really difficult task at the moment,
01:04because if you go in too heavily handed,
01:06then of course that causes you problems.
01:08But of course the sort of, they softly, softly,
01:10perhaps that's not sort of having the desired effect.
01:13So the difficulty is that, yeah,
01:16Birmingham has had enough bad news in sort of recent years
01:19to last a lifetime, as it were.
01:22And so the difficulty it has,
01:24if it continues to get this really dreadful publicity,
01:27and of course social media plays its role in this,
01:30then it's got to do something,
01:31because of course international investors,
01:33or I mean domestic investors,
01:34they're not going to want to come to it.
01:36And we've seen some major retailers disappear.
01:38So something should be done.
01:41The real difficulty is that how soon can it be done,
01:43and the amount of resource that's got to go into it.
01:46Crime is a central issue.
01:49West Midlands Police have reported city centre incidents recently,
01:53including a serious stabbing in Victoria Square,
01:56disorder involving teenagers,
01:58knife recoveries and arrests linked to planned disruption.
02:02Officers say Project Guardian is targeting youth violence and knife crime
02:07through patrols, searches and prevention work.
02:10But perception matters too.
02:13TikTok and YouTube clips showing large groups of young people on busy streets
02:18have helped shape fears about whether the city centre feels safe.
02:24School kids, they like to congregate.
02:25Nothing new in that.
02:27But there is no doubt perhaps there's a greater,
02:29if I use that sort of that word,
02:31edginess to sort of the fact these kids do,
02:33and of course they do it for social media purposes.
02:35It's not a good look.
02:36Birmingham is changing.
02:38Public round works are improving areas around New Street,
02:41Temple Street and routes towards Victoria Square,
02:45while Metro, bus and rail investment is reshaping access.
02:50The challenge now is whether those cleaner streets,
02:53stronger policing and major regeneration
02:55can restore confidence and bring visitors back.
02:59So thank you very much.
02:59So thank you.
Comments

Recommended