VIDEO OF MIRIAM DEFENSOR APPEARS IN VP SARA TRIAL

The defense presented a video of the late senator Miriam Defensor Santiago questioning the prosecution team after the withdrawal of articles during the impeachment trial of former chief justice Renato Corona.

House prosecutor Atty. Chel Diokno objected to the presentation, saying it was a different story. However, the court overruled the objection and allowed the video to be shown.

The video was presented after the defense asked the witness whether the withdrawal of impeachment articles could weaken the allegations against the respondent. (Video courtesy of Senate of the Philippines)

Subscribe to the Manila Bulletin Online channel! -
https://www.youtube.com/TheManilaBulletin

Visit our website at http://mb.com.ph
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/manilabulletin
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/manila_bulletin
Instagram: https://instagram.com/manilabulletin
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@manilabulletin

#VPSaraOnTrial
#ManilaBulletinOnline
#ManilaBulletin
#LatestNews

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00How would you characterize po yung strength po, yung lakas ng allegation kapag gawin ni Drono po?
00:05Well, I leave it to the sound wisdom, sound discretion of the Honorable Impeachment Court.
00:10How would they assess the strength or the weakness or the fact that it was withdrawn?
00:16So I leave it to the wisdom po.
00:18All right. Thank you.
00:18Now, let me show you a video and then ask you thereafter.
00:22Your Honor, this video is unmarked, but we reserve the right to mark it at the proper time.
00:27This is around seven minutes, Your Honor, so we beg the court's indulgence.
00:32If we may be allowed to play, Your Honor.
00:35Before the video is played, Honorable Chell?
00:37Yes, I see from the caption that the video pertains to statements made by the late Senator Miriam, Defensor Sanchago.
00:45I believe that would pertain to the Corona Impeachment Trial.
00:50That's correct.
00:50Yes, then I would have to object, Your Honor, because the circumstances pertaining to that trial are different in terms
00:57of the withdrawal to this trial and the situation here.
01:01I have no question yet.
01:02We are aware of that, counsel.
01:06Again, subject to cross, insofar as pointing that out is concerned, is there a shorter version of this, Attorney Mark?
01:14I distinctly remember, actually, what Senator Miriam said in this.
01:18Well, we will ask a certain portion of that material, Your Honor, if you may be allowed to.
01:24Yes, when you get to that point, you can pause it already.
01:29All right, thank you, Your Honor.
01:31Tech is instructed to play the video.
01:33There is no further meaning factor that prevents you from presenting your evidence that you already said to us in
01:44January you are going to present.
01:45Letter C is merely corroborative or cumulative.
01:49This does not apply because when you file an impeachment complaint, you have different articles of impeachment which are separate
01:56from and independent of each other.
01:57So, none of these articles of impeachment, just like causes of action in a civil case, are said to be
02:03cumulative or corroborative.
02:04Cumulative means you already produced evidence in the form of one witness, and you just want to add, let's say,
02:0910 more witnesses to completely repeat what that other witness said.
02:13That is corroborative.
02:14Kaya, kung corroborative lang witness mo, pwedeng hindi mo na ipresenta.
02:18Ito naman, hindi corroborative eh.
02:20Because they are separate and distinct articles of impeachment.
02:26And, letter D, the suppression is an exercise of a privilege.
02:29Kanyang defendant sa bank accounts niya, ayaw niyang magbigay ng consent niya.
02:35But we cannot apply this presumption to him because the suppression is the exercise of his privilege.
02:43That is a privilege given to any person who opens a dollar bank account.
02:46The law provides confidentiality is absolute except only when the depositor is...
02:55giving his consent.
02:57Ngayon ito, kaiba itong inyong kaso na ito.
03:00Wala kayong privilege eh.
03:02When you file an article of impeachment or a cause of action, it is not only your right to present
03:10evidence, it is also your duty.
03:13It's not a privilege that you can just waive at will.
03:15That is not what the law means by the suppression is the exercise of a privilege.
03:21You have no such privilege to bother the court.
03:24Cases.
03:25People v. Melo Santos, 1995.
03:28The prosecution evidence must at all times be competent and admissible to sustain its stand.
03:36The prosecution cannot rely on an imaginary person charging a serious offense without extending to the accused the benefit of
03:46confronting his accuser.
03:48In default of a satisfactory premise for the non-presentation of crucial witness, it ineluctably follows that disputable presumption that
03:58evidence deliberately withheld would be adverse if reduced remains undisturbed.
04:13What are you conducting trial by publicity? Is that what you're trying to do?
04:19We will not be swayed.
04:22The entire capacity for tsunami waves by Manila Bay can fall over this impeachment court and will not be affected
04:32by what you say in the public or what your chosen public brings back to you, particularly if they've been
04:39paid to do so.
04:41Please, do not try these little dirty tricks on us.
04:44We're all old people here.
04:47Tumanda na tayo lahat sa politikawang nyo kaming ginaganyan, ha?
04:53Kamukha ng survey, just as I predicted.
04:56Aba, may balita kanina, sa isang dyaryo, ng survey daw sa UP, 500 ang respondents, at like 75% of
05:04them said,
05:05no, we no longer trust the chief justice.
05:07Kayo nga, UP kayo, dapat kayo i-kick out immediately.
05:12If you are true, actual person, you should be kicked out immediately.
05:18Because you do not deserve to be in UP, and the people who machinated the publication of that press release,
05:25should likewise be kicked out of UP.
05:28If they're enrolled in the roles of the university as alumni, they should be permanently erased from the roles as
05:38a perpetual shame on the university.
05:40Pero mo, may survey daw sila, na 500 katao sa UP, nagsabi, ng chief justice so far because of the
05:48prosecution evidence, can no longer be trusted.
05:53Eh, ang tasa pa naman ng pagtingin ng tao sa UP, pakatapos limang daan lang, out of let us say
06:0050 million all over the Philippines,
06:01and it's not even conducted on scientific basis, it's not conducted by any of those reliable survey firms
06:07that have already been proven in their forecast for election results.
06:13Kanya-kanya lang sila.
06:14Grabe!
06:15My goodness me!
06:18If I were,
06:21the symbol of UP is standing there, naked,
06:24called the ablation,
06:26I would immediately throw away my fig leaf.
06:31I cannot imagine a survey where 500 high IQ people will say,
06:40we have already lost trust in the chief justice because we have already heard the evidence from the prosecution,
06:46although we admit that the defense has not yet presented its case.
06:50Grabe naman.
06:51Sino namang PR firm nag-isip nito?
06:53Sabihin lang ninyo, tanapin ko yun.
06:57You are playing games!
06:59I was not born yesterday.
07:02I was born a long time ago and I'm about to die.
07:05I want to leave a legacy
07:07that at least, when presented with this anomaly,
07:11in trial technique, I rose to condemn it.
07:14Kindly pause the video.
07:16Mr. President, kindly pause.
07:25For more nations,
07:30to give us your notice among people right now,
07:30including verse yunshake.
07:30I love everybody.
07:30For more nations,
07:31we are a 모�dera.
07:31we are a אבל adult jeunes community,
07:32We are figuring out,

Recommended