- 4 minutes ago
Madonna’s “Confessions” era is back in the spotlight as we compare the original dance-pop classic with its long-awaited follow-up. From seamless club-ready production and iconic samples to more experimental sounds, deeper vulnerability, and new collaborations, we’re breaking down how the Queen of Pop keeps evolving on the dance floor.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Are you ready, New York?
00:05It's mother.
00:07Welcome to Ms. Mojo.
00:09And today, we're comparing and celebrating Madonna's two-album confession cycle
00:14about finding freedom on the dance floor.
00:16I would say I think the best thing for you to do is to listen to Confessions on a Dance
00:21Floor Part 2
00:22before you go out while sipping a glass of rosé.
00:26The Queen returns to the dance floor.
00:30Even after a record-breaking world tour, Madonna shows no signs of putting the period on her career.
00:35Released on July 3rd, her 15th album immediately claimed the top two spots on Billboard's pop album charts.
00:42I feel so free.
00:48Everything begins with consciousness.
00:52Confessions 2 is a sequel to her 2005 dance pop opus Confessions on a Dance Floor in every way.
00:59Across its 16 tracks of electronic dance pop brilliance,
01:03it captures the spirit of the original album while telling us where she, and the greater culture, is now.
01:09I've got something I want to talk about.
01:10Talk about.
01:11Talk about.
01:12I've got something I want to talk about.
01:14Talk about.
01:15Confessions 2 is a prime example of why we're still hung up on Madonna after four decades.
01:21But how does it stack up against Confessions on a Dance Floor?
01:24I wonder if you like it this way.
01:28No me gusta, pero que hago, please.
01:32Creating Conception 2.
01:34After completing her incredibly successful celebration tour, Madonna saw the state of the world and said,
01:40I have to do something.
01:42The people needed to dance again.
01:43Everything's cyclical.
01:45So the tour ended, and we had been working on music during the tour,
01:50and it was like, I was going to make a movie.
01:52Everybody knows that.
01:53And then it didn't happen, and so I thought, well, let's make music.
01:56She and producer Stuart Price set out to create an antidote of love and music.
02:00This next album had to be less pop-inspired, going back to her roots as a dance artist,
02:06fusing modern sounds with classic ideas about losing yourself on the dance floor.
02:10When you're here with me, there's nothing that we can't do.
02:17There's nothing that we cannot do, let me hear you say it.
02:20The album continues the project of Confessions on a Dance Floor,
02:23inspirational dance music in a time of political, social, and spiritual strife.
02:28Half anthemic, half autobiographical, over its 63 minutes of non-stop music,
02:34it firmly cements itself as a landmark achievement in the latter half of Madonna's reign.
02:39Come here, baby, I can give you much support tonight.
02:44Oh, baby, let's do it right.
02:48Confessions 2
02:49Like the original album, this new offering is presented as a series of interconnected tracks.
02:55There are no fade-outs, no distinctive breaks between songs.
02:59The result is a seamless, polished, and instantly danceable stream of music.
03:03But it's good for the soul to let down your hair
03:10Confessions 2 emulates the original's disco and electronic sounds,
03:15but this time adding a more experimental edge that is purely current.
03:19Though not a narrative album, the tracklist feels like a journey through a night of dancing
03:23and a journey through Madonna's entire life and career at the same time.
03:27It's kind of different every time, but since I was a child, you know, that's survival.
03:35Finding a way to turn disappointment or loss into some form of joy, and I love to tell stories.
03:45It is vulnerable for her, even with its big production.
03:48Critics and fans far and wide have called it more than a worthy sequel.
03:52Confessions 2 is being hailed as the best Madonna album since Confessions on a Dance Floor.
04:05Creating Confessions 1
04:14After the mixed to poor reaction to her more political, more angry American life album,
04:20Madonna decided to respond to cultural unrest in another way.
04:24Confessions 1 was born out of a desire to spread joy through dance music.
04:31When it was released in 2005, Confessions on a Dance Floor's evocative production had a purpose.
04:40In the digital age, the way we engaged with music was changing.
04:44This was the era of the iPod shuffle, and just before the advent of streaming.
04:48Confessions 1 was created to urge us to enjoy an uninterrupted program of dance music without just skipping to our
04:55faves.
04:56Like more traditional albums, it was curating an experience instead of a collection of vaguely related bids for Top 40
05:03radio play.
05:10Confessions on a Dance Floor
05:12The original Confessions album has peaks and valleys.
05:15Though there are more confessional, vulnerable moments that the title promises,
05:19the first album is bolstered by major singular tracks, unforgettable hooks, and clever sampling.
05:33Hung Up, with its ABBA sample, remains one of Madonna's most essential tracks.
05:38Despite its conception as a curated DJ set, songs like Sorry, Get Together,
05:43and even the knowingly silly I Love New York could stand alone.
05:55Contemporary reviews were revelatory, and the album was the clear winner of the 2007 Grammy Award for Best Dance Electronic
06:02Album.
06:03Its legacy has almost become its curse.
06:06Every album Madonna has released since has failed to live up to it.
06:09I don't want to hear, I don't want to know, please don't say forgive me
06:16Genre fusion
06:18On the spiral like we fly, we will be one, we will be divine
06:25Where most of Madonna's albums are more comfortably defined as pop,
06:29both entries in the Confessions duology sit more squarely in dance music.
06:33The first is more in touch with traditional disco and electronic music.
06:37Madonna's lead vocal is front and center, and the song is built around her.
06:50A major change for Confessions 2 is that there are many tracks where her vocal is buried,
06:55in fact becoming more like an electronically manipulated instrument than a voice.
06:59This speaks more to its experimental and house inspirations.
07:03However, the less pop, radio-friendly tracks of Confessions 2 make it feel more ethereal, moody, and vulnerable.
07:16Samples and features
07:18The influences are all over Confessions on a Dance Floor.
07:21They're often incredibly explicit.
07:23Using ABBA's Gimme Gimme Gimme A Man After Midnight is an obvious one.
07:27Confessions 2's samples are much more subtle.
07:38It's most recognizable sample is a classical piece.
07:42However, one major difference reflects a larger trend in pop music.
07:46The first album, released in 2005, contains no features.
07:50Confessions 2 has four.
07:52However, it's notable that these songs don't sacrifice the overall vision to make room for its guest artists.
07:57I know where the bodies are buried.
08:01Don't try to shut me up.
08:05The single, Bring Your Love, folds Sabrina Carpenter's voice into the soundscape as another instrument.
08:11But the most meaningful feature is its most surprising.
08:14Madonna's daughter, Lourdes, credited as Lola Leon, accompanies her on the penultimate track, The Test.
08:20It seemed so simple, really.
08:22It was such, like, a duh moment when I asked her.
08:25Because it's like, why the frick wouldn't we...
08:28Good save.
08:29Good save.
08:30Oh, wouldn't we work together?
08:32And wouldn't we...
08:34Kind of a no-brainer.
08:35Yeah, yeah, exactly.
08:36It felt so natural, honestly.
08:38Personal themes.
08:39Both Confessions albums make their statements about the dance floor explicit.
08:43The dance floor is a spiritual place.
08:45It's a threshold, a ritualistic space where movement replaces language.
08:53As described in tracks from both, the dance floor is a sacred space where ego and identity melt away.
08:59People become one.
09:01But if one thing separates the two albums' lyrical content, it's the success of the more intimate moments.
09:07Even positive reviews of the first album noted that the more introspective song slowed things down.
09:12On the second album, she goes much further.
09:14A perfect example is Fragile, a song about the fraught relationship with her late brother Christopher.
09:20I wanted to take the loss of my brother Christopher, for example, and turn it into something that was, you
09:27know, transcendent.
09:29You know, like, I'm going to take this pain and I'm going to rise above it.
09:32And I know that my brother is with me in a different way.
09:37The test, her collaboration with daughter Lourdes, is also intensely personal.
09:41The pop icon's vulnerability makes these some of the most rewarding moments on Confessions 2.
09:55Confessions 1 was reviewed like it was a miracle.
09:58Madonna sounded young again.
10:00It's no wonder she used her next albums to collaborate with the artists who came after her,
10:04even if the results weren't as successful.
10:14For so long, the album served as a reminder of the Madonna many thought was gone.
10:19Confessions 2 is a return that respectfully honors her place in the industry and the culture.
10:32In track number 5, Danceteria, Madonna gives her own contemporaries the same treatment she gave the classic Hollywood stars in
10:39Vogue.
10:39She puts Jean-Michel Basquiat, Keith Haring, DJ Mark Kamens, and therefore herself,
10:45in their rightful place among those who changed music, culture, and art forever.
10:57If you love games, be sure to check out WatchMojo's new game, Terrible Influence.
11:02Just launched for purchase at TerribleInfluence.com.
11:05Terrible Influence is a satirical board game about the dark side of fame
11:08from the writer of the most popular girls in school and us, WatchMojo.
11:12Boom.
11:13I can make an apology video.
11:15Oh, you so would.
11:16Click on the link in the description to check out the game and be the first to play Terrible Influence.
11:22Madonna is back.
11:24Confessions 1 and 2 are dance albums that get at the love, community, and spirituality of the dance floor.
11:29Movement is only one part of it.
11:32One step away from your heartbeat.
11:35One step away.
11:37One step away.
11:39With Confessions 2, Madonna's message of joy and euphoria gets a more mature, but no less vibrant and energetic climax.
11:47It's hard to tell how this newest album will play into her legacy.
11:50What is clear is that she's nowhere near done impacting the culture.
11:54Freedom, cause you can't shake me.
11:58Freedom, cause you'll never break me.
12:02It also reminds us that while Madonna herself may not live forever, the dance floor is eternal.
12:08The address may change, and so will the people, but the ghosts of the past and the future dance there
12:13together.
12:14The Queen of Pop is back, but if you've been paying attention, she never left.
12:19I just wanna lose myself in the room.
12:23Get over here.
12:24Everybody get up and dance.
12:28Which Confessions album do you prefer?
12:30Keep it civil in the comments.
Comments