Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 14 hours ago
Going mainstream can be a tough gamble for musicians – sometimes it pays off, and other times it backfires spectacularly. Join us as we explore the biggest success stories and the most notorious flops among artists who took the plunge to sell out. From genre shifts that shocked fans to career-defining hits, see which moves hit the mark and which ones missed it completely!

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:04Welcome to Miss Mojo, and today we're counting down our picks for the most and least successful
00:09musicians who decided to go mainstream.
00:195. David Guetta Worked
00:22Over his decades-long career, David Guetta has become one of the best-known DJs on earth.
00:28He first released an album in 2002, but became truly mainstream with his 2009 release, One Love.
00:40He also produced I Got a Feeling by the Black Eyed Peas in the same year, which dominated charts globally.
00:47It's worked out for him, as he's still wildly famous over two decades later.
00:51The only thing we know how to do, said it's the only thing we know how to do, work hard,
00:58play hard.
00:59A large factor could be how EDM and house music just weren't as popular in the early 2000s,
01:05but Guetta has tons of passion for what he does, which is probably more important.
01:09I would have the luxury to be able to afford not to work if I wanted to, but right now
01:17I'm having so much fun.
01:18I have no reason to do that.
01:195. 30 Seconds to Mars
01:21Sucked
01:22Years before Jared Leto took up the mantle of Morbius, he was the frontman of the band 30 Seconds to
01:29Mars.
01:37They became pretty big during the 2000s, primarily in the alt-rock scene.
01:42The band became less celebrated as time went on, and things only got worse with their 2018 album, America.
01:49Do you believe that you can walk on water?
01:55It was electronic pop, a significant departure from their usual sound.
02:00It divided the fan base, getting the most conflicted reviews in the band's history.
02:05A documentary directed by Leto was also released as a companion to the album called A Day in the Life
02:10of America.
02:11Despite the mixed critical reception, America ended up at number two on America's Billboard 200.
02:17Uh, but it's nice to break... boundaries.
02:234. Metallica Worked
02:26As one of the big four of thrash metal, Metallica is easily one of the most influential metal groups in
02:32history.
02:36Excellent, end of night
02:39Unlike the other big three, they managed to go mainstream during the early 90s.
02:45In 1991, they dropped Metallica, better known as the Black Album.
02:49It featured some of metal's most famous tracks, like Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters.
03:02It was so immensely popular that it was in the American charts for over 550 weeks, making it the fourth
03:10longest album to do so.
03:12Unless you exclude compilations, then it's second only to Dark Side of the Moon.
03:23Unfortunately for Metallica, they couldn't maintain the momentum and had a career decline in the 2000s, especially when they began
03:31suing Napster.
03:324. Liz Phair
03:39Sucked
03:40During the 90s, this singer-songwriter was known all across the United States.
03:45Now, she's way more niche, with her decline beginning with her 2003 single, Why Can't I?
03:57All of her earlier work had been lo-fi indie rock, but this was a clear shift into pop, and
04:03not everyone was happy about it.
04:05Her following self-titled LP was so controversial, both the New York Times and Pitchfork called her a sellout.
04:11It won't surprise you to learn the shift was primarily pushed by her label, which only had dollar signs in
04:17its eyes.
04:17I'd grown up listening to radio, and I'd always wanted to hear myself on the airwaves, and I was ambitious.
04:25But on the other hand, I'd lost my anchor of the people who understood the kind of music I made.
04:32People have since warmed up to the album, with the Pitchfork reviewer even apologizing for their savage comments.
04:383. Aerosmith
04:40Worked
04:41This hard rock band was formed in 1970 and became icons by the end of the decade.
04:53During the early 80s, the group was in an especially challenging period.
04:58Their 1982 album was a major flop, despite costing $1.5 million.
05:03Their career experienced a resurgence in 1986, when their track Walk This Way was covered by Run DMC, with assistance
05:11from Aerosmith.
05:17It was one of the earliest examples of mixing the two genres, and people loved it.
05:22It's easily one of the bravest moves in music history, with Run DMC surprisingly refusing to do it at first.
05:29They must be so glad they did, since it's played regularly.
05:32We looked at everybody in that room and said, y'all can be happy as y'all want, but y
05:37'all better not put this record out as a single.
05:40Wow.
05:41Look at what it did now.
05:42Number 3. Bring Me The Horizon
05:45Sucked
05:45This English group is one of the biggest metalcore bands in the scene.
05:49Can you feel, can you feel more?
05:56Their sound is defined by the vocalist's intense screaming.
05:59But in 2019, they departed from this style completely.
06:03Their 2019 album, Ammo, was adored by many critics, but massively divided the fan base.
06:09It also earned them a bunch of new fans, many of whom had no interest in their earlier music.
06:15There's a bunch of people saying they hate it, but there's a bunch of people saying they absolutely love it,
06:18it's the best thing we've ever done, and that's what's important.
06:20It's not that everyone's going, yeah, this isn't as good as their other stuff.
06:23One of the album's most popular tracks was Medicine, which lead singer Ollie Sykes even threw shade towards in a
06:292024 performance.
06:31So while the album wasn't everyone's cup of tea, we have to give them credit for the experimentation.
06:36I think it's time to stop, you need a taste of your own medicine.
06:43Number 2. Gwen Stefani, Worked
06:46Stefani's career began as the vocalist for the new wave and ska group No Doubt in the 80s.
06:52Don't tell me cause it hurts, no, no, don't sing.
06:59Together, they released some pretty successful albums alongside a few that fell flat on their face.
07:04The group disbanded in 2004, then Stefani pursued a solo career, dropping her debut solo album Love Angel Music Baby
07:13in the same year.
07:14It sounded like an homage to 80s new wave, and people ate it up.
07:18Few times I've been around that track, so it's not just gonna happen like that, cause there ain't no hollabat
07:24girl.
07:24In the years since, she's maintained a solid career, and is now generally better known for her solo stuff than
07:31her time with No Doubt.
07:32From the garage to the penthouse girls, underdog to the top of the world.
07:37Number 2. Weezer, Sucked
07:48It's a common joke among Weezer fans that you aren't truly a Weezer fan if you don't hate every single
07:54thing they've ever released.
07:56Their self-titled debut album was everywhere in 1994.
08:00People were fed up with the grunge craze, meaning their lighthearted rock debut was a breath of fresh air.
08:06If you want to destroy my sweater
08:11Then they released Pinkerton, which massively influenced the emo genre, but its depressing nature meant most fans hated it at
08:20first.
08:21It's now a cult classic with a dedicated following.
08:24After its failure, they disbanded for a few years, then eventually returned to making upbeat pop rock.
08:31Real Weezer fans know that they haven't had a good album since Pinkerton in 96.
08:36Oh, wow, uh-oh, looks like we have a purist in the house.
08:39Many of these albums were slammed by their fans, like the infamous Ratitude.
08:44But there were a handful of anomalies, such as their White album.
08:48Number 1. Black Eyed Peas, Worked
08:59You'd be forgiven for thinking that this hip-hop group formed in the 2000s.
09:04In actuality, they began making music in 1992.
09:07They just didn't achieve mainstream success until the 2000s,
09:11firstly with the track Where Is The Love featuring Justin Timberlake.
09:15We only got one, one, one, one, that's all we got, one, one, one, one, there's something wrong with it.
09:21After a string of failures within a fairly underground scene,
09:25they added Fergie to the group and shifted to a more radio-friendly style.
09:29It worked wonders with the group becoming one of the defining acts of the 2000s.
09:41They're still going strong, too, but have got a bit more experimental with recent releases,
09:46which they had the freedom to do so after making so many massive tracks.
09:51Number 1. Green Day, Sucked
09:54This punk group have their origins in the California punk scene of the 80s and 90s.
09:59They were shunned from the scene in 1993 after signing to a major label,
10:03getting them banned from 924 Gilman Street, the most important venue in the scene.
10:08We couldn't play anymore because we signed to a major label,
10:14and there's this kind of a rule of no major label bans, everything's got to be indie, DIY.
10:21This worked wonders, though, as they became one of the decade's most definitive bands.
10:26In the 2000s, their releases became increasingly pop-influenced,
10:31making them more mainstream than ever.
10:38Their modern sound is wildly different from the unpolished earlier releases like Dookie.
10:44None of their album synths have matched their earlier successes,
10:47but they still sell millions of tour tickets.
10:50Some fans would say they feel more like a brand than a band these days.
10:54When it's all double-talk of conspiracy,
10:58the American dream is killing me.
11:01Do you agree with all our picks?
11:02Or were there some sellouts we didn't mention today?
11:05Let us know in the comments below.

Recommended