Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 5 months ago
In conjunction with World Refugee Day, this episode takes a close look at refugee policy in the region amid declining humanitarian funding. In light of the recent wave of hate speech against Rohingya refugees in Malaysia, Nailah Huda speaks with Aslam Abd Jalil from Universiti Malaya and Saqib Sheikh from RSIS to explore sustainable and practical solutions to managing refugees.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:07this is Awani Global with me Nailah Huda and this week in conjunction with World Refugee Day
00:12we want to take a close look at the refugee ecosystem in the region amid declining humanitarian
00:19funding and with the recent wave of hate speech against Rohingya refugees in Malaysia it's
00:25important that we look beyond the rhetoric understand facts and explore what a holistic
00:32sustainable refugee policy might look like in this part of the world and joining me in this hour to
00:38unpack some of these key issues we have joining us Aslam Abdul Jalil Senior Lecturer at the International
00:45Institute of Public Policy and Management University Malaya and also with us Saqib Sheikh Researcher at
00:51the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies thank you so much Aslam and Saqib for joining us
00:56today perhaps I'd like to start with Aslam first looking at this year's World Refugee Day with the
01:03theme until everyone is safe but you know looking at what's happening around us in this world where
01:10we're facing growing conflict growing displacement what do you think this message actually means in
01:15practical policy terms in the context of reality well maybe I could start off thank you for having us
01:23first we appreciate it and it's a very relevant and important topic given the events of the day
01:31your question related to the theme that's been selected one of the more I think important aspects that we've seen
01:41in recent years has been and you've sort of touched on it the drying up of funds now that hasn't
01:49just been due to
01:51rising economic cost or changing of political guards in the West it also has to do to a certain extent
02:01with other
02:02conflicts that have arisen that have sort of withdrawn funding from existing conflict areas so to give an example
02:10um you had the world's largest refugee settlement in uh Cox's Bazar in Bangladesh uh where there are huge
02:19economic costs just to maintain humanitarian needs but the moment the Ukrainian war happened we saw
02:26a surge of funding diverted towards Ukraine and um that reflected uh international priorities as well uh at that
02:36time in the West and uh it did lead lead to a rationing in terms of the uh refugees in
02:43Cox's Bazar so this has become a
02:46a theme where uh the idea is that some refugees may may be more prioritized than others and then also
02:53a in a general
02:55environment of deprivation um some refugees are going to be left by the wayside while uh funding is more selected
03:02towards those who fit certain
03:05ideological filters so i think with this this theme the idea is here is that they want to ensure a
03:12protection regime that is equal and accountable for all um uh aslam talking about the declining
03:19humanitarian funding with the u.s pulling out of the united nations and so on how do you think this
03:24might
03:24be changing the way governments uh international organizations and how they're approaching refugee
03:30protection today? America contributed around 25 to 30 percent of annual global refugee funding so with the
03:39funding cuts uh that means a lot of lives are being impacted terribly because of uh the loss of support
03:47and
03:47assistance i just would like to give you uh context uh about Malaysia our role itself uh Malaysia has hosted
03:55thousands of thousands of refugees and at the same time Malaysia used to donate to UNHCR so from the year
04:011990
04:03until the year 2000 Malaysia actually contributed more than 589 million uh 89 000 us dollars to UNHCR uh to
04:15support
04:15UNHCR operations uh with the highest uh contribution in the year 2000 uh with amount of 220 000 us
04:24dollars however uh this donation stopped in the year 2001 until now so Malaysia used uh to be uh generous
04:32in terms of supporting uh refugees uh because of our role uh we wanted to be the champion and in
04:40fact you
04:40know we were the champion of the voice of the marginalized people so i think uh looking at the history
04:46Malaysia was generous back then and i think we should continue that momentum in being generous in welcoming
04:53uh refugees in our countries because uh we should uh take the responsibility um in terms of hosting
05:02people throughout the world uh because nowadays what is happening when uh many countries uh they think
05:08that uh it is not their responsibility that's why uh many lives are impacted greatly due to the
05:15withdrawal of support by all these countries globally yeah um maybe you can pin that thought and we can dive
05:22deeper
05:22into uh Malaysia's refugee policy um a bit later but um one of the more recent headlines um recently
05:31looking at thailand they um eased employment restrictions on refugees living along the myanmar border
05:38thus allowing thousands to enter the workforce um sakit what are your thoughts on this how significant is
05:44this shift from a policy perspective and might this be um relevant for for other countries perhaps
05:51i mean it is a positive development uh it you we also should mention it's very specific to thailand in
05:59terms of the inner dynamics of the country because uh it can thailand has has more of a history of
06:06using
06:06uh particular uh refugees uh as uh having some sort of semi-formal role in the workforce um and having
06:17some
06:17degree of uh if not fully formal status but semi-formal status um that allows them that ease of movement
06:25and
06:25ability to work uh but this recent move has uh moved it further along the lines of formalization
06:34and uh i think that there are many different lessons that can be picked up from that uh the main
06:40thing i
06:40think is that uh there is a space between uh full sort of you know uh recognition or full citizenship
06:49status given to any particular refugee and then the other extreme which would be uh having um you know a
06:58refugee be completely living in the informal or in the black market economy and uh be unaccounted for
07:05so um finding a way where refugees can be uh you know formalized into the system i i think has
07:15uh
07:16certain dividends in the long run and uh many such examples can also be taken up in malaysia
07:22as it tries its current different initiatives that we'll probably be talking about later on as well
07:28yeah um of course talking about this um you know there's a lot of uh labor shortages as well that
07:34thailand is trying to address by uh taking this step but um aslam what are your thoughts on this could
07:40economic necessity be reshaping attitudes toward refugees across the region i i believe um there was a
07:47uh report that was published by ideas malaysia um saying that projections indicate if refugees were
07:53granted equitable access to education uh their annual contribution to the malaysian gdp could exceed
08:006.5 billion ringgit by 2040 so there is that economic rationale but do you think it's enough to try
08:06and
08:07um change mindsets here it's have been contributing greatly to our society and our economy and as you
08:14rightly pointed out they could contribute uh up to 6.5 billion ringgit to malaysia's gdp with 250
08:22million um annual tax contributions um so and in fact there's also another study by uh the unicef as
08:30well as university malaya's social well-being well-being research center if proper education and
08:36employment um are given to non-citizen children born in malaysia which also includes refugees they could
08:44contribute to malaysia's gdp up to 208 billion uh to malaysia's economy so i think it is a win-win
08:53situation because refugees need to support their livelihoods and at the same time they are also
08:58filling in the labor gaps in many uh sectors of the economy um and we also need to be mindful
09:07that
09:07refugees are not homogenous uh because some of them have skills and talents qualifications some of
09:14them are professionals doctors lawyers and engineers therefore we need to consider that there are refugees
09:21who could contribute professionally in different sectors and in the situation that we are experiencing
09:28brain drain and we want to retain and attract talents i think refugees are um are the ones who could
09:35actually uh fill in the gaps both in the low wage sectors as well as in the professional sectors
09:43however i need to also uh be uh i mean we also need to be mindful about not seeing refugees
09:49as just
09:50economic actors uh because some of them are unable to work because of various reasons maybe they have
09:58disabilities they are elderly they are children therefore what about them who are unable to work if we view
10:05them solely as economic actors this means you know we would include majority of other people who are
10:12unable to be part of the labor force um sakit what do you make of this what sort of lessons
10:19can
10:19malaysia learn from thailand's experience i mean as you said what thailand has done here is a lot more
10:25relevant to their uh situation to their uh border context of course um with myanmar but do you think the
10:31same
10:32model of easing employment restrictions could potentially work here in malaysia what do you think
10:36are some potential pitfalls that policymakers should be aware of i think there is a potential for it to
10:43work well uh what i would say is that it shouldn't be uh treated just as sort of an economic
10:49issue uh
10:51because um that that that can be a very limited approach it needs to be seen as an issue a
10:57sort of
10:57holistic uh solution that you're looking towards uh the refugee situation in your country um because
11:04one of the issues that has plagued uh malaysia or or over decades has been that there is seemingly sort
11:13of a limbo between uh hosting refugees which malaysia has done very graciously uh versus you know being
11:21able to uh give refugees some sort of clear status or if not status but some type of um uh
11:30some some
11:31type of um semi-formal uh situation where they're able to interact with the larger society so that they
11:39don't necessarily stay on the margins and uh because as the professor mentioned malaysia is not a signatory to
11:46the 1951 convention um they're not under any sort of like legal obligation to give citizenship uh but
11:55the question is what serves malaysia in the long-term interest of having a refugee population where uh you
12:03want them to be uh integrated to some extent into the local economy and not necessarily be a burden on
12:10the country so i would say that the economic uh part of that equation has to be seen connected to
12:16the
12:16to the other aspects as well and um you want to also ensure that there is a transition period so
12:23that the refugees who are involved are also aware of the nature of the program and it's not necessarily
12:29a top-down sort of enforced mechanism that can end up driving some of the participants you want in
12:36the programs away from uh participation um one mechanism that might potentially work in malaysia
12:45is um how malaysia is now currently piloting the refugee registration document program in which
12:52they're exploring pathways for refugees to work legally and in this case supporters are arguing that
12:58legal employment would reduce exploitation a boost economic contribution as we've discussed uh
13:03potentially increasing contributions to gdp and as well as taxpayers of revenue there um but at the same
13:09time of course we can't ignore the recent wave of um hate speech um online petitions calling for
13:17rohingya refugees to be removed from malaysia even um you know really disturbing content about um uh just
13:24people uh you know sort of attacking rohingya refugee children or um what they're assumed to be uh refugees
13:32just out on the streets so it's a you know concerning time here um aslam what do you make of
13:39this
13:39how do you think you know we can sort of counter the kind of misinformation and disinformation the hate
13:45speech that's out there um while at the same time we're looking and piloting exploring pathways for
13:52them to work legally do you think that um you know the sort of hate speech that we're seeing is
13:57being
13:57exacerbated by social media do you think that this is representative of the general public's sentiment do
14:04you think that you know this is something beyond saving um and how might from the policy makers perspective
14:11um they might want to balance between you know countering and targeting the gray area that refugees are in
14:18but at the same time um taking into serious account some of the um concerns that's being voiced by um
14:26online uh sort of netizens or the public uh it's kind of a loaded question here but uh you know
14:32of course a lot to
14:33take into account uh aslam what we've seen nowadays you know there's like a lot of hatred and uh hate
14:40messages online and i believe that that is not representative of malaysian people because we have
14:45been welcoming uh people from all over the world and i think there are certain things that we need to
14:51clarify let's say when there's a claim about crimes being perpetrated by rohingya refugees and other
14:58migrants uh statistically you could see that the proportion is very low so majority of refugees are
15:06not committing crimes they are uh honest people who are just trying to survive every day and i also like
15:14to challenge what crimes really mean if it involves immigration offenses definitely the mere presence of
15:23these refugees is a crime because they do not have legal status so are we actually criminalizing
15:29the existence of human beings no human being is illegal therefore we need to really challenge what
15:37crimes mean uh what offenses uh really mean that are being recorded by uh the authorities and i believe
15:45that in order to change the perception of people towards refugees is through empowerment policies we cannot
15:51have um a short-term policy alone i believe empowerment policies is very important uh what we need to do
15:58is to allow refugees to work legally in malaysia because that is the only way for them to support
16:04themselves in a dignified way and for the long-term policy is to support their education um situation
16:11because at this moment refugees have been denied from education for decades in the case of rohingya
16:17therefore having an education is the only pathway for them to change their lives to change their
16:24family's future and it could also uh benefit the whole society and malaysian uh state in general
16:33um uh sakib um a lot of the concerns being voiced out by uh social media users in malaysia mostly
16:40have to do
16:41or revolve around uh issues of social and cultural integration do you think there are some helpful
16:48models of uh social integration policies concerning refugees that might be relevant in the malaysian context
16:57yes and and there have actually been efforts in the past also at um social integration programs where
17:04you have uh some facilitated contact between uh leaders and representatives from the rohingya as well as
17:11uh from the locals even uh gotong royong type of uh interactions at uh you know some religious events
17:19that at least uh give some level of um you know positive positive connection between the people because a lot
17:27of the times
17:28uh these um these um these sort of uh social media uh posts and these campaigns they are based on
17:36you know some sentiments that may be shared by certain sections of the public i wouldn't i would agree with
17:42professor aslam that it's not necessarily representative of a broad stroke um you know public uh fervor
17:49uh and there is a certain degree to which these social media campaigns are artificially sort of boosted
17:56uh potentially by foreign actors as well that needs to be looked at because there are reports uh we have
18:02to remember this isn't the first time this type of uh online hysteria has happened uh it really sort of
18:08began
18:09after or during the covet lockdowns where we saw um the first sort of nationalist type of sentiment
18:16uh against the rohingya and then since then it's come in um periodic waves or campaigns and even now
18:24this social media campaign is also met by uh banners that you occasionally see at certain public uh
18:34public locations like a flyover uh where it may have a sign related to no rohingya or bringing to get
18:42out uh so that is concerning from a just a standpoint of just a stability standpoint um you want to
18:50have
18:51uh interaction as much as possible between leaders of the community and other representatives within
18:59the community because much of the uh fear and hysteria results from lack of interaction or
19:06the fact that uh the interaction that takes place tends tends to be just you know within very isolated
19:12examples so that's one thing and then also i think there's an important role for public officials
19:18to calm down sentiments to not really stoke it further and to also how they frame uh the rohingya
19:27and the refugees because in one sense if you're trying to uh semi-regularize the presence of refugees
19:35you also don't want to on another uh you know on the other side uh present the refugees as some
19:43sort of
19:43clear and present danger in a way that can generate or just feed into a lot of hysteria so uh
19:49again i
19:50would say there there's a wider approach that you need to take within the members of society as well as
19:56the officials on top i mean i think that might be difficult given that there's a lot to be gained
20:01politically um you know by feeding into these fears and misinformation as we've seen um you know examples
20:08from the us and europe um but um aslam how do you think um you know policymakers can address legitimate
20:17concerns um about you know economic security while at the same time also upholding their humanitarian
20:24obligations how much of uh this hostility that we're seeing do you think actually stems from valid
20:31public concerns about the economy and how much of it is actually um misinformation as sakib said um
20:37perceptions about security there should be a clear policy regarding refugees uh currently this national
20:45security council directive number 23 that addresses uh the issues and the rights of refugees however this uh
20:53circular or this directive is not made transparent and we uh many stakeholders were not involved
21:01in the uh amendment of this uh directive therefore the government needs to actually uh get input from
21:08the stakeholders from the refugees themselves in order how to improve uh the refugee management system
21:14as you mentioned earlier document pendaftaran pelarian or the registration uh for refugees is not an asylum
21:22framework because it is merely a registration process this is an exercise where the government actually
21:28collects data from refugees to know about their presence and their data what we need to do is to have
21:35a
21:35comprehensive asylum framework that encompasses uh important aspects in terms of registration
21:43documentation legal employment access to affordable healthcare and access to proper education so the policy has to
21:52be comprehensive that covers all these aspects because uh these aspects are important to refugee lives
21:59and if we do not uh address the issues that and the hardships that they are facing they would uh
22:06be uh many
22:07other consequences uh from our ignorance and our policy in action um and i believe that legal employment is very
22:16important because it allows refugees to be independent as they are always are um and uh to support their
22:23education when you know parents have stable income they are able to uh pay for their uh for the education
22:30for
22:31their children and they would also be able to actually buy insurance so i know that many people have been
22:37complaining about refugees going to our public hospitals uh for your information uh unhcr with the
22:44collaboration with alliance they actually uh have set up an insurance program called a refugee medical
22:50insurance um it's a yearly program that refugees have to subscribe so if refugees have stable income
22:58they can not just send their children to school but they are also able to subscribe to this insurance and
23:05this
23:06would actually uh make their lives better and that would not burden uh our public health care system
23:13just to to add on to dr aslam's point um because you did ask about what sort of public officials
23:20can
23:20do to to calm um public sentiment uh one of the things is just to explain that because there is
23:28a perception
23:28that uh refugees get subsidies or that they're on the public door which uh is is a misconception
23:36and is just it's not really true um even in terms of uh the public hospitals refugees still have to
23:44pay
23:44fifty percent of what is a foreigner fee so it's not uh like they're getting the same treatment as
23:50locals and i think that public officials do occasionally uh say that but it's important to mention especially
23:57in the midst of uh hysteria campaign yeah um lastly sakib uh you know we're talking about what an ideal
24:06or
24:06realistic uh malaysian refugee policy might look like taking into account everything that we've
24:11discussed of course domestic political sensitivities um public sentiment um and of course resource
24:18constraints as well what we do know is the government was expected to present a broader plan to the
24:24cabinet uh later this month um in conjunction with the refugee registration document the dpp framework
24:31managing uh you know 200 000 refugees uh in malaysia what do you think policy makers should keep in mind
24:38yeah i uh going back to an earlier point i mean the idea is that uh it may be just
24:44simply unrealistic to
24:46grant uh full formal status but you don't want to uh have a limbo sort of status where refugees are
24:54essentially operating completely in uh the informal sector so the idea is to give some type of semi-formal
25:01status that can at least assure the public that um there isn't any sort of security concerns but it
25:08also has to respect uh to to an extent the sort of privacy concerns that people have in terms of
25:14data management of uh sensitive refugee data uh and that's a very um yeah it's a it's a very it's
25:22it's fraught with many of these uh potential challenges uh we should also mention that uh a couple
25:28years ago malaysia did try a system called tris uh which eventually had to be shelved which was a
25:35data management system for refugees um so there is some indication that they've uh tried different
25:42approaches and that's this current one with dpp uh seems more geared towards the employment sector
25:50what i would say is that you you have to uh ensure a policy that can can have a wide
25:57degree of participation uh even this pilot program i believe has 4 000 uh initial entrance in it
26:03um that has to be sort of expanded upon uh to make it to cover the majority of the refugee
26:10population
26:11uh one thing also to mention is um and this should be talked about in terms of resettlement
26:18uh of refugees because the idea is that malaysia sees refugees as um temporary residents eventually
26:26that they're going to be resettled to a third party country uh most likely in the west and uh
26:33what we've seen in in the west especially in the united states but also in europe is that uh there
26:38seems to be less of an appetite to open their their doors towards um refugees even those in need
26:46for example in the us traditionally you know under the democrats you had 125 000 refugees that were
26:54accepted and then under trump trump he sort of brought this down to just around 6 000 refugees
26:59which means that a lot of the rohingya a lot of the other refugees um from different countries that
27:05malaysia hosts uh they don't really have a channel to go back to which complicates malaysia's plans further
27:11and makes it more necessary for them to have some type of arrangement where refugees have a status
27:17uh but that that status is a is clear to the public as well as clear to the refugees themselves
27:24yeah uh plenty more we'd like to discuss of course but that is all the time that we have thank
27:29you uh
27:30once again to aslam and sakir for joining us to unpack um in conjunction with world refugee day
27:35some of the misconceptions that we tend to hear a lot about refugees and what an ideal and realistic
27:41refugee policy might look like in this region that is all on awany global this week with me
27:45i would i will catch you next time

Recommended