Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 12 minutes ago
Tuesday, May 6, 1913

(Page 1, Column 5)

A solid negative alibi, backed by family and friends including his brother and father in Newnan, appears to exonerate Paul P. Bowen. Detectives arrested the young man Monday night in Houston, Texas, as a suspect in Mary Phagan's Atlanta murder on April 26. Yet nothing ties him to the area that day.

Houston police report "strong evidence" at Atlanta's request. Telegrams describe a photo of Mary Phagan in his trunk, a bloodied girl's vest, letters from Atlanta signed "Mary" or initialed "M. P." and "M. J. P.," plus a blood stained, hole riddled woman's shirt found in an alley behind his hotel just before his move to a boarding house.

A neighboring room's female occupant grew suspicious after seeing Bowen react emotionally to Phagan murder details. She heard him moan that he wished he had not "done it" and that he would avoid the same mistake if given a second chance.

Left Atlanta Last Fall

The Journal's thorough investigation finds no link connecting Bowen to Atlanta or Georgia since he departed for Arkansas last October. Police and detectives uncover no such ties either.

Friends and relatives confirm Bowen has not visited Georgia since then. Charley Kimball of the Southern master mechanic's office at Inman Yards received a letter from Bowen dated Houston, April 23. His father got a recent postal card from there. Brother Paul reports a letter about two weeks ago. No acquaintances have spotted Bowen in Atlanta or Georgia lately. He worked the past six weeks as a secretary, traveling with a Texas railroad general manager and based in Houston.

In short, Houston evidence implicates young Bowen on some authority. Atlanta investigations absolve him completely.

Alibi Stands Firm

Either Houston suspects the wrong Paul P. Bowen, or the arrested man uses his name. Paul P. Bowen may have visited Georgia on April 26, but evidence suggests otherwise. His Houston alibi holds strong.

The Journal and its Houston correspondents uncovered these key facts on Paul P. Bowen's life and movements, unknown to the public until Tuesday.
Transcript
00:00Paul Bowen, held in Houston, known here but left Atlanta in October, hasn't been back.
00:04Atlanta Journal, Tuesday, May 6, 1913. Page 1, Column 5. Negative alibi seems established for
00:10young man held in Texas City as suspected murderer of Mary Fagan in Atlanta police.
00:15There's a strong evidence, but nothing shows. Young man was around here. April 26. Brother in
00:22Noonan says Paul has been in Houston six weeks, out west since October. Two friends, young men in
00:27Atlanta report recent letters from him brother has had one, so has father detectives say Quinn
00:31changed his story. Newt Lee declares, murder must have occurred during the afternoon. A negative
00:37alibi established for Paul P. Bowen by several authorities, among whom are his brother and
00:41his father Noonan, seems to clear the young man arrested Monday night in Houston Tex from any
00:47suspicious connection with the murder of Mary Fagan in Atlanta on the night of April 26. Strong
00:53evidence against the man whom they have arrested and are holding, at request of the Atlanta
00:58police, as a suspect, is reported by the police of Houston in telegrams to the Atlanta police.
01:04One dispatch says they found a photograph of Mary Fagan in the young man's trunk. Another
01:09says they found there, too, a girl's vest, with blood on it. Letters from Atlanta signed Mary,
01:15and others initialed MP, or MJP, are described among other finds in the trunk. A woman's shirt,
01:22blood-stained and full of holes, was found in the alley back of the hotel where Bowen had been
01:27stopping, just before he moved to the boarding house where the police arrested him. The suspicions
01:32of a woman whose room adjoined that of Bowen in the hotel led the police to him. She saw him
01:38manifest
01:38emotion over the details of the Mary Fagan murder, the dispatch's state, and heard him moan that he
01:44wished he hadn't done it, and that if he had his life to live over he would not make the
01:48same mistake,
01:49or words to that effect. Left here last fall. Yet there remains the fact that in no ways does the
01:58journal's searching and thorough investigation connect young Bowen with Atlanta, or even with
02:03Georgia, since he left here for Arkansas last October, nor have the police and detectives found
02:08that vital connection. Friends and relatives of Bowen say that he has not been in Georgia, so far as they
02:13know since last October. Charlie Kimball of the Southern Master Mechanics Office at Inman Yards
02:18reports receiving a letter from Bowen, dated at Houston, April 23rd. The young man's father reports
02:25a postal card from him there recently. Paul's brother says he received a letter from Paul about two weeks
02:30ago. No one who knows Bowen has seen him in Atlanta or Georgia recently, as far as appears, and he
02:35is
02:36reported to have been employed for the past six weeks as a secretary, traveling with the general
02:40manager of some railroad in Texas living in Houston. In short, the Houston end of the story tends to
02:45involve young Bowen, you on more or less authority in the murder. The Atlanta end of it absolves him
02:50of any connection with it. Seems to have alibi. Either Paul P. Bowen is suspected wrongfully in Houston
02:56taxi, or the man under arrest there has assumed the name of Paul P. Bowen. It is, of course, entirely
03:02possible that Paul P. Bowen may have been in Georgia on April 26th, but it does not seem probable,
03:07and the indications are that his alibi in Houston is as good as established. The following investigation
03:13by the journal and its correspondence in Houston seems to have revealed very pertinent fact about
03:18the life and movements of Paul P. Bowen, who was unknown publicly until Tuesday morning.
Comments

Recommended