00:00Pinalagaan ng Defense Team ni Vice President Sara Duterte
00:03ang binanggit ng Anti-Money Laundering Council sa Kamara
00:06na mga bilyong pisong kahina-hinala umanong transaksyong dumaan
00:10sa mga bank account ng Vice Presidente.
00:13Nanindigan si Vice President Duterte na lahiti mo
00:16ang lahat ng pinanggalingan ng bawat senti mo ng kanyang pera at ari-arian.
00:21Saksi, si Tina Panganiban Perez.
00:26Sa pagdinig kahapon ng House Justice Committee
00:29na puna ang hindi umanong pagkakatugma ng sala
00:32ay ni Vice President Sara Duterte
00:34at mga transaksyong dumaan sa kanyang bank accounts.
00:38Bagay na pinalagaan ng Defense Team ng Vice Presidente.
00:41Para po sa amin, actually, wala naman pong hindi nagtutugma.
00:45Perhaps it's just the way that things were presented.
00:47Kung accurate ba yung presentation na gano'n.
00:51Ang sabi kahapon ng Anti-Money Laundering Council o AMLOC,
00:55mayroong mahigit 600 covered at suspicious transactions
00:59na dumaan sa mga bank account ng Duterte
01:02at kanyang asawang si Atty. Manasa Scarpio
01:05na aabot sa 6.7 billion pesos
01:08pero giit ng Defense Team.
01:10Hindi raw nangangahulog ang may malinang ginawa.
01:13Suspicious transactions does not equate
01:16to any wrongdoing or unlawful activity.
01:20Perhaps the bank thought or tagged it as suspicious
01:23so umakyat nun sa AMLOC.
01:27Hindi naman ibig sabihin nun ay iligal na kaagad
01:30or may money laundering na kaagad
01:31or may krimen na kaagad.
01:33Umapot daw sa halos 7 milyong piso
01:35ang halaga ng mga transaksyon
01:37dahil pinagsama-sama ang halaga ng mga transaksyon
01:40sa loob ng 18 taon.
01:42Ibig sabihin, lahat ng withdrawals mo
01:45lahat ng deposits mo
01:47pagdating sa inflow and outflow
01:49eh pinagsama-sama.
01:51Kasi aggregate yung ginagawang number.
01:54So lahat ng inflows dyan,
01:56lahat ng outflows dyan,
01:57in-add up lang.
01:58Kaya may tendency talaga
02:00na maging bloated yung figures.
02:03But it is not determinative or conclusive
02:05as to magkano ba talaga yung nasa loob ng account.
02:09Sa isang pahayang,
02:10pinuna ni Duterte ang mga opisyal ng AMLOC
02:13dahil hindi raw nila nilinaw na walang findings
02:16na mga paglabag sa batas
02:17ang kanyang mga transaksyon
02:19at hindi totoong may bilyone
02:21sa kanyang mga bank account.
02:23Sabi niya,
02:24nakadeklara sa kanyang SALEN
02:26ang lahat ng kanyang pera
02:27at ari-arian.
02:28Ang bawat sentimo raw ay lehitimo
02:31at may kaukulang dokumento.
02:34Binanggit din niya
02:35ang inilabas na notice of disallowance
02:37ng Commission on Audit
02:38sa confidential funds ng OVP.
02:41Tila itinaon daw
02:42ang paglalabas ng report
02:44at naaayon sa mga nararanasan
02:46niyang political attack.
02:48Pinababalik ng COA
02:49ang 73 million pesos
02:51na confidential funds
02:52ng tanggapan ng BUSE
02:54paglilinaw ng kanyang abogado.
02:57Hindi pa po final yan
02:58dahil may remedies pa po
03:00ang mga officials ng OVP.
03:03Again,
03:03motion for reconsideration
03:05within 30 days
03:06and then upon denial
03:08kung ano man ang balance
03:09nung 30-day period na yun
03:11ay maaari pa kaming umakyat
03:13sa Supreme Court
03:14on Rule 64.
03:15At doon lang po
03:16sa desisyon ng Supreme Court
03:17magiging final
03:19itong disallowance na ito.
03:21Sa testimony naman
03:22ni dating Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV
03:25na tumanggap umano
03:26ang BUSE
03:27at kanyang pamilya ng pera
03:28mula sa isa umanong drug lord
03:31sinabi ng BUSE
03:32na halos isang dekada na raw
03:34gumagawa ng kwento
03:35si Trillanes
03:36hinggil sa di umano'y bilyones
03:38sa kanyang bank accounts.
03:40Wala raw nagbago
03:41sa kanyang mga kwento
03:42pero ngayon
03:43ibang makinarya na raw
03:45ang nasa likod niya.
03:47Ito raw si Pangulong Bongbong Marcos
03:48na dapat anya
03:49ay magpa-drug test
03:51at ang mga tinawag ng BUSE
03:52na mga lawbender
03:54na kongresista
03:55na tumanggap
03:56na mga maleta
03:57at paulit-ulit
03:58anyang binabaliwala
04:00ang constitutional limit.
04:01Kung gaana raw
04:02katindi ang paninira
04:04sa kanya
04:04ganun din daw
04:05katindi ang katahimikan
04:07at takot
04:08ng administrasyon
04:09na managot
04:10sa bilong-bilong pisong
04:11ninakaw umano
04:12inilagay sa maleta
04:13at inilabas
04:15ng bansa.
04:16Hinihinga namin
04:17ang reaksyon
04:18ng mga personalidad
04:19at mga tanggapang binanggit
04:21ni Duterte.
04:22Ipaniliwanag naman
04:23ang kanyang abogado
04:24ang sinabi sa komite
04:26kahapon
04:26na ilang taon
04:27umanong hindi
04:28nagdeklara
04:29ng cash on hand
04:30and in bank
04:31si Duterte.
04:34She disclosed
04:35because it was all
04:37lumped under
04:38yung others.
04:40Kasi sa personal items
04:42kung makita nyo
04:42dun sa salin
04:43nakasulat dun eh
04:46vehicles
04:47others.
04:48So yung cash in bank
04:50kasama siya
04:51dun sa others.
04:51I just wanted to clarify
04:52kasi baka sabihin
04:53parang sinasabi namin
04:56mali
04:56o sinungaling
04:57yung mga
04:58house members.
04:59Hindi naman po
05:00kasi ang sinasabi naman nila
05:01is walang line item
05:03ng cash in bank.
05:04Muling iginiit
05:05ng defense team
05:06ng DSE
05:07ang kanilang naunang
05:08posisyon
05:08na sa tamang forum lang
05:10haharap
05:11at sasagot si DT
05:12at ang kanyang
05:13mga abogado.
05:14A mere presentation
05:16of supposed evidence
05:19before a committee
05:20that is not authorized
05:22to conduct trial
05:23does not really
05:24amount to prove.
05:26Every evidence
05:27whether it's
05:28something that you present
05:31in an ordinary case
05:33or in this case
05:35in an impeachment proceeding
05:36must still survive
05:39scrutiny.
05:39It happens only
05:41in a proper trial
05:43before a tribunal
05:46or a body
05:47that has
05:48jurisdiction
05:49to conduct trial.
05:51Ang pagdinigdang
05:52House Committee of Justice
05:53ginagawa raw
05:55para alamin
05:56kung merong
05:56probable cause
05:57para i-impeach
05:58si Vice President Duterte.
06:01Na-reach na po ba
06:02yung threshold
06:02for probable cause
06:03sa tingin po ninyo?
06:04This is my take, ha?
06:07In my personal capacity
06:10not as Justice Chair
06:12after all
06:13I do not vote.
06:14Tingin ko
06:15baka nga
06:17nalampasan pa
06:18with the weight
06:19of evidence
06:20that was presented
06:21that were presented
06:22in yesterday's hearing.
06:24Ang net inflow
06:25na dumaan
06:26sa mga account niya
06:27ayon sa AMLA
06:28ay umabot sa
06:292.87 billion pesos.
06:32Samantalang
06:34ang na-declare niya
06:36sa kanyang sal-end
06:37ay 88.5 million pesos lamang.
06:41Napakalaki ng
06:43pagkakaiba
06:44yung discrepancy
06:46ng dalawang halaga na yan
06:47at either dito
06:49sa committee
06:50o kaya sa senado
06:51kung yan ang kagustuhan niya
06:53ay dapat ipaliwanag niya.
06:56Para sa akin
06:57ito ay isang
06:57smoking gun
06:59na at least
07:01insofar as
07:02probable cause
07:03is concerned
07:03ay
07:04andyan na yan.
07:06May nakita ng
07:07probable cause
07:07ang ilang miyembro
07:08ng House Committee on Justice
07:10para i-impeach
07:11si Vice President
07:12Sara Duterte
07:13kahit hindi pa
07:14nabubuksan
07:15ang kahong isinumite
07:16ng Bureau of Internal Revenue
07:18na naglalaman
07:19ng mga income tax returns
07:20ng BICE
07:21at ng kanyang asawa.
07:23Pagbobotohan pa
07:24kung bubuksan
07:25ang kahon
07:26o hindi
07:26sa susunod na hearing.
07:28Ang kahon
07:29ng income tax returns
07:30ng BICE
07:31nasa pangangalaga
07:32ngayon
07:32ng Sekretary
07:33ng Kumite
07:34tatalakayin din
07:35sa susunod na pagdinig
07:37ang umunoy banta
07:38ni Duterte
07:39sa Pangulo,
07:40First Lady
07:41at dating Speaker
07:42at inaasahang
07:44pagbobotohan na
07:45pagkatapos nito
07:46kung may probable cause
07:47para i-impeach
07:48ang BICE.
07:50Hindi naman
07:51natuloy
07:51ang pagbiyahe
07:52abroad ng BICE
07:53na magsisimula
07:54sana ngayong araw
07:55base sa kanyang
07:56travel authority
07:57na kahapon
07:58in-issue
07:59o inilabas.
08:00Sabi ng BICE
08:01salama
08:02sa anya'y
08:03last minute
08:03na pagbibigay
08:04sa kanya
08:05ng travel authority.
08:06Nagbago na raw
08:08ang kanya mga plano
08:09dahil sa hindi
08:10kasiguruhan
08:11kung papayagan ba siya.
08:13Maghahain daw siya
08:14ng panibagong request.
08:16Ayon sa Malacanang,
08:18April 14,
08:19hiniling ng BICE
08:20ang travel authority
08:21o isang linggo
08:23bago ito
08:23pinagbigyan
08:24paglilinaw pa
08:25ng palasyo.
08:26Para sabihin na
08:29last minute
08:31resolution
08:32or decision to,
08:33hindi po ganun.
08:34Dahil yun po palagi,
08:36normally,
08:37nangyayari po
08:38ang pagbibigay
08:39sa kanya ng travel authority
08:40a day before.
08:41Normally po,
08:42mga five working days
08:44inaayos
08:45at
08:47pagka
08:48ang BICE presidente
08:49naman
08:49ang umihiling,
08:51hindi naman niyang
08:52tinatanggiyan.
08:52We usually expedite
08:54the processing
08:55of the travel request.
08:57Pero may mas mahalagang tanong
08:59ayon sa palasyo.
09:00Bakit nagbago
09:01ang isipan ni Pangulo
09:03or rather ni dating
09:04ni BICE presidente?
09:06What made
09:07her change
09:09her mind
09:09is the
09:116.7
09:12billion
09:13question.
09:15Idiniindi ng palasyo
09:16ang pagiging mataas
09:17na opisyal
09:18ng gobyerno
09:19ng BICE
09:19bilang tugon
09:20sa hiling ng BICE
09:21para sa confidentiality
09:23sa mga impormasyon
09:25tulad ng mga biyahe.
09:26Sa palasyo galing
09:27ang detalya ng bansang
09:29pupuntahan
09:29ng BICE.
09:31May mga bagay
09:31na dapat nalalaman
09:32ng publiko
09:33dahil siya
09:34isang public servant.
09:35Ako si Tina
09:36Panganiban Perez
09:37ang inyong saksi.
09:44Pangan
Comments