Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
What happens when a massively popular historical novelist clashes with modern views on race, colonialism, and history? Literary historian Michael Henrik Wynn examines the controversies surrounding Wilbur Smith — the bestselling author of the Courtney and Ballantyne series, whose books have sold more than 140 million copies.

Raised on a colonial ranch in what was then Northern Rhodesia, Smith crafted gripping tales of adventure, violence, and empire that thrilled readers around the globe. But his vivid portrayals of Africa and its people have drawn sharp criticism for romanticizing settler life and perpetuating stereotypes.

In this segment from www.historyradio.org , Wynn unpacks Smith's complex legacy: from high praise (including admiration from Stephen King) to accusations of historical revisionism and cultural insensitivity.

Love historical fiction? Curious about the politics of popular literature? This is essential listening. Decide for yourself: adventure classic or problematic relic?

If you enjoy literary deep dives and historical debates, hit subscribe and turn on notifications for more from www.historyradio.org .

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00History, according to Wilbur Smith.
00:25The sun rose over the African continent like a slow tide of fire,
00:29spilling across the Kalahari sands and the scrubless plains
00:32where the mirage lay so thick you could almost drink it.
00:36Behind the hills the sky paled to ash, then to a pale blue canvas,
00:41streaked with the first eagles turning on the thermals.
00:44The land stretched away in every direction, baked and glittering,
00:48where the tracks of the early hunters had long since been erased by the wind,
00:52and the bones of dead oxen bleached beside the wagon trails.
00:57Time seemed to hang here, suspended between the raw brutality of the present
01:02and the legends of the past,
01:04the men who had crossed this emptiness with pistols and horses,
01:08trusting faith and luck to carry them to the goldfields
01:11and the rivers whose names had become myth.
01:14As the caravan moved forward, dust rising like the breath of the earth itself,
01:19the emptiness pressed in, immense and indifferent,
01:21a stage on which empires and men would rise and fall without witness,
01:26save the sky and the vultures circling high above.
01:30From Birds of Prey, 1976.
01:36Birds of Prey
01:36Birds of Prey
02:03Wilbur Smit's historical fiction was dug by controversies over racism, colonialism, and historical revisionism.
02:10He is remembered as the modern incarnation of H. Ryder Haggard, and like him, he romanticized the many foreign intrusions
02:17into a dark continent.
02:19Smit spent his early years in the wild, untamed landscapes of northern Rhodesia, now Zambia,
02:25born in Endola and raised on his family's vast 25,000-acre cattle ranch along the Cafu River near Mazabuka,
02:33where endless forests, hills, and savannah stretched in every direction.
02:39Accompanied by the young black sons of the ranch workers, he ranged freely through the bush,
02:44hiking, hunting birds and small mammals, and living a boyhood steeped in raw physicality and frontier life.
02:51It was an unmistakably colonial and hyper-masculine world.
02:56His father, a metalwork and boxer-turned-rancher, was an unyielding man's man who scorned books,
03:02including his son's later novels.
03:05From him Wilbur inherited toughness and self-reliance,
03:09as well as notions of imperial entitlement and colonial supremacy.
03:13His father saw writing as a sentimental waste of time,
03:17but his quiet mother reared him on nightly tales of escape and adventure,
03:21and nurtured his imagination.
03:23But it was ranch life that shaped his later career,
03:27rugged action over intellect and wide mastery of the African bush.
03:32Wilbur Schmid shot his first lion at the age of 14.
03:36He eventually became an adventurer himself,
03:37not too different from his fictional mercenaries,
03:40flying his own plane to remote destinations and running his own wild game reserve.
03:45He remained slim and fit even into his 70s,
03:48with a fine face and a mischievous smile rarely captured in photographs.
03:53His debut novel, When the Lion Feeds, from 1964,
03:58launched both his career on the first major backlash.
04:01The story of twins Sean and Gary Courtney romanticized the Anglo-Sulu war and white settler life,
04:08but South Africa's publication control board banned it for 11 years on grounds of dealing in an improper manner,
04:14with promiscuity, passionate love, sin, sexual intercourse, obscene language,
04:19blasphemous language, sadism and cruelty.
04:22Court hearing during appeals descended into literary criticism,
04:26describing passages as in poor literary taste,
04:29and calculated to incite lustful thoughts and sexual desire.
04:35Schmid followed with The Sound of Thunder in 1966,
04:38advancing the court knitwends through the Second Boer Wall.
04:42Both early courtly novels were repeatedly attacked for glorifying European settlers
04:47and downplaying atrocities against indigenous populations.
04:50The Dark of the Sun from 1965 and Shout at the Devil from 1968
04:56drew similar fire for reducing Africans to stereotypes and secondary characters
05:01and celebrating mercenary violence.
05:03The 1976 film adaptation of the latter, starring Roger Moore and Lee Marvin,
05:09fanned the flames considerably.
05:11Goldmine from 1970 and its 1974 film Gold
05:15faced condemnation for focusing on white protagonists
05:18in the apartheid-era mining industry, while ignoring black labour exploitation.
05:24By the 1980s, Schmid had launched at the Ballantyne series
05:28A Fountain Flies from 1980, Men of Men from 1981,
05:33The Angels Weep from 1982,
05:35which chronicled the white colonization of Rhodesia and the Matabella Wars.
05:40Critics accused these books of sanitizing violence and displacement of indigenous peoples,
05:45while presenting its sympathetic portraits of white Rhodesian settlers during the Bush Wars.
05:51The Egyptian novels, River Gods from 1993 and Seven Scrolls from 1995,
05:58were faulted for an Orientalist exotism that reduced Egyptian cultures to mysticism and historical inaccuracy.
06:05The faceless condemnation, however, centered on rage from 1987,
06:09the courtly novel set against late apartheid turmoil and the Sharpeville massacre.
06:14One academic described the entire Courtney saga as an obvious example of the application of biology
06:20to support the separate development of blacks under apartheid,
06:23arguing that the black characters in Schmid's books were essentially and naturally debased.
06:29Contemporary reviewers singled outrage as the worst offenders in the series,
06:33with one stating that he had read it to see if it was as bad as he had heard.
06:37I discovered, no, it was worse.
06:39Another scholar, writing in the journal South African Studies,
06:43accused the novel of presenting biased, illiberal views against African nationalism.
06:48Post-colonial theory traced a red line of objectionable politics throughout Schmid's whole body of work.
06:55A prominent South African journalist labeled Schmid a racist and a sexist child of the British Empire
07:00in a 2021 obituary, arguing that Schmid's fiction brimmed with the nostalgia of empire.
07:07Schmid himself would have disagreed.
07:09In a 2011 interview, he insisted,
07:12I would say that is the way the world works.
07:15If you see that in my book, then you see something that is not there.
07:20Schmid once confessed that he had hated the loneliness and doubt that told his early mid-book crisis.
07:26He did not see himself as an easy man.
07:29His divorces were bitter, and he was estranged from several of his children.
07:32He left Radicia during Ian Smith's era, allegedly because he did not want to perpetuate injustices.
07:39Even so, his next books continued to romanticize the colonial conflict.
07:44Later in life, he changed publishers several times.
07:47He went from Heinemann to Panma Macmillan, then to HarperCollins, then to Bonnier Zafra,
07:52partly to accelerate output with co-authors after fans demanded more Courtney and Ballantyne stories.
07:59In his 2018 autobiography, On Leopard Rock, he acknowledged shifting social attitudes and the need for more inclusive storytelling.
08:08His early books, however, continued to attract attention for their uncritical portrayals of colonialism and race.
08:15Will Smith died in Cape Town in 2021, obituary centered on his divided legacy.
08:21He sold millions of books worldwide, but was somehow entrenched in racial and colonial stereotypes.
08:26He became a larger-than-life icon, celebrated for an inexhaustible creative energy and passion for storytelling.
08:35But memories of his most contentious titles, when the Lion Feeds, Rage, and the broader Courtney and Ballantyne cycles,
08:42often resurface in literary reviews.
08:45Many readers, including former British Prime Minister John Major, loved Webber Smith's books for their unapologetic escapism,
08:53their high-staked dramas, and their vivid and immersive setties.
08:57Millions were transported into an Africa red in tooth and claw,
09:00into vast savannas, gold rush, into colonial frontiers, or ancient Egyptian courts, or big game hunts.
09:08They scented open grassland, heard roaring lions, and felt the thrill of impending battle.
09:15And this fast-paced action could assume an almost epic quality, a saga of generation,
09:21interspersed with meticulous, if controversial, historical detail.
09:25They were African-Western novels, with a cinematic quality, and they hooked readers from the very start.
09:31Smith created protagonists that resonated with many, and he invoked a sense of wonder about Africa,
09:37its wild life, its politics, and its untamed past.
09:42Smith's transcendent controversy, and his books became the guilty pleasure of young and old,
09:48with total sales surpassing 140 million.
09:52In the summer of 2006, Stephen King nominated his Best Historical Novelist,
09:57I would say Wilbur Smith, with his swashbuckling novels of Africa, he declared.
10:02You can get lost in Wilbur Smith, and misplays all of August.
10:09Is it true you mercenaries will do anything for money?
10:12What are you talking about?
10:12That we're going to pick up 50 million dollars worth of diamonds.
10:16Hey, you want to come?
10:19I'll be there.
10:20Right!
10:2450 million dollars in diamonds is their mission.
10:29A deal, Captain.
10:32Three days.
10:34To keep the Congo alive.
10:37Danger is their 9-to-5 job.
10:51This is HistoryRadio.org, a free radio stream.
10:56Promoting knowledge of literature and history.
10:59One.
11:13But it's true you've got a 13-day radio stream.
11:13One.
11:13But it's history.
11:14One.
11:14Two.
11:14Many.
11:14Three.
11:15One.
11:15Three.
11:15Nine.
11:20Three.
11:20Three.
11:20Three.
11:21Ten.
11:22Three.
Comments

Recommended