- 9 minutes ago
As West Asia war triggers severe economic repercussions on global markets and India, experts share their perspective on how to deal with its impact on the economy.
Category
đź—ž
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shaquille.
00:02The war in West Asia shows no signs of ending.
00:06With tensions escalating, global economies are feeling the strain.
00:10And India is no exception.
00:12Rising food, oil and gas prices, coupled with potential disruptions through the Strait of Hormuz,
00:18are adding immediate pressure on India's import bill and inflation outlook.
00:23The ongoing Iran conflict is now rippling across supply chains,
00:28pushing up input costs, unsettling the currency,
00:32and is raising concerns over energy security within the country.
00:36The crisis in India is also exposing structural vulnerabilities
00:41from energy dependence to supply chain resilience,
00:44prompting urgent questions about how prepared India is
00:48to navigate prolonged geopolitical shocks like this,
00:51and whether this moment actually calls for faster diversification,
00:55stronger domestic capacity, and sharper economic safeguards.
01:00Before I bring in the guests to discuss the real impact of the war on India,
01:04here's a report.
01:11A war in West Asia, but a global crisis.
01:14The impact of the conflict on India is deepening,
01:17and it's no longer limited to cooking gas and petrol.
01:21Signs of stress are already visible.
01:25India's manufacturing PMI has slipped to 53.9 in March,
01:29the lowest in nearly four years, as rising input costs.
01:34Shortage of raw material and global uncertainty begin to weigh on production.
01:39Inflation risks are building again.
01:42Prices of key inputs from metals to chemicals and fuel
01:45have seen the sharpest spike since August 2022,
01:50raising the likelihood of costlier goods in the coming weeks.
01:53But the biggest pressure point remains energy.
01:57India imports more than 80% of its crude oil.
02:00And with Brent crude hovering around $100 per barrel,
02:05the country's import bill is set to rise sharply.
02:09The rupee is already under pressure,
02:11trading close to new record lows,
02:13making imports even more expensive.
02:16Growth projections are now at risk.
02:18India's expected 7 to 7.4% of GDP growth
02:23for financial year 2027 faces downside pressure
02:27due to elevated energy prices and supply chain disruptions
02:30linked to US-Israel war on Iran.
02:35The government has already begun responding.
02:38Excise duty cuts on petrol and diesel to contain inflation.
02:42Steps are being taken to stabilise the rupee
02:44by tightening forex market exposures.
02:47And a closer monitoring of fuel and fertiliser supply chains.
02:51But the impact is spreading beyond core sectors.
02:55India's $6 billion bottled water industry
02:58is seeing price hikes due to higher packaging and transport costs.
03:03Energy-intensive industries are also taking a hit.
03:07In Gujarat's ceramic hub,
03:09production has slowed as gas prices surge,
03:12forcing units to cut operations.
03:14And there's a strategic risk emerging.
03:18Nearly 60% of India's internet traffic
03:21passes through undersea cables
03:23near the Gulf and Red Sea.
03:25With rising threats in the region,
03:27any disruption could impact digital services,
03:30banking networks and global connectivity.
03:35From inflation to industry,
03:38from currency to connectivity,
03:41the West Asia war is now testing
03:43India's economic resilience.
03:47Bureau Report, India Today.
03:50Let me go straight to our guests
03:52who are joining me tonight.
03:54Shankar Ayer, political economist,
03:55author and columnist.
03:57We also have Prachi Mishra,
04:00professor of economics,
04:01director and head of the ISAC Center
04:03for Public Policy at Ashoka University.
04:06Shankar Ayer, let me begin with you.
04:08If this conflict drags on
04:10for the next few months,
04:12where does the first visible crack appear in India?
04:16Farmer incomes, industrial activity
04:18or financial markets?
04:20And how quickly does it start
04:22hitting overall growth?
04:25Well, we can see the cracks as it is now
04:28in the real economy in terms of...
04:32So India is facing both an issue,
04:35double whammy of availability and pricing.
04:39So availability and affordability in the economy
04:42translates, transmits to the real economy.
04:44In the sense that one's gas...
04:46So petroleum products are responsible
04:49for 6,000 products from heart valves
04:54to hydrocarbons used for fertilizers and stuff.
04:57So there are many sectors from packaging,
05:01from, for instance, in Madhya Pradesh,
05:04the last one week they have not been able
05:06to procure food grains
05:09because of lack of bags to take them into.
05:12So that is because the PDP, HDP,
05:16all those bags are not produced
05:18because the raw material is not available.
05:20In textile units, the same story
05:22for dyes and chemicals.
05:25This will seep into the pharmaceutical sector
05:27because even an humble product like paracetamol
05:30requires, you know, hydrocarbons.
05:34So this is what I call a molecular contagion.
05:37So this will seep through.
05:39We will see it playing out.
05:41If this war lasts more than April,
05:44we will see extensive damage.
05:47And even if it ends, Maria, in the next two weeks,
05:52the impact will be felt for the...
05:57This is because the incomes, the disruption,
06:00the migrant labor, which has gone back.
06:03This is the peak season of construction.
06:06And you don't have labor in most cities.
06:09This is the peak season for production
06:11of manufacturing goods
06:13because this is when people and companies
06:15are unable to deal with the situation.
06:17And so there is a genuine fear.
06:20And on top of it all is the crash in the rupee.
06:25I mean, it's gone down from somewhere near 89 to 95,
06:29and now the RBI has taken some steps.
06:32But nobody's quite sure where it goes.
06:34If Tauji Trump does something crazy tomorrow,
06:37then, you know, it will have its own repercussions.
06:40Now, you asked about the financial sector.
06:42Now, each of these businesses is borrowing from the banks
06:49and NBFCs, and each of these sectors
06:52is a depositor in the banks and NBFCs.
06:55So this is, again, a double value.
06:57Okay. I'm coming back to you in just a quick...
07:00First of all, let me take an opening comment also from Prachi.
07:04Prachi, India is heavily import-dependent for fertilizers.
07:07Let's put the spotlight on farmers here.
07:10If supply chains are disrupted,
07:13are we looking at higher input costs for farmers
07:17because of the, you know, season,
07:20the farming season which is going to begin?
07:21And could that then translate into food inflation
07:24and pressures on rural incomes in the coming crop cycle,
07:29something that has been under control in India so far?
07:32The food inflation is very much in control.
07:35So, Maria, pleasure to be here.
07:38I think let's step back.
07:39I think Shankar mentioned, you know,
07:42let's think what the nature of the shock is.
07:44You know, analysts are comparing it to COVID,
07:46but this is a different shock.
07:47You know, COVID was...
07:48It originated from a health shock.
07:50And the impact on the economy, remember, in COVID,
07:53occurred through direct impact on consumption and production.
07:57In fact, my research is suggesting that, you know,
07:59globally, there's not much scarring from COVID.
08:02This time, it's very different.
08:04It's an upstream shock.
08:06And the reason I'm calling it upstream is exactly what you mentioned.
08:10It strikes intermediate inputs, and that powers everything else.
08:16And that escalates into, you know, everything else.
08:18And I think for us, I think the more useful comparison, for example,
08:23is the 1979 OPEC embargo or the Iranian revolution.
08:29And let me tell you, few people are aware that, you know,
08:32the Iranian revolution, you know, after 1979,
08:36India turned to the IMF in 1981 for the then largest loan of 5 million SDRs,
08:42the special drawing rights.
08:44Coming back to your question, I think the impact, the macroeconomic impact,
08:49whether it's the impact on inflation, whether it's the impact on the current account,
08:53whether it's the impact on fiscal, depends on the duration.
08:57And here, and maybe Shankar mentioned as well,
09:00we have to distinguish between de jure duration and the de facto duration.
09:05So how long will the shock last?
09:07I think, honestly, you know, nobody...
09:09Forecasters admit that they do not know.
09:11But even after the conflict ends, I think energy market normalization
09:16can take months, if not days.
09:19Think about, you know, tanker routing, insurance premiums,
09:22refinery schedule, all have their own momentum.
09:25So I think the impact on inflation, food inflation, etc.,
09:29I think will depend on how long the shock lasts.
09:33Our baseline, my team's baseline projections, you know,
09:36if the de facto shock wanes by, say, June,
09:39I think the macroeconomic damage will be manageable.
09:43However, if it escalates to the rest of the year,
09:48in de facto terms, I think then the impact will be much more severe.
09:52And then there you could have a situation where, you know,
09:55CPI inflation could reach the 4% target,
09:58even with, you know, limited consumer pass-through.
10:00I'll just say one quick thing.
10:02I think this time is different also because of our initial conditions.
10:07Remember that, you know, we are entering this crisis
10:10with much better initial conditions.
10:12You can think about, you know, growth, you can think about inflation,
10:16you can think about external sector.
10:19So that gives us some buffer.
10:21But remember that, you know, the buffer is not unlimited.
10:23Okay, so Shankar, I am coming back to you.
10:27Let's look at the Indians here in the Gulf.
10:31With this uncertainty continuing,
10:34how serious is the risk to remittances and Indian jobs overseas?
10:39And could that then trigger a quiet demand slowdown in rural
10:44and small towns of India, especially in remittance-dependent states?
10:51Maria, if there is a problem tomorrow, day after,
10:55if there is an attack on the Gulf countries
10:58and they are forced to evacuate or jobs are lost,
11:01demand constraint will be the least of our problems.
11:05We will have 10 million people looking for jobs,
11:09looking the fear, the panic that this will set off
11:12will be unbelievable.
11:14I mean, you know, we've seen some of it when the OPEC thing happened
11:19and Venkatraman, who was the finance minister,
11:22went to IMF and got a bailout.
11:25Thereafter, in 1990-91, we had to switch,
11:29you know, allow U.S. planes to refuel in India
11:33and that's when the gold pledging happened
11:36and India had to sort of go to the IMF again.
11:38This time, with that, all the macros which are in our favor
11:44are not helping us sustain the rupee at a certain level.
11:49And so we don't know, there are many unknowns here.
11:53So if the job losses happen in the Gulf countries,
11:57if those people come back to, say, Sivan or Trichur
12:01or to Trichnapalri,
12:02there will be a serious social, political impact of it.
12:07The economic impact of it is a secondary story.
12:10It's a second-order issue.
12:12And so we hope that that won't happen.
12:15I think the one...
12:18So Shankar, you are saying that even that social impact
12:21is likely to play out only if the war continues
12:25the whole of April that we are in, this month.
12:28Yes. Yeah.
12:29So, you know, there is an unknown red line in this.
12:34At what point do Indians start thinking of leaving?
12:38For instance, that not many people will admit it,
12:41but people sort of, even in Israel,
12:44are sort of going out via Egypt.
12:46In Dubai, they are going to other countries
12:48towards Turkey and coming out.
12:50So there is a certain amount of exodus.
12:53All those gold visa fellows who were there,
12:55as the 500,000 people who had got gold visas,
12:58I don't know how many of them are still there in Dubai.
13:01So that's an interesting story to follow up.
13:04But if there is a sustained attack on the Gulf countries,
13:09A, you will lose the supply of oil and gas.
13:13Qatar already has said that 40%, 50% of its gas production
13:18is shut down.
13:18The second is these Gulf countries are also markets for us
13:22around $20, $25 billion worth of exports
13:26is sent to these countries.
13:28The third is the job and the remittances picture.
13:31Now, if the remittances fall,
13:33you have to think about a trifecta here.
13:37The FIIs have sold 1 lakh crore's worth of stocks
13:41in the last one month.
13:43The FDI, net FDI is negative.
13:48And if remittances drop,
13:50our current account situation will be tight.
13:54And we will have to do extraordinary measures.
13:57But I will sort of end with this, Maria.
14:00In India, crisis is a feel-good factor
14:04because that is the only time when reforms happen.
14:07Yes, and it's an opportunity.
14:09So, when we look at the picture as of now,
14:13the showing stress,
14:14which are the sectors which are already showing stress,
14:18Prachi?
14:19MSMEs, construction, auto,
14:22or export-linked industries?
14:28Yeah, look, I think, you know,
14:31again, I would emphasize that, of course,
14:35you know, there's a macroeconomic impact
14:38and that will feed into certain sectors.
14:40And we have seen, actually, government policies
14:42to be quite agile in terms of supporting
14:46particular sectors.
14:48I think, too, overlooking,
14:50I would like to mention, you know,
14:51to add to what Shankar said, Maria.
14:53There are also too often overlooked
14:56cushioning effects here.
14:58Remember that, you know,
14:59our customs duties are ad valorem.
15:03And, you know, we actually,
15:05we have, you know,
15:06ad valorem customs duties
15:08can actually improve the fiscal.
15:10And India, remember that India
15:12is also the fifth largest
15:13refined petroleum exporter,
15:16which means that, you know,
15:18higher crude oil prices
15:19are partially offset through export revenues.
15:22That's why it's all not,
15:24at least in the short term,
15:26I think there are offsetting factors
15:28which actually drive some
15:29of our rather benign projections.
15:32If, you know,
15:33if de facto war situation,
15:36de facto, the reason I say de facto
15:38for the reasons I explained,
15:39that is, you know,
15:40even after the conflict ends,
15:42you know, there can be energy markets
15:43can be under pressure,
15:45normalization can take time.
15:46But I think if de facto war ends
15:48in, by June,
15:50I think we are still
15:51in a manageable macroeconomic scenario
15:54and that implies for sectors as well.
15:57However, in the escalation scenario,
15:59if it escalates beyond,
16:01you know, mid of this year,
16:03I think then,
16:04I think there I see
16:05a more serious situation.
16:07And there, I think the effects
16:09can be quite non-linear.
16:11And let me give you an example.
16:12People, you know,
16:13we live in a world of integrated
16:14global value chains, right?
16:16So crude oil, for example,
16:18it is an input into our exports
16:20of refined products.
16:22So therefore,
16:23as crude gets more and more expensive,
16:25it will have a ripple effect.
16:27And that will have an adverse impact
16:30not only on, you know,
16:32you know, you know, imports,
16:34but it will offset the cushioning effect
16:37on refined exports.
16:38So the cushioning effect
16:40we have in the short term
16:41will slowly wane
16:43because of these ripple effects.
16:45And, you know,
16:46particular sectors, of course,
16:47will get more affected.
16:48So I would think,
16:49I think if de facto war
16:52continues beyond mid-year,
16:54I think then there is,
16:56you know,
16:57the situation will be harder to manage.
17:00Okay.
17:01Macroeconomic with implications
17:02for certain sectors.
17:03And of course,
17:04there are unequal impacts
17:05across states,
17:06as, you know,
17:06Shankar mentioned
17:07in terms of remittance.
17:08And remember that remittance
17:10is also important
17:10for the current account.
17:11Remittances are a cushioning effect
17:13for our current account deficit.
17:16You know,
17:16our current account deficit
17:17is low because,
17:19you know,
17:19partly due to remittances.
17:20If remittances get affected,
17:23you know,
17:23that will have
17:24an adverse impact
17:26on macroeconomy
17:27and an uneven effect
17:29across states.
17:30For example,
17:31Kerala would be
17:31definitely more affected.
17:33Yeah.
17:33Shankar,
17:33let me give you
17:34the last word
17:34on the show tonight.
17:35So you say that,
17:37you know,
17:37every crisis
17:38is an opportunity here.
17:40What can the government do?
17:42A quick response
17:42in one minute, please.
17:45I think India
17:46should start doing
17:47the things
17:48that are needed
17:48to be done
17:49so that we don't
17:50face this again.
17:51They cannot change
17:53what is happening
17:54on the ground
17:54beyond the incremental
17:57access of fertilizers,
17:59immediate goods,
17:59transmission of credit
18:01to sectors
18:02and stuff like that.
18:04What this offers us
18:05is to think about
18:07how you will build
18:08a $10 trillion economy
18:10without energy security.
18:12And that is what
18:13they should focus on,
18:14should focus on solar.
18:15We should also ramp up
18:18gigawatts.
18:19So, you know,
18:19we should move
18:20from this idea
18:21of barrels-fueled economy
18:23to gigawatts-fueled economy
18:25and there are many things
18:26that can be done.
18:28But important,
18:29let's plan
18:30that this doesn't
18:31happen again.
18:32Certainly.
18:33Shankar Aya,
18:34Prachi Mishra,
18:35really appreciate your time.
18:36Thank you for joining us
18:37and sharing your thoughts.
18:40Thank you, Maria.
18:43Earlier,
18:43I spoke with Dr. John
18:45Asfakya Anakis,
18:46a prominent
18:47Riyadh-based economist
18:48about the economies
18:49and sectors
18:50that are facing
18:51or are likely
18:52to face a significant
18:53global impact.
18:54I'm leaving you
18:55with this exclusive conversation.
18:57Thanks so much for watching.
19:04As the war drags on
19:06and Donald Trump
19:07signals there is
19:08no immediate end in sight,
19:10the economic impact
19:11is now spreading
19:12well beyond oil,
19:14hitting trade,
19:15aviation,
19:16manufacturing,
19:16and financial markets.
19:18The key question
19:19tonight is
19:20which economies
19:21and which sectors
19:22are taking the biggest hit
19:24from a prolonged conflict.
19:26Joining me on the show tonight,
19:27Dr. John Asfakya Anakis,
19:29who is a chief economist
19:30and head of research
19:31at the Gulf Research Center.
19:34John,
19:34how would you describe
19:35the overall economic impact
19:37of this war now?
19:38Is it still contained
19:40or already spilling
19:41across sectors globally?
19:45I believe it's gradually
19:47spreading.
19:48We're seeing the beginning
19:50of what seems to be
19:52a recession.
19:53We are beginning to see
19:55higher inflation.
19:56We're beginning to see
19:57queues of people
20:00going into
20:02a fuel shortage situation.
20:04We're beginning to see
20:06what are the elements
20:08of a global recession.
20:10The longer this war
20:11drags out
20:12and the longer
20:13the strait is shut,
20:15the more are the difficulties
20:16that Asia,
20:17as well as Europe,
20:19and the United States
20:21is going to face.
20:22But particularly Asia,
20:24because Asia
20:25needs the oil
20:27out of the Gulf
20:28and they're getting
20:29very little.
20:31Which economies,
20:32according to you,
20:33are most exposed
20:34right now?
20:36Energy importing countries
20:38like India and Europe,
20:40or are emerging markets
20:42facing a deeper shock?
20:45Definitely the first
20:47hit countries are those
20:48that are in emerging markets.
20:50You mentioned India,
20:51for sure.
20:52Shortage in terms
20:53of cooking oil,
20:54you see it every day
20:55in India.
20:56But also Pakistan,
20:57heavily impacted.
20:59Philippines,
21:00Indonesia,
21:01you're going to see
21:02other Asian countries
21:03facing the difficulties.
21:05Australian natural gas
21:06is not enough.
21:07we need more natural gas
21:09for Asia.
21:10But also,
21:11you will see it spread
21:13throughout the rest
21:14of the Middle East.
21:15Egypt is facing a crisis.
21:17Jordan is going
21:18to face a crisis.
21:19And even poor
21:20and destitute Yemen
21:22is going to be facing
21:24a huge crisis.
21:25So,
21:25the have-nots
21:26are facing it now.
21:28But the haves,
21:29the developed world,
21:30is going to face it
21:31very quickly
21:32because they already
21:33see it in terms
21:34of higher fuel costs.
21:35And remember,
21:37we're still at the beginning
21:38of this crisis.
21:39If we go into
21:40the summer months
21:41with the issue
21:43of the strait
21:44being shut,
21:45then we're going
21:46to go into
21:46a deep recession
21:47in the winter.
21:49Let's go beyond oil.
21:50Shipping lanes
21:51are disrupted.
21:53Insurance costs
21:54are up already.
21:55How severe
21:56is the hit
21:56to global logistics
21:58and trade flows?
22:01Well,
22:02I'll give you
22:02an example.
22:03You're absolutely
22:04correct to indicate
22:05towards that direction.
22:07Fertilizers.
22:08They're coming
22:09out of the Gulf.
22:10Principally,
22:11urea,
22:12fertilizers,
22:13and all the other
22:14components
22:15that go into
22:16the agricultural sector.
22:18How are we going
22:19to grow
22:19our crops
22:22if we don't
22:23have fertilizer?
22:24That will be
22:25a major issue
22:25for Asian countries,
22:26but also
22:27for developed countries
22:29that are farming
22:30the world.
22:31Then we're going
22:31to see it
22:32in our food table.
22:33In our food table,
22:34if we have
22:35rising costs
22:37for our everyday rice,
22:39our everyday products,
22:40our bread,
22:41our wheat,
22:42we're not going
22:43to be able
22:43to manage.
22:44And you know,
22:45over the last
22:46three years,
22:46we have been facing
22:47with increasing prices.
22:50Inflation has become
22:51a post-COVID reality
22:53because we unleashed
22:55this paper money,
22:56but also money
22:57into the economies.
22:59And now,
22:59we're facing
23:00with a very high
23:02inflation
23:02for a long time.
23:04And the result
23:06is that
23:06the world economy
23:07cannot sustain
23:08another food crisis,
23:10another inflation crisis,
23:12on the back
23:13of what we faced
23:13immediately after COVID.
23:15So there is
23:16a huge supply issue
23:17that is being created.
23:19If we go
23:20into the coming months
23:22with supply and logistics,
23:24then we're going
23:25to see it
23:25as consumers.
23:26I'll give you
23:27another example.
23:28Jet fuel
23:28is not readily
23:29available in Asia.
23:30That's right.
23:31Ticket prices
23:31have gone up
23:32by 600%
23:33already in Asia.
23:35So people
23:36will have to
23:36make due
23:37less flights,
23:39less airlines.
23:40Airlines are going
23:40to be losing money.
23:42Jet fuel
23:43is going to be
23:44a competitive fuel,
23:45and there will be
23:46great competition
23:47between the Asian market
23:49for jet fuel
23:50and the European market
23:52for jet fuel.
23:53And the higher bidder
23:54and the highest bidder
23:55will end up
23:56taking that,
23:57and it's not going
23:58to be the have-nots.
23:59It's going to be
24:00the has.
24:01Okay.
24:01So my last question
24:02then is what happens
24:03to another sector,
24:04crucial sector,
24:05which is manufacturing,
24:06and sectors like
24:07automobiles
24:08that depend on
24:10complex global
24:11supply chains.
24:12Are we looking
24:13at production
24:14slowdowns
24:15and cost spikes?
24:18Absolutely.
24:19And we have seen
24:21this during COVID.
24:22At that time,
24:23the issue was
24:23the microchips
24:24and the ability
24:25to produce
24:28products that went
24:29into vehicles,
24:30be it electric
24:31or otherwise,
24:33combustion engine.
24:34Today,
24:34the main issue
24:35is that if we don't
24:36have the components,
24:38which is plastic,
24:4060 to 65%
24:41of an automobile
24:42is made out
24:43of plastic.
24:44The dashboard
24:44is made out
24:45of plastic.
24:45That becomes
24:46an issue.
24:47I'll give you
24:47another example.
24:49For the basic
24:51ammunition that goes
24:52into a hunting
24:53cartridge,
24:54a lot of it
24:55is made out
24:56of plastic.
24:56That plastic
24:57has already
24:58gone up,
24:58component,
24:59by 10%.
25:00That will be
25:01an added cost
25:02for everybody
25:03who is a
25:03recreational hunter
25:04or a sport hunter
25:05or a sportsman.
25:07That alone
25:08is an example.
25:09Automobiles
25:10will go up.
25:10Electric vehicles
25:11will be far
25:12more costly.
25:13The cost of energy
25:14will go much higher.
25:16And that is not
25:17going to be
25:17good news
25:17for the global
25:18economy.
25:19All right.
25:20Thank you so much
25:20for sharing
25:21your thoughts.
Comments