- 14 minutes ago
Joey Zwillinger, the founder of Allbirds and Biologica, sat down with Jason to talk about the challenges of finding your ideal customer. Joey's done it both ways. Starting with a product and searching for the right people to buy it, and starting with a problem and building the solution. In this conversation, he breaks down what actually works when you're hunting for product-market fit, and what to do when your customers surprise you (because they will).
Category
đź—ž
NewsTranscript
00:00The way I think about extending what you do as your core offering for a consumer is through a little
00:05framework of weirdness.
00:07If you go one degree of weird and you test that out cautiously, but you test it out and you
00:13extend your brand a little bit, the consumer will often go for it.
00:16If you go two degrees of weird, it's likely too weird.
00:19In the footwear industry, a good way to think about it very tactically is like you got a bottom and
00:24you got a top.
00:25And you could change the bottom and keep the top, or you can change the top and keep the bottom.
00:30But if you change the top and you change the bottom, you've gotten two degrees of weird and it is
00:33way too weird.
00:34And people will be like, why are you making that product?
00:38Running a business means solving problems.
00:41I tell you how the smartest entrepreneurs do it.
00:43Hi, I'm Jason Pfeiffer, Editor-in-Chief of Entrepreneur Magazine, and this is Problem Solvers.
00:54Is there any more potent but also haunting phrase than product market fit?
00:59Let me make the argument for both sides.
01:02Important, obviously, because if you do not have product market fit, if you do not have something that the market
01:09wants, then what are you doing?
01:11You're not going to sell a single thing.
01:12But it's haunting because so often we take something to market and then cannot figure out what's wrong.
01:18And then it turns out that we built the right thing for the wrong people or we were targeting the
01:23right people, but we had the wrong thing.
01:25And that is why this phrase, I feel, can be so haunting.
01:29Well, today I've got someone who has done it and done it.
01:32Joey Zwillinger is the co-founder of Allbirds.
01:35He served as its CEO until 2024 after leading its IPO in 2021.
01:40And he is currently the CEO and co-founder of Biologica, a company focused on addressing underserved areas of women's
01:46health, which he can fill in on.
01:48Which means that this is a guy who understands pretty well how to find product market fit.
01:52He has done it to great acclaim before and will do it again.
01:56Joey, thank you so much for joining me on Problem Solvers.
01:58Amazing to be here.
01:59I love the show.
02:00I love your tactical advice.
02:01I think it's amazingly helpful for people who tune in.
02:04Well, thank you.
02:05Thanks for coming here to be really helpful.
02:06So, Joey, before we got recording, you were telling me that you have seen and executed a lot of different
02:13approaches to finding product market fit.
02:16So, maybe we start high level with how you think about this topic for your companies.
02:22I've got it really right and really wrong, too, at grave consequences and some very fortuitous consequences.
02:30So, yeah, hopefully I can share some battle wounds and some things I've tried.
02:36You know, I tend to do the best here when I'm giving examples of what I've done.
02:40So, hopefully we can just dive into specifics.
02:42Please, please.
02:42I love examples.
02:43Interpret what we do.
02:45Without examples, everything sounds abstract.
02:48Hand wavy.
02:49Yeah, exactly.
02:49So, yeah, I mean, I think finding product market fit is the most essential thing you can do, whether it's
02:58a software product, a deep tech or new AI product, or a physical product that you're trying to sell to
03:05people for them to purchase and consume and hopefully buy more of.
03:08It's the most essential thing you can possibly do, and it's extraordinarily high leverage when you get it.
03:14So, it's worth taking the time to try to get that right, and, you know, I think there's a variety
03:21of different ways to understand it, but I'd say most simply what you got to do is identify a need
03:29in the market, and usually that is an insight that is born out of your customers, and you have to
03:34go find that insight.
03:36And it should be very obvious in hindsight and unobvious and usually pretty simple when you find it in the
03:43first place, but you got to go out and get it.
03:46When you find it, you then need to innovate and create something that really meets that need.
03:52That sounds incredibly simple, and that's why I think I say, like, specifics are going to be pretty important.
03:58I've done it very anecdotally and qualitatively with a lot of subjective opinion put into it, and it's been successful.
04:06I've done that as well, and it's been unsuccessful.
04:09I've also done it in a way where it's extraordinarily analytical and quantitatively driven.
04:15You know, as an example, you mentioned in my bio, after leaving the helm of Allbirds, I started a company
04:22called Biologica with my wife.
04:24In that example, we have gone through five focus groups, two hours each across the country, demographically split.
04:32We then did a thousand-person study to identify all of the specific health needs that are most acute for
04:38women based on a variety of different factors, and then we led innovation directly against the findings of those.
04:45And we knew we were going to be successful in that because we knew how prevalent these needs were and
04:50how the dearth of companies that were addressing them in the way that we thought most obvious.
04:56Yeah.
04:56Well, so what you said sounds, of course, like you said, very simple.
05:01It's about understanding the consumer, right?
05:04You find the insight, and then you innovate to meet the need.
05:06And you say that, and everyone should think, well, yeah, obviously, isn't that what we do?
05:11We go and we, like, figure out what people want.
05:13Although a lot of people don't do that.
05:14A lot of people come up with an idea and are just convinced of its value and then take it
05:19to market without actually first figuring out if it's something that people want or building for what people want.
05:24You laid out this interesting juxtaposition where, with Biologica, you're doing this really data-driven research to find the need,
05:33and with Allbirds, not as much.
05:34So maybe take me into the process or how you decide which process to follow based on what your company
05:42does that gets you to the insight that you need.
05:46Yeah.
05:46Let me give you a couple of vignettes, one from Allbirds, one from Biologica, because I think it'll give you,
05:51like, a good rounding out of things that I think can be successful.
05:56So early on, my co-founder, Tim Brown at Allbirds, he actually ran a Kickstarter with an early prototype of
06:04what would later become Allbirds.
06:06So in that, he shot a video.
06:08He did the standard Kickstarter thing.
06:10This was back in 2014.
06:13Yeah, 2014.
06:15And he expressed a set of brand attributes that I thought were beautiful, really resonated with me, and that he
06:22identified certain things.
06:24The hook there was no socks, no smell.
06:29And he was using this new fiber that had never been used in shoes before, ultra-fine merino wool.
06:36It's an incredible fiber that can be knit or woven into a really beautiful fabric, which is what we eventually
06:42did with an Italian factory.
06:44And, you know, I remember we were sitting around the dinner table, Tim, myself, and another friend and all of
06:50our spouses.
06:52And we were sitting there having a good time.
06:54It was at my dining room table.
06:56My wife's an amazing cook.
06:58And this guy, Tom, pretty big dude.
07:02Like, I'd say 250, 275 pounds, at least that.
07:07And he's like, guys, I freaking love your shoes.
07:11Like, and he had one of the prototypes.
07:14He's like, I love them.
07:15But, you know, I just smelled them the other day, and they stink.
07:23Oh, no.
07:24And we're like, well, what did you do?
07:26What did you do to, like, make them stink that bad?
07:28He's like, well, I took them on, like, a seven-mile hike with no socks.
07:32When you realize, what is the insight that you, like, a couple things that we took from that.
07:36One is consumers will do what you tell them to do, and you need to be extraordinarily clear in your
07:42messaging with a product.
07:43And your fit in a market is only so good as the message that you actually express and the value
07:47proposition that you suggest to them.
07:50The second thing is, is that the claims that you make when you make a product are absolute.
07:56They're not relative.
07:57You can't, no one's saying, oh, this Nike shoe smells worse than my Allbirds shoe when I compare and do
08:04the exact same activity.
08:05So we're like, all right, that is a fairly significant set of understandings that we need to bake into this.
08:12Like, we can express a little bit of these attributes, but we need to actually, like, why do people really
08:17love it?
08:17So then what we did is we went into people's homes.
08:20We did kind of an ethnographic research where we really went in there, and I often was the cameraman.
08:26We would ask questions.
08:27How do they shop?
08:28How do they use it?
08:29Why do they like it?
08:30Like, all these, like, really deep, interesting questions, and we would pull out and tease out these really interesting insights
08:36that we had.
08:37And so, you know, what we realized when we started the business was, like, this is a very big trend.
08:43Athleisure had taken over what was in apparel, and it hadn't happened in shoes.
08:48And we had this really interesting long-term tailwind in that sense.
08:51But it needed to be very versatile, both in its aesthetic as well as its comfort, and the comfort was
08:57the performance,
08:58because you're using it versatility throughout your day.
09:00Before you go to Biologica, I just want to pull out something that I heard in there and just have
09:05you react to it.
09:07So the first concept of no socks, no smell sounds really smart and also is eye-catching.
09:17Oh, really?
09:18You can do that?
09:19It's a good hook.
09:20But it's a good hook.
09:21But, you know, I got to say, the more I thought about it in contrast to where you landed, which
09:27was this insight about not just that there is a trend of athleisure that you could extend deeper into this
09:35part of the category,
09:36but rather what that really represented was that people wanted flexibility.
09:40They wanted things that could work in different environments.
09:43It could work professionally.
09:44It could also work socially, et cetera.
09:46When I put those two next to each other, I think the market for people who don't want to wear
09:52socks with their shoes, and that is their primary pain point, feels actually much smaller than the market for people
09:59who want more flexible footwear.
10:02That feels like a larger market and a more interesting and common problem to solve.
10:07And I like to approach this thing.
10:09Yeah.
10:09You're right.
10:10But what we realized was that when we were expressing no socks, what we were trying to express was, it's
10:17so comfortable, you don't need socks.
10:19Totally.
10:20But the literalness.
10:22But the way we express it, yeah.
10:24But people say, like, they interpret what you literally say.
10:27So when we realized that, it was like, oh, okay, we just need to reframe what we're trying to say
10:34with a different kind of a hook.
10:36And we also realized, you know, I was a material scientist, and I've been doing that for quite a long
10:41time prior at a biotech company, but engineering background as well.
10:45So I had this landscape of – and the reason we started Allbirds was we knew there was all these
10:50materials out there that we could do, we could use, that the rest of the industry was not using, that
10:56would consistently and systematically make more comfortable, better products for consumers.
11:00They happened to be a sustainable route.
11:03That was my background.
11:04That was my itch that I had that I wanted to use in business was to make an impact on
11:10climate change through entrepreneurship.
11:12But the way we thought we could do that was, like, systematically get these materials to market, make the product
11:17more comfortable and aesthetically different and more beautiful, and hence deliver that value.
11:22But, yeah, no socks, pretty small need state.
11:25Like, not that many people need that.
11:28There's more with our guest coming in a moment, but first, it is time to play Tax Trivia, brought to
11:35you by TurboTax.
11:36So, ready?
11:37Let's see how much you know about your taxes.
11:39True or false?
11:41You do not need to report side hustle 1099 income in your taxes.
11:46Is that true or false?
11:48Tune in later in the episode for the answer and learn more about filing your taxes with Intuit TurboTax.
11:55Visit TurboTax.intuit.com.
11:59It's interesting to hear, and I'm glad that I pushed you on that so that people could hear what you
12:04were really thinking, that the no socks thing was meant to represent something broader.
12:08But the way that a consumer, and even me, as I was hearing that anecdote, takes things, is so literal.
12:15And so, you have to be really careful about every word that you use and make sure that all your
12:21language is, in some way or another, your target consumer's language, so that they instantly understand what you're talking about.
12:27So, okay, take me into the more data-driven version of this.
12:30Yeah, and by the way, I want to caveat by saying whether it's data-driven or subjective and analytical, neither
12:38of those lack logic, deliberateness, and an analytical lens to it.
12:44So, I don't want to give the sense that, like, go with your gut.
12:49That's, like, that's the way to do it, and that works.
12:51Like, it can work.
12:53You can get lucky, but that's not what I would want to bank my career on.
12:56So, I think some deliberateness in this is pretty important.
12:59After I handed over the reins at Allbirds to a great guy named Joe Vernaccio, the opportunity to reset and
13:04look at another sector was really interesting.
13:07My wife and I had talked about women's health for a long time.
13:10Similar to sustainability in footwear, very, very little leadership in the space.
13:16Lack of funding, lack of focus, lack of attention.
13:20Typically, that leads to an interesting opportunity to build a brand.
13:23Now, that doesn't mean you can make money.
13:26It means that maybe you can make a cool brand, but a cool brand doesn't really work, and it's not
13:30actually that cool or good for the world unless it gets some scale.
13:34We had a very broad lens at first.
13:36We started to narrow down when we realized there was a really interesting opportunity in vitamins and supplements, and the
13:44opportunity being that there was a big white space in the market.
13:47I'll tell you how we found that.
13:48First, when we got interested in the space, we started just talking.
13:52My wife has a very strong lived experience to give us a launching point, but we started assembling groups of
13:5810 women.
13:59We did this five times, as I mentioned earlier.
14:01Everybody wanted simplicity.
14:05Everybody wanted a more credible source of truth with a really rigorous scientific background.
14:11That was pretty universal, and everybody wanted to do something about this.
14:14Then we launched a pretty expensive and extensive study on 1,000 women where we asked them their different health
14:23conditions, top-of-mind concerns, what plagues them on a weekly basis.
14:27Not only did we confirm that insight, but we got very sharp on exactly what was happening across.
14:32We were able to then take that data and focus our product development muscle exactly on solving that problem.
14:40Then we launched one product per hormonal stage when we eventually launched the company in December of 25.
14:48We have three products.
14:50It basically felt like, okay, now we have something that feels very tailored and personalized to the woman who's taking
14:57the product, but pretty high leverage because we have three products that we have to manage.
15:01We can do a good business model in that.
15:06Now we have a brand opportunity plus a business model opportunity with a product that we think can be really
15:13sensational, and that gets us excited to say, okay, we feel like we have a hunch on product market fit
15:20that has a pretty high leverage model around it.
15:23Let's go after that.
15:24Yeah, and so first of all, let's just state, you know, I had said we break this down into the
15:30find the insight and then develop the innovation to meet the need, and what story you just told there is
15:35essentially flowing through both of those.
15:38And yet when I zoom out and think about that in contrast to the Allbirds example, something else that really
15:44jumps to mind, which I'd love to hear you speak to, is in the Allbirds example, you had an idea,
15:50you saw an opportunity in the market, you knew who you were targeting,
15:53but you also developed the product, at least to the point where there were beta testers like that big guy
16:00who sweats too much, whereas here with Biologica, it sounds like you did the research before developing the product,
16:06that you were looking very specifically for understanding the consumer and the need before you went out and did the
16:11innovation.
16:12What's your feeling on whether to do the research first or start with a product?
16:18I mean, totally different by category.
16:21The reason we felt so confident in the case of Biologica is that we would only follow the most rigorous
16:32scientific research that was available.
16:34So like this idea, and I'll forget who to attribute this to, certainly not myself, I think it might have
16:39been Andy Jassy actually, but minimum lovable product versus a minimum viable product.
16:44I'm very much in the minimum lovable product when you are in a physical product environment, because it is so
16:51hard to move things around in a supply chain.
16:55When you're building a supply chain for scale, when you make little changes, it can be very, very difficult, much
17:03more than you would give it credit.
17:04And so, you know, trying to get it to a place that was really good to start is essential in
17:11my mind.
17:12That doesn't mean that you don't then have a, you know, we're talking about product market fit, that you take
17:18your eye off the ball.
17:19Like at Allbirds, I'll tell you, we did 30 changes to the Wool Runner in the first two years of
17:24manufacturing and development with the Wool Runner.
17:28Just one product, the Wool Runner, we did 30 changes.
17:32They were always running changes.
17:33We never told the consumer they were happening, but, you know, we would have these issues.
17:37We would come in, we had enough scale that we would get, you know, we did a million dollars in
17:41the first month.
17:41So we had like, you know, close to 10,000 customers, let's call it, in the first month that tried
17:46the product.
17:46And then, you know, a lot of them had issues.
17:48Like we didn't, we didn't get it perfect.
17:50That's for sure.
17:51So we look at that and we say, okay, what do we need to change?
17:53What's cost effective to change?
17:55How do we do this in the best way?
17:56And, and then lo and behold, you start to like sharpen that product market fit and make your product much
18:01better.
18:02And, you know, you move from minimum lovable to something that you're extremely proud of.
18:06And that's the path that you have to get on pretty quick.
18:08Yeah.
18:09That, that, that, that's really helpful breakdown.
18:12I also want to unpack marketing and here's why.
18:16Because as I was listening to you talk about the research that you did in Biologica and this really core
18:24insight about the different segments of women that you're targeting and how they all, once you segment them properly by
18:33hormonal stage, they all have, you know, the same consistent need.
18:37I imagine that that also really helps you understand how to target that specific consumer and the language that you're
18:44going to use to appeal to them.
18:45Because now you know exactly who you're speaking to and what their top concerns are.
18:50And I'd love to hear you speak to how this research into product market fit also helps fuel the marketing.
18:57Yeah, I mean, you're, you're spot on there.
19:01I mean, there's two levels of marketing.
19:04There's kind of your, um, aspirational upper funnel brand marketing.
19:10Um, that's one kind of aspect that you need to need to address.
19:14And the second one is a, is a point of sale marketing and point of sale is like that lower
19:20funnel stuff.
19:21And typically the things that work the most and work the most efficiently at that point of sale is the
19:29things that are the most prominent need states.
19:32As you know, we've, we've talked about that before, like the need state of people who really, really want to
19:37wear a sneaker without socks, probably pretty small.
19:39Um, same is true for the people who buy a sneaker because it's sustainable.
19:43That's very small, five, 7% of the population people who buy a shoe because it looks good and is
19:48incredibly comfortable.
19:49Is that a good price 95% so, so like that's, you really have to sharpen that message and at
19:57the point of sale, deliver the benefits to the consumer through smart, concise communication and do that over and over
20:05and over again, that really, um, hit at the core insights that you've uncovered during that research phase.
20:12And that, that, that, that like constant iterative testing phase.
20:15So that, that's absolutely right.
20:17All right.
20:18A little earlier in the episode, we were playing tax trivia brought to you by TurboTax.
20:24I asked a question.
20:25I said, the answer would be coming later.
20:27So here it is.
20:28The question was true or false.
20:30You don't need to report side hustle 10 99 income in your taxes.
20:34The answer is of course, absolutely false.
20:38All income must be reported on your tax return.
20:41Even if you don't get a 10 99 NEC or 10 99 K learn more about filing your taxes with
20:49Intuit TurboTax.
20:50Visit TurboTax.Intuit.com.
20:56Joey, for a show called problem solvers, I cannot let pass that.
21:02You said at the very beginning that you have done this incredibly wrong in the past too.
21:06Uh, can you unpack a moment in which you got product market fit really wrong or approached
21:13it really wrong?
21:14I'd just love to hear what the opposite of these two great strategies looks like.
21:17A good example, which is, it tortures me, um, is when COVID happened in April of 2020,
21:25we were trying to push the boundaries of where we were selling products.
21:29What needs we were meeting for the consumer into a slightly more athletic, um, posture.
21:35Not, we don't want to go like, we're going to build cleats, but we wanted to do, be able to
21:39support
21:39people in like light cross training, wear it right to the office.
21:43Maybe it's like, you know, even golf would be the furthest we would go play a little golf,
21:47go at like people like to play golf and then wear the same shoes to whatever they're doing next.
21:50We launched a shoe called the Dasher and the Dasher crushed it.
21:56Absolutely crushed it.
21:58And it did something like, I think it was like $50 million in sales in the first year.
22:03And we were only four years old for one product.
22:05It was like, it was a good, good launch, really good launch.
22:08What we took from that was that the consumer was like, okay, we love your comfort and we
22:13would love you to support us in a little bit of light activity.
22:16Maybe it's hiking, maybe it's running, you know, we could pick our poison there and we need
22:19to do a lot of research on that, but it was clear to us based on that signal, like, yeah,
22:24they're down.
22:25Turns out when COVID happened, people who hadn't run in 15 years started running again and they
22:33would literally buy from whatever brand they liked, they would try whatever.
22:37And I think we were, we were getting this extreme false positive and our sales were really
22:42buoyed by a very short term change in consumer behavior, but we didn't have the muscle and the
22:48merchandising muscle to really, and the data, to understand the long-term data, to understand
22:53what was actually happening was this was kind of a blip and we got to stay closer to our
22:57knitting.
22:58And I think, you know, at that point we looked at that quantitative data.
23:02We looked at a lot of subjective data that we had internally and subjective decisions that
23:08we thought would be interesting for the brand versus what the consumer thought.
23:12And I think we went pretty hard at that for a bit.
23:14We've now fully unwound that and we are distinctly and unique and only a lifestyle footwear brand
23:23in that category of, you know, versatile comfort and aesthetic that meets those different needs.
23:28But that was one of those where, you know, we got, we got it wrong.
23:31What could you have done differently looking back on it?
23:34I mean, this was not a mistake that just all birds made back then.
23:38Consumer behavior was shifting really fast.
23:42People were throwing tons of money at what seemed like new discoveries of what people wanted.
23:48I mean, I think that the classic case here wasn't the Allbirds Dasher.
23:52It was Clubhouse, that audio first conversation app, which was the hot thing for like one second.
23:59$10 business for like one second, man, they should have sold that thing.
24:05And, but everyone thought, oh my God, this is what everyone wants to do now.
24:08But it wasn't, it was what everyone wanted to do during that very brief moment.
24:11So you weren't the only one fooled by that, but I'm curious, looking back on it, what you
24:14could have done to really understand the signal.
24:19I would say, you know, that I alluded to this, but the way I think about extending what you do
24:25as your core offering for a consumer is through a little framework of, of weirdness.
24:30If you go one degree of weird for a consumer and you test that out cautiously, but you test
24:38it out and you extend your brand a little bit, the consumer will often go for it.
24:42If you go two degrees of weird, it's likely too weird.
24:46And in the footwear industry, a good way to think about it very tactically is like you got
24:51a bottom and you got a top and of the shoe.
24:54And you could change the bottom and keep the top, or you can change the top and keep the
24:59bottom.
24:59But if you change the top and you change the bottom, you've gotten two degrees of weird
25:03and it is way too weird.
25:04And people will be like, why are you making that product?
25:07And, you know, I think we, we, um, we did a good job of cautiously expanding with the
25:13dasher.
25:14And then we did a bad job by going two degrees of weird right after that.
25:19I was going to now wrap it up and ask you to tell us just a little bit more about
25:23Biologica.
25:24But before I do, I just have to double click on one thing about the two degrees of weird,
25:28because it's such a great way of thinking.
25:31Can you tell me what successful one degree of weird thinking looks like?
25:37Like, is it, you take a thing that people like and you change one element of it, but
25:42make sure that there's enough anchoring that isn't changed so that you don't get the two
25:46degree of weird.
25:47Like, how would you apply that to something other than the shoe example where there's a
25:51top and a bottom is really nice and clear.
25:53And I'm just trying to make sure that I understand how to apply it to any other category.
25:57It's true.
25:57You know, I was talking with a woman who has a really successful, um, underwear company
26:01for a women's underwear company.
26:04And, you know, she was talking to me about whether she should extend into, um, jackets,
26:09outerwear, uh, all these different things because they have something like interesting
26:13in the fabric.
26:14And it was like, uh, I don't know that that's what people think about your brand.
26:18I think they think it's like awesome underwear and like, you could do like nylon stockings
26:25if that's a good market or maybe bras and maybe build out from there.
26:30And like, that's the kind of core that I think you're getting right.
26:33So understand that deeply and then extend it.
26:36And then, you know, hopefully in the, in the underwear example, it's like, she does have a
26:40really incredible fabric that she's done a lot of innovation on that has antimicrobial
26:44activity and it's comfortable, blah, blah, blah.
26:47So great.
26:49Where can that be applied?
26:50That is the core that people think.
26:51So like, sure.
26:52I think a bra would be a phenomenal example of a place that would apply your, the core
26:57innovation that really makes you special and unique in the market and better than your
27:00competitors and move that into, um, move that into a different sector.
27:05Super helpful.
27:05I'm glad I asked.
27:06All right, Joey, you said that biological hit the market pretty recently.
27:09So what should people know and how can they learn more?
27:12Go to biologica.com, uh, and buy some products and I promise you, you will feel better very
27:19quickly.
27:19Um, particularly for somebody who is looking to do something for their health, but is overwhelmed
27:26by the, uh, the, the various places to go get information about your health and the
27:33number of pills and other things that you'll end up concocting for yourself into a
27:39system that generally doesn't work.
27:40We've kind of tried to take the heavy lifting there and designed it with, with, with the
27:45help of like a very, very, uh, impressive medical advisory board, uh, and our internal
27:51staff, which has doctors on it to make a product that takes the work off of your shoulders
27:57and puts what you need to make you feel better for the woman that you are today.
28:01That's amazing.
28:02Well, Joey Zillinger, really, really appreciate your time and thoughts.
28:04Thanks so much.
28:05Thank you for having me.
Comments