• 9 months ago
Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi launched a blistering attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government over the Union Budget and the trade deal with the United States.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Some time back, Rijijuji asked me, how do I keep fit?
00:09You recall that?
00:12And I mentioned to him that I do jujitsu, I do martial arts.
00:19And lots of people now in India, youngsters do martial arts.
00:26MMA is becoming very popular.
00:29Judo is there, jujitsu is there, many different types of martial arts.
00:33And the foundation of martial arts is because it starts with grip.
00:43When we start, we try to take a grip to the opponent.
00:51If it doesn't get grip, it doesn't happen.
00:54I'm saying it's a good thing.
00:56But...
00:58I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:00I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:02I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:04Sir, I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:06Sir, please...
01:08I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:10I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:12I'm saying it's a good thing.
01:14Sir, give a little creative freedom.
01:16Please give a little creative freedom.
01:18Please...
01:19So what reduxuse that, if you don't!
01:21And when I do feel this quality of Bonjour.
01:23We take the courage and that's why it's always about how to do it.
01:25And then again the moment means that you have resistance will do youracement in the light.
01:35the first grip, the second grip, and then it goes into a choke.
01:38It goes into a choke and took it.
01:40And the focus of the choke is wrong.
01:44So let's talk about the budget.
01:51So the focus is talking about the budget.
01:53I'm coming.
01:54The government didn't say anything about it,
01:56he was also saying anything.
01:58No. Thank you.
02:00So the focus is on the grip,
02:03the fight starts with the grip,
02:06and we go into a choke with the grip.
02:09Sir,
02:12when a man comes in a choke,
02:21the opponent is seen in the grappling,
02:24the opponent is seen in his eye.
02:28It's seen, it's seen,
02:30the problem is that I have taken it.
02:34And what happens is that he has resisted.
02:37Two or three times he has resisted,
02:39and then he also knows that I have gone.
02:43And then the situation is over there,
02:46and then he surrenders and hits it.
02:50Sir, this is a central piece of martial arts.
02:53Compare it from the grip to the choke
02:56and put the choke Thats.
02:58And you probably got to ask maybe
02:59any Mohian as well,
03:02any Judo one as well.
03:03The work is starting to start by, sir.
03:05Sir?
03:06Sir grip?
03:07Sir,
03:14So that is the starting point, sir, I was looking at the economic survey and two points
03:38I found there, solid points, profound points that I liked.
03:46First point, that we are living in a world of intensifying geopolitical conflict.
03:55The dominance of the United States is being challenged by the Chinese, by the Russians,
04:20by other forces and the second thing, also profound thing, that we are living in a world of energy
04:30and finance weaponization.
04:33It means that energy or finance is made of power.
04:43Main thing they are saying here is that we are moving from a world of stability to a world
04:51of instability.
04:53Prime Minister stated and NSA stated, shockingly, some time back, that the era of war is over.
05:02In fact, we are moving into the era of war.
05:06And you can see war is there in Ukraine, war was there in Gaza, war is there in the Middle
05:14East, threat of war is there in Iran.
05:17We had Operation Sindhu, so we are moving into a world of instability.
05:24The dollar is being challenged.
05:28The central game, as my friends on the other side understand, is the dollar is being challenged,
05:36US supremacy is being challenged.
05:38We are moving from a world of one superpower to some new world that really we can't predict.
05:46Maybe two poor superpowers, maybe multiple powers.
05:49And it's an unstable world.
05:51And that is what you have said in your economic survey and I agree with it, 100%.
06:00At the center of this fight is the concept of AI.
06:07Everybody says that we are moving into the era of AI.
06:13And I'd like to warn the government that AI is going to have many, many consequences.
06:22One consequence of AI is going to be that something that we relied on, the Congress Party and the
06:28UPA built, the entire Indian IT industry, companies like Infosys, companies that are
06:37at the forefront of information technology are going to struggle.
06:41They're going to be challenged.
06:43The idea of becoming a software engineer, which is a very popular idea in India, going
06:49to be challenged.
06:50Lots of our software engineers are going to be replaced by AI.
06:55So, why I'm saying this is we're moving into a turbulent world, dangerous world.
07:00Now, when you move into a dangerous world, what is the first thing that you have to understand?
07:08The first thing you have to understand is what are your strengths as a person and as a nation.
07:15So, I'd like to say to the house here, what I think are the strengths of our great country.
07:26And I would say that the central strength is our people.
07:321.4 billion people, brilliant, energetic, dynamic, who can challenge anybody in the world.
07:46Biggest strength.
07:49Biggest strength.
07:50Biggest strength.
07:51Biggest strength.
07:52Biggest strength.
07:53Biggest strength.
07:54Biggest strength.
07:55Biggest strength.
07:56Biggest strength.
07:57Biggest strength.
07:58Biggest strength.
07:59Biggest strength.
08:00Biggest strength.
08:01Biggest strength.
08:02Biggest strength.
08:03Biggest strength.
08:04Biggest strength.
08:05Biggest strength.
08:06Biggest strength.
08:07Biggest strength.
08:08Biggest strength.
08:09Biggest strength.
08:10Biggest strength.
08:11Biggest strength.
08:12Biggest strength.
08:13Biggest strength.
08:14Biggest strength.
08:15is being generated in India and data is wealth everybody talks about AI but
08:23talking about AI is like talking about the internal combustion engine without
08:29talking about petrol the petrol for AI is data so let me repeat that the petrol
08:40for AI is data meaning if you have AI and you don't have data you have nothing if
08:49you have AI and you don't have data you have nothing now which is the which are
08:55the two biggest pools of data on the planet the Indian pool of data and the
09:00Chinese pool of data they also have 1.4 billion people we have bigger population
09:06than them we allow more freedom we allow our people to do more dynamic things so
09:12we have in fact more interesting data what's the second strength the second
09:21second strength and what do you need in difficult times you need food who
09:26produces our food our Kisan's produce our food our laborers produce our food this
09:36is what gives us strength this is what allows that data to be produced this is
09:40what allows that brilliance to be generated and we fought for food security food is
09:48abundant today so that's the second thing and the third thing what do you need to
09:56run a modern country you need energy you need fuel you need petrol so these are the
10:04three things that need to be protected in turbulent times our people and our data our
10:16food supply the ability to produce food and our energy system now what's interesting to me
10:27is that the budget recognizes these things the budget recognizes that we are going
10:38into a dangerous time intensifying geopolitical conflict the budget recognizes that energy and
10:48finance are being weaponized all across the world dollar is being weaponized dollar
10:53is weakening in value gold silver prices are going up everybody can see this but there
10:58is nothing in the budget there's absolutely nothing in the budget that looks into these two issues
11:05there is nothing in the budget about energy and finance weaponization there is nothing in
11:11the budget about the intensifying geopolitical conflicts and what we are going to do about it
11:16the budget just reads like any of their budgets right and budget is something of course
11:27that comes once a year but in parallel to the budget something new has happened
11:34the us deal we have made a deal with the united states now
11:45one thing i'd like to make very clear and this is something that is not well understood
11:55in a contest between the united states and china the single most valuable asset
12:09is indian data if the americans want to remain a superpower
12:17please understand what i'm saying it is very profound what i'm saying
12:22if the americans want to remain a superpower and if the americans want to protect their dollar
12:32the key to that is indian data why because the chinese have a data pool of 1.4 billion people
12:42and you can take european data you can take african data you can take american data add it all up
12:47it does not compete with chinese data so the real fight that is taking place i'm saying what is our
12:56strength i'm saying if india is going to go to the table then what do we put on the table what do we say
13:02listen this is what we put on the table and what we put on the table it's beautiful what we put on the
13:10table is our people their wisdom what they do their likes dislikes their imagination their fear this
13:23suddenly in the 21st century has got value in the 20th century it had no value
13:31i remember so many people saying that population is a weight population is a disaster
13:36no population is the biggest asset you can have it's a strength but it's only a strength
13:46if you recognize that data is important
13:57now what is surprising to me
14:00what happened in the deal
14:08if we were if the india alliance
14:13was negotiating
14:16with president trump
14:20i will tell you what we would say
14:22the first thing we would say is president trump
14:31the most important thing in this equation
14:34is indian data
14:37you want to protect your dollar
14:41you want to protect your dollar
14:43we are your friends
14:44we appreciate you we want to help you protect your dollar
14:49but please remember
14:52that if you want to protect your dollar
14:55the biggest asset that can protect your dollar is lying with the indian people
15:01first thing second thing we would say
15:05president trump
15:05if you want
15:10if you want access to this data
15:13then please understand that you are going to talk to us as an equal
15:20you are not going to talk to us
15:23as if we are your servants
15:28second thing we would say is mr trump please understand
15:30that our energy security is our energy security
15:40and no matter what happens
15:43we are going to protect our energy security
15:47and the third thing we would say is president trump
15:52we understand that you have a voter base
15:57agricultural voter base
15:58we understand that you need to protect your farmers
16:04but we will also protect our farmers
16:09but the main thing i'm saying is
16:11that an india alliance government would go there and say
16:15data is our biggest strength
16:18now let us talk
16:22meaning we would go there as equals
16:24we would not be made equal to pakistan
16:33and if president trump decided that pakistan
16:37army chief is going to have breakfast with him
16:40then we would have to we would have something to say about that
16:45now what has happened
16:47you've done a trade deal
16:49it's small it's written small in the back
16:56now let me tell you what is written about data
16:59our most valuable asset
17:05the thing that is going to transform india in the 21st century
17:09the thing that is going to make us
17:10us a superpower in the 21st century this is what the modi government has done with our data
17:19number one
17:21we give up control over our digital trade rules
17:25number two there is no need for data localization
17:36number three free data flow to the united states
17:41number four limit on digital tax
17:45number five no need to disclose any source code
17:49the finance minister is smiling she likes to smile
17:52she likes to smile a lot 20 year free tax holiday
17:59to anybody who wants it to the big tax company
18:02this is what you've done on data
18:06second no i'll come to that brother
18:08second
18:10what have you done
18:13on tariffs
18:15at the beginning
18:16three percent was the average
18:25three percent was the average
18:28it has now gone up to 18 percent
18:31but six percent increase
18:35six x increase
18:37sorry thank you
18:39us imports
18:41to go up
18:44from 46 billion dollars
18:46you're talking about our budget
18:48u.s imports to go up from 40
18:5246 billion
18:55dollars
18:55to 146 billion dollars
18:59i think this is absurd
19:03this is absolutely absurd
19:05and they have no commitment to us
19:11we have a commitment to them
19:12we are going to add a hundred billion dollars a year
19:15to your imports
19:15and no commitment to us
19:18we're just standing there like fools
19:26and our tariff has gone up from three percent to eighteen percent
19:30and theirs has come down from 16 to zero
19:37now
19:38i understand
19:40that the people across the aisle here
19:44want to protect our country
19:46i understand the people across the aisle here
19:49value our data
19:52i believe they do
19:54i also believe that the prime minister understands
19:56that india's biggest asset it's its people
20:02and as a result it's data
20:03i know that
20:04i do not believe for one second
20:07that the prime minister does not understand this
20:11next
20:13textiles
20:15i visited a gurgaon factory recently
20:18and i asked them what's going on they said
20:21we're finished
20:23as a result of the tariffs
20:25now what have you done
20:29you have
20:30the united states
20:33has reduced bangladesh's tariff to zero
20:37and our tariff is eighteen percent
20:41what do you expect our textile people to do
20:43they're dead
20:44they're finished
20:46the entire textile industry is gone
20:50because their competitor is bangladesh
20:52if bangladesh imports us cotton
20:57they have zero percent
21:00duty finished
21:01textile industry gone
21:06let's talk about energy
21:08what we need
21:09for the data what we need for our food
21:13what we have fought for
21:16energy security gone
21:17now the united states will decide who we buy oil from
21:25the united states will come to us and say you cannot buy oil from so and so and so and so and so
21:31russia iran whoever they want
21:34they will decide
21:35our prime minister will not decide
21:40please understand and they will monitor
21:43they will keep a watch
21:45meaning they will look
21:46and if india buys oil
21:50from anyone they do not want
21:53they will punish us
21:56and they will take our tariffs right back
21:59to fifty percent
22:00for the first time in indian history
22:07our farmers
22:09are facing a storm
22:13makkah
22:14soya bean
22:15lal jawar
22:16kapas
22:20you have opened the door
22:21you have opened the door
22:26to mechanized
22:28american farms thousands and thousands of acres each farm
22:32you have opened the door to crush
22:35our poor farmers
22:36it is it is disgraceful
22:40it is disgraceful
22:43no prime minister has ever done this before
22:45and let me tell you no prime minister after you is ever going to do it
22:51so we are facing
22:56a storm
22:58you accept
23:00that we are facing a storm
23:03you yourself say
23:06the error of one superpower is over
23:08intensifying geopolitical conflicts
23:10you yourself say energy and finance weaponization
23:13and you have allowed the americans to weaponize our finance and our energy against us
23:17what does it mean when america says you cannot buy oil from somebody it means our energy is weaponized
23:29what does it mean when they say your terrace will go down
23:34our terrace will go down and yours will come up
23:36it means finance trade is weaponized
23:40so you are telling us
23:41you are telling us that the world is a place where geopolitical conflict is intensifying
23:47you are telling us energy and finance will be weaponized
23:49and then you are having it done to you
23:52you are having it done to our farmers
23:54you are having it done to our youngsters
23:57you are handing our data over
23:58how can you even make these statements
24:07how can you even come to this house
24:10and talk this type of nonsense
24:13are you not ashamed of yourself
24:15are you not ashamed of giving
24:16no no no we are patiently listening to the honorable leader of the opposition
24:28but but the words
24:29i'm not yielding sir
24:30no no but you are saying shameful
24:33you are you are saying nonsense
24:34nonsense
24:39is that replies in the evening
24:41the leader of the opposition should listen to the reply of the honorable finance minister
24:47my request is please use the word whatever you you choose to use
24:52but don't make it abusive
24:55it doesn't
24:55that's not abusive my friend
24:56nonsense
25:01is not an appropriate
25:02i did not use nonsense
25:03you have you
25:04you have you
25:05you have you
25:06okay sir i won't use nonsense
25:08sir ashamed is not an abuse
25:09there's nothing there's
25:12in saying are you not ashamed
25:14there is no abuse
25:15no ashamed you can use
25:16i am i am just stating
25:18whatever you have
25:18okay sir let me speak
25:19okay sir let me speak
25:20i am saying
25:21speaker sir
25:23i am saying
25:24i am saying
25:25that you have sold india
25:28are you not ashamed of selling india
25:33do you have no shame of selling india
25:35you have sold our mother
25:37Bharat mata
25:38do you have no shame
25:39but sir
25:44the interesting thing is
25:46i know
25:48the interesting thing is that i know
25:51that the prime minister would not sell india under normal circumstances
25:56he will not do it
25:57you know why he sold india
26:00because they are choking him
26:02they have got a grip on his neck
26:08they have got a grip on his neck
26:10speaker sir
26:11speak sir
26:12i have told you
26:13when you have chokes
26:14you are making a mistake
26:15you are making a mistake
26:16you are making a mistake
26:17you are making a mistake
26:18sir
26:18you are making a mistake
26:18I'm sorry.
26:19I'm sorry.
26:20I'm sorry.
26:21I'm sorry.
26:22I'm sorry.
26:23I'm sorry.
26:24I'm sorry.
26:25I'm sorry.
26:26I'm sorry.
26:27I'm sorry.
26:28Speaker, sir.
26:29Sir, two things, sir.
26:32One, sir Epstein.
26:34Epstein case.
26:35Sir, three million files are still locked up.
26:41I want to understand.
26:42I will not allow you.
26:47I will not allow you.
26:48I will not allow you.
26:49I will not allow you.
26:50I will not allow you.
26:51I'm not saying Epstein.
26:52Speaker, sir, at the center of our budget, if you look carefully, at the center of our
27:13defense budget is a choke applied by Mr. Adhani.
27:14So I'd like to talk about Mr. Adhani and the case in the United States against Mr. Andhra
27:30Andhra.
27:31Because that is a central part of the budget.
27:33Why, sir?
27:34Look.
27:35Hello, sir.
27:36A, sir.
27:37Iです-
27:38I see money, customer.
27:40You can see a position.
27:42Speaker, sir.
27:43If you are keeping any statements that, sir, may I know you 325 and 354, but Quintessly
27:44マh.
27:45SUBSCRIBE to me.
27:46you know mehum 355 and 354
27:50you can't name them
27:53but the way you have a higher authority
27:56or prime minister or the government
27:59you know mehum
28:01you know mehum
28:03you have a budget
28:06whatever you want
28:08you have to say something
28:10you have to say something about your budget
28:12I'm doing sir
28:14you have to say something about your budget
28:18you have to say something about your budget
28:22but when you take someone's name
28:24and hire authority
28:26you will go to the minimum
28:28and you will not put it in this way
28:30you can't put it in this way
28:32sir, Mr. Adani
28:34sir, Mr. Adani
28:36is not
28:38an ordinary businessman
28:40Mr. Adani's company
28:42Mr. Adani's company
28:44is not an ordinary company
28:46please understand
28:48that the case in the United States
28:52is targeted to the prime minister of India
28:54not at Mr. Adani
28:56it is targeted, sir
28:58at the financial network of the BJP
29:06at the financial architecture of the BJP
29:08you are leveling charges against higher authority
29:12and only you can speak
29:14for how in 对
29:16your care
29:18poolt of order
29:20what is your point of order
29:22what is your point of order
29:24what is your point
29:26But when you are leveling serious charges without any reason, without any backing of substance,
29:51without any proof, you are just making a wild dedication.
29:56I'll give you a reason, give me.
29:57That will diminish your own position.
29:58I'll give you a reason.
29:59I'll give you a reason.
30:00You're a reason of the opposition.
30:01Okay.
30:02Please make substantive point.
30:03Yes, I will.
30:04We are here to listen to your suggestion.
30:05I will, I will.
30:06If you give good suggestion, we will listen.
30:07Yeah, I will.
30:08We are here to listen, but don't make wild allegations.
30:11I will.
30:12Speaker, sir, there is a businessman called Mr. Anil Ambani.
30:19I want to ask the question, why is he not in jail?
30:22The reason he's not in jail is because his name is in the Epstein files.
30:25That's why he's not in jail.
30:26I'd also like to ask Mr. Anil Ambani who introduced him to Epstein.
30:32Mr. Chair.
30:33Mr. Rahul.
30:34Mr. Rahul.
30:35No, no, no.
30:36I know who introduced him.
30:37He's a minister, sir.
30:38Sir, I know who introduced him, and Mr. Adipuri knows who introduced him.
30:50We both agree.
30:53Adipuri is a member of parliament here.
31:01He's a minister, sir.
31:02A member, a member while speaking, shall not refer to any matter of fact on which a judicial decision may make a professional and for huge offensive expressions about the conduct of the parliament in any state, reflect on the determination of the house exempt notion, and reflect upon the conduct of, reflect, reflect upon the conduct of persons in high authority,
31:31unless the discussion is based on the circumstances.
31:34So please, aap jiska naam hai, uska naam meli hai.
31:36I am on rule 352, cross Roman 5.
31:46While he's speaking, reflect upon the conduct of persons in high office authority, unless discussion is based on a substantive motive drawn in terms of proper term.
31:58And, manifesto ga naam lya, mansiya ka naam lya, has he made any substantive motion, nai hai hai, to reject kar yhe.
32:09It is complete, nai ha god, no.
32:13Now listen to me, listen to me. They have said 352. But I, no, Saugat Raiji, Saugat Raiji, Saugat Raiji, no. I, Rahul Ji, I'm going to be on your 353.
32:28You have labeled the charge against him. If you go through the rule 353, no allegations of a defamatory nature shall be made by a member against any person unless the member has given educate, advance.
32:50Now you have, you have labeled the charges against him. So please, being a leader of a position, I think so, notice. Then educate, advance notice. Then you can mention the name of any minister. And if you have, aap baitiye, aap baitiye. Nah, nah, nah, nah, say deke. Nah, nah.
33:12Whatever, whatever Rahul has made a legation, that will not go on the record. Now you can speak.
33:22One minute, sir. No, no. You have made a legation. You have made a legation. That will not go on the record.
33:27Sir, I agree, sir. Agree, sir. But, but, rule 352 is only applicable for leader of opposition?
33:35No, I'm reading 353.
33:36Sir, sir, one minute, sir. One minute, sir.
33:38Rule 352, mentioning about Rahul Raiji Shankar Prasadji, where is the issue?
33:44In that house, two days before, a member has given a very, very derogative remarks against the former prime minister.
33:52To former prime minister.
33:53Where was the truth 352?
33:55Applicable to everybody. Not only for him. Not only for him.
33:59Where was the?
33:59That will be applicable.
34:00Please, can you take it.
34:01You're not going to be applicable.
34:02What is applicable, what to him?
34:04Rahul Gandhi.
34:06Because, sir, because, sir, the, the, because, sir, Anil Ambani is not a member of the house.
34:12He's not. So, I can speak about Anil Ambani?
34:15He's a defense. He's, he's involved in defense, sir.
34:19He's involved in defense. He's involved in defense budget.
34:22Leave leave leave industry.
34:24Explain it.
34:25Whatever you are leveling charges against him, I think so, you will not take.
34:28Please.
34:29So, there is a certain businessman.
34:30Yes.
34:31Whose name has appeared in Epstein files.
34:34And that businessman is not in jail.
34:37That businessman has criminal cases against him.
34:40The subject.
34:41What file you are taking?
34:43No, no, Epstein files.
34:45No, no, no.
34:46How I can allow you?
34:48No.
34:48You are, you are, you are, you are, you are mentioning it is, how, if there, if there are any file, if any subject is not related with the budget, you can't dispute.
35:00Please, please, please, you can't dispute.
35:03You can't dispute.
35:04Sir, I will, I will, I will tell you what.
35:11Well, I will, sir, I will be.
35:14Because, sir, you are, you are, you are, you are, ex-Congress Party member.
35:29So, I will do you a special favor today, sir.
35:33I will back down.
35:34This is a charge here.
35:34No, no.
35:35This is not going to be a function.
35:37I, I, I, I...
35:39If you don't have, if you don't have any propriety for the chair, if you don't have, sometime your present member of parliament used to occupy this chair, Selja.
35:53Selja is also...
35:54Because, sir, you know we have fondness for you.
35:58You're an ex-member of our party.
35:59So I will not go very aggressive today.
36:02Why you are mentioning too much?
36:04You're a member of our party, sir.
36:05Ex-member.
36:06Ex-member, no?
36:07And we're fond of you, sir.
36:09I'm here as a presiding of it.
36:12But we like you, sir.
36:14And we know your heart is not there, sir.
36:17We know your heart is here, sir.
36:18If you believe my thing, then you don't sit there.
36:22If you are sitting there, then only because of you have not taken my advice.
36:26Here I'm advising you.
36:28Here if I'm advising you, you should move on the correct track.
36:32I think so.
36:33Still you have time.
36:35Still you have time to move on the correct track.
36:37As today, as you are...
36:39Sir, in the spirit, in the spirit of our conversation,
36:50I will not say the name Epstein, and I will not say the name Anilambani,
37:00and I will not say the name...
37:02No, I will not say, sir.
37:04You are a leader of a position.
37:10Okay.
37:10So let me speak, sir.
37:12Please.
37:12I think, sir...
37:13I will not do it, sir.
37:14The whole nation is watching you.
37:16I know.
37:17I know that.
37:18That's why I'm saying it, sir.
37:18On one side, you are saying, I will not mention the name.
37:21Again, you are mentioning the name.
37:23I'm saying I will not mention it.
37:23I think you are not ready to avoid the law.
37:26Okay, anyway.
37:27So I will not go into the names.
37:28But I would like to say...
37:30I think, sir, you have to speak only on budget.
37:33I'm, I'm...
37:33But here, sir, you have to speak on budget, right?
37:39There is a general discussion on the union budget for...
37:43Okay, sir, let me speak.
37:4427?
37:45Okay.
37:45So I think...
37:46Nice.
37:56Nice, nice.
37:57So, speaker, sir.
38:02So I will avoid...
38:04I will avoid that.
38:04So, the point is that I do not believe that any Indian Prime Minister, including Mr. Modi,
38:26would sign such a deal unless there was a chokehold on him.
38:36Sir, I do not...
38:39Sir, this budget that you have...
38:40You and your member had not been released.
38:43I believe that there.
38:46Then, you had made a statement on the floor of the house.
38:49Sir, please conclude, sir.
38:53Okay, okay.
38:57So, we have buckled on tariffs.
39:13We have handed out our data, given up control over digital trade rules, no data localization,
39:24free data flow to USA, limit on digital tax, no source code disclosure, and 20-year tax holiday.
39:31The most valuable asset that India has and will ever have has been handed over.
39:39Our farmers have been left to the mercy of metanized massive American farms.
39:50Our textiles have been wiped out.
39:59Bangladesh now is going to wipe out our textile industry.
40:06Our energy security has been handed over.
40:09We can't buy oil from who we want to buy oil from.
40:12Now, I don't believe any Indian Prime Minister would do this.
40:19Logic in here, sir.
40:24Logic in here, sir.
40:25Yeh, yeh jo hua hai, sir.
40:28Yeh, poora surrender hai.
40:34Sir, aapne zahadha bolne diya mujhe aaj.
40:37Sir, aapne mujhe thoda zahadha jaane diya aaj.
40:39Baat aagay.
40:40Toh, this is a wholesale surrender.
40:43And it is a tragedy.
40:45Because it is a surrender not just of the Prime Minister.
40:49He has surrendered the future of 1.5 billion Indians.
40:55And he has surrendered the future.
40:58Because he wants to protect the BJP's financial architecture.
41:03On which there is a case in the United States.
41:05He has surrendered.
41:13I'm not saying anything.
41:14This is a rule.
41:15Do you repeat it?
41:17We repeat it again?
41:18Repeat it.
41:19Come on the start.
41:19What is this?
41:20We say it again?
41:21Sir.
41:21Come on.
41:22Come on.
41:22Come on.
41:22This rule is can be said.
41:23Do you not say it again?
41:24It does not be said.
41:25Do you understand any rule of this rule?
41:26This rule is going on behind it.
41:27Without a means of it?
41:29Do you have to stop it?
41:30foreign
41:44foreign
42:00you are the leader of opposition when you speak on certain thing there is a serious connotation
42:30i would i would urge honorable leader of opposition because he is the leader of opposition
42:36all the points he has made have serious replication he must authenticate on all the allegations he has
42:44had i will sir i will authenticate right now i've got it kindly kindly kindly already you have taken
42:5445 minutes kindly sir let me authenticate sir but kindly sir he has said to authenticate i will
42:59authenticate right now that you have to just give in advance and that you have no no sir i will
43:04authenticate right now i'm authenticating i will say it and then i will give it no no i will say it
43:15now and i will give it i have it here sir you ask authentication now you are not giving it to me
43:23i have to please proceed
43:29Sir, what do you mean by the authentication?
43:41What do you mean by the authentication?
43:45He should produce the proper documents, proper records, and sign it.
43:51Otherwise, the authentication...
43:55Sir, you conclude.
44:05Sir, Minister has asked me to authenticate my allegations.
44:21I have them written here. I am going to authenticate.
44:24That is a procedure.
44:26I will also give the procedure.
44:28Then you have to follow that procedure.
44:30Yes, but I will...
44:32Here you are only...
44:34Only you just conclude your budget speech because if you want to submit something,
44:41so please in future you can just according to your procedure, then you have to submit.
44:47Okay.
44:48Speaker, sir, the evidence, sir, is in Department of Justice files that have been released in the United States.
44:59Hardeep Puri's name is in it.
45:01Anil Ambani's name is in it.
45:03No!
45:05Sir, the evidence is that Government of India has refused a summons to Hadani for last 14...
45:09Mr Rahul, Mr Rahul, Mr Rahul, you have made a promise to the chair, I will not mention the name of the minister, but you are repeatedly just mentioning the name.
45:23How you can?
45:24How you can?
45:25You have made a promise.
45:26No, no.
45:27You have made a promise.
45:28Mr. K.C. Benugubal, I will not...
45:30I am not allowing you.
45:31K.C. Benugubal, I am only talking to Rahul.
45:35I am not allowing to you.
45:37If I have already, if you have made a promise to the chair that I am not going to mention the name of any minister, not the member, and repeatedly, if you are...
45:49Repeatedly, it means you are defying the... even ruling of the chair also.
45:54Okay.
45:55Speaker, sir.
45:56Speaker, sir.
45:57Speaker, sir.
45:59Speaker, sir.
46:00Speaker, sir.
46:01Speaker, sir.
46:03Speaker, sir.
46:04Speaker, sir.
46:05Speaker, sir.
46:06Speaker, sir.
46:07I am not saying that this house is a budget speech in general.
46:22It was a great speech in this house.
46:25What is a great speech in this house?
46:29What should you do in the budget?
46:31What should you do in the demand for grants?
46:34What should you do in the budget?
46:41What should you do in the government?
46:43What should you do in the government?
46:46What should you do in the budget?
46:48What should you do in the budget?
46:50It's a different way to the government.
46:53You will always say it.
46:56But it's not a mistake.
47:00When you have a chair with a chair, you will see that the chair is a chair.
47:06All members are so satisfied.
47:09If all members are speaking to the parliament of any party,
47:13then all speakers call the members at night to 12-12,
47:17and you have to give up the time.
47:21If you have a court of no confidence,
47:23then what do you do in the budget?
47:25What do you do in the budget?
47:26It's a little bit.
47:28You will always say it.
47:30You will always say it.
47:31You will always say it.
47:33You will always say it.
47:34You will always say it.
47:36You will always say it.
47:37You will always say it.
47:38Sir.
47:39Let me speak.
47:41Let me speak.
47:42Speaker, sir, I am concluding.
47:43Speaker, sir, I am concluding now.
47:44Let me speak.
47:51Speaker, sir, I'm concluding.
47:53Speaker, sir, I'm concluding now.
47:58I only started to say that because the minister said that I should authenticate.
48:05Now, I have the papers to authenticate.
48:07I have it here.
48:09One second, please.
48:10I have the paper.
48:11Now, I said to you, one second.
48:13I have the documents here.
48:15I said to you that I will authenticate and I will also hand, I will authenticate right
48:22now and I will put it there on the table.
48:24But you're not allowing me to do it.
48:26Anyway, I understand that.
48:29I understand it.
48:30I understand you don't want me to authenticate here.
48:33You want me to authenticate there.
48:34That's not a problem.
48:35What I want to conclude with, sir, is we are heading into turbulent times.
48:42And the nation has been sold.
48:45The nation has been sold out.
48:47Its data has been sold.
48:50Its farmers have been sold.
48:51Already you have said.
48:52I think so.
48:53Can I conclude?
48:57Sir, its farmers have been sold.
49:02In a turbulent world, all its software engineers have been sold out.
49:09Its small and medium businesses have been sold out.
49:13And most importantly, our forces and our energy security has been sold out.
49:18Thank you, speaker.
49:20Sir, sir, I'm not using this camera.
49:22Sir, sir, our request is that the process is authentic.
49:27Because we have already said that we need to do authentication.
49:30There is a process to submit the authentication.
49:35That is what we will do.
49:36And the leader of the opposition has also said that we will do.
49:39We have to do it in a due process.
49:40We have to do it in a due process.
49:41We have to do it in a due process.
49:42But what I have to say, what I have to say, is that I have to say one line.
49:45Absolutely.
49:46Rahul Ji said that our country, our country has been sold out.
49:53You have sold out.
49:54I want to say that I have not been sold out until today.
49:57You have sold out.
49:58We have sold out.
49:59We have sold out.
50:00We have sold out.
50:01I have sold out.
50:02You have sold out.
50:03I have sold out.
50:04We have sold out.
50:05I have called him with me.
50:07This country is the most perfect prime minister, Dharachana Bhotiji.
50:10No one can't remove.
50:11No one can remove.
50:12What would happen to you?
50:13Do you have told me?
50:14You've also told me that that you have to do so much.
50:16I called you that you have to move only in 2014.
50:19What up, for you to do this country, you have the most likely to raise your country,
50:23what will you be in this country with your country?
50:27And today, the country is moving forward, and you are not happy about it.
50:32The Congress will get upset from coming forward.
50:36With that, we have the courage to do this.

Recommended