00:00Pino na at sinita ng ilang miembro ng House Committee on Justice
00:03ang basehan sa mga aligasyon sa unang impeachment complaint
00:08laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos.
00:10Tinalakay rin ang pagiging authentic ng mga dokumentong kalakip ng reklamo.
00:16At nakatutok si Tina Panginiban Perez.
00:21Paano nga ba dapat sukatin kung ang impeachment complaint ay sufficient in substance?
00:26I-sinalang sa tanong na ito kanina ang impeachment complaint na inihain ni Atty. Andre De Jesus
00:32laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos matapos itong ideklarang sufficient in form kahapon.
00:39Sa ilalim ng Section 5 ng Rules on Impeachment,
00:42sufficient in substance ang isang impeachment complaint kung may recital of facts
00:47o malinaw na salaysay na mga pangyayari at aligasyon na hindi paratang lang,
00:52kundi pasok at tugma sa mga ground for impeachment.
00:56Sufficiency in substance is not about whether allegations are loudly made,
01:05repeatedly asserted, passionately believed, or politically resonant.
01:13It is about whether the complaints allege ultimate facts,
01:18not mere conclusions,
01:21whether they show a personal, culpable act or omission by the impeachable official,
01:29and whether those acts, as pleaded,
01:33amount to culpable violation of the Constitution,
01:38treason, bribery, graft and corruption,
01:42other high crimes,
01:44or betrayal of public trust as the Constitution strictly enumerates.
01:50Pinaigting din ng Komite ang sukatan,
01:54matapos manalo sa botohan na dapat authentic ang mga dokumentong kalakip ng complaint,
02:00tatlo ang grounds for impeachment ng De Jesus complaint,
02:03betrayal of public trust,
02:05culpable violation of the Constitution,
02:08at graft and corruption.
02:09Isa sa mga puna,
02:11puro news article daw ang basehan sa allegasyong kinidnap
02:15at binigay sa ibang bansa,
02:17si dating Pangulong Duterte.
02:18The first offense,
02:21most of the annexes are news articles.
02:26It might be insufficient for evidence to be based on mere news articles only.
02:36Honorable Nisai,
02:38the question is very specific.
02:40Whether or not you are aware of a case of kidnapping filed against the impeachable official?
02:47I'm aware, Madam Chair.
02:50You are?
02:52Aware.
02:53So, you are aware that there is a case of kidnapping filed against the impeachable official?
02:59No, no, no.
03:00That there is no, ma'am.
03:01Sinita rin ang basehan ng allegasyon na drug addict daw ang Pangulo,
03:06kaya epektado ang kapasidad na mamuno.
03:09This ground presupposes that because PBBM is an addict,
03:14or an alleged addict,
03:15he is unfit to be president.
03:19However,
03:20unfitness per se
03:21is not a ground for impeachment.
03:25Ganon din ang allegasyong hindi vinito ng Pangulo
03:28ang unprogrammed appropriation
03:30sa budget noong 2023 hanggang 2026.
03:34At kumikbak din daw ito
03:36sa mga budget insertion
03:37at ghost flood control project
03:40na ang basehan ay mga video
03:42na pino sa Facebook
03:43ni dating congressman Zaldico.
03:45Video exposes abroad
03:47wherein we in the later part
03:50will have to hear
03:51this particular person
03:54has to be present
03:56otherwise it's a piece of paper
03:58and a piece of video
04:00that is not allowed to be introduced
04:02in any proceeding.
04:03Inusisa rin ang basehan ng
04:06allegasyong binoo ng Pangulo
04:07ang Independent Commission on Infrastructure
04:10para protektahan ang mga kaalyado niya.
04:12The body of the complaint
04:14does not contain
04:16any express provision
04:17in the ICI's charter
04:20that limits investigations
04:22only to political opponents
04:24nor does it contain
04:26any instances
04:29of limiting
04:30of any instances
04:33or policy or rule
04:35exempting allies.
04:37In fact,
04:37I remember that even the president's son
04:39was summoned
04:41to the ICI.
04:43Ipinagpabukas ng
04:44House Committee on Justice
04:45ang botohan
04:46sa sufficiency in substance
04:48ng DeJesus impeachment complaint
04:50para raw mabigyan
04:51ang pagkakataon
04:52ng mga kongresistang
04:53pag-aralan ng issue.
04:54Ipinagpabukas din
04:55ang pagdalakay
04:56sa sufficiency in substance
04:58ng pangalawang reklamo
04:59ang Masa et al impeachment complaint
05:02at bukas din inaasahang
05:03pagbobotohan nito.
05:06Para sa GMA Integrated News,
05:08Tina Panganiban Perez
05:10Nakatuto, 24 Horas.
Comments