- 6 days ago
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:00in 2010 a woman vanished seemingly into thin air there was no sightings there was no one coming
00:16back police scarred packed city streets and wild empty forests detectives suspected this
00:25was a murder but they faced an almost impossible task to convict the killer there's no smoking gun
00:32that's going to convince the jury to convict when you've nobody their strongest evidence came from
00:38the electronic shadow we all cast every day every contact leaves a trace you're using your mobile
00:44phone or you're you're stepping into an area where the cctv you're leaving that trace this
00:50is critical evidence which can foil even the smartest of criminals
00:57a criminal who has never admitted to any wrongdoing
01:01and whose silence means never-ending agony for one family it's difficult to think that she's lying
01:08somewhere nobody knows where she is he's thrown her away as if she didn't matter at all
01:20when there's a murder with no suspect no leads perhaps not even a body that's when investigators
01:31face their toughest test the evidence must be gathered the evidence must be analyzed
01:40but the evidence is worthless if you can't pin it to a suspect
01:56the only way to crack the hardest cases of all
02:00the only way to prove what actually happened the difference between success and failure
02:06and failure critical evidence
02:27on may the 4th 2010 38 year old bookkeeper suzanne pillie was on her way to work in central edinburgh
02:36and she sent a text to her parents
02:43well she text at half past eight on the tuesday morning she wanted to borrow her dad's phone
02:50to go to the cinema it was two tickets for one and we said yes
02:58this was the last anyone would hear from suzanne
03:00and then at one o'clock in the day we got a phone call from her work
03:08saying that she had never appeared so that's when they first found out that she was missing
03:16and my husband went up to the house and there was no sign of anything there and we waited and we
03:23found and we'd text everybody that we knew of and the time was getting on it got to about six o'clock
03:30and i said to my husband i'm going to phone the place
03:36although suzanne had only been missing a few hours
03:39her mother sylvia and sister gail already knew that something was seriously wrong
03:44it would be highly unusual that she would just take herself away um she would either phone mom she
03:51would phone me i did give very angry voicemails on her phone to say that you know everybody was really
03:58anxious and that mom and dad were again it more and more upset
04:06detective sergeant stuart houston shared the family's worries
04:09the fact that um if um she had been going to to make some sort of unexpected decision to leave
04:19um that wouldn't that would have been completely out of character the fact that she had a cat that
04:24she cared for that she had made arrangements for her family to feed for that day or any time she was
04:30out she hadn't put that in place her work and colleagues were spoken to from from an early
04:35stage trying to piece together that picture of what uh suzanne was like what was the the likelihood of
04:44her um going off by her own volition which again added to the picture that that there was something
04:51untoward here there was something not quite right edinburgh is a city of nearly half a million people
04:58police hope someone near suzanne's work on thistle street would remember seeing anything unusual that
05:08morning detective chief inspector gary flanagan led the inquiry it's the city center of edinburgh it's
05:17you know peak time in the morning there are literally thousands of people milling around heading to work
05:23it was vital that we spoke to them to to say has anyone seen suzanne this morning we needed to
05:29understand who would be in and around the area of her work that morning there was no sightings there
05:36was no one coming back to say that they knew where suzanne was or that there was some explanation why
05:41suzanne herself had you know had decided to to to leave edinburgh or not to turn up to work that day
05:48police also discovered that suzanne's phone and financial records showed no activity after the
05:56morning of may the 4th there was never any more activity on her mobile phone after the text to
06:03mom and dad that morning and so again that's a big red flag for us something has happened something
06:10has taken place i'm going to tell suzanne's family that we now believe that she have um she's come to harm
06:18but suzanne's mother sylvia already feared the worst
06:28i knew where she was every day and we always spoke or text every day after the next again day and the
06:35next again day i knew she was never going to come back
06:42the police did not have any evidence to tell them what had happened to suzanne
06:47or why she had vanished they couldn't be certain if she was still in edinburgh
06:53or if she were alive or dead but the investigation did have one thing in its favor
07:01the electronic devices which surround us and track our every movement every minute of every day
07:07our lives our behavior is predictable from the electronics that we you know we have in our pocket
07:15or that we come into contact as we walk along the street you know the cctv that picks us up we're
07:22brushing with wi-fi with all number of things
07:24for the police to figure out what had happened to suzanne they would need to build a complex electronic
07:33picture of her life where had she gone and who had she met we speak about in forensic that every
07:44contact leaves a trace but it's exactly the same in all sparks of evidence and the fact that every time that
07:49you you you're using your mobile phone or you're you're stepping into an area where the cctv you're
07:55leaving that trace
07:58edinburgh bookkeeper suzanne pillie had failed to turn up to work on the morning of may the 4th
08:082010. her phone had not been used her bank account was untouched suzanne had vanished seemingly into
08:18thin air and the police were concerned she'd come to harm gary flanagan was the officer in charge
08:27he began by talking to suzanne's family friends and workmates
08:33one of the principal actions that we're looking to do is to eliminate people from our investigation
08:39so in effect clearing our feet as we go anyone who may have had contact with that person around the
08:45time of their disappearance or their death we'd be interested to eliminate them one of the people
08:51they were keen to speak to was david gilroy a married father of two and a manager in suzanne's office
09:00police visited the office in thistle street the day after suzanne disappeared
09:06but gilroy had been on business at loch gilphead on the other side of scotland
09:11the police were keen to talk to him because they found out he and suzanne had been having an affair
09:17came apparent there had been a relationship and we required to speak to him
09:21in relation to that and at that stage em it was very much in the fact that he may have someone who
09:27is a as a witness who may have some information regarding suzanne's whereabouts or where she may have
09:32gone to gilroy arrived at castor from police station in edinburgh late that evening
09:41suzanne had been missing for just over 36 hours david gilroy was helpful in a sense that he was
09:49giving us an insight into suzanne and how she lived her life the type of things that she liked to do
09:56and the friends that she had and you know how she you know our social life
10:00he was suggesting that perhaps suzanne was in touch with you know boyfriends and such she'd had
10:12relationships her behavior had been slightly erratic but you know in the first statements they've been
10:18very helpful and keen to do whatever he could to help us as gilroy spoke detectives noticed his
10:26hands they were covered in small scratches he gave an explanation which and you know on the face of
10:34it was reasonable he said that the injuries that he'd had were fairly superficial injuries but they'd
10:40been the result of gardening work that he you know been doing recently that is and the officers
10:46who had dealt with him they accepted that at face value so an affair and strange scratches on his hands
10:56potentially grounds for suspicion not necessarily there's nothing particularly incriminating here
11:05the police had to corroborate what gilroy was saying with the people who knew suzanne best
11:09and that's when things became interesting according to suzanne's mother sylvia the relationship with
11:22gilroy had not always been a happy one he told too many lies and he was always getting caught out
11:30and then they had a violent argument in the october and that was the first indication that he was
11:38quite a violent argumentative person he did pack his bags a few times and she did ask him to leave
11:46and he went back to his wife and um i had a conversation with her saying you know i mean
11:52that's it you need to you need to end it you need to move on you need to look for you know somebody
11:58that will take you into your future with the marriage kids that's that's where she was heading
12:05the police learned that suzanne had ended the affair and begun a new relationship with another man
12:12the police also discovered gilroy had bombarded suzanne with 400 messages in the weeks leading up to
12:19may the 4th as well as text messages there were voicemails
12:24the messages were plaintiff and pleading
12:54they suggested a man unable to accept the end of the affair
12:59as the investigation developed we could see text messaging to david gilroy which was highly suggestive
13:05of a relationship that as far as suzanne was concerned was finished but david gilroy still felt
13:11the relationship could be could be salvaged what was clear from the outset well there was a contradiction
13:17there the picture that he was painting was you know very very different from the impression
13:23that we were given from the text messages
13:28this was a contradiction which raised suspicions about gilroy
13:32and the exact nature of his relationship with suzanne
13:41but police still needed critical evidence to solve the mystery of what had happened
13:45all they knew was that she'd been heading to her office in thistle street on the morning of may the
13:51fourth well suzanne's workplace became crucial to us because if we could demonstrate that suzanne had
13:58made it to work and there was no other possible explanation she hadn't gone back in herself
14:05she hadn't gone into the office and gone out the back door and disappeared some other way
14:09the police brought in jacqueline pastel an expert in forensic image analysis
14:18jacqueline knew identifying exactly where suzanne had gone missing was critical to the investigation
14:26if it can be proven that she arrived at work and didn't arrive her desk then that's where she then went
14:34missing if the footage could not prove that she arrived at work then she could have vanished anywhere in edinburgh
14:44jacqueline's job was to study individual cctv images in minute detail to build a convincing
14:51timeline of suzanne's journey we have to go through a logical process look at the differences
14:58look at the similarities and form a informed judgment as to how strong the evidence actually
15:04is to whether you can identify that person or not building this timeline involved a methodical study
15:10of skin tone the color of her clothes and physical characteristics now you can see clearly the type
15:18of clothing she's wearing and her hair and her physique so you can get an idea of what she looks like
15:27what bags she's carrying and etc so you can pick her up on cctv and the more you've you've watched of
15:33her the more the sightings you've seen the easier to pick up where she is or in the next piece of
15:38imagery jacqueline rebuilt suzanne's journey image by image this appeared to show her arriving in thistle
15:48street but there was no footage showing suzanne actually entering her office there's footage of
15:56suzanne pilly as she passes a set of revolving double doors
16:03this is just around the corner from thistle street
16:06the last sighting on thistle street was where it became really poor quality however it was still
16:13possible to identify the tones of uh the jacket the top and the trousers and the tone that could
16:22possibly have been the handbag also and given the location of that sighting compared to the last
16:28sighting which was just around the corner and the timings that were all involved in those sightings
16:34it was still possible then to to have a a good level of confidence that it would that we're looking
16:40at the same person throughout the the whole um footage police believe these were the last images
16:46of suzanne only meters from her office on thistle street and despite extensive analysis they could
16:57not find any images of her leaving the street we traced people that were in that street in front of her
17:07we traced people that were walking behind her we traced em people that were walking in the opposite
17:14direction suzanne's last image is she's disappearing beside a taxi it's one of the first things we were
17:20able to do is to trace that taxi driver to find out who his fears were and to rule him out to eliminate
17:27him has been a possible explanation for our disappearance if there was no evidence suzanne had left thistle
17:35street police realized the nature of their investigation would need to change
17:40as the investigation progressed it was very clear that we were looking at something more than a
17:48missing person investigation and we started to realize that we were looking at a murder investigation
17:58a murder really suzanne had been missing for less than a week unusual yes worrying of course
18:08but murder the police were a million miles from proving that for a start where was the body
18:18the police needed to know exactly what happened in thistle street
18:23none of suzanne's colleagues had seen her at her desk so where had she gone
18:30the problem i faced with a the office block is not only was suzanne's office a large open office with
18:38you know 60 odd people working in the stair that she had access to had four similar offices with
18:44hundreds of people working in there with basements so it's you know which haystack do you start to look
18:50on may the 9th five days after suzanne's disappearance gary flanagan decided the best way to examine the
18:57whole building was to call in the dogs you've got to try and have a starting point so i brought in the
19:03the cadaver dogs in order to to give us that starting point gary believed the cadaver dogs might
19:11be able to confirm there had been a dead body in this building and also provide an indication of
19:17exactly where that dead body had been cadaver dogs react to decomposition in a body so as the body breaks
19:26down the dogs recognize that scent the dogs could speak they would tell us but they're a remarkable tool
19:32and still under under exploited two cadaver dogs roamed through the whole four-story office block
19:43and thistle street their strongest reactions came in and around the basement garage near a fire door
19:53at a parking spot and in a recess under the stairs
19:57the cadaver dogs gave us a fantastic response the dogs are suggesting that there's been a body in all
20:08those areas but the dogs did more than that they also appear to connect the existence of this dead body
20:16to david gilroy we then know that david gilroy had a specific parking bay which was numbered and he'd
20:23taken that that day when he'd parked his vehicle underneath the very area where the boot of the
20:29vehicle was parked the dogs gave a reaction and the dogs also gave a reaction when they examined you
20:34know his vehicle the cadaver dogs were able to identify a fire door you know where he would have
20:40had to negotiate so you've got two or three separate incidents if you like where the dogs are giving an
20:47indication the cadaver dogs provided critical evidence they suggested there had been a dead body in and
20:56around the basement garage near david gilroy's car in the absence of any other forensic evidence
21:06there is no evidence to suggest that suzanne has been murdered within anywhere within the building
21:13the dogs provide that evidence they give support to the fact that suzanne has been murdered within the building
21:23the police still didn't have a body but they were now almost certain they had a murder
21:30and they had lots of questions about the movements and behavior of david gilroy
21:36the investigation began to focus intensely on gilroy himself
21:42the police now needed to know exactly where he'd been and what he'd been doing on may the 4th and may
21:49the 5th
21:58may 2010 edinburgh bookkeeper suzanne pillie had disappeared
22:06police had used forensic analysis of cctv to conclude that she had arrived in her office
22:13the police had become increasingly suspicious of suzanne's former boyfriend and colleague david
22:26gilroy now they used the same forensic analysis of cctv to build a picture of david gilroy's movements on
22:34the day suzanne disappeared we were able to demonstrate cctv of david gilroy traveling on
22:42the bus carrying a rucksack the point he leaves the bus and then pick him up walking through the streets
22:47of edinburgh and catching him on the last camera as he walks into the void if you like outside the office
22:54but then officers noticed that gilroy's movements after he arrived at work were unusual
23:00he logged in to his computer that day that was the first action around um 8 30 in the morning
23:07then there's nothing there's no trace of him during that crucial period when suzanne's arriving at work
23:13there's no electronic footprint which suggests that he's doing anything he's busy he's not using a
23:18telephone he's not using his own telephone he's mobile so we're left with the question well where
23:23is he what's he doing to find out the police analyzed gilroy's computer which had lain idle from 8 30
23:31until sometime after 9 00 a.m not long after the time police believed suzanne had arrived at work
23:39the first action after suzanne's gone missing is to change the diary to to give him an excuse to go
23:45down to lock gilped
23:49david gilroy worked um for a firm who had public contracts with schools in the argyll area there's
23:56nothing unusual at all about david gilroy traveling to argyll to go to school what was unusual was that
24:05it wasn't scheduled for that particular day
24:13the office had a basement garage there was no cctv inside but the lane outside was covered
24:21gilroy appeared in this lane throughout the day
24:24again his behavior struck please as odd and worthy of further investigation
24:33he actually left office and returned home to pick up his vehicle now there was nothing to suggest
24:41that he had required his car when he left to come to work that day he had got a bus to work
24:46we see him leaving the the premises and walking out towards princess street coming back carrying a bag
24:52and walking back into the area it was a distinctive pink colored bag we were able to you know make
24:59inquiries to see who sold pink bags and that led us to a shop where he made purchases then have to work
25:06through till receipts to try and pinpoint anything that could be relevant and from the till receipts
25:12we left a cash purchase pinpointing the purchase of air fresheners disappearing from sight in the office
25:23leaving to pick up his car going in and out of the back lane buying air fresheners
25:32none of this was critical evidence but all of it raised police suspicions about what exactly
25:37gilroy was doing on may the 4th they became even more suspicious when they discovered that whilst
25:45suzanne's worried family and friends were calling her all day to find out where she was
25:51the only one who didn't call was the man who had left her 400 messages in the previous few weeks
25:58david gilroy not even a text to ask if she was all right
26:03after that day there is no more contact really from that day on there was nothing so all these
26:11things in isolation don't amount to a great deal but when you start to put into context you start to
26:17show how that fits into the overall investigation then suddenly you've got something which is quite
26:23powerful on the evening of may the 4th the same day suzanne disappeared gilroy was captured on cctv
26:32again david gilroy went off to a school performance with his family and then went for a meal in an italian
26:40restaurant he didn't eat a great deal that night but he was there with his you know with his family
26:46engaged in conversation and stuff so you know to the outside world david gilroy was acting normally
26:53but the cadaver dogs and the cctv suggested behavior which was not normal as he sat eating
27:02this meal had gilroy already killed suzanne and if so where was her body the police knew he had an
27:11appointment in lock kilphead in argyle the following day may the 5th that's over 130 miles from edinburgh
27:18on the other side of scotland the journey to argyle winds through a remote mountain past known as the
27:27rest to be thankful
27:33recreating this journey in precise exhaustive detail and looking for inconsistencies in gilroy's account of
27:40the trip became the focus of the investigation firstly the route he'd been out 30 times in the
27:48previous year to the contracts in argyle and he'd always gone through the rest and be thankful it's
27:53the most straightforward route but this time gilroy took a longer route ignoring the rest of the
28:00thankful and detouring north to sterling and tindran experience tells us that people in these
28:08situations will mask where they're trying to go so david gilroy went an alternative route uh to mask
28:16from the police where his true destination was so in order to unmask his route the police analyzed
28:24gilroy's phone they discovered it had been switched off at specific points on the journey to and from
28:32loch gilphead he'd switched his telephone off at stirling he traveled all the way around by tindram down to
28:40inverary he'd switched his telephone on at inverary continued down to the school driven back up to
28:46inverary where he switched his telephone off again he doesn't switch it on for you know almost an hour and
28:52a half an hour and 40 minutes and then on the journey back home he switches his telephone back on at ard louis
29:06was gilroy trying to create an electronic black hole in which he could hide his movements
29:11police now turned to cctv to try and get a visual on him
29:14we looked at the opportunities to track that car traveling across scotland that was a large task a
29:27number of systems at that point where although digital systems of really good quality they would
29:32overwrite after short periods of time some were in seven days some were a lot less than that it was
29:39trying to make sure that we had ample opportunity to get out there and capture that as soon as possible
29:44steward houston and his team studied 250 cctv cameras to build a picture of the journey and
29:53to place gilroy at specific locations at specific times and that's when they realized gilroy had been
30:01on the road longer than he should have been we'd see ctv in a garage in tindram which is in the north of
30:09urgyll the next period that we have cctv is in the town of inverary so the time it takes you to get
30:19between those two points is 36 minutes on average driving and average speed
30:26but cctv revealed gilroy had taken not 36 minutes but two hours and 29 minutes to travel between these
30:34two towns on the outward journey and two hours nine minutes on the way back that's nearly three and a
30:42half hours unaccounted for on a stretch of road surrounded by forests for the police this was a
30:50critical discovery that em was i would say quite a turning point in the fact that we knew he was
30:58familiar with that area we knew that he had that opportunity if he left tindram and traveled towards
31:04inverary that he could turn off that would take you into some quite remote areas of her gil
31:13if you're going to go and dispose of something not just not just the body but other items
31:20you know you have that time frame you have that opportunity to do it
31:28and if he had taken more time on his journey police wondered whether he might also have used more
31:40fuel indicating perhaps that he had traveled to unseen spots along the main route
31:48the last action when he left and thistle street was to go and purchase fuel so we were able to work in
31:55the assumption he'd have a full tank of fuel so working with experts from the traffic management
32:02we were able to recreate the journey we were able to establish that he had 124 miles missing from his
32:09journey analysis of cctv and his petrol tank indicated gilroy had used more time and more fuel
32:18than would normally have been expected between tindram and inverary
32:21the police continued their detailed examination of gilroy's car
32:39they hope to find more critical evidence hidden in the chassis or engine
32:44so we took his vehicle apart three out of the four main springs in the vehicle were damaged we found
32:51grass on the underside of the vehicle we started to look at environmental profiling our hope was that
32:58there'd be something unusual about the argyle forest that there'd be ancient woodlands there
33:04unfortunately it's commercial forest it's mundane there's nothing terribly unusual about it
33:09but you know from the vehicle examination from the foot pedals from the floor mats from the tires we look
33:16at soil samples we look to see if there's anything unusual in that which can help us with the search
33:22despite extensive scientific tests police could not isolate exactly where the vegetation on the car
33:28had come from but combined with the damage to the vehicle they were now confident gilroy had driven it
33:35off the main road all these things are pointing to one thing that he's been off-road he's been potentially
33:43in a forest or in some other place where he's tried to dispose and successfully disposed of suzanne's body
33:51finally cctv revealed that gilroy had arrived at the school in loch gilphead at around 4 30 in the
33:58afternoon but he appeared to meet no one or do anything of any importance there was nothing to
34:06suggest that he had done anything significant during that visit there was nothing to say that he carried
34:11out any huge inspection of of of the property or anything like that it was a an awful long way to go
34:19for really doing not very much technology combined with old-fashioned piecework had uncovered critical
34:29evidence which shone a new light on gilroy's trip to loch gilphead cctv had captured much of his journey
34:37his mobile phone records suggested he might be trying to disappear
34:42and the fuel consumed by his car indicated over 100 miles that were unaccounted for
34:49on the 23rd of june police decided they had enough to charge gilroy with suzanne's murder
34:56but they still didn't have the one piece of evidence which most murder investigations have
35:02a dead body
35:03and in 2010 there had been only four successful nobody murder convictions in scottish legal history
35:12gary flanagan knew everything now hinged on the combined strength of the circumstantial evidence
35:18he and his team had assembled in a complex investigation like this there's no one single
35:26fact there's no smoking gun that's going to convince the jury to convict when you've nobody
35:31there was no smoking gun but there was cctv just a few frames of which would provide another
35:40critical clue to gilroy's movements that day
35:50june 2010 police in edinburgh had arrested david gilroy for the murder of his former girlfriend
35:59suzanne pilly they suspected he may have killed her at work and disposed of her body in a remote forest
36:09but police hadn't found suzanne's body
36:14we carried out a lot of work in the area in argyle looking for routes or where someone may have went
36:19if you are trying to get rid of a body where you could do that we focused a number of areas we looked
36:26up what the conditions were for someone to be able to take a body from a car and take it to a weighted
36:33area or an area off the road
36:43we used experts we used national advisors from the national groups that support major investigations
36:50unfortunately regrettably we didn't find suzanne the police couldn't find suzanne's body but their
36:59relentless analysis of cctv was still paying dividends when we look at any particular line
37:08of investigation where we need to squeeze every opportunity from that line of investigation so
37:14one of the tasks for the cctv operators is to describe or to look for little nuance little
37:20changes within the appearance of the vehicle and that's when an alert officer spotted another piece
37:28of critical evidence one which would complete the picture of gilroy suggested gilroy had stopped
37:35somewhere in the forest out of sight of the cctv
37:39to open the boot of his car before returning to edinburgh at 11 30 that evening to talk to the
37:46police there was nothing to indicate that it had been out being used that day i think it proves there
37:51was some sort of activity in and around the boot of that vehicle during the course of that journey
37:59now the police believe they had succeeded in building a complete picture of may the 4th
38:04and may the 5th they believed suzanne had arrived at work where gilroy had confronted her about the
38:12end of their relationship either in or near the basement he'd killed suzanne possibly sustaining
38:19injuries to his hands in the process and then hidden her body
38:26he had brought his car into the garage and put suzanne's body in the boot where it would remain for
38:32well over 24 hours he'd bought air fresheners to disguise the smell of decomposition from human if
38:41not canine noses he'd then traveled to loch gilphead the following day there he'd try to hide his movements
38:50before conducting a cursory visit to a school with suzanne's body almost certainly still inside the boot
38:56then he disposed of suzanne's remains somewhere in the argyle forest before heading back to edinburgh
39:05despite no forensic evidence and no body the police believed the circumstantial evidence was compelling
39:13now it was up to the jury on reflection in this particular case there's no one critical piece of
39:21information it's everything taken in its entirety which leaves absolutely no doubt whatsoever that
39:28there's only one conclusion here that suzanne pillier was murdered within thistle street having made it
39:33to her work and the person responsible for that murder was david gilroy
39:39in 2012 gilroy was found guilty of suzanne's murder and sentenced to life imprisonment
39:4625 years ago this case might well not have succeeded the car would have vanished in our guile
39:55and police would have been none the wiser about his movements but now he couldn't escape cctv
40:02mobile phone records voicemails and text messages he couldn't escape the realities of modern technology
40:09but while gilroy couldn't hide what he'd done suzanne remains lost somewhere in these forests
40:21gilroy has never admitted to this crime or hinted where suzanne's body might be found
40:28suzanne's mother sylvia and her sister gail live with the pain every day
40:33i do believe that one day she will be found and i feel that the best way to ensure that
40:42is for the law in scotland to be changed so that killers like him can't get out on parole until they
40:49tell the families in our position where they've buried their victims it's difficult to think that
40:56she's lying somewhere nobody knows where she is and as if she didn't matter as if he's throwing her away as if she didn't matter at all
41:10despite gilroy's conviction the case is not yet completely closed we need to keep
41:17this open in the fact until we find suzanne em there may be someone out there who knows something
41:22who may be able to help us may be able to point us in the right direction i intend to keep trying
41:30every opportunity to the fact that how we can recover our body
Be the first to comment