- 11 months ago
Hey everybody. I'm Jon, and this is the series finale of FOOL TIME. Thank you so much for showing up for this. This is one of the most interesting and fun projects I've ever had the chance to work on, and I hope you enjoy the final episode. If you'd like to catch up on the earlier episodes, they're all available on YouTube and linked below.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00:00.
00:01:30We have some very weird 1800s crap on the menu this evening for you.
00:01:34I hope we can interest you in our international dishes featuring plates from all over the world.
00:01:39America, France, Germany, and the British Isles.
00:01:41You know, the four places.
00:01:43We've also got calf brain fritters and something called Riesel of Cam.
00:01:48I tried to look this up and I found nothing.
00:01:50I still have absolutely no idea what it is, but it is guaranteed to be the nastiest thing you have ever eaten, seen, or thought about.
00:01:57Enjoy.
00:02:27Did they drag 2,000 or so miles of telegraph cable across the ocean and actually got it to work in 1858?
00:02:34Fifteen years ago, this technology didn't even functionally exist outside of laboratories.
00:02:38Now you can sit in New Orleans and have a conversation with somebody in Moscow without anybody having to get out of their chair.
00:02:44But nowhere have people partied harder than in New York City.
00:02:48The whole town's been on a bender for weeks.
00:02:50In mid-August, they set up this big, brilliant pyrotechnics display at City Hall in celebration of the telegraph.
00:02:56Everything went just great, except for the part where City Hall almost burned down.
00:02:59At first, onlookers thought the outpouring of flames was just part of the fireworks display,
00:03:04and it wasn't until the dome on the top finally collapsed and caved in that they realized it probably was not.
00:03:09Fires were a big problem for Americans around this time, as was recognizing what is and is not part of the show.
00:03:15But in the few minutes before the building started burning down, at least, New Yorkers were treated to big, bright lettering,
00:03:21spelling out the name of the man who's instantly become an international hero, Cyrus W. Field.
00:03:27They got his middle initial wrong, but that's okay.
00:03:32On the very same day as President Fillmore's banquet, the city of New York throws a massive parade in celebration of the cable
00:03:39and of Cyrus, the founder of the Atlantic Telegraph Company.
00:03:42It's the sort of parade that'll only be equaled in measure and spectacle by future military victories and sports championships.
00:03:49In 1858, nobody has seen anything like this.
00:03:53It looks as though the entire city is standing on the street.
00:03:55Signs and banners bearing Cyrus' likeness are hanging from every other building.
00:03:59Banks, newspapers, government buildings have been shut down.
00:04:03The New York Times reports, quote,
00:04:04Cyrus Field is being lauded and celebrated as few, if any, other human beings ever have to this point in history.
00:04:21It's everything he ever wanted.
00:04:23His horse-drawn carriage slowly creeps through the adoring masses.
00:04:27I'm sure he's smiling and waving and doing everything he's supposed to be doing, but
00:04:32I'm just as sure that deep down inside, he's saying to himself,
00:04:38once all these people know what I know,
00:04:42I am fucked.
00:04:44Before we go any further, I'd like to give a nod to a few especially valuable sources I leaned on throughout this project,
00:05:05all of which deserve a little bit more than just a passing mention in the closing credits.
00:05:09There's Lightning Man by Kenneth Silverman, Degrees Kelvin by David Lindley,
00:05:14and A Thread Across the Ocean by John C.L. Gordon,
00:05:17all of which tell larger stories that are beyond the scope of this project.
00:05:20So, if you're interested in learning more, highly recommend those.
00:05:23Also, want to give a special shout-out to Bruce J. Hunt,
00:05:26who, across several different writings,
00:05:28offered a lot of crucial and fascinating insight into some of the elements of this story,
00:05:32and to the website AtlanticCable.com,
00:05:34an absolutely exhaustive treasure trove of rare and hard-to-find materials
00:05:38that has been around since 2001 and is still being updated today.
00:05:42So, before we continue to complain about the substandard makeup of this transatlantic telegraph cable,
00:05:48let's first appreciate what has been accomplished here.
00:05:52This could have been a phone charger, could have been a lamp cord,
00:05:54and it still would have been outrageously impressive that in the middle of the 19th century,
00:05:59when ships were still mostly made out of wood and doing everything took forever,
00:06:03they were able to spool nearly 2,000 miles of it across the ocean floor,
00:06:07that this works at all is a MacGyvering of historical proportion.
00:06:11It's built of impure copper, an organic insulation they pulled out of plants,
00:06:15which is all they had in 1858, which makes this whole enterprise feel like an anachronism.
00:06:19It's like when you fire up a game of civilization,
00:06:22and you go so one-sided with your tech tree that your cities are pumping out space shuttles
00:06:26and aircraft carriers before you've researched, like, pottery.
00:06:29It feels like something that shouldn't have been accomplished for another 50 years at least.
00:06:34And in that sense, I consider all of this to be a monumental victory
00:06:38regardless of what happens to the cable going forward.
00:06:42Or rather, who happens to it.
00:06:44The remainder of this story is primarily one of two men.
00:06:53Wild Man Whitehouse, the catastrophic Tim, and William Thompson, his transformational Al.
00:06:59This is the most powerful Tim and the most powerful Al we have yet encountered.
00:07:04Strangely, and in ways I never could have imagined, both will be necessary.
00:07:10Thompson, along with Charles Bright, head back to London once they disembark from the HMS Agamemnon at Valencia Island.
00:07:16Wild Man stays right there on the island.
00:07:19As chief engineer, he holds immediate authority both here in Ireland
00:07:22and on the other side of the cable in Newfoundland.
00:07:25But he ultimately still has the bosses at the Atlantic Telegraph Company to answer to,
00:07:29bosses with whom he has not been on great terms lately.
00:07:32You see, Wild Man is pretty annoying.
00:07:34He talks a lot, he complains incessantly.
00:07:37When it's put up or shut up time, he always finds an excuse to punk out.
00:07:41He always found reasons to stay home while everybody else braved the dangers of the open seas.
00:07:46At the same time, he demanded impossibly large budgets for his equipment and experiments.
00:07:51Consider that manufacturing the cable cost the company 225,000 pounds.
00:07:55That would be just over 30 million modern U.S. dollars.
00:07:58A later report will specify that in total,
00:08:01Whitehouse's experiments cost them 176,000 dollars.
00:08:05That's then money, and now money, that's about 6.7 million bucks.
00:08:10Consider also that this big chunk of money bought them 2,500 miles of cable.
00:08:16Through every bit of it runs strands of copper, a very expensive metal to acquire in bulk,
00:08:21some 300 tons of gutta-percha which had to be ferried in from across the world,
00:08:26an exterior of wires made of iron, also not cheap.
00:08:29That's not including the massive machinery required to produce this.
00:08:33On top of the labor costs, on top of other unforeseen expenses,
00:08:37it makes perfect sense that this cable is as incredibly expensive as it is.
00:08:41And while, granted, equipment and experiments cost a non-zero amount of money,
00:08:45Whitehouse doesn't have to build a clean room, or a Hadron Collider, or anything like that,
00:08:50his expenses should be an invisible spec compared to this cable.
00:08:54What are you doing, man?
00:08:55What is this for?
00:08:57Well, to take one example,
00:08:58at one point, Wildman expensed these two gigantic, laughably expensive plates for the batteries
00:09:04that were made of pure silver,
00:09:05only to throw him out upon realizing that regular graphite plates worked better.
00:09:09If he were an actual electrician, he probably would have known that to begin with,
00:09:13failing that if he were just a normal person, he would have asked around first.
00:09:17But, again, Wildman is neither practical man nor scientist.
00:09:22It's kind of amazing that he's still around at all.
00:09:25At first, he was useful, but only as a loud, blustery champion of this considerably substandard cable
00:09:30Field had ordered.
00:09:31Now that it's acquired and laid down, he's mostly just irritating.
00:09:34While Whitehouse does remain chief electrician,
00:09:37Field recently bought him out of his ownership stake entirely,
00:09:39which Whitehouse publicly denounces as the, quote,
00:09:42frantic fooleries of the Americans.
00:09:44Until now, Whitehouse could at least count on the support of another Tim and Samuel Morse,
00:09:49a fellow attention-starved poser with a poor grasp of both theory and execution,
00:09:53but Morse has now bailed on both Whitehouse and the entire project.
00:09:56And you know you've totally lost the room when you've lost William Thompson,
00:10:00who at every turn has demonstrated himself to be an especially patient, empathetic, and gracious guy.
00:10:05Once willing to overlook Wildman's ridiculous, ascientific non-arguments and extend the olive branch of friendship,
00:10:12not even Thompson wants much to do with him these days.
00:10:14It got to the point where Field had to make sure Thompson and Whitehouse didn't stay on the same ship during their voyages,
00:10:19an issue that of course was made moot when Wildman bailed.
00:10:23I'd be unhappy too if I were a god of contemporary science who couldn't finance my modest yet brilliant invention,
00:10:29because this idiot had already burned through the entire budget.
00:10:32Being intimately familiar with the failings of this transatlantic cable and realizing that devising workarounds was paramount,
00:10:38Thompson requested a far smaller budget and didn't even get that.
00:10:42He ended up taking just 500 pounds.
00:10:44That was the amount they could find in their couch cushions after Whitehouse drained their finances dry.
00:10:49Thompson had to cover the rest out of his own pocket.
00:10:51In modern US money, that's about 67,000 bucks.
00:10:54Again, Whitehouse blew through a reported 6.7 million or so, just about 100 times as much.
00:11:02What Thompson was after, and what he soon achieved, was an elegant, ingenious device perfectly suited for the problem at hand.
00:11:10The cable's insulation is not great.
00:11:12The copper core, against his own recommendations, is extremely small, literally thread-like in diameter.
00:11:17Too small for a heavy charge, which does absolutely nothing to account for these problems anyway.
00:11:22The wire is also obviously really, really, really long, and it's less than perfect insulation is surrounded by seawater that would love to leach away some of that current any chance it gets.
00:11:32The answer, then, is to go lighter with the charge.
00:11:36Traditional above-ground telegraph engineers sometimes detect current on a line by literally sticking their tongue on it and seeing if they can taste a little charge.
00:11:43But the current on this line needs to be far more weak and subtle.
00:11:47Traditional galvanometers, which measure electric currents, aren't nearly precise enough to measure signals that weak.
00:11:53Necessitating William Thompson's mirror galvanometer.
00:11:57This, unlike Cyrus Field's line across the globe story, is an origin myth I actually do buy.
00:12:07One day he noticed his monocle dangling loose from his neck and its reflection throwing light around the room with absolutely zero effort, and there he experienced his epiphany.
00:12:16An infinitesimally small current is all it would take to nudge a tiny magnet connected to a virtually weightless thread attached to a tiny mirror on which you can shine a light that the mirror will reflect and throw left or right.
00:12:29Does it automatically record Morse code like traditional instruments do? No.
00:12:33The current isn't nearly strong enough to push ink to paper, so you have to watch the readings and write them down by hand.
00:12:38Easy to overlook considering what it will do.
00:12:41Make transatlantic telegraph communication possible.
00:12:45Thompson has already tested it extensively on this cable, and it works great.
00:12:49Now you might think William Thompson makes for a strange Al Borland, huh?
00:12:52He's an academic, a college boy.
00:12:55Not at all callous handed and big and imposing, but those superficialities do not matter because they don't matter to Al, and they never did.
00:13:02Al is traditionally masculine, but he doesn't seem to care whether he is or not.
00:13:06Al Borland loves square dancing.
00:13:08He prefers to settle disagreements over a cup of tea.
00:13:11He knows his astrological sign.
00:13:13He's populated with canonical flourishes that run afoul of Tim's idea of masculinity.
00:13:18Now, deconstructing the gender politics of home improvement kind of feels like escaping an escape room.
00:13:24You know, it's prefabricated.
00:13:25You can't deconstruct it.
00:13:27They kind of already did it for you.
00:13:28Masculinity is something Tim does, and it's something Al is.
00:13:31That's the joke.
00:13:32Things like The Man's Bathroom might not seem as funny now because this genre of comedy is just so played out by every hacked stand-up comedian and Rules of the Man Cave poster, but this cottage industry could arguably trace its roots back to home improvement.
00:13:46Maybe it's because it hadn't been played out yet, maybe it's because I was 11, but I thought The Man's Bathroom was funny.
00:13:51It's pretty cool to imagine grabbing a brewski and watching the game from the crapper with your friend
00:13:56kind of just sitting in there with you on his weird chair.
00:13:59This is what real guys like to do.
00:14:01This is what me and all my friends do.
00:14:03Now, Tim's toilet is obviously terrible engineering that is terribly suited for this purpose.
00:14:08He can't recline on a toilet.
00:14:10It's a really bad idea for reasons best left unspecified here.
00:14:15Let's just say it lacks precision.
00:14:30That is, swear to God, the name of Wildman Whitehouse's signature invention, the Electromagnetic Steel Yard.
00:14:38He's so proud of it, he calls it his pet child.
00:14:40Man, what a weird couple of words to put together.
00:14:43Anyway, what Wildman has done here is turn the science of electrical telegraphy into weightlifting,
00:14:49quite literally.
00:14:49A current pulls on an electromagnet, and if the current is strong enough, it lifts this weight,
00:14:54which can be adjusted back and forth like the scale at a doctor's office.
00:14:58It's neat, sure, but Whitehouse is trying to vault this thing from neat to scientifically useful
00:15:04by quantifying the strength of an electric current in weight.
00:15:07If it can lift X amount, that's how much it weighs.
00:15:10A sensationally stupid way to quantify something like electricity that you'd only resort to
00:15:15if you didn't really know anything about electricity and had no interest in learning.
00:15:19What is this thing actually measuring?
00:15:21Voltage? Current?
00:15:23Wildman doesn't know, and he doesn't care.
00:15:25And besides, as renowned electrician J.N. Herter observed upon studying the device,
00:15:30Whitehouse seems to have just rolled out of bed one morning and decided that the weight a current
00:15:34can lift on this thing will always be consistently proportional to its strength, which it's not.
00:15:39Herter concedes that this thing might be well suited for some specific applications,
00:15:43but there are too many unaccounted for variables for this to do what Whitehouse says it will do.
00:15:48It's never stopped Wildman before, though.
00:15:50He's a born bullshitter, and judging from his defensive impulse to outbluster all potential comers,
00:15:55he knows that about himself. In 1857, before he'd completely annoyed and alienated everyone else
00:16:01in the Atlantic Telegraph Company, he used the company letterhead to fire a preemptive shot
00:16:05across the bow toward the electromagnetic steel yard's chief competition, the galvanometer,
00:16:11specifically William Thompson's mirror galvanometer.
00:16:14That thing is a dinky little mirror tied to a piece of silk Thompson pulled out of his niece's dress.
00:16:19It's like a woman. Am I right, fellas?
00:16:22Wild and crazy, ecstatic, impulsive, passionate, hysterical.
00:16:26Whitehouse's steel yard is, on the other hand, steady, strong, sure, stable, staid, businesslike,
00:16:32self-possessed. As Bruce J. Hunt observes, the language is strikingly gendered.
00:16:37The choice is clear. Do you want to be a real man, or do you want to, uh, succeed?
00:16:43The Atlantic Telegraph Company, despite a few glaring indications to the contrary,
00:16:47has decided it wants to succeed. This transatlantic cable requires nuance.
00:16:52Finesse. And an intimate understanding of what it means to fire the world's hopes and dreams
00:16:57through 2,000 miles of speaker wire. And that means opting for the mirror galvanometer.
00:17:03It's the Atlantic Telegraph Company's apparatus of choice going forward.
00:17:11So it's August of 1858. Now that the cable is successfully linked to each end,
00:17:16its operators spend a few days calibrating their instruments and sending out test signals.
00:17:20At this point, they're mostly just shooting solid currents that don't actually translate into morse
00:17:25code. They're just shoving them out there to let the other side know that they are indeed connected.
00:17:29August 10th is when the official message log begins. The Valencia End in Ireland is run by a
00:17:35Wildman Whitehouse, and the Newfoundland End is managed by respected electrician Charles De Sauti.
00:17:40On day one, Newfoundland thinks Valencia is trying to send them something, but they can't tell what it is.
00:17:45They ask for it to be sent slower, and aside from one instance in which they think they get a yes,
00:17:50no luck. They ask Valencia to send them the letter B, which in morse code is a dash dot dot dot,
00:17:55and the letter V, which is a dot dot dot dash. More of this in day two, in which Newfoundland again
00:18:01asks Valencia to slow down. Meanwhile in Valencia, Whitehouse is keeping the directors of the Atlantic
00:18:07Telegraph Company in London a prize via conventional telegraph, and he believes the instruments over on
00:18:12the Newfoundland side still need more calibrating. The directors reply by cautioning Whitehouse not
00:18:17to use too strong a current on the cable for fear of damaging it. Whitehouse is so offended by this
00:18:23that he doesn't immediately answer. He calls the directors childish for daring to try to micromanage
00:18:28him from hundreds of miles away. This defensiveness is beautifully ironic considering that up until this
00:18:34point, he's always been the one far away from the action making wild claims and prognostications from
00:18:39twenty downs over. Whitehouse finally responds, insisting, hey listen, I'm not using any overly
00:18:45strong currents or doing anything weird at all over here. Don't worry about it. Oh, by the way,
00:18:49Thompson, can you shoot me an entire half a ton of copper sulfate for the batteries? No reason,
00:18:56just because. I just want some. Day three is more of the same with Valencia able to read Newfoundland's
00:19:03messages, but Newfoundland can't make out what Valencia is sending. Finally, in the early hours of
00:19:08day four, they can make out the first word sent from Whitehouse's end, Atlantic. For whatever reason,
00:19:14that doesn't last long. Newfoundland asks Valencia to send literally any word. No? Okay, uh, send the
00:19:21alphabet. No? Okay, just send the letter V. No? Uh, fuck it, just send me a bunch of dots. This is
00:19:30obviously not quite going as planned so far, so the board of directors tells Whitehouse they'll be
00:19:34sending him some assistance in the form of one Mr. France, a respected electrician. The historical
00:19:40record tells us virtually nothing more than that about Mr. France, whoever he is. We don't know
00:19:46where he was from, what he looked like, or what he did before or after this. But judging from
00:19:51Whitehouse's reaction, we can think of him as the Bob Vila of this operation.
00:19:55The Tool Man hated Bob Vila. Hated him. Vila, the god of home improvement television, represented
00:20:07everything Tim was not. A host who was genial, likable, widely respected, and who, crucially,
00:20:13actually knew how to do stuff. In his first guest appearance on Tool Time, Al gets a brief
00:20:17taste of the far better life he could have had, chopping it up with an equally knowledgeable co-host.
00:20:22Folks, it's a good idea to use your framing square at this point in the job because you
00:20:26want to make sure this header goes in there nice and level. Excellent point, Mr. Vila.
00:20:29Yeah, there's nothing worse than trying to hang a door at an opening that isn't true.
00:20:32How true, how true. But this is Tim's world, one in which a Bob Vila cannot survive for long.
00:20:38Al, I was going to get to that.
00:20:42Whitehouse, enraged by their decision to send him Mr. France, angrily replies to the directors,
00:20:48this is a huge mistake. I hate Mr. France. Tell him to turn around and go home.
00:20:53Wild Man never specifies exactly what he doesn't like about Mr. France, but it isn't hard to figure
00:20:58out. Mr. France actually knows what he's doing, and having someone like that around threatens to
00:21:03compromise Wild Man's big huge make-believe electrical funhouse adventure, a magical world
00:21:08in which he doesn't have to recognize the difference between voltage and current, he doesn't believe in the
00:21:12law of squares, and he just sorta kinda makes things up as he goes along. Mr. France is clearly the
00:21:18sort of chief electrician this company should've had instead of Whitehouse. If he were, this whole
00:21:22story would probably play out a little differently and a lot better. Unfortunately, Whitehouse is
00:21:27chief electrician, and as day four continues, those on the Newfoundland side are beginning to
00:21:32strongly suspect he's using hardware that's far too powerful. They ask him to either switch out his
00:21:37powering apparatus or scale it down. Now crucially, Whitehouse has used his authority as chief
00:21:43electrician to insist that both sides use his own proprietary equipment instead of Thompson's
00:21:49mirror galvanometer, and that is not at all what the directors intended. On day five, however,
00:21:54Newfoundland finally gives up on Whitehouse's ineffective paperweights and switches to Thompson's
00:21:59device. It is impossible to Wild Man that his beautiful little electrical pet children could be
00:22:04the problem, which I bet is why he now makes up a new problem. He's suddenly fully convinced that
00:22:10somewhere on his end of the cable near the shore the insulation is damaged. What is giving him this
00:22:15idea? Is electromagnetic steel yard the thing that is completely unsuited for this cable and can tell
00:22:20you absolutely nothing about it? Probably, and he decides it's up to him to save the day. Three voyages
00:22:27of a tented oceanic cable laying have made its operators intimately familiar with this cable. Remember
00:22:33that many on board began to think of the cable as a dear friend, one they obsessively studied and
00:22:38fussed over and repaired and lost sleep worrying about. When the Agamemnon was fighting for its
00:22:43life in that storm of the century, they'd considered throwing the cable overboard to stabilize the ship
00:22:49and potentially save their own lives. They just could not bring themselves to do it. To say they know
00:22:55and respect this cable would be an understatement. Whitehouse, stricken with the world's unluckiest series
00:23:02of tummy aches, did not go on any of those voyages. Even his mostly pointless pseudoscientific
00:23:07experiments were mostly conducted on other cables, not this one. He doesn't know shit about this cable,
00:23:12this enormously expensive cable that should not be touched without getting the green light from the
00:23:17bosses. So, of course, on day five, Whitehouse fires off another message to the directors.
00:23:24Hey, heads up, I think the cable's busted. I'm sending my boy out there to screw around with it and see
00:23:29what's what. A bit later in the day. Yeah, we found some kinks in the cable and buoyed it. What do you
00:23:34think? This appears to give the directors a full-on panic attack. Immediately, they shoot back a message.
00:23:40Do not touch the cable. Don't underrun it. Don't buoy it. Don't inspect it. Don't try to repair it.
00:23:46Don't look at it. Stay away. George Soward, one of the directors of the company,
00:23:51also sends a second message directly to Whitehouse to hammer the point home.
00:23:55I just talked to William Thompson. He says that whatever you're saying is the problem is not the
00:23:59problem. It's something else. Again, do not mess with the cable. I don't know why you wouldn't mess
00:24:06with it without telling us first that you are not authorized to touch it. Sit tight. Mr. France is on
00:24:12the way. You need his help. Stop talking shit about him. Whitehouse's subsequent reply doesn't
00:24:17acknowledge any of that. Instead, he continues to complain about the supposed damage on the cable,
00:24:22which he believes spells certain doom unless something is immediately done,
00:24:27Wildman begs them to send none other than William Thompson to help. Thompson, of course,
00:24:31is fairly fed up with Wildman, but at least has a history of being nice to him and overlooking
00:24:36his constant screw-ups, and at this point he might be the only person left in the company who doesn't
00:24:41hate him. While Whitehouse's side still can't manage to push intelligible messages to Newfoundland,
00:24:46Newfoundland is at least now able to string together some longer messages to Valencia.
00:24:51They're clearly feeling the heat over there as word has started to get out that this cable is not
00:24:55working as well as advertised. They're stuck doing damage control in the American press explaining that
00:25:00this is no ordinary cable and delays were always to be expected. People seem to buy that for the
00:25:05moment as most of America is basically holding a jubilee over this thing, but they gotta figure out
00:25:11what's going on here and they gotta figure it out now. At 10 p.m. on day number five,
00:25:15Soured again directly messages Whitehouse, clearly agitated by his elusiveness,
00:25:20Nothing so important as that which you have undertaken should have been done without proper
00:25:24sanction, much less in disobedience of positive instructions. You have assumed a serious
00:25:29responsibility from which I cannot relieve you until Monday. Oh, buddy, you're in trouble.
00:25:36Big trouble. I think they're about to fire your ass. Sensing this, Whitehouse still refuses to
00:25:42acknowledge anything he's being taken to task for, but he does send a few messages to show the
00:25:46directors what a good boy he's being. What should I do? Should I keep receiving messages? They want
00:25:52me to relay a message, but I told them, wait, I'd better ask the directors for permission. That's the
00:25:58right thing to do. That's me though, always doing the right thing and being a good boy. Early on day six,
00:26:05a response from Soured. Yeah, okay, whatever. I don't fucking care. Anyway, I heard that you want to
00:26:09assign Mr. France to some menial job. This guy is a pro. You need to treat him with more respect.
00:26:14You need help? Let him help you. Whitehouse. No, fuck Mr. France. I hate him. I've assigned him the job
00:26:22of clerk. He can write down messages. That's all he gets to do. Later, Whitehouse will explain his
00:26:27thinking here. Jealous? No, definitely not jealous at all. He writes that assistants, quote,
00:26:33came in a most questionable form at a time and in a manner calculated to do the utmost damage
00:26:38possible to the reputation of the company's officers. Oh boy, things are going down the tubes
00:26:44on Valencia Island. Wildman Whitehouse is not only an unqualified idiot. He's not only using the wrong
00:26:50instruments. He's not only messing with a priceless cable in violation of direct orders. He's not only
00:26:55refusing help. He's not only being a jerk and alienating everyone. Now, on top of all this,
00:27:00he's going paranoid, insisting that sending Mr. France is the company's way of sabotaging him.
00:27:05He can call it what he wants, but all they're doing is sending a person who's actually qualified,
00:27:10and you can take one look around in the Valencia Telegraph station, observe all of Whitehouse's
00:27:14worthless inventions, and realize he's a fraud. That cannot be allowed. And Whitehouse will not
00:27:19shut up about it either. He now demands that instead of Mr. France, the company send him a guy named
00:27:24Phillips. Phillips is Wildman's boy, one of the few who've actually bought into his
00:27:29bullshit and can help maintain this facade. Sauer replies, nope, sorry, already fired him.
00:27:41The walls are clearly closing in on Wildman, who's now fired off another big long screed,
00:27:46saying he, quote, hourly trembles for the safety of the cable, declaring that all will soon be lost
00:27:51if it isn't repaired. He also complains about how hard he's working, how hard his job is,
00:27:56how the directors have failed him by not coming to Valencia Island themselves, which is clearly
00:28:00a bluff because he would hate it if they actually did. Anyway, that's the play here. Just start being
00:28:05a crybaby on top of everything else. People love it when you do that. A big long letter, which the
00:28:10board of directors wrote a couple days ago, finally makes its way to Whitehouse on day number seven.
00:28:16Turns out there's a mole in Whitehouse's operation, and that mole has let the directors
00:28:20know that Whitehouse is still planning to go out there and mess with the cable some more.
00:28:25This after being told multiple times explicitly not to do so under any circumstances. Sauer also
00:28:32continues to insist that Mr. France, a highly distinguished electrician and a pretty tough get,
00:28:37be treated with more respect. Whitehouse returns fire with an even longer letter. This one is a
00:28:43monster running about 1,600 words long. Folks, I think he's starting to lose it a little bit.
00:28:49At one point, while trying to explain his treatment of Mr. France, he deploys this mammoth 174-word
00:28:57run-on sentence. It's a preview of what's to come from Wildman, who also fires off a second, much
00:29:02shorter message. I didn't let Mr. France see any of the instruments or even enter the instrument room.
00:29:07Since you wouldn't fire him, I did. And that does it. Sauer replies,
00:29:12Come to London right now. The board of directors is assembled and waiting for you.
00:29:16We don't have the full minutes from the subsequent meeting, but we do have the important part.
00:29:21Citing his treatment of Mr. France and refusal to stop interfering with the cable,
00:29:26Chief Engineer Wildman Whitehouse is terminated, effective immediately.
00:29:33Didn't even make it to the New York City accidental arson party.
00:29:42The impossible has happened. Wildman the Lightning King Whitehouse has been fired from the Atlantic
00:29:51Telegraph Company, a fate as unimaginable as Tim the Tool Man Taylor being fired from Tool Time.
00:29:56He was Cyrus Field's golden boy, his ace in the hole, the champion of this substandard telegraph
00:30:02cable defending all attacks from the world of science and the law of squares. Having far outlasted his
00:30:07usefulness in that regard, he found a way to remain entrenched, but couldn't overcome his own
00:30:12combativeness and obsession with tinkering, which did him in. But it's now, and only now, when the
00:30:19fun really begins. For most of us, being fired would signal the end of the story. For somebody like
00:30:25Wildman, it's only beginning. He soon snaps off another thousand word letter to the board of directors.
00:30:32His misspelling of his own name as Wildman is maybe the fourth or fifth funniest thing in here.
00:30:38He talks as though he still works here, delivering a report in which he reveals that under his
00:30:42leadership they've only been able to transmit to Newfoundland at the rate of 1.5 words per minute.
00:30:47That is so slow that if you wanted to transmit a really long letter, like Wildman's here for
00:30:52example, you might want to take your chances stuffing it into a bottle and throwing it into the
00:30:56ocean instead. Once again, Wildman blames the directors for all his problems and accuses them
00:31:02of conspiring against him. He concludes by formally submitting his resignation, which is such a powerful
00:31:07thing to do several days after you've been fired. What a move. But it gets even better when he requests
00:31:14that the board of directors, who he just got done accusing of orchestrating a Machiavellian conspiracy
00:31:19against him, give him the title of honorary consulting electrician, which of course they don't. I bet they
00:31:25never even read this. You and I might be the first people to ever read this.
00:31:30Meanwhile, like magic, transmission across the cable improves as soon as Wildman gets the boot.
00:31:35During his last full day on the job, his team in Valencia had tried to transmit a message of
00:31:39goodwill from the Queen of England to President James Buchanan. The message was 99 words total.
00:31:45If you were to tap out this message at a standard signaling speed and send it along a line with zero
00:31:49latency, it would take you about nine minutes. Valencia began sending it at about 6.30 pm and did
00:31:55not finish until nearly seven in the morning. It took them 12 entire hours and change.
00:32:01Newfoundland answers with a similarly long message from President Buchanan to the Queen,
00:32:05Valencia receives the message much more quickly, within an hour or two. You know why? Because
00:32:10Newfoundland and Valencia are finally getting on the same page. Now that White House isn't in
00:32:15Valencia breathing down everybody's necks, the technicians there can not only use Thompson's
00:32:19mirror galvanometer, but more importantly tell the other side they are using it. They're operating
00:32:24compatible systems and now know they are, rather than resorting to a solution that wasn't unlike
00:32:30trying to shove a Nintendo cartridge into a Sega Genesis. They openly tell each other,
00:32:34hey, I'm using the galvanometer, are you using it too? Okay, great. Transmission immediately and
00:32:41dramatically improves. Soon William Thompson himself arrives in Valencia to keep an eye on things.
00:32:47Wildman has of course put Thompson through the wringer. First by publicly attacking his law of squares and
00:32:53dismissing his findings as a quote, fiction of the schools. Then upon mending fences and somehow
00:32:59becoming friends, White House repaid Thompson for his graciousness by burning through the company's
00:33:04budget and leaving almost nothing left over for Thompson. Unsurprisingly, after many days of this
00:33:09cable completely crashing and burning, Thompson fully supported the board's decision to fire White
00:33:14House. But now he takes a look around here in the Valencia Island telegraph station. What he finds
00:33:21surprises him. It would appear that White House had actually been using Thompson's galvanometer all along,
00:33:28like he was supposed to. How did Thompson not realize this? Was there a miscommunication somewhere?
00:33:35He couldn't say. But upon seeing that his old buddy had actually been using his instrument,
00:33:40Thompson's sentimental side takes over. Maybe Wildman had been misunderstood. Maybe he hadn't
00:33:46been doing such a bad job after all. Maybe they'd been too hasty and they ran him off too quickly without
00:33:51getting the facts straight. On August 21st, Thompson writes to the board of directors. Yes, he says it's
00:33:57true that things haven't gone great over here. Wildman shouldn't have been such a jerk to Mr. France.
00:34:02His behavior was not acceptable, but whatever errors and judgment he made could be explained by all the
00:34:08pressure he's been under. Thompson recommends that the board reverse its decision and reinstate Wildman
00:34:15White House. Thompson even wants to bring the old tool time duo back together, suggesting that he and
00:34:21White House should team up in Valencia to try to turn this project around. He also telegraphs White
00:34:26House directly in London to let him know he has his back and is trying to get the board to reconsider.
00:34:32Thanks, Wildman says. But the worst of it has not yet been revealed. Thompson would never be this
00:34:42gracious if he had any idea of what exactly Wildman White House has done.
00:34:51For starters, White House has stabbed Thompson in the back again. While it is true that he switched
00:35:04to using Thompson's mirror galvanometer, he did so in secret, which is why Thompson never knew about it.
00:35:10White House was too proud to let anyone know that he'd given up on his own stupid instruments to the
00:35:15extent that he actually appears to have forged the record. Upon receiving messages on Thompson's
00:35:21device, he would have an assistant turn around and print them out word for word on the White House
00:35:26device and send that to the board, thus perpetuating the lie that his equipment was working as advertised.
00:35:32Maintaining this lie meant enormous consequences and single-handedly explains why Newfoundland had so
00:35:38much more trouble receiving his messages. Since he didn't tell them, they had no idea they should have
00:35:44been switching out their own devices accordingly. They were still trying to use White House's
00:35:48crappy instruments to read signals. It would seem that White House was willing to risk dooming this
00:35:52entire project for the sake of preserving a lie, a lie that obviously and inevitably was gonna be found
00:35:58out one way or another eventually. There's really no explanation for this logic behind the simple
00:36:03observation that Wildman White House is an idiot.
00:36:06And even that was not the stupidest thing he did.
00:36:16Even outside of the context of this transatlantic cable, the mirror gallinometer is a brilliant and
00:36:21elegant device. But what makes it so perfect for this application is its ability to detect the weakest
00:36:27and most negligible of currents. Which means, of course, that you can send smaller currents that won't
00:36:33overwhelm the cable. But a Tim sees no value in that. A Tim understands quantity and nothing else.
00:36:47Come on now, that's a girl drill. We need a man drill, don't we?
00:36:52A Tim equates quantity with masculinity. A Tim assigns masculinity to, say, an electromagnetic steel yard
00:36:58or a 6.8 amp power drill. But Tim, this is the proper tool.
00:37:03And Al is agnostic as to how masculine a thing is or is not. He is only concerned with finding the
00:37:09proper solution. Yeah, I bet it is, Al. You know, men, we want a job done right and we want it done
00:37:14quick. What do we need? And an Al, more often than not, is shouted down and shut out.
00:37:21Consequently, ruin befalls Tim when there's no Al to save him from his own impulses.
00:37:261,400 RPM, 6.8 amp.
00:37:32Left to his own devices, Tim's only answer, Wildman White House's only answer, is more power.
00:37:43Thompson had originally intended the signals to be powered by a Daniel Cell battery, the most common
00:37:48and reliable type of battery in this time. It stands about a foot tall, it packs a decent punch,
00:37:53it's capable of shooting a current across these hundreds of miles of cable that is frankly very
00:37:57weak. But again, that ought to be fine because his mirror galvanometer can easily pick it up.
00:38:03White House, without consulting Thompson, without consulting anybody, wire together dozens of these
00:38:09Daniel Cell batteries. At least 25, sometimes as many as 50. This alone actually wouldn't be so terrible.
00:38:17But White House connected all of these batteries to his induction coils. Now, what an induction coil
00:38:24does is pull power from a DC power source, such as a battery, and it charges itself up until it is
00:38:30capable of outputting enormous voltage. We don't have any photographs or illustrations of the exact coils
00:38:38White House used. This coil is likely a little bit different, but it gives you the basic idea.
00:38:43We do know that each of White House's coils was five feet long. Based on what I've read, these might
00:38:51have been, as of 1858, the largest induction coils built anywhere on Earth. These coils, in fact, are among
00:38:58the hardware that cost the company so much money that there was nothing left for Thompson. Not that Thompson
00:39:04ever needed that much, especially not in the voltage department. Thompson's estimation of exactly how much
00:39:08power would suffice seems to have shifted over time. At one point, he seems to have reckoned that a single
00:39:13Daniel Cell would be enough to carry a signal across the ocean. A Daniel Cell was itself the original
00:39:19basis for the unit of measurement known as the volt, so we're talking about one volt here. A volt is not
00:39:25a measure of energy itself, but rather how quickly and forcefully that energy is pushed out. A couple years
00:39:31later in 1860, Thompson wrote that a maximum of 20 Daniel cells would have been acceptable.
00:39:36That's 20 volts, which is still pretty modest. For comparison's sake, a standard American power
00:39:41outlet supplies 120 volts. If you have something like a big heavy-duty window air conditioner unit,
00:39:47it probably asks for 230 volts. White House's configuration, of course, maxed out at 50 Daniel cells,
00:39:55not 20, but the coil was what really spiked it into oblivion. It should be emphasized that Thompson
00:40:04expressly warned against using a coil in the first place. So how many volts did White House actually
00:40:11produce? Thousands. The number most commonly thrown out there is 2000, a catastrophic number of volts,
00:40:20no doubt. But this figure isn't very well sourced. It's possible that someone once wrote that White
00:40:26House generated, quote, thousands of volts and someone took that to mean 2000 volts and that's
00:40:30the number that stuck. In a footnote from his book, Imperial Science, Bruce J Hunt points to a passage from
00:40:37the Joint Committee report in which somebody who tested the coils testified that the voltage was 10,000 to
00:40:4315,000 volts. This, again, when Thompson felt that any more than 20 volts would be irresponsible.
00:40:5410,000 to 15,000 volts. This is enough to throw an electrical charge over an empty span of air. It is
00:41:04more than enough to throw somebody across the room and kill them. Thankfully it didn't do that, but if it
00:41:09can do that to us, what chance does a little 22 and a half gauge wire stand? It's essentially speaker
00:41:16wire. It's imperfect. It's of varying purity from mile to mile. It's surrounded by equally imperfect
00:41:23organic insulation. It's so delicate. It needs our help. It needs us to understand it if it's going to
00:41:31faithfully carry our signals and survive. It's our poor little guy. It's our little friend, the one ship
00:41:38hands treated with such love and care as they laid it across the ocean floor. Even the most grizzled
00:41:44sailors aboard worried over it and paced and wrung their hands just hoping it would stay in one piece,
00:41:49hoping it would be okay. Remember? Oh, you don't remember, do you? You don't remember because you
00:41:55called in sick for every single voyage, didn't you? You demanded far more from this little tiny cable
00:42:01than you could ever expect of yourself.
00:42:06Upon receiving this cable on Valencia Island, Whitehouse immediately connected this poor little
00:42:11wire to these 25 to 50 batteries and gigantic induction coils and prepared to slam
00:42:17thousands of volts of morse code across it. Even if it did not threaten to fry the cable,
00:42:22it never would have worked the way Whitehouse hoped it would. There was no excuse for this. Nobody advised
00:42:28him to do this. On the contrary, Thompson had already perfectly demonstrated what was possible with
00:42:34his modestly powered system. Whitehouse ignored all his findings and in order to burnish his own
00:42:39legend, in order to prove the superiority of his masculine little trinkets, he decided that he could
00:42:45brute force the immutable laws of nature themselves. That he could bully the universe and shake its
00:42:50principles out of its pockets like they were its fucking lunch money. Whitehouse took to the coil and
00:42:55slammed this cable with thousands of volts for days over and over and over and over. How could anybody
00:43:03be this stupid? And what you first utter as an exasperated rhetorical question might be interesting
00:43:11to answer in earnest as best we can. What was he thinking? Tim's passion project throughout the entire run
00:43:20of the show was his 1933 Ford Roadster, which I never really got as a kid. Why a hot rod? It's a silent
00:43:28generation nerd mobile. Sure, it had a V8 engine and it was loud, but some casual forum browsing tells
00:43:33me that the zero to 60 time of a stock 33 Roadster was about 15 or 20 seconds, maybe even more. The worst
00:43:40car you've ever driven probably would have smoked it. It didn't even make a lot of sense as a nostalgia
00:43:44play since Tim Taylor was born decades after its production run. But he loved it because it was loud and more
00:43:50crucially because it was his. Relatively speaking, it may not have been that powerful, but it sounded
00:43:56powerful and by way of his endless tinkering and fussing over it, he was able to feel that he did
00:44:02that, that he produced that power. It's become more and more difficult for us to claim ownership of our
00:44:08machines because as they become more sophisticated, we inevitably become more and more passively along
00:44:14for the ride. That's the price of admission for technology that's vastly superior in almost every
00:44:19respect, a price that some of us are happier to pay than others. This shift has largely occurred
00:44:24between the 1990s and the present day, but Wildman Whitehouse caught what was probably the first wave
00:44:29of this phenomenon way back in the 1850s. This cable required new logic. It rewarded less power,
00:44:36not more because power, in its more abstract definition, was no longer a matter of quantity.
00:44:42An idea, the most powerful of all human creations, can be shot to another hemisphere at the speed of light,
00:44:48or at least so close to the speed of light that the difference doesn't matter. Nothing could be
00:44:52more powerful than that, but to harness that power the voltage must be weak. So weak that it barely
00:44:58nudges a little thread of silk on the opposite continent. All of a sudden things were upside down,
00:45:04brute forcing no longer worked, and in fact was the very worst thing you could do. It was a new world
00:45:10that a man like Wildman Whitehouse was not ready for. He seemed to have forgotten the spirit behind the
00:45:16entire enterprise. A global telecommunication network is, by definition, an acknowledgement
00:45:21that we all need and rely on one another. That the community, the network, is bigger than the self.
00:45:28Because otherwise, what are we building this for? So the thing that was required on his part was a
00:45:33signing away of his personal ownership. A sacrifice of his individual conquest. An admission that he was a
00:45:41small part of the whole. He refused. He wanted it to be his. He wanted it to feel his power and bend to
00:45:49his logic. He wanted to own it. And when it refused to be owned, he fried it to death.
00:45:55It wasn't immediate. After Wildman was finally removed from his post, the others treated this brave
00:46:13little cable with the care and respect it had always deserved. It stayed together and passed
00:46:18along its currents as best it could for as long as it could. It's somewhat amazing that it lasted as long
00:46:24as it did, but all the abuse has finally caught up to it. By the end of August, signals are fading fast.
00:46:30On September 1st, the day of Cyrus Field's parade that shuts down Manhattan,
00:46:35the cable dies in the middle of transmitting a message from George Sauer to Field, and it never comes back.
00:46:54So
00:47:06It won't surprise you to hear that the supposed fault in the cable near the shore, and one
00:47:28that White House was certain was the problem, never existed at all.
00:47:37This cable's existence was justified by the unheralded and ingenious work of Alfred
00:47:42Bale, who died young without ever reaping the benefits of his code.
00:47:46The groundwork was laid by people like Frederick Gisborne and his Mi'kmaq companions who braved
00:47:50deadly terrain in pursuit of a future none of them could quite see yet.
00:47:54The cable was strung into incomprehensible lengths by hundreds of people whose names we will
00:47:58never know.
00:47:59It was taken to sea by sailors who nearly died trying to protect it, who refused to throw
00:48:04it overboard even at the risk of their own lives, who cared so much for it and placed so many
00:48:09of their hopes and dreams in it that they almost humanized it and wept in shame when they broke
00:48:14it.
00:48:15The sacrifices had been made.
00:48:16The miracles had already been performed.
00:48:19The hard parts were done.
00:48:20For about two or three precious weeks, humanity had vaulted into the future.
00:48:26We were able to send messages across the ocean to the other side of the planet, one of the
00:48:31foremost definitional qualities of modern life.
00:48:35We had it.
00:48:36For a couple weeks.
00:48:38And then we were all thrown right back into the Stone Age.
00:48:41It turned out that the most daunting barrier of all, more unforgiving than the storms or
00:48:46the salt water or the logistical nightmares or the confounding properties of electricity
00:48:51or anything else, was the relentless stupidity that inhabited a man named Wildman Whitehouse.
00:48:59Nothing could survive that.
00:49:05Whitehouse demonstrates that being stupid, pure, industrial grade tool man stupid is not simply
00:49:11a matter of not knowing things.
00:49:14It's not even about having the opportunity to know things and turning it down.
00:49:17I mean a lot of us are busy, you know?
00:49:19Instead, it's about knowledge being served up to you on a silver platter, in his case enjoying
00:49:24the company of experienced professionals as well as one of the greatest scientists in the
00:49:28world, and turning down that enormous privilege because you have decided you know more than
00:49:32they do.
00:49:33This kind of stupid, the kind that's inseparable from one's ego, is the kind of stupid you cannot
00:49:38fix.
00:49:39Whitehouse has aggressively resisted learning a single thing throughout his entire six-year
00:49:42career in electrical telegraphy, so of course, the aftermath of the transatlantic
00:49:46cable's failure is no different.
00:49:48He spends all of September trying to defend himself, continuing to insist that he was right
00:49:52all along and that it was actually everybody else's fault.
00:49:55This confidence, this pride, has not been earned.
00:49:59Where does it come from?
00:50:00We could ask the same question of Tim.
00:50:02By season three, it's pretty well established that Tool Time is a complete farce of a TV
00:50:06show that nobody should take seriously, but when Tim's son Randy jokes about it, Tim gets
00:50:11oddly defensive.
00:50:12Tool Time puts clothes on your back and food on your stomach, alright?
00:50:16Look at me when I'm talking to you.
00:50:17Tim's a clown.
00:50:18His own son understands this, everyone understands this, except for Tim.
00:50:22What could Randy possibly have said to set Tim off like this?
00:50:25Well earlier in the episode, Tim installs an intercom system in the house.
00:50:30It's one of the many spiritual descendants of the telegraph, one of the funnier ones actually,
00:50:33that exploded in popularity only to nearly instantly be rendered useless by cell phones.
00:50:38While working on the intercom, Tim inadvertently hears Randy talking about Tool Time with his
00:50:43friend.
00:50:44Brief content advisory, what you're about to hear is an absolutely devastating insult.
00:50:48I deliberated for some time over whether or not to censor the footage or perhaps avoid
00:50:53using it entirely.
00:50:54Ultimately, I did make the decision to allow it to play uncensored, so if you have children
00:50:59present in the room with you, or if you'd rather just not expose yourself to it, then
00:51:03you are welcome to skip a few seconds forward.
00:51:06Thank you, and we can now play the clip.
00:51:08Boy, your dad's funny.
00:51:10I wish my dad was like that.
00:51:12No, you don't.
00:51:13My dad's a total goofball.
00:51:15Ever see Tool Time?
00:51:17I thought all those scoops were just an act.
00:51:19Are you kidding?
00:51:20They're thinking of changing the name of the show to Fool Time.
00:51:32Tim disintegrates upon hearing that Tool Time is more like Fool Time.
00:51:37This is a Tim we aren't at all used to seeing.
00:51:39We are witnessing a man annihilated.
00:51:43Wildman Whitehouse, obsessed with his fame and reputation, keeps his ear to the newswire.
00:51:48Cyrus Field, after enjoying one last hurrah in the form of that New York City parade,
00:51:53finally makes it known that the cable will soon be dead, if it isn't already.
00:51:56He and the other directors of the Atlantic Telegraph Company have decided that Wildman
00:52:01will shoulder the blame.
00:52:03In fact, many in the press have already done so, scapegoating Wildman, suspecting that
00:52:07all his supposedly superior methods are useless, calling him childish, and reporting that his
00:52:11experiments alone cost the company $176,000, which again would be well over $5 million today.
00:52:19The world is convinced that Tool Time is indeed more like Fool Time, and they're right.
00:52:25The cable's failure is most directly Whitehouse's fault.
00:52:28He's a fraud, a farce, and he's the only person who does not accept this as true.
00:52:33So rather than simply take his medicine and retreat, he fights back, hard.
00:52:38And if we think of this telecommunications network as the proto-internet, we can also
00:52:42consider Wildman to be its proto-poster.
00:52:45By reading things on the wire that make him mad, and by shooting his own words at volume
00:52:49back into the wire, he is among the very first people ever to be mad online.
00:52:53Every neighbor you've ever seen who posts 95-thesis-style proclamations on Nextdoor, every member of a
00:52:59college football message board who posts 65 angry things a day and has since 2007, every
00:53:04social media paladin who keeps replying to you a week after you've muted them, all these
00:53:08keepers of the flame can trace their spiritual lineages directly back to Wildman Whitehouse.
00:53:15Whitehouse's posting throughout the month of September 1858 is truly heroic in magnitude.
00:53:21Having lost all relevant allies and friends, it is up to him to single-handedly convince
00:53:25the world that Tool Time is in fact not more like Fool Time.
00:53:30His opening salvo is completely unprovoked and preempted.
00:53:33George Sauer, secretary of the Atlantic Telegraph Company, rips off the band-aid and, with great
00:53:37pain, announces to the world that the cable is no longer functioning.
00:53:41He admits that they have no timetable to offer as to when or if it will work again.
00:53:45Sauer doesn't mention Whitehouse, he doesn't even take any subtle swipe at him.
00:53:49Nonetheless, Whitehouse, the least qualified person on earth to say I told you so, fires
00:53:53off a big thousand word long I told you so in response.
00:53:57I think he thinks the fault they're talking about is the fault he was sure was there.
00:54:01They're actually talking about the catastrophic damage Whitehouse inflicted with his induction
00:54:05coils and are, for now, nice enough to not publicly blame him for.
00:54:09Within this prolonged response, Whitehouse mostly just whines and complains about how
00:54:12he deserves no blame and everybody else in the company failed him.
00:54:16Sauer has little choice but to respond but he keeps it brief a few days later on the 11th.
00:54:20He says only that Whitehouse's claims are vastly false except for the few garbled portions
00:54:24that are too unintelligible to be either true or false.
00:54:27Whitehouse's letter was, quote, read with much astonishment in this place.
00:54:32There is nothing a true poster hates more than a succinct response.
00:54:35If you just laugh at him, if you aren't as mad as they are, they can't take that shit.
00:54:39Sends him up a wall.
00:54:40Whitehouse's initial reply to this is a 400 order that calls the board of directors negligent
00:54:45and incompetent.
00:54:53Later in the month, he submits a 3500 order to the British Association for the Advancement
00:54:58of Science in which he shares all his supposed learnings about submarine telegraphy.
00:55:02But aside from one veiled shot at the end, he mostly holds his fire.
00:55:05Maybe he's finally giving it a rest.
00:55:08Nope.
00:55:09The London Daily News, September 20th.
00:55:11Can you spot where exactly on this page Wildman Whitehouse's letter is printed?
00:55:16Should be pretty easy because it's almost the entire page.
00:55:20By my count, it runs 9003 words.
00:55:25So what we'll do now is break this down paragraph by paragraph in order to...
00:55:28I'm just...
00:55:29I'm fucking with you.
00:55:30We're not doing that.
00:55:35The London Daily News, nine days later on September 29th.
00:55:40Another letter from Wildman Whitehouse that totals another 8,759 words.
00:55:46I promise we're not gonna read any of this one either except for this one little passage
00:55:51that gives you a taste of the martyrdom on display here.
00:55:54If science, as has often been the case, must have its victims, I will not fall the butt
00:55:59of unrefuted slander and detraction.
00:56:01I had long been aware that sinister and unseen influences were at work.
00:56:05There is a feeling in the mind of every man which tells him of forthcoming evil.
00:56:09Yet here, at least in this enterprise, it might have been hoped that unity and sincerity
00:56:12would have gone hand in hand.
00:56:14And that pretended friends should not have been so suddenly perverted into foes.
00:56:18So, he says he's a victim of science.
00:56:21He describes the rest of the company as sinister and evil menaces who conspired against him.
00:56:26He even talks about fake friends.
00:56:28This is all straight out of the loser playbook.
00:56:30Especially since, in true poster fashion, he's going on these endless rants long, long
00:56:34after his intended targets stop paying attention.
00:56:37An ocean of words that will go entirely unnoticed.
00:56:40The Atlantic Telegraph Company has not responded, and will not respond, to any of it.
00:56:51What's particularly interesting and fitting here is that there actually are a couple good points to be found in these letters.
00:56:58Throughout, he continues to point out that the directors left him to fend for himself, despite him repeatedly asking for help.
00:57:04Honestly, that is on them.
00:57:05He also, and this seems notable, charges that they never actually bothered to bring the special shore-end cable to Valencia Island.
00:57:12You remember that extra thick cable they'd built for the shores to provide it with some extra insulation?
00:57:17Whitehouse correctly points out that they never bothered to install it, and left it on the docks in England.
00:57:22Fairly damning stuff.
00:57:24Problem is, it's drowned out by an ocean of what I have counted to be a total of about 22,600 words Whitehouse wrote and published within a span
00:57:34of about three weeks.
00:57:36No one on earth read it all.
00:57:38It was my job to read it all, and I didn't read it all.
00:57:41Absolutely no one was ever going to navigate these endless torrents of complaining and rage and blame and self-pity
00:57:47for long enough to notice any good points he might have had.
00:57:50But isn't this the Wildman Whitehouse experience?
00:57:53Just as with the cable, all he understood, all he ever understands, is quantity.
00:57:59He believed he would find salvation in pure volume.
00:58:06There's a coda here, one in which Whitehouse demonstrates another common behavior of a true poster.
00:58:12Not long after stumbling out of his weeks-long rage bender, he pops back up as if none of it ever happened.
00:58:18On October 23rd, nearly two months after the cable went dead and stayed dead, and about a month after his public temper tantrum,
00:58:24he writes to the board of directors and asks for his job back.
00:58:28He says he'll finance the cable with his own money, and do whatever he can to bring it back to life.
00:58:33Look at the dateline.
00:58:34Whitehouse is back on Valencia Island.
00:58:37Aside from the telegraph station, there is nothing else to do on that island unless you own a farm.
00:58:42Nowhere else to put himself.
00:58:44What is he doing here?
00:58:45Staring sadly at the cable all day?
00:58:47Jiggling the handle on the telegraph station door?
00:58:50Go home, dude.
00:58:52George Sowerd responds,
00:58:53They told me I had to answer you, so here is me answering you.
00:58:57No.
00:58:58You cannot come back.
00:58:59Three days later, Whitehouse replies,
00:59:01Yeah, well, uh, hey, I'm in town.
00:59:04Can I, um, can I just see it?
00:59:07I bet I can fix it.
00:59:08Two days later from Sowerd,
00:59:10No.
00:59:11Fuck off.
00:59:13A week later, Whitehouse responds with a 1400 word letter, adamantly and delusionally claiming that he knows he can fix the cable that everyone but him understands is deader than dead.
00:59:30He continues to rant about the mythical faulty section of cable near the shore, still refusing to acknowledge that his 10,000 volt induction coil barbecuing had anything to do with its failure.
00:59:41The Atlantic Telegraph Company does not reply, nor do they ever acknowledge him again.
00:59:47Because, you see, he already played his part, and it's been an invaluable one.
01:00:02What the board of directors never wanted to believe, much less publicly acknowledge, was that this cable was going to die regardless.
01:00:10It was manufactured about as well as one could expect on a first try in the 1850s, but still not well enough to be viable long term.
01:00:17Cyrus Field realized this some time later after examining some unused samples of cable that had been sold off as souvenirs.
01:00:24He wrote to Thompson that in some places the wire had sunk so far off center that it was stuck in the middle of the gut of purging insulation.
01:00:31This might have been caused by a flaw in manufacturing, improper storage, damage it accrued during a near shipwreck, or all three.
01:00:38Who knows how much longer it might have functioned? Maybe months, maybe years.
01:00:42White House's electro rampages were without a doubt the most acute reason for the cable's failure,
01:00:47but they only rapidly accelerated a more or less inevitable outcome.
01:00:51Imagine if White House never arrived on Valencia Island with those induction coils,
01:00:56and the cable fizzled out unceremoniously sometime, say, a year later.
01:01:00The Atlantic Telegraph Company would be left with very poor options.
01:01:04Either they'd have to acknowledge that their cable was poorly designed and had too thin of a copper core,
01:01:09or they'd have to claim that they really did do their best,
01:01:13and that laying a viable transatlantic telegraph cable is simply not possible with present technology.
01:01:18Both answers would completely destroy any potential of raising more money in making another attempt.
01:01:24But having a fall guy? That changes everything.
01:01:27Since White House operated by his own ascientific principles, worked with his own proprietary devices,
01:01:33and was openly insubordinate, they could convincingly spin the story that this was never about the cable itself.
01:01:40It was, they could say, about one electrician who betrayed the company and went rogue.
01:01:44You could make a pretty solid argument that this was ultimately a Cyrus Field problem.
01:01:49He was the one who ordered all the substandard cable too hastily.
01:01:52He was the one who initially championed White House and gave him the job of chief electrician.
01:01:57The qualities that made him such a good bullshitter about the virtues of the cable were the exact same qualities
01:02:01that made him the master of disaster once he actually got put in charge of something.
01:02:05Of course White House deserves blame, but also deserving blame is the guy who put him there.
01:02:10But by strapping all the blame to White House and throwing him overboard,
01:02:14the entrepreneurs, scientists, and practical men alike could completely absolve themselves of responsibility.
01:02:19This wouldn't have worked with somebody of standard-issue stupidity and overconfidence,
01:02:24but Wildman was so in love with his own stupidity and imploded in such a public and humiliating way
01:02:31that investors could be convinced that he single-handedly doomed a project that was otherwise totally deserving of investment.
01:02:38In the years to follow, Cyrus Field raised more capital,
01:02:41this time accepting William Thompson's input on the design of a new transatlantic cable.
01:02:46This cable boasted the two improvements Thompson had advocated for all along,
01:02:50a significantly larger copper core and stronger insulation.
01:02:54After waiting out the Civil War and another failed expedition in 1865 that ended with a broken cable,
01:02:59they tried again in 1866 using just one gigantic ship, the SS Great Eastern, instead of two.
01:03:07The cable was laid across the Atlantic, it worked, and it lasted,
01:03:11remaining operational for more than five years before it required refurbishing.
01:03:15By that time, enough lessons were learned from this transatlantic cable to lay several more.
01:03:20Those cables, the lost 1858 cable, all the fiber optic cables that now crisscross the floors of every ocean,
01:03:27and the stubby little RF cable that hangs out of your living room wall, are family.
01:03:31Together, they form this everlasting superstructure.
01:03:36Wild Man White House single-handedly set back the progress of global telecommunications by quite some time.
01:03:52This is an oversimplification, but it's still interesting to consider that we are living in 2025 right now,
01:03:57when we should be living in 2033, were it not for Wild Man.
01:04:01Paradoxically enough, though, his load-bearing stupidity, capable of supporting enormous amounts of blame,
01:04:06was arguably what allowed it to move forward again.
01:04:09That's the confusing thing about it, Tim.
01:04:11Sometimes you need somebody to break something so completely that there's no repairing it.
01:04:16Nothing left to do but start over and build it again.
01:04:19Home Improvement ended its run in 1999.
01:04:23More than 20 years after that, the character of Tim the Tool Man Taylor was brought back
01:04:27for an episode of Tim Allen's new show, Last Man Standing.
01:04:30In one scene, a much older Tool Man introduces himself to Mike, Allen's new character.
01:04:35My hunch is that Allen initially okayed this, but maybe during table reads or something,
01:04:40he realized how little use he had for the Tool Man anymore.
01:04:43I was pretty famous myself. I had this TV show for eight years called Tool Time.
01:04:47They called me the Tool Man. Oh, oh, oh, ah.
01:04:50It's a decidedly half-hearted rendition. You can't blame him. Party's over.
01:04:54Because it was, you know, man, oh, oh, a little annoying.
01:04:58He'd served his purpose, for him and for everybody.
01:05:01Tim's have an expiration date, and since Tim was the star of Home Improvement, not merely a star,
01:05:06the show just hasn't lasted in our memories the way so many others have.
01:05:09It's rarely referenced or quoted. We just had our fun and now we're done with it.
01:05:14Here's a true story. I was writing part of this script on the couch while the TV was on.
01:05:18I have cable TV. I'm probably the youngest person in America who has cable TV by a margin of 20 years,
01:05:23but it makes you feel like you're living in a hotel. It's great.
01:05:26One thing it means is that you see a bunch of commercials and infomercials you otherwise would not.
01:05:31Like this one. On this night, I looked up for my script and unexpectedly saw an old friend.
01:05:38I'm Richard Karn, and I love my hose.
01:05:41Working blue, Al. Love it.
01:05:45He's advertising a garden hose, not a telegraph cable, but it offers some features that are Al Borland.
01:05:50William Thompson would have killed for. It has copper. Pure copper.
01:05:54Not the janky and consistent copper they used in that old cable.
01:05:57It features three layers of latex insulation and is wrapped in polymer filament.
01:06:01Synthesized materials that were eons beyond the wildest dreams of a company that had to settle for glorified tree sap.
01:06:08But all this jargon is little more than an expected song and dance.
01:06:11We don't actually care whether the copper bullet hose is any good.
01:06:14They're not selling that. They're selling Al.
01:06:17It's the best pocket hose in the world.
01:06:20The infomercial. The stomping grounds of beloved icons.
01:06:24Ron Popeil, Billy Mays, people we trust more than any president or politician.
01:06:28There is no station in American life that is more broadly respected than that of the infomercial pitchman.
01:06:34It's an institution that opens its gates for almost nobody.
01:06:37But it opened them for Al.
01:06:40Home Improvement has fallen so far off the map that unlike virtually every other sitcom of its time
01:06:45that was even somewhat popular, it's not even syndicated on TV anymore.
01:06:49But Al, despite being only a supporting character, transcended it entirely.
01:06:54We know him, love him, trust him so much that we haven't let him go.
01:06:58Unbelievably, in the end, Al won.
01:07:05William Thompson went on to win further fame, fortune, and virtually every title, honor, and award they had for a scientist and inventor.
01:07:13In 1892, upon becoming a baron, the queen allowed him to choose his own title.
01:07:17As a goof, his friends suggested the name Lord Cable.
01:07:20It sounds like he thought about it, but he ended up choosing a different title.
01:07:31There he is. There's the beard. See, folks, he really is an Al.
01:07:34Yes, William Thompson is Lord Kelvin.
01:07:39Yes, that Lord Kelvin.
01:07:41Yes, my bibliography already kind of gave that away already.
01:07:44Whatever.
01:07:45The Kelvin, the SI unit for temperature, is named after him, as are countless other things.
01:07:49Time scales, effects, theorems, inventions, awards, institutions.
01:07:53Ever since his death in 1907, he's been heralded as one of the greatest and most consequential scientists of all time.
01:07:59Anyone fortunate enough to have worked with him, to have been in his company, should have benefited enormously.
01:08:06Aside from one last brief gig, Wildman Whitehouse managed to land as a telegraph consultant,
01:08:11and being dragged before a joint committee to explain himself in 1861, he was never heard from again.
01:08:17When he died in 1890, he received a 15-word stub of an obituary in the London Times.
01:08:23The same obituary he would have received had he remained a doctor in Brighton.
01:08:32The struggle between these two is a pitched battle that has probably raged on since the dawn of civilization,
01:08:37and as long as there are people, will never end.
01:08:39We'd love to believe that Al always wins, but we know better than that. Cosmic justice is flaky.
01:08:44Here in our story, one Al has been immortalized as a legend, and one became a hero in his little corner of the world,
01:08:50but one died young, broke, and without any of the recognition he deserved.
01:08:54One Tim has entered history as a footnote just barely long enough to secure his place as one of history's signature idiots,
01:09:01and one's incessant meddling finally caught up with him later in life,
01:09:04but one became even more of a household name than Lord Kelvin himself,
01:09:08so much so that his unrelenting hatefulness and bigotry has been conveniently swept out of view.
01:09:13There will always be a Tim. Sometimes he wins.
01:09:16Whether he wields the levers of international power or is simply impossible to work with at the office,
01:09:21you and I and everyone else are made to pay the price for the lumpy, burbling cauldron of neuroses, insecurities,
01:09:26and desperation that tells him every comforting lie he needs to hear and dictates his every action.
01:09:31He is, as we saw here, and as we continue to see, capable of dimming the world's light in some way for a little while.
01:09:39One day, though, his show's run will end and he will be gone.
01:09:43So will all of us, of course. So will Al.
01:09:45The difference is that when we have each other, and when we tie ourselves together tight enough,
01:09:51none of us really, truly go.
01:09:54You and I are here because we've descended from selfless helpers, heroes, and geniuses whose names we will never know.
01:10:00People who aspire to become something greater than the self.
01:10:04This network, our network, has been built and maintained by those seeking to accrue wealth and maintain empires of one kind or another.
01:10:11We might not have built it, but we didn't design our own bodies either.
01:10:15We didn't map out our own ventricles and veins and arteries.
01:10:18They are nonetheless ours. They pump and flow because of us.
01:10:22We are what gives this thing, this superstructure, meaning.
01:10:26It's an exhibition of our love for one another and our monument to that love.
01:10:30It requires eternal replacements and repairs. It's often dense and beaten up.
01:10:35But it does not break.
01:10:38Neither will we.
01:10:40It lacks room for the harvest.
01:10:45Although there is no function andليen, it doesn't matter.
01:10:49You know?
01:10:50We have great Movies.
01:10:52We get a natural voice over here, and we lack the time.
01:10:55We move alegria into this canto quiet space.
01:10:57We can wait till death and breakfast.
01:10:58We'rellowing giggles and staring for ע shafts.
01:11:00We are open to these proximity grips.