Skip to player
Skip to main content
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Bookmark
Share
More
Add to Playlist
Report
Judas Priest and Subliminal Messages: When Heavy Metal Rocked the Courtroom
Rizzle
Follow
2 weeks ago
Category
🎵
Music
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Judas Priest and Subliminal Messages
00:02
When Heavy Metal Rocked the Courtroom
00:04
As moral panic gripped America's suburbs in the late 1980s,
00:08
heavy metal found itself in an unprecedented legal crosshairs.
00:12
The 1990 trial of Judas Priest became the music industry's most surreal courtroom battle,
00:18
testing whether artists could be held liable for tragic real-world consequences
00:22
allegedly triggered by their recordings.
00:24
The case stemmed from a devastating December 23, 1985 incident in Reno, Nevada,
00:30
where two young metalheads, James Vance and Ray Belknap,
00:33
attempted suicide after consuming alcohol and listening to Judas Priest's cover of
00:38
Better By You, Better Than Me.
00:41
The tragedy that started it all.
00:43
Ray Belknap died instantly from his self-inflicted gunshot wound.
00:47
Vance survived with critical injuries, but died several years later.
00:51
The family sued Judas Priest and CBS Records,
00:54
claiming the song contained a subliminal do-it command that triggered the suicide pact.
00:58
What followed was a three-week legal circus that captivated the music world
01:03
and terrified record executives.
01:06
The presiding judge made a crucial ruling.
01:08
Subliminal messages being unconsciously perceived don't qualify for First Amendment protection.
01:14
This decision created a legal pathway for product liability claims against musicians,
01:18
assuming plaintiffs could prove their case.
01:20
Legal Precedent and Industry Impact
01:23
Despite the judge's ruling on subliminal speech,
01:26
the court ultimately found Judas Priest not liable.
01:30
The scientific evidence simply couldn't establish that subliminal messages
01:33
could cause conduct as severe as suicide.
01:36
As the judge noted,
01:38
the scientific research presented does not establish that subliminal stimuli
01:41
can cause conduct of this magnitude.
01:44
The financial toll was significant.
01:46
Judas Priest spent $250,000 defending themselves,
01:50
while CBS was ordered to cover $40,000 in plaintiffs' costs due to procedural issues.
01:56
More importantly,
01:57
the case established a high legal bar for causation claims against musicians.
02:01
This verdict effectively ended the wave of similar lawsuits targeting rock artists,
02:06
including cases against Ozzy Osbourne.
02:08
The trial reinforced that musicians generally aren't accountable
02:11
for listeners' interpretations of their work,
02:14
safeguarding artistic expression in popular music
02:16
while acknowledging the complex relationship between art and audience.
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
Recommended
3:03
|
Up next
Judas Priest – The Story Behind Breaking The Law | Louder
Louder
2 years ago
2:07
Kim Kardashian Slammed Online After 12-Year-Old North West Reveals Finger Piercings
Rizzle
21 hours ago
2:07
Ryan Seacrest Slammed by 'Wheel of Fortune' Fans for ‘Awkward,’ ‘Lazy’ Interactions with Contestants
Rizzle
21 hours ago
2:18
10 Gardening Mistakes To Avoid If You’re Growing Jalapeño Peppers This Year
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:00
9 Signs That Mean Your Houseplants Have Root Rot
Rizzle
1 day ago
1:48
10 Gardening Tips For Growing Big Juicy Figs
Rizzle
1 day ago
1:56
10 Reasons Why Your Zucchini Leaves Are Turning Yellow
Rizzle
1 day ago
1:54
10 Gardening Mistakes To Avoid While Growing Green Beans
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:00
9 Gardening Tips For Growing Delicious Microgreens
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:14
10 Reasons Why Your Pothos Leaves Are Turning Yellow
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:13
10 Companion Plants That Are Perfect To Grow With Daylilies
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:40
10 Herbs You Can Grow At Home That Help With Digestive Health
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:10
No More Manure: 10 Vegan Fertilizer Options For Your Garden
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:09
10 Plants That Don’t Mind Being Overwatered
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:06
10 Gardening Mistakes Everyone Makes When Growing Anaheim Peppers
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:25
BossMan Dlow – “How I’m Livin”
Rizzle
1 day ago
2:09
Red Sox Eye Big Bats to Fill First Base Role
Rizzle
2 days ago
1:44
Rosie O'Donnell Opens Up About Getting Her Irish Citizenship In New Interview After Fleeing The US For Europe Because She No Longer Felt 'Safe' Following Donald Trump's Win
Rizzle
2 days ago
1:25
Jennifer Aniston Opens Up About Struggling To Get Pregnant And Slams The Media's Portrayal Of Her 'Not Wanting' Kids: 'That's Not Anybody's Business'
Rizzle
2 days ago
1:48
Demi Lovato Fans Say She 'Destroyed' Her Face After Looking Unrecognizable In New Photos And Break Down Her Potential Cosmetic Procedures: Buccal Fat Removal, More
Rizzle
2 days ago
2:18
Trump pushes false Obama claims from satirical news site
Rizzle
2 days ago
1:44
Former Trump advisor tells conservatives they’re ‘going to prison’ if Dems win
Rizzle
2 days ago
2:09
Charles and William negotiate a 'trade-off' for Andrew and Harry
Rizzle
2 days ago
1:41
Harry and Meghan 'bonded' over their 'trauma and heartbreak'
Rizzle
2 days ago
1:19
Sarah Ferguson 'discouraging' Beatrice and Eugenie from being seen with her
Rizzle
2 days ago
Be the first to comment