Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 year ago
Reports in the press this week about Australian oil supplies have triggered concerns about the country's ability to stock shelves in the event of a supply chain disruption. Along with the low supplies, there's concern Australia is failing to meet international obligations to have enough oil in case of a global emergency. Tony Wood is a Energy and Climate Change Senior Fellow at the Grattan Institute. He says he believes Australia is in a good position even though the numbers can look concerning.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00There's almost three different categories of our fuel. Remember that we have diesel, we
00:06need petrol, and we need aviation fuel, all three, and they differ to different times
00:11as to how important they'd be, particularly during COVID. Now, we have a situation in
00:16Australia where we have only two oil refineries left. We used to have about eight, one in
00:20Brisbane now and one in Geelong, and we import all of those other three products to where
00:25we need them. The government imposed, the previous government, and implemented by the
00:29current government, federally, imposed a requirement of about between 20 and 30 days supply of
00:35each of those fuels. That obligation is on the refiners and those who import fuel into this
00:41country. In addition to that, when we look at our exposure or how much we've got in stock,
00:48we also count what's on ships that are on their way to Australia. So we end up with somewhere
00:53between 20, if you look at the actual onshore, about 25 days, and if we look what's offshore
00:58closer to 45 to 50 days, and it's been up and down a bit, but that's where we are. Now,
01:03that's to do with our own domestic security. We also have an international obligation as
01:08part of something that was put in place during previous Middle East crisis, where we have
01:12to have 90 days available as our contribution to a global problem, and that's quite a different
01:17arrangement. In that case, we have an arrangement with the United States that we pay for and have
01:21fuel stored in the United States, which is closer to market, and they have the storage
01:25to be able to do that on our behalf. Just on that, on those international treaty obligations,
01:31how long has it been since Australia's been compliant with that 90-day obligation? Because
01:36it's my understanding, it's been years and years and years. Should we be concerned we haven't been
01:40able to meet that obligation? Yeah, look, we were pretty easily able to do it, I think,
01:45when we had all those refineries. We had plenty of storage on those refineries, and that gradually
01:49fell away as we closed our refineries, and we were not in compliance for a long time.
01:55Several governments have looked at this problem. They've looked at whether we need to build a huge
01:59amount of storage in Australia. But Australia is a long way from where some of these international
02:03problems could arise. And so, in some ways, it actually makes sense to do this deal with the
02:07United States, to have our contribution stored in the United States. It's been used actually once,
02:12when Angus Taylor was the Energy Minister in Australia. So, there's a debate as to whether
02:17or not that's allowed under the rules. And I guess the other point that the Australian
02:21governments of both political persuasions has made, that maybe that arrangement is actually
02:25no longer fit for purpose. Maybe what the Australian government should be doing is saying,
02:29well, rather than being suggesting or accused of not failing to meet an obligation, we should
02:36be saying, well, is this obligation still necessary? Now, of course, the global geosecurity
02:40situation today suggests maybe we should take both of these issues, the international and
02:46the domestic issue, a little bit more carefully, because you might say that stability might be
02:51more of a problem now than it was five or ten years ago. But, you know, I think broadly
02:54speaking, Australian government would say, look, we are contributing to the international
02:58situation. We do have our own domestic situation covered. But from time to time, it's worth
03:04reviewing that.
03:04Yeah. And as you said, that was a treaty that was first written up in 1974. So, maybe time
03:08for a review. We're almost out of time, Tony, but I just want to ask, because the response
03:12from some this week has been pretty alarming. I mean, Rex Patrick, for example, the country
03:17could be shut down without any shot being fired on Australian soil. Now, the government
03:22said, we are fuel secure. We've had that statement from the climate change and energy minister.
03:27But I'm just finally keen to hear your thoughts on this. Are we really that close to a situation
03:31where we won't be able to stock supermarket shelves?
03:34Look, I don't think we will. But, you know, this is about insurance. And we always like
03:39to think we've got enough insurance. And how much is enough? How much will we be prepared
03:41to pay for this? A number of people, including Senator Patrick, have been critical of where
03:46we are for many, many years, and have proposed that we should improve it. You know, the government's
03:51got to make a choice as to how much we pay for that insurance and how much are we prepared
03:55to deal with the situation. So far, it's gone well. We haven't had a problem. In fact, we've
03:59probably had fewer actual fuel shortages since we closed our refineries than when we had them
04:04opened. So I think we're in it. Personally, I think we've gone pretty well. But that doesn't
04:08mean we should be blasé about this or not concerned to make sure that, for example, is
04:14it likely there could be disruption? So it's worth reviewing. But I think the government
04:17can also say, look, we've got this under control. We will be looking at it. And we're
04:21pretty comfortable that Australia is in a good position because those numbers can look
04:26pretty alarming if you paint, you know, a catastrophic position. But we haven't seen risks of that
04:30catastrophe really at all in recent times.
04:32Always great to hear your thoughts, Tony. Thanks for joining us.

Recommended