• 1 year ago
Charlie Kirk shooting_ Firing squad a legal execution method in Utah
Transcript
00:00here to live now from Fox. I'm Andy Mack. Let's turn our attention as the DA in Utah yesterday
00:06calling it an American tragedy, the fatal shooting of conservative activist Charlie Kirk exactly a
00:13week ago on the campus of Utah Valley University. We did see some of the charges being filed
00:19yesterday, including aggravated murder, which potentially carries a being put to death. Of
00:26course, the death sentence, the death penalty in this case, in this, a man accused of it as the
00:31attorney, Jeff Gray, calling the murder American tragedy in this press conference, talking about
00:37some of these charges. Let's be joined right now by Deseret News reporter, Dennis Romboy.
00:42I appreciate your time here on Live Now from Fox. And the attorney, district attorney said he made
00:47this decision independently, saying there was real no influence from others on what they're seeking.
00:53Can you go speak to some of the history of the death penalty in Utah and what the DA is seeking
00:59in this? Yeah, so obviously the death penalty has existed in Utah for a long time. For a lot of years,
01:06you could, a defendant, a convicted killer could choose a firing squad. And then that was rescinded
01:16in 2004. So the only option was lethal injection. However, in 2015, Utah legislature reinstated the
01:26firing squad as an option only if the drugs are not available for lethal injection. And that's where
01:33the law stands currently. And how important was it for the DA there, Jeff Gray, to speak to that,
01:40saying it was an independent decision, that he read some of the facts, and that is why he's choosing
01:45to move in this direction for the sentence? Yeah, I think, you know, obviously this has been very
01:50politicized and people on both sides calling for this or for that. And I think he looked at his
01:58evidence. There were aggravating circumstances. There are probably a dozen or so aggravating
02:03circumstances under which a county attorney could file aggravated merger charges that carries a capital
02:10punishment along with it. And this fit into that category in terms of, I think they charged it under
02:18the provision that Charlie Kirk was killed by this suspect, but also he endangered the lives of other
02:25people as well. Of course, we didn't know if there's an active shooter situation right after this
02:31happened. But so that that was the way that the aggravating circumstances were charged in this case.
02:37And it's so very interesting to look at almost this on a case-by-case basis in different states
02:42and different protocols when approaching the death penalty. Can you speak to the history of that
02:47in Utah? Obviously, it's a complicated history. How would you classify it?
02:53It's complicated. You know, in Utah, there was an effort in 2022, I believe, by some Republican lawmakers
03:02to repeal the death penalty. That proposed bill failed to get out of the House committee.
03:08Since Utah was the first state to execute someone after the United States reinstated the death penalty
03:15in 1976, Utah executed Gary Gilmore by firing squad in 1977. And the state has had seven executions
03:24since then. I think three of them have been by firing squad. The remainder have been by lethal injection.
03:29And that is obviously what we're talking about here, just kind of the route in which they would do with the
03:36death penalty. And when you say firing squad, it obviously brings a graphic image to your mind. Is that a
03:42possibility in this case with the suspect, Tyler Robinson, if he is convicted?
03:47I'd say it's a possibility if, in fact, the drugs for lethal injection are not available within 30 days of the
03:55execution date. That's what the law says currently. So I would think that that would be a possibility
04:00if those drugs are not available. The last execution here in Utah was last year, 2024.
04:07That man was executed by lethal injection. The last firing squad lethal execution was in 2014, I believe.
04:16And can you speak to it at all? Because we see some of these death penalty cases in different parts of the
04:21country where the defense isn't necessarily trying to find a not guilty or kind of make them innocent
04:28in a way, but also to take the death penalty off the case. Do you believe that potentially could be
04:32the defense's move? Has that been any precedent in Utah before?
04:37Yeah, I think prosecutors have used the death penalty as a bargaining chip to say if your client pleads
04:43guilty to, you know, the charges straight up, then we'll take the death penalty off the table.
04:49That certainly could be a possibility here in this case. As you know, Mr. Robinson does not have an
04:56attorney currently, and so that issue has not been discussed publicly at this point, but I would
05:02believe that that would be on the table. All right, very good. Dennis Romboy, I appreciate your time,
05:06your insight there on this case in Utah. Thanks again.
05:10Thank you. All right, thanks so much. All right, great conversation as always. So many complex details to
05:15this live picture right now there in Phoenix, Arizona as Turning Point headquarters as the
05:21tributes continue to pour in. And I also want to put up this in Nature talking about Utah death penalty
05:26lies as this aggravated murder is the only charge eligible for the death penalty. Lethal injection is
05:32the primary method of this. Firing squad also considered a legal alternative, and Utah has executed
05:39eight men since the U.S. reinstated capital punishment back in 1976. I'm Andy Mack. We're back after this.

Recommended