00:00Hi, everybody. I'm Brittany Lewis, a breaking news reporter here at Forbes. Joining me now is
00:08Matthew Martin, Senior U.S. Economist at Oxford Economics. Matthew, thanks so much for joining me.
00:14Hi, Brittany. Thanks for having me. It's good to be back.
00:17Days before President Donald Trump's August 1st deadline, the U.S. and E.U. struck a trade
00:23agreement. And essentially what this boils down to is that they are agreeing to a 15 percent
00:27tariff rate on most E.U. goods. And President Trump described this deal as the biggest deal
00:33ever made. What do you think? What are some of your takeaways here?
00:37You know, I think it's a great question. And obviously, as we're getting more of these deals
00:42across the line, we're getting a bit more information of what, you know, the end game is for tariffs.
00:48Now, in terms of whether this is the largest deal ever, I think that's certainly up for question,
00:53mainly because the deal in itself has a plenty of lacks a fair bit of, you know, details and clarity
01:02of ultimately where it's ended up. And like its previous deals before, it's not a binding contract.
01:07So in the end, you know, we're still left with a little bit of uncertainty.
01:12And that's a similar sentiment that you gave us back in May when you and I were talking about the U.S.-U.K.
01:18framework of a deal. And you said, though, that the U.K. comes out farther ahead than the U.S.
01:24in that deal. What do you think of this one now? Based on the scant details, we know who's the winner,
01:30who's the loser? Yeah, I think first and foremost, you know, obviously, this is an escalation in tariff
01:38rates overall. So I think those who are importing goods from the EU are certainly going to see a bit
01:43of a loss there. I mean, we're moving up towards 15 percent in most sectors. You know, steel and metals
01:50are still 50 percent. So those who are importing are still going to see a higher rate. I think where
01:54the quote unquote winners will be will certainly be on the oil side. The EU had committed to buying
02:01up to 250 billion dollars of gas and oil exports from the U.S. Now, the question there is really just
02:08A, is that feasible? And B is like, how likely are they to be held to that to that contract? And
02:16when we look at the numbers, the U.S. exports somewhere around 300 billion a year in total
02:21exports. So the idea that we're going to be able to double total production and the drop of a hat
02:27seems unlikely. A lot of producers here are more tied to global oil prices and at their current levels,
02:33it doesn't make sense to really ramp up production. And so I think and then in terms of the additional
02:39investment that the U.S. agreed to, 600 billion or something of the like, you know, the EU can't
02:45really force private industry to really invest in the U.S. that they already didn't have planned.
02:50So whether that will actually come to fruition is certainly up for question. So, you know, I think
02:56the win here is that we have some more certainty around tariffs and ultimately where they're going to
03:01end up. But certainly, you know, we're going to be facing higher prices. It doesn't necessarily
03:06mean the U.S. exporters have a lot of additional market access. So, you know, it's hard to really
03:11parse through, you know, who the true wins are at the moment.
03:16I want to talk about this tariff whiplash that we've really seen since April 2nd, which President
03:21Trump dubbed as Liberation Day, because that day he threatened the EU with 20 percent reciprocal tariffs.
03:27And then since then, the threats have changed. At one point, it was 50 percent tariffs for the EU.
03:32Then it was 30 percent. And now we landed on this 15 percent for most goods from the EU.
03:38Do you think that rate is a high enough rate where businesses might say, you know what,
03:42that's too high for me? I can't do business with the United States.
03:48You know, I think it's probably, you know, when we're talking in, you know, if you'd asked me a year
03:53ago, a 15 percent tariff obviously sounded much higher. But at this point, you know,
03:58where we've seen levels come down from, this still, you know, classifies as, you know,
04:02a bit of a de-escalation in, you know, trade talks. I think where, you know, where the real
04:08focus will be is, you know, tariffs are likely here to stay. It does not seem like we're going
04:13to be going down from here. It seems like 15 percent is going to be the base layer across all
04:18countries. You know, in terms of doing business with the United States, it's not going to be like
04:22there's a lot of places to hide for U.S. importers. They're going to be facing similar levels at other
04:27countries. So I think what we're going to see is while we'll get that additional 15 percent on EU
04:34goods, at least the importers know that, you know, this is likely to be the level going forward and
04:39that there aren't going to be additional whiplashes. So I think rather than, you know, cut off the,
04:44you know, any import export from the EU, it's actually going to lead to, you know, continued
04:50trade. You know, there might be some diversion to other countries. U.S. importers might look to other
04:56sources, but at the same time, at least they now have some uncertainty that 15 percent is level.
05:02They can continue to bring them. They can pass that price along either to their customers or the
05:06consumer in the end. And we'll have that, you know, one-time price increase. And then from there,
05:11we'll kind of just move forward as, you know, business as usual, if that is the case. So
05:17there has been mixed reaction to this deal. President Trump, as you and I discussed,
05:23touted it as perhaps one of the biggest deals ever made. The markets reacted favorably to this.
05:29The European Commission president said the deal, quote, creates certainty in uncertain times. It
05:34delivers stability and predictability. But there haven't all been kind words for this deal. The
05:38French prime minister said this, quote, it is a dark day when an alliance of free peoples united to
05:44assert their values and defend their interests resolves to submission. And France's high
05:49commissioner for strategy and planning said the deal was unequal and unbalanced and Europe didn't
05:54wield its strength. We are the world's leading trading power. What do you make of that reaction?
05:59And what does that say to you as an economist? Yeah. And I think for, you know, particularly
06:05those countries in the EU, it's a fair reaction. I think that is a key kind of detail of the deal
06:11overall is that it did not include additional reciprocal tariffs in the EU. So they are essentially
06:16accepting that their goods sent to the US will have this 15 percent watermark, but that they're not
06:21going to apply anything onto US goods. And I think what that really means is, you know, ultimately,
06:27tariffs are going to be used as a sort of source of revenue here in the US, you know, as a, you know,
06:32a tax on US goods coming into the US. And they're unlikely to go anywhere once they're a solid source
06:39of revenue for the federal government. So I think ultimately what it means is that, you know, it seems
06:45like tariffs are here to stay. It seems like if you're willing to play ball with Trump, you know, if the EU is
06:50not going to put on reciprocal tariffs, it's unlikely that other countries are going to feel bold enough to
06:54do so. I mean, obviously, there's still a lot to be had with the US-China negotiations. But ultimately,
07:00you know, it seems like this is kind of the route we're heading towards.
07:04And the EU and the US have such an important trading relationship and they're huge trading
07:09partners. The Commerce Department said that last year alone, the US and EU collectively traded over
07:16$975 billion worth of goods. So what do you think that this deal really does to both economies?
07:22And what do you think this says largely about transatlantic trade?
07:27Yeah, I think, you know, at the end of the day, the additional 15% increase on EU goods is going to
07:35lead to, you know, less consumption of them overall. If it's just a more expensive good,
07:40you're less likely to consume as much. So I think what you will see is a decrease overall in trade
07:44flows, you know, particularly into the US, you know, in terms of additional market access,
07:50you know, outside the oil and gas didn't just seem to be a lot of the lease in the deal itself,
07:55a lot of additional access for US exporters into the EU. So not a lot of, you know, details that
08:02point to expansion of trade flows between the two countries or the EU and the US. So I think
08:10ultimately, this still leads to, you know, less trade. I think the upside here, again, is at least
08:16it leads to some certainty. And it removes at least some of the, you know, hesitation from
08:22doing trade is that you didn't know where tariffs were going to end up, at least for now, you know,
08:26where they are.
08:27And I think that that's a big theme, perhaps the biggest theme really since Liberation Day
08:31was this sense of uncertainty. Because as we know, President Trump has flip flopped on tariffs
08:37over two dozen times since he started his second term. This 15% rate, though, it seems like he's liking
08:44the 15% because a recent deal with Japan, they have the same tariff rate at 15%. August 1st is right
08:51around the corner here. Do you think that that 15% is going to be the baseline?
08:56Yeah, again, I think obviously we've seen some trade deals come through and they've been on major
09:01trading partners, the UK, Japan, the EU, obviously, but there's still a fair bit of countries out there
09:07that have not, you know, had a deal struck at the moment. So it does seem likely that 15% is really,
09:13you know, the starting point. For the EU, you know, there was some benefits in that it was a 15%
09:18for all goods. So that kind of brings down the total tariff on autos, pharmaceuticals,
09:24semiconductors. So, you know, I think that's where we're headed. Ultimately, I think there's going to
09:30be a much different deal struck between the US and China. I think that is a, you know, a different,
09:35you know, partnership unto itself. But for other countries, I think really, the starting point
09:40is 15%. And that we're at least the limit is 15%. And then it's about whittling down from there and
09:47getting other exemptions. And so, again, I think tariffs are here to stay. And we're going to see,
09:52you know, the average effective tariff rate in 2025 and 2026 to be much, much higher than where it was
09:58in 2023 and 2024. And we've seen the Trump administration kick the can down the road when
10:04it comes to these tariff extensions. They say a date and then they say, never mind, it's extended
10:09to X, Y, and Z. The latest extension was August 1st. But it seems like that's the drop dead date.
10:14Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick just over the weekend said, no extensions, no more grace periods.
10:20August 1st, the tariffs are set. August 1st is just a couple of days away. So what are you looking
10:25out for come August 1st? Yeah, you know, it's, we're going to be obviously paying attention come
10:33Friday, kind of figure out what are what's going to happen. I think ultimately, you know, as we saw
10:39as well over the weekend is that we're during this week is that the US and China negotiations are going
10:44to be kicked down the road. They had their, you know, expiry on their negotiations for August 12th.
10:50That looks to be moved further down the road as they try to, you know, whittle down to a deal.
10:54And I think ultimately, you're going to see a lot of that come August 1st as well. Again,
10:59the biggest deals, a lot of the biggest deals are already out of the way, obviously, EU being
11:02one of those. And so I still think the Trump administration wants to avoid, you know, the
11:08largest of economic repercussions from having these high rates of tariffs. And if he's, you know,
11:14already seeing deals come through on bigger trading partners, maybe he feels confident that,
11:18you know, smaller trade deals are going to come through as well. And so maybe he's more willing to
11:23provide additional race period for those for those deals to be struck. But again, I think we're still
11:30in a period of high uncertainty and kind of trying to predict what happens August 1st is a bit of a
11:36fool's errand, unfortunately.
11:37And I know that we're in high uncertainty. But do you think we'll get to more certain territory
11:44once that China deal is struck and is not just a framework, not just a handshake to a framework,
11:50it's actually signed, sealed, delivered?
11:52Yeah, I think that is likely the biggest piece we really need to, you know, hear from. China is
11:59obviously a large source of imports for a wide range of materials, obviously rare earths being
12:06one, but also computer electronics, but also down to your small items like toys, apparel and whatnot.
12:11And so that is going to be a key, you know, deal that needs to be struck to iron out uncertainty
12:18and really get to a place where businesses can start to plan for the future.
12:22You know, make decisions on where they're going to source goods from, where they're going to invest
12:27in production. I think that's what's really needed in order to, you know, ultimately get to a more certain
12:33period. But again, we haven't seen a ton of breakthroughs in that negotiations. It's been kicked down
12:39another from August 12th to a predetermined date. So I think we're still a bit of a long way off
12:46from that period, unfortunately.
12:49And I think that this is how a lot of the tariff conversations end, right? It's there's a lot of
12:54uncertainty. And until the next time a development comes, I'll talk to you then. And I think that's
12:59where I'm going to end it now that we have this August first date just a few days away. There's a lot
13:04to look out for between now and then. And I hope once we see more of those deals
13:09hammered out, you can join me again. Thank you so much for joining me. You are welcome back
13:13anytime. Matthew Martin.
13:15Matthew Martin Absolutely. Thanks again for having me.