Skip to playerSkip to main content
Forensic psychologist Joe Aston tackles a scientist accused of killing her boss.

Scientist Grace Hayle and her boss were working alone in the laboratory. Now he's dead and she's the only suspect in a murder case. Grace claims to have no memory of what happened and there is little evidence to go on.

David Napthine's thriller introduces Joe Aston, an expert in the controversial field of "recovered memory", as he attempts to uncover the truth.

Stars Jeremy Swift as Dr Joe Aston, Rosie Cavaliero as Grace Hayle, Carolyn Pickles as DI Karen Dennis and Colin MacLachlan as Tom Aston.
Producer: Toby Swift

First broadcast on BBC Radio 4 in 2001.


Do you enjoy the variety on Oldtuberadio?
Like, Share and Subscribe to be notified of our new shows
#radio #crime #thriller #drama
To Support this channel please visit
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/oldtuberadio
https://ko-fi.com/oldtuberadio98
https://www.patreon.com/oldtuberadio
https://locals.com/Oldtuberadio

Category

🎈
Fun
Transcript
00:00It was agreed with you and your solicitors that you'd talk to Dr. Aston.
00:11I'm not mad, you know.
00:13No one thinks you are, Miss Hale.
00:16Would you like tea brought in?
00:17That'd be nice.
00:18How'd you like it, Doctor?
00:19Milk, no sugar, thanks.
00:21I'll have coffee, please. Milk, no sugar.
00:24Right. I'll see you later, Dr. Aston.
00:26Miss Hale.
00:30Those bruises look painful.
00:35They are.
00:36How did you get them?
00:37I don't know, do I? I don't know how I got them, but they hurt like hell.
00:40Can you stop them hurting?
00:42No.
00:43Then why are you here?
00:45My job, Miss Hale, is to help people recover their memory.
00:48And how are you going to do that, Dr...
00:50Aston. But, uh, please, call me Joe.
00:53Yeah, whatever.
00:54Do you believe I've lost my memory?
00:57I don't know.
00:58So you think I'm lying.
01:00I'd like to do some tests with you.
01:01What sort of tests?
01:02Nothing complicated.
01:03What are you writing?
01:05Notes.
01:06Just to help me.
01:07Help you what?
01:08Remember.
01:11That's funny, isn't it?
01:11You can't remember, but you expect me to.
01:14I don't expect anything, Miss Hale.
01:17In a minute, I'm going to tap my fingers, and I'd like to...
01:19That's a new age crap, is it?
01:21No.
01:22They're tests that have been used by a psychologist for many years.
01:25So it's still crap, then?
01:27Is that what you think?
01:28Look, I work with verifiable data and arrive at provable and practical results.
01:33That's science.
01:34Whereas what you do is just...
01:37Mumbo-dumbo.
01:38I'm going to tap my fingers, and I wouldn't like you to...
01:42Hey, presto.
01:43My memory will come back.
01:45No.
01:47Then why do it?
01:48Why won't anyone believe that I can't remember what happened?
01:52Who says people don't believe you?
01:54They don't believe me.
01:55They?
01:55The police.
01:56We don't know that.
01:57I do.
01:58I don't.
01:58And I thought psychologists knew what made people tick.
02:01If you like, Miss Hale, I can go.
02:03And then what would happen?
02:05I don't know.
02:06What do you know?
02:07Nothing.
02:09That's why I'd like to do the tests.
02:12Is there a problem?
02:13You're hoping to trick me, aren't you, so that I'll make a confession.
02:16I'm not interested in confessions.
02:17But you work for the police.
02:18No, I work with the police.
02:20And from where I'm sitting, there's no difference.
02:22There is.
02:23Prove it.
02:24How?
02:24Well, it's up to you.
02:25You're the expert.
02:28These tests, will they help me?
02:32They'll help me work with you.
02:35All right, then.
02:38In the first test, Miss Hale, all you have to do is listen.
02:42Nothing else.
02:43Okay.
02:44Tap my fingers.
02:49Okay.
02:51That's it.
02:52What now?
02:52I'd just like to talk to you for a while.
02:55About what?
02:55I'd like to find out at what point you lost your memory.
02:58You do believe me, then?
03:00That I can't remember what happened?
03:01Yes, but I need to find...
03:02Well, will you tell them?
03:03Tell them that I'm not pissing about?
03:05Yes.
03:06He's dead, isn't he?
03:08Dr. Jones, strangled.
03:10He was asphyxiated, yes.
03:12Oh, I wouldn't be here if it was an accident.
03:14I know that.
03:16They said I was the only one in the clean room when it happened.
03:19Is that right?
03:21It would seem that way.
03:22So I'm the only suspect.
03:23Or the only witness.
03:24What do you think?
03:25It doesn't matter what I think.
03:27Well, that's a shame.
03:29And why is that?
03:29Because you believe me.
03:32Oh, it's a blank.
03:33It's empathy.
03:34I...
03:34I keep saying...
03:35I keep saying that I don't remember anything.
03:38And you believe me.
03:40Just tell them I'm not lying.
03:42Oh, tell them what they need to know.
03:43And then what?
03:44We'll find out how much you can remember.
03:47There you go.
03:48Thank you, Constable.
03:49Just put it on the table.
03:52Thanks.
03:53I'll just be outside, Doctor.
03:54Uh-huh.
04:00I'll tell you something, shall I?
04:02What?
04:02They've brought me tea instead of coffee.
04:05Oh, I'll see if I can get it.
04:06Forget it.
04:06Forget it.
04:06There's not much difference, anyway.
04:09So, Miss Hale.
04:11Grace.
04:12I prefer to be called Grace.
04:13You calling me Miss Hale all the time.
04:15It sounds...
04:16Well, it's a bit uncomfortable.
04:18Okay.
04:19Grace.
04:20Tell me something about the day before yesterday.
04:25Well, I can't remember.
04:26Anything at all?
04:27I don't get this.
04:28I don't...
04:29I don't get what this is about.
04:31I've said I can't remember.
04:32Well, do you remember getting up in the morning?
04:35Yeah, well, of course I remember getting up in the morning.
04:37And going to work?
04:39Yes.
04:41You are trying to catch me out, aren't you?
04:43Let something slip that shows I've not really lost my memory.
04:47That's it, isn't it?
04:48Because it's the same questions as before.
04:50It's the same words, but with a different tone.
04:52I need to find out at what point you lost your memory, that's all.
04:54And then help you retrieve what has been lost.
04:57But, Grace, I can't make you do anything you don't want to do.
05:00What if I did kill him?
05:04And what if I didn't?
05:07What if I saw who killed him?
05:09What if they saw me?
05:10Is it better to be like this?
05:14Not remembering?
05:16I can't answer that.
05:18Because I'm tired and I'm scared.
05:20Hmm.
05:22Will I feel better if I remember?
05:24I can't answer that.
05:26Or will it be worse?
05:27Your memory could come back at any time, whether you want it to or not.
05:32Is that right?
05:33Yes.
05:34And is that good?
05:35That's not for me to say.
05:36So, it's better if it comes back here with you.
05:40Is that what you're saying?
05:42Quite possibly.
05:43Dr. Joe Aston, talking with Grace Hale.
05:48Are you recording this?
05:49Yes.
05:49Why?
05:50So I can listen to it later.
05:52Yeah, to catch me out.
05:54Grace, I have no interest in catching you out.
05:56Then why record it?
05:58We'll talk about a lot of things, and one of us might say something that on reflection may well give us a way back into your memory.
06:05Why should I trust you?
06:07Because I'm a doctor.
06:08Dr. Joe Aston, talking with Grace Hale.
06:1514.20 hours, Saturday the 13th.
06:19Grace, you have agreed to a series of interviews that will have been recorded, and you've agreed that these can be held without the presence of your solicitor.
06:27Now, have you agreed to...
06:30They'll be used to assist the police in their investigations.
06:32Oh, so you are helping them.
06:33No, but our conversations might.
06:36Right. So, have you agreed to these interviews?
06:41Yes.
06:44Now, Grace, I'd like you to describe your typical working day.
06:51Grace.
06:51Why?
06:52I'm interested.
06:53You'd be better off getting a life.
06:55Tell me about your journey to work.
06:56Oh, I'm sorry, I'm too tired for this.
06:58You look tired.
07:00Then why make me do it?
07:02It'll help.
07:03How?
07:04Give it time.
07:05I use the A66.
07:09Do you know it?
07:10Mm-hmm.
07:12And it was raining, wasn't it?
07:13I hate driving when it's like that.
07:15It's the spray from the lorries.
07:16Can't see properly.
07:17Mm.
07:19What happens when you arrive at work?
07:22I sign in.
07:23And you did that the derby for yesterday?
07:25I do that every day.
07:26We all do.
07:27I show them my identity card, and then I sign the book.
07:31They all know me about the masters.
07:32Not so many people working there as they used to be, but, you know, parts of the site don't
07:39seem to have anyone there.
07:40It's a bit like a ghost town, really.
07:42It's changed a lot.
07:43Do you know it?
07:44My uncle worked there.
07:46Oh, what did he do?
07:47Not sure.
07:48But me, my mum, and Auntie Jean would be walking to the shops, and my auntie would stop and
07:54sniff the air, you know, and she'd say, smell that too, and there'd be this acrid stink,
07:59you know.
08:00And she'd say, your Uncle Tom's responsible for that.
08:03Even now, I'm not sure whether I was supposed to be proud of him or not.
08:07Well, it's different now.
08:08I know.
08:16Come in.
08:18Oh, Dr. Aston.
08:19I wasn't expecting you just yet.
08:21How'd it go?
08:23It's early days, Karen.
08:24Not for us, it isn't.
08:26Sit down.
08:27She's very tired, so I didn't push it.
08:30Given her facial bruising, it looks like there's been damage to the temporal frontal
08:34lobe.
08:35What did the doctor say?
08:36That she was severely concussed.
08:38Which has given rise to amnesia.
08:40Well, that's certainly what the tests indicate, but the moment I don't know the extent of her
08:45memory loss.
08:46Did she tell you how the bruising happened?
08:48No.
08:49But she has lost her memory.
08:50It would seem so.
08:52Were Dr. Jones and Grace definitely the only two in the clean room?
08:56Has she told you there was someone else?
08:58She hasn't told me anything.
09:01Can her memory be recovered?
09:03Yes.
09:03When?
09:04I don't know.
09:05Right.
09:06Come in.
09:10Sorry to disturb you, ma'am, Dr. Aston.
09:12I just thought you'd like to see the latest from Forensic, ma'am.
09:14Ah, any use?
09:16Not much.
09:17How are you getting on with Grace, Doc?
09:19As expected.
09:20Anything that might help?
09:21I'm sure that as soon as Dr. Aston has something helpful, he'll tell us.
09:24I'll be very interested to see what you come up with, Doc.
09:26Sure.
09:27Do you know much about my area of work?
09:29Do you fancy a drink when you're done?
09:30We like to nip over the road and throw a dart at a picture of David Blunkett.
09:34I'd like to meet first thing tomorrow, Doctor, to see the progress you've made here.
09:39Of course.
09:40Maybe another time, Jeff.
09:42I look forward to it.
09:43Then we can make an application to hold Grace Hale for another 24 hours.
09:46That should be straightforward, ma'am.
09:47I'd rather not take anything for granted.
09:50I wonder if you could get a couple of things for me.
09:52I'd like a complete set of overalls from the clean room and a recording of the air conditioning system.
09:59What for?
10:00Visual and oral stimuli.
10:01I'll get that for you, Dr. Aston.
10:03Tomorrow morning.
10:05I'll carry on then.
10:08Right.
10:09Thanks a lot, Dr. Aston.
10:09Don't say a thing, Jeff.
10:14Does he reckon she's really lost her memory, then?
10:16Yes.
10:17You saw it in there.
10:18It must have been a fight.
10:19Well, with no fingerprints.
10:20No memory, apparently.
10:22We have to rely on Dr. Aston.
10:24Is he any good?
10:25He has a considerable reputation.
10:27As an academic?
10:28Well, the assistant chief constable rates him and that's all we need to know.
10:31When our killer speaks, I'm sorry.
10:34It's a trial period, Jeff, to see if his expertise helps us.
10:38That at the moment is our best bet.
10:40If he does make her remember, how will we know that what she's remembering is the truth?
10:45I've no idea.
10:51So now you're actually doing something, are you moving out of Misery Street?
10:54Aye, come on, Tom.
10:56I've not been that bad, have I?
10:57Your Auntie Jean reckons he's sickening for Helen.
11:00It's just strange being back in Middlesbrough, that's all.
11:03Aye, but you and Helen are all right.
11:05Aye, aye, aye.
11:06There's nothing for you to worry about.
11:07Aye, aye.
11:08It's your Auntie Jean that's worried, not me.
11:11So when's Helen moving up, then?
11:13Let's just see how this trial period with the police goes.
11:17I've been trying to explain to your Auntie Jean what you do.
11:20I mean, I know it's to do with people losing their memory, but when it comes to saying how
11:24you actually walk with it, the coppers, where you get lost off.
11:28Oh, right.
11:28Well, people can't always remember what happened when a crime's been committed, so they...
11:33Especially when they did it, eh?
11:35Aye, amnesia can be genuine, Tom.
11:37Why, it's excuses, man.
11:39I can't remember.
11:41I was stressed.
11:42I got depressed when me cat joined the masons.
11:45You're people that do out to avoid consequences.
11:48Human nature.
11:49Well, you're a shrink.
11:50You should know about human nature.
11:52It's complicated.
11:53Right and wrong, isn't it?
11:55So are you on the side of the rogues or the coppers?
11:58I don't take sides.
12:00Well, you've got to take sides.
12:02Well, you used to with every opportunity.
12:04Or did you just sell socialist worker because he had to have some excuse to wear a combat
12:08jacket and a woolly hat?
12:10Do you want one?
12:11I've stopped.
12:12What?
12:12Even the happy tabs?
12:13Hey, hey, hey.
12:14And you work for the coppers now.
12:15Aye, tshush, man.
12:17So are you coming to the match, then?
12:19Aye, of course.
12:21Ah, who's round with it?
12:22I can't remember.
12:24Convenient.
12:25So I can tell your auntie, Jane, that you and Helen are all right.
12:28Aye, well, fine, man.
12:32Oh, they loved this club, didn't they?
12:34Mum and Dad.
12:35Loved it.
12:37Remember that time Dad broke his arm and Mum said...
12:40I could stink, you know.
12:43And she'd say, your Uncle Tom's responsible for that.
12:47Even now, I'm not sure whether I was supposed to be proud of him or not.
12:51What is this, Doctor?
12:52An oral history project?
12:54It's the start of building a relationship, Karen.
12:57Then I can find out how much memory's been lost and establish a context and a timeline.
13:02How long will this take?
13:04How long is a piece of string?
13:05That's no help, Dr Aston.
13:06It's other evidence that will establish whether she's guilty or not.
13:09Unless she confesses.
13:10Whether that will mean anything or not is another thing altogether.
13:13Don't forget she's in trauma.
13:16The bank of the head damaged the brain, not severely, but enough.
13:21Add to that whatever happened in the clean room, which must have been unpleasant, and the brain will shut down as protection.
13:27Interrogation doesn't help either.
13:29She was interviewed, Doctor, by two very experienced officers, and in strict accord with PACE regulations.
13:34I don't doubt that.
13:36Nothing on towards happened.
13:37I know.
13:37That's the way I work.
13:39I know.
13:40I'll move as quickly as I can.
13:42This stuff I asked for, right?
13:45Yeah, first thing.
13:47At least, if the amnesia's genuine, permission to detain her for longer might be easier.
13:52Good.
13:53Want one of these?
13:55Is this a bribe?
13:56I've stopped smoking.
13:58These are my favourite.
13:59I have to race the kids to get these.
14:02How many kids?
14:03Two.
14:04I'm the wicked stepmother.
14:06What sense wicked?
14:07Well, it depends on what I bribe him with.
14:09What flavour do you like?
14:11Nicotene.
14:12Oh, I'm sorry, Karen, but I can't make memory conform to legal procedures.
14:18I've got to be careful about planting suggestions, because the slightest hint of that and a half-decent defence lie will make mincemeat of me.
14:24I'm too young to face that kind of trauma.
14:27Oh, you'd be fine, Doctor.
14:28You'd just block it from your memory.
14:30Oh, God.
14:31Look, I'd like you to come to a briefing at some point, when you feel you've made progress.
14:38Right.
14:39Is there a problem?
14:40Would you want me to play the recordings at the briefings?
14:43Of course, if you think they'll be useful.
14:46I'd like to think they will be.
14:48You're a member of the team, Doctor.
14:50Good.
14:50Well, that's why I'd like you at the briefing.
14:52I don't want to waste anybody's time, and I don't want what I do misinterpreted.
14:56It could make things more difficult.
14:57This is a good team, Doctor.
14:59We're experts at what we do.
15:01So am I.
15:02Well, then we should trust one another.
15:04I'd like you to show me how you dress at work.
15:10What do you mean?
15:11Would you mind putting these on?
15:13You've got a thing about overalls, have you?
15:16There are many techniques to help recover the memory, Grace.
15:18This is just one of them.
15:19I haven't played Let's Pretend since I was a kid.
15:22I reckon we play Let's Pretend all the time.
15:24You want a sweet?
15:25No, thanks.
15:26Tell me about Dr. Jones.
15:29He was a shit.
15:31He gave me a hard time when he was breathing, and he's giving me a hard time now.
15:37The bruises?
15:39They're painful.
15:41Could he have fallen?
15:42I've never done it before.
15:44Well, you got the bruises in the clean room.
15:46Or afterwards.
15:48About Dr. Jones.
15:49I couldn't stand the man.
15:50I told the police that.
15:52Did you?
15:52They don't tell you much, do they?
15:55That they trust you.
15:57Give me an example of your relationship with Dr. Jones.
16:00I've told you.
16:02Any particular incident that sticks in your mind?
16:06Last Wednesday, I think it was, I queried something.
16:10I reckon that he might have made a mistake with his figures.
16:12Not much, but enough.
16:15I pointed this out, and do you know what he did?
16:19He just leaned back in his chair, smiled, and said,
16:21I think you'll find that the fault is not with the figures.
16:24Were the figures wrong?
16:25Yeah, of course they bloody well were.
16:27So I had to go over them again and again.
16:29I got them right in the end.
16:32He patronised, he bullied, he blocked me all the time.
16:36I was brighter than him.
16:38I could easily have been heading the programme, and he knew it.
16:42All right.
16:42He wasn't going to retire, and I wasn't about to take over, but he wouldn't encourage you.
16:47He'd take the credit, but never the blame.
16:49Right, I've got the overalls on.
16:53Now, do you just walk straight into the clean room?
16:55No.
16:56It's sensitive work, so there can't be any trace of dust or germs.
16:59You go into the gowning room first.
17:02You step onto a tacky mat that sort of pulls the bigger lumps of dirt from your shoes,
17:07and then you put the gloves, hats, mask, and shoe covers on.
17:12You swing your legs over the low wall that separates you from the clean area, and you step in...
17:17Could you have fallen getting over the wall?
17:19No.
17:20Then you step into an air shower, which blows loose dirt off the gown.
17:24And that's what you did three days ago?
17:26That's what I do every day.
17:28What's a clean room like?
17:30Clean?
17:32Can you talk to each other?
17:33Not easily.
17:34The airs change constantly, so there's this continuous noise.
17:38Can I get out of these now?
17:39When did you take them off?
17:41When I left the clean room.
17:42I was in everyday clothes when Don found me in the canteen.
17:45Don?
17:46Don Turner, the security guard.
17:48They really do keep you in the dark, don't they?
17:53So, you must have taken them off.
17:56Yep.
17:57Can you remember where?
17:59In the changing room, I expect.
18:02I'd like to know how you take them off.
18:03Why?
18:04I'm building up a picture.
18:05This is either silly or perverted.
18:07That bag's the incinerator bin, and that one is the laundry bin.
18:11Do it at the speed you normally do.
18:13I've come out of the clean room and stepped over the wall.
18:19I take off the gloves, and then the mask.
18:22The gloves go in the incinerator bin, along with the hat.
18:26And I do the same with the shoe covers.
18:28Are you always so methodical?
18:30Yeah.
18:30Every time?
18:31Yes.
18:32Are the others?
18:33I should think so.
18:35Was there anyone else in the clean room?
18:37There shouldn't have been.
18:38Why?
18:38I don't know.
18:41I don't know.
18:43Was Dr. Jones there?
18:44Well, he must have been.
18:45He didn't leave, did he?
18:46Did I do it?
18:56We don't know what happened.
18:58If I did it, I want to confess.
19:01But I don't know, and nobody will tell me.
19:04Nobody.
19:07Was it me?
19:08How did I get these bruises?
19:10I didn't fall, so there must have been a fight.
19:14There must have.
19:14There must have.
19:17Was there?
19:18Did I hit him?
19:21Oh, if I could remember.
19:25Yes.
19:26I could confess.
19:31Where do you put the gown?
19:34In the laundry bag.
19:38There.
19:39It's done.
19:40And you're always methodical.
19:41Yes.
19:42With everything in it.
19:43Yes.
19:43She wonders if there was a fight.
19:44Does she?
19:45Well, there's no doubt that somebody hit her, and hit her hard.
19:50Does she know anything about a fight?
19:51No.
19:53Well, if there was, Dr. Jones may have been bruised in somewhere.
19:56There was bruising around his throat.
19:58From someone squeezing?
19:59Yes.
20:01There was nobody else in the room, Doctor.
20:04She did tell me that she hated Dr. Jones.
20:06But that's not reason enough to kill anyone, is it?
20:09If it was Dr. Jones who hit her, why did he hit her?
20:12Self-defence.
20:14Was Dr. Jones defending himself?
20:16Or defending Grace.
20:17You will be at the briefing, won't you?
20:21Of course.
20:22If it's useful.
20:23I must have bought the cup of coffee myself, but I don't remember.
20:26Look, I don't even know how I got there, but I do remember Don finding me in the canteen.
20:32How long had you been there?
20:33I don't know.
20:34And did you have the bruises then?
20:36Something was hurting, and Don asked me what I'd done to my face.
20:39Uh-huh.
20:39What were you doing when he found you?
20:41Drinking coffee from the machine.
20:43Do you remember going to the machine to buy the coffee?
20:46No.
20:46I can remember Don talking to me, asking me why I was there.
20:50I shouldn't have been there.
20:51Not then.
20:52Where should you have been?
20:53I don't know.
20:54Home?
20:56I've been thinking, if we were the only two in the room and somebody hit me, that somebody
20:59must have been Dr. Jones.
21:02Did Dr. Jones hit you?
21:05I can't remember.
21:08Can you describe the clean room?
21:10I've done that.
21:10That's right.
21:11You said it was tidy, clean, ordered.
21:13That's what it's like.
21:14Is it always like that?
21:15Yes, but if Dr. Jones hit me...
21:18Yes.
21:18Was there a fight?
21:19Was there?
21:21Was Dr. Jones in a fight?
21:22I don't know.
21:24Tell me something more about Dr. Jones.
21:26Did he hit me?
21:27We don't know what happened.
21:28Why would he hit me?
21:30You said you didn't like Dr. Jones.
21:32Well, nobody liked him.
21:33He was a bully.
21:35I was better at the job than he was.
21:37Well, that's very frustrating.
21:38Did I hit him?
21:44You're always easy to sleep, aren't you?
21:46Well, it's a substitute for cigarette.
21:48Would you like one?
21:49Oh, go on then.
21:52No.
21:53I've changed my mind.
21:55Okay.
21:57You said that it was noisy in the clean room because of the machines changing the air.
22:01So, was there much talking?
22:03Well, you could hear him bollocking.
22:04You all of us heard that.
22:05All of you?
22:06But there was no one else in the clean room.
22:09Not them.
22:10Uh-huh.
22:11Where had they gone?
22:12Home.
22:13So, why were you still there?
22:15Was I working late?
22:17I mean, Dr. Jones.
22:19That happened.
22:20So, why were you working late?
22:23I didn't know I was going to work late.
22:25At least, I don't think I knew.
22:27He was like that.
22:28He'd say something needed finishing and you worked late.
22:31So, there was just the two of you in the room?
22:34Must have been.
22:35And can people just walk in and out?
22:37No chance.
22:37Trick security.
22:39If there was someone in there who shouldn't be in there, would you know who they were?
22:42Of course.
22:42Even though their faces were covered by a mask?
22:47He didn't know that he had to work late until he told you.
22:50You'd think he'd have said it.
22:50Normal people would.
22:52Maybe he didn't know until last minute.
22:53He'd know.
22:54When did you know?
22:57When did I know what?
22:57That you had to work late.
22:58I don't know.
23:00Can you tell me what you were working on?
23:01I can't remember.
23:03It would be on the worksheet.
23:05What words do you remember being spoken?
23:11He asked me if I was all right.
23:12Don.
23:13Don asked me if I was all right.
23:15I said I was and I drove home.
23:17You felt well enough to drive.
23:19I remember feeling tired and climbing into bed.
23:22The next thing I remember is the police at my door.
23:25And they were really nice.
23:28But then I came here.
23:30Tell me more about Dr. Jones.
23:33If we were the only two in the room, he must have hit me.
23:41Joe?
23:43I don't know.
23:46Do you know what it's like in here at night?
23:48When they lock the door, they lock everything up.
23:52Everything.
23:54Including your thoughts.
23:57That shouldn't happen.
23:59It's not right.
24:02Is that how you feel?
24:03That your thoughts have been locked up?
24:08What have they done wrong?
24:11Do you know?
24:15Neither do I.
24:16Well, Grace is in shock and frightened by not being able to remember.
24:22Now, we mustn't forget what it's like to be brought into a police station.
24:26The first time it happened to me, I was terrified, even though I was full of adolescent bravado and snakebite.
24:31Now, we didn't call it snakebite then.
24:33Were you traumatised?
24:34So much so that I sobered up within two minutes.
24:37They have solicitors, Dr. Astor.
24:39And Grace Hale's amnesia is ten times better than any solicitor.
24:43So what does this mean for us?
24:44The brain is like a landscape that has to be explored.
24:49You see pictures in travel brochures, yeah?
24:52And you think, I'd like to go there.
24:54And when you arrive, you recognise the place, but you don't know it.
24:58So what do you do?
24:59Complain to the travel rep.
25:00All right, which gets you nowhere, right?
25:04So slowly, you explore the hotel, the town, the beach, till it becomes familiar.
25:10Sorry, Doc, I'm not with you.
25:11All right, let's say the memory's a huge jigsaw puzzle.
25:15In this case, the jigsaw's been knocked over with pieces everywhere, maybe some missing.
25:21Now, I'm trying to put the jigsaw back together.
25:23And it's very easy to try and jam the wrong piece in, especially when you're in a hurry.
25:28Now, tell me, have any of you got a feeling about this case?
25:32Would that be feminine intuition or copper's nose, Dr. Astor?
25:36Well, instinct, intuition, gut feeling, copper's nose, still the brain working,
25:41drawing on experience, personal memory and stories we've been told.
25:45And it means nothing without hard evidence.
25:47But that feeling might guide us to that hard evidence.
25:51She's bright, Dr. Astor. Could this be a bluff?
25:54I don't think so.
25:55But it could be.
25:56If she didn't do it, who did?
25:58I'm afraid that's your problem.
25:59I thought you were on our side, Dr. Astor.
26:02I'm trying to help you establish what happened.
26:05There was a violent confrontation, yeah?
26:07Between Dr. Jones and Grace Hill.
26:09With no forensic evidence, we can't be sure, can we?
26:12No.
26:13Now, I'd like to play you one more thing, if I may.
26:17I've come out of the clean room, stepped over the wall, I take off the gloves and then the mask.
26:26The gloves go in the incinerator bin along with the hat.
26:30I do the same with the shoe covers.
26:32Are you always so methodical?
26:33Yes.
26:34Every time?
26:35Yes.
26:36Are the others?
26:37I should think so.
26:39Was there anyone else in the clean room?
26:41There shouldn't have been.
26:42The fact that she was so methodical in removing her overalls and that there was a physical confrontation is interesting.
26:50But I understood that her overalls...
26:51So how do you explain it, Doctor?
26:53She could have been running away.
26:55From what?
26:55Someone.
26:56Or something.
26:57That she'd done.
26:58Or seen.
26:59It might mean that she wasn't there when the incident happened.
27:03So why the bruises?
27:04I'll be interested to hear if she changes her story.
27:07She won't.
27:07What makes you so sure, Dr. Astor?
27:09Because she hasn't got a story yet.
27:11So, Dr. Astor, what can I say to the magistrates?
27:18Tell them that I need to release her memories.
27:20Oh, I'll eat that.
27:21And I need to keep walking round her bread.
27:23Well, if I tell them that, she'll be released and you'll be locked up.
27:27All right.
27:28I hope this has been of some use.
27:31Oh, it has.
27:32Yes, yes.
27:34Thank you, Dr. Astor.
27:35Thanks, Doctor.
27:36Well?
27:40Could you tell DC Patton not to interrupt me, ma'am?
27:43I have to.
27:43We know that she didn't take her overalls off methodically.
27:46They were thrown all over the place.
27:48If she's told him otherwise, shouldn't he know?
27:50We have to be very careful.
27:52If Dr. Astor knows too much, he may ask Grace leading questions.
27:55Well, I thought he knew what he was doing.
27:56He does.
27:57We have to disclose that we're using Dr. Astor.
28:00And if there's even the slightest suspicion that he's been used inappropriately, the case
28:04goes out the window.
28:04We're not going to have a case at this rate.
28:06We will if we don't blow it.
28:07What do you mean by that?
28:08All right, that's enough.
28:09Any more thoughts?
28:10Yeah, well, that bit about everyone knowing that she was better than him.
28:14Well, though, as I interviewed, reckon she was a bit full of herself.
28:17Like Dr. Jones.
28:18Must have been hell working with those two.
28:21So, what are we saying?
28:22At the moment, we're saying that he hit her, so she strangled him.
28:26Then she gets her kid off quick and she...
28:28And has a nice cup of coffee in the canteen.
28:30It's possible.
28:31You know, if she's lying.
28:32Which is what I'm saying.
28:34But we've got to be careful.
28:35Decide on the spur of the moment that you had to work late.
28:39I wouldn't do it voluntarily.
28:40If I was working late, he must have told me to.
28:42What did you say to him when he told you?
28:44I might not have said anything.
28:45Just bit my lip and got on with it.
28:48I'd like to play something, Grace.
28:50And I'd like you to close your eyes and listen.
28:58It's the clean room, so what?
29:00Where would you be in relation to Dr. Jones?
29:03Depends on what he's doing.
29:05Describe where Dr. Jones would be in the clean room.
29:07It depends on what he's doing.
29:09What is he doing?
29:13He's...
29:13Working.
29:15He's just working.
29:16Would he be facing you?
29:17Would he have his back to you?
29:18Would he be moving...
29:19Back to me.
29:19Right.
29:20And what's he doing?
29:23I can't see.
29:25So he's working as he normally works.
29:27He shouldn't be doing it.
29:29What's he doing, Grace?
29:30I can't remember.
29:32How do you feel about what he's doing?
29:34I've said...
29:34What have you said?
29:35I've told him.
29:38Could he have hit you because you've told him?
29:40He just ignored me.
29:41Is there anything he can do about that?
29:43He shouldn't be in here.
29:44Where should he be then?
29:45Outside.
29:47I told him, outside, and he should have stayed outside.
29:49But he ignored me and now he's in here.
29:53I shouldn't be doing it.
29:55Would you use force to stop him?
29:57I've never hit anyone.
29:59Never.
30:01I'd never do that.
30:03What would you do if someone hit you?
30:04I don't understand why anyone would want to hit me.
30:07I'm very tired.
30:08I just...
30:10All I want is to be in my own bed.
30:11OK.
30:12All right.
30:14There's just one thing, Grace.
30:15When you take off your overalls, are you always so methodical?
30:19I've said, haven't I?
30:20I have.
30:21Even when you're in a hurry?
30:22Who said I was in a hurry?
30:23I've never said anything about being in a hurry.
30:26Yeah.
30:26But we know that something must have happened in the clean room.
30:33Oh, sometimes I wonder why you bother.
30:36Dad used to ring us every week to tell us how bad Borough plan.
30:39Tell him about Chelsea.
30:41Chelsea, then.
30:41They're a football team.
30:42They're a language school.
30:44Yeah.
30:44Hey, so what do you think of the new stadium, then?
30:47Oh, it's all right.
30:47Well, your dad never really talked to it.
30:50He said it was like going to the Metro Centre, but without the atmosphere.
30:54He went to the Metro Centre?
30:56Aye, well, your mum made him.
30:58There's a race night here Wednesday.
31:00Do you fancy it?
31:01Why not?
31:03So Dad went to the Metro Centre with Mum?
31:06Aye, someone that did together.
31:07Like Saturday night at the club.
31:09A big night out, that's what you called it.
31:10Aye, she was like most of the women.
31:13They came because the men came, and if they didn't come here, they would never go anywhere.
31:17Yeah.
31:17Except the Metro Centre.
31:19She was in the Lady's Darts team there, eh?
31:20Oh, the boys.
31:21Night out that men have proved of, eh?
31:23But things have changed, eh?
31:25For good or bad, things have changed.
31:28One thing hasn't.
31:29Ah, what's that?
31:30Boris still crap.
31:32There you go.
31:35What's this all about, Grace?
31:36Don't you know?
31:37No.
31:37Why?
31:38Can't you remember?
31:39What is actually going to happen to me?
31:42Well, that's not up to me.
31:44Well, what is up to you?
31:44Do you know?
31:45Look, um, do I have to talk to you?
31:47I might be helpful.
31:47Well, it hasn't been so far, has it?
31:50Sorry you think that.
31:51I trusted you.
31:52Look, I don't know what happened, Grace.
31:54Oh, you know what happened.
31:55No, I don't.
31:56But I would like you to tell me.
31:58And then you'll go back to that copper and tell him what I've said, and then he'll twist it.
32:02Dr. Aston, it's not as simple as...
32:04I want to know what happened.
32:05Once DC Patton gets here.
32:07What's the point in me spending all this time getting...
32:09All right, we'll sort it out.
32:12I'm sorry, Karen, but I'm back at square one.
32:15Is that what you wanted?
32:16No, of course not, but you must understand.
32:19Come in.
32:22You wanted to see me, Mum?
32:23Yes, we did.
32:24Right.
32:26Jeff, what did you say to Grace Hale when you re-interviewed her?
32:30I asked her about leaving the clean room.
32:32She told Dr. Aston that she'd changed as normal, but the evidence contradicts that.
32:36All we're after is the truth, Dr. Aston.
32:38What words did you use?
32:39I can't remember.
32:40Oh, that's convenient.
32:41Look, I'm only sure...
32:42A mistake was made, now we should just try and forget it.
32:43Trust has been broken, and that's worse.
32:46By accident, Doctor.
32:49There's a dead body in a distraught family wanting an explanation.
32:53We're under pressure to solve this.
32:54So am I.
32:56You might think all eyes are on you, but they're on me.
32:58A lot of those eyes want to see me fail.
33:00And I will fail if I'm not trusted to do what I'm supposed to do.
33:04I was beginning to get somewhere with Grace.
33:06I'm sorry if I made an error of judgment.
33:08How am I supposed to be part of a team here?
33:09You know, a team is supposed to be after the same thing.
33:13And we are.
33:13All we want to know is who killed Dr. Jones.
33:16Maybe you hope that I'll magic her memory back, and then she'll confess to everything.
33:19We just want the truth, Doctor.
33:21She could be protecting somebody.
33:23There was nobody else in the room, ma'am.
33:24As far as we know.
33:26Would she have anything to gain from his death?
33:29Well, she thinks that she was better than him, so she may have thought...
33:31We all think we're better than someone else.
33:33Dr. Aston, my problem at the moment is that I need to ask the magistrates for a final extension.
33:38And I don't trust Tricks cyclists.
33:40They're not convinced it's scientific.
33:42What is?
33:43Forensic evidence.
33:44As in the case of the Birmingham Six.
33:45Oh, nobody's perfect, Dr. Aston.
33:47Well, you know, don't expect me to be.
33:53Sorry.
33:55I didn't mean to cause a problem.
33:56But I've not broken any rules.
33:58I know, I know.
33:59Perhaps if we had a beer together, me and Dr. Aston.
34:02It's just a suggestion, Karen.
34:04But I might calm things down a bit.
34:06Maybe we should all start smoking again.
34:13You're playing the tape of the clean room again, so what?
34:17I've said all along, Grace, that if you don't want to party...
34:19Right, right, right.
34:20The magistrates know you're working with me, so if I stop now, it'll look as if I've got something to hide.
34:25Not necessarily.
34:27Shall we start the story again?
34:32Okay.
34:34Grace, is Dr. Jones coming out of the clean room?
34:37No.
34:38Where is he then?
34:40I don't remember.
34:41But you've been working with him.
34:42Yes.
34:43So where is he?
34:44In the clean room.
34:45Have you finished work?
34:48No.
34:49So why are you taking off your overalls?
34:51The dish is on the floor.
34:53The dish?
34:53The petri dish.
34:54Where is it?
34:55On the floor.
34:56It's broken.
34:59All that work in pieces on the floor.
35:01So why is it on the floor?
35:05I don't remember.
35:06Has it been dropped?
35:07I don't remember.
35:08I won't stop.
35:08All right, Grace.
35:10Okay.
35:13Do you want one?
35:14No.
35:15Honey and lemon?
35:15No.
35:18Don't blame you.
35:18I've only got them because of my sore throat.
35:21We couldn't go in the clean room if we had an infection.
35:24Germs, you see.
35:24Bacteria.
35:26This is from the football.
35:28It makes sense, doesn't it, not being allowed into the clean room if you had an infection.
35:31I did it.
35:32Did what?
35:34I dropped the dish.
35:35So, Grace, the dish is on the floor.
35:40Yeah, you're seeking a sweet.
35:42That's right.
35:43He shouldn't have been there.
35:44Who?
35:45He shouldn't have been in the clean room.
35:47Who?
35:47Take the sweet out of your mouth.
35:49Is that what you said to Dr Jones?
35:51Outside the clean room.
35:53Before you went in?
35:53He shouldn't have gone in.
35:54But he was working with you in the clean room.
35:56Take the sweet out of your mouth.
36:00That's better.
36:02Did Dr Jones take the sweet out of his mouth?
36:05Oh, he just looked at me.
36:07What did you say?
36:08Take the sweet out of your mouth.
36:10Was this inside the clean room or outside?
36:12I told you, outside.
36:13Take the sweet out of your mouth.
36:18I have.
36:20He had a sore throat.
36:22So he shouldn't have been in the clean room.
36:24No.
36:25What did he do?
36:26He went in.
36:27What did you do?
36:28I went in.
36:29He was sucking a throat sweet, so you told him not to and he ignored you.
36:33He took the sweet out.
36:34I told you.
36:35So he didn't ignore you?
36:37Don't put the bloody sweet in your mouth, you prats!
36:41I said!
36:43You're not!
36:44Oh, she went for you.
36:45She was scared, Karen.
36:47Of a sweet?
36:48Well, she attacked Dr Jones because of a throat sweet.
36:52I don't know the sequence of events.
36:53When you put the sweet in your mouth, she thought you were Dr Jones.
36:57When I put the sweet back in my mouth, it prompted her memory.
37:01I don't think she thought I was Dr Jones.
37:02So what did she think?
37:04I think she was scared.
37:05But not because she thought you were Dr Jones.
37:07What did she say to you then?
37:09Did she call you Joe or did she call you Dr Jones?
37:12She called me your bastard.
37:14And then she went for my throat.
37:15Hang on, hang on.
37:16Did she go for him because he didn't do what she said?
37:20And then he hit her trying to protect himself?
37:22Did she attack him?
37:23I don't know.
37:24She attacked you?
37:25No.
37:26She went for me.
37:27Isn't that the same thing?
37:28Not necessarily.
37:29Are you sure?
37:30So what are you going to do now, Doctor?
37:33I'm going to talk to her again.
37:34Do you want someone in with you?
37:35That won't be necessary.
37:36I wouldn't be so sure, Doctor.
37:39I knew who you were, Joe, but I didn't want you to put the sweet back in your mouth.
37:45Why?
37:47You'd get hurt.
37:48Sucking a sweet?
37:49Yes.
37:50How?
37:51I don't know.
37:52Did Dr Jones often eat sweets?
37:54No.
37:54But if you had a sore throat, you...
37:57He shouldn't have gone in the clean room.
38:00Close your eyes, Grace, and imagine that you're in the clean room.
38:09That noise.
38:11The clean room?
38:11No.
38:13What noise, then?
38:14That noise.
38:16In the clean room?
38:17Yes.
38:18Describe the noise.
38:21Shit!
38:23You've opened your eyes.
38:24You're sucking a sweet.
38:25You can hear me sucking a sweet.
38:27It's too noisy.
38:27I could see.
38:29Well, what could you see?
38:31His hands at his throat.
38:33Whose hands?
38:34His hands.
38:34Then I heard that noise.
38:38But is it the truth?
38:40She was trying to dislodge the sweet stuck in his windpipe.
38:43She failed.
38:43But by the time his body was found, the sweet had dissolved.
38:47It's bizarre.
38:48Yes, but it's supported by the evidence, isn't it?
38:51Look at the lab reports.
38:52Traces of eucalyptus and incipient throat infection.
38:55She's a clever woman.
38:56So?
38:56She could have taken the opportunity to kill him.
38:59She sees he's choking, right?
39:00So she goes across, puts her hands around his throat and makes sure he does choke.
39:04Neat.
39:04Ah, but is it the truth?
39:06I bet she's glad he's dead.
39:07That doesn't make her a murderer.
39:09How is she, Doctor?
39:11Relieved, but not necessarily innocent.
39:13Well, of course, she can't remember everything.
39:15But she's remembered enough.
39:17So it would seem.
39:20Um, does anyone fancy a drink later?
39:22If you do, give us a knock.
39:23I'll be writing up my notes.
39:24And I'll see you first thing in the morning, Doctor.
39:27Of course.
39:28See you later.
39:31Well, thanks, everyone.
39:33If you could get your reports to me as soon as possible, I'd be grateful.
39:35So, has Doctor Aston been a success, Mum?
39:38Well, we know what happened.
39:40We know what Grace Hale's been willing to tell us.
39:42Which is all we have.
39:43And all we're likely to get.
39:45Let's just say there's no case to answer.
39:48A bit like Grace, then.
39:52So no celebratory drink in the snoo the copper's napping, eh?
39:56Not as far as I know.
39:58Anyway, the beer's cheaper, eh?
40:00Yeah, and we've had some good times here, eh?
40:03Christenings, weddings, birthdays and funerals
40:05are still talked about.
40:06Right.
40:07And casually, mainly.
40:10Why was every family party held here?
40:12Right, because it was.
40:14Right, the fuse has been fixed,
40:17so we'll be running the first race soon.
40:19Your Auntie Jean was saying
40:20it'd be nice if you lived back here.
40:22Your Helen would like it.
40:24I'm not sure what she'd take to this place.
40:26Not like Mum.
40:28You having a bet, then?
40:30I'm still deciding.
40:31Well, look, all you've got to do
40:32is study the card, the form, the conditions,
40:35then close your eyes and trust your luck.
40:37A bit like psychology, then.
40:40No, somehow I can't see me and Helen
40:42sitting here on a Saturday night
40:43like Mum and Dad.
40:45Ah, well, you see,
40:46they're like the good singer.
40:48One who sang the songs
40:49that brought back their dreams.
40:51Well, I did.
40:52All of us singing them dreams
40:54of whiskey, brown ale, whatever.
40:56Turned them into hangovers
40:57so they wouldn't hurt so much in the morning.
41:00See, you've moved out.
41:02On and up, and good for you.
41:04You've got brains
41:05and you're married a lass with brains.
41:07But you forget.
41:09We all forget.
41:10It's human nature, that.
41:11Hey, that lass you've been working with,
41:14she wanted to forget.
41:15Maybe not consciously, but still.
41:18She got banged on the head.
41:19We get pissed up,
41:20but the result's the same.
41:21Maybe it's no bad thing, eh?
41:23And just to remind you,
41:24there's no standing on the chairs
41:26during the race.
41:27So do you reckon he did a good job?
41:29In fact, no standing on the chairs
41:30at any time.
41:31I've no idea.
41:32I mean, nobody'd thank me.
41:33Well, why should they
41:34have done your job, that's all?
41:36Yeah, you're like your mum.
41:38You always wanting more.
41:39You should just make do.
41:41Is that what mum did with Dad?
41:43Made do?
41:44Like us all.
41:46Like us all,
41:47your dad couldn't give her
41:48all she wanted,
41:49and maybe she learned
41:50it was cruel to us.
41:51Does Helen ask more of you
41:55than you can give her?
41:56If you don't know,
41:57I'd find out sharpish.
41:59We're fine.
42:00You know, me and Helen, fine.
42:01Oh, good, good.
42:02It's none of my business.
42:03It's just your Auntie Jane.
42:04Oh, yeah.
42:05Well, you know what she's like.
42:08What happens, though,
42:09when that lass does remember everything?
42:11What happens
42:12if it's different
42:13than what she said?
42:15Do you know something, Tom?
42:16I've no idea.
42:18But you're not the only one
42:19who's asking the same question.
42:20Ladies and gentlemen,
42:22bets are now closing
42:23for the first race
42:24from Williger Park.
42:32In The Recall Man
42:34by David Napthine,
42:35Dr. Joe Astum
42:36was played by Jeremy Swift,
42:38Grace Hale
42:38by Rosie Cavaliero,
42:40and Karen
42:41by Carolyn Pickles.
42:42Tom was Colin McLachlan,
42:44Jeff Paul Brennan,
42:45and Jane Sue Scott-Davison.
42:48The director
42:49was Toby Swift.
42:51of the