- il y a 6 heures
Watch Murder on Trial, Season 2 Episode 3 on Dailymotion (2026).
Catégorie
📺
TVTranscription
00:30...might have been targeted for his sexuality and for who he was on campus.
00:34Jay was last seen alive leaving his apartment in the early morning hours.
00:39He leaves, has nothing but a night robe on, looks to be a bonnet, and he gets into his car
00:46and he drives away.
00:48We didn't know where Jay Lee was going, and it's like he just fell off the face of the earth.
00:52If anyone knows anything or sees anything, this is my plea that you help find my child.
01:01You have to take your investigative mind to the dark place of, we're going to be working a death investigation.
01:26Game day at Ole Miss.
01:31It is big. They say Ole Miss may lose a game, but they never lose a party.
01:36You go to the game and cheer on Ole Miss and get to yell hotty-totty.
01:40Hotty-totty!
01:43It's a school known for its time-honored traditions and cultures.
01:48It's the premier university in the state. Kids from all over the country are going to go to Ole Miss.
01:53Ole Miss, my hand!
01:56For Jimmy J. Lee of Ridgeland, Mississippi, graduating from Ole Miss was a dream come true.
02:03He came to me, he was like, you know, I really want to go to Ole Miss.
02:08J. Lee!
02:11My name is Jimmy Lee, Jr., the father of Jimmy J. Lee III.
02:17He, when he got there overall, he ran into some opposition.
02:25As a gay black man, J. had to navigate his own way through Ole Miss.
02:30He definitely stood out. J. had a very flamboyant personality.
02:35He was very strong in who he was.
02:37He participated in different activities, like the Black Student Union and something called Code Pink,
02:42which was a student-run drag organization.
02:54In his junior year, J. actually ran to be the school's homecoming king.
03:01And when he campaigned, he's in these heels, he has makeup on, his hair is done, his nails are done.
03:08Not everyone at Ole Miss loved it.
03:10I know he had, you know, folks say some of the cruelest things.
03:15Folks just used racial slurs.
03:18They used comments against his identity.
03:23J. spent the summer after graduating on campus, preparing for graduate school.
03:29On July 8th, his parents reported him missing.
03:32J. It was the day of my wife's birthday.
03:35And J. would never miss his mother's birthday.
03:39Since my son was, you know, old enough to even sing or talk, he would call, he would sing, he
03:45would,
03:46it wouldn't be like one time in the morning, it would be throughout the day.
03:50J. would never let anything keep him from calling Mom.
03:54J.'s parents raced to Oxford to try to find their son, fearing the worst.
03:59We just didn't have a good feeling about it.
04:01Very, very crushing.
04:04Never experienced anything, you know, of that multitude.
04:08Jimmy J. Lee's family and Oxford residents formed a search party,
04:12looking in areas around town for the missing Ole Miss student.
04:15We're just holding that strength and that faith, the size of a muscle seed,
04:20it's just, that's all we're holding on to.
04:22It's just that faith and that strength and staying strong.
04:25A lot of praying, a lot of prayer.
04:27My wife and I, we were leaning on each other.
04:31It's hard wrenching.
04:33After a few days, university security brought in the city of Oxford Police Department.
04:38We jumped in with both feet with them early.
04:41My name is Jeff McCutcheon and I'm the chief of police for the city of Oxford.
04:45And we start game planning.
04:46They do welfare checks.
04:47They go by the house.
04:48They're calling the phone, trying to talk to friends.
04:51And they were coming up with nothing.
04:54Unanswered questions tonight as authorities search for a missing Ole Miss student.
04:58The University of Mississippi police has issued a missing persons alert for Jimmy or J. Lee,
05:05who's been missing for three days.
05:07They should be alert now if it is a kidnapping because it's unlike him.
05:16We got a glimpse into a young man that was very active on social media, very active in the community,
05:25and it's like he just fell off the face of the earth.
05:28You're now into day three.
05:31You have to take your investigative mind to the dark place of we're going to be working a death investigation.
05:38The university's LGBT community and J. Lee's friends rallied to support the search.
05:46I think people thought that he might have been targeted for his sexuality and for who he was on campus
05:52and for how just out there he was.
05:57He was so confident.
05:59He was just so unapologetically himself.
06:02We were open to anything.
06:03We just knew that we had to get information in.
06:06That was coming from friends.
06:07That was coming from tips.
06:09Anybody that his friend group told us to go talk to, we went and talked to.
06:14Police used the surveillance camera videos from Jay's university apartment complex
06:19to track the last time he was seen alive in public.
06:22just after four in the morning on July 8th.
06:27You see Jay Lee leave his apartment early morning hours, has nothing but a night robe on,
06:33looks to be a bonnet, and has a cell phone in his hand.
06:36And he gets into his car and he drives away.
06:41He returns a short time later.
06:48And then leaves again.
06:49Jay Lee, the second time he leaves, uh, at the time we didn't know where Jay Lee was going.
07:01So the search went on.
07:03It has been one week since University of Mississippi student Jimmy J. Lee was last seen.
07:09That's right, and tonight Jimmy's family is asking for your help.
07:12I'm calling and reaching out to anyone that could have any information to help in his return.
07:19I want everyone to know that whether you're black, white, green, polka dot, it doesn't matter who you are.
07:25I'm asking that if anyone knows anything or sees anything, say something.
07:34This is my plea that you help find my child.
07:38Thank you.
07:39The first break in the case came after a police social media blast showing Jay Lee and his missing car.
07:46It's a very specific car.
07:48It's a black sedan with a gold racing stripe down the back of it.
07:53Police found the car had been towed from an apartment complex blocks away from where Jay Lee lived.
07:59We're missing his car keys.
08:00We're missing his cell phone.
08:01So we started canvassing the area, looking for any kind of video, any cameras.
08:05Now, police wanted to know how that car got to the lot from which it was towed.
08:12Video showed the car arriving on the morning of July 8th, but the driver could not be seen.
08:18And that's where we originally started our investigation, trying to figure out if Jay Lee was there, and did he
08:26go missing from there?
08:28Is he visiting a friend?
08:30It soon became clear to police that someone else had driven the car there and dumped it.
08:36We ended up seeing an individual run out of Mollibar Trails.
08:41Then he starts walking, and he goes toward the gas station there.
08:48And then we see that same individual go behind a truck, and a car pulls into the gas station, and
08:56that individual runs and gets into the car.
08:58It's a white car.
09:00We couldn't make out the tag fully, but we wanted to know who that individual was within minutes of Jay
09:07Lee's car coming in.
09:08Now, finally, some solid leads.
09:26For Oxford, Mississippi, police detectives, the priority was to find out where was Jay Lee going in the early morning
09:33hours when he was last seen alive.
09:36They hoped his emails and social media posts would help.
09:39We could not see Jay Lee's messages that were sent, but we saw messages that were sent from a red
09:47-eye underscore 24 Snapchat account.
09:50You have a red-eye 24 talking with Jay Lee the morning of the 8th, and it appears that that
10:00individual, red-eye 24, is trying to get Jay Lee to come over to see him.
10:05Now, detectives wondered if the man seen running away from Jay Lee's car on the 8th of July and getting
10:12into another car at a gas station was red-eye 24.
10:27It turned out that driver had actually been pulled over by police on a speeding stop right after he picked
10:34up his mystery passenger.
10:42The left side of the passenger can be seen in the body cam video, and officers later determined the driver
10:49had no connection with Jay Lee's disappearance, but he was helpful.
10:53We started asking him who it was, and he tells us that the individual's name is Tim.
10:59And he said he dropped Tim off at his nearby apartment, where a Tim Harrington was a tenant.
11:05So we ended up getting a photo of Tim Harrington, a driver's license photo, and showed it to this individual,
11:14and he said, yes, that's Tim.
11:15That's who I picked up.
11:16But the investigation stole when detectives say Snapchat was slow to respond to a warrant for more information on red
11:24-eye 24.
11:26Time matters, especially in a missing person's case.
11:30I mean, it just makes you furious.
11:32You know, you're pouring your heart and your soul into this, and you have people in other areas that it
11:40doesn't matter to them.
11:41Snapchat says any suggestion that it did not support the investigation is simply inaccurate.
11:47I mean, there was no dealing until we brought in our U.S. Attorney's Office.
11:53And so thankfully, we used that tool to be able to get information back rather quickly.
11:58Tim Harrington, at that point in time, becomes a very strong person of interest, and we want to talk to
12:04Tim Harrington.
12:06Hey, sir.
12:07How are you?
12:08Hey.
12:08I'm Shane Fortner.
12:09Nice to meet you.
12:10This is Detective Baker.
12:11Nice to meet you.
12:11We're an officer police officer.
12:12Are you Sheldon Harrington?
12:13I am.
12:14Hey, Sheldon.
12:14So you may have noticed on the social media or the news that we're investigating a missing person over there.
12:19Right, right, right.
12:19So what we're doing is we're going around and talking to anybody that had contact with him.
12:25Yeah.
12:25And the strategy was pretty simple.
12:29We wanted to be very calm, demeanor, and we wanted to ask him questions.
12:35Did he see, did he know Jay Lee?
12:38Did he have any contact with Jay Lee the morning of the 8th?
12:43We got some records back, phone records and stuff like that.
12:46I noticed that you had contact with him.
12:47Yeah, right, right.
12:48Can we come in and talk to him?
12:49Yes, sir.
12:53And as we're walking in, you know, I'm observing what's going on.
12:58I'm hoping maybe Jay Lee's sitting on the couch, but he's not.
13:01All right, so we've got these records that we're having in the line, Tim.
13:06You said Tim, right?
13:07Yes, sir.
13:07Let's talk to him.
13:08We'll be back.
13:09All right.
13:10All right, Tim, do you know Jay Lee?
13:12Yes, sir.
13:13I know him.
13:14How do you know Jay Lee?
13:15Students.
13:16You know, we were in Black Student Union together.
13:18Oh, okay.
13:19That's where we met and stuff like that.
13:21I got you.
13:22How well do you know him?
13:23Oh, we were cool.
13:24Like, we were, like, I wouldn't say we were, like, best friends, but we were, like, you
13:29know, just, you know, acquaintances, friends like that, yeah.
13:32Okay.
13:33Have you had any contact with him lately?
13:35No, sir.
13:36I haven't heard anything since, you know, it's been a minute, you know, since.
13:41I know, like, since he's been gone, I haven't heard anything.
13:45So, before he was gone, when was the last time you had any contact with him?
13:50That night.
13:50I had talked to him.
13:51We chill.
13:52What night is that?
13:53I'm not sure what night it was, but it was, like, I would say a couple of weeks ago.
14:00I'm not sure the exact date.
14:01I didn't mean to cut you off, Tim.
14:02You said y'all chilled that night?
14:04Yeah, sir.
14:04We were cool.
14:05Like, yeah, we used to...
14:06Where'd y'all chill at?
14:07Over here or over at his apartment?
14:09Nah, like, we were outside.
14:10He came by and stopped by.
14:11He came by and stopped by.
14:12How long was he here for?
14:14I don't know.
14:15It was a few minutes.
14:16It wasn't too long.
14:17Did he come back?
14:20Did you go over there?
14:21Did you see him?
14:21Nah, I didn't see him after that.
14:23Like, he...
14:23I saw him that night.
14:25That's why I was like, you know, like, they can't be missing.
14:27Like, you know, I just...
14:28Yeah.
14:29I didn't think it was...
14:30You know, I didn't, like, really believe him when I first saw him, because I was out of
14:33town when I first got the news.
14:35So we wanted to dive into it further.
14:38We asked about a sexual relationship they may have had, and Tim denies any kind of sexual
14:44relationship.
14:44Well, we figured out how, uh, how, you know, some of the things he did do.
14:49It sounded like, uh, we know he liked to, he dressed as a female.
14:53Right, right, yeah.
14:54Uh, and then he would, uh, oftentimes, I think, have sexual intercourse with different males and
15:00stuff like that.
15:01Oh, what?
15:02Uh, so I'm just, we asking everybody, okay?
15:05Yeah.
15:05Does he mean he don't have a sexual relationship of any kind?
15:07Nah, I'm not sure.
15:08I don't want that.
15:09Okay, so no, no, no, nothing?
15:11Yeah, we were just cool.
15:14Detectives knew that Tim was the person seen running away after Jay Lee's car was dumped
15:19at an apartment complex.
15:21That's what, uh, I don't know if you heard, that's kind of what happened to Jay Lee's car.
15:24Yeah.
15:25It was parked over there and towed.
15:27Yeah, so I don't, I personally don't go over there.
15:29I remember one question we asked Tim was, what do you think happened to, uh, to, to Jay Lee?
15:37What do you think happened to him?
15:39I don't know if he just, like, went and had casual sex or somebody and got kidnapped like
15:43that.
15:43That could be...
15:44We talked to multiple people through this investigation.
15:47Nobody gave that answer.
15:49And that troubled us.
15:51A team of officers was waiting outside with a search warrant for Tim's apartment.
15:56We called for the other officers to come up.
15:59Uh, they detained Tim for us.
16:02Uh, and then they executed a search warrant on the apartment.
16:05And Tim Harrington was taken to the police headquarters for another round of questioning.
16:19We got Tim down to the interview room and we advised him of his rights.
16:24He waived his rights.
16:26And we pretty much tell Tim that we need to kind of know the truth.
16:30You know, we know there's more to this.
16:33Okay, talk, kind of walk me through you and Jay Lee's knowing and friendship and all that.
16:38We did have, like, like something.
16:42Like a deep professional team.
16:44We'll just...
16:45So is it possible, Tim, what you told us in the apartment was not as accurate as it was made
16:50out to be?
16:51No, sir, it wasn't as accurate.
16:53I think it was more in jail.
16:54I didn't think so, Tim.
16:55And that's the reason why we had to do what we do.
16:58I think it's important that we get it out on the table.
17:01The strategy in of itself is trying to get as much as we can out of Tim.
17:07And Tim acknowledges that he had a...
17:10He did, in fact, have a sexual relationship with Jay Lee.
17:40Now, Tim Harrington's secret was out.
17:44He lived a very publicly straight lifestyle.
17:48His parents only knew him to date women.
17:51He was from Grenada, Mississippi.
17:53He had a very...
17:56His family was very well-to-do.
17:57Where he leads me.
17:59They also were the heads of the largest African-American church in Grenada.
18:06I love Jesus.
18:08He loves Jesus.
18:10Clap your hands as you...
18:11Tim's grandfather and father were the pastors.
18:13So it's a dishonor for us not to honor our father and mother.
18:18For the Bible's sake, if you dishonor it, that your days may be shortened.
18:22He hung out with very traditional masculine men.
18:26And that's what he...
18:28That's how he presented himself.
18:30He had a lot to lose if this was to get out.
18:34The night he came over.
18:36Yes, sir.
18:36Did y'all have sexual relations that night?
18:39Yes, sir.
18:40We did.
18:41Okay.
18:41Talk me through those.
18:42What happened?
18:43And again, when you walk out of here, you can tell them the thing you want.
18:46Yes, sir.
18:46I want the truth.
18:47And the truth is going to get nasty.
18:49I don't mind with that.
18:50Okay?
18:50Yes, sir.
18:51I do not care.
18:51So what happened when Jay Lee come over to the apartment?
18:54Yes, sir.
18:55So he came over and then, like, you know, he just gave me an order like you would do it.
19:01And so I doze it.
19:02So I doze it.
19:03Where did that happen at?
19:05To you?
19:05No apartment.
19:06In your apartment?
19:07But Tim says Jay Lee got angry at him for not reciprocating.
19:12I really didn't want to do, like, the oral thing or something.
19:14He got, like, upset with me.
19:15Because he was upset because he, uh, you wasn't telling him to give him the oral or did you give
19:21him the oral?
19:22Like, I told him, like, I was going to do the oral thing.
19:25I gave him to you or you didn't know him?
19:27Me and him.
19:28You didn't want to do it and he got upset.
19:30Yes, sir.
19:31That's when Jay Lee went home, sending a message detectives think Tim took as a threat to out him.
19:39At 4.36 a.m., Jay sends an iMessage text message to Tim saying,
19:46fun being the first guy, experiment over.
19:49I just wanted to be able to say I had you be DL.
19:52DL referring to down low.
19:54We think that at that point was the trigger that set Tim off.
19:58And you can see Tim, uh, frantically trying to lure, uh, Jay Lee back over to his apartment.
20:13He says to Tim that he'll only come back if he gets up front or in the front is what
20:18it says.
20:20Tim responds, hmm.
20:26And that's where Jay Lee headed when he was last seen alive that early morning of July 8th.
20:33Once Jay Lee commits to going back to Tim's apartment,
20:37Tim searches, how long does it take to strangle someone?
20:40All right, tell me what happens when Jay Lee comes back.
20:44When we come back and get in, like we do the same thing, I make it up to him.
20:49You make it up to him?
20:50Yeah, I did, like.
20:51Well, tell, isn't it?
20:53Yes, sir.
20:53And so, um, that was like...
20:57How do you feel right now, Tim?
21:00I mean, I don't know, I don't, I don't feel, like, I don't know.
21:07So he leaves after you give him oral sex?
21:10All right, yes, sir.
21:13And did you have any contact with him from that point before?
21:18No, I said we're gonna talk about it.
21:20Tim is only trying to give us what he believes we need to hear,
21:24uh, but he doesn't know what we know either.
21:28So it's kind of a cat and mouse game.
21:31Detectives knew Tim was not telling them the whole truth.
21:34We already have Tim running out of the apartment complex,
21:38and we have the witness that they gave him a ride.
21:41We wanted to hear Tim's version of it.
21:44Tim, bear with me here.
21:47Did you leave the apartment after, after, uh, Jay Lee left?
21:55Did you go anywhere?
21:58Yes, sir.
21:59Police ask him, like, what he did after that,
22:03and he is a little cagey.
22:06Where'd you go?
22:07I went to Walmart.
22:09Detectives later pulled surveillance video at the store,
22:12where he appears to have purchased a number of items,
22:15including a roll of duct tape
22:17that he said he used in his part-time moving business.
22:20Did you go around that morning?
22:21Yes, sir.
22:22Can I slide this out of the way?
22:27Yeah, I just want to come back to you.
22:32And Tim began to realize he was the mouse
22:35in the cat and mouse game.
22:44What did I say I wanted you to be?
22:47Complete the mouse.
22:48Okay.
22:53Remember, Tim.
22:54Yes, sir.
22:56Walk out of here.
22:57You can tell anybody anything you want.
22:59Yes, sir.
22:59But what did I tell you you need to tell me?
23:01Complete the truth.
23:02One, one, two, three.
23:03Okay.
23:12Be honest, Tim.
23:13Be honest.
23:14Yes, sir.
23:15Okay.
23:16Yes, sir.
23:17How'd you get over there?
23:19That's what I'm saying.
23:20I think with that thing,
23:22do I need to have a training or something at this point?
23:25And at that point in time,
23:27Tim's had enough talking with us,
23:28and he wants to end the interview.
23:31Okay.
23:32Whatever I don't say,
23:34we'll keep investigating.
23:35Would you not leave the year today?
23:37That's fine.
23:38At this point,
23:39we know that we have our person.
23:42But there was no confession,
23:44and more importantly for prosecutors,
23:46they still had no idea
23:47of the location of Jay Lee or his body.
24:02It's been 76 days since Ole Miss student Jimmy J. Lee disappeared in Oxford, Mississippi.
24:10A suspect is charged with murder, but Lee's body has yet to be found.
24:14In the months leading up to the trial, police searched frantically for Jay Lee's body.
24:19He needed the body.
24:21We understood that there was going to be that big hurdle.
24:26Police pulled surveillance video of Tim in his hometown of Grenada, Mississippi,
24:30showing up at his parents' house in the truck he used for his moving business.
24:35And you see Tim pull up in the box truck, gets out.
24:39You see him then load onto the box truck shovels and a wheelbarrow.
24:46But they did not know where he went next.
24:49We tracked Tim's movement.
24:51We spent weeks upon weeks,
24:53and we just can't find the body.
24:55Tim, I need you to help us find Jay Lee.
24:57There's a family group in mind.
24:59Do you understand?
25:00Yes, sir.
25:01Even after Tim had said he wanted a lawyer,
25:04detectives had tried one more time
25:05to get him to talk about where was Jay Lee.
25:08Where can we find Jay Lee, Tim?
25:10I don't know.
25:12I'm going to sit down low.
25:14I'm going to breathe.
25:20So they went to trial against Tim Harrington,
25:23charged with capital murder,
25:24with what's known to prosecutors as
25:26a notoriously difficult-to-prove-no-body homicide case.
25:30The biggest challenge with a no-body homicide case
25:33is that there's no definitive proof that the person is dead.
25:38The courtroom was packed with people supporting Jay Lee.
25:42It meant a lot to me to know that he had a lot of people
25:46that heard the story, saw what happened,
25:51and Riley behind us.
25:53Members of Tim's family were also in the courtroom,
25:56but the graphic details of the case had been upsetting
25:59to some in his church community.
26:01When the information came out that he was in a sexual relationship
26:05with Jay Lee, all the people that came from the church
26:09stood up and walked out.
26:10Good morning.
26:13You know that nobody was ever found.
26:22But the person, that body was a person,
26:27and his name was Jay Lee, the third.
26:34Jay Lee.
26:35He knew who he was, and he was confident in himself.
26:39If he wanted to wear heels that day, he was going to wear heels.
26:43If he wanted to wear silk pants, he was going to wear silk pants.
26:46This is not known to be a liberal state,
26:51and it's a pretty conservative place,
26:53and we worried that people might be put off
26:58because of having to hear all of this.
27:01The evidence will show that Tim,
27:03he's not openly in the LGBT community.
27:08In fact, he told the officers,
27:12I don't give that.
27:14What Jay wanted him to do.
27:18But despite that,
27:21he invited Jay back over
27:23with a promise that he was going to do something
27:25that we've never done before.
27:26Right before he gets there.
27:28A few minutes.
27:31Timothy searches
27:33how long does it take to strengthen someone?
27:37I'm going to ask
27:38that you provide the only verdict
27:41that justice will demand.
27:44And it's going to be guilty.
27:47Thank you.
27:56Kevin Horan is a prominent Mississippi defense lawyer
27:59and a member of the Mississippi House of Representatives.
28:02These are touching subjects
28:05for everybody to get involved in.
28:07It doesn't matter whether or not
28:09it's heterosexual conduct
28:12or otherwise.
28:14Nothing against the young man,
28:16but there's going to be
28:17a lot of information.
28:19I think you're going to hear
28:21about
28:23this police
28:25conduct
28:26prior to
28:28this night
28:30and the manner
28:31which he conducted himself.
28:32the defense attorney
28:34sort of tried to paint Jay
28:35in a negative light.
28:38Now, let's talk a little bit about
28:40what the state's required to approve
28:42and what I don't think their evidence
28:44is going to show.
28:45Proof of the dead.
28:47What's the problem?
28:50Proof of any dead whatsoever.
28:54Zero.
28:57DNA evidence.
28:58Blood.
28:59Urine.
29:02Trace evidence whatsoever.
29:05Trace evidence whatsoever.
29:05Ladies and gentlemen,
29:07you are not going to hear
29:09anything
29:11that supports
29:13a finding
29:14of a killing or a death.
29:17Period.
29:19only a third
29:20you can return
29:23going to be not given
29:24not the man's law
29:26not the second degree
29:27not the murder
29:28certainly not the capital murder
29:30or any of them.
29:35And that's what I'm going to ask you to do.
29:37Thank you.
29:45Jay's mother, Stephanie Lee
29:46told the jury
29:47she realized
29:48something was wrong
29:49when her son
29:50did not call her
29:51on her birthday.
29:53I was suspecting
29:54his call at that point
29:55because of
29:56him knowing that I'm up
29:57okay, the first thing
29:59he's going to do
29:59hey mama
30:00it's your birthday
30:00happy birthday
30:01I love you.
30:02And prosecutors
30:03hoped her testimony
30:04would prove
30:05that Jay Lee
30:06was dead.
30:07Since that time
30:08I know you talked about
30:08have there been any charges
30:09that you've had to pay
30:10for Jay's credit cards?
30:12No ma'am.
30:13Have there been any
30:15withdrawals
30:16from his accounts?
30:17No ma'am.
30:17Has Jay ever
30:19disappeared
30:20for long periods of time?
30:22No ma'am.
30:23The pain
30:24of her heart
30:25right there
30:25on that stand
30:26I could feel
30:27every bit of it
30:29you know
30:31but she said
30:32she knew
30:32she knew
30:32she had to do it.
30:35but she would not
30:36be the only parent
30:37to testify
30:38at this trial
30:39as Tim Harrington's
30:40father and grandfather
30:42would take the stand
30:43and be asked
30:44if they accepted
30:45his son's sexuality.
30:55The capital murder trial
30:56for Sheldon
30:57Timothy Harrington Jr.
30:59now enters
30:59its second week.
31:01Prosecutors
31:01have spent
31:02the first week
31:02building their case
31:04with circumstantial evidence.
31:06I think everyone
31:07knew it would be
31:08a challenge.
31:09You still don't know
31:11where Jay Lee's body is.
31:12And the search
31:13of Tim Harrington's apartment
31:15showed no evidence
31:16of a crime
31:17being committed.
31:18You don't have DNA.
31:19You don't have any
31:20biological evidence
31:21in the apartment
31:23to suggest violence.
31:26So they built the case
31:27with the surveillance video
31:29of Jay Lee
31:29coming and going
31:31and with
31:31Tim Harrington's
31:32interviews with police
31:34where he initially lied
31:35about having sex with Jay.
31:37Yeah.
31:37Do you think you don't have
31:38a sexual relationship
31:39of any kind?
31:40No, I'm not sure.
31:41Only that.
31:41Okay.
31:42Plus, testimony
31:44from Detective Ryan Baker
31:45about what he recovered
31:47from Tim Harrington's phone,
31:49including that damning
31:50internet search.
31:52At 5.57 a.m.,
31:55Mr. Harrington
31:58searches in Google.
32:00Does a Google search
32:00how long does it take
32:02to strangle someone?
32:04Did you learn anything
32:05about Mr. Harrington's sexuality
32:07over the course
32:08of your investigation?
32:09Yes.
32:10Mr. Harrington
32:11was not openly gay.
32:13His cell phone extractions,
32:15his social media,
32:19just all through the investigation
32:20of looking into him,
32:21that he was not
32:23portraying himself
32:24as being that way.
32:26When you're talking
32:27about a circumstantial
32:28evidence case,
32:29you need every circumstance
32:31that you can get
32:32to give to the jury.
32:34Can you tell the jury
32:36who you are?
32:37My name is Khalid Fierce.
32:39And then a friend
32:41of Jay Lee's
32:41who spoke to him
32:42on the phone
32:43just before he went
32:44to Tim's apartment
32:45the second time
32:46and warned Jay Lee
32:48to be careful.
32:49Yeah, I would tell him
32:51that a down-low man
32:54or a man
32:54who isn't comfortable
32:55with their sexuality
32:56is not someone
32:57you want to be out here
32:59hooking up with.
33:00I was like,
33:01because, you know...
33:05what did you tell him?
33:07I told him I said
33:07they would kill you
33:08before their dirty
33:09little secret
33:09gets exposed.
33:14State your name
33:15for the record
33:15and if you would.
33:16Sheldon,
33:17Timothy Harrington, Sr.
33:18and what is your relationship
33:20if any to the defendant
33:21Timothy Harrington?
33:22Tim is my son.
33:24The defense wanted
33:25the father's testimony
33:26to show that
33:27Tim would not have been
33:29shunned for being gay.
33:31Did Tim accept him
33:32and love him
33:33like he gave
33:33to judge your other children?
33:34Sure.
33:35Did he have gay friends?
33:37Do you know?
33:39I'm not sure
33:40if he had
33:40gay friends.
33:42I'm not sure about that.
33:43Witness him
33:44at any time
33:45treat anybody
33:46that was part
33:48that was gay
33:49or bisexual
33:49when you think
33:50wrong was like
33:51you could witness
33:51you treat those individuals
33:53any different?
33:54No.
33:56No burglars.
33:57Call the nomination?
33:59Good afternoon, Sr. Harrington.
34:01Good afternoon.
34:03Has Timothy
34:04ever
34:06brought
34:06any girlfriends
34:07or anything
34:08in relationships
34:09to church with him?
34:10Sure.
34:11Okay.
34:12Has he ever brought
34:12any boyfriends
34:13or relationships
34:14to church with him?
34:15No.
34:16And were you aware
34:18that Timothy
34:18had an interest
34:19in men?
34:20No.
34:21Today are you aware
34:22that he has
34:23an interest in men?
34:24By the proceedings,
34:25yes.
34:26So after the reports
34:27came out
34:28is when you
34:28discovered that?
34:29Yes.
34:30So he was not
34:30open with you
34:31about that?
34:32No.
34:33Is that something
34:34that your church
34:35approves of?
34:37Not necessarily
34:38the church
34:38approves of.
34:40I think that
34:43with that
34:44people have
34:44their own opinions
34:45about it.
34:46His father testified
34:47that he would have
34:48accepted him
34:49but the
34:50larger church
34:51community
34:52I'm not so sure.
34:54Now
34:54the defense
34:55had to decide
34:56whether Tim
34:56would testify.
34:57have you reached
34:58the decision
35:00about the decision
35:01whether you reach
35:02to testify in this
35:03case or reach
35:04not to testify?
35:05I have.
35:06What is that
35:06decision?
35:07I want to testify.
35:08all right
35:08and at this time
35:09the defense is resting
35:11correct?
35:12Correct.
35:15What the state has proven
35:17is that Tim
35:18Harrington
35:18lived a lot.
35:20Not only did he lie
35:21to his family
35:22and his friends
35:23about his sexuality
35:26being on the damn
35:27they all thought
35:29he was into women
35:31in order to protect
35:32that lie
35:33he had to give
35:34him to the jailer.
35:35That's what he did.
36:01Harrington's lawyer told the jury
36:02the police should have looked
36:03more into J. Lee's sex life
36:06to find the killer.
36:07They should have
36:08broadened their scope
36:09a little bit more
36:10and said
36:11let's look at these things
36:12going on in
36:13Jimmy Lee's life
36:15just look at some of the
36:17other people
36:17outside
36:18of this
36:19direct circle.
36:20and he said
36:22the text that J. Lee
36:23sent to Tim
36:24was hardly
36:25a threat.
36:26I don't know exactly
36:27what they're talking about
36:28but it didn't sound to me
36:30like J. Lee
36:32is making any type
36:34threat to
36:35Tim Harrington
36:36that he's going to add on.
36:39That's what the state
36:40wants you to believe.
36:42But this man
36:43killed
36:46J. Lee
36:48over this one word.
36:49He said
36:50it's safe
36:51no facts to support
36:53because we just don't know
36:54what they were talking about.
36:55The most reasonable burden
36:57the one that's supported
36:59by the lack of evidence
37:01is not given.
37:03Thank you.
37:04As the court went into recess
37:06and the jury began
37:07its deliberations
37:09prosecutors were confident
37:10they had proved their case
37:12what happened next
37:13would come as a shock.
37:26We're following breaking news tonight
37:28jury deliberations
37:29in the capital murder trial
37:30of an Ole Miss graduate
37:32accused of murder
37:34going into the sixth hour now.
37:35and jurors twice
37:36told the judge
37:37they were deadlocked.
37:39All right ladies and gentlemen
37:40the jury
37:41I have received
37:42another note
37:43that says
37:44we are unable
37:46to reach the agreement.
37:47One of the jurors
37:48very angrily
37:49I might add
37:49he said
37:50yes
37:5111 to 1.
37:52There was an audible gasp
37:54in the
37:54entire courtroom.
37:56You had one hold down.
37:57They were not going to
37:59convict without a body
38:00no matter how much
38:01how strong the evidence was
38:03there was no way
38:03they were going to
38:04convict without a body.
38:09I'm going to play
38:10on a mistrial.
38:12I appreciate your effort.
38:17I'm going to let y'all
38:19do the jury room.
38:21It was one of the biggest
38:22gut punches
38:23I've ever experienced.
38:24Jay's father was angered
38:26as he watched
38:27Tim Harrington's reaction.
38:28It was like
38:29I beat this
38:30let's go
38:31yeah
38:31yeah
38:32I beat this
38:33let's go.
38:34The prosecutors vowed
38:35to put Harrington
38:36on trial again.
38:38I was immediately ready
38:39to go again
38:40100%.
38:41And then
38:42two months later
38:43a discovery
38:44in a rural field.
38:45It was a
38:46unseasonably hot day
38:48in the south
38:49in February
38:49and so there was
38:50a landowner
38:51that was out and about.
38:58and as he's checking
39:00he sees
39:01what he believes
39:02to be a skull.
39:05More than two years
39:06after he was reported
39:07missing
39:07the remains
39:08of Ole Miss student
39:09Jimmy J. Lee
39:11have officially
39:12been found.
39:13Mississippi Today
39:14reports a gold necklace
39:16with missing Ole Miss student
39:17Jimmy J. Lee's name on it
39:19was found on those
39:20human remains.
39:21To have your child
39:23you know
39:23you know they're gone
39:24but you know
39:25their body
39:27you know
39:27laying off
39:28in a ditch
39:29or in a
39:30wooded area
39:32in a field
39:33or whatever
39:33that
39:35that's a
39:35added
39:36you know
39:37pain
39:38is like
39:38salt on your wound.
39:44Prosecutors now
39:45had the evidence
39:46they had hoped for.
39:47Jay was found
39:48approximately
39:4920 minutes
39:50from Tim's parents' house
39:52with the bonnet
39:52that we see
39:54is the last thing
39:56he was seen
39:57leaving his apartment
39:58wearing.
39:59A major piece
39:59of evidence
40:00that we had
40:01was Jay's body
40:02was found
40:02wrapped in
40:03moving blankets.
40:04which had been
40:05secured
40:06by duct tape.
40:08And the FBI lab
40:09found that the duct tape
40:11and its tear patterns
40:12matched the duct tape
40:14that Harrington
40:14had bought
40:15at Walmart
40:16the day
40:17Jay disappeared.
40:18We had Jay's body
40:19we could finally
40:20put the family
40:21at ease with that
40:22they could finally
40:23put him to rest
40:24and we had
40:25a smoking gun.
40:28Prosecutors now
40:28brought a new
40:29set of charges
40:30against Tim Harrington.
40:31This has got
40:32a hundred times harder.
40:33Harrington's
40:34new lawyer
40:35told his client
40:35the duct tape
40:36was a devastating
40:38piece of evidence.
40:39I said we have
40:40a fight on our hands
40:41like this is going
40:41to be an uphill battle
40:43in a capital murder case.
40:44Worst case scenario
40:45is life without
40:46the possibility
40:46of parole.
40:47We were picking
40:48the jury
40:48and the defense
40:49lawyer comes
40:50and says
40:51you know
40:52can you give me
40:53an offer?
40:54Harrington agreed
40:55to plead guilty
40:56to second degree murder
40:57and he admitted
40:58to everything
40:59in a private meeting
41:00with prosecutors.
41:02That he was
41:02triggered by that
41:03text message
41:04that he thought
41:06that Jay was
41:07going to out him.
41:08He said this was
41:12the first time
41:12he'd ever really
41:13said any of this
41:14out loud
41:15and that he
41:16felt good
41:17to admit it
41:18that he was
41:19very emotional
41:21very physically
41:23physically shaking
41:24and crying.
41:42The plea deal
41:44called for Harrington
41:45to serve 30 years
41:46in prison.
41:47Perhaps
41:48I'm hoping
41:49that
41:50you know
41:51he takes
41:52that time
41:53to reflect
41:53and truly
41:55you know
41:56seek God
41:57you know
41:58because
41:59you know
42:00he doesn't have
42:00to go to hell
42:01for this.
42:02The Bible
42:03lets us know
42:04that it's not
42:05in his will
42:05that any
42:06should perish.
42:07That includes
42:09Timothy.
42:09On the world
42:10of Mississippi
42:12got might
42:12this case
42:15was investigated
42:17more thoroughly
42:18than any case
42:19I've
42:20ever dealt
42:21with in my
42:2135 years
42:22in
42:23crepting
42:24death
42:24of Susan
42:25good care of
42:26him
42:27you still
42:28have a chance
42:29to lie
42:30just believe
42:31mom
42:31that you
42:32still have
42:32a chance
42:32to lie
42:33I'll encourage
42:34you
42:35to take
42:36advantage
42:36of that opportunity
42:39it's just awful
42:41that's what
42:42you would call
42:43a senseless murder
42:44there's no
42:45excuse
42:46to ever
42:46take someone's
42:47life
42:47I think
42:48his legacy
42:49to me
42:49is
42:51that of
42:52a person
42:53that
42:53didn't mind
42:54crossing barriers
42:56didn't mind
42:57doing
42:58whatever it
42:59took
42:59to help
43:01or be an
43:01influence
43:02of positivity
43:03to anyone
43:10boy