- 25 minutes ago
On News Track, Marya Shakil examines the political controversy surrounding Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi's sharp critique of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's foreign policy.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack and I'm Maria Shaquille.
00:04Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi has launched a sharp attack
00:07against Prime Minister Narendra Modi's foreign policy,
00:12claiming India has become a side player in global affairs.
00:16Speaking at the University of Chicago during his US visit,
00:19Rahul questioned Prime Minister Modi's diplomatic approach,
00:22arguing that personal friendships cannot drive foreign policy.
00:26He went further, sharing a photograph of the Trump-Xi-Putin meeting in Shenzhen
00:33and has claimed that a Congress-led government
00:35would have secured India a seat at that table.
00:38Rahul also alleged that Prime Minister Modi was compromised
00:41and unable to participate in crucial global conversations.
00:46The BJP hit back, accusing Rahul of damaging India's image abroad
00:51and echoing Pakistan's narrative.
00:53It questioned Congress' own foreign policy record,
00:56citing the 1962 China war
00:59and the 2009 Sharmul Sheikh talks with Pakistan.
01:04Rahul's remarks, the BJP argued, put national interest at stake.
01:09Union Minister Kiran Rajuju urged Rahul
01:12not to make statements against the country while overseas.
01:16The political sparring raises a larger question.
01:19Where does criticism of the government end
01:22and India's national interest begin?
01:25We'll be taking that up in debate in just a bit.
01:28First, take a look at the World Awards.
01:38India should be involved at the global level in these conversations.
01:43But frankly, India's a side player.
01:47I mean, I'm pretty shocked.
01:51The leader of opposition Rahul Gandhi is on a foreign visit.
01:59But his political offensive is firmly aimed back home.
02:02After a jibe at India's election process, economy and education system,
02:09now India's foreign policy is in the crosshairs.
02:12At the University of Chicago, Rahul Gandhi accused the Narendra Modi government
02:16of pushing India to the sidelines of global diplomacy.
02:20To make his case, he pointed to Pakistan,
02:23citing Islamabad's role in facilitating U.S.-Iran talks as evidence.
02:29India should be involved at the global level in these conversations.
02:34But frankly, India's a side player.
02:37I mean, I'm pretty shocked that Pakistan is busy negotiating with the Iranians and the Americans.
02:45Rahul also took aim at Prime Minister Modi's style of personal diplomacy.
02:50Our Prime Minister talks in terms of, he's my friend.
02:58You know, Trump is my friend.
03:02Putin is my friend.
03:04You know that friendship is not the point.
03:08Yeah.
03:09I mean, you and me know who gives a damn about friendship, man.
03:13You really think that geopolitics is going to work because the guy is your friend?
03:20He's leading a structure.
03:22He's got a whole economic system sitting under him.
03:26He's not going to make decisions based on whether he likes you or doesn't like you.
03:30And it did not stop there.
03:32Rahul, in a social media post, shared a photograph of Trump's Xi Putin meeting in Shenzhen,
03:38taking a swipe at Modi, saying Congress-led government would have secured India a seat at that high table.
03:44He went further, alleging that Modi was compromised and unable to engage in key global conversations.
03:51The BJP hit back, turning Rahul's foreign policy attack into a question about the Congress' own record.
03:58From the 1962 China war to the 2009 Sharm al-Sheikh talks with Pakistan,
04:05BJP accused Congress of compromising India's national interest and weakening its global standing.
04:27Union Minister Kiran Rijijju made a simple appeal to the leader of opposition.
04:32Stop attacking your own country.
04:59Rahul Gandhi may be taking his political battle overseas,
05:03but the BJP wants him to draw the line at India's national interest.
05:07The big question, should foreign policy become another casualty or political point scoring?
05:13Bureau Report, India Today.
05:17And as the word of words escalates, let's bring in a diplomatic perspective.
05:22Joining me now is former diplomat Casey Singh.
05:25Ambassador Singh, really appreciate your time.
05:28Can you hear me, sir?
05:34Ambassador Singh, can you hear me?
05:37Yes, now.
05:38Yes.
05:40Trump, Xi and Putin are increasingly shaping conversations on global security and geopolitics.
05:46Should India's absence from this engagement in Shenzhen be seen as a diplomatic setback,
05:52or is that an over-interpretation?
05:56I think foreign policy can't be assessed on the basis of one event or one meeting or one summit.
06:03You see, if you go over the last 21st century, the first 10 years were defined by unipolarity,
06:11polarity, where there was only America.
06:13So you had a BJP government, Vajpayee.
06:16He started negotiating the nuclear deal because he had tested the nuclear devices.
06:20So America-India relations had hit a bottom.
06:24Then when he left, when Monsingh carried on with the same.
06:29So the nuclear deal was not just created by Congress.
06:32It was BJP, started by BJP and finalized by Congress.
06:37And that's why Mr. Brijesh Misha finally supported it.
06:42Though initially he was critical of it, he was the first NSA, Vajpayee's NSA.
06:46Now, what has happened in between?
06:48So we have to realize that Trump has had two terms.
06:52There is the first term, when I think Prime Minister Modi invested a lot in the Indian diaspora,
06:58invested in a lot of personal connection with him, etc., and then came COVID.
07:03So that term was kind of disrupted.
07:05We didn't see it fully through.
07:07Now came Trump, too.
07:09And I think there, well, India has misread him, but so has Canada.
07:13So have the Europeans.
07:15So have Japan.
07:17Look at what yesterday, what was happening.
07:20Three of them sitting there is more threatening to Japan than to India.
07:24Yes, it is.
07:26You know, Trump has already created a lot of disruption.
07:29There's disruption of global trade, disruption of the global order, which was there after World War II.
07:35So that's why they are saying that, are these three who met yesterday trying to create another global order?
07:42But they never mentioned Ukraine war, never mentioned Iran war.
07:45They mentioned four points, and those are very general.
07:48How to make UN more effective.
07:50Well, UN will be more effective.
07:52The three of them didn't use the veto.
07:54Whereas countries like India, Brazil, Japan, Germany, we want the Security Council expanded.
08:00They're not talking about that.
08:01So we are at a point where, yes, Trump has pulled up China, pulled up Russia, given them a seat
08:09at the high table.
08:10But that may not last.
08:11Because by the time he gets back, the Democrats will be in position in January.
08:16And they'll start going after him and start analyzing his domestic policies, his foreign policy.
08:21So this may not last.
08:23Secondly, Ukraine war is not about to end.
08:25And I think the Ukrainian president said it.
08:27He says leaders of other countries, they keep thinking they can control the world.
08:32They can't.
08:32That was his reaction.
08:34So I think we can say that I don't think India would have got a place at that table.
08:39Because Trump has made up his mind that he's going to be dealing with these two authoritarian regimes.
08:44He's always in front of Putin.
08:47And with Xi, he has gone out of the way.
08:49Now, we say that Xi came to the airport to receive him.
08:52But he first, in September of this year, also went to the airport to receive Xi.
08:59Now, I don't think he will do that for any of the other prime ministers or leaders of NATO and
09:04anyone else.
09:05And look at Canada.
09:06It was the closest ally of America with tremendous trade links.
09:10It's completely disrupted.
09:12So we are in a disrupted world.
09:14Yes, I think the mistake, probably the mistake that India made was we aligned too closely with Israel and with
09:22UAE and the Abraham Accords,
09:25where you could see the war starting in Iran.
09:28And once that happened, I think India has been correcting it now.
09:30That's why they're now supporting all U.N. resolutions, which are pro-Palestine.
09:36I think, bit relatedly, we are correcting it.
09:39But I think aligning too closely, the moral is, if you align too closely with one leader, especially U.S.,
09:46that all connections break broken down.
09:48Because the Indian policy since 2000 was based on the assumption that America finds India important for dealing with China.
09:57Now, that's not the case.
09:58He's going and dealing with China directly.
10:01He met the Quad.
10:02But Quad, he kind of met with and said a few things and then really went to Shenzhen.
10:06And so it's an evolving new world in which I think value judgment is neither easy nor should be instantaneous.
10:14Ambassador Singh, who really emerged the best out of Shenzhen, according to you?
10:20You know, these three leaders went to Shenzhen with different objectives or perhaps they had different outcomes in their mind.
10:28Besides the optics, what do you think came out of that?
10:32Look, President Putin came out the best because he's got ICC warrants against him.
10:38And now, you know, amongst the four items that the three of them decided on, one is that ICC should
10:45have no right to go after any official of any country.
10:49Now, which are the officials they're going after?
10:51They're going after Netanyahu, which President Trump doesn't want, and they're going after Putin.
10:56So, essentially, ICC and the second commission, which looks out of the states, is U.N. monitored.
11:05It's essentially to see that human rights are observed.
11:08This is what America supported for the last 80 years.
11:13And now, you know, all of a sudden, Trump kind of changes and says ICC, although all three countries are
11:19not signatories to it.
11:20So, they're passing their judgment without being there.
11:23So, essentially, Putin is the one who was seen as having suffered, done badly in Ukraine, lost a lot of
11:31people, not winning there.
11:32And therefore, he was a pariah.
11:35He's managed to come back to the main table.
11:38So, he's the big winner.
11:39And the second winner is China.
11:41It is not Trump.
11:43Trump has raised the level of China.
11:45And that's what India always feared.
11:47He called his meeting with China G2.
11:49Now, if you create a new G2, that means countries like India, Brazil, Japan, European countries, Germany, you're putting them
11:57a level lower.
11:59No, it is not for him to decide what a level is.
12:01So, we have to go to—so, I think there's a correction which will have to be brought about in how
12:06you deal with Trump over the next two years.
12:10But he is going to be a very distracted leader.
12:12He's not going to be the same Trump as in the first two years.
12:15Let's see what the Democrats do.
12:19A couple of more questions.
12:20Is Pakistan gaining diplomatic ground at India's expense?
12:23That's what the opposition seems to suggest here in India, with Islamabad perhaps positioning itself as a channel between Washington
12:31and Tehran.
12:32Is Pakistan finding strategic relevance that India has been unable to leverage?
12:37Look, this is not new.
12:38This is what they did in the 50s.
12:40They became allies of America.
12:42They got weapons from them.
12:43And that is how they started the war in 1965.
12:47They had better planes than us, better tanks than us.
12:50So, they've done it many, many times.
12:52So, they massaged the ego of Trump.
12:55And they jumped into that thing that, you know, he stopped a nuclear war between India and this.
13:01And they suggested he should get a Nobel Prize.
13:04Now, they are very good at that.
13:06And they've done it.
13:07That's all right.
13:08Let them do it.
13:09But, yes, then they created the Mecca Pact, which is Saudi Arabia.
13:13So, what has happened in the Gulf is the Gulf is split now.
13:15So, it's not the old Gulf here.
13:18We could be dealing with all of them on the same level.
13:20UAE is all right.
13:21But UAE is isolated, too.
13:24But otherwise, other than UAE, Saudis, Turks, Pakistanis, they've gone into a separate group.
13:32So, you know, therefore, it is definitely Pakistan, like Putin.
13:36Trump has made Pakistan come up at the diplomatic level and given them diplomatic credence.
13:43Now, can they retain it?
13:45Can it continue?
13:46It will depend on the next president in America.
13:48It will depend on the next time.
13:49In America, there's a regime change every now and then.
13:52So, it's not permanent.
13:53Okay.
13:54I'm basing my last question.
13:55What we are seeing is a deeply polarized global climate.
13:59We are speaking at a time when there are two life conflicts already.
14:03How can India maintain its foreign policy message without domestic political differences weakening its international standing?
14:14Look, I think BJP has to realize that domestic politics and foreign policy are interrelated.
14:20You can't treat that as separate from the other.
14:22Now, you take the diaspora.
14:24How much PM has invested in the diaspora in these countries, especially America?
14:28As a single person, they have squeaked when Trump came after us.
14:33They won't.
14:34It's all right.
14:35If your relationship is normal, they see the U.S. president and the Prime Minister friendly, they'll come to your
14:40meetings.
14:41Now they're worried about ICE.
14:42They're worried about their visas being canceled.
14:44They've got other concerns.
14:46So, essentially, once they become American citizens or they have residency there, you can't count on them to fight your
14:52battle.
14:53That is one thing.
14:55And the other one is that, yes, we have to essentially—we could have anticipated some of it, but most countries
15:01have got it wrong.
15:02So, not just India.
15:03Nobody thought Trump will go down this road this way.
15:07So, now there's rectification.
15:08I think we have to get together with Europe.
15:11We have to meet with Japan and Australia.
15:13We're already doing it separately.
15:15You have to get ready for a world where U.S. may not be a major factor, and China will
15:21be a bigger factor.
15:22Now, how do we deal with it?
15:23I think that's what the next 10 years are going to show.
15:27All right.
15:28Ambassador Casey Singh, really appreciate your time.
15:30Thank you so much for joining us here on the show.
15:33And let me open this debate and bring in Rakesh Sina, former Rajesh Sabha MP of the BJP.
15:38Dr. Amol Deshmukh is the Congress spokesperson.
15:41Rajiv Bhatia is former Indian ambassador.
15:43We also have Sandeep Unitan, senior journalist.
15:46And here in the studio is my colleague Pranayupadhyay, editor of India Today Global.
15:52Rakesh Sina, Rahul Gandhi says a Congress prime minister would have been sitting alongside Trump, Xi, and Putin.
16:01Should the government be concerned that India was missing from a conversation involving three major powers?
16:10No, I think Rahul Gandhi has been demonstrating low moral, low nationalist morality.
16:19Whenever he goes outside the country, he speaks something which is embarrassment for every Indian, not only the government.
16:26And I think that he is being used by the international forces to defame India.
16:33He is a tool.
16:34And I think this Congress party has do seriously soul searching.
16:41Outside the country, the way you are defaming the country, you are not defaming the prime minister and the Bharati
16:47Janata Party.
16:48For an outsider, India is a nation.
16:52It does not belong to a particular government.
16:55We are not a fractured politics.
16:57That fractured politics is a domestic affairs.
17:00Second important thing is that you see Prime Minister Narendra Modi's diplomacy.
17:06That he safeguarded India's interest in the scenario when the world is not bipolar due to ideological reason.
17:17Previous Cold War was based on ideological, basis was ideology.
17:22The Soviet Union, former Soviet Union, America, the two polars, and one communism, other capitalist class.
17:28Here, that was easy to handle.
17:31Here, bipolarization is based on the trades, lowest level of the national interest, America, Russia, or even the Saudi countries
17:44are playing.
17:45In that situation, when China is playing its own card, America is playing its own card, Russia is playing its
17:51own card,
17:51in that situation, very diplomatically, Prime Minister created delusions among these world powers.
17:58They consider sometimes that India is very closest to them.
18:01And in that situation, India is safeguarded its national interest to see the minimum impact of war on India.
18:12India could not be dragged into the petty politics between these forces during the war.
18:18We are friends of Israel, but we could not be dragged.
18:22Okay, Dr. Amul Deshmukh, Rahul Gandhi is saying that Congress Prime Minister would have been sitting at the table.
18:27On what basis?
18:28What specific diplomatic relationships or strategic interventions would have secured India that position?
18:36If you see, Modi has made India a side player on the world stage, and Rahul Gandhi is saying so
18:42is a service to the nation.
18:44Not an insult delivered abroad.
18:46That's number one.
18:47If you look at Pakistan getting a room for Iran and U.S. while India watches, is a clear sign
18:55to that effect.
18:55Let's have Rakeef Sina also on the screen, please.
18:56Go ahead.
18:57If you look at India's trade dependence on China, which is about to hit about $150 billion in deficit, and
19:05through an unresolved border conflict, which has been going on for months, and that's not been resolved, there's no answer
19:12to that.
19:13Given these aspects, it's quite clear that India doesn't get a table amongst U.S., Russia, and China is symbolic
19:23enough for the whole world, where India stands today.
19:27And that is amply clear and made a statement abroad doesn't differ because we are living in a globalized world,
19:35and that needs to be considered by every citizen.
19:37But India is not a member of APEC. Why should its absence from this particular meeting be interpreted as a
19:43diplomatic failure?
19:45So it's not an APEC meeting that the U.S., Russia, and China have done.
19:50It is on the sidelines. So let's not fool ourselves or anybody else.
19:55No, I mean, there has to be certain explanation. You are saying that India has become a side player.
20:01What about India's continuing engagement with Russia, the U.S., the Quad, the BRICS, and the Global South?
20:09As Mr., the general already said, that India has done mistake by being two together, being very close to Israel
20:17and UAE.
20:18And now we are trying to get away with it, already tells that.
20:23India has a history where we had the non-aligned movement started by Nehruji, and that as a fresh country.
20:30And by 1983, when Indira Ji was at the U.N. summit, she was talking on behalf of 100 nations.
20:38And that was the seat that India had way back in 1983.
20:43Coming to even Vajpayeejee's, he was able to handle even the sanctions and take it forward.
20:51What about Modi?
20:51Ragesh Sina, please respond to that, and then I'll bring in others.
20:54Ragesh Sina.
20:56No, I am really surprised.
21:00The Congress spokesperson forgave that it was Nehrubian regime that India lost almost 36,000 square kilometers to China,
21:10and not only one, two, three, four, five, hundreds of the Jawans, martyred because they lacked the weapons.
21:18And they are talking about the China.
21:20They made the entire border unsafe.
21:22It is during the Modi regime that the Indo-China border is highly safeguarded.
21:28Infrastructure at the border, unprecedented.
21:31That is a reason for China's anxieties for India.
21:34Second important thing, as for Pakistan, is concern.
21:37Pakistan is merely a tool.
21:39Whatever America or any country does for Pakistan, it lacks the credibility.
21:44You know, during the last 10 years, particularly during the war regime, Prime Minister Modi emerged as a most credible
21:52world leader among the global south.
21:57He is a raise of hope.
21:59You see the way China is trying to hegemonize it, and America is openly demonstrating its greed.
22:06Russia is doing everything conditional.
22:09In that situation, it is only India, which is also playing a vital role among these so-called super-powered
22:17developed countries,
22:18as well as it is taking the leadership of the global south.
22:21I think that non-alignment was a bankrupt movement.
22:25It has nothing to do with the national interest.
22:27That was only a mask for the country to hide its weakness, not protect its national interest.
22:34Now, the concept of non-alignment was good, but India, it became more symbolic than substantive.
22:41Here, Modi is playing substantive.
22:43And I was listening.
22:44You are talking to some diplomat.
22:47You know, Prime Minister Modi used the Indian diaspora as a vibrant, vibrant class.
22:56They all became very active, and they became just like a protector of India's interest.
23:02And that is a pressure group among the countries, in different countries.
23:07They are acting as a pressure group, which were not earlier done.
23:11So, here I consider that, as for foreign policy is concerned,
23:17any leader going outside must think that he is representing India.
23:23Okay.
23:23There may be differences between the opposition party, the ruling party,
23:27but that should not demean our own country, demean our own foreign policy,
23:31demean our own constitutional leadership, Prime Minister and President.
23:34Ambassador Ajeev Bhatia, should India's absence from this meeting worry us,
23:38or is Rahul Gandhi reading too much into a photograph?
23:41No, I think I would use your previous phrase.
23:45This is very much an overstatement.
23:48I think India should be very realistic in terms of dealing with the world today.
23:55There is no basis at all to expect that India would be at that table.
24:00As you rightly pointed out, it is essentially an epic conference.
24:05There is on the sideline a meeting that is being called.
24:09That's okay.
24:09I think, as an experienced and mature nation,
24:13we should take these things in our stride.
24:15I would also suggest that, you know, this is not a new Yalta.
24:22It is not a defining moment where the world is going to change completely.
24:27India has a very strong role to play in the world affairs today.
24:31We must recognize that foreign policy of India has been always showing a blend
24:38of continuity and change.
24:40It is a dynamic foreign policy.
24:43It is not a static foreign policy.
24:45It is based on principles and values, but it changes with the change in time, with the
24:52change in the world.
24:53Therefore, my central point would be that if political parties want to make hands of those
25:01who run foreign policy strong, they must first have a serious dialogue within the country.
25:08And I would actually use this opportunity to call upon some of the leading think tanks of
25:13this country to organize a series of roundtables on foreign policy so that the representatives
25:20of various political parties can sit down, discuss, understand each other, and develop a consensus among themselves.
25:28That will be the sure guarantee to ensure that India's national interests are fully preserved and protected.
25:36Ambassador, is the Trump-Shi-Putin meeting a defining moment in global geopolitics?
25:43Could we be looking at a new G3 that increasingly sidelines other major powers?
25:48Ambassador, on the basis of being a former foreign policy practitioner for 37 years
25:54and a humble student of Indian foreign policy for the past 15 years, I would say that I'm
26:01quite skeptical about this.
26:04In the first stance, it looks more at drama, more optics, because we know that each of them
26:12has serious differences among themselves.
26:14They have not announced yet whether this would be a regular feature.
26:19We have studied and dissected that four-point peace declaration, which is really without any substance.
26:28So, I think this whole storm created by a 90-minute meeting where everything is scripted,
26:36including very much naturally the document which was issued.
26:40We should be a mature nation, we should take it in our stride, and we should not feel that
26:47this is the end of the world.
26:48India is doing well in terms of foreign policy.
26:51I would not say everything is hunky-dory, essentially, because this is the world of turbulence,
26:58this is the world of tension, this is the world of unpredictability.
27:02This is the time when India's political class, India's academia, India's scholars and thinkers
27:09must join hands, understand India's national interests, and advise the government together
27:15as to how they should play their hand.
27:18Okay.
27:19So, let me bring in the two editors of our channel.
27:23Come in now, Sandeep Unithan and Pranev Padeh.
27:27Prane, coming to you first, how do you look at Rahul Gandhi's charge?
27:32You know, there is other criticism that India's foreign policy is also perhaps becoming too
27:37personality-driven.
27:38You know, Maria, as leader of opposition, he's all entitled to take a dig on, you know,
27:44Prime Minister Modi or, you know, ruling party.
27:47He's well entitled to do that.
27:48But as far as, you know, what exactly he's trying to attribute, because, you know, I can share
27:54those pictures with you just a year ago, when in Tianjin, Prime Minister Modi, Xi Jinping
27:59and President Putin were, you know, holding hands.
28:03There was a picture and there was a reaction in Washington, D.C.
28:06U.S. President made a very scathing remark regarding that meeting.
28:11That was also a trilateral meeting taking place on the sidelines of the SCO summit.
28:15And, in fact, it was one of the close aid of President Vladimir Putin, Khilal Dimitri,
28:22who's one of the key interlocator with Washington, D.C., for Kremlin.
28:25He made a social media post, and I can share that social media post with you.
28:30In that social media post, he said that perhaps these three leaders are missing their friend,
28:35Donald Trump.
28:36So, as a country, you know, as a rapidly, fastly growing economy, as an, you know, aspiring
28:42country, ambitious country, Indians or people in India, political class in India might have
28:48an expectation to be included in every important table.
28:52But every country decides and defines their own national interests based on their priorities,
28:58their own national objectives.
29:00And India is also well entitled to do so.
29:02India has multiple, you know, forums, multiple trilaterals with a similar set of leaders.
29:08India is part of definite and different groupings.
29:11I kind of agree with Ambassador Rajiv Bhatia, and I completely echo his ideas that there should
29:17be some common minimum consensus in this country as far as the foreign policy objectives are
29:22concerned, because we are dealing with a very turbulent world right now, Maria.
29:26And it is so important to go and convey a very informed messaging for the larger audience
29:32in this country so that we can have a consensus on our national priorities.
29:38Look, foreign policy objectives should remain same.
29:41You know, not static, but there should be a common approach.
29:45Dana, you know, diplomacy can be dynamic.
29:47Your approach to a story could be different than my approach towards that story.
29:51But obviously the story is important.
29:53And in this case, India's story is a beautiful story.
29:56And we have seen United States changing its approach as far as the Russia-Ukraine conflict
30:01is concerned.
30:02You have seen what has changed from Joe Biden administration to Donald Trump administration.
30:06While if you see India's approach, India always maintained that the dialogue and diplomacy
30:10is the only way forward.
30:12Now these countries are coming and echoing the same thing, that dialogue and diplomacy is
30:17the only way forward.
30:18And these issues cannot be resolved on the battlefield.
30:22All right.
30:22Thank you so much for joining us, Rakesh Sina, Dr. Deshmukh and Ambassador Bhatia.
30:27And that's all from me on this edition of NewsTrack.
30:30Thanks so much for watching.