• 14 minutes ago
Rahul Gandhi faced backlash after critical remarks on Modi government during his US visit. His comments sparked debate on voicing internal issues abroad or domestically.
Transcript
00:00So let's begin first with this report.
00:02It's a political fresh flashpoint that's erupted after the leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi,
00:08made one remark after another, and this time in New York.
00:11He was speaking at the Columbia University and multiple engagements that he was a part of.
00:15Rahul Gandhi launched this scathing attack, except on his screen,
00:19targeting the Modi government, questioning India's electoral credibility,
00:23economic vision, and the functioning even of the central agencies.
00:27Rahul Gandhi's remarks have triggered a sharp BJP counterattack, expectedly immediately,
00:32with the ruling party accusing him of maligning India on foreign soil.
00:37So the question we are asking, is this criticism valid?
00:41Is it about India's reality being mentioned on foreign soil?
00:44Or is this about defaming country and talking about internal politics?
00:49And is it a way of asking for foreign actors?
00:53All that and more first in this report.
00:59From questions over the 2024 Lok Sabha election results,
01:03to serious allegations against central agencies,
01:07Rahul Gandhi has launched a wide-ranging attack on the Narendra Modi government from foreign soil.
01:13During an interaction at Columbia University in New York,
01:17the leader of opposition raised a host of issues,
01:19questioning the government's economic vision, electoral credibility, and approach to education.
01:26Addressing the recent wave of dissent,
01:28Rahul Gandhi said that student protests had broken the climate of fear in India
01:32and warned that the government's response to mounting protests could turn violent.
01:40If the pressure goes beyond a certain point, which it will,
01:44the government will react nastily.
01:47But the government will not be so kind
01:53and will probably react violently and aggressively.
01:59Rahul Gandhi stressed that restoring India's electoral system is a priority
02:03and alleged election rigging.
02:06He claimed that insiders in the election commission are sharing information with the Congress.
02:10Rahul also pointed to what he described as growing discontent within the bureaucracy,
02:15claiming that officials within the CBI and the ED are leaking information about alleged government wrongdoing.
02:22What's interesting is there is also a revolt in the bureaucracy.
02:26And there's also a revolt in the coercive arrangements of the state.
02:31You know, the CBI, the ED, the intelligence agencies,
02:35they're also revolting.
02:37And they are giving us information about this type of wrongdoing.
02:42So I'm quite positive.
02:46And making a pitch for his own political identity,
02:49Rahul said Prime Minister Modi could not compete with his distinctive style,
02:53citing the 4,000-kilometre Bharat Joro Yatra.
02:58As a politician, even Mr. Modi does not actually compete with anyone.
03:05If you think about it,
03:07he's fundamentally different than all other politicians in India.
03:11Would you agree with that?
03:13The BJP was quick to hit back,
03:15calling Rahul Gandhi immature, anti-India and the Mir Jafar of India.
03:19The BJP has said that every Indian feels ashamed by his statements.
03:40The Saffron party has also gone all guns blazing at Rahul over his dick at the BJP's 2047 Viksit Bharat
03:47target.
03:49I also don't think GDP is the best number.
03:54I think it's a very deceptive number.
03:56There's no GDP number that says how settle your money.
04:00So to me, it's a hollow number.
04:22The Rao comes just days after a massive political storm had erupted when an Italian politician
04:28raised the slogan, Vote Chor Gaddi Chor, at a Congress event in Hyderabad.
04:33Vote Chor Gaddi Chor.
04:40Courtesy translation, Vote Thief, leave your seat.
04:45As the showdown intensifies, the question is, do Rahul's remarks abroad amount to defaming the country
04:52or criticism of the government.
04:54Piyon Report, India Today.
05:04Let's debate and discuss and let's try and understand what is the strategy with our politicians
05:09talking about India's internal politics on foreign soil.
05:12Joining me from the Bharatiya Janata Party.
05:14The party has been all guns blazing against Rahul Gandhi.
05:18BJP National Spokesperson Sanju Verma is joining us.
05:21Also the party that's expectedly defending their leader, Bhavya Narasimha Murthy,
05:26Congress National Spokesperson.
05:28And he's been a former senior journalist.
05:30He's joining us as an author, political analyst, Ashutosh as well.
05:34Let's start with Congress.
05:36Bhavya, help me understand this.
05:37Why would a leader of opposition of the country in the Lok Sabha,
05:41senior leader of the opposition party,
05:43consistently speak about these issues of India's internal politics,
05:47realities or defaming is subjective.
05:49But speaking about it, on foreign soil,
05:52if it is not about asking for foreign actors to intervene.
05:56What else is it?
06:00So the problem is where he spoke or about what he spoke?
06:04Both.
06:04I just want to be sure before I answer.
06:06Both.
06:06Both.
06:08Starting with what he spoke, he stated facts from government agencies.
06:15Whether it is about inflation, the WPI inflation is 22% in October.
06:22All right.
06:23And sorry, 12% in October, which was 11% in September.
06:28He's speaking about the price hikes, which is actually affecting the people of India.
06:34All right.
06:35Not just that.
06:36The top 1% of India's population is actually holding 40% of its wealth.
06:42And it is actually, the national income is 22.6% of national income has been held by top 1%.
06:51And I don't see anything wrong in what he spoke.
06:55Although now, coming to the point of where he spoke.
07:00Yes.
07:00Here, I would like to make two points.
07:02You know, I am an alumni of Columbia University and the same school,
07:06School of International and Public Affairs.
07:12There, the master's degree is public administration, where we, you know, prepare ourselves to be policy analysts and experts and
07:20policy makers.
07:21When you go there, and it is not just one country he is speaking in.
07:25Let me tell you, the class consists, during my time, it consisted of students from 89 nationals.
07:32People who are passionate about, there we just not study about India or America.
07:36We study about every country, the economy of every country, the politics of every country.
07:41All right.
07:42The second point is, when Narendra Modi can stand on a political platform in America and say that he is
07:48ashamed of India,
07:50you expect a leader of opposition not to speak about the government's inefficiency.
07:57Although, Mr. Gandhi did not speak anything.
08:01No, no.
08:02I am just asking, what comment are you referring to about PM Modi saying he is ashamed of India?
08:05Oh, PM Modi has said he was ashamed of being an Indian before 2014.
08:1014.
08:11Yeah, he has said that.
08:13Okay, so you are saying that it is the same.
08:14But, Mr. Gandhi has only said, and Mr. Gandhi has never spoken about India.
08:18The way BJP is portraying, BJP is a political party.
08:23BJP is not India.
08:25BJP is at the center of forming a government today.
08:28They are not there forever.
08:30They cannot identify themselves as India.
08:32India is a country.
08:34Because Rahul Gandhi loves India, he is speaking for India and against every corruption that is happening here.
08:41Okay, point, point.
08:42And the inefficiency of the government.
08:44So, please do not term this as he is speaking against the country.
08:47Okay, let the BJP respond to that.
08:49Sanjeev, you heard.
08:51What was wrong, what he said, where he said it, it should be seen as common and normal.
08:56And after all, he is speaking against BJP government, not India.
09:01You know, Pooja, I am an economist, you know, by education.
09:06I worked in one of the world's biggest global investment banks, JP Morgan.
09:10I have served in desks across the United States of America, UK, Hong Kong, Australia.
09:15So, I know a lot more than just textbook economics.
09:19You know, I have been a high-profile investment banker, if that helps.
09:22Now, let me tell you something.
09:24And this is what your audience needs to know.
09:26Rahul Gandhi was spewing gibberish and vicious lies from fragile five.
09:32Today, India last quarter grew at 7.8%.
09:35In the September quarter, we are expected to have a GDP growth of 7.7%.
09:40And let's not talk about wholesale inflation.
09:43Between 2023 and 2025, the wholesale inflation was negative.
09:48And at that time, Congress, Darbaris used to come on television channels and say,
09:52oh, wholesale inflation is not the correct yardstick.
09:55It is retail inflation.
09:56So, let me tell you, between May and October, average retail inflation is 4.8%.
10:03The fiscal deficit today is 4.4%.
10:06Under Congress, it was 6.7%.
10:09The current account deficit today is less than 1%.
10:12Under Congress, it was 5.9%.
10:14Forex reserves under Congress were $287 billion.
10:18Today, it is $720 billion.
10:22And guess what?
10:23You want to reveal the source also, Sanju.
10:25Where are you quoting this from?
10:26Pooja, I heard her.
10:29You did not interject.
10:30I need my time.
10:31You can then question me.
10:32Sure.
10:32All these data points.
10:34Can I please?
10:35You are number to Sanju Verma.
10:37Please hold your horses.
10:38Let Sanju respond.
10:38Yes, go ahead.
10:39Yes.
10:39I don't know why she gets so rattled and starts smiling in a stupid manner without having correct data at
10:44her disposal.
10:45No personal remarks.
10:46So, let me now talk to the...
10:47Now, don't interject me, Pooja.
10:49What is the source?
10:50The source is Finance Ministry Archives.
10:53The source is available in public domain.
10:57Okay.
10:57The source is secondary sources, primary sources.
11:00The whole world knows.
11:01Forget Sanju Verma.
11:02IMF, World Bank, OECD, Asian Development Bank, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley.
11:10Till six months back, each of these institutions were saying India in FY27 will grow at perhaps 6.4%
11:18or thereabouts.
11:19Today, all of them are saying India will grow at 7% or more.
11:23And mind you, Goldman Sachs barely 48 hours back said the U.S. this year and next year, 2.3
11:30% and 2.4%.
11:31The world economy this year and next year, 2.7% and 2.8%.
11:36China this year and next year, 4.5% and 4.4%.
11:40And what does Goldman say about India?
11:42One minute.
11:43Goldman says Indian GDP growth will be 7.9% this year and 7.2% next year.
11:52This is not WhatsApp University saying so.
11:54No, we are also putting out data.
11:56We are also putting out data.
11:57Quotings from the World Bank report.
11:59Situation is better.
12:00Sanju.
12:00Second point.
12:02Then second point.
12:03So, are facts the issue?
12:04Or the fact that he spoke in the U.S.A. is a problem?
12:07Quickly, then I'll go to Ashraf.
12:08I have one little point to make.
12:12What Modi ji said in 2010 or 2012, I can turn around and say,
12:16did Narendra Modi, when he was the chief minister of Gujarat,
12:19ever say that Bharat mein vote chauri hoti hai?
12:22That there was vote kept?
12:24Did he lump on and criticize the judiciary?
12:26No.
12:27And do you remember, Puja?
12:28In 2013, at the UNGA meet,
12:31the dead Pakistani prime minister, Nawaz Sharif,
12:34called the dead prime minister of India, Manmohan Singh.
12:37Dehati Aurat.
12:39Who opposed Nawaz Sharif's deplorable comments?
12:43Okay.
12:43It was the BJP.
12:44It was the RSS.
12:46We said calling the sitting prime minister of India.
12:49Then in 2013, Dehati Aurat is absolutely condemnable.
12:53But today, Rahul Gandhi, he's laughing like a spoilt, entitled brat,
12:58saying,
12:59vote chaur, gaddi chaur,
13:00jo log goltai hai hai,
13:01Bharat mein aakar,
13:02on Indian soil at an Indian event,
13:04Rahul Gandhi starts jeering, cheering, sneering and clapping.
13:08Shame on Rahul Gandhi.
13:09Shame on Congress party.
13:10Shame on the Italian road.
13:12Is it about,
13:13even when you're targeting the prime minister,
13:15the manner in which is it being done,
13:17is it fair?
13:17Ashutosh is joining us.
13:19Also, Sujata Pandey is joining us as a political analyst.
13:21Ashutosh, first to you.
13:22You've been a journalist as well,
13:24and as political analyst,
13:25you tell me.
13:25What is your understanding?
13:26And this is not about BJP or Congress,
13:28but an opposition leader going on and on,
13:30constantly about what India has become,
13:32according to him.
13:34Is this fair?
13:34Does it look fine?
13:35Especially when the electorate back home,
13:37getting ready for elections is watching.
13:40See, Pujad, there are three things.
13:42First of all,
13:43who started it?
13:44The prime minister, Narendra Modi,
13:45had gone to Seoul in May 2015.
13:47And you know what he said?
13:49Mere aane ke phele,
13:51log kate te hai ki humne kya galat kaam kiya,
13:53humne kya paap kiya ki mujhe Hindustan mein paida hona pada.
13:56You know?
13:57Can anything be more dangerous than this?
13:59Can it be more insulting to India than this?
14:02And then, you know what?
14:02When the question was asked here,
14:05the Sudhansu Trivedi has said,
14:06no, no, no, no, no, no,
14:07he was not attacking the India.
14:08He was just only talking about
14:09the policy paralysis in the country.
14:11So now the word has changed in 12 years.
14:15Now, if Rahul Gandhi has said something,
14:16now what Rahul Gandhi has said,
14:17I heard the entire conversation.
14:20He has said,
14:20the India is sitting as an economic disaster.
14:23Is it not a true?
14:24Is it not truth?
14:25The fact of the matter is,
14:27even the foreign...
14:27How are we sitting on an economic disaster?
14:30IMF says we are a bright spot
14:32in the dark horizon.
14:33Pooja, let me come.
14:34Let me come.
14:35Let me come.
14:36Please, please go ahead.
14:37And Sanju Varma was quoting
14:39the foreign institutions,
14:40World Bank and all and all.
14:42He has forgotten.
14:43IMF a few months back
14:45has said India's data
14:46should be put in the category C.
14:48That means Indian data is doubtful.
14:51Then former finance secretary
14:54who has worked in the Narendra Modi,
14:55when the data came 7.8% GDP growth,
14:58he said it is not 7.8%,
15:00it is 2.6%.
15:02The Surjit Bhalla,
15:04the member of the Economic Advisory Council,
15:06he said,
15:06in 2013-14,
15:08India was in the Frasile 5.
15:10Now India is in the Frasile 2,
15:12along with Turkey.
15:13These are the people
15:15who have worked with Narendra Modi,
15:16the Prime Minister.
15:17And they do not have
15:19a very high opinion
15:19about Indian economy.
15:21Let me put the third thing.
15:24The WPI inflation
15:26is something around 12.29%,
15:28except the retail is 6.09%
15:31beyond the RBI's apprehensions.
15:35Food inflation is 8.3%,
15:37which is affecting
15:38every Indian in the country.
15:40The fuel and the power inflation
15:41is 32.84%.
15:43Then, above all,
15:46India was known
15:48as a software superpower.
15:51In 2011 and 2021-22
15:55to 2024-25,
15:58there is a drop of
15:59almost 30% in India's
16:01software exports.
16:02Now,
16:03a country which was supposed
16:05to be the software superpower,
16:07there is a drop
16:08from 11.59 lakh crore
16:11to 7.75 lakh crore
16:14that speaks volume about it.
16:16So, first of all,
16:17the BJP should answer
16:18to Subhash Garg
16:20who said India's economy
16:21is not going at 7.8%,
16:23but 2.6%.
16:24Let everyone have their say
16:26and I will come back to you.
16:27Sujata Pandey is also joining me.
16:29Sujata,
16:29what do you think?
16:30Do you think that
16:31India's image has changed
16:32on the global stage
16:34compared to
16:35even what our leaders
16:36have been saying earlier
16:37that compared to,
16:38let's say,
16:382014 or 20
16:40or 2000
16:41in 2026
16:42that pride
16:43is more visible
16:44or all of that
16:45has been just rhetoric?
16:47So, Pooja,
16:48first of all,
16:49I think Rahul Gandhi
16:50is sitting in a
16:50constitutional post
16:51and nowhere in the world
16:52you'll have an example
16:53of a LOP
16:54going to a foreign
16:57land in the financial
16:58capital of the world
17:00and going and bashing
17:01his own country.
17:02This is Rahul Gandhi's
17:03own country as well,
17:04isn't it?
17:04It is not just
17:05Narendra Modi's country,
17:06it is Rahul Gandhi's
17:07country as well.
17:08And then I think
17:09it is just not bad optics,
17:10it's bad politics also
17:12because,
17:13you know,
17:13today,
17:14what do you,
17:14what does the youth
17:15look for?
17:15What Rahul Gandhi
17:16is raising,
17:17unemployment issues
17:18and education issues
17:19and what is he denting at?
17:21He's denting the same
17:22investor which would
17:23come here and
17:24provide education,
17:25you know,
17:26investment in the
17:26education sector
17:27and, you know,
17:29help the youth
17:30get employed.
17:31Then second thing is
17:32I think neither
17:33Asutosh or
17:34I don't know the other
17:35panelists is an MBA,
17:36I think Sanju
17:37and me can show
17:37their MBA degree
17:38and tell that
17:39how are the ratings
17:40of the,
17:40you know,
17:41whole,
17:42you know,
17:43this global education,
17:44global fintech,
17:45you know,
17:46the ratings have gone
17:46up.
17:46You know,
17:47S&P upgraded
17:49India's rating
17:49in 18 years.
17:50It made it BBB.
17:52In the last rating
17:53it has never done that
17:54because IMS
17:55has said it on record
17:56that India,
17:57the way India
17:57has been taking
17:59people out of
18:00poverty line
18:00is something that
18:01is for the books.
18:03Then from the IMS
18:04to the World Bank
18:05to the S&P
18:06to the Fitch,
18:07all of these reports
18:09are on the thing.
18:09So I think,
18:10you know,
18:11they would know
18:11much more better
18:12economics than
18:13Ashutosh for that
18:14matter.
18:15Then I think
18:16from an LOP
18:17perspective,
18:18he can definitely
18:19criticize government
18:20but in here.
18:21When he goes out,
18:23he has to have
18:24data to show
18:25how Congress
18:26government was
18:26better than
18:27Modi government.
18:28But he knows
18:28that those will
18:29not fall flat
18:30on his face
18:31because the numbers
18:32can't even be
18:33compared.
18:33We were in
18:34Brazai in 5.
18:35We were on the
18:36world with our
18:37gold.
18:37Baba, you want
18:38to respond to that.
18:39She's made a good
18:40point which is
18:41with the kind of
18:43statements going
18:43from Rahul Gandhi,
18:44aren't you spreading
18:45a fear?
18:46There could have
18:47been actually
18:47investors,
18:48educationists who
18:49would be actually
18:49interested,
18:50Aukhin,
18:50to invest in India
18:51or take talent
18:52pool from here.
18:53Instead,
18:53you're giving
18:54this negative image
18:55that will impact
18:56India and Indians
18:57because going by
18:58the data,
18:58it appears
18:59that extreme poverty
19:00has come down.
19:01The GDP has
19:03seen a growth
19:03as well.
19:04The real GDP
19:04growth at about
19:057.8% in the
19:07first quarter year.
19:08I'm quoting some
19:09of the statistics
19:09that has come in
19:11from international
19:11organizations as well.
19:12Is this fear-mongering?
19:14Are you bringing
19:15in actors who
19:16need not interfere
19:17in our internal
19:17issues?
19:22You're asking me?
19:23Bhavya, yes,
19:24please go ahead.
19:25Because your voice
19:26was breaking before.
19:27Yes.
19:28So...
19:32Bhavya, for
19:33you, yes.
19:33Is this fear-mongering?
19:34Let me state some facts.
19:35Let me state some facts.
19:37If I state facts,
19:38maybe it's easy
19:39for you to understand.
19:40Let me read it out.
19:47Quickly, Bhavya.
19:49The government's
19:49latest release.
19:50The government's
19:51latest release.
19:52No, I'm reading
19:53the facts from
19:53the government
19:55websites that I
19:56have researched.
19:58The government's
19:59latest release,
19:59is the July-September
20:002026 quarterly
20:01bulletin.
20:02All right?
20:03That was released
20:03on 10th of November.
20:04Shows the national
20:05youth number
20:06easing to 15.3%,
20:08but the improvement
20:08in entirely rural
20:09story.
20:10The rural youth
20:11unemployment
20:11fell from 14%
20:13to 13%.
20:14Rural youth
20:15employment,
20:16meanwhile,
20:16rose to...
20:18Unemployment
20:18rose to 18.9%
20:20over the same
20:22quarter.
20:23With unemployment
20:23among the urban
20:24young women
20:25at 26%
20:27and urban
20:28young men
20:28at 16%.
20:30This is not
20:31Congress data.
20:32This is not
20:33some random
20:33third-party
20:34research
20:37person's data.
20:38This is the
20:38government's data
20:39recently released.
20:41All right?
20:42When you interpret
20:43data,
20:45you just want
20:45to be selective
20:46about the data
20:47you want to present.
20:49But let's talk
20:50about very
20:51common things
20:52that's affecting
20:53the common people.
20:54the petrol price,
20:56the diesel price,
20:58the LPG price.
20:59Most importantly,
21:00what's happening
21:01to the rupee?
21:02Dollar and rupee.
21:04To which,
21:04quoting Prime
21:05Minister Modi Bhavia
21:06for you,
21:06he spoke at the
21:07Bharat conclave.
21:08What I'm telling you
21:09is what the
21:09government says.
21:10Government says
21:10the price rise
21:11for the few
21:12years could have
21:13actually gone
21:14much higher
21:14because of the
21:15West Asia war.
21:16It was actually
21:17the government
21:17absorbing a lot
21:19of that pressure.
21:21Okay.
21:24Then why is
21:25that pressure
21:25only forced
21:28upon the poor
21:29when the top
21:301% of population
21:32is holding
21:3340% of the wealth?
21:35Let's take
21:3522% of national
21:37income.
21:37No, wait,
21:38wait, wait.
21:38One more point.
21:39Ms. Sujata
21:40was sujata.
21:41I'm not sure
21:42if you actually
21:43heard what Mr. Gandhi
21:44said in Columbia
21:45University.
21:46If you had heard,
21:48you wouldn't say
21:49he was bashing
21:50India.
21:51He was, yes,
21:51he was exposing
21:53BJM state of
21:54economic disaster.
21:56India is in a
21:57state of economic
21:57disaster.
21:58Okay.
21:59Sanju, the fact
22:01is, okay,
22:02there are some
22:02real concerns
22:03like unemployment,
22:05especially
22:05like inflation.
22:08So, if the
22:08leader is talking
22:10about Bhavia,
22:11Bhavia, time's
22:12up, time's up.
22:12Let Sanju respond
22:13now.
22:13Because if there
22:14are some real
22:15issues that he's
22:16speaking about
22:17in the USA,
22:19is that really a
22:20concern?
22:21Do you think
22:21that he's either
22:22exaggerating it,
22:23lying about it?
22:24Because some of
22:24these are concerns.
22:25Unemployment,
22:26inflation is a
22:27concern for India.
22:29Pooja, now I
22:30don't wish to be
22:31heckled.
22:32Bhavia Narsimha
22:33Murthy is a
22:34rapid liar.
22:35I have the data
22:36from the Ministry
22:37of Statistics
22:38and Programme
22:39Implementation
22:39and this is the
22:41actual data.
22:42Let your audience
22:42know this dim-witted
22:43spokesperson knows
22:45nothing about
22:46the economy.
22:46Oh my God.
22:47Sanju Verma,
22:48what are you
22:49saying?
22:49Pooja, can I
22:50finish?
22:51You know, you
22:51are speaking on a
22:52national television.
22:53They can cross-check.
22:54Remember, they can
22:55cross-check.
22:56You have learned
22:56about everything.
22:57You have been
22:59running your whole
22:59life on our
23:00television.
23:01Can you, Bhavia,
23:01let Sanju speak?
23:03Remember, you
23:04on a national television.
23:06Can you
23:06cross-check?
23:08You guys have
23:09done it.
23:09Let me speak.
23:10Let her finish
23:10your point.
23:11Let her make her
23:11clean.
23:12If it's a clean,
23:12ladies' clean.
23:13You liar.
23:15Okay, Sanju.
23:15Sanju.
23:16No person.
23:17Can I finish?
23:19We'll restrict
23:20with personal
23:20remarks.
23:21Sanju, only the
23:22facts.
23:23Go ahead.
23:23Your audience
23:24needs to hear
23:25this.
23:25Thank you,
23:25Pooja.
23:26The Ministry of
23:28Statistics and
23:29Programme Implementation
23:30has released
23:31this data for
23:32the month of
23:32October.
23:33The month of
23:34November data
23:34is not yet out.
23:35For the month
23:36of October,
23:37overall rural
23:38unemployment rate
23:394.2%.
23:41Rural male
23:43unemployment rate
23:444.3%.
23:46Rural female
23:47unemployment rate
23:483.8%.
23:50Overall
23:51unemployment rate
23:524.2%.
23:54Rural labor
23:55force
23:56participation
23:56rate
23:57It's highest
23:58ever
23:58amongst
23:59females
24:00at 42%.
24:01For males
24:02at more
24:03than 79%.
24:05And
24:05Bhavya
24:06had the
24:06audacity
24:07to say
24:07unemployment
24:07rate
24:08is 15%.
24:19I don't know
24:22cement
24:22producing
24:23economy
24:23in the
24:23world.
24:24India.
24:24Which is
24:25the second
24:25largest
24:25mobile phone
24:26manufacturer
24:27in the
24:28world.
24:28India.
24:29Which is
24:29the third
24:29largest
24:30automobile
24:30manufacturer
24:31in the
24:31world.
24:32India.
24:32Which is
24:33the largest
24:34two-wheeler
24:34manufacturer
24:35in the
24:35world.
24:36India.
24:36Which is
24:37the fifth
24:37largest
24:38economy
24:38in terms
24:39of stock
24:40market
24:40capitalization.
24:41India
24:42overtook
24:42Taiwan
24:42last year
24:43to become
24:43the fifth
24:44largest
24:44in terms
24:44of stock
24:45market
24:45capitalization.
24:46But
24:46Sanju,
24:47are you
24:47saying that
24:48there is no
24:48unemployment?
24:49Can I
24:50finish?
24:51Now,
24:51now,
24:52now.
24:53IMF,
24:54the IMF,
24:55and this
24:56is for
24:56Ashutosh.
24:57Yes,
24:57the IMF
24:58had flagged
24:59concerns
25:00pertaining to
25:01India six
25:01months back,
25:02but barely
25:03three weeks
25:04back.
25:05IMF
25:06applauded
25:06Narendra
25:07Modi for
25:07carrying out
25:08structural
25:08reforms and
25:09saying the
25:10fact that
25:10the Modi
25:11government
25:11changed the
25:12base year
25:12from 2011-12
25:14to 22-23
25:16is a great
25:17move and
25:18as for
25:18Subhash Garg,
25:19I have
25:20nothing to
25:20say about
25:21a disgruntled
25:22jobless man
25:23looking for
25:24opportunities.
25:26You made
25:26your point.
25:27Sanju,
25:28you made
25:28your point
25:29and you
25:29made it
25:29how?
25:30But
25:30Ashutosh,
25:31because before
25:31I wrap up,
25:32I want everyone
25:32to have their
25:33say,
25:33Ashutosh,
25:33here's my
25:34question and
25:34you can of
25:35course respond
25:36to what
25:36Sanju is
25:36saying.
25:37Let's say
25:37what Rahul
25:38Gandhi had
25:39to say,
25:39some of
25:39those issues
25:40are pertinent.
25:41Make it
25:41back home.
25:42Elections
25:43are coming
25:43in.
25:44You're making
25:45these statements
25:45in the USA
25:46on foreign
25:47soil,
25:48which the
25:48BJP is
25:49cashing on
25:49to say,
25:54especially when
25:55Prime Minister
25:55Modi and
25:56the party
25:56still has
25:57a strong
25:57hold,
25:57especially
25:58in states
25:58like
25:58Uttar Pradesh.
25:59So come
25:59make it
26:00back home
26:01in the
26:01parliament,
26:02debate it,
26:02why go all
26:03the way to
26:03the US
26:04or the UK
26:04to make
26:05such statements
26:06is what
26:06everyone's
26:06been asking.
26:07Ashutosh?
26:08Pooja,
26:09first of
26:09all,
26:09let me
26:10correct my
26:10two colleagues
26:11on the
26:11panel.
26:12One,
26:12Sujata Pandey
26:13has said,
26:13the leader
26:13opposition post
26:14is a
26:14constitutional
26:15post.
26:15It's not
26:16a constitutional
26:16post.
26:17It's a
26:17statutory
26:17post created
26:18in 1977
26:19by a law
26:20in the
26:21parliament.
26:23second point
26:24is India
26:25doesn't
26:26manufacture
26:26mobile phones.
26:27It only
26:28assembles.
26:2975%
26:31of parts
26:34are...
26:35Sanju,
26:35please be
26:37civil.
26:38You are
26:38out of
26:39touch with
26:39unity.
26:41You are
26:41consumed by
26:42hatred for
26:43the government.
26:44Let him
26:44finish.
26:45Sanju,
26:45Sanju.
26:48The phone
26:49that I
26:49use is
26:50manufactured
26:50in
26:51Kuja uses
26:53or Sujata
26:54uses is
26:55Sanju,
26:56there's
26:57limited time.
26:59There is
27:00an expansion
27:01that India
27:01has been
27:02doing in
27:03component in
27:03some assembly
27:04parts.
27:05I'm really
27:07aghast
27:07that the
27:09former banker
27:10does not
27:11know the
27:11difference
27:11between
27:12manufacturing
27:12and
27:13assembling.
27:13India only
27:14assembles
27:15mobile phone.
27:16It is not
27:17manufacturing.
27:18Let's be
27:18clear on
27:19this.
27:19The point
27:20number two,
27:20have you
27:21heard from
27:21the BJP
27:22in the
27:22last six
27:23months that
27:23India is
27:24the third
27:24largest economy?
27:26No,
27:26because it
27:27has slipped
27:27from fourth
27:28to sixth.
27:29Have you
27:29heard that
27:30India's
27:30stock market
27:31has shrunk
27:31and that
27:31is why it
27:32has slipped
27:32from fourth
27:33position to
27:33the seventh
27:34position?
27:35Have you
27:35heard how
27:36India's
27:36stock market
27:37is doing?
27:37in the
27:37last one
27:38year?
27:3930
27:39lakh
27:40crore
27:41money has
27:42slipped out
27:43of the
27:43stock market.
27:4430
27:45billion
27:45foreign
27:46portfolio
27:47investment
27:47has gone
27:48out of
27:49India's
27:49market.
27:50market and
27:50then she
27:52is critical
27:53about
27:53Subhash
27:54Chandi goes
27:54fine, but
27:55what about
27:56the former
27:56chief economic
27:57advisor Arvin
27:57Subramaniam?
27:58He's saying
27:59from the
28:00rooftop, writing
28:01articles after
28:02article, that
28:02India's data is
28:03doubtful and
28:04suspect.
28:05at least it
28:06has been
28:08artificially
28:08inflated by
28:092-3%.
28:10Final point,
28:11final point.
28:12The IMF
28:13World Economic
28:14Outlook data
28:15says that
28:15Indian economy
28:16is growing at
28:17the rate of
28:174.2%, not
28:197.8%.
28:21And then,
28:22again I'll
28:23quote Sujit
28:23Bhala, whose
28:24work as
28:24Economic
28:25Advisory
28:25Council,
28:26that per
28:26capita GDP
28:27growth in
28:28US dollar
28:28is...
28:29Sanju,
28:29Sanju,
28:30but I need
28:30to get all
28:31views.
28:32Because before
28:32I wrap up,
28:33I'm being told
28:33the time.
28:33Sanju,
28:34Sanju,
28:35quickly, I
28:35want Sujata
28:36also to
28:37speak.
28:37I've given
28:38a chance to
28:38everyone.
28:39Sujata, as
28:40a closing
28:41comment that's
28:42coming in,
28:43at this
28:43point, everyone
28:44has been
28:44asking, especially
28:45from the
28:45ruling party,
28:46and people
28:46are watching
28:46it too.
28:47People are
28:48also wondering
28:48if you have
28:49any view,
28:50you're meeting
28:50leaders like
28:51Ilhan Omar,
28:52who's a
28:52known India
28:53beta,
28:54you're interacting
28:54with individuals,
28:55do have a
28:56questionable
28:57authority as
28:57well, and
28:58importantly,
28:59why are you
28:59going to the
29:00USA, to the
29:00UK on
29:01foreign soil?
29:01If you have
29:02these issues,
29:03valid issues,
29:04debate it
29:04here on the
29:05soil, voters
29:06are going to
29:06eventually vote
29:07for either
29:08Congress or
29:08BJP.
29:09Is it the
29:10electorate only
29:11that matters,
29:11Sujata?
29:12Or do you
29:13think the
29:13worldview also
29:14matters?
29:15No, both
29:16matters,
29:17Pooja, but
29:18at the right
29:18forum and at
29:19the right
29:19stage.
29:21In my
29:22opinion, any
29:22electoral, whether
29:23you're a
29:23Congress supporter
29:24or a BJP
29:25supporter, doesn't
29:26like India
29:26bashing,
29:27especially on
29:28a global
29:28stage.
29:29and that
29:30has been
29:30done
29:30repeatedly
29:31and that
29:31has been
29:32used by
29:32BJP to
29:33counter Rahul
29:34Gandhi
29:34repeatedly.
29:35And still
29:36Rahul Gandhi
29:36keeps on
29:37doing.
29:37I do not
29:37see as a
29:38political
29:38analyst that
29:39adds to
29:40everything to
29:41Rahul Gandhi's
29:41image, rather
29:42he dents his
29:42image.
29:43So I think,
29:44I'm quoting
29:44Prime Minister
29:45Modi, I
29:45think this was
29:46a completely
29:47different context
29:48and different,
29:49so you can't
29:49really give a
29:50panel.
29:51Prime Minister
29:51Modi never
29:52shamed the
29:53country, Rahul
29:53Gandhi shamed the
29:54country.
29:55And first of
29:55all, UP
29:56elections are
29:56coming, Rahul
29:57Gandhi should
29:58be here,
29:58not doing
29:59this.
30:00The Congress
30:01spokesperson is
30:02short, the BJP
30:03spokesperson agrees
30:04to it, but
30:05I'm told that's
30:06all the time I
30:07have for, I
30:07really have to
30:08wrap up, I
30:08appreciate all
30:09of you for
30:09giving your
30:10views, eventually
30:10remember,
30:12Janata
30:12is watching, the
30:13people will
30:14vote in
30:15Uttar Pradesh, in
30:16Punjab, in
30:17other states as
30:17well, they will
30:18decide if Rahul
30:19Gandhi is the
30:20next big leader,
30:21is it Prime
30:22Minister Modi
30:22again, is it
30:23Yogi
30:24Adityanath
30:24again, so I
30:25leave it to
30:25the people
30:26watching, eventually
30:27you get to
30:27decide and
30:28that's the
30:28voter of
30:29India.
30:29Thank you
30:30very much for
30:30watching this
30:31discussion.

Recommended