• 5 minutes ago
KC Singh analyses the geopolitical moves of Trump, Xi, and Putin at the Shenzhen summit, stressing India's strategic alignment with global powers.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00And as the word of words escalates, let's bring in a diplomatic perspective.
00:04Joining me now is former diplomat Casey Singh. Ambassador Singh, really appreciate your time.
00:11Can you hear me, sir?
00:17Ambassador Singh, can you hear me?
00:20Yes, now.
00:21Yes. Trump, Xi and Putin are increasingly shaping conversations on global security and geopolitics.
00:29Should India's absence from this engagement in Shenzhen be seen as a diplomatic setback, or is that an over-interpretation?
00:39I think foreign policy can't be assessed on the basis of one event or one meeting or one summit.
00:46You see, if you go over the last 21st century, the first 10 years were defined by unipolarity, where there
00:54was only America.
00:55So you had a BJP government, Vajpayee.
00:58He started negotiating the nuclear deal because he had tested the nuclear devices.
01:03So America-India relations had hit a bottle.
01:07Then when he left, when Monsingh carried on with the same, so the nuclear deal was not just created by
01:14Congress.
01:15It was BJP, started by BJP and finalized by Congress.
01:20And that's why Mr. Brijesh Misha finally supported it, though initially he was critical of it.
01:27He was the first NSA, Vajpayee's NSA.
01:29Now what has happened in between?
01:31So we have to realize that Trump has had two terms.
01:35There is the first term, when I think Prime Minister Modi invested a lot in the Indian diaspora, invested in
01:42a lot of personal connection with him, etc.
01:44And then came COVID.
01:46So that term was kind of disrupted.
01:48We didn't see it fully through.
01:50Now came Trump too.
01:51And I think there, well, India has misread him, but so has Canada, so have the Europeans, so have Japan.
01:59Look at what yesterday, what was happening.
02:02Three of them sitting there is more threatening to Japan than to India.
02:07Yes, it is, you know, Trump has already created a lot of disruption.
02:12There's disruption of global trade, disruption of the global order, which was there after World War II.
02:18So that's why they are saying that, are these three who met yesterday trying to create another global order?
02:24But they never mentioned Ukraine war, never mentioned Iran war.
02:28They mentioned four points, and those are very general.
02:31How to make UN more effective.
02:33Well, UN will be more effective.
02:34The three of them didn't use the veto.
02:37Whereas countries like India, Brazil, Japan, Germany, we want the Security Council expanded.
02:43They're not talking about that.
02:44So we are at a point where, yes, Trump has pulled up China, pulled up Russia, given them a seat
02:52at the high table.
02:53But that may not last.
02:54Because by the time he gets back, the Democrats will be in position in January.
02:58And they'll start going after him and start analyzing his domestic policies, his foreign policy.
03:03So this may not last.
03:05Secondly, Ukraine war is not about to end.
03:08And I think the Ukrainian president said it.
03:10He says leaders of other countries, they keep thinking they can control the world.
03:14They can't.
03:15That was his reaction.
03:16So I think we can say that I don't think India would have got a place at that table.
03:22Because Trump has made up his mind that he's going to be dealing with these two authoritarian regimes.
03:27He's always in front of Putin.
03:30And with Xi, he has gone out of the way.
03:32Now, we say that Xi came to the airport to receive him.
03:35But he first, in September of this year, also went to the airport to receive Xi.
03:42Now, I don't think he will do that for any of the other prime ministers or leaders of NATO and
03:47anyone else.
03:48And look at Canada.
03:49It was the closest ally of America with tremendous trade links.
03:53It's completely disrupted.
03:55So we are in a disrupted world.
03:57Yes, I think the mistake, probably the mistake that India made was we aligned too closely with Israel and with
04:04UAE and the Abraham Accords, where you could see the war starting in Iran.
04:10And once that happened, I think India has been correcting it now.
04:13That's why they're now supporting all UN resolutions, which are pro-Palestine.
04:19I think a bit relatedly, we are correcting it.
04:22But I think aligning too closely, the moral is, if you align too closely with one leader, especially U.S.,
04:28that all connections break broken down.
04:31Because the Indian policy since 2000 was based on the assumption that America finds India important for dealing with China.
04:40Now, that's not the case.
04:41He's going and dealing with China directly.
04:43He met the Quad, but Quad he kind of met with and said a few things and then really went
04:48to Shenzhen.
04:48So it's an evolving new world in which I think value judgment is neither easy nor should be instantaneous.
04:57Ambassador Singh, who really emerged the best out of Shenzhen, according to you?
05:03You know, these three leaders went to Shenzhen with different objectives or perhaps they had different outcomes in their mind.
05:11Besides the optics, what do you think came out of that?
05:15Look, President Putin came out the best because he's got ICC warrants against him.
05:21And now, you know, amongst the four items that the three of them decided on, one is that ICC should
05:28have no right to go after any official of any country.
05:32Now, which are the officials they're going after?
05:34They're going after Netanyahu, which President Trump doesn't want, and they're going after Putin.
05:39So essentially, ICC and the second commission, which looks out of the states, is UN monitored.
05:48It's essentially to see that human rights are observed.
05:51This is what America supported for the last 80 years.
05:56And now, you know, all of a sudden, Trump kind of changes and says ICC, although all three countries are
06:02not signatories to it.
06:03So they're passing their judgment without being there.
06:06So essentially, Putin is the one who was seen as having suffered, done badly in Ukraine, lost a lot of
06:13people, not winning there.
06:15And therefore, he was a pariah.
06:18He's managed to come back to the main table.
06:20So he's the big winner.
06:22And the second winner is China.
06:24It is not Trump.
06:25Trump has raised the level of China.
06:28And that's what India always feared.
06:30He called his meetings with China G2.
06:32Now, if you create a new G2, that means countries like India, Brazil, Japan, European countries, Germany, you're putting them
06:40a level lower.
06:41No, it is not for him to decide what a level is.
06:44So we have to go to...
06:45So I think there's a correction which will have to be brought about in how you deal with Trump over
06:51the next two years.
06:52But he is going to be a very distracted leader.
06:55He's not going to be the same Trump as in the first two years.
06:58Let's see what the Democrats do.
07:01A couple of more questions.
07:03Is Pakistan gaining diplomatic ground at India's expense?
07:06That's what the opposition seems to suggest here in India, with Islamabad perhaps positioning itself as a channel between Washington
07:13and Tehran.
07:14Is Pakistan finding strategic relevance that India has been unable to leverage?
07:20Look, this is not new.
07:21This is what they did in the 50s.
07:23They became allies of America.
07:25They got weapons from them.
07:26And that is how they started the war in 65.
07:29They had better planes than us, better tanks than us.
07:33So they've done it many, many times.
07:35So they massaged the ego of Trump.
07:38And they jumped into that thing that, you know, he stopped a nuclear war between India and this.
07:44And they suggested he should get a Nobel Prize.
07:47Now, they're very good at that.
07:49And they've done it.
07:50That's all right.
07:50Let them do it.
07:52But, yes, then they created the Mecca Pact, which is Saudi Arabia.
07:56So what has happened in the Gulf is the Gulf is split now.
07:59So it's not the old Gulf.
08:00We could be dealing with all of them on the same level.
08:03UAE is all right.
08:04But UAE is isolated, too.
08:06But otherwise, other than UAE, Saudis, Turks, Pakistanis, they've gone into a separate group.
08:14So, you know, therefore, it is definitely Pakistan like Putin.
08:18Trump has made Pakistan come up at the diplomatic level and given them diplomatic credence.
08:25Now, can they retain it?
08:28Can it continue?
08:29It will depend on the next president in America.
08:31It will depend on the next time.
08:32In America, there's a regime change every now and then.
08:34So it's not permanent.
08:35Okay.
08:37I'm balancing my last question.
08:38What we are seeing is a deeply polarized global climate.
08:42We are speaking at a time when there are two life conflicts already.
08:46How can India maintain its foreign policy message without domestic political differences weakening its international standing?
08:57Look, I think BJP has to realize that domestic politics and foreign policy are interrelated.
09:02You can't treat that as separate from the other.
09:05Now, you take the diaspora.
09:07How much PM has invested in the diaspora in these countries, especially America?
09:11As a single person, they have squeaked when Trump came after us.
09:16They won't.
09:17It's all right.
09:17If your relationship is normal, they see the U.S. president and the Indian prime minister friendly,
09:22they'll come to your meetings.
09:23Now they're worried about ICE.
09:25They're worried about their visas being canceled.
09:27They've got other concerns.
09:28So essentially, once they become American citizens or they have residency there,
09:33you can't count on them to fight your battle.
09:36That is one thing.
09:37And the other one is that, yes, we have to essentially, we could have anticipated some of it,
09:43but most countries have got it wrong.
09:45So it's not just India.
09:46Nobody thought Trump will go down this road this way.
09:49So now there's rectification.
09:51I think we have to get together with Europe.
09:53We have to meet with Japan and Australia.
09:56Are we already doing it separately?
09:57You have to get ready for a world where U.S. may not be a major factor.
10:02And China will be a bigger factor.
10:04Now, how do we deal with it?
10:06I think that's what the next 10 years are going to show.
10:10All right.
10:11Ambassador Casey Singh, really appreciate your time.
10:13And thank you so much for joining us here on the show.
10:15And thank you so much for joining us here on the show.

Recommended