• 22 minutes ago
A debate over alleged corporate espionage and data leaks at Guidance Tamil Nadu raises calls for inquiry and transparency amid claims involving Andhra Pradesh.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Let me bring in on this broadcast Sandhya Ravi Shankar, Senior Journalist and Mr. Suman C. Raman, Political Analyst.
00:05Sandhya, I'll begin with you.
00:06You know, to make such a grave charge that there's espionage happening
00:11and then to point fingers at a state, your neighbouring state,
00:15when there's already healthy, stress on healthy, healthy competition on investments,
00:21you turn that into something that's a larger conspiracy
00:24and then 24 hours later, no proof, no evidence, so you backtrack.
00:29It's not a good look.
00:31You're absolutely right, it's not a good look.
00:33But who made that claim in the first place of espionage?
00:37From what I understand, it was a Tamil magazine called Vigadan that wrote it
00:41and they did not quote any sources.
00:43They did not say anybody from the government told them that.
00:45So the premise of this debate itself is unknown, right?
00:52Like, we don't know who has come out with this.
00:54For all you know, it could be the DMK putting this out in the open
00:59and, you know, trying to run down the TVK government.
01:05But the main point is this.
01:07Why is this coming up five days before the investors' conclave
01:12that is scheduled for November 25th, right?
01:14And this, whatever resignations or, you know, sacking that happened,
01:21it happened in June and July when the TVK government took over.
01:25So why is this becoming an issue today,
01:28five days before the investors' conclave of the TVK government?
01:34I think the timing is very suspect.
01:36And I, from everybody I have spoken to,
01:40whether it's the employees who have resigned,
01:42whether it is, you know, the officials at guidance
01:47or at various levels of government,
01:51none of them is actually saying that there has been a data leak.
01:55So I really don't know where this has come from
01:58and I really don't know what, you know,
02:01why it's been blown out of proportion.
02:03You know, I'll say a couple of things here
02:05because a lot of questions have been asked of us,
02:09of our coverage also,
02:10and I think we owe some answers also on what this is about.
02:13One of the questions is, oh, where did this come from?
02:15Look, this is not manufactured.
02:17Let's be very clear that it didn't come from any political opponent.
02:20It came from within the TVK.
02:22Was it a section of the party?
02:23Was it part of the government?
02:25That's something that, you know,
02:26our reporters will not be willing to rivalge
02:28because they have their sources and wouldn't like to reveal that.
02:30But I will highlight that this was no political opponent game play here.
02:34This was clearly from within the TVK
02:36who still very much believe there's a conspiracy
02:39but are unwilling to take that extra step
02:41because of what it could mean with relations to Andhra Pradesh as well,
02:45which is the right mature thing to do.
02:47That in the first place,
02:48they shouldn't have come out and said this
02:49if they didn't have the evidence to back themselves up
02:51because ultimately with Andhra Pradesh,
02:54it would lead to soaring relations.
02:57Mr. Sumansi Raman,
02:58I'll bring you in also on this, sir.
03:00What do you make of all this that has happened?
03:02You know, the DMK is suggesting
03:03that this is the TVK's immaturity,
03:07inexperience that's showing.
03:09Okay.
03:10First of all, Akshita,
03:11the statement from Guidance Tamil Nadu clarifies nothing.
03:15What is a mass resignation?
03:16Is it five people?
03:18Ten people?
03:18Twenty people?
03:20What?
03:20There is no definition for mass resignation.
03:23The allegation was 15 people.
03:23No, I believe genuinely
03:24that they've kept it vague on purpose.
03:26That it's intentional.
03:28Yeah.
03:29Yeah, that's the first point.
03:30The second point,
03:32very clearly,
03:33is,
03:34was there,
03:35two major questions remain unanswered.
03:38Were there a series of complaints
03:40against the higher up officials
03:43of the Guidance
03:44in the months leading up to July 2026
03:47when these resignations happened?
03:49Point number one.
03:50Point number two,
03:52where,
03:53was there any evidence
03:55that confidential information
03:57was leaked,
03:58whether it is by these people
03:59or by somebody else,
04:00those who left the organization?
04:02Point number three,
04:03where any employee is asked to leave
04:04in the month of July.
04:06Now,
04:06these are very simple questions
04:07for which Guidance can provide the answer
04:09literally in about a minute.
04:10Yet,
04:12this whole thing is that
04:13there were no mass resignations,
04:15people are free to pursue opportunities
04:17to enhance their career.
04:18That is nonsense.
04:20I mean,
04:21that is basically stuff
04:22that everyone knows.
04:23No organization
04:24can prevent somebody
04:25from quitting.
04:25So,
04:26I think that Guidance
04:28has not answered
04:28any of the questions.
04:30All the questions
04:31still remain
04:32exactly as they were.
04:34Bottom line is
04:36there needs to be
04:36a formal inquiry.
04:38Now,
04:39has there been
04:40a leakage of documents?
04:41Now,
04:42the more the government
04:43tries to say nothing,
04:44this whole thing
04:44is a conspiracy
04:45and,
04:46you know,
04:47it's just rumors,
04:49why can't they put out
04:50the facts?
04:51Why can't they just say
04:52these are the people
04:52who quit in July?
04:54These are the places
04:55that they went to
04:57and we have found
04:59no evidence
04:59of any leak.
05:01At least,
05:01the least that they owe
05:02the public of the state
05:04is at least to issue
05:04a formal statement
05:05saying that
05:06there is no evidence
05:07that any information
05:09has been leaked
05:09in an unauthorized manner.
05:12So far,
05:12I have not seen that
05:13in the statement.
05:14They have not said it,
05:16Sandhya,
05:16and that's why
05:16there are questions
05:17about whether
05:18this is something
05:19that they are looking into.
05:20What do you think?
05:21Do you think that
05:22based on what we have
05:24on record
05:24and that's very little
05:25by the way,
05:26based on what is known,
05:28do you think
05:28there is a possibility
05:29that there is any truth
05:30whatsoever
05:31to all of these claims
05:32of your officials
05:33working for other states
05:34while being in guidance,
05:35Tamirnadu?
05:37There does not seem
05:38to be any evidence
05:40prima facie
05:41in terms of
05:43any sort of
05:44spying
05:45or espionage
05:46or data leaks
05:48because
05:49the officials
05:51have also
05:53analyzed
05:54the data,
05:56the computer,
05:57email records
05:58of various employees
05:59and they did find
06:02that one employee
06:03has
06:03taken
06:05some sensitive
06:06information
06:07away
06:07but
06:08there is
06:10absolutely
06:10no way
06:11for a conclusion
06:12to be reached
06:13and officials
06:14themselves
06:14are saying this
06:15that we cannot
06:16establish
06:17beyond the shadow
06:19of a doubt
06:20whether this
06:21information
06:22has been passed
06:23on or has not
06:24been passed
06:24on.
06:24So we really
06:25don't know.
06:26Prima facie
06:27they are going
06:28with nothing
06:28has happened.
06:29Now
06:30the other point
06:31I also wanted
06:32to mention
06:33Akshita
06:33is that
06:34you know
06:35states
06:36don't go
06:36by
06:38young kids
06:39who are
06:39five or
06:40seven years
06:40into the
06:41industry
06:41right
06:42like five
06:43or seven
06:44years of
06:44work experience
06:45I don't
06:46think
06:46multinational
06:47corporations
06:48would take
06:48a decision
06:49on which
06:50state to
06:50invest in
06:51because they
06:52like
06:53you know
06:53x y z
06:54person
06:54who is
06:55the points
06:56person
06:56from that
06:57particular
06:57state
06:58for that
06:58particular
06:59sector
06:59right
07:00and
07:01they are
07:02all
07:02youngsters
07:03it's
07:03not like
07:04they are
07:04seasoned
07:05government
07:06officials
07:06who are
07:06capable
07:07of
07:07pulling
07:08off
07:08you know
07:09huge
07:10incentives
07:10or promising
07:11them huge
07:12land
07:12or whatever
07:13it is
07:14so I
07:15frankly
07:16I would
07:17credit
07:18corporates
07:18and multinational
07:19companies
07:20with a lot
07:20more business
07:21acumen
07:21than is being
07:23discussed
07:24right now
07:25on social
07:26media
07:26about whether
07:27you know
07:27these guys
07:28stole
07:28investment
07:29investments
07:30from
07:31you know
07:32ultimately
07:32it's a bad
07:33look
07:33Mr.
07:34Sumanci
07:34Raman
07:34lack
07:35of clarity
07:36whatever
07:36it is
07:37you know
07:38for investors
07:38they are
07:39going to
07:39think twice
07:40wondering
07:40whether
07:40guidance
07:41Tamil Nadu
07:41has what
07:42it takes
07:42to be
07:43handling
07:43big ticket
07:44investments
07:44whether
07:44they can
07:45bring in
07:45what's
07:45needed
07:46for the
07:46state
07:46of
07:46Tamil Nadu
07:47people
07:47will have
07:48that
07:48question
07:48Andhra Pradesh
07:49well there are
07:50questions about
07:51what this means
07:51for relations
07:52between
07:52Tamil Nadu
07:53and Andhra Pradesh
07:53now
07:55yeah
07:55I don't think
07:56that this is
07:57going to
07:57damage any
07:58kind of
07:58relations
07:59between
07:59Tamil Nadu
08:02important
08:02when the
08:04TVK government
08:05took office
08:05itself
08:06the rumours
08:07started
08:07first there
08:08was an
08:08industries
08:09minister
08:09whose
08:10mother tongue
08:12is Telugu
08:12second
08:13there is
08:15one of the
08:15three
08:16very close
08:16advisors
08:17to the
08:17chief minister
08:18also happens
08:19to be
08:20a Telugu
08:21speaking
08:21person
08:23and then
08:24there was
08:24always talk
08:25of the
08:25trio of
08:26reddies
08:27who were
08:27very close
08:28to the
08:29chief minister
08:29so this
08:30is not
08:31something
08:31which started
08:32yesterday
08:33or so
08:34it started
08:34right from
08:35the time
08:35the government
08:36took office
08:36and then
08:37once
08:38investments
08:38started to
08:39go to
08:39Andhra Pradesh
08:40and it is
08:41possible
08:41investments
08:42went to
08:42Andhra Pradesh
08:43even during
08:43the DMK
08:44period
08:44so you
08:45cannot
08:45jump
08:46to conclusions
08:46and say
08:47they went
08:47because
08:48somebody
08:48was actually
08:49sabotaging
08:51investments
08:51from Tamil Nadu
08:52and pushing
08:52them into
08:53Andhra
08:53I don't
08:53think there's
08:54any evidence
08:54of that
08:54but having
08:56said that
08:57the way
08:58guidance
08:59Tamil Nadu
08:59and look
09:00the previous
09:01government
09:01kept
09:03guidance
09:03as a kind
09:04of show
09:04piece
09:04to tell
09:06everyone
09:07we've got
09:075 lakh crore
09:08we've got
09:088 lakh crore
09:09then they were
09:09asked to submit
09:10a white paper
09:10and they held
09:10up a plain
09:11A4 sheet
09:12of paper
09:12which is
09:13different
09:13but the
09:14point is
09:16why is
09:17the guidance
09:17Tamil Nadu
09:18not coming
09:18out to the
09:19categorical
09:19why is the
09:20industries department
09:20forget guidance
09:21Tamil Nadu
09:21why doesn't
09:22the industries
09:22department
09:23come out
09:23to the
09:23categorical
09:24statement
09:24saying that
09:25look this
09:25is what
09:26it is
09:26there is
09:27no truth
09:28to this
09:28we have done
09:28an internal
09:29investigation
09:30there is
09:31no evidence
09:31that anyone
09:32has passed
09:32on information
09:33to Andhra Pradesh
09:35or any other
09:36state for that
09:36matter
09:37and these
09:38are the facts
09:39instead of that
09:40you get a
09:41vaguely worded
09:42statement which
09:43conveys absolutely
09:43nothing at all
09:45You know I will
09:46reiterate again
09:46that there have
09:47been several
09:47questions of our
09:48coverage on this
09:49incident and I
09:49think the
09:50statement itself
09:50tells you that
09:51there is a lot
09:52missing here
09:53that there are a
09:54lot of loopholes
09:55that still need
09:55to be addressed
09:57and let's see if
09:58there is complete
09:59transparency because
10:00that's perhaps the
10:00only way we can
10:01get all of the
10:02answers right now
10:03to some very
10:04serious charges
10:05that have been
10:06leveled
10:06they have attempted
10:06to water down
10:07those charges
10:08that's not good
10:08enough
10:09the question is
10:09whether there
10:10will be absolute
10:11complete transparency
10:12on exactly what
10:13happened from the
10:14government
10:14Thank you Mr.
10:15Subhansi Raman
10:16and Sandhya for
10:17joining us on this
10:18broadcast

Recommended