00:00He's our buddy from NFL Blue Book. He's Mr. Charles Robinson. He's covered the NFL for a very long time.
00:06He's done a phenomenal job of it, and he might be as perplexed as all the rest of us, as
00:11the Browns sit at 6-4 at the bye week.
00:14Charles, welcome. How are you?
00:15Hey, Matt.
00:17Doing well, gents. How are you doing?
00:18We're good. It's a beautiful day here in Cleveland.
00:20Yeah, it is, actually. Nice out and everything else, so it's a good deal.
00:25You have a story out about a gentleman who wears number four for the Cleveland Browns.
00:29That would be Deshaun Watson.
00:32If you eliminate the fourth-quarter comebacks, how has he played this year?
00:42Well, come on, guys. You're taking away the good part.
00:46I know. Well, we're going to get to that. I thought we'd go twofold.
00:49Yeah, I mean, you're eliminating the cheese in a grilled cheese sandwich.
00:53That's right.
00:56Yeah, I mean, it's been amazing, obviously.
00:58The fourth-quarter comebacks, you know, the go-ahead drives, that's all been – it's been great.
01:06His last three starts, he's gone over 300 yards for the first time since the end of the 2020 season.
01:15You know, so you do see some flashes there.
01:19There are times where, you know, I watch him run, and I'm like, okay, this kind of reminds me of
01:23the guy I used to see in Houston.
01:26I think, you know, his arm seems to look better, but there's still inconsistencies when it comes to, I think,
01:33you know, drops, reads.
01:34You know, Todd Munkin's been pretty clear that there's still plenty of work to do here and access.
01:40But, you know, I would say that, as I described it, and when you talk to people around the league,
01:48what they view it as a quarterback of a 6-4 team is, you know, having a middle-of-the
01:53-pack season at best.
01:57And, you know, how long can you also live with the fourth-quarter stuff, right?
02:02Like, you can't – this is not – I don't think it's sustainable.
02:05At some point, it feels like it's – you can't hit green lights, you know, in that respect for the
02:13remainder of the season.
02:14So, what I wrote, I reached out to executives, some executives around the league, and I said, hey, you know,
02:21the Browns are in this situation where this guy is – he is playing better, and they are 6-4,
02:27and let's see how this finishes.
02:31But it's looking like, with the way the contract's set up, he's going to have to be released.
02:36So, the post, you know, a June 1 designation to split the cap hit, is there going to be a
02:41market out there for him in free agency?
02:43And the response I got back was, no, that there is not a thought process, that there's going to be
02:49a market out there for Deshaun.
02:50And it's really twofold.
02:52It's because the Browns have the sunken cost of already having dealt with the drama, right, of all the legal
02:59stuff and everything.
03:01Other teams don't have that.
03:02And it would be new and fresh for them.
03:05So, first and foremost, no matter how far in the rearview mirror that stuff gets,
03:12I think executives of other teams are saying, it'll be new for us.
03:17It'll be new for our fan base, and we'll have to go through that.
03:19And so, what's the risk-reward here, just from that standpoint?
03:24And then from a football player perspective, I think, you know, it's just too big of a risk.
03:31He's not really played good football since 2020.
03:34And this is the first time he's starting to do that, and you wonder how much of this is Todd
03:39Munkin.
03:41You know, it's just, there's just a lot there.
03:45So, I even had at one point, and this wasn't in the story, but I was talking to an executive,
03:50and he started to walk me through the quarterbacks in the league.
03:53And he got to the point where he was like, look, look at the top.
03:56You're going to really look at the bottom like five or six situations.
03:58He's like, you know, you've got Pittsburgh, Aaron Rodgers.
04:01This is his last season.
04:02You've got the Jets.
04:03Geno Smith is already in a bridge situation there.
04:05Malik Willis with the Dolphins, Daniel Jones with the Colts, and the Gardner Minshew with the Cardinals.
04:13And his point was, in all these different situations, the Steelers are already working on, you know,
04:21grooming some younger backup guys.
04:23Plus, I don't think the Roonies, he said that he didn't think the Roonies would go for the off-the
04:29-field stuff
04:29that Deshaun's dealt with in the past.
04:31That's not something that they would want to approach.
04:33The Jets have the draft capital to kind of go and get whatever they want.
04:37They're going to be able to have potentially three top 10 to 13 picks.
04:43The Dolphins, I don't know that they would see Deshaun as an upgrade over Malik Willis.
04:49You know, the Colts, literally, this guy said to me, do you think Carly, or say Gordon,
04:55is going to, her first big quarterback, you know, change as an owner,
04:59is going to be to go get Deshaun Watson.
05:00Do you think she's going to do that?
05:03So, it's just like when you look at the landscape, there's just not,
05:07it doesn't look like there's a lot of opportunity there.
05:10And the Browns have already kind of paid the cost with all the negative stuff
05:15and then the years that, you know, he didn't live up to, you know,
05:18the finances of the contract and injuries.
05:22So, there's a chance, and that's really what was relayed to me over and over.
05:27He's a post-June 1 designation.
05:29They cut him, and then they just go, okay, let the market price you,
05:32and we'll see where you're at.
05:34And maybe we can find a number to bring you back as a bridge quarterback for a short period of
05:38time,
05:39like maybe a two-year window.
05:41But that's only if they believe that what's going on with Todd Munkin right now with Deshaun
05:47is a sign that he can continue to get better.
05:49Like, hey, maybe the second year with Todd Munkin will be even better than the first year.
05:54So, it's very intriguing, and I think it's going to be a really interesting storyline down the stretch.
06:00So, Charles, just looking over your piece, I want to make sure that I kind of got it right,
06:04that in talking with other people, there is really no market for him at the end of the season.
06:09Elsewhere.
06:10Elsewhere, yeah.
06:11And so, the market is really Cleveland for him.
06:14How does that – but I think we've always – we're kind of like 30% of the way there
06:20and changing.
06:21I think he's 30% of the way there.
06:23I don't know if he'll ever get to 100% of the way there to try to change people's minds
06:27because, I mean, if you would have asked six months ago or a year ago in Cleveland,
06:32would we ever see Deshaun Watson or even think about him coming back next season,
06:37the answer would have been a hard no.
06:39So, now it's almost softened to the point where, like, hey,
06:42that doesn't look like it's such a crazy option.
06:44How much better does he need to play down the stretch to keep changing minds?
06:49I think – look, I think if he continues to improve, you know, another seven games
06:54and you show, you know, some of the stuff that – the inconsistency of play gets cleaned up, right?
07:00Like fewer slow starts.
07:03Just the functionality of how he's running Munkin's offense where he's talked about.
07:07Like, look, the reads and, you know, the depth of drops and just being more consistent.
07:15I think if that continues to improve, that 30% will continue to rise.
07:21And there's another part of this, too.
07:22There's another factor in this.
07:24It's that as the Browns play better – and this is fine.
07:28This is just – hey, this is just a champagne problem.
07:31As the Browns play better and their record is better, their likelihood of getting, let's say,
07:37their top choice in the draft at quarterback lessens, right?
07:41Because you're weakening your team's draft position, your pick.
07:45The Rams right now are, you know, they're looking like they've gotten themselves back on track.
07:51That draft pick looks like it's going to be weakened.
07:53And so the thought of, like, when we came into the season, I think some people were of the mind
07:58that, hey,
07:59the Browns could have a top five pick.
08:01Their pick could be a top five pick.
08:02That does not look remotely feasible now.
08:05And so if you lessen the other quarterback options on the table, then what are you left with?
08:13You know, you're left with, hey, we have familiarity with Deshaun.
08:16We've gone through a lot with this guy.
08:17And now the head coach we have now, he believes in him, you know, built the offense in a way
08:23that he's very comfortable with Deshaun running it, and Deshaun showed progress.
08:27And if we can get another year into this with Todd Munkin and Deshaun,
08:31maybe that progress continues on the same sort of trajectory.
08:34He's 31.
08:35He's not 38.
08:38And so, you know, yeah, I mean, I can kind of see it being that situation where really his best
08:43market
08:45is still staying in Cleveland where there's that element of familiarity.
08:49Now, I don't know about other quarterback options.
08:52There could be other quarterback options out there that, beyond the draft,
08:57that the Browns could be interested in.
08:59You know, I'm not saying you're interested in J.J. McCarthy,
09:02but the way J.J. McCarthy's playing right now with the New York Giants,
09:05there's a chance that by the end of the season, that's still Jackson Dart's team.
09:09The Giants could poke around and say, hey, you know, J.J. looks, he's still a young player.
09:14He's rebounded nicely with us.
09:16Do you still believe in that talent?
09:18And if you do, what would you be willing to give up to bring him in
09:20and, you know, groom him as your future star?
09:23Almost like a Malik Willis situation.
09:25Malik Willis went to Green Bay.
09:27All of a sudden, it was like, hey, wait a minute.
09:29This guy might be a viable starter, and that's how he ends up starting in Miami.
09:34So there might be other options on the table right now.
09:36But this is certainly complicated, and I'll say this one thing about Deshaun.
09:41Dave Muligeta's going to know what Deshaun's market is.
09:45I would guess that David knows right now.
09:47Like, he's already kind of formulated, this is what's most likely going to be available out here.
09:52This is our shot of, you know, going to the table and negotiating a deal with whatever's out there.
10:00And then you weigh that against the possibility of doing an extension either before he gets released by the Browns
10:08or after.
10:10Charles Robinson joining us, NFL Blue Book, and in his story, the recalibration does it every week.
10:18Big stuff on Deshaun.
10:19Let me ask you one last thing on Deshaun.
10:21Do you see, even in Cleveland, where he could get a going rate for a starting quarterback?
10:27Jack, which, you know, in this day and age is what, Charles?
10:31If you're upper echelon, $50 million a year plus.
10:34I can't fathom the idea that the Browns would pay him that much or would have to pay him anything
10:40like that.
10:41Do you?
10:43Yeah, no.
10:44I mean, it's just, I mean, even if you just look at the finances alone.
10:48I mean, they're on the hook no matter what in terms of accounting for $86.21 million.
10:54You know, so remember, anything you sign him to, now granted, an extension can, it can help because it preserves
11:03the existing kind of proration schedule, right?
11:06So the 86.2, let's say you sign Deshaun, right?
11:09Let's just say you sign him through 2030.
11:11Maybe you won't be there through 2030, but you sign him through 2030.
11:15You're going to stretch that 86.2 and change.
11:19It's going to be, you know, $34 million in 2027, $25 million in 2028, about $17 million in 2029.
11:27So you're still, you're taking the 86.2, you're stretching it out over four years.
11:31But whatever you pay him for the new deal for that extension is going to go on top of that.
11:38So any money, if you're going to pay him $50 million a year, that's just, it's not sustainable.
11:44There's no way.
11:44You can't add, I mean, you could add void years and do all kinds of stuff, but that's what got
11:48them into this situation.
11:49Now, being stuck under a really rough contract, having to constantly add or, you know, manipulate it to make it
11:58workable.
11:58And now they're left with $86.2 million charge.
12:02And that's why I think when you talk to people around the league, they're like, look, man, if you just
12:05look at the finances, the most likely scenario here,
12:09if he wants to test a market is for them just to do the post June one release, split the
12:15cap charge, eat it, and then figure out what the landscape looks like after that.
12:19Because maybe Deshaun doesn't have a market and you're like, okay, we will bring you back on a bridge deal,
12:25but it's going to be a low bridge deal.
12:27Well, considering we just paid you $240 million and, you know, we really didn't get the return we expected on.
12:34Again, though, who knows what the rest of the season looks like.
12:37That can change a lot of people's minds.
12:38If he, you know, tears the roof off the rest of the season and really shows a lot of improvement,
12:44that changes.
12:47Charles, thank you.
12:48And anybody who wants some great information on this whole situation, go to nflbluebook.com, nflbluebook.com.
12:56You can read Charles' story on Deshaun.
12:58It's outstanding.
12:59You can also sign up for his newsletter.
13:01I have.
13:02It's outstanding.
13:02It shows up, and I love it.
13:04Charles, thank you very much for your time, bud.
13:06Thanks, Mark.
13:06Appreciate it, guys.
13:07Enjoy the day.