• 13 minutes ago
Pierwszy unijny hub powrotów migrantów w Rwandzie budzi spór o prawa do azylu

W tym wydaniu naszego programu debatanckiego europosłowie Lena Düpont (EPL) i Robert Biedroń (S&D) ścierają się w sprawie polityki migracyjnej UE.

CZYTAJ WIĘCEJ : http://pl.euronews.com/2026/11/19/pierwszy-unijny-hub-powrotow-migrantow-w-rwandzie-budzi-spor-o-prawa-do-azylu

Zasubskrybuj nasz kanał.Euronews jest dostępny na Dailymotion w 12 językach

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:08Hello and welcome to The Ring.
00:11I'm Maria Tadeo and on this show we take you right to the heart of the European Parliament
00:16where we debate some of the most relevant issues shaping the European Union.
00:21And this week we focus on migration, certainly polarizing but also incredibly relevant this week
00:28as five EU countries have now entered a partnership with Rwanda to return rejected asylum seekers.
00:35This is a first for the European Union and would signal a much harder migration policy.
00:41My producer Luis Albertos has more.
00:46In March this year, the European Parliament adopted a reform enabling member states
00:51to set up migration return hubs in third countries for rejected asylum seekers.
00:56This week five EU countries announced the first ever return hub for migrants in Rwanda.
01:03Denmark, Austria, Germany, the Netherlands and Greece unveiled the first pilot project during
01:09the Vienna Migration Conference.
01:12And it is not without its share of controversy over respect for fundamental rights and compatibility
01:17with EU law, especially after the UN raised concerns over the track record of respect for
01:22for human rights in Rwanda.
01:25While supporters argue that a credible migration system needs effective returns, better control
01:30of irregular arrivals and stronger cooperation with third countries, critics, however, warned
01:35that outsourcing migration management could weaken access to asylum and leave vulnerable
01:40people without legal protection.
01:43Is Europe striking the right balance between security and human dignity or moving towards
01:48a more restrictive approach?
01:51Are return hubs part of the solution and can the EU balance stricter migration policies
01:56with growing human rights concerns?
02:14Lena Dupont, a German MEP from the Central Right European People's Party.
02:19She serves on the committee on civil liberties, justice and home affairs.
02:22She says, effective returns are an integral part of a functioning asylum system.
02:27Those who need protection must receive it.
02:30Those who do not need protection cannot be allowed to stay.
02:33Return hubs operating within a clear legal framework and in cooperation with reliable third-country
02:39partners can help ensure that return decisions are effectively implemented.
02:44Robert Biedron, a Polish MEP from the Socialist and Democrats Group.
02:48He is the vice chair of the Committee on Development and a member of the Committee on Foreign Affairs
02:52and the Subcommittee on Human Rights.
02:54He says, the EU is still the world's strongest protector of human rights.
02:59It is a requirement under the treaties for all of our policies, including migration.
03:04As the Parliament's co-rapporteur on the Global Europe Instrument, I will fight to make
03:08sure that the EU will continue to support democracy and human rights around the world and that
03:13the EU will never fund migration actions that violate human rights.
03:20So let me now welcome our two members of the European Parliament, Madame Dupont and Mr.
03:26Biedron.
03:27Let me begin perhaps by you, Madame Dupont, because you voted in favor.
03:32You have expressed a support for this policy.
03:36Is this a good idea to send rejected asylum seekers to countries they have no connection with?
03:42Well, first of all, I think it is a bit good to have a reminder of where the policy comes
03:47from.
03:48I mean, in the last term, we extensively negotiate the so-called asylum and migration pact, where
03:52return was always part of the package.
03:56There were political reasons why it was taken out of the packet, but it was always clear that
04:00there are two sides to an effective, let's say, an effective promise of protection.
04:05So, A, good and efficient procedures to grant protection, but also, and this is the second
04:11side of the model, is that if you don't have the right to stay within the European Union,
04:15if you're not eligible for protection, you need to go.
04:17And I think everyone understands if you don't have the right to be in the EU, you have to
04:22go.
04:22But there is a substantial difference between a return to a country of origin to a third
04:27country like Rwanda.
04:29Would you feel safe as a woman if you ended up somehow in Rwanda?
04:32Well, also there, let me remind that, as it was mentioned also by Robert, actually, in
04:38his starting remark, that under the EU principle, under international law, under also the national
04:44principles of legality, there is the right to protection and, of course, the safeguards
04:49also to human rights.
04:51But if you are, and if you're, you say, your home country is not cooperating with the European
04:57Union and you cannot be sent back to your own country, then, of course, member states
05:02need to find a way of actually really also offering an opportunity there.
05:06And the very important thing there is that, based on the agreement, that you also have
05:12a perspective in that country.
05:14And I think that this is also part of the whole debate.
05:17And that means off to Rwanda, but still, I'm not sure you would want to go as a woman
05:21to Rwanda, even if you ended up in the European Union illegally.
05:24We'll go back to that later.
05:25We'll talk about that in a second, but Robert, you have said that this is bad policy and
05:29it's not going to fix the problem.
05:31Why?
05:31Because it didn't work in the past.
05:33We have example from UK, where lots of taxpayers' money was spent for the return
05:39hubs in Rwanda.
05:41The fact that it was ruled unlawful by the UK Supreme Court.
05:46And the plane couldn't take off.
05:47And the plane couldn't take off.
05:49And it didn't work in Albania, where the populist, Melonese government has spent a lot of taxpayers'
05:55money again to fund this return hub.
05:58And de facto, the hub which was to accept 36,000 immigrants yearly adopted a few hundred.
06:08And there are serious concerns about human rights situation in this return hub.
06:13So we have a situation where populism won against the human rights.
06:20And I'm really surprised because we are social democrats.
06:23We were ready to negotiate good migration policy for European Union.
06:29And European People's Party created a populist product on return hubs together with far right.
06:37And it's the biggest surprise to myself.
06:39Let me shortly react to it.
06:40Your pattern to the far right and your policy is bad.
06:42That's what he argues.
06:43No, because I think there are two remarks, basically, to what you had just been saying.
06:47First, EU, UK, Uganda, Rwanda, Italy, Albania.
06:53They were also about the asylum procedures as such.
06:56For the return hubs, we're speaking about people who had really completed with all legal safeguards
07:01all procedures within the European Union and were not granted protection
07:05and have the return decision legally fixed also by all the judicial safeguards.
07:09So we're speaking about a different model here.
07:12Second, it was always clear for us that, you know, two sides of one metal.
07:17If you want to grant protection, you also need to have a solution for the returners.
07:22And one in five returners just effectively leaves the European Union.
07:26It's also a question of, you know, respect for the principle, also of rule of law.
07:30Because if we set rules, we need to make sure that they're also up here.
07:33And the third remark, just let me shortly finish.
07:36The third remark is that when you look at the countries actually now going forward with this agreement,
07:42there are EPP governments, there's an S&D government, there's a liberal government.
07:46So I don't buy the, let's say, the notion that it's just a populistic movement.
07:52I think what we need to deliver on the ground is really solutions that work for our society.
07:57But this is not a solution.
07:59This is the populist construct which sends people who have nothing in common with Rwanda.
08:06I just want to remind you, I don't know if you are familiar, Rwanda is a dictatorship country.
08:12It's a country in the human rights ranking which is close to Russia.
08:17I'm appalled.
08:18I cannot imagine that one day you will find an idea to send people, for example, to Russia.
08:24Because it has the same human rights score as Rwanda.
08:30It's like sending Ukrainian migrants who sooner or later they are illegal in the European Union to Belarus.
08:38This is the same concept.
08:39And I want to remind you, just a few months ago, we put sanctions as European Union against the Rwandese
08:47individuals
08:48because of their engagement in serious human rights violations.
08:53And now you want to send these people to Rwanda for what?
08:56They will be disconnected from their countries. They will don't know the culture.
09:01We don't know what will be the conditions in Rwanda.
09:04And yes, the argument of Maria, as a woman, imagine being in this country where there's serious human rights violations
09:13similar to Russia.
09:14I cannot imagine.
09:15And you point to the human rights record and you point to the legal issues.
09:18We're going to debate them in detail.
09:20I see you're warmed up, but let's move into our next section.
09:28Let me now ask you to put a question.
09:30You can put a question to Madame Dupont and Madame Dupont.
09:33You can put a question to Robert and then we can debate the three of us.
09:38Let's start perhaps with you, since I cut you off.
09:41Yes, since we talk about compassion and mercy and human rights values, I want to ask you, Lena,
09:47because you come from a historically very important party in Germany, a Christian Democrats Union.
09:54And so you represent, you should represent the values of Christianity, mercy, compassion on democracy, human rights, rule of law.
10:03I want to ask you personally, how do you cope with merging these values with return hubs when these values
10:13will be completely devastated?
10:15Well, thanks for that question, actually.
10:16And I do hope that I get the time to answer it correctly, because it actually gives me the opportunity
10:22to also say a bit about the personal note here.
10:24And it's serious words, what he's saying.
10:26It is. It is. And this is why I'm going to answer in all seriousness, because I entered politics because
10:31after the aftermath of 2015, 2016 in Germany,
10:34where we had a huge arrival of people coming to seek protection within the European Union, I saw what it
10:40did to the political debate.
10:41I saw how it put constraints on all our systems, be it the social welfare system, be it the health
10:48system, be it schooling, be it access to the labour market and to housing.
10:52And I saw that there's a European dimension of a responsibility that we need to take up at the European
10:57level.
10:57You mentioned the one million Syrians going to Germany just to give a historical context.
11:01And there are also other challenges that came up in the aftermath.
11:04This is why we focus so much on actually really bringing together 27 member states, three institutions, I would say
11:11three and a half political families here in the House to agree on what I call the inner dimension of
11:16the European asylum and migration system, which was our own rules here.
11:20But it was always clear that because migration is something within the European Union, but it's also something externally, that
11:27the external dimension will always be part of it.
11:30And your notion on saying that indeed, and there is a very good reason why there is so much emphasis
11:36on the respect for human rights.
11:38And if you look at what has been agreed by now, there's a huge section on exactly that.
11:44But if you take it together with, you know, the notion that I was sending in, one in five is
11:49effectively returned because far too often we have a lack of third country cooperation undergoing the international obligation to take
11:56back your own citizens, member states do look out for different reasons.
11:59And that's a real favor of the system.
12:02And what they have proposed now is together with the cooperation of international organizations like IOM and UNFCR to really
12:10have a legal set to offer perspective in that country.
12:14And to your point on the question of whether I would go there as a woman, we still have all
12:19the asylum rules in place that allow for effective protection, even under regional, let's say, differentiation.
12:26So a woman will always have a different vulnerability status.
12:30It's not part of the return agreement, actually.
12:33And when you look at the text, it clearly says that vulnerable groups, that children, that children and families are
12:39protected and not part of the deal.
12:41Well, it's like really, again, it's like sending these families to Russia.
12:46It has the same human rights core, Rwanda and Russia.
12:51I cannot imagine that you would be so blinded on that issue that you are sending these people to the
12:58country where the situation will be uncertain.
13:01And by the way, there is no time limit how they will, how long they will be kept in this
13:06country.
13:07It's not open facilities, it's not about keeping people.
13:10But it's still not their country of origin.
13:12Yes.
13:13Indeed.
13:14But if your country of origin does not cooperate and is not willing to take you back, which is their
13:19international obligation.
13:20But does the government pay the price for the individual, the person, vulnerable persons?
13:23If you have the possibility to develop a decent life in another country, and to add to that, it is
13:31part of the agreement that they have access to the labour market, that they have access to health,
13:36that they have access to housing, and that they have the possibility to really develop a decent life.
13:42That which, by the way, will also be supported.
13:44Robert, let me give Madame Dupont just the floor to ask you a question, and she brings up a very
13:49fair and also valid point.
13:51There is an issue in the European Union when it comes to legal court orders that say this individual must
13:58be expelled.
13:58They simply do not happen. That is also a failure of the system. Madame Dupont, your time for your question.
14:04Well, thanks a lot. And that actually already leads to my question because, I mean, we've been through very emotional
14:10debates here in the House,
14:11which is always the case when we speak about asylum immigration, because it's about people.
14:15And you're completely right on that. You're completely right on putting that emphasis over there.
14:19But at the same time, we also need to make sure that we have policies that are respected, not only
14:25by law, but also by our societies and by our people.
14:28And that leads me to the question, what would be your answer to one in five returnees actually is only
14:35effectively returned?
14:36And how should we solve that within the European Union if this is not, and again, I'm saying it's part
14:40of the toolbox.
14:42It's one tool complementary to every other thing that we developed in the last years.
14:47Yes, well, it's a very good question. And I agree we should look for effective solutions. And I'm a Polish
14:53citizen.
14:54I remember when millions of Polish people were migrating outside our country.
14:59And I think the clever thing we did in Poland, together with Germans and European Union, is to create opportunities
15:07in the country of origin.
15:09This is important, that these people will have a chance to stay in their countries of origin and not be
15:16forced to migrate because of climate change,
15:19lack of job opportunities, war or conflicts. And in our committee and in Global Europe Instrument, which I work on,
15:27we create these opportunities.
15:28And it's important that we do that. And we don't go into this populist.
15:33But Robert, you say populist.
15:35Which doesn't work.
15:36But you say populist and you allude to Giorgia Meloni. Giorgia Meloni is also saying to a large degree,
15:41we need to work with countries in Africa to develop their economy so they do not migrate into Europe.
15:46Is this a double track then in which you help some of these African governments, and not just African by
15:52the way,
15:52there's a lot of cliches into that, but also say there needs to be a way to simply enact returns.
15:58Yes, of course.
15:59It's not one or the other, it's the two.
16:00There should be a way, but it should be a legal way.
16:02It should be a way which respects EU values, EU legislation and international human rights standards.
16:09And these legislation on return hubs violates all of these regulations.
16:15Lena has mentioned IOM and UN Human Rights Commission.
16:20They say they have no access to return hubs and they don't have details.
16:27They need to be invited by Rwanda.
16:30How do you want to invite IOM and other UN institutions while Amnesty International operates under cover in Rwanda,
16:41and Human Rights Watch has even no access to Rwanda.
16:45How do you ensure the legality of it?
16:47Well, it's part of the agreements, actually.
16:49And it's part of that the five member states of the European Union reached out to the international organization,
16:55making them part of not only the legal agreement, but also the implementation on the counter.
17:01Rwanda who has to ask.
17:02And this is part of the deal as well.
17:06And I think what you just mentioned, and I fully agree with you here, that there is a very high
17:13value
17:13and a very high need, actually, of having our development policies, of having our third-country cooperation
17:19also focusing on the countries of return.
17:21This is without any doubt, but it's not vice versa.
17:25It's both ways.
17:27And to that point, let's just take a breather here.
17:29I know you have a lot of things you want to say.
17:32I think it's not a coincidence that people are being sent to Rwanda, and now we talk about Uganda.
17:37This is not a coincidence.
17:38Well, that's next on the list, it would seem, because it's not just going to be one country.
17:41It looks like it will be multiple countries in the future.
17:43We will debrief that.
17:44But first, let's take a breather here.
17:47Let's take a quick pause, and we'll be right back in the next section.
17:58Now, welcome back to The Ring.
18:01I'm Maria Tere.
18:01We continue debating the implications around migration policy in the European Union.
18:07with Lana Dupont.
18:08You are German from the Conservatives.
18:10And of course, Robert Biedrin, you are Polish and progressive, which can actually happen.
18:14You can put those two in the same sentence.
18:17And of course, we are, of course.
18:20And of course, as I say, we are focusing on migration.
18:24And a week after five EU countries enter now a partnership with Rwanda to send back
18:30to return rejected asylum seekers away from EU territory.
18:35I do want to, however, look at the numbers, because this is important in this debate to inject a form
18:41of nuance.
18:42These are numbers from Frontex.
18:44In the first half of this year, so 2026, more than 33,000 people were returned to non-EU countries.
18:51That means on a year-on-year basis, there's been a 10% increase.
18:56Around two thirds went back to their countries voluntarily.
19:00That means approximately 21,000 people.
19:04So, Robert, how does that add up to your thesis that this is not going to work and that it
19:10is simply a PR stunt?
19:11Well, there is another also number that there is less and less migrants willing to enter EU.
19:20We see the decrease on that.
19:22So, the data go against these populist ideas, which don't work on return hubs.
19:30Again, while we create opportunities for people in their country of origin, they are willing to stay.
19:37No one wants to leave their country.
19:41People leaving their families in desperation, looking for a better life.
19:45So, what we should do…
19:47So, you say they are going back because in their country of origin, the country where they come from, the
19:52situation is better.
19:52You honestly believe that?
19:54Well…
19:54You think in Syria the situation is better now than it was 10 years ago?
19:57People are coming back because of that reason.
20:00But what differs us from global powers like China and Trump administration as European Union?
20:08That we have values.
20:10We have some standards which we respect.
20:13And this is why Lena, Maria, me, we all feel protected by these values.
20:20And these values should not be braked to the people just because they are migrants.
20:27This is not only moral obligation, but the legal obligation for these people.
20:32Look, that's a good question.
20:33What about values?
20:34Is this Trump without calling it Trump?
20:36No, of course it's not because we have been investing in the past years quite extensively on the European answer
20:42to it.
20:43Let's say the European way of how we handle things and how we want to do it.
20:46And this is why exactly we focus so much on the Asylum and Migration Pact.
20:50Remember that it has actually come out of 10 years not being able to come forward with a functioning legally
20:57sound policy.
20:58And we did that not only here in this house, but also together with the member states.
21:02The French and the Spanish say you are undoing the migration pact.
21:05No, we are not.
21:06It has always been.
21:07You saw there was a furious reaction from Emmanuel Macron just a month ago at the European Council.
21:11Yeah, yeah, of course. I remember.
21:12But I can also say that when you look at...
21:13And you did it and handled it far right.
21:15Lena.
21:15Let me just shortly answer, Robert.
21:17We invested so much in the center of the house in concluding the pact.
21:23Return was always part of it.
21:25Third country cooperation was always part of it and has always been part and needs to be part of it.
21:32Because again, like you just said, we have a duty also to help with whatever we can to improve the
21:37situation on the ground.
21:39Nevertheless, we still have a situation within the European Union where we are indeed facing lesser arrivals,
21:45which is part of the pacts and of course the measures that we had taken in between.
21:50But we still have a lot of people within the European Union that have an effective return decision after all
21:55legally procedures have been absolved.
21:58And they don't return.
21:59So you said a court order has to be implemented.
22:01A court order has to be implemented.
22:03And like you just said, it's about the principle of rule of law.
22:06If we set rules based on our values, based on our legal principles, based on our treaties, based on national,
22:13European and international law,
22:15there needs to be consequences if you don't...
22:17But we have...
22:18Lena is bringing...
22:18But she is bringing a fair point.
22:20There are individuals who at times have not just one, but multiple orders to quit.
22:25And we are...
22:26And they are not implemented.
22:27Please, please, just one very, very important thing here.
22:30Because you were speaking about the voluntary returns.
22:33Voluntary returns is what we not only support financially and with integration measures,
22:39but it's always for the European level and for the national level the first measure.
22:44Return hubs, look at those where we don't have a good cooperation with the...
22:48So you think the problem is a country of origin?
22:51Yeah.
22:52But then we need to work with the countries of origin on that.
22:55But there are also at times non-democratic countries, you know it.
22:59Imagine, Lena, again...
23:01But if they're not following the international obligation to take back their own citizens,
23:06then there needs to be also a consequence in the way we cooperate with third countries.
23:09Robert, that's a fair point. Go ahead.
23:10But not sending people to countries which are de facto dictatorships.
23:13Imagine one day something goes...
23:15So what's the solution? What's the alternative solution?
23:16The solution is, of course, better measures within European Union.
23:19Which means what specifically to our viewers watching this?
23:22Screening, for example, these people, where they move.
23:24I understand many of them are not being screened when they are.
23:28We're losing track on them.
23:29We have ways to screen these people.
23:32And once you screen them and you determine, okay, you are here irregularly, illegally, then what?
23:37This needs to be individually judged.
23:40That's also the ruling of European Court on Human Rights.
23:43Yeah, but that's still the principle.
23:44There is the European Court on Human Rights.
23:47But that doesn't take away the fact that you cannot legally be in Europe.
23:49So in your view, if a return hub is basically a peer stunt and is populism with the far right,
23:54that's a very heavy statement.
23:55Yes.
23:55What is the alternative?
23:56The alternative is to cooperate with the countries of their origin.
24:01They don't want to do it at times.
24:02Yes.
24:03But you cannot...
24:06You are strict trade?
24:07Would you propose?
24:08Would you sanction countries that don't take them back?
24:10Individuals?
24:11We're talking about people.
24:11We, as European Union, we have tools to work with these countries.
24:15Which are, for example, sanctions on these countries, which is a pressure.
24:20And not to send these people.
24:21Well, you ask about the numbers.
24:24The thing is that for your populist solution, the taxpayers will pay seven times more than
24:32these people would stay.
24:33This is an example from Italy.
24:36In Albania, the cost for Italy, for each person, is 153,000 euros.
24:44Again, Italy was about the asylum procedure, not about returns.
24:49So you're saying it will be even more cost...
24:52No.
24:52It's going to be the other way around.
24:54Consuming in Rwanda?
24:55No.
24:55It will be even more expensive.
24:56We need to move on.
24:57But Giorgia Meloni would argue the Italian taxpayer prefers to pay and not have a regular
25:03migration in the country than to have to integrate and put forward policies to integrate.
25:09That's what she would argue.
25:10Migration also needs to be handled with a possibility to enforce returns.
25:15Maybe Giorgia Meloni is similar to Mertz, the councillor of Germany, who once said he
25:21doesn't want to see these people on the streets because they spoil the picture of the city.
25:26Well, in a way they are similar.
25:27But that's really going very far.
25:29It's a explanation why at German local level all the MPs, including the S&D governments,
25:35were supporting a statement in October 26th saying that they welcome and support the initiative
25:40by the federal government.
25:42And that is also your group.
25:42But we need to now take a pause here and move on to our next round.
25:46Stay with us here on The Ring.
25:51Now we need to bring in a new voice, and that is the Spanish Prime Minister.
25:57Allow me to read you this full quote.
25:59I don't see a future nor humanity in it.
26:02We are a country of principle that respects human rights.
26:06And over the course of this year, the aggregate figures show that irregular migration has fallen
26:12by around 38%.
26:14And on the Atlantic coast, it has fallen by more than 70%.
26:18And this is because there has been a public policy behind it that is based on cooperation
26:23with the countries of transit and origin.
26:27The Spanish Prime Minister had a big problem over the summer in Ceuta too.
26:30So cooperation is not working in every time.
26:33The Spanish Prime Minister goes a step further and now says it is simply inhumane.
26:38This is not what the European Union should be.
26:41When you hear this kind of language, Elena, do you go, perhaps we're taking it too far?
26:48No, let me differentiate here a bit.
26:50First of all, I think also with the development on the Canary Islands this week,
26:56probably the Spanish government should probably take up some responsibility there.
27:01Do you think he's on talk, no action, Spanish Prime Minister?
27:04At least they need to react to something.
27:06And the history of the reaction so far was not necessarily in a well-managed situation.
27:13Second thing, how on earth, and I fully agree with that whatever we do at European level,
27:19leave aside the fact that it's five countries, it's not a Euro initiative,
27:23it's a bilateral, five-lateral initiative by member states.
27:27It looks like a pilot, however, for more countries.
27:28But how on earth can we say that if you have five member states based on the legal base in
27:34European law
27:35under the obligation of international, European, and national law,
27:39say that this instrument is doomed from the very beginning on?
27:43The UK said the same and it didn't work. Are you sure this is going to be different here?
27:48It was about the asylum procedures. Again, there is a difference when you look at the procedures.
27:51And we need to make that distinction because whatever Robert said was right.
27:55Of course we need to improve our third country cooperation.
27:58Of course we need to speak about sanctions if they don't work in well.
28:00And we have a toolbox there. Return hubs are one part of a broader toolbox for us in managing migration.
28:09Uphelding the values and the protection status that we granted.
28:14And we grant based on our treaties and laws.
28:18And if you're not eligible for protection, we need to find ways of organizing that.
28:23Of course it needs to be in a humane way because this is what we upheld to.
28:26Robert.
28:26And this is what we're forced to.
28:27But when you look at the possibilities of staying within the European Union illegally,
28:32with no proper perspective or having a perspective,
28:36being able to build up your own life again in a country,
28:40in a country and there are probably also others that are in the discussion.
28:44In Rwanda, maybe Uganda, Kazakhstan has also been mentioned.
28:46It's a decision that you can take.
28:49Well, actually, I think there is no coincidence that these countries are like Rwanda, Uganda,
28:56Uzbekistan and so on and so on. These countries have serious problems with the human rights violations.
29:01But I'm also wondering, Lena, what makes you sure that Rwanda's dictatorship, de facto,
29:08will send these people home, will create in Rwanda also job opportunities.
29:13They will take care of their families. They will protect these people.
29:17We have no evidence on that. Opposite.
29:19We have evidence also from Trump's administration that it didn't work.
29:25The breadth of the human rights violations in this country is serious.
29:33And for me also, as a Pole, you know, I'm Polish and from my historical memory,
29:39I have terrible, terrible memories on camps.
29:43Really, when I hear camps, the people by force...
29:46Do you think these are deportation camps? Because the word really matters.
29:50These people don't want to go to Rwanda. They will not be willing to go to Rwanda.
29:54They will be by force, illegally, in my opinion, sent to Rwanda and kept that.
30:01So the EU is enforcing right now deportation camps?
30:05Well, how do you want to call it? You can nicely call it haps.
30:09But those are camps. In Albania, do you have access to Albanian Return Hub?
30:19Even human rights organizations...
30:22There is no Albanian Return Hub.
30:23Robert, please.
30:23Well, it's not functioning. It's not functioning.
30:27Looking at the policies, you know, by just throwing in, you know,
30:29Trump a bit there and Russia a bit there and camps.
30:32There's a history in Europe.
30:34That does not solve problems. And believe me, I've been investing time in that field,
30:38exactly because I don't want us to do it right.
30:42But without overloading the debate with unbalanced comparisons, I would say.
30:49And I really, really appreciate your stance on really pointing the fingers on the respect for human rights
30:55because this is what makes us humans. This is what makes us Europeans.
30:59But respect for human life and respect for our treaties and values also comes with the obligation
31:05that everyone within the European Union needs to follow the law.
31:10And that was our approach.
31:12And that includes returns after legally ended procedures.
31:15But you changed your mind and you went the extreme right way.
31:18No, I didn't.
31:19Who voted with you?
31:20Extreme right way.
31:21We put forward an EPP proposal and we had invited you all the way long to be part of it.
31:27You, for whatever reason, and I respect that, decided not to be part of it.
31:31Because we didn't want to participate in human rights violation standards.
31:35But not all the policies that you are just not fine with are far right, honestly.
31:39Well, I'm appalled and I'm very emotional about that because we have a history in Europe.
31:45We have a history and we are different with China and Russia and Trump administration because we don't do these
31:55things.
31:56We just simply don't go this way.
31:59And I'm shocked that the EPP went together with Le Pen, with all these populists from Vox, with Confederation from
32:12Poland together to go this dark narrow where we will be people treating people like toys that you can replace
32:20them to the country.
32:21They have nothing in common, put them in this situation, dictatorship country.
32:25That's international law.
32:26No.
32:26It has nothing to do.
32:27It is international law.
32:28It violates the international law.
32:31No, it does not.
32:31We have rulings on that.
32:33It actually adheres to international law.
32:34You cannot send individuals to the country where there is a danger of breaking their human rights.
32:42You cannot do that.
32:43There is...
32:44Yeah, you're right on that.
32:45And the second thing...
32:46Rwanda.
32:47Rwanda is the country.
32:48It's also about the non-refoulement.
32:50But if this is legally sound, under the agreement, assured that it's not happening, and also have in mind that
32:57Rwanda had actually taken in quite a substantive number of refugees from neighboring countries.
33:05So there is already a huge migration population under the ground.
33:09Although they do it for money, obviously they do it for the money incentive, but Robert, I want to think
33:11about it.
33:12I want to think about something that bounds them to the agreement.
33:15But just...
33:15And of course there will be a huge emphasis in the implementation of the agreement.
33:19But Robert, my point is that we cannot just, you know, end all the debates just because of the emotional...
33:24I agree with you.
33:25But let me pick up on this point, Robert.
33:26One second, please.
33:27We should be constructive on that.
33:28Robert, but let me pick up on this point.
33:29I promise you we will go back.
33:31We take a pause from here.
33:32We'll come right back and then I will put you yes or no questions before our final word.
33:37Stay with us.
33:41Now I'm going to ask you, please, to keep it very short.
33:44This is a yes or no round of questions.
33:47So perhaps, Robert, since I left it on you, let me ask you, yes or no, will return hubs effectively
33:54reduce irregular migration in the short term?
33:57Yes or no?
33:58Any term, no.
34:00Madame Dipan, same question.
34:01As tool in the toolbox, yes, it can help.
34:05Robert, back to you.
34:06Do return hubs outside the European Union undermine the right to seek asylum?
34:11Yes or no?
34:12It's obvious.
34:13Yes, they break the human rights standards, not only in Europe, but internationally.
34:18No, because we're speaking about returnees after all the legal procedures have been exhausted.
34:22Madame Dipan, is the rise of the far right driving EU migration policy more than actual facts?
34:28When you look at the numbers, are you enacting this policy because you are concerned that you're going to lose
34:33voters?
34:33Or because the numbers are warranted?
34:35Or because the numbers are warranted?
34:35Populists will use whatever floats the boat.
34:38But besides that, we have problems within our societies that we need to solve.
34:43Robert, same question to you.
34:44Is it being driven by the far right?
34:47It's a voter calculus, not really a real fact.
34:50That's to my disappointment because we work perfectly on so many issues.
34:54I respect the European People's Party on so many issues.
34:57We have a platform in the European Parliament together and there is no need for cooperation.
35:00Very quickly, yes or no.
35:02Is the Migration Commissioner Brumer doing a good job, yes or no?
35:05I have doubts.
35:06You have doubts.
35:06Is the Migration Commissioner doing a good job, yes or no?
35:09Yes.
35:10Well, on that note, thank you so much to the two of you for joining us in this debate.
35:16It is clear you have very different views, but that also reflects the debate out in Europe.
35:22So that is it for this edition of The Ring.
35:25As always, we want to hear from you, so please do send us your comments and feedback to our
35:30email address, theringaturonews.com.
35:33Thank you so much.
35:39Thank you so much.

Recommended