00:00Another day, another round of EU sanctions on Russia.
00:03The bloc's foreign ministers have approved another package of sanctions
00:07taking aim at Russian banks, oil refineries and its shadow fleet.
00:11It targets almost 150 extra individuals and entities,
00:15including 50 financial institutions,
00:17companies linked to the shadow fleet
00:19and people and organisations involved in cyberattacks and hybrid activities.
00:23This batch of sanctions and the 22nd economic sanctions package expected later this month
00:29once again show how keen Brussels is to plug the holes
00:32in its Foreign Affairs Council sanctions regime.
00:34But how is Russia able to get round them in the meantime?
00:37What sanctions are actually effective against Moscow?
00:41And also in this episode, with many pointing the finger squarely at Russia
00:45for the string of recent bomb threats on European planes,
00:48how much do we actually know about the threats and who's really behind them?
00:53This to come on Euronews Verify.
01:00So, in short, Russia leapfrogs EU sanctions
01:03by routing goods and financial flows through third countries,
01:07exploiting trade loopholes and using an illicit shadow fleet for its energy exports.
01:12In other words, restricted Western products are imported through non-EU countries,
01:17not part of the sanctions regime.
01:18For example, such as China, India and those in Central Asia.
01:22The shadow fleet, meanwhile, might sound cool,
01:25but it's actually a vast group of older Russian tankers
01:28with opaque ownership and frequent name changes
01:31to cloud their true origin.
01:33These tankers conduct ship-to-ship transfers in the middle of the ocean
01:37to hide that crude oil and petroleum has come from Russia
01:40before heading to buyers in Asia and elsewhere.
01:43As for which sanctions appear to be the most effective against Russia,
01:46analysts say that oil import bans and export controls on Western tech
01:50hit the country hardest, because they deliver a blow to its economy
01:54and its ability to make sophisticated military equipment.
01:57They're the short answers to our first questions,
02:00but let's take a more in-depth look.
02:02The EU has slapped sanctions on around 4,600 individuals and entities
02:06and frozen more than 28 billion euros in private assets
02:10since Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
02:14Putting an exact price tag on the sanctions is difficult,
02:16but we do have estimates that say that they've cost Russia billions and billions
02:21in lost oil revenues and higher import costs.
02:24For example, Western sanctions have cost the Russian economy
02:271.3 trillion euros since that time, according to Brussels.
02:30Other analysis says that the West's withdrawal from the Russian market
02:34accounts for about $85 billion lost in imports,
02:38$70 billion of which is down to the EU,
02:40and that Moscow's only managed to plug the gap by half via Chinese imports.
02:45This latest package is meant as a new round of targeted sanctions listings,
02:50rather than a comprehensive new trade embargo.
02:52By going after some 50 Russian banks,
02:55the EU is hoping to restrict their ability to conduct transactions
02:58and access European financial services.
03:01This makes it harder for Russia to move money internationally and finance trade.
03:06But it's worth remembering that these are targeted bans of specific institutions,
03:11not a blanket ban on all Russian banking.
03:13Targeting oil refineries and the Shadow Fleet, meanwhile,
03:17makes it harder and more expensive to trade Russian oil,
03:20therefore squeezing Moscow's ability to fund its invasion of Ukraine.
03:24The listed individuals and entities covering malicious activities,
03:27such as disinformation and foreign interference,
03:29will be hit with asset freezes and travel bans.
03:32Yet, despite all this, Russia is still often able to get through the cracks.
03:36How does Russia obtain goods, technology, money and services from the EU
03:42and other European countries, despite the restrictions in place?
03:46The bad news is that, you know, the most simple, direct, straightforward way works pretty well.
03:52So you don't, if you are somebody inside Russia who wants to get the sanctioned goods,
03:57it's not that difficult.
03:58So a lot of this comes through third countries like Kazakhstan, Turkey, Armenia, Hong Kong and so on.
04:06There are many of those and you don't even have to hide them
04:10because on the Russian side of the border it's legal.
04:14And, yeah, to the best of our knowledge, there are other schemes,
04:17but to the best of our knowledge, this is the main channel and it works pretty well.
04:23Nevertheless, analysts say that restrictions on oil revenues,
04:26export controls on tech and sanctions on Russian banks are still the way to go
04:31because they have the biggest effect on Moscow's war chest.
04:34There are many papers like my own that estimate the effect of import sanctions.
04:40So, well, let's say European export sanctions.
04:44So when Europe prohibits the import of goods like microchips to Russia.
04:48And then even though there are these ways to import microchips,
04:52still we find that Russia imports a lot less microchips because of that, because of sanctions.
04:58So it's through third countries, it's much more expensive, you get a lower quality and so on.
05:02So in the end you get a much lower amount of everything, everything that is forbidden,
05:09and then you can use less of it for your military effort.
05:13And once we aggregate these estimates, we get that maybe Russia loses about a half or one percentage of GDP
05:21because of these import restrictions.
05:23And if you think that these revenues are about five or six percent of GDP,
05:29then it also becomes around one percent of GDP of total loss due to these sanctions on Russian oil and
05:35gas.
05:36And then it becomes roughly comparable to the export sanctions.
05:40These are in contrast to sanctions which simply add more Russian citizens or companies to blacklists or asset freezes
05:47because they have a more limited impact on Moscow's coffers and its ability to wage war.
05:53That's not to say they're totally ineffective, though.
05:56They target the networks that help Russia get around existing sanctions
06:00rather than simply adding more restrictions on direct e-Russia trade.
06:04Now, we mentioned earlier that one of the reasons Russian individuals and entities keep getting blacklisted
06:10is due to their hybrid and cyberattacks against Europe.
06:14And following a wave of bomb threat hoaxes against a number of European airlines,
06:19many were quick to put the blame on Moscow.
06:22Over to Tamsin Patanoster now to tell us how far Russia and pro-Russian actors are involved.
06:34In just five days, more than 50 flights across Europe were caught up in a wave of bomb threats.
06:40Aircraft were diverted, fighter jets were scrambled, and passengers faced lengthy delays
06:46only for searchers of airplanes to find no explosives.
06:50So what do we know so far about who is behind these threats?
06:55The first incident in this wave that we've identified was on Monday, the 2nd of November,
07:00when a Whiz air flight from London to Sofia diverted to Budapest,
07:04escorted by a Hungarian fighter jet.
07:07The following day, at least seven more flights across Europe were targeted.
07:12And by Thursday, the 5th of November, nearly 30 flights were affected,
07:16including services involving Madrid, Prague and Rome.
07:21And on Friday, the threats continued on at least 18 flights,
07:25including a Whiz air flight from Prague to Rome, which was diverted to Venice.
07:31A day prior, an email sent to an airport in Rome came to come from Mayo's state.
07:37This is a Russian ultranationalist and misogynistic movement founded by former fitness trainer
07:43Vladislav Pozniakhov.
07:45The group was banned in Russia in 2021, although Pozniakhov remained active on Telegram.
07:51He has denied involvement in the threats,
07:54posting on Telegram that the movement hasn't even existed since 2021.
08:02But how credible are the clues linking the threats to the male state?
08:06I would say it, I mean, it can't be discounted,
08:09but I sort of assess it to be fairly unlikely that it is directly connected to this sort of historic
08:16group.
08:17That same day, thousands of kilometers away in Colombia,
08:22authorities in Bogota said they were investigating whether an email address belonging to a public health institution
08:29could have been used to send threats against European flights.
08:34But neither the send an address nor the signature proves who was behind the threats.
08:39Experts told us that senders like these can use tools such as VPNs to obscure their apparent location,
08:46while compromised email accounts can make identifying the person responsible even more difficult.
08:52On Friday, 6th of November, Italy's Prime Minister Giorgia Maloney warned that civilian infrastructure was under attack,
08:59although she said it was unclear if bomb threats or other recent cyber attacks were connected.
09:05Beyond the question of who sent the threats,
09:08there's also the question of what such disruption could achieve.
09:11Yeah, I think it does fit into a wider pattern.
09:16I mean, we can see that all kinds of infrastructure is being targeted.
09:20And the aim is always with these kind of attacks is always to impose some economic costs.
09:26But more importantly, it's really, I would say, the political cost that comes with it.
09:32Citizens are worried, feel worried.
09:34It is part of an information campaign, part of a political campaign against the political system,
09:44against the existing political order.
09:47And it really aims at destabilizing our countries.
09:51In November, the Financial Times reported that some intelligence officials suspect pro-Kremlin activists
09:57or hacking groups may be behind the threats.
10:00But no evidence publicly establishing Russian involvement has emerged yet.
10:05Unfortunately, there's very little hard evidence that it's sort of directly linked to Russia.
10:12We've got speculation in popular reporting, including some alleged reports from anonymous security officials close to investigation.
10:23But what I think we can say is that it's consistent with the operational intentions
10:29and the sort of tactics we've seen from Russia previously.
10:35Thank you, Tamsin.
10:36That's it for today.
10:37Thanks for being with us on Euronews Verify.
10:40And as always, stay skeptical, demand the facts, and we'll see you next time.
10:52Thank you.
10:53Thank you.