- 4 minutes ago
This video dives deep into the challenges faced by promoted teams in the Premier League. We analyze managerial tactics, team performance, and historical data to determine if survival is truly possible, or if it's a case of being out of their depth.
Category
đŸ¥‡
SportsTranscript
00:00We're nine games into the Premier League season and the three promoted clubs have 31 points between them.
00:05That's just over a point a game, which is roughly what it takes to stay up.
00:09And for three teams who spent the summer being written off, that should be the headline.
00:13But it's not, because what they're doing to get those points is far more telling than the points themselves.
00:18I'm Matt from 442 and today we're asking, have promoted teams finally cracked the Premier League?
00:27Last weekend, Hull City and Ipswich Town went head-to-head in a meeting of two newly promoted sides with
00:32differing styles.
00:33And whilst the hard-fought-to-all draw will probably please both sets and fans,
00:37it also means that even at this early stage of the season, Hull maintains their unbeaten home record.
00:42Five games at the MKM so far, one win and four draws.
00:45It's a fairly important number to draw your attention to because in the last decade,
00:49only two other promoted teams have started a Premier League season campaign unbeaten in their first four home matches.
00:56Wolves in 2018-19 and Sunderland last year, both of whom went on to finish seventh.
01:02Well, one stat isn't a trend, so let's zoom out a little bit.
01:06These aren't three teams cruising by any stretch, they're just not collapsing the way their predecessors did.
01:11I mean, you only need to look at the state of the promoted teams a few years back to see
01:14what true stubbornness looked like and where it left them.
01:17In 1953, the philosopher Isaiah Berlin split thinkers into two types.
01:22The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing.
01:26I'm fully aware that comparing Frank Lampard to a woodland mammal is a stretch,
01:30but stay with me because it explains things better than any tactics board could.
01:35For years, promoter managers were hedgehogs.
01:38One big idea of stubbornly defended to the death and not squished at the side of the road death,
01:43but footballing death in the form of relegation.
01:45Vincent Kompany is the poster boy for this.
01:48His Burnley side won promotion with seven games to spare, 101 points, three defeats all season,
01:53and slick, confident football that made the championship look like, well, just another training session.
01:58They then reached the Premier League, kept doing the exact same thing, and finished 19th with 24 points.
02:03The ideas hadn't changed, the opposition had.
02:06And here's the bit I still find funny.
02:08They didn't even sack him.
02:10He stayed to the bitter end, went down with the ship, and then left for Bayern Munich.
02:14Russell Martin, on top of this, is the other case.
02:17A year later, Southampton went the same way, and he insisted there was no other way to play.
02:21His footballing stock could not have fallen further since.
02:25You could point at company successor Bayern and say that, oh, he was onto something,
02:29but realistically, the level of his talent in the current Bayern squad makes that a tough comparison.
02:34What isn't up for debate, though, is the body count.
02:37In 23-24, all three promoted sides went straight back down.
02:40Burnley, Sheffield United, Luton.
02:42The year later, it happened again.
02:44Leicester, Southampton, Ipswich.
02:46Six promoted sides, six relegations.
02:48Even Ipswich, a well-run club with a well-liked manager in Kieran McKenna, couldn't dodge the bullet.
02:54Two seasons of the same experiment with the same result, and at some point,
02:57the data stopped being bad luck and starts being a message.
03:01Which raises an obvious question.
03:04If the hedgehog's singular way of thinking wasn't working,
03:07who actually paid attention and tried to do something differently?
03:11Before we carry on, though, a quick word from today's sponsor, Norton VPN.
03:15Whether you're working from a coffee shop, traveling, or just browsing at home,
03:18you're constantly sending information across the internet.
03:21Norton VPN helps add an extra layer of privacy by encrypting your internet connection
03:25and helping keep your online activity more private.
03:27It's simple to use, works across your everyday devices,
03:30and you can connect to VPN servers in locations around the world,
03:35whether you're at home or on the move.
03:37So, if you want to add another layer of privacy and security to your everyday browsing,
03:42click the link in the description below to find out more and see the latest Norton VPN offers.
03:47Right, back to the video.
03:49This is where we look at the Foxes.
03:51No, not Leicester City, God knows what animal they'd be right now in League One,
03:55but the managers who know many things.
03:57Take Ipswich this season, and in particular their game against Manchester City.
04:00They lost narrowly, scoring twice at the Etihad, but the interesting bit was the shape.
04:05Gary O'Neill, who took over from Kieran McKenna in the summer,
04:08switched to a 5-for-1 out of possession for the first time in his current job
04:11because he felt the game required it.
04:14O'Neill is on record as saying he prefers his team to have the ball.
04:16He's also on record as saying that at the end of the season,
04:19people will only care about how many points they put on the board.
04:22Perhaps the most Fox-like of all, he said that there are some games you have to adapt a bit.
04:27You have to try and be clever and pick your moments.
04:30Philosophy or arithmetic?
04:32He's clearly picked arithmetic.
04:34Then there's Frank Lampard, whose commentary side won the championship
04:37playing some wonderful attacking football.
04:39Asked how that would translate, he was refreshingly honest,
04:42saying we'd be fools to think we could go and play like we did in the Champ every week,
04:46which is basically a manager telling you before a ball has been kicked
04:49that he's retired the greatest hits in favour of something a little bit more pragmatic.
04:52Last season, they had 55% of the ball, the fourth most in the division.
04:56A quarter of the way through this season, the Nats dropped to under 39%.
04:59But Lampard isn't the first to make this tactical call.
05:02The template arrived last season.
05:04Daniel Farker kept leads up and Regis Labrie took Sunderland to seventh,
05:08both after moving away from their championship styles
05:11towards something more muscular and counter-attacking,
05:14with experienced signings providing the sort of knowledge and backbone
05:17to steer the respective clubs through choppy waters when the tough moments arrived.
05:21Burnley, by the way, were the third promoter's side and they went straight back down.
05:24But two of three surviving wasn't that bad after those two brutal seasons prior.
05:29The numbers back the pattern too.
05:31These three clubs, two of whom were known for their footballing prowess,
05:34are in the bottom four for the lowest average possession in the league.
05:38Hull and Coventry have the lowest pass completion
05:41and Coventry's Carl Rushworth actually tops the long pass leaderboard
05:46ahead of Hull's Konstantinos Solakis.
05:49So, three managers, three different routes, one destination.
05:52A pragmatic approach to getting points on the board.
05:56If defensive solidity and set pieces are good enough for Mikel Arteta's side
06:00to become champions of England,
06:02it's hard to call them a character flaw when you're scrapping for survival.
06:05A style that used to get sneered at now has an elite level stamp of approval.
06:09Also, I'd add one more reason into that.
06:11Lamport and O'Neal both have something to prove back in the Premier League
06:14and neither is in a position to be precious about it.
06:17But before anybody commissions a statue of them,
06:20this is just nine games of evidence
06:22and nine games will back up pretty much any argument you fancy.
06:25Take Hull.
06:26Last season in the Championship,
06:28they picked up far more points than their performances deserved.
06:30They beat their expected points by 19.9,
06:33the biggest gap in the division,
06:35which is the kind of number that makes Analyst break out into a sweat
06:37because it's unsustainable and unpredictable.
06:40Then there's Coventry,
06:41who are averaging around 1.15 expected goals for and 1.7 against.
06:46That's a negative expected goal difference of more than half a goal a game.
06:50It's not a knife edge.
06:51It's more of a warning light.
06:53And none of this, by the way,
06:54accounts for January recruitment or who pulls a hamstring in February.
06:58Now, there are some counterexamples
07:00and there's probably one you've been screaming at the screen about.
07:02Brendan Rodgers.
07:03He kept Swansea up playing proactive football
07:05and it got him the Liverpool job, to be fair.
07:07Okay, but that was 2012
07:10and the Premier League he did it in is a long way from this one.
07:13Proactive survival hasn't become, therefore, impossible.
07:16It's just rarer and a lot riskier.
07:19The managers here aren't going rogue.
07:20They're just adapting.
07:21Having more arrows in your bone never mattered more.
07:24And the days of a manager building a career on one trick
07:27are well and truly over.
07:28But adapting doesn't guarantee survival.
07:32And all of the three can still be fairly labelled, I think, as relegation candidates.
07:36But thinking positively, and after all the evidence, the quotes and the animal metaphors,
07:40the question still stands.
07:41Have they cracked it?
07:43Short answer, they've cracked the method, but not yet the result.
07:47Holipswich and Coventry have worked out the thing their predecessors refused to.
07:51That these days the Premier League is a different animal
07:53and you don't get to bring up the same one from the Championship.
07:55Nor do you get to draw on inspiration from years gone by.
07:59That's the part that's real.
08:01It's a genuine shift and modern football evolves at breakneck speed.
08:04Through all this talk, though, danger constantly lurks
08:06from those higher up on the footballing food chain.
08:09Hull's unbeaten record at home can end any day.
08:11Coventry could easily have another brightened performance on their hands.
08:15And Ipswich are one or two big injuries away from a tactical switch
08:18that looks a little less viable.
08:20Isaiah Berlin described the Hedgehog's worldview
08:23as a fanatical unitary inner vision.
08:25In recent years, that was supposed to be what a promoted manager had.
08:29It was a brave personal brand that drew admiration, but rarely success.
08:34These three have swapped it for points on the board,
08:36and if that cost them a little dignity on the way,
08:38I'd argue that dignity doesn't butter any parsnips.
08:41They've cracked how to stop being the punchline,
08:43but whether they can stay in the division is another matter.
08:45And I'm not going to guess after just nine games.
The best football videosDiscover the Football Corner