- 1 hour ago
On today’s episode, Editor in Chief Sarah Wheeler talks with Lead Analyst Logan Mohtashami about housing construction, including permits and builder confidence data.
Related to this episode:
Why housing construction is sliding back toward COVID-era lows
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/housing-permits-covid-lows/
HousingWire | YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire
Top 5 Trending:
Fitch warns of growing balance-sheet strain at top nonbank mortgage firms
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/fitch-nonbank-mortgage-ratings-outlook/
Mortgage rates jump to 7.58% as inflation lifts bond yields
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/mortgage-rates-jump-758/
Homebuilder confidence sinks to a 14-year low as buyers hibernate
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/homebuilder-confidence-november-2026/
How far can brokerages go when clawing back commissions from departing agents?
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/q2-2026-agent-moves-chinatti/
UWM’s rights offering draws just $1.4M from investors, forcing Ishbia family backstop
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/uwm-rights-offering-mat-ishbia-backstop/
Want more from Sarah? Don’t forget to subscribe!
The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look behind the scenes of the top mortgage and real estate.
Related to this episode:
Why housing construction is sliding back toward COVID-era lows
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/housing-permits-covid-lows/
HousingWire | YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire
Top 5 Trending:
Fitch warns of growing balance-sheet strain at top nonbank mortgage firms
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/fitch-nonbank-mortgage-ratings-outlook/
Mortgage rates jump to 7.58% as inflation lifts bond yields
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/mortgage-rates-jump-758/
Homebuilder confidence sinks to a 14-year low as buyers hibernate
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/homebuilder-confidence-november-2026/
How far can brokerages go when clawing back commissions from departing agents?
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/q2-2026-agent-moves-chinatti/
UWM’s rights offering draws just $1.4M from investors, forcing Ishbia family backstop
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/uwm-rights-offering-mat-ishbia-backstop/
Want more from Sarah? Don’t forget to subscribe!
The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look behind the scenes of the top mortgage and real estate.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:10Welcome, everyone. I'm joined today by lead analyst Logan Motoshami to talk about housing
00:15construction, including permits and builder confidence data. Before we dive in, here are
00:20the top five trending stories on housingwire.com. First, we have Fitch warns of growing balance
00:26sheet strain at top non-bank mortgage firms, followed by mortgage rates jump as inflation
00:32lifts bond yields. Then we have home builder confidence sinks to a 14-year low as buyers
00:37hibernate. And how far can brokerages go when clawing back commissions from departing agents?
00:43Finally, we have UWM's rights offering draws just $1.4 million from investors,
00:48forcing Ishbia family backstop. Okay, we're ready to dive in. Logan, welcome back to the podcast.
00:54It is wonderful to be here. It's so good to be back to home and not living in an airport
01:01and
01:02not knowing what to do. So I feel like myself today. I think the last podcast, I was just still
01:07like
01:08not... I'm so glad. That was a long journey. Four or five days too long. Yes. Okay, well,
01:14let's get to our topic today, which is the home building report. What do we see?
01:19So housing starts, the headline housing starts beat, which tends to happen often, you know,
01:26because it's such a volatile monthly data, but the housing permits were just look terrible.
01:32And this has been happening for years now. So I always like to harp back to
01:37that article we wrote in June of 2021, that when rates rise, the whole construction boom is going to
01:44and so don't put all your eggs into this basket. And the reason I say this is because when you're
01:49part of team higher rates in February of 2021, people come back and go, well, housing construction
01:55is going to be hit. Inventory will never grow. That's not how inventory grows in the existing
02:03home sales market. And like over 90% of inventory growth in this country comes from the existing
02:08home sales market. It's just a bigger stock. When the builders build homes, they provide a house for
02:14people to buy, but you know, it, the active inventory, their completed units of sales rarely
02:21gets over 120,000. So it's not a lot of homes available for sale, but the existing home sales
02:27market, definitely for sure. Like just two weeks of our new listings data during the seasonal peak
02:32is more than what the builders typically perform any year going back to the 1960s. So, but this sector
02:41is just continuing its trend. The question is, do we go to the COVID-19 recession lows over the next
02:48year? Okay. Well, let's answer that question. I mean, cause that, that's not great. We don't want
02:53to be down there. We don't, but that's the laws of supply and demand economics. There simply isn't
03:00enough demand for new homes for the builders to get very excited. Now, new home sales in the last
03:08two reports were peak perking up. So it was confusing to a lot of people because rates had
03:13been moving higher. The builders confidence have been falling, but just remember that the HMI, the,
03:18the, the builders confidence index that a lot of people use that we write in the articles that's
03:24tilted to small builders, not the big publicly traded builders. So there's been a lot of consolidations
03:28in the, in the housing construction industry. So the big builders are just paying down rates.
03:33Again, they're efficient sellers. They're keeping new home sales around 2019 level. So housing starts,
03:39even though we're technically at levels to where the early part of COVID-19 recessions are,
03:45are still at 2019 levels. But the permit data just got really bad. And we're not that far from
03:53single family permits being at the lows of 2022 after that sales crash. We're not that far from the
03:58COVID-19 single family permit low. So basically looks, looks about right considering where everything
04:04is, but the new home sales report has basically been in a channel range for 10 years. Uh, they're
04:10just managing their supply and their supply of total completed units for sales actually been falling
04:16from the start of the year. So it's, it's a very, it's a very funky housing cycle, but if you
04:22don't,
04:22if you're not trained to like follow the builders and how they operate, it could be very confusing.
04:28So one of the things that you always say is what do you say that the first one of the
04:32rules of
04:32fight club or, or from, um, ghostbusters, you don't cross the streams, right? So we do not talk
04:38about the new home sales and his existing home sales in the same way. These are two very different
04:43things. Those are that that's the fight club rules. That's not crossing the streets, crossing
04:47the streets is something else, but the fight club rules. Yes. We never talk about fight club,
04:51but we never mix the existing and new home sales market together because the new home sales market
04:57is still up here. It's like 2019 levels for existing homes is like one to 1.3 million higher,
05:02but they provide seller, uh, uh, buy downs and buying rates, uh, uh, uh, even sub 5%, uh, even for
05:12some products over the years. And, and the housing market shifts just when rates get near 6%. So
05:17imagine the existing home sales market with mortgage rates between five and five, five and a half
05:23sales. So this is my question. Yeah. So this is my question for you. And also I can't keep all
05:28of
05:28the culture, pop culture references straight. Okay. So you got to give me a break on that.
05:33No, I don't. You're my boss. You get put your finger at me. So I'm going to, you know,
05:37fight back and you, you should know the 67 different, uh, versions of our Loganism terms over the years.
05:44Absolutely. Okay. So you always say that demand, you can, you can chart demand,
05:49housing demand gets better when rates are under 6.64%. That, and then as they get closer to six,
05:56that's really where we see it when it comes to the new home sales, is that the same level or
06:01are
06:01they different? No, because the builders are majority always working on a sub 6% rate. So
06:07when it does lower rates, it provides a profit margin boosts in terms of it costs less for them to
06:15do the,
06:16to do the buy downs, but, uh, the new home sales are so elevated versus the existing home sales market
06:22that, uh, uh, it, it would take a lot to get new home sales to really start growing because they're
06:29already elevated compared to that where the existing home sales market, like the pending home sales data
06:33came out. It was softer. Again, uh, purchase application data are still low. It doesn't take
06:38much to move the needle to the upside here. Uh, so it's not the same thing. You have,
06:45you have a lot more upside in the existing home sales market than the new home sales market because
06:49new home sales that outperformed to me, at least in the biggest fashion in, in recent history.
06:55So as you know, I had a Scott Cox on yesterday to talk about home building issues. I thought it
07:00was
07:00a really good conversation. He talked a lot about the demographics and sort of the, um, the sobering
07:05reality of what's coming and how, when, when it comes to demographics and who's going to be buying
07:10homes and what that does to the new home sales market. Um, did any of that surprise you or is
07:15that, does that fit in with your demographic work about 2020 to 2024? I mean, years, 2020 to 2024 was
07:22going to be peak demographics for America that like this century, we're never going to have like so many,
07:27um, uh, millennials at their home buying age on top of everything else.
07:34What I did disagree with him on is that because there's 162 million people still working and the
07:42buyer profiles are kind of five levels in terms of silent generations, baby boomers, Gen X,
07:49uh, millennials and Gen Z, and then Gen A coming, you still have enough demand to keep sales here.
07:56And if you look at the history of new home sales, going back to the 1960s, you know, it's, it's
08:02really
08:03hard for new home sales to really break above 800,000, you know? Um, so the housing bubble years
08:10was, was a whole different conversation that went to 1.4 million COVID. We got to a thousand, uh, excuse
08:17me, a million, 1.4 million, a million, but you could still have enough people to buy new homes. They
08:23just peel off from the existing home sales market. But to me, the demographic story changes going out
08:29in the future because population growth is slowing down, but you still have, if there wasn't a move
08:35up or a move down buyer, that's a different equation, but they do, you know, if you're fully levering up
08:41on first-time home buyers, there's limits on what you can do out here, but going out in the future
08:46as population growth slows down, you know, especially when the baby boomers start dying off 2035 and on,
08:53the builders competition is the existing home sales market. So the existing home sales market
08:58will naturally have more supply. So the builders operate off of down the line, that can be an issue
09:03because older homes tend to be cheaper and geographically they're all around an estate or
09:09city where the new homes are basically clustered into areas with land and all the costs that go with
09:15it. So, um, there's, there's, there's some things I agree with him on the, on the demographic side,
09:21when population growth slows down, you limit, but we still have 162 million people. We're going to
09:26have over 170 million people working in by the next decade. And that gives you that buyer profile
09:33to keep new home sales roughly at these levels, maybe a little bit higher if, if, uh, rates and
09:39things get a little bit better, but that's, that's the new home sales market going back decades.
09:42Like you could go back and, and, and see how it operates.
09:46Something you're always looking at is like, you know, the builder supply, what all their
09:50inventory that's built that maybe hasn't been sold yet. Um, how is that looking?
09:55Well, in the last new home sales, we're going to get the new home sales report, uh, shortly.
09:59So that number gets updated, but actually it peaked. This is a, this is another anomaly here
10:05is that the supply of completed unit sales peaked in actually January and it's been trending lower.
10:12I think the last number was 111,000, 113,000. Um, so that completed units of sale has been falling.
10:19That's the big builders moving stuff, right? You know, so people are always like looking at the
10:24new home sales, like what's going on here. It's like a perfect channel for like 10 years, you know?
10:28Uh, but the builders build something it's ready to go. They don't typically like to have,
10:33uh, completed units of sale in their, in, on their books for three months. So they're efficient
10:38sellers. They, they get that out because they sell homes as a commodity or not the existing
10:43home sales, existing home sales market. You have a seller, you have a buyer, you have people moving,
10:47you have this emotional ties, you have all this stuff. Uh, you have a lot of old homes that need
10:51repair and that's a whole different project builders. Like I got to build it. It's ready to go.
10:55We find a, find a buyer. If we have to pay down rates to five and a quarter, they can
11:01do that still.
11:02Um, so their completed units have been, uh, falling, uh, where the active inventory in America,
11:08which was negative during the mid part of the year, it's, has been picking up on a year over
11:13year basis. Not a very big percentage, but, uh, um, two different marketplaces in that. And I think
11:18that's always the confusing things when people see monthly supply of new homes, let's say at 10 months,
11:24that's not actually 10 months of completed homes ready for sale. So it's really not that much. I mean,
11:29people are just shocked when I show them the data going back decades on how small the completed
11:35units for sale are in America for like, it rarely, it doesn't really go above 120, even the housing
11:41bubble crash years, it never even got to 200,000. And we had 4 million active inventory at one point
11:46in 2007. So, uh, the builders are efficient sellers because if they weren't, they wouldn't be in
11:52business, right? They would, uh, uh, uh, simply not make enough money to do that. And they're
11:59managing and they're managing as best as they can, but it's much harder for smaller builders in this
12:04environment. I remember when, um, the Biden administration came in and they were all about,
12:08we need to build, was it 10 million new homes or like five, it was some crazy number of new
12:14homes
12:14that needed to be built. And you and I were like, that's not even, I mean, that's more homes that
12:19get
12:19sold in a whole year existing and new. I think that was, uh, the white, the current white house
12:24estimate. It was 10 to 12 million, you know, uh, uh, that, Oh, was it a Trump thing? I thought
12:29that
12:29was the, no, no, it was this year when Trump said it. I think everyone on, on X laughed altogether,
12:35you know, um, I'm not a housing shortage person. Once the NAR is active inventories above 1.52 million.
12:44And that's been my line for, for many years now, because if you're above 1.52 million and you are
12:52above four months of supply, that's a functioning marketplace, which means I never really believed
12:57in the shortage story for the last six, seven decades. COVID was something else. So COVID I had
13:03to change because I could see what's going on here for the first time in history. We have massive
13:08amounts of, uh, decline in inventory to levels that we've never seen before. And I I'm not the biggest
13:13fan of using population adjusted numbers for the existing home sales market, because we have so
13:18many people in America, but only a small percentage of people sell and buy homes each year and housing
13:23tenure has doubled in some cases tripled. Uh, but, uh, uh, we're not, we're not going to get,
13:30we're not 10 million short. In fact, you can see it right now. There's enough supply in the existing
13:34home sales market and housing permits are down. That's the business model, right? And I think that
13:40that's where the difference is between, you know, all this hype about this new bill to build more
13:45homes in America and all this stuff and look where housing permits going and it's heading lower and
13:50lower. Uh, Trump did, did say one very, very correct thing about this whole process and industry.
13:58He said the, the bill for housing is a big yawn. I get that. He says, and he said, the
14:06only thing that
14:06matters is rates. I get that too, because if the builders couldn't, let's say the builders couldn't
14:13pay down rates, new home sales would be much worse and housing starts to be much worse. So
14:19Trump is actually more correct than the yes in my backyard people and the congressmen and everything
14:25on how the system works, right? And the system has been here for decades and decades and decades.
14:30And I always like to show people, if you look at housing construction versus population,
14:35that thing has been in a downtrend for years, decades, decades. And people go, look, we haven't
14:39built enough. That looks pretty normal to me, to a country that built a lot of homes since the 1940s.
14:46And every decade that goes by the existing home sale crop of homes, their competition is bigger and
14:53bigger and bigger while the new home sales market is trying to just peel off buyers and have enough
14:59demand to build a housing starts over a million. Uh, so it becomes more difficult for them. But again,
15:05I think that's, that's the odd part of this. There's the business of building homes and then
15:09there's a, we need to build more homes everywhere. And it's just, it's just, this part has always won
15:15for decades. You want to go with that rather than politicians who say a lot of things, right? Uh, um,
15:22but, uh, uh, it, you could see what happened. People just, the inflation of housing perked up so much
15:28that all the politicians finally said, we have to see like we're doing something, but then the data looks
15:33like this. But you know, the other part of that is that if you had all those new homes and
15:38you had a
15:38whole bunch more people, I mean, as supply, you know, gets bigger than people's, you know, home
15:43prices would go down, home values would go down, which if you had, you know, millions of, of new,
15:48uh, units coming on for supply, then you have people's, you know, home equity goes down and nobody
15:54wants that. The reason I don't fundamentally buy that premise is because the builders have never been
16:00able to outbuild the existing home sales market supply curve. And the, the, the reason I say that
16:07is the builders have never been able to get completed units of sale above 200,000 for six
16:13decades. There's never going to be millions of homes out there. They do not even allow that process to
16:20happen because, because it would actually ruin their business model. So the existing home sales
16:26market though, going back to 1942 to 2026, that's a long time. We, that is, you know, that's, that's
16:33pre you and I, the one time where we actually did see aggregate price declines for multiple years was
16:41massive amount of inventory, massive amount of distress sales, distress sales as a higher percentage.
16:46So I, I know this discussion gets a lot that the builders are just going to, they've never been able
16:51to do this, nor would they ever want to, because it would destroy their business model. Right. And nor
16:57would we want them to, because it would destroy home. I know, but it's just like a lot of, this
17:03goes
17:03back into the argument of everyone wants more housing, but nobody wants to make, you know, like
17:10if you take all the subsidization away from house, the housing market is so subsidized. So if you want
17:15more affordability, you need prices to fall, right. If you need prices to crash, so you can't have it,
17:20you can't say, this is my number one investment. I want more affordability. So take all the government
17:25subsidies away from housing, have, you know, unfettered, no, you know, get mortgage rates up
17:32to 12 to 13%, have home sales declined for 12, 13 years, then every, oh my God, affordability. But
17:41it's a semantics discussion that I try not to get into because I can't model it out. Right. But it
17:48gets a
17:48lot of talk where people think this, this magnanimous event is going to happen because
17:53of the builders and the builders go, yo, man, I do not build more than 200,000 homes for sale
17:59ever
17:59in the last six decades. Where are you guys coming with this? So, and that's the, that's how housing
18:06is operated. And as somebody who would forecast that slightly negative home prices, I look at it
18:14as a positive where people will be like, you know, oh my God, this is no, we don't have that
18:19in the
18:19data, right? It's now the fourth calendar year after the fastest crash in sales ever. So I know the
18:28argument that it was just being made. I just don't believe in the conversational tones because
18:33anything that's going to happen with prices has to come from the existing home sales market.
18:37And it has to become, on the national basis, has to come from there, not from the builders. The
18:43builders are just way too small to move the needle much. Well, we can't end this episode without
18:48talking about the fact that we had Christopher Waller came out, Fed Governor Christopher Waller
18:53came out again today, talked about how we need to hike rates, how the Fed needs to hike rates.
18:59What's your take on that? What did the market do? Well, I mean, Christopher Waller's trolling Kevin
19:03Walsh. Okay. They don't like each other. Christopher Waller's, Waller's a deadlifter. So he's got to
19:09kind of have that attitude. But even Waller has talked about, if you're going to do a 25% rate
19:16hike,
19:16you need to guide the market for another 25% rate hike going out. So to me, I still think
19:25all they want to do is get their insurance rate cuts that they did last year back, even with
19:30Christopher Waller. Now, if he's going to do, let's do 50, December 50 in the first meeting in
19:372027, that's a whole different cause. Now, nobody, not even Beth Hammock, not even Beth Hammock is
19:43calling for a 50 basis point rate hike. So I think Waller does not like Walsh and our new band
19:51forward
19:51guidance. Waller is just projecting forward guidance to the extreme, which is trolling Walsh
19:57also. Now, the 10-year yield perked up a little bit. I think the 10-year yield is down almost
20:02seven
20:02to eight basis points from that level today. And that's the stocks are selling off again.
20:08But to me, it's just they want to get those insurance rate cuts from last year back. And then
20:14let's see where we're at. Because they're really hoping that the conflict is over and the trade war is
20:19over. I mean, I thought Goldman Sachs did a really good job. They basically outlined that all the
20:25inflation, the excessive inflation, not 100%, but most of it is the trade war and the conflict. And
20:31they break it down to the subjects and where it comes from. If those two things never existed,
20:37we wouldn't be here. Now, the AI inflation is, of course, data centers, electricity costs,
20:42all of it. There's so much investment coming into America. That's 100% true. But they've really
20:47made a good case that most of the inflation growth excessive, right? We always have inflation rising
20:53in America. It's rare to get deflation. But the extra juice really comes from these two things. So
20:58I think the Fed, in some ways, are biding their time and waiting until that. And then they can
21:04reassess everything. And we'll see. Whenever that does happen, we'll see how that outcome turns out.
21:14Oh, my gosh. Well, so far today, it is Wednesday. So far, we haven't had like some major news about
21:20like either banks having an outage or, you know, FEMA getting hacked or like, you know,
21:25ground stops. So fingers crossed, everybody. Fingers crossed. That was six days of a lot of
21:31drama. But Sarah, we've talked about this from the start. Skynet wins. Eventually, I'm telling you all,
21:39we they were pissed off that we were going to do moratoriums and shut down and they're fighting.
21:44They were listening. This is just the beginning of a very, very interesting rest of the century with
21:50technology and humanity. So buckle up, arm up, whatever it is, you know, if you see skull robots
21:59with big guns running around, you know, Skynet had enough of it.
22:04Okay, well, we'll still be doing the podcast. All right, Logan, thank you so much for being on.
22:09We'll talk soon. Pleasure.