- 44 minutes ago
Why does Moscow seem to belong to a different Russia? This political and social analysis traces how federal money, power, high-paying careers, corporate headquarters, and cultural influence concentrate in the capital—drawing talent and opportunity away from regions across the country.
From the doctor and graduate pulled toward Moscow to the anger felt in Belgorod and Kursk over the war’s unequal costs, Elvira Bary explores how regional inequality fuels resentment. The discussion also examines land and waste conflicts, migration, ethnic identity, and why regional artists often need Moscow’s recognition to reach a national audience. For viewers interested in Russian politics, Moscow’s economy, centralization, and the divide between Russia’s capital and its regions, this documentary-style commentary offers a deeper look at where money and influence really go.
From the doctor and graduate pulled toward Moscow to the anger felt in Belgorod and Kursk over the war’s unequal costs, Elvira Bary explores how regional inequality fuels resentment. The discussion also examines land and waste conflicts, migration, ethnic identity, and why regional artists often need Moscow’s recognition to reach a national audience. For viewers interested in Russian politics, Moscow’s economy, centralization, and the divide between Russia’s capital and its regions, this documentary-style commentary offers a deeper look at where money and influence really go.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00Russians have an old saying – Moscow is not Russia.
00:05Russia stretches across 11 time zones and contains more than a thousand cities.
00:11It should have multiple cultural and economic centers,
00:15yet it feels as though there are only two places that really matter – Moscow and St. Petersburg.
00:22Ask people outside Russia to name Russian cities and many will struggle after those two.
00:27Maybe they'll remember Stalingrad – a city that hasn't even been called Stalingrad since 1961.
00:36How did one of the largest countries on Earth become so concentrated around its capital?
00:44I am Elvira Barrick, a Russian-American writer who grew up in the Soviet Union.
00:48Today we are going to look at the uneasy relationship between Moscow and the rest of the country.
00:54Here is our roadmap – the capital vacuum.
00:57Why money and power keep concentrating in one place?
01:03The talent drain.
01:04How Moscow's success helps reproduce regional decline.
01:09Two different rushes.
01:11What happens when the capital begins to feel like another country?
01:16The war's unequal cost.
01:18Why Belgrade and Kursk change the emotional meaning of Moscow?
01:22The bad deal.
01:24Why desirable things move toward the center while unwanted costs move outward.
01:30Who counts as Russian?
01:32How ethnicity adds another layer to regional resentment.
01:37Permission to matter.
01:39Why even cultural success often needs Moscow's approval.
01:43Before we begin, I want to tell you about a project where even a modest nation can make a very
01:49concrete difference.
01:50Meds for Ukraine helps disabled, seriously ill and other vulnerable civilians in Ukraine
01:56by the medicines they need.
01:58The project is run entirely by volunteers with zero overhead.
02:03Donations go directly to patients while volunteers in Ukraine identify
02:07people who need help and verify how the money is used.
02:11The project is run by Tamza Song Club.
02:14A community of people around the world who meet on Zoom, bring their guitars,
02:20sing together and raise money for Ukrainians who did not choose this war or their illness.
02:25But now we have to face both.
02:28You'll find the link below if you'd like to contribute.
02:31Now let's follow the money.
02:34The Capital Vacuum
02:38In a political system like Russia's, power rests on three things.
02:43Who controls the money?
02:44Who controls the important careers?
02:47And who controls the people with guns?
02:50And all three roads lead back to Moscow.
02:54Start with money.
02:56Russian regions do have their own budgets and keep important sources of revenue.
03:01So it would be wrong to say that every ruble earned in the provinces is simply confiscated by Moscow.
03:08But the biggest financial pull in the country is the federal budget.
03:14Major revenue streams, including VAT, customs duties, the federal share of corporate profit tax,
03:22substantial mineral extraction revenues, and some exercises, flow into it.
03:28Federal money is then distributed across the country through spending programs and transfers.
03:34Russia's system of intergovernmental finance is usually centralized for federation,
03:39and some regions depend heavily on federal transfers to finance their obligations.
03:45That changes the political relationship.
03:48A governor who wants a major highway, a new hospital, a larger industrial project,
03:54or emergency financial help needs cooperation from the federal government.
03:59What matters politically is how much control a region has over the money it needs.
04:05A wealthy region may generate enormous revenues, but major projects and financial decisions
04:12can still depend on federal approval, federal programs, or transfers from Moscow.
04:19The second source of power is careers.
04:22Russia is formally a federation, and governors are generally elected either by voters or,
04:28in some regions, by regional legislatures.
04:31But they operate inside what Russian law itself now calls a unified system of political power.
04:38The president coordinates that system and can remove a governor for loss of confidence.
04:44Below the governor, many institutions that can shape political life in a region are
04:50not really regional institutions at all.
04:53A regional prosecutor is appointed by the president, senior officials in the interior ministry
04:58to the federal hierarchy. The local FSB office is part of a centralized federal service.
05:05So, if you are an ambitious official, prosecutor, security officer, corporate executive,
05:11or political operator, Moscow matters enormously.
05:15Careers can be made there, protected there, or stopped there.
05:20And then there is the third pillar – force.
05:24This may be the most important one. The FSB is legally defined as a single-centralized
05:31system, and its regional branches are directly subordinated to the federal service.
05:38RosGuardia is also a federal structure under presidential leadership.
05:43Senior Interior Minister appointments belong to the federal chain of command.
05:48That means a governor does not command his own independent security apparatus.
05:53And this matters because Russia is enormous.
05:57Governing a country this large from one capital would be difficult under any system.
06:03In a highly centralized political system, it creates a constant problem.
06:08How do you prevent powerful regions from becoming independent political centers?
06:14Money, careers, and security provide the answer.
06:18A region may have oil factories, sports, or millions of people.
06:22But if major financial decisions require federal participation, important careers lead through
06:28Moscow. And the security services answer upward to federal authorities.
06:33Economic strength does not easily turn into independent political power.
06:39This also explains something that otherwise looks strange.
06:43Russia has many large and potentially prosperous cities.
06:49Yet Moscow keeps falling in corporate headquarters.
06:53Talented graduates, ambitious officials, lawyers, consultants, and entrepreneurs.
06:59They go where the decisions are made. And once enough decisions are made in one place,
07:05everyone else has another reason to go there.
07:08Russia is a country governed by competing elite groups fighting for resources and access.
07:14In such a system, physical and social proximity to the center matters.
07:20You want to know the people allocating the money.
07:23You want someone to remember your project.
07:26You want access to the officials who can approve, protect, or block it.
07:32That is why Moscow functions as more than a capital.
07:36It is the marketplace of access.
07:39And access is one of the most valuable commodities in the Russian system.
07:44This creates a powerful feedback loop.
07:48Moscow has the power, so people and companies move to Moscow.
07:53Their arrival brings more money, expertise, and influence.
07:57That makes Moscow still more powerful and makes the rest of the country still more dependent on it.
08:04The capital vacuum keeps feeding itself.
08:08But there is a political price.
08:10When people in the regions watch money, careers, and talented young people flow toward Moscow,
08:17they do not necessarily see an efficient national center.
08:21Very often, they see a city getting richer because the system has been built around it.
08:29And that is where resentment begins.
08:32The Talent Train
08:37Imagine you are 18 years old in a small city three hours from Moscow.
08:42You are ambitious, good at math, and you want an interesting career.
08:47What should you do?
08:48Go to Moscow.
08:50Because that's where you can go to a better university.
08:53When looking for a job, you will have more options to choose from.
08:57You can land an internship with a major company, which is not possible elsewhere.
09:02Now imagine you are 35 and a good doctor.
09:07Your hospital is understaffed.
09:09The equipment is all.
09:11Your salary is limited by a regional budget.
09:14200 kilometers away in Moscow, another hospital can pay you five times more.
09:21Again, the rational decision is obvious.
09:25Leave.
09:25Russian officials themselves admit this problem.
09:28In 2025, Tula governor Dmitry Milaev described proximity to Moscow as both
09:34an advantage and a problem because the capital pulls away personnel.
09:39In Saratov region, officials said roughly 100 qualified medical specialists a year
09:45were leaving for Moscow and St. Petersburg because salaries were higher.
09:50In Tver, the regional head said openly that doctors leave for Moscow, Moscow Oblast, and other
09:58richer regions because they can earn more.
10:00Now notice what happens next.
10:03After a good doctor leaves, the regional hospital becomes worse, a good teacher leaves,
10:10and the local school becomes even less attractive.
10:13A programmer leaves, and the local company has more trouble growing.
10:18A young couple leaves because they want better jobs and schools,
10:22and their future children are born somewhere else.
10:26This is how original disadvantage reproduces itself.
10:31This problem cannot be solved with slogans about patriotism.
10:36You can tell a graduate to stay and develop his native region,
10:41but he is comparing two lives.
10:43In one, he is stuck with a low-paying, dead-end job and lack of better options.
10:49In the other, he may double or triple his opportunities by moving to Moscow.
10:55Two different rushes
11:00Eventually, concentration changes something deeper than salaries.
11:05It changes how people see their country.
11:07Today, a trip from a regional city to Moscow can feel like crossing a border.
11:13During the first nine months of 2025, the average monthly salary in Moscow was about 171,000 rubles,
11:23or $2,000.
11:25In Vladimir or Belgorod, in Vladimir and Belgorod regions, it was around 72,000 rubles.
11:32In Bransk, about 64,000 rubles.
11:37So, a person can travel a few hours and enter a labor market where the average salary is more than
11:42twice as high.
11:43And higher salaries create more services of better quality.
11:48Private clinics, restaurants, museums, theaters, universities.
11:51That's how the advantage fits itself.
11:54Healthcare makes the mechanism very easy to see.
11:58In 2024, Moscow had about 69 doctors for every 10,000 residents.
12:04Vladimir region had fewer than 39.
12:07I found a wonderfully revealing line in an online discussion from someone in Kursk.
12:12He described going to Moscow as almost like going to Europe.
12:16Think about what that means.
12:18He was traveling to the capital of his own country, but the difference in infrastructure, wage,
12:24services, and possibilities was large enough to feel foreign.
12:28And this creates resentment even when nobody in Moscow has personally done anything to you.
12:34A Moscovite may look at his beautiful thriving city and think,
12:39this is what competent government can build.
12:42A regional viewer in a small town that is falling apart can look at the same picture and think,
12:49of course, they spend everything on themselves.
12:52And if the gap keeps widening, the resentment will grow.
12:56The war's unequal cost
13:01The war brought another layer to this resentment.
13:04Before 2022, a regional resident could look at Moscow and think,
13:08they have better salaries, better roads, better hospitals.
13:12After 2022, people in Belgrade, Kursk, and Bransk began asking whose life the state protects first.
13:20The decision to invade Ukraine was made in Moscow.
13:23But for years, war was experienced mostly directly by those Russian civilians
13:28who lived hundreds of kilometers away from the capital.
13:32Belgrade was repeatedly shelled and attacked by drones.
13:35People lost homes and moved into temporary accommodation.
13:40Kursk region experienced something even more dramatic in 2024,
13:44when Ukrainian troops crossed the border and residents fled front-line settlements.
13:51And this year, when a large drone attack finally hit Moscow and Moscow Oblast,
13:57something revealing happened online.
13:59Some residents of the border regions responded with anger and glee, rather than sympathy.
14:06When a Moscow blogger complained that people from the region seemed almost
14:09pleased the drones had finally reached the capital, the answers were brutal.
14:15A woman from Belgrade said that her region had carried the war on its shoulders,
14:20while people in Moscow barely noticed.
14:23A commander from Kursk asked whether Moscovites had even made videos mooring people killed there.
14:31Another wrote essentially,
14:34Now you understand what we live through every night.
14:37And perhaps the most important comment was the simplest.
14:42Moscow and Moscow Oblast live and enjoy life.
14:46What about us?
14:47What makes us worse?
14:48These comments show how an old economic hierarchy turned into a moral hierarchy.
14:54If your city is being attacked and you believe the country reacts differently
14:58when the same thing happens in the capital, you wonder,
15:01do our lives count the same?
15:03The capital stops being merely a city and becomes a symbol of the people
15:08who make decisions while leaving others to deal with the consequences.
15:13The Bad Deal
15:17Now we come to perhaps the easiest regional complaint to understand.
15:22Moscow comes to your region and takes the good things.
15:25Then Moscow sends you the bad things.
15:28This pattern appears in completely different places.
15:32Start with Sochi.
15:34Housing there is expensive for many reasons.
15:38The city attracts a lot of people because it has a warm climate,
15:42mountains, the sea, and a strong tourist economy.
15:45But read local discussions and one villain appears constantly.
15:51Moscowites.
15:52They bought everything, the entire coastline.
15:56They drove up the prices.
15:58One commenter this September complained that Moscow buyers had bought up property
16:03and inflated prices so far that ordinary locals could no longer afford living in Sochi.
16:09The same resentment appeared much more sharply in the Altai Republic,
16:13a remote mountainous region in southern Siberia, famous for spectacular landscapes and
16:19increasingly popular with tourists.
16:22As tourism grew, wealthy investors and large companies from Moscow began buying
16:27land and developing resorts there.
16:29Land prices rose while some local residents feared losing pastures, culturally important places,
16:37and control over territory their communities had used for generations.
16:42Those fears became part of the much larger protests that swept the Republic in 2025.
16:49Now, reverse the direction.
16:52What happens when Moscow has something it does not want?
16:55The Shia's landfill conflict gave us a perfect example.
17:01Authorities planned to send Moscow's waste north to Arkhangelsk region.
17:06People there protested for years.
17:08And listened to the logic of one protester.
17:12Moscow, he said, wants clean air and clean water.
17:16It has already taken the money to the center,
17:18And now the region is supposed to take Moscow's garbage too.
17:22To the local people, that felt like a highly unfair deal.
17:27A similar feeling appears with desirable land becomes inaccessible.
17:32Near Gelencik, their coastal territory around the luxury property,
17:36widely associated with Putin, became restricted.
17:40Local residents and visitors could no longer walk freely along parts of the shore.
17:45That may be reasonable security measures, but for a local person,
17:50it still feels like yesterday, this was our cost.
17:55Today, somebody much more powerful has decided that we cannot use it.
17:59The common question is ownership.
18:02Who gets to decide what a region is for?
18:06The people who live there?
18:07Or the people who arrive with more money and more political power?
18:12Who counts as Russians?
18:16There is another contradiction in Moscow's relationship with the rest of the country.
18:21The capital depends on millions of people who do not fit the traditional image of a Moscovite.
18:28Some come from Russia's own ethnic republics.
18:31Tatars, Bashkirs, Dagestanis, Chichens, and many others.
18:36Others are labor migrants from Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, and other former Soviet republics.
18:42They build apartment blocks, drive taxis, deliver food, work in warehouses, clean streets, staff services,
18:50and fill jobs that Moscow has difficulty filling with its own population.
18:55This is not a marginal workforce.
18:58Researchers at the higher school of economics estimate that temporary labor migrants alone
19:04make up at least a quarter of all workers in Moscow.
19:08Their labor fills entire niches in the city economy and helps compensate for shortages in jobs that many
19:17local workers do not want.
19:18So Moscow needs these people every day.
19:23Yet, their visibility often produces a completely different reaction.
19:27You can see during major Muslim holidays.
19:30Moscow has a very large Muslim population, while its main cathedral mosque holds only about 10,000 people.
19:37During it, tens or even hundreds of thousands may gather for prayer, and worshipers spill into surrounding streets.
19:46In 2025, the city closed roads to accommodate the crowds.
19:51And every time images like this circulate online, they trigger angry arguments about whether Moscow is
19:57becoming too Muslim, whether these people belong there, and why they are praying in public.
20:03Similar resentment has increasingly been directed at Central Asian migrants more broadly.
20:09That exposes an awkward contradiction.
20:13The city wants their labor.
20:15It is far less comfortable with their presence.
20:19And this matters beyond Moscow itself because the capital has another kind of power.
20:23It helps define what Russia is supposed to look like.
20:27National television is produced there.
20:29Political language is created there.
20:30Cultural careers are made there.
20:33The accent heard from Moscow becomes the neutral accent.
20:38Moscow institutions decide which regional writers, artists, histories, identities enter the national conversation.
20:46So Russia can officially describe itself as a multinational country,
20:51while still revolving around a cultural center, whose definition of normality is much narrower.
20:58For people far from Moscow, the question can therefore become larger than money.
21:03Who gets to define a Russian?
21:06And why should that definition come from Moscow?
21:10Once those questions begin reinforcing one another, regional identity can become much more politically important
21:17than it looked during stable times.
21:19I have a dedicated video about how the Northern Caucasus Republic, where regional identities are historically strong,
21:27can become the first to distance themselves from Moscow.
21:31Permission to matter.
21:35And now we come to the least visible monopoly Moscow has, the monopoly of importance.
21:42Russia has talented people and cultural institutions everywhere.
21:48There are local theaters, orchestras, and museums.
21:52But there is still a huge difference between being successful in your region and nationwide.
22:00And Moscow often sits between those two things.
22:03But look at the language people use.
22:06Nobody is surprised by a famous Moscow theater.
22:10But say, a nationally famous theater from Eugene Ogren,
22:14and suddenly the location itself becomes part of the story.
22:19Why?
22:19Because national visibility is concentrated in the same place as everything else.
22:26The biggest media, the federal television channels,
22:30the important producers, their professional networks.
22:34Russia even has programs designed specifically to support regional theater.
22:39But those programs still reveal the hierarchy underneath.
22:44The festival of theaters of small Russian cities selects productions from around the country.
22:51The winning performance gets shown at the Theater of Nations.
22:57Where?
22:58In Moscow.
22:59Think about the symbolism.
23:00You prove that a regional production matters nationally by bringing it to the capital.
23:06Another example is almost too perfect.
23:09In 2025, Moscow launched a national competition called Talents to find future leaders for Moscow figures.
23:18Almost 400 people applied from 46 regions.
23:22The strongest candidates came to Moscow, trained on Moscow stages, and competed for the chance to lead Moscow institutions.
23:31From Moscow's point of view, this is excellent recruitment.
23:36For regional theater, the three says, your most ambitious director becomes successful, and their reward is the opportunity to leave
23:46you.
23:46The problem is not that talent outside Moscow does not exist.
23:50It is that talent often has to pass from Moscow to become nationally visible.
23:54And this changes the behavior of ambitious people before they have even succeeded.
23:59They start connecting their future with Moscow while staying home is seen as limiting.
24:05That may be the most powerful form of centralization of all.
24:10Once one city decides which voices become national voices and which culture represents the whole country,
24:16the regions lose more than their best people.
24:19They lose the ability to imagine themselves as centers.
24:23Now I'd like to ask you something.
24:25Have you ever felt that your country's capital is sucking up the money, talent, opportunities,
24:31and political attention from everywhere else?
24:34What does that look like where you live?
24:36If this video gave you a useful way of looking at Russia,
24:39please like it, subscribe, and share it with someone who might find this discussion interesting.
24:45And if you want to help make this kind of independent analysis possible,
24:48you can support the research behind these videos from my ThinkThing, Paypal, or Superfix.
24:55But let's also remember the Meds for Ukraine project I mentioned earlier.
24:59It helps vulnerable civilians in Ukraine pay for essential medications,
25:04and even a small donation can make a direct difference.
25:08You'll find the link below.
25:10If you are listening on Spotify, please follow the show so you don't miss the next episode.
25:16And for something much lighter, you can follow me on Facebook,
25:20where I am publishing my memoirs about growing up in the Soviet Union
25:24and starting a new life in America.
25:28I'll see you in the next one.
25:47Where are you?
25:51ng