- 20 hours ago
Could the West’s reliance on aid and shared security be a source of influence—or a hidden weakness? Author Elvira Bary explores “khalyava,” a Russian concept for something received for free, and argues that giving resources can build power and status while receiving them may create dependence, resentment, or a struggle for respect.
Through historical examples and commentary on the United States, Russia, Europe, and international relations, Bary examines how this dynamic shapes alliances, corruption, social hierarchies, and political decisions. This geopolitical analysis connects the idea of khalyava to Western strategy and the challenges facing Europe. A thought-provoking video for viewers interested in Russian history, political commentary, international affairs, power dynamics, and the future of Western security.
Through historical examples and commentary on the United States, Russia, Europe, and international relations, Bary examines how this dynamic shapes alliances, corruption, social hierarchies, and political decisions. This geopolitical analysis connects the idea of khalyava to Western strategy and the challenges facing Europe. A thought-provoking video for viewers interested in Russian history, political commentary, international affairs, power dynamics, and the future of Western security.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00Halewa is a Russian term for something you get for free.
00:03Something you did not earn, deserve or even take from someone else but received simply
00:09because it was given to you.
00:11In this video, I will explain how the fundamental law of halewa is causing the current crisis
00:17in the West.
00:18My name is Elvira Barry, I am an author and I've spent 20 years studying history, anthropology
00:22and other social sciences that help us see the current political landscape as a whole.
00:28And when we see the full picture, we can make the right decisions.
00:39Halewa could be a valuable item or a highly desired service.
00:44The key is that you really, really want it.
00:47The law of halewa is simple.
00:49Whoever gives out halewa gains power over others.
00:53Whoever receives it, submits.
00:55In other words, halewa granted converts into a higher social status.
01:01In ancient times, a strong man could beat everyone in his tribe and claim his right to leadership.
01:08But he was only recognized as a leader if he also shared halewa with others.
01:13This could be military or hunting spoils, valuable weapons or assistance in various matters.
01:21If the tribe saw nothing but violence from him, he wouldn't be a leader.
01:26As soon as he fell asleep, a rock would be dropped on his head.
01:31Oops!
01:32If there were plenty of halewa, it flowed down the social pyramid from the supreme leader
01:38to the very bottom.
01:39Thus, a vertical power structure formed where each higher rank became a source of halewa for
01:45those below and therefore gained control over them.
01:50This is how military alliances and eventually states were formed.
01:54This is how hierarchy works in any society, whether it's a group of cool kids at school,
02:01a church council or an international summit.
02:04The law of halewa is followed when everyone involved in distributing halewa is content with
02:10the balance between what they get and their social status.
02:14For example, in traditional families, the man is considered the head because he brings
02:20halewa into the home and no one disputes his status.
02:25But if his grown-up son also wants to claim the title of head of the family but still depends
02:31on his father's handouts, conflict is inevitable.
02:35The law of halewa is universal.
02:37It gives power not only to individuals but to entire countries.
02:42The Spanish discovered America and found vast reserves of gold and silver.
02:47For several centuries, this halewa made them the most powerful nation in the world.
02:53By the early 19th century, halewa ran out.
02:56And one by one, Spanish colonies broke away from the empire.
03:01No more halewa, no more power and status.
03:13The United States is the leading country in the world not because it is the richest.
03:18It was already wealthier than most by the end of the 19th century.
03:22For America to become a global leader, it needed to apply the law of halewa.
03:28And that's exactly what happened after World War II.
03:31The USSR had seized Eastern Europe and acquired nuclear weapons.
03:36And America needed allies in Europe and the Far East to contain the potential threat.
03:42Halewa, provided by America, took the form of loans to its allies, capital to rebuild economies
03:49destroyed by war, a vast consumer market for goods, military bases that guaranteed security,
03:56and the US Navy patrolling sea routes, thus significantly lowering transportation costs.
04:03In the second half of the 20th century, humanity entered an era of unprecedented prosperity.
04:09And this happened thanks to five key factors.
04:13The absence of large-scale wars for several decades.
04:17Free movement of capital, allowing investments anywhere in the world.
04:21The invention of technologies for extracting and transporting petroleum products, fueling industry
04:28and transportation.
04:29The invention of the shipping container, which made global trade possible.
04:34The invention of the internet, enabling the free flow of information.
04:39America played a leading role in all of this, while the rest of the world benefited from its
04:45innovations.
04:46The US handed out halewa and in return it gained power and social status.
04:52The Russians also tried to use the law of halewa and supplied their allies with fuel, weapons,
04:58money, and more.
04:59The USSR didn't collapse because its enemies defeated it.
05:02It fell apart because halewa ran out.
05:05There was nothing left to give.
05:08And Moscow's power evaporated immediately.
05:17Halewa has its dark sides.
05:20First, those who give it out begin to see themselves as the center of the universe.
05:26They distance themselves from others and, not confronting their problems, simply ignore
05:32them.
05:32Again, this is a universal phenomenon.
05:35This is how all rulers have acted, whether Roman emperors or modern bureaucrats in Washington.
05:42Along with halewa comes arrogance, a complete belief in one's exceptionalism and their unquestionable
05:50right to teach others how to live.
05:52This is not done out of malice.
05:54Very often, it's an attempt to give out halewa in the form of unsolicited advice, thus earning
06:00even more social credit.
06:02But there's more.
06:03Despite the fact that halewa benefits those who receive it, they don't always feel immense
06:09gratitude toward their benefactors.
06:12This happens when they are unable to repay kindness with kindness.
06:17In such cases, their social status automatically drops.
06:21And that's unbearable for people whose life purpose is to win, prove their worth or dominate
06:28minds.
06:29If you'd like to see what your life purpose looks like, visit my website alvirabari.com
06:36and check out my Sphinx method.
06:38The link is in the description for this video.
06:42The exchange doesn't have to be equal, but it should be valuable in the eyes of both parties.
06:49For example, when a king grants land to a knight, the knight fights under the king's banner.
06:55But if the knight is old and can no longer serve, his status is immediately lowered, even
07:02though he may not lose material wealth.
07:05The inability to repay halewa leads to feelings of humiliation and resentment.
07:11In the 1990s, Russia went through a severe economic crisis and Western humanitarian aid helped
07:18a great deal.
07:19Well, the part that wasn't looted by officials.
07:22Do you think Russians were grateful for this?
07:26No.
07:27Because along with the aid came humiliation.
07:30If Russia had had the chance to offer a meaningful service to America and Europe in the 1990s, there
07:37would have been no resentment.
07:39It arose precisely because Russia had to accept halewa but wasn't prepared for the corresponding
07:46status.
07:47It wanted to be treated as an equal.
07:50It is not surprising that the strongest anti-American sentiments are found where America sends help.
07:58It may never reach the people and end up in the pockets of the local elite, but it is precisely
08:05this elite that spreads anti-American narratives.
08:08Take Gaza as an example.
08:10Its economy relied on the nations from Europe, Canada, and the United States.
08:15Before the war, Israel provided infrastructure and complex services.
08:20Who did the Hamas try to kill on October 7th?
08:24Who did they take hostage?
08:25Who do they blame for all their troubles?
08:29It doesn't matter where you live, in a remote Siberian village, Los Angeles or Tokyo.
08:34Self-identification, social status and self-respect are the most important values for us.
08:41We are deeply unhappy if we feel we are being humiliated.
08:46Why do you think migrants, when they arrive to Europe, often act out or even commit terrorist attacks?
08:53It's because these young people feel anger and frustration toward their hosts who have taken them in.
09:00They are not seen as equals.
09:03They are despised and feared.
09:05And they feel this keenly.
09:07I will soon release a book called The White Ghosts Empire, which tells the story of Russian immigrants who left
09:14for China after the Bolshevik Revolution.
09:16This happened 100 years ago and tens of thousands of white Russian refugees found themselves in the same position as
09:23Syrian refugees in modern Germany.
09:26It was a very strange experience. During the times of rampant racism, white people arrived in an Asian country and
09:33found themselves not in the position of masters.
09:37This will be the second book in my Russian Treasures series. The first volume is already available on Amazon and
09:44you can find the link in the description.
09:46To get updates about the release of the second book, sign up for the newsletter on my website.
09:56The human mind is quite inventive and it's come up with a clever trick to ensure that you can receive
10:04haliava without feeling humiliated.
10:07In this case, the recipient of haliava must treat their benefactor as a sucker who has been duped out of
10:15money.
10:16In this situation, social status may not increase, but there will be no feelings of humiliation.
10:23I can illustrate this with the following example.
10:26I have an acquaintance who made a lot of money of American taxpayers for many years.
10:32She knew many education leaders because she met with them at conferences and was constantly networking.
10:39This acquaintance is a very charming and attractive woman.
10:43She invited high-ranking officials to good restaurants and over lunch told them about her program aimed to improving teachers'
10:51qualifications.
10:52Education officials have budgets that they must spend for such purposes.
10:58And they spend it as they pleased, essentially giving away haliava.
11:03But how do you decide who to pay with government money?
11:08The answer is simple.
11:09All these people want to climb the career ladder, so they hand out haliava to those they think are useful
11:16or particularly charming.
11:18Neither discount sexual attractiveness, as the desire to please a beautiful woman is deeply ingrained in our behavioral code, just
11:27like the ritual surrounding haliava.
11:29The scandals that have rocked America regarding misuse of funds have these very roots.
11:35The same thing is happening in Europe on all levels of power.
11:39The same story is unfolding in Russia.
11:42People, like my acquaintance, simply figure out what they can sell to officials.
11:48They know the right bureaucrats and understand how to present themselves and their projects, and in some cases, they even
11:55pay commissions.
11:57The result of this innocent embezzling of funds done strictly legally and with good intentions are as follows.
12:05The US is drowning in debt, and Europe is in crisis.
12:10How did this happen?
12:12We can view the situation we find ourselves in as a disease of society.
12:17And society will have to go through some unpleasant procedures to return to normal.
12:23The side effects of the medicine sometimes look even worse than the symptoms.
12:28But living things as they are is not an option.
12:33Fair and effective distribution of haliava is one of the most important questions of social organization.
12:39In countries with authoritarian regimes, it is concentrated in the hands of dictators, giving them unprecedented power.
12:48In democracies, however, haliava slips through the cracks.
12:52Power becomes ineffective, efforts and resources are dispersed, and despite technical and economic superiority,
13:00the West is powerless to deal with international hooligans.
13:08There is an old Russian joke.
13:11Mice went to a wise owl for advice.
13:14Everyone tries to eat us.
13:16What should we do?
13:18Become hedgehogs, the owl replied.
13:20If you are prickly, no one will eat you.
13:24The mice were happy, ran home, and then had a thought and rushed back to the owl.
13:30How do we become hedgehogs?
13:33The owl answered.
13:35My job is to provide a strategy.
13:38How you do it doesn't concern me.
13:41Now, I'll play the role of the owl.
13:44But I really hope that a wiser owl will come along and figure out the tactics.
13:50Let's begin by stating the facts.
13:53America will gradually eliminate unnecessary expenditures.
13:57Military technologies have advanced so much that Russia, which spends months fighting for some barn in Ukraine, no longer poses
14:06a threat to America.
14:07Since that's the case, the entire international security system built after World War II on American haliava no longer holds
14:16any economic or strategic value.
14:18But America is far away.
14:20And it's not like you can attack it with Russia's sole aircraft carrier.
14:24However, Russia can easily attack Eastern Europe and cause chaos in the already struggling European Union economy.
14:33If anyone finds this unrealistic, let me remind you that Hitler rose to power during the Great Depression when Germany's
14:42economy was in ruins.
14:43Austria was annexed into the German Reich in 1938.
14:49And in 1949, the Nazis invaded Poland.
14:52So, events can escalate quickly.
14:55Of course, back then, Germany had millions of surplus young men who could be put into military service.
15:02But Russia faces a major issue with this.
15:05However, Europe also faces a demographic crisis.
15:09If there is no one to defend it, Putin can manage with the forces he has.
15:16America will continue distancing itself from Europe.
15:19This will happen regardless, whether with Trump or without.
15:23Putin will keep up the pressure because all of his actions are driven by the same law of haliava.
15:29He got Russia's vast natural resources for free.
15:33And he feels that he himself is not deserving of respect.
15:37And he craves respect.
15:40This is precisely why he started his war.
15:43His ancient behavioral program tells him,
15:46Go raise your social status by force.
15:49Let them not love you, but at least let them fear you.
15:53For his personality type, this feeling is crucial.
15:57If anyone is interested in understanding Vladimir Putin's psychological profile,
16:01I have a separate video on this topic.
16:03See the description below.
16:06Europe needs to do the same thing as America.
16:08Audit the flow of haliava and figure out where its money is going.
16:12What is more important?
16:14Maintaining security or sponsoring projects created purely for embezzling funds.
16:20Europe needs a modern army with drones as its main strike force.
16:25The value of human life in Europe is very high, so defense must rely on technology.
16:31Europe also needs to boost birth rates.
16:34And this is only possible if the status of wife and mother is seen as equally prestigious as that of
16:41a successful working woman.
16:43The world is not ruled by love, but by the desire for social success.
16:48People are willing to do anything just so their peers see them as valuable individuals.
16:54If the current norm is that businesswomen are admirable and mothers are not,
17:00women will make the corresponding choice.
17:03However, this is a separate topic for discussion and maybe I'll get into it one day.
17:08No one will save Europe.
17:10If it wants to survive in its current form, it will need to gather strength and figure out how to
17:16become a prickly hedgehog.
17:18If not, future generations of writers and historians will have plenty to write about.
17:29Consistently receiving haliava from any source leads people to either live like con artists who need to outsmart others,
17:36or to regress into a state of artificial childhood.
17:41They move down the social ladder to a place where, in traditional societies, children sat,
17:47where no one asks them anything or expects anything from them.
17:52Some people are okay with this position.
17:55But if they are not, no amount of money or benefits will make the recipient of haliava happy.
18:02By accepting it, they lose the most important thing – their self-respect and agency.
18:09People stop talking to them because their opinion no longer matters.
18:14Haliava is like water.
18:15You can't live without it because we use it to build personal and business relationships and to help those in
18:21need.
18:22But if it is not carefully managed, it becomes contaminated and poisons everything around.
18:28It will be stolen, corruption schemes will be built on them, and social discontent and mistrust will grow.
18:36For healthy relationships to form, the giver shouldn't be arrogant, thinking they know everything and understand everything.
18:45The recipient should have the chance to repay the kindness.
18:48It is very important for everyone to have the opportunity to earn and prove themselves.
18:55It is one thing to inherit a million dollars and another thing entirely to earn it through one's own mind
19:01and hard work.
19:03In the first case, the person will spend their life proving to themselves and others that they are worthy of
19:09the million.
19:10In the second, they will strive to earn another one.
19:14The second option is far more beneficial for society.
19:17This is how we get taxes, new products and inventions.
19:22If refugees are just given welfare, they will feel inadequate and instead of gratitude, they'll have contempt for the suckers
19:31they've conned out of money.
19:33It's completely different if we give them the opportunity to gain respect and high social status through perseverance and hard
19:41work.
19:41Yes, not everyone will succeed, but if this opportunity exists, it will completely change the social dynamic within the migrant
19:50communities.
19:51In fact, for centuries, humanity has been trying to figure out the best way to distribute haliawa.
19:57The ideologies of communism and socialism grew out of these attempts.
20:02But for now, that's all.
20:04If I was able to provide value to you with this video, please consider giving a super thanks or clicking
20:11on the join button to support my channel.
20:14Thank you all and see you soon.