In January 2007, a young couple was carjacked at gunpoint in Knoxville, Tennessee and taken to a house on Chipman Street. What happened inside those walls over the next two days is one of the most disturbing cases in American criminal history. Five people were caught. Four were convicted. Then the judge who ran every single trial was exposed as a drug addict who had been corrupting his own courtroom. The convictions collapsed. The families walked back in and did it all again. This is the case of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.