Judge Judy Calls Out a $12,000 Insurance Scheme

A mysterious fire, a brand-new insurance policy, and a $12,000 payout? Judge Judy isn't buying it! When a tenant claims an apartment inside a church building suffered major fire damage, Judy starts asking questions that neither party seems prepared to answer.

How could such a serious fire happen without the rest of the church knowing about it? And why was there so little documentation? As the story falls apart, Judge Judy questions whether both parties were involved and suggests the insurance company got taken for a ride. Then she's had enough. With a firm "Guys, we're done," she ends the case without awarding either side a dime.

Watch this classic Judge Judy clip as Judy Sheindlin confronts a suspicious insurance claim and abruptly ends the proceedings.