Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 9 minutes ago
A debate has emerged over opposition protests and remarks regarding regime change in India, drawing comparisons to street agitations across Europe and Bangladesh. Union Ministers Kiren Rijiju and Rajnath Singh cautioned against efforts to replicate Europe-style unrest or take democracy hostage, stressing that leadership changes in India occur strictly through the ballot box. Conversely, opposition figures and activists asserted their democratic right to dissent. Senior advocate Prashant Bhushan described the agitation as a democratic fight for regime change led by civil society and youth organisations. Congress leader Pawan Khera clarified that seeking a regime change is a standard objective of the opposition achieved through elections, rejecting claims of illicit destabilisation. Meanwhile, student leader Neha Bora referenced Bangladesh's Gen Z movement while advocating democratic and voting rights. The confrontation highlights sharp disagreements between the ruling government and the opposition over drawing the line between democratic protest and national destabilisation.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00You heard the warning from the Prime Minister and the RSS chief.
00:03They come at a time when protests, political confrontations.
00:07And then there are questions over regime change statements.
00:10They're dominating conversations, not just in India, but across the world.
00:14From Europe. I mean, talk about what's happening in France, what's happening in Italy,
00:18what's happening in Portugal, what's happening in Albania.
00:20Street protests have shaken governments and institutions in different parts of Europe.
00:25In India, the opposition and certain left-wing groups and activists,
00:28they've taken to the streets against the election commission,
00:31questioning the credibility of the election commission of India.
00:34But the larger question, where does the democratic right to protest, to dissent,
00:42where does that Lakshman Rekha be drawn?
00:45And when does destabilization of a nation begin?
00:50For example, the images that you see on your television screens from France or from Italy or from Albania,
00:56when buildings are being set on fire, when buildings are being torched or shops are being looted,
01:02is that a democratic form of protest?
01:04And I want you to see those images of Europe and Europe on fire.
01:09Take, for example, Shiv Sena, Uddhav Thakre faction MP, Sanjay Raut.
01:14When he invokes Albania, I want to show you those images of Albania.
01:19Watch those images.
01:21When he invokes Albania, when he claims that the country's Supreme Court was burned down
01:27and public anger was directed at institutions accused of helping who he terms are corrupt political leaders in Albania,
01:36he's urged nations to learn from these events, insisting that his own protests are in the country's interests.
01:46He's not the only one advocating this.
01:49Last week, you had senior advocate in the Supreme Court, Prashant Bhushan.
01:52He openly described the agitation as a regime change operation, saying, of course we want a regime change.
01:59He, of course, then went on to say that's a democratic right.
02:02It's the constitutional right of every citizen.
02:06And then, again, someone who was mainstreamed and platformed by these political parties, opposition parties and leaders,
02:14AISA, left-wing student leader, Neha Bohra.
02:18Neha Bohra invoked Bangladesh's Gen Z protests,
02:22where violence, marred streets and Hindu minorities were systematically targeted by radical Islamists.
02:29BORA invoked that 2024 protest to not just congratulate the students there,
02:35but then said India was fighting the same battle against radical forces.
02:42This nothing could be further from truth, but yet, is this how an attempt is being made to manufacture a
02:48false narrative?
02:49In Bangladesh, now there is evidence to suggest, from Muhammad Yunus,
02:56his statement about who were the chief architects of the protests,
03:00and their links to radical Islamist organizations like Jamaat-e-Islami,
03:04who use students as a facade, as a front, to carry out a detailed regime change operation.
03:11And then, Congress party leader, Pawan Khera, member of parliament,
03:15who argued that opposition wants a regime change,
03:18but he clarified through elections.
03:21And he said regime changes are not new.
03:23They happen through elections in India.
03:25The government, however, sees a very dangerous distinction between
03:30seeking a regime change through elections, through the ballot,
03:33and the government or elements in the government argue that while they may say that,
03:41the real agenda is mobilizing mass anger on the street
03:44and ensure that there are France-like protests or Europe-like protests,
03:50arson and loot and vandalism even in India.
03:54Union Parliamentary Affairs Minister, Minority Affairs Minister Kiran Rijiju,
03:58he is warned against attempts to replicate France-like unrest in India,
04:03insisting that power in India changes only through elections.
04:07Defence Minister Rajnath Singh,
04:09he is accused the opposition of spreading misinformation
04:12and trying to take democracy hostage.
04:16The question is not whether citizens have a right to protest.
04:18Of course they do.
04:20But whether political parties and leaders
04:23and certain elements in civil society
04:25are directing public anger
04:29towards unrest like in France,
04:33like in Portugal,
04:35like in Italy,
04:36like in Albania,
04:37we debate.
04:38But first, listen in to what voices in the opposition have said.
04:44Regime change karana,
04:46har nagrit ka log tantrik adhikar.
04:49Yeh is tarhe ki tana shah sarkar
04:51is desh mein nahin chal sakti.
04:54Sab ne mil kar tekiar ki eb yeh ladaai
04:56pure sare civil society organizations ki students ke agwaii mein.
05:02Or hum students ko yeh shraye djetete hain.
05:05Students ko or youth organizations ko yeh shraye djetete hain.
05:08And unki agwaahi mein yeh ladaaii ladai jayegi.
05:11Who humare leader hoongi.
05:13And unki agwaahi mein
05:15sarhi civil society mil kar,
05:18political parties mil kar,
05:19sab yeh ladaai ladaengi
05:21humare log tantrik ko bachane ke liye
05:23or regime change ke liye.
05:25Yeh mein aaj khule tor par keh raha hon
05:27yehaan yeh regime change ki ladaai hai.
05:30Hey!
05:33We present you our Red Salute
05:35and we know that the Gen Z movement
05:37that we are seeing everywhere in this country
05:39first started in Bangladesh
05:41and congratulations to you
05:43for showing us the way,
05:45for showing us and extending solidarity
05:46to the young people of this country.
05:48We know that the movement that began in Bangladesh
05:51was for democratic and voter rights.
05:54Today, the movement that the young people
05:56are participating in and leading
05:58is also a movement for democratic
06:00and voting rights.
06:02We know that the fight that you fight
06:05against religious fundamentalism in your country
06:07is also a fight that the Gen Z
06:09and the young people of this country fight today.
06:11The whole country is saying
06:12that the vote is not a vote.
06:14We are trying to make our goal
06:16ourselves, trying to make our goal
06:19that we have to overcome this government,
06:22to overcome this system,
06:24to change this system.
06:47How does a regime change in a democracy like India?
06:52Through elections.
06:53All elections.
06:54хочuin号 کے
06:55zaribe
06:55regime
06:56بدलna
06:56ہی
06:56تو
06:56مقصد
06:57ہوتا ہے
06:57vipakş
06:58کا

Recommended